lle:
City after Euralille
2009/2010 Berlage Institute Research Report
Research Report Credits This Berlage Institute Research Report is intended for archival purposes only and represents unedited and ongoing student research. Produced through the department of broadcasting, it is the collective effort of Berlage Institute studio participants, tutors, and staff. This publication is part of a limited edition of copies and is strictly intended for use only by the Berlage Institute. February 2010 Š 2010, Berlage Institute, Rotterdam
The Berlage Institute is an international postÂgraduate laboratory for education, research and development in the fields of architecture, urban planning and landscape design.
Postal address: PO Box 21592 3001 AN Rotterdam The Netherlands
2
Visiting address: Botersloot 25 3011 HE Rotterdam The Netherlands
t f e i
+ 31 10 403 03 99 + 31 10 403 03 90 info@berlage-institute.nl www.berlage-institute. nl
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Euraring Lille: City after Euralille Professors: Petar Zaklanovic, Markus Appenzeller Local Experts: Mathieu Goetzke, Charlotte Rosier, Ari Brodach External Experts: Kees Christiaanse, Lars Rompelberg, Michael Trinkner Berlage Jury: Vedran Mimica, Elia Zenghelis, Roemer van Toorn Pier Vittorio Aureli, Joachim Declerck, Solomon Frausto Participants: Si Wu, Yuichi Watanabe, Tzu-Hua Wu, Hyun Soo Kim Maria Iglesias Martinez, Pei-Lin Hsieh, Chu Liu, Taiwan Kim
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
3
4
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
5
6
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
7
8
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
9
10
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Studio Brief The introduction of modern, global and regional, communication, and transport networks into mid-sized cities were intended to place them on the global map. Instead they have sucked the flavor out of existing cities, forming self-centered nodes that have transformed the spaces around them into peripheral zones, cities into metropolitan hinterlands. The resistance of local communities to the creation of big infra-hubs, political decentralization and many failed projects of the kind have all shed light on this urban strategy. But the necessity to connect to regional networks via big hubs still remains. There is a need to redefine the role of cities hosting important regional infra-hubs in the global game of power and success. What kind of relationship between these hubs and European cities can lead to a new harmonious development framework? What strategies can be employed in order to reclaim city territory and save it from monotonous concepts often attempted to find a place in the global market? Lille is the exemplary case. In the 1990s, the Euralille development undeniably placed it on the map of Europe. Current spatial initiatives happen at the fringe. Lille consists of paradigmatic, historical, urban patterns juxtaposed to one other: Medieval to Flemish, Flemish to Hausmannian. It’s a human-scale Paris! Special, attractive and functional! Large-scale restructuring and densification of the city is not an option. The center of Lille is practically untouchable. Eura-ring is proposed! It is a contiguous development along the ring road surrounding the city and connected via four major boulevards to the old city. The premises for the proposal were four-fold: Lille’s size would make the proposal concept accessible to the whole city. Eurallile has already established a precedent for successful, unaggressive ring road development. The space around the city has many attractive but underused and underconnected assets, including a waterfront, sport facilities, and a Citadel. And, the ring road doesn’t cover the city’s western edge, allowing Lille to remain easily extendable. This first-year research studio, through a series of research and design efforts, will consider: how can the proposed development framework be implemented spatially? What are its potentials? How can it induce the regeneration of the existing city? Can we come up with new strategies and intelligence on dealing with infrastructure? The project aims to redefine the symbiosis between urban agglomerations and their supra-regional infra-networks. It will search for new means of growth and regeneration for the mid-size European cities.
