HAlli
HAIII P ACKJIA,Ll;
BH3HEC
.QAflbWE HE no nYT~ TeKcr:
II otteMy napmHepbt pacxoaamca
M11xa11n AA;iMOBM'I
BH3Hec ua ycrroBHHX napTHepcTBaHBJieHHe ,lJ;OBOJibHO pacnpOCTpaHeHHOe B BerrapycH. CoBMeCTHbie KOMnaHHH '!acTo C03,!1;aJOTCH c APY3bHMH H ep;HHOMbimrreHHHKaMH. Ho o6w;aH pa60Ta MeHHeT OTHOmeHHH. 0Ka3biBaeTcH, 'ITO npHHTHO p;p)')KHTb p;o TeX nop, llOKa Tbl He CBH3aH C p;py3bHMH cjJHHaHCOBblMH 06H3aTeJibCTBaMH.
B nocrrep;Hee BpeMH Y'JaCTHJIHCb CJIY'IaH paCXO)f()J,eHHH MHOfOJieTHHX napTHepoB llO 6H3Hecy. IlpH 3TOM JIHillb HeMHOfHe KOHcjJJIHKTHbie HCTOpHH pa3pemaJOTCH MHpHbiM DYTeM. EorrbmHHCTBO norpH3aiOT B cyp;e6HblX TIDK6ax, TpaTH Ha 3TO Macey CHJI, BpeMeHH H 3,!1;0p0BbH. qTo Hap;o cp;erraTb npH co3p;aHHH o6w;eH: KOMllaHHH, 'IT06bi B03MOlKHbiH pa3BO,!I; npoxop;HJI MeHee 6orre3HeHHO?
Cse>KMe npMMepbl
<1< AJIBOpOI"t >-> ), O,ll,llaKO 11a cpHHHWHOi"L 11p51MOH npoeKTa Me)l(,ll,)' )'4pe,ll,I!TeJJ5l~lll B03HHKJJO 51.6JIOKO pa3,ll,opa. KmmanboHaM Ka3aJJOCb, 4TO Ka)l(,ll,bri"l BHec
B na'laJle TeKywero ro,ll,a rpo~tKtrti KopnopantBHbll"l KOHcjJJIHKT ITOTp51C <1< MHJlaBH-
6oJJbWHfl BKJJM B npoeKT , 4CM ocTaJlbllbJe. Cnopbt Me)l(,ll,)' lliiBecTopa~nr
U)' >-> . OcHOBHOtt aKUHOHep KOMnaHHH -
pacT5111YJII1Cb 11a noJITopa ro,ll,a. CHaL1ana JIHTOBUbl ,ll,06HsaJIHCb HCKJIIO'Ie-
XOJI,ll,HHr Silvana Fashion Group 3CTOHCKO-
Jllt51 )l,osuapa H3 npoeKTa. Ho B HTore 6eJJopyccKHtt 6H3HecMeH ca~1 BbiKy-
ro 6H3HecMeaa ToMaca TooJia -
nHJJ BeCb JIOfHCTll4eCKHJ"t KO~JflJleKC.
peWHJI
j],o cyAe6HbtX T51)K6 ,ll,omeJJ npouecc pa3BO,ll,a y AH,~~;peH 3hipHHooa
H3MemrTb CTPYKTYPY npo,ll,IDK 6cJlb51. c ueJibiO MaKCHMH3HpOBaTb flOJI)''!ei!He np116bi-
H ,UMHTpHH Mep30Ha H3 <1<MHJIJJel!tr)'M fpynn >-> . Om1 3aHHMaJ!HCb ,ll,HCTpH-
Jill, HO BCTpeTHJJ HeflOHIIMaHIIe CO CTOpOHbl
6yuuet't 11 ccpBHCOM asToTexmtKJL Scania, OKa3b!BaJB1 TpaacnopTB0-3Kcne-
p51,ll,a pocc~tikKHX ,ll,HCTpn6biOTopos. B HTO-
,ll,HWIOI!Hble ycnym. Ewe O,ll,Hmi HanpasJJeHHe~l 6H3Hec a 6bJJJH ,ll,HCTpu6y-
re MHOfl1e npo,ll,aBUbl JJH60 OTKa3aJJHCb OT
UH5l 11 cepsuc aBTOM06Hnerr Mitsubishi. IIopTaJI TUT.BY ITOKIIH)'Jl O,ll,IIH H3 C03,ll,aTeJiei1 11 KJ!l04eBbiX TOIT-MeHe-
TaKOrD COTp)',ll,HH4eCTBa, JIH60 CHJ!31LJJ H o6beMbl 3aKynoK . OceHb!O npowJJoro ro,ll,a
,ll,)l(epos KHpHJIJI BoJIOUDUI. ToLJHee, OH ocTaJJC51. COBJJa,ll,CJlbUeM rropTaJJa,
