COMMUNITY MAPPING
Thought Leadership from Collaborate This document was published in collaboration with CAFO Research Center & Mukuru on the Move1
2
Collaborate A FORUM FOR GLOBAL LEADERS
CAFO Collaborate workshops initiate conversations about effective care for orphans and vulnerable children within local church and NGO networks around the world. These workshops generate ideas to: • creatively share information • involve more churches and individuals, • equip local churches for more effective
COMMUNITY MAPPING. In a June 2021 Virtual Collaborate DISCUSS session, over 30 global leaders from 20 nations brainstormed about community mapping projects in their cultural contexts.
3
COLLABORATE OUTCOMES Global leaders were divided by world region for the purpose of this discussion. Given the unique nature of each world region and the indigenous cultures native to each region, the feedback from regions varied. Each group was tasked with the following question: How would you implement a community mapping project in your community? In other words, • Consider which cultural elements would impact your project. • Based on what was presented, what would NOT work for you? • Who would you NOT want to invite, but SHOULD invite anyway?
4
5
REGIONAL STRATEGIES Asia, Europe, Middle East, and North America Korean leaders are currently in the process of beginning a network. First steps include a Zoom conference where they will introduce many small organizations and map the work being done. After this event they will better know gaps of service. Canadian leaders are implementing CarePortal in communities across Manitoba to allow churches to meet needs of local families through social service agencies. As a form of community mapping, CarePortal allows child welfare organizations to see where the needs are and connect children and families to available resources. Canadian leaders identified the following cultural elements which would impact their project: • Differences in governance between cities and provinces provide for a challenge in a mapping project, particularly in cities that span two provinces. • Language barriers provide a unique cultural challenge in Canada. Networks have a unique opportunity to connect French and English speaking organizations through mapping projects. Korean leaders identified a culture of nonacceptance towards orphans and vulnerable children within the church. This limits involvement of churches in the OVC space. Both Korean and Canadian leaders expressed a scarcity mentality within organizations. Organizations are sometimes hesitant to share information and work together over competition for funding.
6
Both groups recognized a need for inclusion beyond Christian organizations in mapping projects to gain a full understanding of those working in the OVC space and expand the scope of services to families in need. Latin America Latin American leaders identified a need for a national map for each country where CAFO network members work that is focused on possible partners in the OVC world. Latin American leaders also identified a need for more in-depth maps for each community of origin of the children in their care. Latin American leaders identified the following cultural aspects which are places of potential growth in community mapping projects. Despite these challenges, Latin American leaders expressed a commitment to overcome identified challenges and grow in cooperation and collaboration between organizations, churches and governmental institutions. • Latin American leaders noted a mentality of inferiority among their peers. They feel they have many resources but do not trust in their own abilities. Confidence in their networks and strengths is an area for growth. • Latin American leaders noted a culture of individualism within networks and the need for more collaboration. Networks note that organizations tend to operate in isolation from one another and a more collaborative environment is needed to thrive. • A lack of government support makes effective community mapping difficult. Better relationships with government institutions would help in this area. • A culture of distrust exists among Latin American organizations. Organizations are hesitant to provide information to others.
7
Eastern & Southern Africa Eastern and Southern African leaders identified the following first steps • Mobilize local authorities • Work first with partner organisations • Develop a questionnaire which could be distributed to a wide variety of stakeholders • Eastern and Southern African leaders expressed the need to invite cultural leaders, men and women, NGOs and local leaders. They also expressed the need to be inclusive of all stakeholders, including government officials. • • Western & Central Africa Western and Central African leaders suggested advocacy visits to community leaders and gatekeepers ahead of the community mapping event to share the vision and invite them to participate in and advocate for the event. Leaders also identified the following steps to take for a community mapping event: • Audit resources available and identify sources of potential funding. • Build consensus through town hall meetings. • Launch the collective map and market throughout participating organizations and communities.
8
Community Mapping
9
Table of Contents Part 1: What Is Community Mapping?.................3 Part 2: How Can My Program Implement Community Mapping?...............................................7 Part 3: Community Mapping Worksheet..........15
10
PART 1: WHAT IS COMMUNITY MAPPING? 11
WHAT IS COMMUNITY MAPPING?
View this video to learn more about what Community Mapping is.
Vulnerable children and families have very diverse needs, and no one program can fulfill all of them. “It takes a village to raise a child,” is an African proverb that means that children grow best when supported by an entire community of people. Supporting the development of that system is one way organizations can support children and families, understanding that we can only meet their needs by working together.