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
11
12
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
CONTENTS
xx xx xx xx xx
task: Lille after euralille discoveries: real lille framework: hopeless space for hope communities reactivated interventions: st. sauveur Message 1: Embrace the World Message 2: Believe in what is there
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
13
i. the task
14
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
lille after euralille
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
15
The level of Prime Intermed
16
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
diate Space Transformable areas Catchementzone of metro stations Social housings
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
17
Task: Search For Space Of Hope Can European cities regain the vitality and attractiveness? How should they cope with the unstoppable Globalization? Can they send an “everything is possible” message, like the most vital world cities do? The message of openness and inclusion? What policies would be needed to support this message? What kind of people would be able to initiate the feeling? What kind of space would be able to house the initiatives? Eventually, is there such a space in European cities? What’s Wrong? European cities are stuck in a pointless search for the uniqueness. Exhausting competition without real winners. Same arguments, same tools. Energy spilled over in a an ever lasting reproduction of the status quo. City development in Europe is largely influenced by the profit making and short lived political agendas aimed at ad hoc results for campaigning purposes. This significantly shortens the time frame and simplifies criteria for the evaluation of the results. Answers from policy makers today inspire regeneration strategies which, regardless the scale, suffer from one or more of the following issues: simplification of the context and hence the task, irreversible exploitation of resources and cosmetic (not sufficient) character of transformation. The proposals end up as results of not enough understood hypes. Ultimate generators of opportunism. Sometimes it is the specific program that seems to be needed, sometimes the infrastructure. A sort of aspirin like intervention, it helps but doesn’t cure. Or, the interventions often irreversibly use the vital resources (such as the city owned land) making the regeneration significant but incapable of adapting to the demands of the future. A sort of a last bet strategy. Exploit Local: City Is A Creator Every serious attempt to regenerate and enhance European city space today must acknowledge its complexity as a whole. Even more, it must use it as the key value generator. The ultimate source of new ideas! All elements of a city must be inspired to participate in the regeneration. There should be no forgotten areas regardless their size and position. Also, no excluded or hidden inhabitants and communities. Everybody must be inspired to join and even more importantly to - contribute any major regeneration process. Yes, we live in a postindustrial condition. The creative class is rising. However, the concepts for regeneration must not only be about recognising and dragging (attracting) the new class into a city. They should also make conditions in which it could be generated from the local condition, existing population. Cities must become creators of the creative class! The Global Context The context we must ultimately take into account is global. The rise of new societies and their economies pushes for an extreme openness and competition. The new players employ all their assets.
18
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
They transform all aspects of their societies: social, economical, political and – spatial. Three hundred million Chinese will move to the cities in the coming 30 years. Completely new cities are being and will be built. The existing ones extended and fundamentally changed. Similar urbanization levels are expected in other rising economies. The cities are seen as the generators of goods and ideas. They are already operate as the engines of growth. There is no one who could say now how the cities in the nearby future will eventually look like and operate. This is an experiment, and it is global. No one is spared from it. Everybody must participate. Eventually, if the process saved from cataclysmic events, there will indeed be one system for all. The rudimentary phase of the globalization will move to a more regulated version. Also in space - one big room for all. No exclusive clubs to pillow the reality. The key to succeed is the ability to accept new reality, change and adapt. New European City From all points of view the theme of the urban development in the developing world is a clear one. It is about facilitating and enhancing growth of cities, decreasing poverty, raising standards, establishing rules and so on. It is simply making things better. What about the West? Here everything is already OK. Almost no poverty, standards are high, rules are operational. There is hardly any growth of cities. Actually, they often suffer serious decline. The Globalization will and already is further challenging the situation. The immediate reading (one without a creative effort) could be that the people might become significantly more poor. Hence is the process of Globalization relatively easy to read as a threat. Easy to turn into conservative and discriminatory policies. As a result, serious disruptions, possibly cataclysmic ones could follow. So, the focus should be also on the West. It must be proven possible to benefit from Globalization there too. The concepts which to create capacity of the Western societies to adapt, absorb and benefit from the globalization must be developed. They are largely in the areas of the economical and political domains, but also in terms of social policies. Free movement, free trade, open job markets will tremendously reflect on the spatial development. The ultimate question becomes: can a global city find its place inside of a European one?
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
19
What can be of mid-siz
20
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
e a strength ze cities?.
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
21
COPENHAGEN
ANTWERP
FRANKFURT Useless com LYON
AMSTERDAM
22
RUHSTORF
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
HELSINKI
BRNO
ZURICH LJUBLJANA mpetitions?
POTSDAM
SALZBURG
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
23
globalization is the ultimate context
24
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
25
Ii. discoveries
26
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
real lille
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
27
industrial past
28
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
29
challenge
30
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
31
answers
32
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
33
answers
34
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
35
answers
36
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
37
Objective: Lille as the Bes Mid-Size City to
38
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
st European o Live+Work
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
39
Euralille
Unbalanced d
Isolated Inactivated c Post-industr
40
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Euralille
developments
Euralille
Euralille
districts Balancing Out the developm communities = rial city Lille
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
= 41
Unbalanced d
Isolated
Inactivated c Post-industr
42
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
developments
districts
communities rial city Lille
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
43
Unbalanced d Isolated
Inactivated c
Post-industr
44
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
developments districts
communities
rial city Lille
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
45
Unbalanced d Isolated Inactivated c
Post-industr
46
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
development districts communities
rial city Lille
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
47
The final de within a glob
48
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
estination is bal contact.
