Lc rea

[^_+yb - TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f 'a'`'f+2 +2

[^1y[ +i U'c U'c'd]gY 'd]gY 'd ie1bd][Z' k]g[*'Y+[d'21bd[+e U'c'd]gY +[E ]e +eTe')]g[*. A [e' ce' )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 'Y+[ ('[ bd+W4c+2 .[*'Y+[. Y1 i'[1 U','e d'e1 'a'`S 68 0'Y dA]W]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W : je+e1 .[/'fi]gYB bT '/+1bd[+e. U'c'bd1'f[]gY +[E /+ 1bdc'4 ^T'E /+ 1bdc'4'\]g[^. 'a'b_+2[+e1 )1ei - A /+ TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. 'a'`'f+2 +[ Y1 \'ei _'d'U'T'[]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i]gYB

'd Y'e*1T Y'b'Y( .[*]g[]gY +[ k]g[*'Y+[d'21bd[+e1 )'W'h'e[+e.E Y'b'Y( -2 '/+1bd[+e1B bT ]ye[ - V+e d+O b'T+d.B 3]gf+ *]gi -2 U'c'd]gY +iE ]e 1bdc'4 T' A U'eO )]gY +i [e' ]bi.S 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B 2'Zf U['e'c]e -S V+, U'Y'e T'eA]e [\'['T]g/Z]g[ ]g[+[ ['A U'Zd[1 )1d['T'[[+O e1 d+b'T+d[+e.E ]ci+e ^+[ .[*]g[]gYE ]e TZ'[i. bd+W4')]eO 4]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B bT +/+ +e+3'[+e ]g[+iE )]gf+ f'[T'O ['i 1Y'['2E /+ 1[^_+b T'e]W +i _'d'b3'[+2 -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 T'Y bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ [e'[f U'ef+e1[B

ye[ - 'Zb )ei]gZT1 [_'d'T.

2

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

Cover: Beach and reef: 5 Digital Vision Ltd/age fotostock

1Zb )ei]gZT1 [_'d'T. ^- 4'We1 +[/'eT+2 k]g[*'Y+[d'O 21bd[+e1 T'Y 'Z[ Y'e*T'[f d+b'T+d[+e.E ]ci+e ^+[ U'c'O d]gY 1bd4]g )]Z]g/Z'[.B 8[*U'T'a'T.S 'Z[ TYW1 V+, c+e'O ['Z+2]gE /+ 1[^1[ +i U'c'd]gY A 1[^]gB 3ei]gZT]gY ('f'd.eO c]gY - 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]gO /Z]g[.E ]e. )]gf+ ^+i ]gb]gY['b1e+2B 1Y'['i ['AS 1[^]g - 1bO T'_+b T'eA]eE /+ 1[^1[ +i U'c'd]gYB cbd'U+yi 'e*Z]i [e'[fE ]ci+e 'b]gY +[E /+ ^T' ('['T'O []g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 1e'e1^ A 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[[+O e. U'c'bd1 ^+[B 9+y 1[i[+e* Ti[[+i 'Z[ d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e.E ]e U'W]e*]gY - 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B ygY 3]bi+e1[ Tcbd'U+i ]g TU'c'd'iS 1bdc'4'\[^1yE /+y -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e1 L5(e'Z+O f1[+e 55B5MB 5T+i Y1'b1[ i[[+[i ]e]\ h'bd+eB

]c'[*'T]g/Z]g[ 8

+[*'[1 Y]2 Y]2]e'T ]e'T

55

yc - ['3')4+2 'a'`1[.

5<

c]2Z]gf1'D c'eT'4[+e A h'bd+e 68

1d]g/Z]g[. A wı[[*]fx )1ei.

