$6.95 jul/12 v.57 n.07
COMMUNITIES IN FLUX
© 2012 Kawneer Company, Inc.
What can an extra inch and a half give you? More. One of the only products on the market to combine superior thermal performance with a larger, more versatile span, Kawneer’s newest Trifab® 601 Series Framing System is built with a 6" frame – that’s an inch and a half more than a traditional storefront. Available in standard, thermally broken and ultra thermally broken, the new Trifab® 3-in-1 platform offers more flexibility, more drama, more options for you to design bigger, better buildings. An extra inch and a half makes a world of difference.
Architectural Aluminum Systems Entrances + Framing Curtain Walls Windows
kawneer.com kawneergreen.com
Umbriano® ®
with Belpasso inlay
Next-Generation Large Format Slab Paving
ColorFusion™ colouring process Modern sleek zero-bevel design Beyond the concentration of traditional wear-resistant materials on the surface, this process utilizes a proprietary blend of nature’s highest performing minerals to deliver an unparalleled colorfast and wear-proof finish.
For more information, samples, or to arrange a lunch and learn session for your company, call us today 1-800-UNILOCK.
™
Trump International Hotel & Tower Toronto Project architects: Zeidler Partnership Paver design: IBI Group
Beyond the concentration of traditional wearresistant materials on the surface, this processutilizes a proprietary blend of nature’s highest performing minerals to deliver an unparalleled colorfast and wear-proof finish.
www.unilock.com
1-800-UNILOCK
14 MCgregor CoMMunity Centre lounge
Migrating Landscapes Organizer
Ben rahn/a-FraMe
terence tOurangeau
Contents
9
news
evitt Goodman Architects reveal the L design for Laurentian University’s School of Archi tecture; prestigious new award for architecture endowed by Raymond Moriyama.
a sMaLL prOject By BOrtOLOttO design architect in a suBurBan at-risk cOMMunity OFFers a saFe and inspiring pLace tO cOnvene. teXt paige Magarrey
18 regent park revitalization
tOM arBan
recent atteMpts tO reintegrate this particuLarLy stigMatized sOciaL hOusing prOject with the greater cOMMunity OF tOrOntO is Fraught with Many chaLLenges. teXt aLex BOzikOvic
25 insites
John Bentley Mays asserts that the process of selection for Migrating Landscapes, the Canadian entry to the 2012 Venice Biennale in Architecture, is more rigorous, community-minded and public-spirited than any other that has come before.
29 teChniCal
R aymond J. Cole and Amy Oliver present a fascinating argument for regenerative de sign as a means of reframing green design.
33 Calendar
BORN AGAIN: The Repurposed City at Architecture at York Quay Centre in Toronto; BRAVOS: Groundbreaking Spanish Design at the Design Exchange in Toronto.
34 BaCkpage
Photographer Morris Lum documents the changing landscape of the suburban edge city, a world that—according to Stuart Keeler—contains a wealth of identities and notions of sustainable building practices. part OF the regent park revitaLizatiOn prOject, the sackviLLe-dundas apartMents By architectsaLLiance in dOwntOwn tOrOntO. phOtOgraph By terence tOurangeau. Cover
juLy 2012, v.57 n.07
The NaTioNal Review of DesigN aND PRacTice/ The JouRNal of RecoRD of aRchiTecTuRe caNaDa | Raic
07/12 Canadian arChiteCt
5
aLan LewIs
viEwpoint
Editor Ian ChodIkoff, OAA, FRAIC AssociAtEEditor LesLIe Jen, MRAIC EditoriAlAdvisors John MCMInn, AADIpl. MarCo PoLo, OAA, FRAIC contributingEditors GavIn affLeCk, OAQ, MRAIC herbert enns, MAA, MRAIC douGLas MaCLeod, nCARb rEgionAlcorrEspondEnts halifax ChrIstIne MaCy, OAA regina bernard fLaMan, SAA montreal davId theodore calgary davId a. down, AAA Winnipeg herbert enns, MAA vancouver adeLe weder publishEr toM arkeLL 416-510-6806 AssociAtEpublishEr GreG PaLIouras 416-510-6808
the reCentLy oPened MIdLand CuLturaL Centre was desIGned by howard rIdeout. Its CoMPLetIon eMPhasIzes the vaLue of CoMbInInG eConoMIC and urban strateGIes to ensure the suCCess of sMaLL CItIes and ruraL CoMMunItIes In ontarIo and eLsewhere. AbovE
The corner of King and Elizabeth Streets in the Town of Midland (pop. 16,300) may not be Ontario’s liveliest intersection of culture and commerce, but it certainly embodies a larger trend of rethinking the strategic importance of smaller communities seeking greater prosperity for their future. What is the primary catalyst in this endeavour? The opening of a new cultural centre for Midland in early June. Designed by Howard Rideout Architect, the Midland Cultural Centre (MCC) is a 30,000square-foot facility that includes art galleries, classrooms, a black-box theatre, banquet facilities, a café and other performance spaces. Although its $7.5-million budget may seem insignificant, the MCC’s impact on the community will be transformative. The facility has already proven successful at bringing together leading entrepreneurs and organizations in Midland and the surrounding Simcoe County who recognize that arts, culture and education are integral components to the region’s success. The MCC’s major funder was local businessman Reinhart Weber. Through his foundation, Weber has also contributed millions of dollars to support local social agencies, hospitals, and educational institutions. When champions of business, arts and culture work together, communities like Midland become more attractive to outside investors while also offering greater support to existing institutions such as Georgian College and the Huronia Players Theatre. The best investment that Midland can make to ensure its future prosperity is to attract innovation and creativity though partnerships that leverage the community’s cultural and economic assets. These challenges are similar to countless towns of a similar size across Canada. When these challenges are met successfully, more buildings like the MCC will be built. 6 cAnAdiAnArchitEct 07/12
Last February, the Martin Prosperity Institute (MPI), a think tank at the Rotman School of Management at the University of Toronto, published a report entitled Benchmarking the Creative Economy in Rural Ontario. The report applied the MPI’s Creativity Index to determine where future and sustainable economic growth is most likely to occur in smaller communities across Ontario. MPI’s Creativity Index is comprised of a variety of cultural capital components (i.e., educational resources, knowledge-based business, cultural diversity) that contri bute to a “Creative Economy” where “the ability to mass-produce goods is subordinate to the innate human capability to generate new ideas, concepts, products and processes. The Creative Class is defined as people in occupations paid to think. Regions that attract and retain this group of workers are best positioned to succeed in the future.” The report examined 50 communities across Ontario, including Midland, which was ranked seventh overall. In Midland, a higher percentage of its population works in art, culture, recreation and sport than in other rural communities examined in the province. Nevertheless, with low population growth, high unemployment and relatively low levels of post-secondary education, Midland still has a number of hurdles to clear. Realistically, it will take more than a new cultural centre to propel the good fortunes of Midland forward, but the critical lesson to learn is the importance of recognizing a small town’s valiant efforts to link business and economic development with arts and culture—an effort that will undoubtedly serve to attract creative energy and spirit to Midland, thereby fostering greater prosperity for this Ontario community. Ian ChodIkoff
ichodikoff@cAnAdiAnArchitEct.coM
circulAtionMAnAgEr beata oLeChnowICz 416-442-5600 ext. 3543 custoMErsErvicE MaLkIt Chana 416-442-5600 ext. 3539 production JessICa Jubb grAphicdEsign sue wILLIaMson vicEprEsidEntofcAnAdiAnpublishing aLex PaPanou prEsidEntofbusinEssinforMAtiongroup bruCe CreIGhton hEAdofficE 80 vaLLeybrook drIve, toronto, on M3b 2s9 telephone 416-510-6845 facsimile 416-510-5140 e-mail editors@canadianarchitect.com Web site www.canadianarchitect.com Canadian architect is published monthly by bIG Magazines LP, a div. of Glacier bIG holdings Company Ltd., a leading Canadian information company with interests in daily and community newspapers and business-tobusiness information services. the editors have made every reasonable effort to provide accurate and authoritative information, but they assume no liability for the accuracy or completeness of the text, or its fitness for any particular purpose. subscription rates Canada: $54.95 plus applicable taxes for one year; $87.95 plus applicable taxes for two years (hst – #809751274rt0001). Price per single copy: $6.95. students (prepaid with student Id, includes taxes): $34.97 for one year. usa: $105.95 us for one year. all other foreign: $125.95 us per year. single copy us and foreign: $10.00 us. return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: Circulation dept., Canadian architect, 80 valleybrook dr, toronto, on Canada M3b 2s9. Postmaster: please forward forms 29b and 67b to 80 valleybrook dr, toronto, on Canada M3b 2s9. Printed in Canada. all rights reserved. the contents of this publication may not be reproduced either in part or in full without the consent of the copyright owner. from time to time we make our subscription list available to select companies and organizations whose product or service may interest you. If you do not wish your contact information to be made available, please contact us via one of the following methods: telephone 1-800-668-2374 facsimile 416-442-2191 e-mail privacyofficer@businessinformationgroup.ca mail Privacy officer, business Information Group, 80 valleybrook dr, toronto, on Canada M3b 2s9 member of the canadian business press member of the audit bureau of circulations publications mail agreement #40069240 issn 1923-3353 (online) issn 0008-2872 (print)
We acknoWledge the financial support of the government of canada through the canada periodical fund (cpf) for our publishing activities.
COLOR TRANSFORMATION
Helping to make children feel better, inside and out. UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh is not just a world-class health care facility and LEED® silver certified. It’s also a vivid example of how designers, architects, and contractors can use color to create a physical and emotional transformation. After extensive research with children and their families, the hospital’s architect chose PPG CORAFLON® and DURANAR® fluoropolymer coatings for the exterior colors, to communicate a facility that is dynamic and alive. Interior walls and trim are coated with PPG PURE PERFORMANCE®, among the world’s first premiumquality zero-VOC* latex paint, in shades designed to promote healing. SUNGATE® 500 glass allows high levels of natural sunlight, while our Atlantica glass supplies the spectacular emerald-green hue. With more than 100,000 custom-created Duranar colors and a wide array of energy-saving tinted glass, no company offers more color choices for your next project. So visit ppg.com to contact an architectural specialist.
Bringing innovation to the surface.™ PAINTS - COATINGS - OPTICAL PRODUCTS - SILICAS - CHEMICALS - GLASS - FIBER GLASS The PPG logo, Coraflon, Duranar, Pure Performance, Sungate and “Bringing innovation to the surface.” are registered trademarks of PPG Industries Ohio, Inc. LEED is a registered trademark of the U.S. Green Building Council *Colorants added to this base paint may increase VOC levels significantly, depending on color choice.
LeviTTgoodmanarchiTecTs
news
Projects Levitt Goodman architects reveal design of Laurentian University’s school of architecture.