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
49
Iii. Framework
50
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
hopless city space for hope city space of the future
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
51
Space For The Future European city needs a concept for a substantial transformation that would give it back the leading role in spatial development. Beyond banal attraction of open air museums. Lasting vitality beyond timely urban planning hypes. Functional and challenging. Comfortable and surprising. Attractive but asking for the active participation. The space in the city which to enable the transformation must be discovered. Inspiring active participation of all levels of the society. Optimistic and inclusive. Able to anticipate the change. Open to the future. Open to the World. Space of hope. Two processes seem to be crucial in the pursue of such a space. Search for the types of spatial preconceptions We should embrace the prejudicial character of large portion of European societies and use it to guide the conceptualization of a variety of different spatial conditions: safest neighborhood, cleanest community, children friendliest area, perfect mix, lively, arty, white, black…. In order to make these spatial conditions easier to perceive and market, we should condense and purify them to iconic levels. Theme parks for caprice and prejudice! European type Celebrations! Purity, rigid selection of ambient! What is not pure does not belong. Comfortable life. Poundbury as a European version of Amish community. Stage society! We should finally start appreciating people who are ready to live in museums. There are many of them. Ready to be exhibited! Frozen happiness! We should exclude all inappropriate city spaces that might surround them, by means of condensation and purification, also appropriate mix use (appropriate is very important aspect). Hopeless city space for the hope Simultaneously, we should focus on the residue space created by the previous process. All the space secretly disgusted for being contaminated with impurity and lack of all or some crucial values. Free from any expectations! Confusing. Dangerous. Strangely enough, not fenced off yet (or are fences in Europe somewhat different). Easy to turn the back on. Easy to forget. Left alone. Free! This is exactly the space we both need and can still find in Europe. It is actually the space that is being created by the growing elitism (driven by a massive denial of the reality, what else?) inside and global pressures outside of Europe. What D. Sudjic calls “space for expansion” (in regard to London Thames Gateway) referring mostly to its redundant industrial past, should get explained as a multifold phenomenon deeply embedded in many levels of the European context. Role of the new space This space could be open for experimental spatial organization that would aim for creating inspiring environments for creating ideas and knowledge, intensive exchange of experience. Not only via institutions, but simply via a new spirit of optimism and feeling of belonging to the whole world. It should integrate communities not by assimilating but by respecting and learning from them. It
52
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
should be inviting people with ideas, not afraid of challenge. Today Today, this space is inhabited with immigrants, students, artists and other outsiders. The key change from what it used to be before is that it has lost its previous role of the waiting room where the outsiders wait before joining the club of the established and assimilated. It is widely, though still quietly understood as hopeless. It is also very well hidden. Partly because it is formalized according to the acceptable European city looks (no minarets referendums). Emerging value Meantime this redundant space acquires its own character and values. Lack of formal clarity frees the space from any expectations and opens it up for creative assertions. It becomes a fair ground for invention. It challenges bright minds. Demands and triggers imagination. It acquires a unique identity. All these values and opportunities are ignored by political and (for a great deal) intellectual elites. They are unable to see and exploit the potential of this space outside of the existing developer’s agendas. Exodus from the city centres and simplified concepts for their regeneration both contribute to the growing conviction about irreversibility of the damage done. This is the space everybody thinks is to wait forever. Nineteen century buildings in a mishmash with social housing from 70’s (half or completely privatized), bits and pieces of the industrial past and office buildings of the end of twentieth century. Sometime ago a typical waiting land. Today quietly deemed incurable. The price of regeneration will never pay off while there are hardly any other ways for evaluation. It is the space under the death sentence that will never be executed. The reasons are however not ethical but purely practical. Even speculative concepts made for promotional purposes are not believable anymore. Political campaigners find it more effective to communicate ideas about new stadiums, shopping malls and Olympic assets than regeneration of these areas. There are also not enough artists and gays to start up the bottom up recovery. However the values of this space are definitely recognized by the communities that inhabit it and by the globalization in general. They might not like it but they understand its purpose. They are the only ones with both whish and ideas how to change it to better. One should start thinking of the recovery of a city by not asking for more than that. At least at the beginning. Contradictory enough, exactly the belief in the permanently lost value of this kind of spaces makes them suitable to possibly escape established planning dogmas and trigger alternatives. Hopelessness as a resource! This is the type of space we should be looking for!
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
53
Intermedia
54
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ate Space
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
55
Space of Identity elements
Urban development plan
Major public facilities
Urban history a morpholo
Space of Id
56
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
and ogy
Land price on districts
Popularity and Attractions
dentity
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
57
58
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
59
60
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
61
62
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
63
Space of Identity
64
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
65
irregular nameless undeveloped unnoticeable indefinable unpopular
66
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
flexible renewable potential transformable variable affordable
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
67
what is the ultimate the space?
potential of the depicted space?