6=

'eA]ye - 'e*Z]iE /+ 1[^1[ +i U'c'd]gY '[V'Y( *]gi 7>

W(Z]ge[+e1 f'[T

5 6>5> WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA ˛[^_+yb - TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f+2 e'd'e'T1^[+eS WATCHTOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF NEW YORKE INCD BrooklynE New YorkE UDSDAD 6>58 /D Y'ed1 Ue'd'e'T]g/Z]g[ Zb )ei]gZT. c'X'ai1 U'Y'e ^-B Z[ j0'[*'T]gY - bdc'4'\[^1 U'Y'\3'eU'Z1[ Te/'T'[ )]e4]gO [+]g/Z'[.E ]e[ 1e'T'['fc]gY U]0'e'T'Y [c1e'(+e]g/Z]g[[+e1 \[]eU1cB ˘/+ 'Z2 T+e_ [\c'4 ^-E bdc'4'O \[^1 Y+`(+e]gY[+e. c+efc'4 +[ w ]e '\3'eUx /'e)Y'[]g/Z]g[1fB

Was Life Created?

Armenian Llc-REAM Made in Britain by Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Britain LRegistered in England as a CharityM ˇ]gZb - d+b+2 +4 e1d'[1'Z]gY

+[*'[1 Y]2]e'T 5eTe1 ce' TZ'[i ^-e 21[1E +/+ ^21[+1[ 'Z[ Y1 \'ei w+e`'[1T _'d'U'T'[]g/Z]g[[+e.xE ]e][i Y1[^A 6>Qe* *'e. *+aAb '[U'Zd -1[ T'Y 21]c1[ U'bT'['21 ^-1[ Y'e*T'[fB $[[+[i *e'[f1f Y1 i'[1b.B Ë&#x203A;

1e T'/1[ )'2'Td1T'Z]gY A 1e+)'T['Z1[ U'Y'T'e)]gY 5eTe1 d+W.E 1[^_+b ['A [e' ]gW+41e.E 'a'[fi1 /+i]g/Z]g[.E _d]gZd1 'e')]g/Z]g[. A w'[b]c]ex ^'h+e ]g[+f]W ]gb1[.B

Ë&#x203A;

')[1b'T'[ *'\d. A Y/[]2]ed.E ]e][i 4'a'Z]gY +[ ]e_+b +eT\+ed ,e'UB

Ë&#x203A;

2['T'[ h]g2+e.E ]e][f Y1`]f]c U'Y'2ec]gY A Y'iec]gY +[ j*1 A `e1 _'\'e[+e.B

1Zb /+Y'[+e1f Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge1[ 4'[]/'['21b U'efe+i 1[i[+e* V+,D w5eTe')]g[*[ 1e (]2]e 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e]c _'d'U'T'[]g/Z'y[E /+y [_'d'T'Z1[ )]e4]g[+]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -xB

4

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

5eT1e. ^-e T'e]W 'c+21 U'eY'e c'Ze )d[+2 TZ'[i1 )]Z]g/Z]g[[ '_'U]c+2]g U'Y'e

e_+b,1 ['Y'T. )d[1 U'bf+'d1e]`.E 4e'e1 ce' _+di - [\c'4 21[1 U'bf+[S +eT1O e.E i'W'i.E h]W]f.B 5T+i )e+[i Y+e Y]2]O e'T1 U'bf+[B 1e T'/1[ )'2'Td1T'[ '[O c'[+[i w+eT1exE 1e+)'T['Z1[ U'Y'T'e).

L1eA. A [e' \]ge` _ddc]W Y]2]e'T[+e.MS wi'W'ixE 1bT +eTe')[*1 ]gW+41e.S wh]O W]fxB +e wi'W'i.xE T'YS 1e+)'T['Z1[ U'O Y'T'e). )d[c]gY - 1e T'/1[ )'2'Td1O T'Z1S wTZ'[i1 U'Y'e ('e+[_'bd )]d1x T]^c]W d'e'4i]gYE ]e. ]^ \'d Y]d - T+[dO e][1[E ]^ -2 \'d U+a]g - T+[de][1fB 1Zb d'O e'4i]gY T' i1Y1'T'[ -2+Y+[d[+e1 X1\d 'Z[i'[ 3d]g/Z]g[E ]ei'[ '[Ue'0+\d TZ'[i1 _'U_'[Y'[ U'Y'eB 1[^*+a 3'O 2'Td1T'Z1 b'UY'[[+e1 Y]d 'Z* -2+Y+[d[+O e. ^'h','[f i1^ +[E 1bT T+[de][]gY Y'U'O