Toronto-based Levitt Goodman Architects have revealed their preliminary design of the Laurentian Architecture Laurentienne (LAL) School of Architecture, set to open in Sudbury in September 2015. Under the leadership of founding director Terrance Galvin, LAL offers an undergraduate program along with a graduate co-operative program, and strives to teach sustainable building design for northern climates. It is anticipated that the design of the entire school will become a teaching tool via exposed building systems and construction details. As the first satellite downtown campus for Laurentian University, the project strives to act as a significant catalyst in rejuvenating the Sudbury core, not only by introducing a new urban landmark, but also by bringing an influx of students, faculty and ideas to the city centre that will positively impact other local institutions and businesses while stimulating further cultural and economic initiatives. Each building wing is conceived as having a unique formal identity and a discernible programmatic character within the school. The two existing buildings are adapted and thoughtfully reused: the Telegraph Building contains faculty offices, and the Market Building houses the gallery and workshop as the centre of production and exhibition. The new North Wing is predominantly made up of studios and is the main face of the school along Elm Street, while the West Wing houses resource programming such as the library and theatre, and will have a higher level of accessibility to the broader community. With an approximate $28-million construction budget, the LAL School of Architecture will provide roughly 75,000 square feet of space for
students and faculty. The two-phased construction project will see the existing building renovation ready for the fall term in September 2013, and the new building is scheduled for completion in September 2015. Having achieved great success with their design of the University of Waterloo School of Architecture in Cambridge in 2004, Levitt Goodman Architects were selected as the design architects for LAL, and worked in consultation with AECOM Engineering, landscape architect Rob Wright, sustainability consultant Ted Kesik, and urban design consultant Susan Spiegel. sid Lee architecture and Ædifica present the salon Urbain at Place des arts.
Sid Lee Architecture and Ædifica have turned the parking area at Montreal’s Place des Arts into a Salon Urbain, a versatile new space ideal for meeting up before or after a musical performance, a gallery visit or a conference. The space fully captures the artistic appeal of the site, located at the St. Urbain entrance of Place des Arts next to the new concert hall. The bar is the pièce de resistance of the Salon Urbain; a sound wave in physical form. It is the key element in a mobile world where people come together, dance and listen. The colour red is omnipresent, associated with performing arts and premiere nights, and becomes the symbol of a hip urban culture that beats to the rhythm of music and the arts. The Salon Urbain is a versatile space, equipped with the latest technology—an ideal venue for a variety of activities. www.sidlee.com and www.aedifica.com
awards Prestigious new award for architecture endowed by raymond Moriyama.
Architecture Canada | RAIC and the RAIC Foundation are proud to announce a major new
aBoVeThedesignforLaurenTianuni versiTy’snewschooLofarchiTecTure wasrecenTLyunveiLed.iTisexpecTedTo heLpreviTaLizesudbury’sdownTown.
award in architecture called the Moriyama RAIC International Prize. The Prize is named after its benefactor Raymond Moriyama, FRAIC, who made it possible with a generous endowment of $200,000. The Prize will be awarded every two years in two categories. The first will be presented to a Canadian or international architect for an outstanding built project, to be selected by juried competition. The second will be presented to a non-architect from anywhere in the world for outstanding contributions to architecture, to be selected by juried nomination. The inaugural Moriyama RAIC International Prize will be announced in late 2013. Raymond Moriyama founded Moriyama & Teshima Architects in 1958. He has enjoyed a long and distinguished career, and has received numerous honours including the Confederation of Canada Medal, the RAIC Gold Medal and the Governor General’s Medal in Architecture. He was also awarded the Order of Ontario, is a Companion of the Order of Canada, and a recipient of the Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal. ciGi campus by KPMB architects receives riBa international award.
The Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) announced that the Centre for International Governance Innovation Campus (CIGI Campus) in Waterloo, Ontario, designed by Kuwabara Payne McKenna Blumberg Architects, is a recipient of the prestigious International Award for Architecture. The RIBA International Awards are presented to architecture practices based outside the UK building anywhere outside the UK, or to practices based in Britain and working outside 07/12canadian architect
9
the EU. All winners are eligible for the RIBA Lubetkin Prize awarded to the best international building by a RIBA member, which will be announced later in the year. The full list of 12 RIBA International Award winners for 2012 is as follows: Clayton Campus—Monash University, Melbourne, Australia by VN Architecture; Balsillie School of International Affairs, CIGI Campus, Waterloo, Canada by KPMB Architects; Guangzhou International Finance Centre, Guangzhou, China by Wilkinson Eyre Architects; Innhouse Hotel Kunming, China by Integer Intelligent and Green; Yotsuya Tenera, Tokyo, Japan by Key Operation Inc/Architects; One KL, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia by SCDA Architects; The Troika, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia by Foster + Partners; Auckland Art Gallery by Toi o Tamaki, Auckland, New Zealand FJMT + Archimedia—architects in association; Solaris Fusionopolis 2B, One North, Singapore by TR Hamzah and Yeang; Urban Housing and Crèche, Geneva, Switzerland by Sergison Bates Architects with Jean-Paul Jaccaud Architectes; Frick Chemistry Laboratory, Princeton University, USA by Hopkins Architects; and Sperone Westwater, Bowery, New York City by Foster + Partners. www.architecture.com/Awards/RIBAInternational Awards/2012/Internationalwinners.aspx
Paul raff studio wins four awards.
Of over 800 entries from around the world, Toronto-based architect Paul Raff Studio’s Bluepoint Condos project has won two highly coveted International Property Awards. The boutique condominiums in Phuket, Thailand were honoured with two awards at the Asia Pacific Property Awards Gala Presentation in Kuala Lumpur on April 27, 2012. The International Property Awards celebrate the highest levels of achievement by companies operating in all sectors of the property and real estate industry, and are split into regions covering Africa, Asia Pacific, Arabia, Canada, Caribbean, Central & South America, Europe, UK and USA. Raff was also recently presented with two prestigious Ontario Association of Architects (OAA) awards: the Bluepoint Pavilion was recognized with a Design Excellence award for transforming a prefab box-frame and off-the-shelf planks into an artful, dynamic sales pavilion for the Bluepoint Condos; and the studio also won an award in the Artifact category for Regina Gateway, a monumental sculptural public artwork that acts as a gateway into the city of Regina in Saskatchewan. Regina Gateway was designed in collaboration with artist and architect Jyhling Lee. www.paulraffstudio.com
coMPetitions transforming seattle’s 520 Floating Bridge: 2012 international design ideas competition.
The Transforming Seattle’s 520 Floating Bridge 2012 International Design Ideas Competition is challenging the design and art communities to envision new, innovative reuse strategies. The 520 bridge will be decommissioned in 2014 due to high maintenance costs, damage, and the need for additional lanes. The Washington State Department of Transportation is requiring of the new bridge’s design-build team that it be reused or recycled in a sustainable fashion; current trends for the reuse of pontoons have been floating docks, breakwaters and piers, but what else could be done with such a feat of engineering? Infrastructure reuse has recently made headlines in architecture. Some examples include the High Line in New York, which converted a raised railroad track into a linear park; Kraanspoor in Amsterdam, a project which built an office complex atop a concrete shipyard craneway; and the current debate on New York’s Tappan Zee Bridge, which many are hoping to see reused as a park. This competition seeks (continued on page 33)
Wire Mesh Building Envelopes Halifax Stanfield International Airport | Los Angeles Police Department | Aurora GO Transit Station Greg Bryson
1-800-325-5993 Ext. 1257
CANADA greg@weavingideas.net
www.weavingideas.net
PLAN TO USE PURPLE. WALLTITE Eco insulation/air barrier fits perfectly into almost every space you design. ®
NOW OFFERING WALLTITE ECO V.3
The industry’s highest long-term thermal resistance performance †
R 12.4 @ 2” | R 19.2 @ 3” | R 26.2 @ 4” You painstakingly consider the utility, look and feel of your design. But how does it perform? Our closed-cell insulation/air barrier provides trusted long-term energy efficiency and enhances the durability of the building. WALLTITE Eco fits into any curve or corner you imagine, ensuring that you have a well-sealed building envelope. That means your design gets the high performance it deserves. At BASF, we create chemistry.
Learn how WALLTITE Eco can enhance your next plan at
www.walltiteeco.com or call toll-free 1-866-474-3538
†
As per Canadian Construction Materials Centre (CCMC) reports for medium density spray polyurethane foam posted December 2011.
WALLTITE Eco is a registered trade-mark of BASF Canada Inc. ECOLOGO is a trade-mark of Environment Canada; GREENGUARD Indoor Air Quality Certified is a registered trade-mark, and GREENGUARD Children and Schools is a service mark, of their respective owners; all used by BASF Canada Inc. with permission. © 2012 BASF Canada Inc.
335-4341_A_WalltiteE_Comm_CdnArch_FINAL.indd 1
12-03-13 4:33 PM
2012 AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE SUBMIT YOUR ENTRY
www.CanadianArchitect.com/Awards/2012-Entry-Form
ENTRY DEADlINE: ThURSDAY, SEpTEMBER 13, 2012
Marrying creativity with the environment. 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Norex速 is the most innovative architectural panel in its category.
速
NOREX速 PANEL WITH POLYISOCYANURATE CORE
1 877 667-2321
norbecarchitectural.com
9
Pub Canadian Architect 9" x 11.25"
A WIDER PALETTE FOR HEALTHY ENVIRONMENTS Introducing noraplan® sentica Developed by architects and designers, noraplan® sentica is what you’ve asked for in a new floor covering. With the durability and comfort of nora® flooring, noraplan sentica provides a subtle tone-on-tone design highlighted by an array of colors to complement any healing environment. While created mainly for healthcare applications, noraplan sentica works beautifully in a variety of settings and also provides a harmonious complement to noraplan environcare. Ask for samples today. ™
nor000994-01Sentica-caD1.indd 1
Follow us @noraflooring
www.nora.com/us/sentica-launch4
5/8/12 11:25 AM
Something in common
Significant challengeS neceSSitate a creative approach to thiS project located in an at-riSk Suburban community of toronto. project McGreGor coMMunity centre LounGe, toronto, ontario architect BortoLotto DesiGn architect text PaiGe MaGarrey photoS shai GiL, Ben rahn
“Basically, the City of Toronto said ‘Here: do something nice,’” says architect Tania Borto lotto while sitting in the sunfilled McGregor Community Centre Lounge, a recently com pleted city build that’s easily one of her most successful projects to date—and, incidentally, one of the tiniest. The 130squaremetre space, 14 canadian architect 07/12
located within Scarborough’s McGregor Com munity Centre and lovingly nicknamed The Commons, is a lesson in doing more with less: less money, less space and less time, all of which resulted in an uplifting space that is already transforming an atrisk community. Though it’s clearly a landmark project for Bortolotto Design Architect, the 13yearold Toronto studio is no stranger to the rigours of government and nonprofit projects—previous endeavours include the Toronto headquarters for Street Kids International and Castlefield’s
Municipal Works office, and, most recently, a new rest stop for Oakville transit workers. “They’re very complex compared to a house or private project,” says Bortolotto. “Because of budgets, because of timelines, because of the complexities of the community and the politics.” And the complexities of The Commons are no exception. The project is one of 26 around the city that benefited from the Priority Neighbour hoods program that injected $13 million in government funds into new playgrounds, com munity spaces and parks in 13 highrisk neigh bourhoods around the city, from a new skateboard park in Lawrence Park to an arts hub at Jane and Finch’s Yorkwood Library. Dorset Park, the West Scarborough neighbour hood where the lounge is located, is affected by
shai GiL above GenerousLy scaLeD cLerestory winDows ProviDe Privacy anD an aBunDance of naturaL LiGht for this new coMMunity centre LounGe in toronto’s west scarBorouGh neiGhBourhooD.