68
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
city network engreen network! enriched!
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
69
extensive slow traffic raffic!
routes connected into a network integrating the whole city!
70
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
perfect location for new facilities! social infrastructure: schools, university, cultural centres.....
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
71
finally, the intermediate space becomes the driving Interactions over the city bo force of lille, source of its new vitality!
72
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
order
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
73
Families
Lamberstart
L
74
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
La Madeleine
Lille Sud
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
75
Professionals and workers
Lamberstart
EuraTechnologies
L
Eurasante
76
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
La Madeleine
EuraLille EuraLille II
Lille Sud
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
77
Students
Lamberstart
EuraTechnologies
Medical University Hospitals
Eurasante
78
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
L
La Madeleine
EuraLille EuraLille II
Lille Sud Universities
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
79
Strategy to find Prime Interm
Transfo
Estate tar Restructu mutable p
Public
B
B
B B
B B B
B
B
B B B
B
B
B
B
B B
B
MB
B M
M
B M B B
B B
B B BB
M
B
B
B B B
M
B B
B
B
B
B M
B
B
B
M
B
B
B
B
M B
M
B B
B
B
B
B
B B
M M B
B B
B B
M B
B B
B
M
B
B
B
B
B
B
B B
B
B
B
B
B
B BM
B
B M
Metro sta Bus statio Catchme
B M
M
Social
Distributio Aggregat
Prime
80
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
mediate Space
ormable areas
rgeted perimeters uring territory perimeter
transport network
ations ons and routes ent zones in 5mins (4oom)
housings
on of social housings tion of social housings
e Intermediate Space
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
81
Transformable areas
82
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
83
Catchment-zone of metro s
M
M
M
M
M
84
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
stations 400
M M M M
M
M
M
M
M M
M
M
M
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
85
Social housings
86
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
87
88
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
89
The level of Prime Intermed
90
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
diate Space Transformable areas Catchementzone of metro stations Social housings
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
91
92
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
93
94
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
95
The present of Intermediate
96
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
e Space
2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
97
The 50years later of Interme
98
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ediate Space
2060
2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
99
100
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
101
Iiii.
102
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
communities reactivated
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
103
Let’s brin back to th
104
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ng people he city-life!
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
105
106
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
107
Human asset is the most imp
Human, is always the
108
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
portant catalyst.
most important catalys Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
109
110
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
-bulding walls -open spaces -vacant buidings -parking lot -roof top -stations -alley/back streets -balcony -window -underground/basement /subway -public buidings -street surface -resturants/bars/cafes -stores/shops/markets -roundabout -green
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
111
+
112
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
+
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
113
Urban DNA
Imm
Fam
Stu
Art
Bu
Re
Sp
114
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
migrant
mily
udents
tist
usiness man
etired people
port man
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
115
116
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
117
ProďŹ le: Retired personal time and personal spaces, tend to be more socially active
ProďŹ le: Young Family affordability average daily routine and busy
household garden
118
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Bench Park
Profile: Students Profile: Gipsy
fixed with their schools tend to show themselves off
fortune-tellers, beggars, performers, or retails lead a vagrant life
Urban stage
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
Movable living
119
120
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Streets being vessels
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
121
122
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
123
124
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
125
the beginning: st. sauveur station site
126
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Iiiii. interventions
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
127
Saint Sauveur Test Case for Intermediate Space
128
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
129
Saint Sauveur = Previ 130
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ious Industrial Station Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
131
Saint Sauveu
132
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ur as Catalyst
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
133
Global
Local In 134
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
lization
nitiative Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
135
Lille is A a Glob 136
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Already bal City. Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
137
Heritage = 138
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
50%
Found in Paris, NY
= Shopping Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
139
100%
Found in Paris, NY
Shopping = 140
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
= Global Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
141
142
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
143
Global
Imagine N 144
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
lization
No Country Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
145
Local In
Power to t 146
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
nitiative
the People Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
147
Iiiii. message 1: embrace the world (the global heart of lille)
148
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Seductive Globalization The proposal aims at tackling the globalization from its seductive end - cheap price of the built structure. The concept is an experiment where the price of the built square meter becomes the average global price, resulting in one third of the local one. Instead of building more in order to exploit the market demand (inevitable developer’s reaction), this sudden opportunity is actually used to increase quality and diversity in order to alter the retrograde processes in the development of the city. Fear Is The Enemy The western societies have a very contradictory understanding of the globalization. They embrace its cheap products which dominate various levels of the western consumerist life style. At the same time, same societies are afraid of the globalization process as such. This fear creates opportunities for irrational conclusions. The globalization is often seen as a threat to the western life style. A number of discriminatory political agendas are already using this argument to successfully increase their participation in political life of many European states. The Future Is Bright Larger house, more open private space, more green space, various cultural programs, good quality safe public space and preserved (reused) heritage buildings are proposed. Together with the urban density and existing advantages of the city life like sufficient social infrastructure, proximity to cultural and shopping facilities and good coverage of the public transport the concept proposed offers a very attractive city space that could possibly reverse some of the spatial trends draining the life outside of cities. The exodus of young families to suburbia is stopped. Professionals are tempted to stay living in the city. Start up companies find it more attractive to operate from in the urban environment, better connected, more opportunities for getting profitable clients, more accessible, cheaper to run. Immigrant communities enrich the ambient adding vital elements of their culture which in return makes them finally feel at home. Eventually, the message of openness is sent. Inclusion and optimism! The place for all! Challenging but rewarding! The image of the globalization is changed. We are looking into our bright future!