5 41 1

5

& NASA/JPL/Caltech

5eTe')[*1 1*+'2'T'[ wU'bf+[x

(+e X'a')'Z/[+e. A 'Z2 cd'[)'c]e )]eO 4][[+e[ +[ \'dE ]e][i '[U['e +[ *'eVO []gY TZ'[i1 )]Z]g/Z]g[.B 1bdW')1d]g/O Z'[ A k1,1T'Z1 ,'e)'fY'[ \[]eU1c )1d['O T'[[+e. _'e,+2 +[E /+ 1[^ U'eY'e d+W )d+2 5eT1e. ]W` d1+,+ei]gYE A *' '_\+fO e+2 - [e'[fB w +[i '_e]gY +[i 'Y+['2'c d'e'4i]gYxEP [\]gY - w 'Z+[/1k1i 'Y+O e1i.[x U'[*+b.5B *+'2'T'[ wh]W]fxB 'T'b 1*+'2'O T'[ ^- ['A 1e+)'T['Z1[ U'Y'T'e) wi'O W'i1x 'Z[ wh]W]f.xE ]ed+W )d[c]gY - 5eO T1e.B +e Y]2]e'T. 1e+)'T1f U+a]g - 59> Y121][ T12]Y+deB 1Z* _'dX'a]c +eTO e')]g[*. ]R^ b'a^]gY -E ]R^ -2 ^'h1f \'d d'i'[]gYE 1[^. ('e+[_'bd _'ZY'[[+e bd+W4]gY TZ'[i1 )]Z]g/Z'[ U'Y'eB 4+a 'c+21[E ]gW+41e. )e+/+ \e`'['VA -B 4e' \[]eU1c +eTe1 A 'eA1 Y1`A U+a'c]e]g/Z]g[.

U'Y'eZ' /+ ^1 h]3c]gY 'Y(]W` d'e1B [^ c+e'(+e]gY - 1e+)'T1[E '_' 'Z[ 'b+b 1*+'2'T'[ ^'h+e ]g[+f]W Y1 U,]e -2+Tde'T'Z'[ -E ]e[ '\3'd]gY - 'a'[f *'*'e1 A '[Ue'0+\d i'['T1 -[+e)1' 'ed'*e]gYB ,]ge ^-E ]e 1e+)'T1[ T]^+2 +[ wZ]ge'U'd]gT 'bdWx6B *+'2'T'[ wU'eA'[]gU1xB y[^ +i T'e4]gYE ]yc T'e]W -e 21[+2 5eTe1 'Y+['O 2'c wU'eA'[]gU1[xB U'eT+ ]gb1[.B ]gbO [1 de'Y')14. 5eTe1 de'Y')41 Y+T i'a]eO *1f h]ieQ1[^ Y+4 -B 1e0+ [\+2 ['AE ]e Y+e

5eTe1 1*+'2'T'[ /+i]g/Z]g[. A _d]gZd.B 5eTe1 'a'[fi1 /+i]g/Z]g[. 67E8 'bd1X'[ -B 1Zb 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z'[ \[]eO U1c )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+[ T21Y'Z'T'[ d'e(+e )]O d1[+eE 1[^_+b ['A _'U_'[c]gY +[ +W'O ['T[+e1 U+e/'h]3. A `+eY'bd1X'[1 d'O d'[]gY[+e1 T'Z]g[ Y1`'T'Zi.B w5eTe1 'a'[fi[ ]g[1 U+[f 'Z[ /+i]g/Z]gO [.E ]e[ '[Ue'0+\d - TZ'[i1 )]O Z]g/Z'[ U'Y'exEP [\c]gY - )1O d'T'[ Y1 )ei]gY 7 LRare Earth P Why Complex Life Is Uncommon in the UniverseMB *+'2'T'[ - ['A f+O e+Tc' A )1\+ec' dA]W]g/O Z]g[.B 5/+ +eTe')]g[*. *'[O *'W _ddc+eE jec' dA]W]g/O Z]g[[ 'c+21 +eT'e T21[+eE 1[^1 _'dX'a]c f+e+Tc' .[/'fi]gY `+eO Y'bd1X'[. ^'h','[f T('eVe'['eE 1bT )1\+ec' .[/'fi]gY ^'h','[f T1`[+eB 'O T'Z[ +/+ 'c+21 'e') _ddc+eE jec' dA]O W]g/Z]g[. TT'eX'['eE )]gf+ 'Z[ dA+e Y1 i'[1 0'YE ]g *e' U+dA'[i]c '[.[*U'd h]/]e1T[+e A 'Z2 'W+d[+e T21[+1[B