high poverty (26.5 per cent of the ward), un employment and dropout rates, which have led to gang activity, crime and violence. The lounge’s budget was limited—just under $800,000 from the federal and provincial Rec reational Infrastructure Canada Program (RInC), the city’s Priority Neighbourhoods In vestment, and donations from the United Way Youth Challenge Fund. And the schedule was tight; with the added community meetings that drew out the schematic and design development
phases to just under two years, the construction phase was limited to about a year. But the real challenges lay in the site. Situated between two existing—and differently designed—buildings, the McGregor Park Community Centre and the 2004 McGregor Park Library (designed by ZAS Architects), the new lounge was to not only link together the two structures, but also create a new façade for the entire complex along Law rence Avenue. “It became a sort of marker for the community centre,” says Bortolotto, who laments that the façade has to compete with the enormous parking lot situated just east of the entrance. “Just the way it fit in with the rest of the building, the site was really challenging. What’s the character of this building? How do we fit it in with everything?” In an extra little
twist, the site also had contaminated and wet soil that had to be treated before they could even break ground. Some of the challenges led to really great things. For example, all projects in the Priority Neighbourhoods initiatives used extensive community engagement to determine what the neighbourhoods really needed; for The Com mons, Bortolotto worked with 30 youths from the Dorset Park Youth Council, an organization committed to developing antigang and anti violence initiatives. Not only did the teens help to establish a community connection to the pro ject from the very beginning, they also helped Bortolotto and her team to prioritize which fea tures were most important to the actual users. Top of the list was, of course, safety. There were certain colours to steer clear of completely due to gang affiliation, so the design team stuck to a simple palette of blue and grey. Expensive bulletproof glass was requested for the Law rence Avenue façade, which Bortolotto circum vented by raising the windows above street level to obscure views of the busy street while bring ing in more natural daylight. And she had to fight for outdoor areas, addressing nighttime safety concerns by adding security lights and surveillance cameras indoors and out. Really, the community’s needs were very clear: a safe, calm place to grow. But when the safety con cerns include guns, gangs and very real vio lence, the challenge is to create a safe place that doesn’t feel like a prison. The answer, for Bortolotto, is uplifting de sign—something that she has focused on in pre vious projects to dramatic result by using a threetiered approach. First, an explorative ap proach to the form and shape of a building— “carving the space,” as she calls it. The height of the ceiling, the width of the space, and tweaks in the overall proportions of the project don’t usually change the budget too much, she says, but they can make a big impact in deviating from more traditional designs. Despite its small size, the lounge completely changes the face of the community centre from the street by jutting out as close as possible to Lawrence Avenue, with its expansive ribbon of windows reflecting back the surrounding trees and sun. Inside, the doubleheight ceiling prevents any feelings of claustrophobia and fosters an openconcept approach: aside from a galley kitchen along the southern wall and a spaceage allglass office cube in the corner, the lounge is totally open and reconfigurable—a necessity, considering how flexible the space had to be to accommodate everything from business meetings and seniors’ 07/12 canadian architect
15
shai GiL
Ben rahn
Ben rahn
clockwiSe from top left a curveD ceiLinG-anD-waLL asseMBLy ProviDes fLuiDity to an otherwise MiniMaL aesthetic within this interior sPace; the LearninG coMMons in neutraL shaDes of sky BLue anD Grey; an overaLL view of the BuiLDinG’s MassinG. oppoSite, top right a corner DetaiL iLLustrates the Project’s BaLance of Privacy anD safety with PLenty of visuaL transParency.
lawrence avenue eaSt
5
2 4 3
1
ground floor 1 2 3 4 5
corriDor LounGe kitchen office courtyarD
16 canadian architect 07/12
0
5m
gatherings to youth lunches and movie nights. It’s the composition that led to one of the most dramatic elements of the space—and Bortolotto’s favourite part of the design. The entrance hallway running along the eastern wall acts as a transitional portal for the space, with glazing on either side that overlooks the sprawling parking lot on one side and the bustling daycare on the other. But as it leads into the lounge, the windows both end, creating a momentary sensation of intense con traction before the room opens up and lifts your eyes to the row of glass panels running below the roofline. “Suddenly you’re forced to look up into the sky,” says Bortolotto. It’s a brilliant element, and a problemsolver: it resolved the need for bulletproof glass, offered the users the privacy they desired, and obscured the lessthaninspiring views of Lawrence Avenue and the parking lot without blocking out the outside world. And the outside world is another thing that Bortolotto instills in every project she works on to evoke that uplifting feel. In addition to bringing in views of the sky and treetops, she included operable windows for nat ural ventilation, and fought to include a small outdoor courtyard through a door on the western wall. “It’s being close to nature. Like we are one,” she says, smiling as she hears her own words. “You have to be part of it and close to it. We’re just automatically attracted to nature, and yet we live in a world so detached from it.” The final element of Bortolotto’s approach is decidedly openended: making the space interesting. This means everything from choice of ma terials to the use of textures—and for The Commons, even the costsaving measures that had to be followed to keep the project under budget. Rather
KENNEDY ROAD
W LA T
AS EE
NU VE EA
NC RE
than wasting money on expensive finishes, the team focused on a simple paredback palette with unique twists. The concrete block walls, for example, are raked horizontally to add more texture, and the southern gypsum wall (painted sky blue, a nongang colour) encloses storage lockers before curving up and across the ceil ing, stopping just short of the glazing to create a slightly dropped ceiling that gives the space a feeling of an open pavilion rather than an enclosed space. “The materiality brings the in terest,” says Bortolotto. “They’re subtle, not pretentious. You might sit here and not know why it feels good.” Since its completion in late 2011, The Com mons has become home to a lunch program for
Winston Churchill students twice a week, a youth photography course, mentoring work shops and youth council meetings. “Everyone seems to be comfortable in the space,” says McGregor Park’s community recreation pro BIRCHMOUNT ROAD grammer Terry Cheung. “It can be used for all sorts of different programming.” A simple re sponse, but exactly what Bortolotto was hoping for when she first saw the site and envisioned what would grow from it. “It was just a small project,” she says. “But I wanted to know how we could make a great project out of something that’s just a room.” ca Paige Magarrey is a Toronto-based architecture and design writer.
shai GiL
axonometric Site plan
client city of toronto architect team tania BortoLotto, aLex horBer, jerry Lin Structural BLackweLL Bowick PartnershiP LtD. electrical/mechanical jain & associates LtD. landScape fLeisher riDout PartnershiP inc. interiorS BortoLotto DesiGn architect inc. contractor truMBLey & haMPton inc. code DaviD hine enGineerinG inc. area 1,450 ft2 budget $800,000 completion sePteMBer 2011
Building on your vision of efficiency WATER-SOURCE VRF HVAC Solutions from Mitsubishi Electric CITY MULTI’s water-source VRF system delivers a higher level of efficiency. Energy efficiency is achieved with double heat recovery and being geothermal-ready. Units can be installed on any floor or location with longer pipe lengths, providing design efficiency to any type of building. Our extremely compact 2-pipe units take up less mechanical floor space than traditional HVAC systems, improving total installed cost efficiency with savings on both labour and material.
www.CityMulti.ca
07/12 canadian architect
PROOF #: 05
17
tom aRBan
Park and re-creation
the massive urban renewal Process well underway in toronto’s beleaguered regent Park reflects the cyclical nature of ideas about urbanism and social engineering. Regent PaRk Revitalization vaRious alex Bozikovic
ProJect
architects teXt
Regent Park was Canada’s first attempt at imposing large-scale urban renewal on the city. It was a broad experiment that signalled clear results. During the development of the neighbourhood between 1948 and 1957, the City of Toronto expropriated and erased 69 acres of Victorian workers’ housing, and replaced that messy swathe of urban “slum” with a perfectly blank slate. Nearby, parts of the Cabbageown neighbourhood soldiered on, with its narrow brick houses and backyard shacks remaining largely 18 canadian architect 06/12
intact. Only one generation after beginning a process of urban renewal that gave birth to Regent Park, the neighbourhood was considered a slum, or as The Toronto Star simply stated in 1968, a “disaster.” Why? Because it shattered the bones of this part of Toronto. The plan, initiated by the influential planner Eugene Faludi, consolidated the area into a massive superblock largely free of streets; it sprinkled a series of low-rise and mid-rise towers across the site, interspersed with unprogrammed green space and parking. The buildings and plan bear only glancing relationships to the major thoroughfares of Dundas and Shuter Streets, which cut across the site; as with superblocks in other cities, navigation is difficult and locating addresses even more troublesome. The buildings mixed Garden Cityscaled walkups (four- to-five-storey cruciform brick structures with Spartan detailing and little landscaping, by J.E. Hoare) and five Corbusian 14-storey towers (by architect Peter Dickinson). It was, in detail and as a whole, a radical break
from Toronto’s 19th-century urbanism. So there is a heavy irony in the fact that the current revitalization project, equally bold, is essentially turning back the clock to a healthier urban life before the superblock. It is, on a grand scale, a neat illustration of the cyclical nature of ideas about urbanism, social engineering and dwelling in the metropolis. Looking down at a scale model of the site that depicts a massive array of new, still-faceless towers, it would be easy to imagine the project as monolithic and institutional. But despite the scale of the project, no singular authority is in charge here. When I saw such a model, I was standing in the sales office that a private developer, the Daniels Corporation, has established to sell the market apartments it will build over the next 15 years in an equity partnership with the beleaguered Toronto Community Housing Corporation (TCHC). This plan, led by Markson Borooah Hodgson Architects and Greenberg Consultants Inc., is centred on the deliberate integration of market
denied. It is urban redevelopment and social engineering on an enormous scale. Its urban planning success, both in terms of social and economic development, will depend on the skill with which the builders bridge the gap between its massive scale and the fine grain of its architecture and streetscape. The results so far are generally good. Most importantly, there is a common aesthetic language that links the public and private-sector projects: a humane Modernism of simple massing and materials, principally red brick, that are compatible with the Toronto vernacular. There are through streets, which reconnect Regent Park back to the adjacent 19th-century city grid. There is a large park and recreation facility at the heart of the development, and its buildings are sited squarely to the secondary streets that now extend through Regent Park which address the major east-west streets in some cases. The first building completed in the project is right next to the park: the architectsAlliance (aA)-designed Sackville-Dundas apartments
teRence touRangeau
teRence touRangeau
and social housing. Since the first iteration in 2002, its proposed buildings have grown taller while this part of downtown has undergone a rapid and increasing pace of gentrification and development. Under the current projections, Regent Park will include 3,000 units of private market housing, and nearly 1,600 units of subsidized housing, down from 2,083 in the previous plan. And all of this redevelopment is being monitored by the City’s planning department. Under the City’s Social Development Plan prepared for the TCHC in 2007, a few other broad principles are equally important to the success of the area: strengthening physical and social links between Regent Park and the city around it; slow phasing so as to maintain the social fabric of the existing community that lives here; and a program to allow social-housing residents to return to the area if they wish. Indeed, this project fundamentally illustrates different ideas than its predecessor about class, social mobility and the ideal form of the city. And yet, the scope of the project cannot be
the context of Regent PaRk within the city can Be seen in this image of DiamonD schmitt aRchitects’ one cole DeveloPment. above left the RelationshiP Between BuilDing anD oPen sPace was a sensitive Design issue, given the conceRns of safety anD visiBility. above comPleteD in 2009, the sackville-DunDas aPaRtments comPlex was DesigneD By aRchitectsalliance, anD was one of the fiRst PRojects to Be occuPieD. oPPosite toP
which were completed in 2009. This two-tower complex imports the typology of the podium and point tower that aA have employed to good effect in commercially built condominiums around Toronto, as well as a material palette from that register: purple-grey brick façades and expansive windows with irregular, staggered mullion patterns. The taller 22-storey tower is home to 224 TCHC family-oriented apartments (and within its base, the infrastructure for the neighbourhood’s district energy plant); the shorter, eightstorey tower to the south is a seniors’ residence 06/12 canadian architect
19
teRence touRangeau
haRolD claRk
one PaRk west By coRe aRchitects maximizes the oPPoRtunities foR Balconies leaDing off fRom as many units as PossiBle; glimPses of the new anD imPRoveD Regent PaRk. below the new sackville-DunDas aPaRtment comPlex incoRPoRates many sustainaBle Design featuRes. oPPosite toP and bottom 40 oaks, DesigneD By hilDitch aRchitects, is an intensely community-focuseD DeveloPment. above, left to right
4
4
2
3
5
2 4
2
1 1
3
sackville-dundas aPartments: residential Program
sackville-dundas aPartments: green design
low-Rise = families high-Rise = senioRs
1 2 3 4 5
20 canadian architect 06/12
atlantis in-gRounD iRRigation system Plantings at gRaDe anD on the Roof stoRmwateR management/wateR conseRvation Regent PaRk community eneRgy system Bicycle PaRking
teRence touRangeau
2
hilDitch aRchitect 40 oaks cutaway
hilDitch aRchitect
with 159 units, and a daycare on the ground floor. The building’s parti is intelligent; the small footprint of each tower means the apartments tend to be wide and shallow, therefore bright and comfortably laid out. Meanwhile, the podium provides a site for infrastructure and, on its roof, a large terrace and green roof to be shared between the buildings.