KOI'!IlaHHJO fl0KIIH)'J1a rpynna 6eJIOp)'CCKHX ~1e11e,ll,)l(epOB BO rJJaBe C rell,ll,HpeKTOpOM
pacxo)l(,ll,eJLne so B3fJJ51,ll,ax Ha se,ll,CHHe 6H3Heca c IOpHeM 3HccepoM
110 onepaullOHHOi"r Jle51TeJlbHOCTbJO y)l(e He 3aHuMaeTc51. IIpH4l·!lra yxo,ll,a H AlleKcaH,~~;poM qeKaHOM. IIocne yxo,ll,a BoJJOWHH cTaJt yrrpaBJI51.Tb aKa-
,UMHTpHeM ,UH'IKOBCKHM , pyt<oBO,ll,llBWHM cpa6pnKol"r c
2001
,ll,eMHei"1 IT-o6pa30BaH!I51 <1< lllAf>-> s EeJJapyCit. AKMeMI!51 npet~cTaBJJe11a 11a pbll1Ke YKpallltbJ y)l(e 14 JJeT, HMeeT 21 cj:HrJIHaJJ s Espone 11 14 Tb!C51.4 cTy-
ro,ll,a. j],o 3Toro 6eJJopy-
Cbl ()l,a4KOBCKHH , Cepreu KyconcKHii H IIaoeJI ,Uaneit:Ko) noTep51JIH see MecTa
AeHTOB. KpoMe Toro, KnpunJI Bonowm1 BJJO>KHJIC51 B llOBb1H pecTopaH
B pyKoBO,ll,51WHX opraaax SFG.
<1< HCTTO >-> . Pa30li.IJIHCb nynt BaxTanra AxBIIe,~~;HaHH H ,UMHTpHH AllKHHa, KOTOpbie
BJIMeneu Kpymtoro 6eJiopyccKoro asTonepeso3411Ka TpaHC >-> ~151.
KOMnaHHH «13eJIHJLTep-
BH'leCJiaB ,UOBHap B CBOe Bpe-
Ha4aJJ CTp011TeJlbCTBO JIOfllCTif4eCKOfO
Ue!upa flO,ll, Pal<OBOM COBMeCTHO C ,ll,B)'M51 JIHTOBCKmm Km1llaHH5!MH (JIOfHCTWJeCKOi:'t <1< BHI!feC TepMHHaJlaC >-> H CTpOHTeJlbHOt1
npo._ecc pa3BOA3 y AHAPeR 3blpRHOBa
MJ\MMTpMR Mep30Ha M3 «MMMeHIIYM rpynn».
C03,ll,aJJ 1·1 Kpyn ue!"rmero rrpo,ll,asua KaH uenRpcKHX TOBapos H ocj:mnwil TexuHK11 Belkanton Group. Ce!"r4ac KOMnaHHIO KOHTPOJIIIP)'JOT AxsJJeJlHaHil ll ero cynpyra EJiena. qepHa.51 KOWKa npo6e)l(aJJa H Me)l(,ll,)' AlleKceeM OJieKCHHbiM
}
11 IOpHeM qH)I(OM . Om1 pa30WJ1HCb rrocne sse,ll,elm51 EC caHI<uml B OTHOWeH!ll! q11)l(a II era 611311eCOB. BHaHl'C-peBK> ::\o 1';
(122! ceuT.ROph 2011
HAIII P ACKJIAL{
HAIII EU:3HEC
KaMeHb npeTKHOBCHIUJ He no3 BOJJHJI J].aJJbWC BCCTH COBMCeTHbiH 6H3Hee OeJIOBaTCJIHM KOMnaHHM << CMTCK » AHt~;pew
Kap-
u.eny H Ceprew CTau.enWiy. I1mKMI!HpH11rosoti rpynnoi{ KOMnaHI1i1 B o6JJacnt e Ta!-1KOCTpOe HHH Te n epb yrrpaBJUieT KapueB. CJI11HilH C o eJiopyeeKoro HHAyeTpHaJibHOro 6anKa e TexHo6aHKOM eymtJ!O eo3 AaHI1 e KpynHoro '-!aenmro 6aHKa . 0AHaKO npHBCJIO K KOHcpJIHKTY OeHOBHbLX aKUHOIICpOB. CoBJiaAeJieu l3I113a B Jiat~;Hc
JiaB K ou.apeHKO BeKope noeJJe TOro, KaK CTaJJ npet(eC,[laTCJICM Ha6JIJO,[laTCJibi!OrG co BeTa Tcx1-1o6am<a, 6bTJJ apeCToBaH. 011
•
PalOWIIMCb nyrM BaxraHra AxBIIeAJ13HM Mj\MMTpMR AIIKMHa, KOTO· pble COJAliiiM KpynHeiiwero npOA<JBI.\3 K3H(IellllpCKMX toaapoa MO.MCHOii TeXHMKM Belkanton Group.