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
149
Globalization
150
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
= Affordable
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
151
Globalization =
152
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
= Reproduction
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
153
Globaliz Immigran
154
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
zation = nt Workers
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
155
Average GDP Growth - L Developing economies had their b Average GDP growth [%] 8% 6% 4% 2% 0%
L
M
H
1970–80
Countries with
156
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
L
M
H
1980–90
Low income
Low/Middle/High Income best decade of growth in 2000–07
e
L
M
H
L
M
H
1990–2000
2000–07
Middle income
High income
Source: World Development Indicators Source: World Development Indicators Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
157
Merchandise Exports fro
Most developing economy expor
Merchandise exports from dev US$ Trillions ($ trillions) 5 4 3
To mi
2 1 0
1990
158
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
1995
om Developing Countries
rts go to high-income economies
veloping economies
To low-income economies
iddle-income economies
To high-income economies 2000
2005
2007
Source: International Monetary Fund Source: International Monetary Fund Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
159
Migrant Remittances to
Top recipients of migrant remittances a
US$billion, Billion, 2008 (US$ 2008) 52.0 40.6
26.3 18.6 10.7
10.0
9.5
9.4
9.0
7.2
Source:Same as table 1. GDP data for 2008 are not available fo
160
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
o Developing Countries
among developing countries in 2008
% of ofGDP, GDP2007) , 2007 (% 46 39 34 28
26
24
23
22
21
19
or many countries; hence data are shown for 2007.
Source: World Bank Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
161
Contrad People get wh through the what they
162
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
diction: hat they want, e process of don’t like.
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
163
$ S
Y
S
T
Cap Inpu
E
M
Let’s Utilize This System. 164
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
pitalism ut
Soci alism Outp ut
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
165
1,109.
Total Amount by Bilbao Ria Funded witho 166
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
.24
Mil. Euros
of Investment 2000 out Tax Money Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
167
m
Glob
S
Y
S
T
E
M
Globalization as Input 168
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
balization
Affor d Hou able sing
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
169
Social Class
Housing
Income Breaking the Chain Link 170
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
g Price
Quality of Life
Neighborhood
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
171
IKEA Sy “affordab
LACK: 1985: $48* 1
4
Today: $12
KLIPPA 1985: $
1
Today:
*Purchace 172
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ystem: ble solutions for better living�
AN: $772
1
4
: $199
POANG: 1985: $290 1
4
Today: $79
e power = Price based on average inflation of 3.7% Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
173
Glovalizi Setting t
Design
Material Selection
Traditional Process: Price
â‚Ź
Globalization: 174
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Design
ing IKEA: the Target Price First. Local Labor
Price
â‚Ź
+ Material Selection
+
Labor Selection
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
175
Housing S
Lille Average : 2 3000 euro/m :
3: 176
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Sales Price
=
: World Average 2 : 1000 euro/m
:1 Source: World Property Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
177
Hypothesis: World Average
178
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
e=Lille Average
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
179
World Average
Possibility Facto
Industrial Land P =Lower than ne
Land Ownership =Power to Set N
Prefabricated St =Selection of L 180
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
e=Lille Average
ors:
Price eighboring sites
p of City New System
tructure Labor Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
181
More Space = Q
182
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Quality of Living
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
183
x3 Buyers
1
3
x3 Space
184
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
185
75m2 Lille Av.
225m 2
Couple
Start-up Business
186
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Family
Growth
x3 Working
Private
€ Mid Income
Private
€
€
Public
€
Low Income x3
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
187
X X X X
X X X X
X X X X
X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X
Global City Multiplicity of Living + Working
X X X X 188
X X X X
X X X X The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
189
Dual city
“Globa
The global city with the domin of other culture
X
190
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
al city , dual situations�
y concentrates diversity. Its spaces are inscribed nant corporate culture but also with a multiplicity es and identities, [...]They are present everywhere.