The complex’s design, led by two aA partners— the late Adrian diCastri, and then by Peter Clewes—follows a laudable sustainability program; it is designed to approximate a LEED Gold standard, largely through green roofs and reflective roofs, passive solar strategies and stormwater management. This despite the project’s broad use of glazing units and energy-inefficient protruding balconies on one side. (It is only 50 percent glazed, according to aA associate Adam Feldmann.) More importantly, the design projects an impression of quality and it gives no overt visual clues that it was developed for subsidized housing—an explicit goal for the project which seems to backfire in some aspects of the architecture. For example, the lobby employs rich Carrara marble used for accent walls and solid, substantial counters in the mailroom. They are expensive and carefully built; yet they differ dramatically from the vernacular of the suburban residential market that many new immigrants coming to Canada—the target purchaser of the development—are most familiar with and may not carry connotations of comfort or domesticity to such residents. However, TCHC’s reported feedback is positive, and so were the comments I heard from the residents I met. On a weekday afternoon, an ethnically diverse group of elderly women hung out in the very chic lounge, comfortably watching The Ellen DeGeneres Show together. Most importantly, the Sackville-Dundas complex is well detailed at street level. Its entrances, landscaping, and the ground-related townhouses
that stretch along its north side all feature attractive proportions and material choices. The gardens are just large enough to create a comfortable visual relationship between private residences and the sidewalk; the outer layer is gravel, and the hardy evergreen hedges add privacy. These are sensible decisions; aA has competently handled this interface between residences, landscape and the city, which is so crucial to the area’s long-term success. The nearby 40 Oaks project presents a similar approach to the street. Located around the corner from the Sackville-Dundas development, it is a bit of an oddity in terms of program and client: it’s the only building in the Regent Park footprint that is neither the work of the TCHC nor Daniels. The client, the Toronto Christian Resource Centre (CRC), was housed in a church that was one of just two sites in the area not owned by the TCHC. That property stood in the way of a planned linear park along Oak Street. The CRC hired Hilditch Architect, a 25-yearold firm with extensive experience building in the non-profit sector to advise them about a land swap with the housing corporation. CRC agreed to give up a parcel of land with a church that was subsequently demolished in exchange for a new site along the north edge of the new park. The design brief was then revised to accommodate 87 seniors’ residences upstairs—from bachelor units to two-bedroom units—and a range of public services on the main floor. The residential spaces benefit from an unusual 06/12 canadian architect
21
tom aRBan
tom aRBan
tom aRBan
r d st
and the public services, which the CRC has historically provided to the entire community. The answer: separate entrances to the residences on the west façade and to the non-denominational chapel on the east side. A chandelier comprised of constellations of suspended rough glass animates the inside of the cylindrical chapel space located on the southeast corner of the building. The chandelier was created by Public Displays of Affection, a non-profit collective of designers who supplied over 100 furnishings, fixtures and installations throughout the interior of the building. Invited by Hilditch, the group’s members— a collection of adventurous craftspeople including Made, Brothers Dressler, Lubo Brezina and
eet
sum
eet
ach
str
eet
et
r e st
tre le s
col
et
kvil
stre
sac
oak
et
d
site Plan—one cole street
as und
str
eet
eas
t
DiamonD schmitt aRchitects
rar
tre nt s
22 canadian architect 06/12
ger
ame
one oak stReet, DesigneD By keaRns mancini aRchitects, uses vaRious BuilDing Planes anD DiscRete winDow comPositions to fosteR intimacy anD scale in the DeveloPment. right an aeRial Photo of Regent PaRk illustRates how new DeveloPments aRe RePlacing the olD DouBle-cRucifoRm-shaPeD PuBlic housing. toP row
was open and welcoming,” Rosenberg says, “where people could come in, have a shower, take a meal, and rest.” The façade’s combination of red and yellow brick helps visually divide the mass of the building; brises-soleil cut direct sunlight and add visual interest; and its substantial glazing links the kitchen at the front of the building with the park out front. Thanks to extensive advocacy by the project architects, much of the park will become a community garden that supports the CRC’s activities that include such programs as fresh food delivery to the local community. At the same time, the architects were charged with making a distinction between the residences
li Pa r
structural system: massive two-storey-tall steel trusses cut through the building along the northsouth axis at different points as the building rises. This allows for column-free spaces through much of the upper floors, creating for flexibility both now and for later. “We like that in the future, if the demographics change, they’ll be able to rearrange the units as needed,” says Charles Rosenberg, an associate at Hilditch who worked on the project. It’s a stark contrast to the immovable shear walls that are standard in marketrate condominium buildings and which—as some local architects, and downtown Toronto city councillor Adam Vaughan have been arguing for years—may prevent adaptive reuse of those buildings, and doom their small apartments to become slums. But the 40 Oaks building’s most important notes are urbanistic ones. There was no capital funding from the city for any public spaces; the CRC’s membership generated that portion of the budget through fundraising—a powerful civic gesture. The main level now includes offices for social service agencies, a non-denominational chapel and a kitchen that can, and does, serve 200 people at a meal. Rosenberg, who led the project together with associate Ken DeWaal, describes this as “a large living room on Regent Park.” They wanted “to create a ground floor that
teRence touRangeau
gRounD-oRienteD housing was cRitical to Re-estaBlishing a neighBouRhooD scale. left RooftoP gaRDens anD geneRous teRRaces aRe incentives to attRact new ResiDents to Regent PaRk. bottom the gRassy couRtyaRD of one cole.
teRence touRangeau
far left
DiamonD schmitt aRchitects
Kathryn Walter among others—have added a layer of humanity and rusticity to the public spaces. They worked with light fixtures, wood and pews salvaged from a demolished United Church in affluent North Toronto. One of the area’s market-housing counterparts is One Cole, the condominium tower designed by Diamond Schmitt Architects Inc. (DSAI), which has anchored the redevelopment at the major corner of Dundas and Parliament since fall 2009. It houses a grocery store clad in an attractive glass façade with well proportioned, narrow mullions. Its addition is a boon for residents in the area. Adjacent to the grocery store is a large and extremely busy Tim Hortons coffee shop. Above
this podium, two point towers—one nine and the other 19 storeys—full of condominiums rise above. One Cole is a close match to the SackvilleDundas complex, just one block away, in both form and parti—amenities and green roof space along the top of the podium with some very well designed red brick townhouses along one side. One Cole was a test case and a billboard for the commercial component of the Regent Park revitalization—and the sales of the condos were quickly successful. So successful, in fact, that The Sun, Toronto’s right-wing tabloid, has accused City and Daniels officials—such as local councillor Pam McConnell, who now lives here— of profiting from their involvement.