2. 3.
BblXOAHlUilM napTHepoM. B 3AO H OAO TaKoi1 eueHaptti1 HeB03 MO)I<eH. IlpH KOIIQ) JI IIKTHO~I eHTyaUMH eueHapHH MOryT 6b!Tb 6oJiee 113 0l[XpCHHbiMH. -
Ho see rAa JJY'IWC H 36eraTb rroAo6noro poAa eueHapHeB, -
ITOA'Iep-
KHBaeT GrenaltOBeKHt't . OueHKa aKTHBOB (BKJiaAOB) HBJIHCTCH KJIJO'IeBoi1 npo6JJeMoi1 rrp11 pa3 BOAe uapTHCpOB. -
Mbl B
100% eJiyqaeB
CTaJIKHBaJIHCb C 3TOi1 np06JICMOH. I1 HMCHHO
3TOT BOnpoe, TOYilCC, HCeOBHat(CHMC B3rJI5!.[(0B napTHCpOB flO 3TOMY BOHpOcy He J].aeT B03MO>KIIOeTH MHpHO 3aBepUIHTb npOHCAYPY pa3BOJ].a , -
rGBO-
pHT at(BOKaT. HCHHbtM?
cpmtallCHeTOB , KOTOpblX o6BHHHJII1 B OT-
-
MbiBaHMH ACHer 11 IIOJIY'-!CtulH He3aKOHHO-
427
EcJIH KOMHaHHH eo3AaHa B cjJopMe 0 0 0 HJIH OL{O, B03MO)I(CH BbJ-
XOA fiYTCJiol llOJ].aYI1 3 aHBJICH11H 0 BblXOJ].C e HOJIY'ICHHCM eTOHMOeTH AOJIH
liTo HY)I(liO fi 3 HaYaJJbHO eAeJJaTb, 'IT06bt pa3BOA noJiy'mJieH 6e3 6oJie3-
HBJIHJICH rJiaBilb!M cp11rypaHTOJiol T.ll. ACJia
ro AOXOAa B pa3Mepe
Bbll<yn / HPOJJ.a)l<a AOJIH HJIH aKUH~l OAHHM / OAHOMY 113 napntepos.
liTo 1-111 ACJiarr, HO npouecc pa3 BOAa seerAa 6yAeT 6oJie3HCHHbiM, -
npeAynp e)KJJ.aeT AJieKeaHAP CTenaHoBei<HH. -
MJIPA py6Jiert.
TeM He MeHee yMeHbUJ~Tb
M a Tb KouapeHKO B eyAax HbJTaJiaeb
6oJib paeeTaBaiiHH MO)I(HO. CaMaH rJiaBHaH npo6JieMa, KOTopyiO AO CHX
oenopHTb npaBo Ha y'-!aeTMe B ynpaBJie -
HOp He Oe031laiOT l>llf0fi1C 6H3HCeMCHbl: I<Ol\11laHI151 -
HMH Tex11o6aHKOM.
