2010 n i d n o c e s ked n a r s a w a ita k p a c Alas r e p n o i mpt u s n o c y g r e). e g a r e v in en a l a n o nati e h t s e m i t ere w a t i (three p a c r e res p u t i d n e p x e 012 2 n i State 7 0 8 , 8 at $ n o i t a n e h t ge). a r top in e v a l a n o i e nat h t s e m i t o d one e r (tw e d i s n o c s is s a m o i b y d ergy n e Woo f o t s o c high e h t o t n o i eas. r a l a solut r u r n i ially c e p s e , a k s in Ala
WOODY
BIOMASS I N
A L A S K A
Converting from fuel oil to wood boilers in Alaska communities — lessons learned Project scope
Community experience
From 2002 to 2012, over four dozen Alaskan rural communities applied for 61 prefeasibility grants to convert from fuel oil to cordwood, wood chip, driftwood and pellet boilers. The Alaska Center for Energy and Power and University of Alaska Fairbanks Cooperative Extension Service looked at resulting data to determine which projects became operational and what technical, economic and social factors lead to success.
Key community members were interviewed to get an idea of what it takes to make a biomass program succeed.
Tok biomass boiler
April 2013 Installed Biomass Boilers Community Coffman Cove Coffman Cove Craig
Project
City center Coffman Cove school (K-12)
Fuel type Cord Cord
Craig municipal pool, elementary school and middle school Delta middle-high school Old school, tribal/city offices, new school and teacher housing, and water plant University classrooms
Chips
Galena Gulkana Haines Juneau Kasilof
Elder’s residence project Several Senior housing center Sealaska building Community hall and domestic hot water building
Cord Cord Pellet Pellet Cord
Ketchikan
Tongass Discovery Center , Federal building and Ketchikan library Sitka Coast Guard buildings Washeteria, city building and teacher housing and school Tetlin school (K-12) Thorne Bay school (K-12)
Pellet/Chips
AGSD Admin office, Tok school, and multi-purpose facility
Chips
Delta Junction Elim Fort Yukon
Sitka Tanana Tetlin Thorne Bay Tok
Installation details Installed Econoburn with problems per creosote Installed 2 GARNS in 2010 and it works great feeding it 2 hours per day (on cold) installed Chiptech in 2008 and is operational
Chips Cord
Installed Messersmith is operational Installed “Garn in a box” protype operating with difficulties
Cord
Installed a Tarm system that has been tested, performed nicely; not in use due to bureaucratic problem issues Installed 3 Tarms and operational Installed Tarms operational with some issues Installed in 2012 and working well Installed 2008 and working very well Installed Garn that are operation 4-5 years satisfactorily, yet not run at full capacity due to labor need of loading it Installed but having auger difficulty (at Discovery Center) and 2 ACTs operating fine Installed 3 ACTs, operational but on hold Installed 6 Garns and 4 Econoburns
Pellet Cord Cord Cord
Installed 2 Garns operational Installed 2 “Garn in a box” systems fully operation; not in use due to bureaucratic problem issues Installed 2010 Messersmith is operation
Economic factors for success
A successful project saved the community money or stabilized the cost of heat and utilized wood resources (which are often a local fire danger) at a sustainable rate.
Questions asked: • What was the fuel usage before and after biomass boiler installation? • How much fuel was displaced/how much money was saved? • Was reliability of fuel delivery a problem? • Is wood availability a problem now? • How was the boiler performance before and after biomass boiler installation? Garn boiler in Tetlin • Was/is the boiler reliable? • Have they had labor or human resources issues? • Is the community happy with the installation?
Typical installation in Alaska In a typical situation, a woody biomassfired boiler was installed in a main building, such as a school or a tribal hall. Often, if the installation and implementation are successful, the next step was to extend biomass heating to other community buildings, such as a clinic or laundromat, either via a district heating loop from the first boiler or the installation of additional boilers.
Coil used to circulate water or glycol in biomass boilers, Tetlin School
Typical fuel oil prices in the Alaska villages can range from $5 to $9 per gallon. A typical range of oil usage for a school in mid-sized community of several hundred residents would be about 10,000 to 50,000 gallons per year. A typical community saved $80,000 to $400,000 per year on fuel costs after installing a wood-fired boiler. 2002 - 2012 Prefeasability Study Applicants
Applicants Actual Installations
However, a wood-fired boiler must be actively and consistently used. The community must be motivated either by economic or emotional reasons to use a boiler. This is especially true in the case of cordwood-fired boilers, which are the most labor-intensive and the least routine.
Social factors for success Social factors are also necessary for a biomass project to succeed. It is important to have a supportive collective community as well as a local champion who is enthusiastic about biomass. Other factors include: • Community pride • Desire for energy independence from Outside suppliers • A more general wish for selfreliance within the community • Creation of local jobs • Concerns about environmental ethics and stewardship
Logistical factors for success
Logistical factors for success must consider the size and insulation of the building and the cost and availability of biomass fuel. In addition: • Wood sources must be either local or reliably delivered. • Wood must be dry (ideally under 30 percent moisture content). • A chipper, if chips are used, must be reliably available. • Sufficient local labor must be available to maintain the boiler. • There must be adequate training of local operators and maintenance workers.
UAF Cooperative Extension Service 877-520-5211 • www.uaf.edu/ces UAF is an affirmative action/equal opportunity employer and educational institution.
Tok School: only low-pressure steam turbine that produces electricity anywhere in the United States
The woody biomass boilers most commonly used in community and tribal buildings in Alaska are manufactured by Garn, Messersmith, TARM, ATC and Chiptec and burn either chips, pellets or cordwood. Buildings are heated by circulating a heatcarrying fluid (generally either water or glycol) in a closed loop between the boiler and the building; the heat is controlled by the flow rate of the water or the glycol, rather than by the air flow (such as accomplished by wood stoves).