Once those accusations are resolved, One Cole will retain its importance as a signpost of the good design and urbanism that have shaped this project. DSAI principal Don Schmitt, who led the design, has been a loud advocate for the entire revitalization project. It shows some of his skill, and reflects DSAI’s long-running commitments to community causes and well-made “fabric” buildings—including the Regent Park Community Health Centre (1999), a gem of a building right across the road. With One Cole, DSAI has established an appropriate tone for the architecture in and around Regent Park in many ways, despite the unnecessarily fussy articulation of the spandrel panels on the upper floors. Similarly, One Park West by Core Architects, the other condo Daniels has completed at Regent Park, compromises its fine massing with awkward façade detailing; the irregular pattern of vertical lines crashes into the top of the building in a pile-up of stucco, mechanical units and (again) unattractive spandrel panels. Nonetheless, its three-storey townhouses hit the mark with simple, well-designed façades and pedestrian-friendly design. Another adjacent set of townhouses, these by Graziani and Corazza—which inexplicably won a Toronto Architecture and Urban Design Award—employ a similar scale and material palette, but their façades are both clunky and fussy. Across the street from One Cole is One Oak Street by Kearns Mancini Architects Inc. (KMAI), a TCHC building development that follows a more sober approach to the aesthetic problems of Regent Park. This 12-storey building, housing 84 mostly family-sized units, makes a self-conscious effort to build on the loft conversions and quasiloft condos that have become ubiquitous in downtown Toronto. “We wanted to get that Toronto language in, through the loft building,” says KMAI principal Jonathan Kearns, who led the project. That meant adopting (and slightly stretching) the foursquare proportions of early 20th-century industrial mid-rises, and cladding them with matte red brick and matching grout colour. This project, like One Cole, was subject to the design review panel that the City has established for Regent Park, and the heights and envelope were largely set by the area plan. “Our main play was in manipulating the building planes and the windows,” Kearns says. His team chose to group the windows—which make up only 31 percent of the façade surfaces—into discrete elements that extend across the floor plates so that, according to Kearns, “You get the scale, but not the number 06/12 canadian architect
23
teRence touRangeau
tom aRBan
tom aRBan
tom aRBan
of floors.” Formally speaking, it is a successful move that yields a cleaner composition for the building. Kearns is most proud of the building’s straightforward plan with its single-loaded corridors that provide uniformly pleasant apartments. The building’s formal modesty and attempts at a friendly, vernacular aesthetic were some of the other goals for the project. “We’ve done a lot of affordable housing,” notes Kearns, “and we’re very conscious of the end users’ perception of the building. The residents’ quality of life is the most important thing.” This raises an important point regarding the cultural connotations of Modernist architecture, especially in the social-housing context. Regent Park is evolving at a time when the Toronto real estate market is fully embracing contemporary design. Driven by architects and clients free of market pressures, the design vocabulary at Regent Park is in a similar Modern idiom, and harmonizes with the architecture being sold by intelligent developers such as Daniels. But while Modernism may be what established and assimilated professionals want, is this what lowerincome citizens and recent immigrants want? The planners and architects shaping Regent 24 canadian architect 06/12
Park have collectively made the best possible response to that conundrum, being neither too formally bold nor too timid. Hopefully, there will remain room for more architectural bravado within individual buildings over time. The TCHC is currently under siege for its allegedly spendthrift practices and high-handed approach to tenants; even if most of the specifics are disproved, the accusations have left the organization on the defensive. Because of the TCHC’s focus on long-term sustainability and its freedom from market constraints, its buildings can and should be laboratories for responsible architectural innovation. Their next projects with DSAI, the Paintbox condo and the Regent Park Cultural Centre, will be slightly unusual—but only in a superficial way, applying rainbow-hued spandrel panels on buildings of grey and black brick and glass. One other building on the Regent Park horizon, a TCHC tower currently under design by Giannone Petricone Associates, has more of an adventurous spirit and promises some very creative but economical brick detailing. Thankfully, the TCHC has invited in a variety of architectural voices, including the firms already mentioned in this article. Over time, involving a
clockwise from toP left incoRPoRating DaycaRe facilities was an essential asPect to the new DeveloPments in Regent PaRk; maRBle claDDing aDDs flaiR to the loBBy of the sackville-DunDas aPaRtments; insiDe one of the units at one oak stReet; the loBBy of one oak stReet.
variety of architectural approaches will accomplish a sense of vitality to Regent Park that avoids the stigma of a “housing project,” only encouraging its integration into the neighbouring context. By all accounts, it’s important to note that the TCHC is ensuring that each building functions well at its most important benchmarks for success: the layout of the units themselves and the urban design principles shaping the area. Social-housing clients deserve buildings and civic neighbourhood blocks that can effectively serve their needs. With this latest version of Regent Park, the people are getting what they need—and happily, Toronto is learning how to appreciate the bold and thoughtful architecture that it deserves. ca Alex Bozikovic is a journalist and critic based in Toronto who focuses on architecture and design.
insites
Migrating to Venice
migraTinglandsCapesorganizer
ThepreparaTionofCanada’soffiCialenTryToTheVeniCeBiennaleinarChiTeCTure isnearingCompleTion.alThoughThisamBiTiousprojeCTinCludedanelaBoraTe seleCTionproCessThaTinVolVedaVarieTyofyoungdesignersfromaCrossTheCounTry, TheexhiBiTionignoresmanyimporTanTandpoignanTaspeCTsofThemigraTion experienCe—TheVeryThemeThaTiTseTouTToexplore.
teXt
johnBenTleymays
Nobody goes to the pageants generated by La Biennale di Venezia—the architecture or visual art shows, the film, music, theatre or dance festivals—expecting to see things that are conventional or prêt-à-porter. According to a tradition going back to the 1920s, what’s displayed in the various editions of Europe’s most famous cultural jamboree is supposed to be new and cutting-edge, or at least considered important by leading trendsetters. The national showcases of architecture and art clustered in Venice’s public gardens and scattered elsewhere throughout the island city, especially, should represent the most trenchant thinking and artmaking in each home country.
Of course, not everything featured in every Biennale exposition has hit this high target. But hitting it dead-centre is the intention of anyone who tackles the daunting, glaringly spotlit job of putting on a show for the Biennale—including David Chipperfield, the well-known British architect and curator of Common Ground, the centrepiece group display in this year’s 13th International Architecture Exhibition, opening on August 29. “Above all,” Chipperfield writes in a statement posted on the Biennale’s website, “the ambition of Common Ground is to reassert the existence of an architectural culture, made up not just of singular talents but a rich continuity of diverse ideas united in a common history, common ambitions, common predicaments and ideals.”
aBoVearenderingofTheMigrating LandscapesinsTallaTionaTTheVeniCe BiennaleThaTspillsouTofTheCana dianpaVilionandonToThesurround ingexhiBiTiongrounds.
The notion that this “rich continuity” needs serious reinforcement seems to have been in the air during the last few years. For instance, a full year before Chipperfield announced his theme, a team of enterprising Canadians—Johanna Hurme and Sasa Radulovic, principals in the Winnipeg firm of 5468796 Architecture Inc., and University of Manitoba architecture instructor Jae-Sung Chon—came up with an ambitious proposal meant both to produce Canada’s 2012 Biennale entry and, long before the festival opened, to affirm and enrich “architectural culture” in the Canadian homeland. The project they offered to the Canada Council for the Arts, which awarded them the commission in May 2011, is called Migrating Landscapes. On Canada Day last year, Hurme, 07/12canadian architect
25
grajewskiphoTographyinC. jaCquelineyoung toPanoVerallViewofTheMigrating LandscapesnaTionalexhiBiTionThaTTookplaCe aTThewinnipegarTgalleryThispasTwinTer. aBoVeTheopeningnighTreCepTionfor TheMigrating LandscapesnaTionalexhiBiTionaTThewinnipegarTgallery.
Radulovic and Chon broadcast a call under this title to players under the age of 45 in the country’s architectural and design communities to undertake two tasks: “to reflect on their cultural migration experiences and un/settling encounters” and “to design dwellings—in a sense, first acts of settlement—onto the new landscape” fashioned by the organizers. This “landscape” (or armature) on which the models would be situated is described as “an abstract assembly made of wooden modules.” To me, it seems less of a landscape than a miniature city with no streets and densely packed skyscrapers rising to various heights. 26canadian architect07/12
Contestants were invited “to act as its first immigrants. The act of constructing the first dwellings will be enactments of first immigration onto this abstract landscape.” In keeping with the subject of uprooting, the models of these dwellings were required to “be portable and meet the luggage requirements of regular national and international commercial air travel.” Applicants were also asked to provide short videos in which they tell their migration stories, and reflect on their “specific, personal instances, encounters or memories of un/settling.” The conceptual concerns with movement and place that are expressed in the competition
brief, by the way, come from deep sources: like millions of other Canadians, all three members of the team were born outside Canada, and arrived as strangers to the anglophone North American world they now live and work within. Submissions came in—about 120 in all—and the labour of sifting out wheat from chaff began. This work was to take the form of a competition, but no ordinary one. Instead of handing off the proposals to a single blue-ribbon jury and running a simple contest, the Winnipeg group empanelled no fewer than seven teams of judges— architects, artists, designers, academics, critics (for the record, I was not one of the critics)—in every section of this country. Each regional jury selected regional winners, whose work was then exhibited on top of a version of the signature wooden substructure or “landscape” in one of seven regional shows. The first exhibition in this series was launched in Vancouver in November 2011. Finally, in March of this year, the organizers gathered the winning proposals from every region into the Winnipeg Art Gallery, and asked yet another jury—this one composed of painter Eleanor Bond, Canadian Architect editor Ian Chodikoff, and architects Anne Cormier, Bruce Kuwabara and John Patkau—to select who would go on to Venice. In one sense, the Biennale display in Enrico Peressutti’s eccentric little 1958 Canada Pavilion will be the culminating moment in this trans-Canada story of jurying and showing. The installation will feature 18 brief narrative videos made by the participants and presented on as many small digital screens, a longer overview video projected on a single larger screen, and 18 physical models. The wooden “landscape” will flow through the pavilion’s spiralling interior space, and spill out the door into the terrain between the nearby German and United Kingdom showcases. Laconic, obviously made in a hurry—the deadlines were tight—the objects are smart and deft, poetic, emotionally very cool, frequently wry. In the videos, the architects and designers tell tales about migrating ancestors, homelands and hometowns forsaken, arrivals in strange countries, new languages and new cities. Certainly, the show in Venice will be a kind of climax; but viewed from another angle it will be only a late trace of the intense and elaborate creative process that will be remembered long after the show in Italy has closed. Months before the Biennale’s gates swing open to the international culturati in August, myriad Canadians in the country’s largest population centres will have been touched, somehow or another, by the cumulative, roll-forward motion of Migrating Landscapes. David Chipperfield hopes Common Ground will help restore architecture’s shaken confidence in “shared space and shared ideas.”
giuliosquillaCioTTi giuliosquillaCioTTi
Over the last year, the Winnipeg team has been acting energetically on that very confidence as though it had never flagged, generating real spaces for dialogue and learning—in one city after another. It’s hard to imagine a scheme for making a Canadian splash in Venice that would involve more people in an act of communitybuilding than this one. So after the year-long unfolding of Migrating Landscapes in Canada, will the contents of the Venice version deliver that splash? I think we should want it to, and it might well make an impression. Since 1980, the Biennale’s architectural exhibitions have usually highlighted such topics as urban experience and “architecture beyond building” (as one recent installment was subtitled)—not the quiddity and practicality that most people think of when they hear the word “architecture.” So both Migrating Landscape’s philosophical theme and the oblique, speculative treatments of it on view are likely to be understood quickly and appreciated by veteran Biennale visitors. But these people are also, unfortunately, always in a hurry for a cultural fix. In accordance with the competition’s rules mentioned above, the models are suitcase-sized and occasionally intricate, and they will be perched on or embedded in the large, heavy wooden framework that will surge dramatically throughout the pavilion and out the door. This impressive armature grabs and holds the viewer’s attention, and is slow to let go. As I found in Winnipeg, it takes a moment for the mind to register the fact that the often slight and sketchy architectural models are situated there among the very conspicuous clustered timber uprights. And that moment may be too long for visitors busily speed-dating their way through the Biennale’s pavilions on a sultry Venetian afternoon. But those who do pay close attention to the videos and material works, and who acquaint themselves with the terms of the competition in order to figure out what this show is actually about, could find themselves facing problems of a different order. A couple have to do with the instructions given to potential contestants. They were invited, you will recall, not to devise architectural solutions for the real problems of immigrants (housing, disorientation, alienation from the new context, and so on), but rather “to act as [the landscape’s] first immigrants. The act of constructing the first dwellings will be enactments of first immigration onto this abstract landscape.” While urging a student to play the role of a disembodied Cartesian intellect designing things in pure Euclidian space may be common practice in the architecture schools, it strikes me as curious. Outside the novels of sci-fi fantasists, the calculations of real-estate developers, the offices of mathematicians and the propaganda of colonizers, abstract, un-
toPCa’giusTinian—TheVeneraBleheadquarTersofThehighlyanTiCipaTedVeniCeBien nale. aBoVeTheCorderieBuildingBeforecoMMon ground,TheCenTralBiennaleexhi BiTionCuraTedBydaVidChipperfield,fillsTheTreasuredspaCe.