Mbl 6yJJ.e M 3 allJ!MaTbe51 » , KOMJJaHJ1H MI1. I1 yeTaB -
J]OBepsu/i..J HO COCTaBnSI~ Opai.!Hblllt KOHTpaKT MBOKaT AneKcaHt~;p
3TO HC npo TO, <i YCM
3TO 11p0 OTHOIIICHHH MC)I(.[(y Jll0.[(b-
llC npoeTO 6yMa)I<Ka , KOTOpaH JLY)I(Ila 11el10JIKOMY AJIH p e-
rHeTpaUH11 !OpHAH'ICeKOro JIM.Ua, a AOI<YMCllT, peryJiapyJOlUM.H OTHOWCI-!HH MC)I(JJ.y rrapTllepaMH. Bo MHOrGM npeue6pC)I(HTCJlbHOC OTHOUJCHHC K f!Ot(rO-
CTerraHOBCKHH
TOBKC Y'IPCAHTCJlbllblX AOKyMCHTOB BCACT K eaMbiM f!JiaYCBHblM noeJJCA-
AaHHOH npo6JieMaTHKoi1 3aHMMaeTCH y)Ke
eTBHHM np11 pa3BOAC napTHCpOB. Il03TOMY , YT06bl B03M0)1(Hb!H pa3BOA f!O-
He OAHH rot(. OH roBopHT, 'ITO B noeJieA-
JIYYHJieH llaHNCIICC 6oJJe3HCHHbiM , CJICAYCT O'ICHb TlUaTCJibJ-10 o6cyAHTb
He e BpCMH paeeTaBamLH npoHeXOAHT O'LCHb
e napntepaml YCJJOBHH yeTaBa H OcpOpMHTb Bee e llOMOlUb!O !OpHCTOB. 0J].HaKO !La 3aKOHO.[laTCJibHOM ypOBHC peryJJHpyiOTe51 He Bee OTHOWCHHH
l\1JIOro. IlpoeTO HCKOTOpblC eJJY'IaH He AOXOAHT t\0 WHpOl<Oi"l 06lUCeTBCHHOeTH.
M C)I<JJ.y -
Ka1<11 e oeHOBHbt e npH'-!HHbT paexO>KAe-
AY
HHH napTI!epoB no 6H3Heey B l3eJJapyeM? -
napTn e pa~m.
IIoaToMy onpaB.[laHHO 3 aKJIJO'-!HTb AOrtOJIIlHTeJibHOe eorJiaweHHe Me)I(rrapTllepaMH , rAe 6yAyT orosopeHbl Te B3aHMOOTHOUJCHHH , KOTOpbte
BIDKlfbl J].JIH l(il)l(t(Oro H3 napTHCpOB, HO npH 3TOM He peryJIMPYJOTeH 3aKO-
CaMblM O)I<MAaCMbTM OTBCTOM Mor 6bt
6biTb ~ ACHbrM » , HO 3TO He TaK. EcJIH AaTb
HOAaTCJibeTBOJiol. L{a , 3TOT AOKYMCHT XOTb H IIC 6yAeT 06JiaJ].aTb JOPHAHYC-
061UyiO xapaKTCpHeTHKY npaKHl'-!CCKH Beex
CKOK eHJIOH , TCM He MCHee Tlp05!eHHT BHJ].CI li1C 6113Heea J].JIH KIDKJ].Oro H3
pa3BOAOB -
napnrepOB, -
3TO paeXO)I(.[(CHH51 B O)I(HJ].aJ-[['1-
ry 11 B yH 3 BJJCilHOM
~'-lyBeTBe
cnl >> . L{pyrHMH eJJOBaMJ1:
<15!
rOBOp11T yrrpaBJIHIOlUHH napT!iCp at(BOKaTeKOro 610p0 <<Cre-
naHOBCKHH, IIanaKyJib 11 napniepbi».
HX HapTHCpOB flO OTHO!IlCHHJO Apyr K Apy-
B 6pa'I!IOM KOHTpaKTe rrpH eo3AaHHH 6H3Heea Ha napniepeKax yeJIOBM-
enpaBeAJIHBO-
HX HC06XOAHMO npeJJ.yeMOTpCTb f!Ot\XOJ].bl L< Ol[CllKC 6H3Heea / AOJIH / ai<TH-
O>KHJ].aJJ, 'ITO
MOH napTHep 6yAeT ACHeTBOBaTb Tal<, a 011
BOB, nepeneKTI1Bbl pa3BHTH51. 6H3Heea, 06H3aHHOeTH l(il)l(t(Oro 113 napTHC-
rroeryn11JI no-ApyroMy -
pOB, HOpHAOK pa3 pCWCHHH B03HHKalOWHX enopOB.
