Submergence in Emergence: Theory of the Small -> Theory of the Large (ft. NeilsDivingJournal)

Page 1


principleof emergence I wasneverexactlysurewhy asthatoftenworks foralongtime IdonotyetknowhowI amtocometothem Whatonefindsmostoddly howassuredlytruetheyareandyetsoelusivelymysteriousindeducingthejustification andinfactprimary tofirstfallinlovewiththecuriousenchantmentofatopicthantofind

ftp.ifengiiiiiii

iiiiiiiiiiitiiI fiiiiiiiiiiIreimiiiiiiii

Sciencebcit'ssofascinating or I aminLovewithherbecausehereyesgivemeelectricthrillsdown science I'malreadyinLovewithit IdonotLoveherbecauseIseeth

doubtsconfusioninordertodiscoverthe limitedthisonemightgoaboutquestioningfor toanecdotalexperience quitefrankly highschooler beexpectedtopossiblyknowwhytheyareinterestedintheirselectedmajorSimply onesimplydoesnoteven enough whatthew knowsandmuchlesshowm eydon.twaboutwhattheydon.tn ignorance hisarttheretrosynthesisofone'scuriosity istheverypinnacleofthosewhoreveretheintellectualendeavors Infact isthisretrosyntheticmomentofeurekawhichcharacterizesthegreatestofacademiciansandtheirlegendaryNobelField's winningdiscoveries Aubiquitoussentimenttobeheardintheirbiographies interviewsgoessomethingakinto manyyears agowhen I wasbutayoungstudent Ifounddeepinterestin topicA Oratleastwhat I thoughtatthetimewas interestin topicA and I workedveryhardinthatsubjectformanyyearsseeminglynotmakingmuchprogress itatall Eventually Imovedon havinglostinterestandfoundmyselfrapturedbytopicB analmostentirelydisparatesectaliento topicA Againtherein topicB cameyearsofworkandseeminglynoprogressandonceagainstruckbyboredom Ifoundmyself rawnto topicC whereagaintheprocessrepeatedagain againthroughtopicsDEF Z Inmydespairhunkeringdownmy astefforts in topicZ I wasstruckbyepiphany There I wasremindedofaverypeculiarfactI'duncoveredallthoseyearsag rommyatthetimeseeminglyunfruitfulworkin topicA whichprovidedmenotjust acrucialinsightin topicZ butfurther gavemerevelationtotugatthestringofmyhistory revealingthegrandstructureofinvariancesunderlyingallofthosetopics

A ZwhichinnaiveglanceappearedatfirsttotallydisparateandirrelevantEversincethenhavingcaughtsightofbutatoeo hegreatbeastofmysterywhichhasturnedouttobethesubstanceI'vebeenchasingallalongthroughvariousfieldsforSwide havestillnotyetcaughtit Butitfollowsmewherever IgoandI lookforwardtofindingitagaininwhatevertopicwhich ndeavorsmenext

Now I amcertainlynonobellaureatenorfield'smedallist ButIstandtosympathizethatthisretrosynthesisofuncoverin heetiologyofone'smysteriousstrikeofinterestsis a ubiquitousone As a highschoolerapplyingtouniversitiesas a Biochemistrymajor I knewverywell I wasinterestedinBiology chemistrybutonlyveryvaguelyandevenillusori if

e i.in myapplicationessaysonit but I simplydidn'tknowenoughaboutthetopictoknowwhyitenchantedmyfascination hispiece isnotgoingtobelikemostothereneilssciencejournalpiecesThisone'sgoingtobealittlebitmoreabou theslowretrospectivemarinationofhow hasstrungalongandrevealeditselfthe f oreofeverything Ihavefoundmyselfin eingSolong I didnotsee it butit wasthereallalongsincethebeginningof

__ myfirstLove

Before lay thelocketsof Love let'stalk bitabout and quandarizingdetailsIt'sno dumb togetherform smar actually peculiarly than emergence strongemergence this suggestion emergent usingonlypropagateddeduction fundamental

firstprinciplesfromthesmallscalestratai.e usingonlythelawsoffundamentalparticle

pff h ff hfffpfÉh

hhhff.se physicsalonecannotrecoverallof Biologybcnewemergentphenomena fffifffffmbfffffff.tl the Éh

a m y p n hath If a particularconcept anywhere severywhere

I canfathomtofindit Ahemisticexample intotheinfinitesimallytinyslicesthatdefine

fifth

theorypursuitinphysics attempting togetthediscretizedtheoryofthe theoryofthelargescale generalrelativity It wouldseematfirstexceedingly different heworldofthesmallseemssoentirelyalmostalien tothetheoryofthelarge Andyetatsomeblurryknife's edge theymustmergeinconsistency Becausewell RealityworksNaturedrawsnoarbitrarydistinction the worldofthesmallandofthelarge It isoneunifiedsubstance andshedoesnotruntwoseparate systemsgoverningthedifferentsizestrataoftheUniverse andyetevenso wehaveKenWilson'snotion effective caleitresidesin Furtheronemay

ndbuildupourintuitionsfromthere

athernansnmy.name she'snot

reductionist

emergencethewhole is greaterthanthesumofitsparts when Carlin Kafka s groupsaslittleas 2peopleormoreforma entirelythanthatofindividualman Conversationsgetdumberas increases deemergence thewholecoalescesintosubstancesimpler constituents Remarkableuniquitiesdiluteawayinlargepools