peopled and empty landscapes do not exist. “Dwelling,” on the other hand, always occurs in a specific place with a geology, a story, a form, a political economy—and it is this grounded character that gives questions of dwelling their urgency, relevance and resonance. The organizers of Migrating Landscapes did not ask contestants to address these urgent questions about migration, and encouraged them instead to recall it as adventure, pioneering, being newcomers in a strange new land full of surprises. The videos destined for Venice, accordingly, too often offer nostalgic recollections of the usual upsets of changing one’s location in
the world—upsets, in each case, handily survived and transcended by ancestors or by the artists themselves. And with a couple of exceptions, the models are abstruse, unpinned to any real place, and are as abstract as the wooden substructure—designed according to the rule given to their makers. Largely missing is the pathos inevitably present in any narrative that sets out to talk about migration as it actually is. I missed some note of that sadness in the competition brief. I think it’s not there because the organizers of this show see migration as a difficult but ultimately positive and lifeaffirming phenomenon—as it has been in their 07/12canadian architect
27
is a city, so the myth goes, of masks and fantasies and luxurious façades and fugitive shimmers and shadows. Myths, of course, have a way of becoming facts—and this urban myth of postmodern slide and empty pomp certainly colours a great deal that goes on in Venice’s public realm, not least the events staged by the Biennale organization. Despite the efforts of one artistic director after another to make audiences sober up and get serious—David Chipperfield is merely the latest in a long line of morally earnest curators— the Biennale’s art and architecture shows are, in the end, extravagant spectacles put on for the entertainment of the sophisticated and very inquisitive bourgeois layfolk and professionals who come from all over the world to see what’s being talked about by the international highcultural elite and the mini-elites in various
own passages from elsewhere to Canada, resulting in successful, fulfilling careers in the architectural field. But for countless migrants, and for the earlier dwellers forced or persuaded to make room for the newcomers, the story of the movement of peoples in the modern world has been marked by immense sorrow and suffering. Indeed, somewhere in the background of almost every modern migration and settlement tale is a crime or calamity—the disaster or injustice or hunger that prompted the migrants to seek a new homeland in the first place, the misery (or worse) inflicted on the newcomers by the people they came among, or by the new immigrants themselves on those who came before. But Venice is probably not the place for such melancholy ponderings, even had the curators of the Canada Pavilion asked anyone to do so. It
countries. It would be unfair to ask any Biennale exhibitor to do anything more than please these large, cosmopolitan audiences. And, indeed, if they give time and proper regard to the Canada Pavilion, visitors will discover that young Canadian architects and designers have been thinking alertly and optimistically, if not profoundly, about the subject of migration. But if visitors go further, and inquire about the generation of the Venice show, they will find a process of selection more rigorous, community-minded and public-spirited than any other in the history of Canada’s participation in this occasional celebration of architectural imagination. ca John Bentley Mays is an architecture critic and writes regularly for The Globe and Mail.
CAN A ROOFING SYSTEM WITH NO FASTENERS BE TESTED FOR WIND RESISTANCE? YES! USE THE CSA A123.21-10 STANDARD! 4 3 2 1
1
Sopravap’R
2
Soprarock DD Plus
3
Sopraply Base 520
4
Soprastar Flam HD GR
This adhered system passes the rigorous requirements of CSA A123.21-10 testing with flying colours. For more information, please contact your local representative.
28canadian architect07/12
technicaL
the neXt regeneratiOn
introduction
Over the past five years or so, the notion of “regeneration” has been garnering increasing interest as a means of reframing green design.1 Unlike conventional green building practices which are directed at reducing environmental impact, regenerative design promotes a coevolutionary, partnered relationship between sociocultural and ecological systems rather than a managerial one and, in doing so, builds, rather than diminishes, social and natural capitals. It is not the building that is “regenerated” in the same sense as the self-healing and selforganizing attributes of a living system but, as Pamela Mang and others in the Regenesis Group2 argue, by the ways that the act of building can be a catalyst for positive change within the unique “place” it is situated. As Peter Clegg3 of the UKbased Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios further suggests, this produces “built form and infrastructure that begins to ‘heal the wounds’ that have already occurred.” Within regenerative design
As with systems the hie r ,w which a hat b archic re sm uild al all ing str u &f What n ast asp ctu a & rate o tural f f rep orc ? e lac es em m en ay to
ry o ve
FUTURE
ic
om
ce
ec
on
us
v al
ue
r ec
rc e
nc e
ou
COEVOLUTION
s re on s te d so t r u c t i o & as s o c i a n eo ob ec d re v er os u t a an t im e uc m l e r a an d av oids p r ces ltu s or a cu f ail ur e, and m ain ta in s
n
ed
le s
OGICAL SYSTEM L O S EC
OGICAL SYSTEM L O S EC
RaymonDJ.coleanDamyoliveR
teXt
er t
S M
Figure 1geneRicmoDelDescRibingtheRelationshipbetWeen DesignstRategiesanDcoevolution
“RegeneRativeDesign”hasbeengaRneRing incReasinginteRestasameansofRefRaminggReenDesign.WhatDoesitmeanfoR pRactice?canbuilDingsbeRegeneRativein asimilaRmanneRaslivingsystems?
iv
CULT URAL SY S CIO TE SO
FUTURE
LAYERING OF COMPONENTS
ct e le ss si e at e Fac ilit ng ch a th te s he Fac ili ta y, w ckl q ui
COEVOLUTION
Wha buildt cultu i r What ng lo al tr n a build future gev diti it o in c Wha g re q han y? factot socio uire ges Can rs a cul m be uthe s ect tu sed lip lo to pa a
Adap ts
NOW
PLACE SPECIFIC
ue nce ns in atio ec t y a ect xp t ma de tex an on ns ec th mic in s? cono t e rs en l & vit y? een laye ra ge etw e? n b tag ge van d
UNIVERSAL
CULT URAL SY S CIO TE SO
DESIGN STRATEGIES
d ral w an atu slo ty f n big & gevi o n lo ? re are he layers t s t ct ec ous a vari f
S M
PLACE SPECIFIC
Figure 2layeRinganDtheRelationshipbetWeenDesignstRategies anDcoevolution
and development, built projects, stakeholder processes and inhabitation are together focused on enhancing life in all its forms—human, other species, and ecological systems—through an enduring responsibility of stewardship. In short, regenerative design aims to rethink how buildings are designed, built and managed. While having proven to be an enormously valuable vehicle for mainstreaming green building practice, LEED’s checklist format that allows users to select what are deemed achievable credits is considered by many as incapable of guiding design in a systems-approach manner and establishing positive links between buildings and their context. Regenerative design uses green building technologies and strategies, but complements these by facilitating positive connections to the social, economic and ecological context. Moreover, whereas green building solely focuses on reducing the environmental impacts of buildings, regenerative design and development is viewed as a process that can accelerate the development of the systems-thinking, shared vision, shared ownership and shared responsibility necessary to transition to a sustainable future. Though many of its core tenets—systems-thinking, community engagement, respect for place— also have long individual histories in architectural discourse and practice, regenerative design
begins to tie them together in a cogent manner. Broadly speaking, regenerative design seeks ways in which sociocultural and ecological systems can mutually benefit each other; in other words, its long-term aim is to support the harmonious coevolution of sociocultural and ecological systems. American environmental biologist John Cairns4 argues that “mutualistic coevolution is the only path to success” and that “a ‘partner’ unable to coevolve with the other partner is in serious, probably fatal, trouble.” Synergies between ecological and sociocultural systems lead to designs that are much more than the sum of their parts and do not simply look after their own needs. To illustrate, regenerative buildings may restore or even create natural habitats, purify water, sequester carbon, produce oxygen, generate energy, and enhance human connections with their environment. Shifting Scale
While the ambition of regenerative design is both positive and inspiring in comparison to the “doing less harm” emphasis of green design, recent critiques emphasize some practical and operational concerns—challenging its feasibility in the urban context and whether or not its core design tenets are scaleable (building, neighbourhood, community and city). For example, re08/12canadian architect
29
generation operates most effectively at a larger spatial scale than that which most architectural projects are commissioned and so raises questions about the ways and extent that individual buildings can participate in the regenerative design process. American anthropologist and historian Joseph Tainter5 raises several important concerns about scale. “If it is too small,” he suggests, “the system will require constant human intervention” and, “it is prudent to assume that a system that requires endless subsidies is not sustainable.” He continues, “[u]nfortunately, this is likely to be the spatial scale (i.e., too small to be self-sustaining) at which many regenerative designs are commissioned. Thus, there may be a scalar contradiction between the aspirations of regenerative designers and the realities of their profession.” extending time Frame
Current green design practice and assessment tools concentrate on describing the initial performance of a building prior to occupancy and can, within the limits of simulation, do this with some degree of certainty. However, it rarely explicitly acknowledges that future performance and changes in a building’s context are always unknowable. Regenerative design, by contrast, accepts this future uncertainty. The notion that the successful performance of a building can neither be predicted nor guaranteed at the completion of design clearly represents a major challenge for architects and other design consultants, particularly in the way that they convey their proposed strategies to clients. Since regenerative performance cannot be known at the design stage, the measure of success in regenerative design is represented in terms of the capacity invested in a building at the outset and stakeholder input that will encourage the coevolution of sociocultural and ecological systems. However, determining if and to what extent a capability has been invested in a project will be based on the collective experience of the design team, continued stakeholder engagement, feedback, reflection and learning. Given the concerns raised above, how can individual buildings participate in the positive coevolution of sociocultural and ecological systems? Can regenerative design offer positive direction to the day-to-day practice of designing buildings amidst a host of time, cost and regulatory constraints? There are currently very few recent examples of building projects that exemplify regenerative design and, given the absence of evidence that demonstrates that claimed benefits and outcomes can and have been delivered, it remains largely an aspiration. The University of British Columbia’s Centre for Interactive Research on Sustainability (see CA, March 2012) is important 30canadian architect08/12