11 aTo, Ha Moi1
-
B3fJUIJ]. , l!eenpaBCAJII1BO ITO OTHOWCH1110 KO
3TO eaMbiC OeHOBHbiC MOMCHTbl. Bee OeTaJibHbiC yeJIOBHH OrGBapHBa-
l\me » . TaK YTO ACHbrH 3JJ.Ceb He Ha rrepBOM
JOTeH B 3aBHeHMOeTH OT MHO)I(CeTBa JJ.pyntX cpaKTOpOB. }I ClUC HH pa3y HC
l\1CeTe , XOTH 01111 BCCr.[(a 3aMeiiJaHbl B pa3 -
BCTpeYaJI OAHilaKOBbiX rrapTHepeKHX eorJiawe Jmt'i. OHM Beer.[(a pa3Hble,
BOJ].C, -
rOBOpHT at(BOKaT.
Bap~taHTOB pa3.[leJia <<eOBMeeTHO Hil)I(HTOro HMYlUCCTBa» CYlUCCTByeT BCJIHKOC MHO>KeeTBO. Bee 3aBHeHT OT Toro, KaK rrapTnepbt pa3BOAHTeH -
rro-xopowcMy
HJJH no-nJioxoMy. EeJIH 6paTb <iXOpOLUHe » BapHai!Tbl, TO 3t(Ceb B03MO>KHbl eJICJ].yJOUXHC.
1.
KJiaceHYCeKaH peopraHH3aHHH (BbiAe-
JICHHe , pa3J].CJICHHC) '1Cpe3: a) Bblt(CJIC!II!C HOBOH KOMJJamm, KOTOpaH nepeAaeTCH OAHOMY H3 rrapntepoB / napTHepaM; 6) pa3t(CJIC!li1C KOM!1aHHH Ha ABC ~~ 6oJICC -
e LlOeJieAyJOlUHM o6oeo6JJCHHCM
B <i CBOCM »
lOp~lt\HYCeKOM
113 rrapntepoB.
JIHUC Ka)J<.[\Oro
nocr<OJibKY Bee JIJOAH H yeJJOBHH HX COTPYAilH't eeTBa TaK)Ke OTJIHYaJoTeH
•
KaMeHb npeTKHoaeHMR He n03BOIIMII A311bWe aecTM COBMeCTHbiM 6M3HeC OCHO· B3TellliM KOMnaHMM
nCMTeK,, AHAPeto Kapr~eay
MCeprero Ctat~eBM'Iy.
Apyr OT Apyra , -
rGBOpHT eo6eee.[(HHK <i DH3!1Ce-peBJ0 1> .
B KOJrrpar<Tax nponHebiBaJOTCH caMbJC HeBepOHTHbie 11 aJiorw-LHble yeJioBHH. AJieKeaHAP CTerranoBeKHH senOMHHJI 11.3 esoei1 npaKTHKH JJ.Ba npHMepa rrot(o6 n oro poJJ.a. IlepBbi H: <iilapTJ!Cpbl He MOryT np11HHMaTb HOJ].apKH OT KJIHCHTOB eTOHMOeTbiO 60JICC
$100.
IloJ].apKH, npCBblUlaJOlUI1C eTOHMOeTb
$100,
J].OJI)KHbl
6b!Tb rrpOJ].allbl, a t\CHC)I(Hb!C epeAeTBa, f!OJJYYCilHbiC OT peaJJH3al[HH 3TI1X TlOJ].apKOB, flOACJICHbl MC)I(JJ.y napTHepaMH JIJ160 HanpaBJICHbl Ha pa3 BI1THC 6u3He ea. B eJtyYae eeJIH napTHep )I(CJiaeT oeTaBHTb 3a eo6oi1 nOA06Horo pOAa fiO.[(apOK , OH J].OJI)I(CH BbTT<YllHTb ero nyTeM BHCeCHHH .[(CHC)I(llblX epCACTB !Ia eYCT KOJ\11laHHH B 6aHI<C1> . BTOpOH: <i ilapTHCpbl B TC'-!CHHC epoKa ACHeTBHH HaeTOHlUCrO eorJJaweHHH H Ha llpOTH)I(CI!HH ABYX JICT noeJie BblXOAa / HeKJIJO'ICHHH H3 napTHepeTBa o6H3 YJOTeH He BbleTyrraTb Y'~PCAMTCJIHMM ApyrHx IOPHAH'!eeKHX JIHU C aHaJIOfH'lllbiM npet(MCTOM .[(CHTCJibllOeTH HaeTOHUXCrO napnrepeTBa » .
•