Community Mapping Building a system to care for vulnerable children and families starts with community mapping. Community mapping is a process of identifying and cataloguing who is doing what in a given geographical area. It allows us to identify key stakeholders, learn about currently available services, pinpoint gaps in services, and facilitate collaboration.
12
Imagine...
A city in which every program serving vulnerable children and families is trying to provide all services to every child and family they work with. Each of them needs to become experts in child development, child protection, education, healthcare, vocational training, the transition to adulthood, government advocacy, and so on. They feel overwhelmed. There are never enough funds and staff to meet the needs, and they feel like they are the only ones doing the work.
Now imagine a different city…
One in which there is a collective, public map of all of the programs in the community, and which services each is providing. Each program knows exactly who is doing what, and where they are serving. The government can ask NGOs for support in their areas of expertise. Families themselves know where to reach out for services, when needed. Case managers can easily find support services for the families they work with. 13
Programs work together to fill gaps in services, as opposed to replicating one another. Programs are interdependent, rather than competitive. Stakeholders feel as though they are part of something bigger, and children and families are well served. This is possible through community mapping. No one organization will ever be excellent at every component of caring for vulnerable children and families, but together, we can make a community system that supports children and families at risk.
How does Community Mapping relate to caring for children and families in adversity? Children and families in adversity often have a variety of needs simultaneously. One family may need parenting skills, income generation, marital counseling, education support, medical treatment, home improvement, and substance abuse treatment - all at the same time. It is ineffective and inefficient for one program to try to do all these things well. However, by knowing what services are provided where, and acting as a hub of connection, programs can play a vital role in seeing that all these needs are met. This is part of the Case Management process that every child and family in our programs should receive. [For more on Case Management, see our Case Management Training Module]. The scope of this training module is limited to mapping at the community level, although some of the principles may apply more broadly. For a framework for mapping at the national level, view Child Protection Systems: Mapping and Assessment Toolkit (Unicef). Further, it is intended that this activity will be completed primarily by adult stakeholders. For a resource on community mapping with children, view Child Participation Tool: Community Mapping (World Vision).
14
PART 2: HOW CAN MY PROGRAM IMPLEMENT COMMUNITY MAPPING? 15
HOW CAN MY PROGRAM IMPLEMENT COMMUNITY MAPPING?
Gather Key Stakeholders
Build Relationships
Establish Parameters
Assess Fit
Create Your Map
Reflect on Learning
Where do we Start? 1. Gather Key Stakeholders The process of community mapping and establishing partnership begins with gathering key stakeholders. It is a time to share knowledge and learn from one another, and to attempt community mapping alone is to miss the opportunity for collaboration. The key is having a sufficient number of programs represented in the room, including those focusing on different goals. This can expand the pool of knowledge, leading to a richer experience and product. As programs serving vulnerable children, we will want to include representatives from: • • • •
16
Children’s homes Adoption agencies Foster care providers Kinship and family strengthening programs
However, rather than limiting the gathering to only those involved in placement of children outside of parental care, consider representatives from: • • • • • • • • • • •
Schools Churches and faith communities Government departments Medical facilities Feeding programs Community networks Children and families Universities Child protection agencies Substance abuse treatment The business sector
The only prerequisite is a solid understanding of the happenings of the community. Some of the most valuable people to have at the meeting may be the elderly, who have often lived in a community for decades and know everything that happens. Don’t be afraid of large groups. If you end up with a lot of people, feel free to break up the group into smaller sections for discussion, perhaps divided by geographic area of the community. To facilitate an excellent community mapping session, we want to do the following: Establish a meeting time in a neutral location. It can be hosted by a specific program, but be aware of political dynamics. If hosting it at a given location may lead some invited participants to decline the invitation, choose a different location. 1
Block out an entire day for the meeting and plan for food, water, etc. It is fine to ask everyone to bring their own food, but would be helpful to offer it. Just make sure everyone knows what to expect. 2
17
3
Have a brief conversation with each invited participant to help them understand the objectives of the meeting. It should be clear that the meeting is: • Collaborative in nature - all parties involved will have equal voice • Collective in product - no one owns the community map, and everyone can use it • Focused on impact - the purpose is to help us all to serve children and families better • Locally owned - this is created by local people, for local people
4
5
6
Ask every participant to bring their own list of who is doing what in the community. Ask each participant to identify 2 other people who should be involved, and invite them. Gather your materials. Some groups like to print a giant map of their community and add notations. Some use post-its, stickers, or tape. Some draw maps by hand. Don’t be afraid of taking a more creative approach with materials like play-dough, paint, pipe cleaners, or recycled materials.