Quark

feme enid

TT

eme

molecularScellBiology ecological8evolutionaryBiologyYoucantakeforexampletheselection Biologywhichis orthodoxicallyconsideredtohappenonthebasisofindividuals Asoncediscussedthisis higherreproductivefitness theyarethepopulationlimitingreagent addingmore beyond11ratiodoesnt don'tovertakethespecies pp pose intahfahypstika.to hfeanfothEngadrYph'idihiemites undergopopulationselect

matewsiblingsinsidemother'sbodybeforetheyarereleased Onemaythinkofthisemergentparadoxpopulationselectionassuchsoyousayorganismsaresubjecttoindividualselection andyetanorganismisapop ofcellsis itnotTrillionsofindividualcellseachafundamentalunitofgeneticmutationanddifferentialselectionformingapop hatistheorganismTheindividualselectionmechanismenforcesontoindividualorganisms large whichareeachapopulation trillionsofcellsThisinabilitytoreconcilethetwostrataemergentofoneanotherisanexampleofthemysteriousincongruency int 3 p

timemei era ffffffffffffffff.pt

egulationonthehistonelevelgovernedbyphysicalsurfacebindingenergyof speakingofwhich isanotherformofemergenceIt'scommonlysaidthat supercoils adoublehelixofdoublehelices doublehelix thesamewaythatÉÉÉÉ

i

Éf

Éf ven that dimensionisincontactwiththemacrodimensionby elix wraparoundhistoneproteinspheresforming out expressed wilder itwasonlyrelativelydiscoveredthatthereare evena 3 oublehelicesofemergentdoublehelicesformedbynucleosomesdoublehelicesofdoublehelical egg shifts eii.fi

iii t.am.fi fdI tnatiaiien beandhowI'veretrospectively my sincebirthobsessionwsharks Idonotlovetheoceanbecause emergence Itisbackwards addict andthatiswhatledmeintoscience wh Iamasascientistcomesoutof ado here'sNeilnotas neilssciencejournal.butNeilas adiver

Ihavenoideaactuallywhy I amsoobsessedwithsharkswhichisof courseaccessorizedbyimplicitloveoftheocean Theyarethefirstthing I can actuallyrememberhavingfirstcometoconsciousnessas achildmyfirstthoughts everseemedtohavealreadycomepreinstalledwithaloveforsharksZizekoncewas

Iaskedbyaninterviewer soisthereazierintherethatisn'taphilosopher I wanttoknowaboutZizekwhenhe'snotbeingaphilosopher responding No there'snosuchthingThere'snomebesideseverything Ialreadyamthistheory philosophy ismeThatwhichhasnotyetbeenconsumedsintegratedbythetheory.is otyetme.Theyarejust meaninglessarbitrarytrivialikemybackache Icaughtacold Iwentforgroceries Theyarejustunattachedfac Theymeannothingtomeuntilthey'reintegratedintothelargerpartofmystoryWhenIcantracebackonsomearticularmomentandpiecetogetherwithinitsomeformofpsychoanalysis Ifeelthesameway sharks Itfeels

SdivingcapitaloftheworldThereisasayinglivinginIndonesiaandnotknowinghowtodiveis ihrelivingintheswissalpsandnotknowinghowtoskisimilartothewaytheoceangoes

Ithisfaiththat.mnt fin'shitftp.iskeahah 9s live airimagineifeachmmoftheairwasteemingwith heseaofwhichIndonesialiesattheveryheartofAnexceptionalhotspotcoveringonly

eneratingfiercecurrentsbut sortsofnutrientsAnotherreasonisthev01

aboutNature'sluckygiftsistheonlyacceptablebrag It particularfamousdivesitecalledCrystalBayaptly itcanoftentimeshavelikeaglassaquariumpumpedfull shallows 5m

iiiiiiiiiii.iiiii.it

9InYing Ifthenuffeta ahhplannedns.tahhdallthefisharebustlingaboutwhereverthecurrenti strongestDiversallovertheworldflocktothisepicsiteontheirbucketlistforachancetomeettheelusivemo molasunfishoneofthemoststrangelookingorganismsLiterallyagiantswimmingheadthesizeofacarTheyr hb g Ém fÑ f the fearf Partman ta HIS Ithitthe heart fight lipwherecurrentsstriketheedgesofandformrippingdowncurrentsIt'shere whereyouholdposition 2030mtryingtomanagethecurrentsshould youspottheelusivemolarisingfromdepthmakeaquickdescentto35 to gettingshffffa f h it notsomethingyouwantThesemolashowup duringtheAustralianwinterJulySepwherethe cold11620watermakesitswaytoBaliandthe