--Saskia Sassen--
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
191
Developer Market Driven
Stragegy
=
Tranditional City Base on Social Value
Alternative Stragegy
Global city
192
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
=
=
=
X Vieux Lille
Vauban Esquermes
Fives
Centre
Wazemmes
Faubourg de Bethune
€
€
Lille-Sud
€
Land price Vieux Lille
Vauban Esquermes
Fives
Centre
Wazemmes
Faubourg de Bethune
€
Lille-Sud
€
€
Social Value
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
193
Social Space -LefebvreSaint Sauvenr as * Representations of space Street as * Represenational space / Lived space
194
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
195
Education Faculty
Mark +
Recreati
Students
+ + + + + + + ++ + + + + + + ++ + + + + + + + + + + + +
+
Community Immigrants
196
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
+
Housing Family
Small Business
ket
Business Starter knowledge worker
ion
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Training Centre
Low income people
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
197
x xxx xxxx x x x x x xx xxx xxxx xxxxx x
Market
198
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Station Museum
Park Saint Sauvenr
Connection to City Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
199
x xxx xxxx x x x x x xx xxx xxxx xxxxx x
Market
200
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Station Museum
Park Saint Sauvenr
Merging with City Infrastructure
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
201
Step
1
Step
[Main connection]
Park
202
2
[Exsiting b
Core
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Step
3
building]
[Plots]
Business Hub
Residential Area
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
203
Housing Park
Exhibition Bookstore
Entertainment
Plaza Commercial Community Centre
Atelier
204
Dormitory
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Fa
Education Tra
Stud
Moho Ho
Open
Housin
aculty
Business Hub
aining centre
dio
Office n Market
ousing
Open Office Administration centre
ng
Small Office
kindergarten
Parking
Residentical Area
Park
Sport Facility
Residentical Area
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
205
[Courtyard Options]
Plan 1
Plan 2
[Anchor / Corner ]
Plan 6
Plan 7
[Iconic Punctiform]
Plan 9
Plan 10
[Intersection: Mix-use / Public Space]
Plan 12
206
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Plan 3
Plan 5
Plan 4
Plan 8
Plan 11
Scheme
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
207
Site Plan A Exhibition B Education / Faculty / Lecture Room C Dormitory D Entertainment / Bookstore / Gym E Temporary Housing / Open Office/ Studio F Commercial / Restaurant G Administration Centre
208
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
H Open Market I Small Office J Office K Commercial L Housing / Creative M Housing /Kindergarte N Sqaure
en
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
209
[Circulation]
[Pedestrain Network]
[Anchor Buildings]
210
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
[Public Space Link]
Sport Facility
[Green Space]
[Public] [Private] [Semi-Public]
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
211
Average size in Lille: 75 212
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
5m2 Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
213
Strategy Process #1 Default
214
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
215
Strategy Process #2 size Hypothesis [x3]
216
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
217
Strategy Process #3 Diversifying Typology
218
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
219
Strategy Process #4 Add Program/Mix
220
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
221
Urban typologies 3 times Value = 1/3 Price
[Slab]
222
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
[Cou
[Tower]
untyard]
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
223
A
B
C
$7(/,(5
678',2
+286,1*
&20081$/
$7(/,(5 678',2 +286,1*
COMMUNAL EDUCATION COMMERCIAL EXHIBITION
LIBRARY BOOKS ENTERTAINMENT
A
224
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
HOUSING STUDIO ATELIER
EXHIBITION ENTERTAINMENT
COMMERCIAL
COMMERCIAL
COMMUNAL COMMERCIAL
2)),&(
KINDERGARTEN
+286,1*
COMMUNAL
HOUSING
OPEN MARKET
+286,1*
+286,1*
2)),&( HOUSING
HOUSING HOUSING
COMMERCIAL
KINDERGARTEN
PARKING
PARKING
PARKING
PARKING
PARKING
PARKING
B
C
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
225
226
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
227
Iiii. message 2: believe in what is there (powerful lille)
228
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Mighty Lillians They proposal postulates conditions where what is widely defined as the creative class, becomes the reinventor of the city. It’s participation in the process of city transformation becomes beneficial for both, the city and the new class. The aim is to reverse the drainage of the vital parts of the population outside of the city. For The City The creative class brought up by the postindustrial condition holds a significant but latent potential for the improvement of the city space. This potential is often understood in a very simplified way, through a relatively high purchasing power of the new class. This simplification, downgrading towards statistical figures, together with a lack of initiatives within the city planning agendas to create more attractive living and working conditions for in the city centre, all too often pushes the creative class outside of the central parts of cities. While suburbia seems to be the inevitable choice, the city centres are continuously missing opportunities to engage the new class as the key agent for the regeneration. Everybody Wins The new inhabitants are encouraged to stay in the city by being given incentives such as free ground, free modules of basic structure, free existing old buildings, which together with standard advantages of the life in city centres (sufficient social infrastructure, good public transport coverage, cultural and leisure activities) form ultimately attractive situations for life and work of variety of inhabitants. In return, the new inhabitants are asked to contribute to this process with not more than creating their own conditions for living and working. The process is helped with sets of development rules which secure the urban character of the development without decreasing the creative process. The city benefits from having held the new inhabitants in its central areas in many more ways than just providing new high quality consumers. It engages their creative energy and imagination as the key providers of ideas for the substantial improvement of the area. This has a snowball effect on the adjacent sites and eventually leads to a completely changed image and improved identity for wider area and eventually the whole city. The ideas dwell on the investigation in already existing strategies in several cities in Europe. Those are improved by the addition of design guidelines aiming at inspiring more creativity, hence resulting in a richer variety of urban conditions.