Then send as many reminders as it will take to gather people together!
18
2. Build Relationships As community mapping is a highly interactive process, begin the meeting with building relationships. Introductions can be brief, but should cover: • • • •
Name Organization Role Length of time living in the community
You may want to add an icebreaker question like: “What is your favorite hobby?” or “What superpower would you like to have?” You may have another idea entirely, get creative! Getting people talking is the goal. 3. Establish Parameters Start with a conversation about the purpose of community mapping. Even if you have stated it many times, you cannot be too clear. Cast vision for the process. Discuss as a group: • • • •
When the community map is complete, what will happen to it? Who would use the map and how? How will a community map help children and families? How will a community map help programs that support children and families? • What do group members hope to see? • Why is this important for the community? Then, begin to establish parameters. How will the community be defined? What is the border of what we are and are not mapping? It is more effective to begin with a smaller area and expand, rather than to try to do too much at once. What types of services will be mapped?
19
It may be helpful to consider: •
• •
•
•
•
•
• •
Educational services, such as preschools, elementary schools, secondary school, and universities. Health services, such as hospitals, clinics, prenatal care, or feeding programs Psychosocial services, such as marriage and family counseling, spiritual support, and support groups. Training, in such topics as parenting skills, hygiene, nutrition, positive discipline, trauma, etc. Alternative care services, family support, such as adoption, foster care, and residential care. Income generation support, such as vocational training, community savings accounts, microloans, and financial management courses. Other family support services, such as housing assistance and repairs, legal advisement, and others. Income generation support, such as vocational training, community savings accounts, microloans, and financial management courses. Other family support services, such as housing assistance and repairs, legal advisement, and others.
Other domains can be found on p. 7 of Mapping Community Assets for Transitioning Youth (Annie E. Casey Foundation). These ideas are just a starting point, and should not constrain your process. Simply ask the group, “What kinds of services might be helpful for children and families at risk?”
20
4. Create Your Map • • • • • •
Name Address Email Contact Phone Contact Website Services Provided
The goal is not to get every detail of information that someone might want, but rather to create a framework understanding broad categories of what services are provided and where. Utilizing a tool like Cerca de Mi, share your learning publicly. Cerca de Mi is a web-based global mapping tool (in English and Spanish), focused on mapping services to support at-risk children and families. There may be key stakeholders who weren’t able to be part of the meeting who will benefit from seeing what you have learned. Making this information publicly available will ultimately benefit vulnerable children and families.
Community Mapping is one way partnerships can develop. For more on this process, view this video on Community Mapping in Practice.
21
5. Concluding Debrief Community Mapping is the start of activity and partnership, not the end of it. To do this activity and walk away without a plan for next steps would be a loss of great potential. As a mapping group, reflect on the following questions: • • • • •
What did we learn from this exercise? What services are readily available? What services are lacking? How might we fill those gaps? Are there any natural partnerships that could be forged? Who else needs to know about what we have learned? Who will be responsible for telling them? • Who can we share this map with? • Should we plan to gather again? • What are our next steps?
22
PART 3: COMMUNITY MAPPING WORKSHEET 23
COMMUNITY MAPPING WORKSHEET Meeting Date & Time:
Participants:
Vision Casting: • When the community map is complete, what will happen to it?
• Who would use the map and how?
• How will a community map help children and families?
• How will a community map help programs that support children and families?
• What do group members hope to see?
• Why is this important for the community?
24
Parameters: • How will the community be defined?
• What is the border of what we are and are not mapping?
• What types of services will be mapped?
Create Your Map: For each service provider, record (through a recorder, on post-its, etc.): • • • • • •
Name Address Email Contact Phone Contact Website Services Provided
As you record each program, add them to the map! * Don’t forget to utilize a tool like Cerca de Mi to share your map publicly. Making this information and your learnings available to all meeting participants and other stakeholders in the community will ultimately benefit vulnerable children and families.
25
Reflect on Your Learning: • What did we learn from this exercise?
• What services are readily available?
• What services are lacking? How might we fill those gaps?
• Are there any natural partnerships that could be forged?
26
• Who else needs to know about what we have learned? Who will be responsible for telling them?
• Who can we share this map with?
• Should we plan to gather again?
• What are our next steps?
27
cafo.org/global This document was published in collaboration with CAFO Research Center & Mukuru on the Move
© 2022 Christian Alliance for Orphans 28