in this regard in that its unfolding performance and consequences will be fully monitored and documented. CIRS is a clear manifestation of core regenerative strategies. It will provide “netpositive” benefits to the environment—creating drinking water from fallen rain collected on site, treating more than its own wastewater on site, and powering itself and a neighbouring building with renewable and waste energy. The combination of an on-site photovoltaic system and creative energy exchange with the neighbouring Earth and Ocean Sciences Building greatly reduces the university’s overall carbon emissions. By being constructed primarily of certified wood and pine beetle-killed wood (that would otherwise lead to carbon emissions as it decays), its wood structure locks in more than 500 tonnes of carbon. This offsets the GHG emissions that resulted from the other non-renewable construction materials—cement, steel and aluminum— used in the building. CIRS can thus claim carbon-negative performance (both embodied and operational). While a university campus permits opportunities not often permissible in most contexts in which architects operate, CIRS nonetheless is illustrative of the potential implications associated with the coevolution of sociocultural and ecological systems—that is, how design strategies offer multiple benefits beyond the boundaries of an individual building. The use of on-site renewable energy and other fortuitous energy supply options, such as those used in CIRS, become an important strategic choice after all possible energy-efficiency and passive strategies have been pursued. Onsite renewable energy options are place-specific— dictated by the seasonal climatic variations and any modifying effects resulting from the surrounding physical context. Fortuitous energy sources and exchange opportunities are also place-specific and dependent on the ways and extent that the energy profiles of adjacent or nearby buildings and systems match that of one being designed. CIRS does exactly this—capturing waste heat exhausted from the Oceans and Sciences (EOS) Building, satisfying its thermal needs and then returning excess back to EOS. Set against the technical potential offered by such synergistic links are a host of sociocultural factors such as a willingness to accommodate renewable energy, matching of energy quality to operation use, enabling inhabitants to understand energy processes and to adjust the systems to meet their changing needs, etc. More broadly, social or industrial metabolism—the socially organized exchange of materials and energy between societies and their environments—represents a critical link between the built environment and the coevolution of ecological and sociocultural systems. While nuclear energy is gaining increasing support as a necessary and seemingly attainable and
expedient response to climate change, clean, renewable energy sources are recognized as key to a sustainable future. Renewable energy options have the potential to contribute to long-term energy security and the withstanding of shortterm disruptions, and enable building inhabitants to understand energy processes and adjust systems to meet changing needs. Figure 1 illustrates the expanded questioning of the role and responsibility of design strategies similar to that embedded in CIRS. It highlights the potential link between building design and the coevolution of sociocultural and ecological systems resulting from the use of renewable energy. Building design (situated in the upper half) can be both informed by ecological systems and/or sociocultural systems that may be placespecific or more universal. Resulting strategies can lead to a building offering positive sociocultural and ecological benefits for its local site context. This place-specific approach to design— drawing on and relating to context—invests a building with the potential for improved performance and contributes to its wider social, cultural, ecological and economic context as shown in the lower half, in the end having benefits that extend beyond its property lines. In summary, green design is directed at reducing environmental impacts—doing less harm, and regenerative design aspires to restore lost capacities—ecological, social and economic— when they are missing or disrupted and establishing new ones. Both are necessary and complementary in transitioning to a sustainable future. While the performance of individual buildings remains of central importance— depending on the process of engaging all relevant stakeholders, understanding and engaging the opportunities afforded by context, and creatively forging synergistic links between these same strategies—these buildings can offer a great deal more. ca Dr. Ray Cole is Professor at and past Director of the University of British Columbia‘s School of Architecture and Landscape Architecture. He holds the designation of Distinguished University Scholar. Amy Oliver holds a Master of Architecture degree from the University of British Columbia and works at an architectural firm in Vancouver. 1 Cole, R.J. Regenerative Design and Development: Cur-
rent Theory and Practice. Building Research & Information 40.1 (2012): 1-6. 2 www.regenesisgroup.com 3 Clegg, P. Commentary: A Practitioner’s View of the “Regenerative Paradigm.” Building Research & Information 40.3 (2012): 365-368. 4 Cairns, J. Sustainable Co-evolution. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology 14 (2007): 103-108. 5 Tainter, J.A. Regenerative Design in Science and Society. Building Research & Information 40.3 (2012): 369-372.
PRODuCT SHOwCASE Create Style with QuARTz QuARTz shower channels allow the bathroom floor to take on a new dimension to become an integral part of the design. Whatever the look you are trying to achieve, Contemporary, Naturalistic, Traditional or Old World, the clean unobtrusive lines of QuARTz shower grates are easily integrated into any bathroom design project. An additional experience can be created with optional lights, taking the design to an even higher art form. www.acocan.ca (877) 226-4255
QuARTz by ACO
Commercial (Model 500 & Model 600) These high quality doors with a unique baked-on finish steel or aluminium skin are of high quality, and are offered in a wide variety of sizes and insulation factors. With over 30 years of expertise, you can rest assured that your Laforge door will meet all your expectations. Visit our re-designed website for more information about our products at www.laforgedoors.com 1-800-665-3667 laforged@nb.aibn.com
Los Angeles Police Department
SOPRASTAR HD GR
W.S. Tyler’s woven wire mesh panels add vibrancy and depth to the LAPD’s Motor Transport Division and Main Street Parking facility. Thirty-four 8-footwide panels provide natural ventilation, while helping to camouflage the primary façade, fulfilling the LAPD’s strict security requirements. The vertically oriented panels fold in, out, and around the cantilevered walkways, forming the primary access to each of the parking levels. The resultant surfaces effectively dematerialize the massive concrete structure behind them. Visit www.weavingideas.net.
The SOPRASTAR HD GR cap sheet membranes (SRI : 70) reflect sunshine thereby lowering the temperature of the roofing system and increasing its serviceable life. The use of SOPRASTAR white membranes on several roofs in the same location significantly reduce urban heat islands. For more information, visit www.soprema.ca.
Expanded Family of AirRenew™ Indoor Air Quality Gypsum Boards
MAPEI’s ECO Prim Grip™ Helps Installers Tile over Tile
CertainTeed Gypsum is broadening its groundbreaking AirRenew™ indoor air quality (IAQ) gypsum board product line with the addition of AirRenew Extreme Abuse and AirRenew Extreme Impact. The expansion rounds out the AirRenew product family with solutions that boast high-performance attributes, such as fire-, abuse- and impactresistance as well as moisture and mould protection. CertainTeed Corporation: 800-2338990. www.certainteed.com Solarban R100 glass Solarban R100 glass combines superior performance and neutralreflectivity to provide a new choice in solar control, low-e glass. Ideal for privacy glass and a perfect complement to spandrels, metal, brick and stone, Solarban R100 glass features a 1.79 LSG ratio that is 17 to 29 percent better than competing products. PPGIdeaScapes.com 888.PPGIDEA
ECO Prim Grip is a ready-to-use bondpromoting primer that prepares an existing tile or stone surface to receive a new installation without the time, labour or dust of scarification. This synthetic-resin-based primer enhances the performance of mortars and their adhesion to existing ceramics and other difficult substrates, and it can be applied with a roller in only one coat. Ready for new tile installation within 60 minutes. Safe for use in occupied interior environments. Visit www.mapei.com. Isokorb® thermal break block Schöck Canada introduces Isokorb®, an innovative thermal insulating, loadbearing element which partitions and connects concrete-to-concrete and steelto-steel constructions. Proven throughout Europe for over 20 years, Schöck Isokorb® consists of a highly effective HCFC-free Polystyrene foam block which provides the thermal break. Forces are transferred through highstrength stainless steel rebars and UHPC concrete compression elements. Visit www.schoeck.ca for more detailed information or to request a Technical Handbook. 07/12CAnADIAn ARCHITECT
31
PRODuCT SHOwCASE
PROFESSIOnAL DIRECTORY noraplan® sentica promotes a healing environment noraplan® sentica is a high-performance floor covering designed to provide comfort and flexibility for healthcare applications. With a broad palette of 38 original colours and a tone-on-tone design that complements noraplan environcare™, noraplan sentica will transform a healthcare facility into a soothing atmosphere for patients, staff and visitors alike. noraplan sentica offers durability, low-maintenance requirements and versatility to drive new projects and complement renovations. www.nora.com/us/sentica-launch3. wALLTITE® Eco Polyurethane Insulation/Air Barrier System WALLTITE® Eco is a medium-density polyurethane insulation/air barrier system designed to improve energy efficiency in any type of building. Industryleading performance means substantial energy savings by maximizing the effectiveness of the building envelope. Its formulation includes recycled plastic and a zero ozone-depleting blowing agent. At BASF, we create chemistry.
Ad_apples_3x5_PRESS.pdf
10/8/09
www.walltiteeco.com www.foammasters.ca 1-866-474-3538 10:29:58 AM
Noise, Vibration and Acoustics Consulting Engineers
Mississauga, Ontario
•
Architectural Acoustics
•
Building Noise and Vibration Control
P: 905-826-4044 F: 905-826-4940 Magazine ads LIMITED press 3.75x4.875.pdf 1 11-10-13 4:03 PM HOWE GASTMEIER CHAPNIK www.hgcengineering.com
PCL Graphics Ltd. T h e Pa r t n e r Yo u Wa n t
C
M
Y
CM
MY
CY
CMY
K
Custom Print Fabricator Specializing in Environmental Graphics Production and Installation services www.pclgraphics.com 1 800 268 7744 1W 3S2
tario, Canada M it 3, Toronto, On Un , ue en Av rk 3761 Victoria Pa7744, Fax: 416-756-1337 Tel: 1-800-268-
416-756-3600
32CAnADIAn ARCHITECT07/12
Dissenting Histories: 25 Years of the Power Plant
March 24-August 26, 2012 This exhi bition is an ongoing project de signed to activate and put into dialogue the Power Plant Contem porary Art Gallery’s rich histories. Installed in a space designed by Markus Miessen, a German archi tect and writer who has considered institutional histories and has contributed to our thinking about participation in public space and design, the archive exhibition con siders the gallery’s history within local and international contexts, as well as within present spatial and theoretical concerns. www.thepowerplant.org Santiago Calatrava: The Quest for Movement
June 27-September 30 2012 This retrospective exhibition at the worldrenowned State Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg, Russia examines iconic architect Santiago Calatrava’s innovative style through various artistic realms such as neverbeforeseen paint ings and sculptures, and celebrated architectural models and sketches. www.hermitagemuseum.org/ html_En/04/2012/hm4_1_305.html Tools for Conviviality
June 30-August 26, 2012 This group exhibition at the Power Plant Con temporary Art Gallery in Toronto concerns work united by the idea of art as tools, specifically those which are interactive and which operate as mechanisms towards selfhelp, political shifts, ritual devices, defence and critique. www.thepowerplant.org MADE—Intersections and Directions in Current Canadian Design
July 8-August 5, 2012 Julie Nicholson and Shaun Moore of MADE have curated an exhibition of 32 design objects for the Visual Arts Centre of Clarington, which reflects on the many ways in which independ ent Canadian designers and mak ers both produce and consider their work. Some of the designers
news featured include: the Brothers Dressler, Elsworthy Wang, FELT Studio, Barr Gilmore, Loyal Loot Collective, Propellor, Toma Objects and Anneke van Bommel. A cur ator’s talk will take place on Sun day, August 5 at 2:00pm. www.vac.ca/current-exhibitions.html 60 Years of Designing the Ballet
July 11-September 2, 2012 This exhi bition at the Design Exchange in Toronto provides a behindthe scenes look at the fantasy of ballet. Magical tales are unravelled with costumes, props, sets, lighting and dance in an ephemeral voyage through the design of ballet. Admission is $10; free for DX members. www.dx.org BORN AGAIN: The Repurposed City
July 20-September 16, 2012 This ex hibition at Architecture at York Quay Centre in Toronto features three Toronto architecture firms— DTAH, Kongats Architects and unit a architecture inc., along with installation artist Gareth Lichty, who have created new installations that explore the adaptive reuse of existing buildings and structures within the urban landscape. www.harbourfrontcentre.com/ visualarts
(continued from page 10) design proposals which either utilize the bridge in its current state or take the bridge apart and reuse its pontoons at a new site on Lake Washington, Lake Union or in the Puget Sound in Washington State. Designers need to constantly assert the need for advancement in creative reuse; our ideas drive design forward. The competition is open to professionals and stu dents of the international design and art communities over the age of 18. Participants may enter as individuals or in teams of up to four members. A registration fee of $100 must accompany each submission; the deadline is August 10, 2012. www.rethinkreuse.org/competition.html
what’s new raic Foundation presents its first centennial Fund for interns and intern architects.