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
229
Work in Ind 230
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
dustrial City Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
231
Lille is already a P
service/profess
service workers 22.9%
68%
manual labourer 15.4%
entreprene
S 232
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Post-Industrial City
sional 23.7%
%
professional workers 21.2%
agriculture 0.1% retired 0.4% unemployed 13.6%
eurs 2.7%
Source: Insee, RP2006 exploitation complĂŠmentaire Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
233
Work in Post-I 234
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Industrial City Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
235
INDUSTRIAL ROOTED ADAPTATION DEFINED TRADITION STABLE PHYSICAL REPETITION FIXED PROTECTED 236
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
POST-INDUSTRIAL MOBILE CREATION AMBIGUOUS INNOVANTION UNCERTAINTY INTELECTUAL DIFFERENTIATION FLEXIBLE EXPOSED
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
237
THIS SPACE COULD BE OPEN FOR EXPERIMENTAL SPAT ING ENVIRONMENTS FOR CREATING IDEAS AND KNOWL VIA INSTITUTIONS, BUT SIMPLY VIA A NEW SPIRIT OF OP WORLD. IT SHOULD INTEGRATE COMMUNITIES NOT BY THEM. IT SHOULD BE INVITING PEOPLE WITH IDEAS, NO WITH IMMIGRANTS, STUDENTS, ARTISTS AND OTHER OU SPACES IS THAT IT HAS LOST ITS PREVIOUS ROLE OF TH JOINING THE CLUB OF THE ESTABLISHED AND ASSIMILA HOPELESS. IT IS ALSO VERY WELL HIDDEN. PARTLY BEC EUROPEAN CITY LOOKS (NO MINARETS REFERENDUMS COMES THE NEW IDENTITY OF THIS SPACE. IT ACTUALL ARE IGNORED BY THE ELITE. HOWEVER THEY ARE DEFI DIVERSITY AND BY THE GLOBALIZATION IN GENERAL. NINETEEN CE FROM 70’SSUBJECT (HALF OR COMPLETELY PRIVATIZED), BITS AN OF THE END OF TWENTIETH CENTURY. SOMETIME AGO ABLE. THE PRICE OF REGENERATION WILL NEVER PAY O IMAGINATION ATE. EVEN SPECULATIVE CONCEPTS MADE FOR PROMO CAL CAMPAIGNERS FIND IT MORE EFFECTIVE TO COMM AND OLYMPIC ASSETS THAN REGENERATION OF THESE TO START UP THE BOTTOM UP RECOVERY. THIS IS THE BODY BUT PEOPLE WHO INHABIT IT. THEY MIGHT NOT L ARE THE ONLY ONES WITH BOTH WHISH AND IDEAS HO OF RECOVERY BY NOT ASKING FOR MORE THAN THAT. A POTENTIAL EXACTLY THE BELIEF IN THE PERMANENTLY LOST VALUE ESCAPE ESTABLISHED PLANNING DOGMAS AND TRIGG THE TYPE OF LAND WE SHOULD BE LOOKING FOR! THIS SOCIALIZE GANIZATION THAT WOULD AIM FOR CREATING INSPIRIN INTENSIVE EXCHANGE OF EXPERIENCE. NOT ONLY VIA I AND FEELING OF BELONGING TO THE WHOLE WORLD. I BUT BY RESPECTING AND LEARNING FROM THEM. IT SH CHALLENGE. TODAY, THIS SPACE IS INHABITED WITH IM THE KEY DISTINCTION FROM OTHER SIMILAR SPACES IS ROOM WHERE THE OUTSIDERS WAIT BEFORE JOINING WIDELY, THOUGH STILL QUIETLY UNDERSTOOD AS HOP FORMALIZED ACCORDING TOReportTHE The Berlage Institute Research 2009/2010ACCEPTABLE EUROP 238 EXACTLY THE LACK OF FORMAL CLARITY BECOMES THE
SPACE
IDEA
CONCEPTION
M
ENERGY
EATIVITY
=P
CREATIVITY
CAPACI
IDEA
CULTURE