6

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

5eT\+ed ,e'U

1+,+ei. cd'[)'c]e )]d1 -E ]ge /'h'O a]gY +[ Y'U'f]g X'a')'Z/[+e A +eT['i'O e+eB 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE Y+e T'_]gZd Y]2]e'T. U'[)1bd '[f[]gY - 1e ]gW1[S 'eU'Y'eU+O 2]c 'Z* cd'[)[+e.B [^]ygB 5eT1e[ ]g[1 +eTO \+ed ,e'US Y')[1b'T'[ *'\d A '[,]g)'O T'[ Y/[]2]edB 5eTe1 Y')[1b'T'[ *'\d.B 5eTe1 Y1O `]gT.E ]e1 Y+` Ue'U+W]gT +eT'/ - _ddc]gYE UbT'Z'T'[ Y')[1b'T'[ *'\d - bd+WO 4]gYB 1Z* U,]e Y')[1b'T'[ *'\d. d'e'4O c]gY - d1+,+ei]gYB 1Zb ,e'U. _'\d_'O []gY - Y+, d1+,+ei1f +T]W X'a')'Z/[+e1f A 1eA1 ce' d+W1 ]g[+f]W 'Td1c +eA]gZ/O [+e1 c['b'T'e ',*+f]g/Z]g[1fB 4e'[i +[S 'e+)'T['Z1[ i'Y1[ L21fi'c]ec'4 Y'b[1TO [+e1 '[.[*Y+` 'a'ic]W U]biME 'e+)'TO ['Z1[ (a[T]gY[+e. L+e( '[`'dc]gY - 'Z[O i'[ -[+e)1'E ]ei'[ Y121'e*'c]e `e'4['O Z1[ a]gY(+e1 _'Z/Z]g[1fME A 'eA'_b'T]gY d+W1 ]g[+f]W _'Z/Z]g[[+e.E ]e][f 0'Y'O ['T Y121'e*'c]e d][['[+e]c Y'd+e1' 'ed'[+dc]gY d1+,+eiB *+_ 'e+)'T['O Z1[ (a[T]gY[+e1 A 0'Z/i]gY[+e1 U+dA'[i]c -E ]e Y+[i T'e]W +[i ,Y'Z2c+2 UZ]gb1b'h'ZO 2]cD Y1 )+W+f1T +eA]gZ/E ]e1 0'Y'['T Y/[]O 2]ed1 c+e1[ \+ed]gYS Y')[1b'T'[ (A+a[+O e1f ]^ U+a]gS Y]g/ +eT['T'Y'e]gYE +eA]gY

Magnetosphere: NASA/Steele Hill; earth tilt: Based on NASA/Visible Earth imagery

1e+)'T['Z1[ U'Y'T'e)]gY )d[c]W YZ]gb (['T'[ 'e('[Z'T[+e. 1e+[f UZ]ge.[T'2 Y]O 2]e'T[+e1 U+d U'Y+Y'd'4 'c+21 h]ie +[E i'[ Y+e wU'eA'[]gU1[xS 5eTe1 U+d U'Y+O Y'd'4B 1e*Z]i *' _'d'U'T'[]g/Z]yg[ -B 40c'e /+B

]gb[1 \[]eU1c d+W1 - ]g[+[]gY Y'T.[/'O f]g/Z]g[ A d+W'dc]g/Z]g[E ]e. T+[b'T'[ [\'['T]g/Z]g[ ]g[1 5eTe1 -T]2])1'Z1 U'O Y'eB 1Z[ ['A [_'bd]gY - 5eTe1 'a'[fO i1 T'Z]g[ *1ei1[B 5/+ Y+e wU'eA'[]gU1[x 1*+'2'T'[ ^'h+e ^]g[+['eE 5eT1e Y]2]e'O T. )[*'T1 _+b T_ddc+e d'e(+e T]WY+e1 ce'E 1[^. TU'[)+f[+e T21Y'Z'T'[E b+,]['O Z1[ A 'Z2 h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e1 ]g 'W+d'21 U+O dA'[i[+e1B

5eTe1 '[d+b'[+21 Y')[1b'T'[ ,e'U.