The RAIC Foundation is pleased to present its first College of Fellows Centennial Fund for interns and intern architects to Team Canada, the 13 young intern and intern architect members of the Migrating Landscapes team who are now part of Canada’s official entry to the 2012 Venice Bien nale in Architecture. The award of $5,000 was recently presented during the 2012 Architecture Canada | RAIC Festival of Architecture in St. John’s. The Centennial Fund for interns and intern architects was created with donations received from members of the College of Fellows and members of the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada to support a deserving intern, intern architect or group of interns/intern architects wishing to promote the value and image of the profession. www.raic.org
Image courtesy of Roy Ooms
calendar
Alberta Wood WORKS!
BRAVOS: Groundbreaking Spanish Design
August 8-23, 2012 This exhibition at the Design Exchange in Toronto introduces the most innovative product design from the Spanish design boom, and features 21 of the most talented and successful art ists and designers who are set to trailblaze the future of Spanish de sign, such as Jaime Hayon, Patricia Urquiola, Martin Azua, and young experimentalists Curro Claret and Nacho Carbonell. www.dx.org FormoreinFormationabout these,andadditionallistingsoFCanadianandinternationalevents,pleasevisit www.canadianarchitect.com
Call for Nominations
The Annual Prairie Wood Design Awards celebrate excellence in wood construction in the Prairie Region and the Territories. Nomination forms are available online and are due August 17th, 2012.
wood-works.org/alberta Alberta Wood WORKS! is a project of the Canadian Wood Council established to promote the use of wood products.
07/12canadian architect
33
Backpage
expansive Terrain
A photogrAphic Artist exAmines the evolution of the postwAr suburbAn lAndscApe of mississAugA. TexT
stuArt Keeler morris lum
pHOTO
Mississauga-based Morris Lum is an urban/ suburban geographer who records the plaza spaces and recycled architectural icons of popular culture located in the edge cities of Ontario. Within his new body of photographic work, night-time abandoned spaces become symbols of the impersonality of supermodernity. The artist presents these spaces as areas where the human figure is void and the automobile is central to the experience, capturing the physical space of the strip mall, the parking lot and other marginal places, highlighting social isolation and unease. A distinguishing aspect of Lum’s voice is the attention paid to the liminality of suburban space. Born in Trinidad-Tobago, he and his family immigrated to Mississauga in 1989. Always interested in the photographic image and the landscape of a city in flux, Lum focused upon this interest while attending Ryerson University. Active in the Toronto art scene, he is committed to the exploitation of a new suburban terrain, and we are asked to assess the order, value, and even beauty of the
suburban Mississauga landscapes that Lum knows intimately. The images clearly have a visual force and intellectual rigour that command attention and consideration. Ultimately, the buildings that Lum documents are recycled: a former Pizza Hut with the iconic hip roof is now a Cambodian restaurant, and an old Taco Time fast-food outlet has morphed into a Vietnamese noodle house whose cactus-emblazoned signage is now overwritten with the new establishment’s name. The artist reminds us that the social space of the newcomer to Canada reimagines the built environment, unwittingly employing sustainable practices in the process, for the benefit of all. The work creates a new understanding of decentralized social spaces to provoke thought about the future of the edge city as a postsuburban condition. Lum also demonstrates that an emotional bond or exploration of the familiar is crucial to the understanding of a place. Philosopher Yi-Fu Tuan suggests that the built world should strengthen our memories, enhance the self, and provide layers of meaning to a space. In his study of Divine Wok 2010/Saigon King 2012, Lum exploits the immigrant’s dream as a terrain, forcing us to question normative, reflexive ideas about metropolitan order
TOp golden squAre mAll in mississAugA houses A continuAl string of new businesses thAt unwittingly pArticipAte in A sustAinAble recycling of retAil spAce. BOTTOM suburbAn strip mAlls such As this one in mArKhAm Are becoming defined by the new immigrAnt cultures thAt Are creAting fAscinAting new identities for the cities they inhAbit.
and beauty, as well as our assumptions about suburban/urban conformity. Again, does the recycling of built form lose its associations? The effect of urban sprawl is also considered—the houses and developments continue as if in fractal formations, the repetition a complex headache of sameness. This sameness can be witnessed in recycled architectural forms such as the famed yellow arches, the alltoo-familiar icons of the North American fastfood economy. At the core of this body of work, Lum points to the aging of postwar suburbia, and the suburbanization of new Canadians and others who have created, in their edge cities, a world that contains more identities and notions of sustainable building practices in the quake of forging a new landscape. ca
Stuart Keeler is the Curator and Director of Programmes at the Art Gallery of Mississauga.
Maximize performance of your thin-tile installation. MAPEI now offers a proven solution for floors.
Ultracolor ® Plus
Efflorescence-free grout
Ultraflex ™ LFT Rapid
Medium-bed large-format tile mortar
ECO Prim Grip™
Bond-promoting primer
Thin-Body Porcelain Tile Reference Guide for Interior Floors 3/16" to 1/4" (4,5 to 6 mm) in Thickness
REFERENCE GUIDE RGT0112
A
fter hundreds of hours of intensive research, MAPEI’s research centers have devised the first completely documented process for successful installation of thin tile. MAPEI combines cutting-edge installation methods and its new-technology products. The result? Complete coverage for a successful installation. Now that’s technology you can build on.
Installation techniques:
• Proper surface preparation • Proper installation material selection • Proper trowel selection • Use of a mechanical edge-leveling system
DEFINING THIN-BODY PORCELAIN TILE
porcelain tile measuring 3/16" to 1/4" (4,5 to 6 mm) thick.
Thin-body porcelain tile is a lightweight product that is produced using less materials and less energy. This combination makes it a perfect choice for many “sustainable” installation projects specifying interior walls, floors and facades.
Note 2: Refer to the thin-tile manufacturer for the maximum allowable service rating per the ASTM C627 test method.
Installation of thin-body porcelain tile is different from standard-body porcelain tile, requiring special installation techniques to prevent breakage during and after installation. Special equipment may be required when placing and adjusting these large tiles. The manufacturer of the thinbody porcelain tile should be consulted before selection and installation to determine the tile’s suitability for the specified project. Typically a “thin-body porcelain tile” has a thickness range of 1/8" to 1/4" (3 to 6 mm) and a “standard-body porcelain tile” is > 9/32" (7 mm) thick. Note 1: Refer to the most current “American National Standard Specifications for Ceramic Tile” (ANSI A137.1) for defining various types, sizes, physical properties, and grading procedures for porcelain tile.
Adhere to the following recommended steps: 1. Proper surface preparation 2. Proper material selection 3. Proper trowel selection 4. Use of a mechanical edge-leveling system SURFACE PREPARATION: FLOORS Interior floors must be structurally stable and capable of supporting the tile, setting system, and associated live loads and dead loads. Concrete and existing tile over concrete are to be fully cured and free of soap scum, dust, dirt, oil, wax, sealers, paint, coatings, and any other substances that could reduce or inhibit proper adhesion performance. Note 3: Refer to MAPEI Reference Guide on “Surface Preparation Requirements – Tile & Stone Installation Systems” (RGT0309) for specific surface preparation requirements. 1) Floors with the following criteria are considered suitable substrates: • Concrete slab, either on-grade or above-grade • Existing tile should be sound, stable, well-bonded and prepared using either of the following options:
Figure 1: Example of a thin-body, 5 mm porcelain tile
For the purpose of this reference guide, all testing data and recommendations are for interior floors only using thin-body
4956 Technical Bulletin Thin-Body2.indd 1
Option 1: Mechanical abrasion with a carborundum disk followed by a clear water wash is recommended. Refer to the most current TCNA (Tile Council of North America) handbook, method TR712; or the TTMAC (Terrazzo Tile & Marble Association of Canada) Tile Installation Manual, details 324 RF. Option 2: Prime the existing tile over concrete with MAPEI’s ECO Prim Grip™. Refer to the most current Technical Data Sheet (TDS) at mapei.com.
1/20/12 3:09 PM
Scan here with your smartphone for the MAPEI thin-tile installation guide, or contact your local MAPEI sales representative.
5544 Canadian Architect July2012_Thin Tile.indd 1
6/13/12 12:01 PM
Loewen Window Centre of Winnipeg Winnipeg, MB 204.942.6945
Loewen Window Centre of Calgary Calgary AB 403.569.8282
Loewen Window Centre of Oakville Oakville ON 905.829.1310
Centre Loewen De Montreal Montreal, QC 514.484.6203
Loewen Window Centre of Edmonton Edmonton, AB 780.452.3753
Loewen Window Centre of Ottawa Gloucester, ON 613.822.6291
Loewen Window Centre of Kingston Kingston, ON 613.546.7111
Loewen Window Centre of Vancouver Richmond, BC 604.233.0477
Loewen Window Centre of Victoria Saanichton, BC 250.544.1553
VI SION IT’S IN OUR NATURE
As an architect, you’re driven by vision. Guided by a sense of purpose to create things never seen before. It’s this passion to stretch the limits of what is and isn’t possible that directs us too. At Loewen, our vision is to create wood windows and doors that outperform and outlast anything ever created. Because we share that same passion to achieve something great. And after a century of innovation, we’re not letting up anytime soon. After all, the vision that drives our company is inspired by you. Visit your Loewen Window Centre and share your vision with us.
www.loewen.com
LWN_64021_Architect_Ad.indd 1 LWN_64021_Cdn_Architect_Ad.indd 1
IT’S IN OUR NATURE
6/12/12 4:41 PM