8 InM L Yemi fhÉ u pᵈthehsti.MIL8YiintghaYEnthatme sitesina.in'sthesina.miieihai.itutbkiiiewas

2 KomodoNHPark WashingMachineBigfishCountry

Chiaigitatangjijithepreviouslydiscussedbigcurrentsmeanslotsofplanktonsnutrientsmeanslotsoffishthusalso sf Isoknownforadrenalinejunkiedivingforthewickedcurrentsandbigfishcountry fmfj.fiffffffffffffffffffffw.fi

ftpfhifhffhffff fffffff ffffffff f entrytodoanegativeentryrollingoffandimmediatelykickingdownand equalizingyourearstodoarapiddescentsothatyouandthesiteby thecurrentsweepsyouoverthetopifyoudon'tdescendfastenoughand divinginIndocurrentsisreallymorelikemountainclimbingattimesfindanice spottotakecoverandtethertohangingonthecornerofthesitelikeakitein thewindandjuststayputandenjoytheshowhugeschoolsoffusiliersdancing grey blueSlowlymakewayaroundthesiteandhike youwill therearesomanydamnfishthatyouSyourcamera's

ffifffffffhff.li

ÉÉÉgÉÉÉÉfÉÉÉff j É

makingsurenottogopasttheedgessuicidalguaranteeddeathforeventhensometimesthecure andabovethesurfaceyoucanwitnessthemonstrousjacuzzidisturbance watergeneratedfromtheragingriversplittingtheislandMindingthatdono

Effeteca SintrinsicYuta's m treatsthis tiring toturtlesandthesheerdensityofswimmingthrougharaincloudof Effi

Iffffff ÉfÉf ffffÉffffffnfffffff É forgiantschoolsofmobularaysorthe takeshelterthereforabittowatchthegroupsof watching the ofthese th hg winds andyour between Hitchhiking for get ree reward som currentjunkiesmelovetheadrenalineofNature'spowersallthepelagicitbring

ZLLfffffffffffff.in

ffffg ffgf fffffh fffgf

t'sduringhistravelshereinIndonesiathathehastheepiphanyoftheWallacelinewhereheobsernnf.hn hatthereissomeimaginarylinejustoffBaliuptothephillipinesexceedinglysimilarandperhapsrelated fffffffmhfhffff.fiffffffffffiffff.fi

If fiff in fffn ÉfÉfÉÉÉÉÉÉ

eoryofEvolutionbyNaturalselectionindependentofDarwinInfacthewrotethesefindingsandhisconjectureofspeciationbygeographicalreproductivebarriers arwinin1858muchtoDarwin'sshockthatitmatchedhisowninspiringhimtoquitbeingaperfectionistandtopublishhismessyabstractoriginofspecies sweallknownowItshouldreallybecalledtheDarwinWallacetheoryofNaturalselectionEvenfurtherWallacediednotknowingthathishypothesizedlinewastrue ndthathe'dactuallyprediscoveredtheexistenceoftectonicplatesfirsttheorizedin1965namelythedeeptrenchesthatkeptAsiaWallaceaAustralia paratedfor50millionyearsduringthepleioceneRajaAmpatisrightsmackdabheartofthecoraltrianglerightonthetipofthebird's here canseemanyoftheseWallaceancreaturesthathavesubtlevariantsexistingonlyhere8AustraliaLikethewobbegongSharkwhich looks more beautifully carpetthanashark lyingoncoralmotionlessthankstotheirspiraclesallowingthem most andhopingtocatchtheunsuspectingfishtosnapupOrperhapsthecuteepaulette has anomalous itspectoralfinsItcanevenwalkonlandtocrosstidepoolsofthemosthellishevolutionary

Australiaalbeitwithminorvariations i.in

maiiifii.iii

iifiii.fiiiiiiiiiiiiiif.fijffififf

sing g nn anengggene speciesqq.sn It'ssituatedrightattheCapetipcornerofKriisland

iins.otfraietoiiitntagonisticseesawhereMost10m

iiiIn afifth staffing hi

fgggggfggggggg.gg

ftp.qggggygfffggggygtgyamgffggggggygy.ggqq.gfgggggggy.gg p

watervisibilityis 1015minaslightlymurkyturquoisegreenThewaterissorichanddensewithnutrien andplanktonthatyoucanactuallyseeitcloudingthewaterwithsomuchparticulatematterwhileth maybeofslightnuisancefortheunderwaterphotographertheequivocalrewardofmarinelifedensitymakes upforitAfterallthefishloveitandthussodothebiggerfish whopreyonthesmallerfishNottomentionthegiantflying seapuppyB2stealthbomberMantaRaysTheyarefilterfeeders muchlikemostothergentlegiantsoftheoceanwhalesetc andareincrediblyinquisitiveplayfulphotogeniccreaturesoften playingwiththeticklybubblemassagesthatdiversgiveThey loveposinganddoingtheirfancyacrobaticsfordiversshovell t É

There'ssomuch I didn'tgetthespacetotalkaboutWhoknowshowmanypages thatwouldtaketomentioneverysinglenookscrannyofmyLoveforallofthis Everylittle divespoteverylittlecritterButevensothat'sthepointright EmergenceAllthelittlethings theyamalgamateintosomethinglargerformethatbigpictureis EmergenceDivingiswhere IdthelessonsandgrowntheobsessionwithEmergence smallthelarge

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.