TIAL ORGANIZATION THAT WOULD AIM FOR CREATING INSP LEDGE, INTENSIVE EXCHANGE OF EXPERIENCE. NOT ONLY PTIMISM AND FEELING OF BELONGING TO THE WHOLE ASSIMILATING BUT BY RESPECTING AND LEARNING FROM OT AFRAID OF CHALLENGE. TODAY, THIS SPACE IS INHABITE UTSIDERS. THE KEY DISTINCTION FROM OTHER SIMILAR HE WAITING ROOM WHERE THE OUTSIDERS WAIT BEFORE ATED. IT IS WIDELY, THOUGH STILL QUIETLY UNDERSTOOD CAUSE IT IS FORMALIZED ACCORDING TO THE ACCEPTABL S). MEANTIME EXACTLY THE LACK OF FORMAL CLARITY BELY ACQUIRES ITS OWN CHARACTER AND VALUES. THE VALU INITELY RECOGNIZED BY THE COMMUNITIES THAT INHABIT ENTURY BUILDINGS IN A MISHMASH WITH SOCIAL HOUSIN ND PIECES OF THE INDUSTRIAL PAST AND OFFICE BUILDIN O A TYPICAL WAITING LAND. TODAY, QUIETLY DEEMED INCUR OFF AND THERE ARE HARDLY ANY OTHER WAYS TO EVALU OTIONAL PURPOSES ARE NOT BELIEVABLE ANYMORE. POL MUNICATE IDEAS ABOUT NEW STADIUMS, SHOPPING MALLS E AREAS. THERE ARE ALSO NOT ENOUGH ARTISTS AND GA LAND EVERYBODY THINKS IT IS TO WAIT FOREVER. EVERY LIKE IT BUT THEY UNDERSTAND ITS PURPOSE. ALSO, THEY OW TO CHANGE IT TO BETTER. ONE SHOULD START THINKI AT LEAST AT THE BEGINNING. CONTRADICTORY ENOUGH, E OF THIS KIND OF SPACES MAKES THEM SUITABLE TO GER ALTERNATIVES. HOPELESSNESS AS A RESOURCE! THIS S SPACE COULD BE OPEN FOR EXPERIMENTAL SPATIAL OR NG ENVIRONMENTS FOR CREATING IDEAS AND KNOWLEDG INSTITUTIONS, BUT SIMPLY VIA A NEW SPIRIT OF OPTIMISM IT SHOULD INTEGRATE COMMUNITIES NOT BY ASSIMILATIN HOULD BE INVITING PEOPLE WITH IDEAS, NOT AFRAID OF MMIGRANTS, STUDENTS, ARTISTS AND OTHER OUTSIDERS. S THAT IT HAS LOST ITS PREVIOUS ROLE OF THE WAITING THE CLUB OF THE ESTABLISHED AND ASSIMILATED. IT IS PELESS. IT IS ALSO VERY WELL HIDDEN. PARTLY BECAUSE I PEAN CITY LOOKS (NO MINARETS REFERENDUMS). MEANT Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille 239 E NEW IDENTITY OF THIS SPACE. IT ACTUALLY ACQUIRES IT
A
SUBJECT
N
MOBILITY
CON
CONSUMPTION
POTENTIAL
PRODUCTION
ITY
SP ACTION
IMAGINATION
One Unit Fits All 240
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
ric ne
Ge
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
241
Frameworks for Control 242
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Heritage as Given
Physical Structure
Setting Rules
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
243
Freedom for Indivisuals 244
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
245
Freedom for Indivisuals 246
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
247
248
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
249
250
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
251
252
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
253
254
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
255
256
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
257
258
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
259
260
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
261
262
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
263
264
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
265
266
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
267
268
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
269
270
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
271
272
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
273
274
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
275
276
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
277
278
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010
Eura-ring Lille: City after Euralille
279
280
The Berlage Institute Research Report 2009/2010