Whittier February 2012

Page 1

The

WM

hittier

February 2012

Wilmington Friends School's Community Newspaper Nagaswami

Since 1884

iscellany Wilmington, DE

Romney Leads, America Hesitates Duncan Hobbs '12 News Writer

Photo of the Month: Chris DiMaria, a junior Mock Trial member, preps for the competition in February.

2012 Quaker Mock Trial is No Joke Josh Schwartz '12 News Writer When most people hear “Mock Trial,” they automatically think of lots of work and “see countless nights pouring over boring legal papers,” according to one member of Mock Trial. However, it really is more than that. “The clichéd line about Mock Trial is that it is a lot of work, but it is a lot of fun, and that is not far from the truth,” says senior member Chris Getty. It is no secret that Mock Trial is a lot of work. Combine practices with school, homework, friends, and sports or extracurricular activities, and it can all add up. During midterms, it is even worse! However, for the actual members, it is worth it. The members of Mock Trial are given a case in November. The case can either be a civil or criminal trial and it rotates every year. The civil cases can involve copyright infringement, breach of contract, fraud, libel, or almost anything else. The criminal cases, however, are always about one thing: murder. Since last year’s competition was a civil trial, this year’s competition is a criminal trial, which means a murder trial. The team is first given six witness statements. Three of these are for the prosecution (or plaintiff in a civil trial) and three of these are for the defense. Whoever is chosen from the team to be a witness must stay within those statements. The team is also given ten exhibits, or pieces of evidence, that will be used in favor of either the prosecution or defense. However, some of these exhibits are not particularly useful or incriminating and do not have to be brought into evidence and used in the actual competition. There is one catch. The Mock Trial team has to prepare both sides of the case. Since the team has to prepare both sides of the case, some people prepare to argue both sides. There cannot be, though, people who do more than one role on a given side. After months of planning, preparation, and practicing, the Mock Trial competition finally begins on February twenty-fourth and twenty-fifth at the New Castle County Courthouse. At the competition, every Mock Trial team presents four times against different teams. For some of those times,

the Friends team is the prosecution, and for the other times, the Friends team is the defense. Scores are given out of ten for each stage of the competition to both the attorneys and witnesses. Also, after each round, two contestants are awarded with the “best attorney” and “best witness” award. Generally, these two awards are split between the two teams to avoid the appearance of favoritism, according to one mock trial member. Eventually, the top two teams go to the final round and the winner is crowned Mock Trial champion. Each of the cases in Mock Trial has a specific order of events. First, the prosecution makes his or her opening statement and then the defense makes his or her opening remarks. Next, the prosecution presents their witnesses and exhibits and the prosecution questions their own witnesses. This is followed by the defense cross examination, or asking questions of, the prosecution’s witnesses. The defense then presents and asks questions of their witnesses and exhibits and then the prosecution cross-examines the defense’s witnesses. Finally, the prosecution makes their closing statement, which is followed by the defense’s closing statements. The prosecution may rebut the defense’s closing statement if they wish. After all of this, the judges hand down their ruling and settle on their score for each respective team. Any member you ask will confirm that Mock Trial isn't just for fun. While working together as a team is great fun, the skills members develop through practice and competition stick with them for the rest of their lives. Senior member Kristi Iannelli says, "Mock Trial gives its members great public speaking skills that help us in every area of academics." While Mock Trial is serious and a lot of work, there is “lots of improvisation” and “you really do develop the ability to think on your feet,” according to one member. Chris Getty says, “It is generally a tight-knit group, and the competition is more lighthearted than you would expect.” Junior member Molly Conces agrees. “The team is a little family and it is really cool to learn about the whole trial process and law in general.” This will be the last high school Mock Trial competition for seniors Chris Getty, Kristi Iannelli, and Daniel Potter, so make sure to wish them good luck!

After winning the Republican primary in New Hampshire by capturing thirty-nine percent of the vote, it seems increasingly likely that Mitt Romney will be the Republican challenger for President to Barack Obama in November. Ron Paul’s isolationist foreign policy as well as his denunciation of both the Federal Reserve and the United Nations will likely prevent him from winning enough support from mainstream Republicans. Both Newt Gingrich and Rick Satourum lost momentum in New Hampshire, making mistakes to be exposed at future primaries. Rick Perry was practically a no-show in New Hampshire, and he is not likely to recover his lost momentum and challenge Romney for the nomination. Mitt Romney has all the money and momentum he needs to be the Republican nominee for president assuming he makes no unlikely gaffes. In polls of voter preference, he consistently does better than other Republican candidates against Obama. So why does the thought of Mitt Romney as the Republican candidate for president seem to make so many prominent conservatives lose their lunch? Though Romney’s Mormon faith is often raised as a main reason evangelical conservatives have been desperately seeking an alternative, they seem far more worried by his inconsistent views on important issues and a lack of conviction about what he does believe. As governor of Massachusetts, Romney supported measures to curb greenhouse gas emissions, balanced the budget by raising taxes and eliminating loopholes, and signed healthcare legislation that became the model for Obama’s National Healthcare Reform Act passed in 2009. His record at Bain Capital has also come under attack from Republicans who have asserted that the investing and restructuring Bain did to other companies destroyed more jobs than it created. Among his other planned executive orders would be a condemnation of China as a currency manipulator, an elimination of all Obama regulations that “unduly burden the economy or job creation,” an elimination of regulations that favor organized labor, and a fast track system for obtaining oil drilling permits. Romney also advocates for reducing the corporate income tax rate to twenty-five percent, cutting discretionary federal spending by five percent, capping Medicaid spending and partially privatizing Medicare, and eliminating taxes on capital gains, interest, and dividends on those earning less than $200,000. While some of Romney's points are vague and unclear, he has strong ideas about the specific things he would do as president. His biggest problem seems to be that he has failed to really condense his ideas into a package suitable for presenting at speeches and using in debates. When asked about the economic reforms he would implement if elected, Romney tells viewers that they should go read his fifty-nine point economic plan posted on his website and fails to focus on a few specific policies that resonate with his audience. His uninspiring performances in debates have led many to question what he really stands for. Whether one is a Republican or Democrat, they might want to take the time to look at these, not only because they elucidate Romney’s policy plans for the nation, but also because they are a source of interesting views and potential solutions for the problems that face our nation. NOTE: This article was originally written on January 20, just after Romney won the New Hampshire primary. More recent campaign developments are thus not reflected in this article. I hope readers will take this important context into account when reading the article.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.