Aurora: Photo: Jan Curtis Lhttp://latitude64photos.comM; meteorite: ESA, NASA

+[ (',Y+e'[) 2]gZb+e1 f]2i+eB 1Zb )+W+O f1T d+b'e'[. Y+, TeT1[ '[)'Y U1\+f[]gY 5eTe1 _'\d_'['T'[ ,e'U1S Y')[1b'T'[ *'\d1 )]Z]g/Z'[ Y'b1[B 5eTe1 Y/[]2]ed.B 'e(+e )',+e1f ('WO T'f'4 +eTe')[*1 'Zb wc+eY'T.x ]^ Y1'Z[ Y+, '_'U]c]gY - '[Ue'0+\d j*]cE 'Z2A 2e'f]gf1^ _'\d_'[]g/Z]g[ - U'[*1b'[]gYB /[]2]ed1 c+e1[ \+ed. Lbde'd]bk+e'M T',Yc'4 - //c'4[1 Y1 d+b'T1fS j,][1fE ]e. T2'[]gY - 1e+)'T1 c['b'T'e ]g2de'O Y'[]g\'T')]gZ[ X'a')'Z/[+e1 == d]T]O b.S _'\d_'[+2]c TZ'[i1 d'e(+e d+b'TO [+e1 )]Z]g/Z]g[.S Y'e*]gf Y1[^A _2'[Td][B +e`1[b '_'U]c]gY - //c'4[1 '[Ue'0+\d i'['T1 Y+4 Y'b.B g\')e'c - ['A 'Z[E ]e bde'd]bk+e'Z]gY j,][1 i'['T]g/Z]g[.

T'Z]g[ ^-D ]ei'[ Y+4'[]gY - ]g2de'Y'[]g\'O T')]gZ[ X'a')'Z/]gY.E 'Z[i'[ 'c+2'[]gY - j,][1 i'['T]g/Z]g[. A U'T'a'T.B e]i ]e j,]['Z1[ \+ed. 1bT'T'[ _'\d_'[]g/O Z]g[ -B 1c+21[E Y/[]2]ed. _'\d_'[]gY - Y+, 'c','U'd1T1f Y1[^A UbT' 0'Za'(+T]e1 ^'h+e ]g[+f]W Y121]['c]e 'b]g_[+e1 'Y+O [jeZ' aY('T]4]g/Z]g[1fB 2'e+('3d'('eE *e'[f Y+4 Y'b. 'Zec]gY - Y/[]2]ed]gY A _'Z4'a 2]gZb - 'eV'T]gYB 4e'[i 'Z[ w.[TO []W 'bdW+e[x +[E ]e][i d+b'[+21 +[ _'e,O

Z]gb1b'h'Z2

T' )1\+e]cB 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE 'Zb ,e'U. ^1 3]^.[*]d]gYE ]e TZ'[i1 U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d X'a')'Z/[+e.S 2]gZb[ ]g `+eY]g/Z]g[.E [+eO /'h'[f+[ +eT1eB /[]2]ed. ['A [_'bO d]gY -E ]e f+e+T. `+eY]g/Z]g[. d'e'4c1 ]W` Y]2]e'T]gYB bT )1\+e. c+eY'T1 _+b 4'4O T]gY - +eT1e.E ]e_+b,1 'Z[ \]gd ^b'a^1B 5eTe1 Y/[]2]ed. A Y')[1b'T'[ *'\d. '[+eA'T'Z+21 U['e'Yd]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i +[E ]e][i 21]c1[ ^+[ ]gb]gY['b1ec+2 Y'eO *]g T]WY1fB 'T'Z[ Y+e Y]2]e'T[ ]g[1 Ab Y1 ,'eY'['21 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[S (['T'[ h]g2+eE ]e][f \[]eU1c +eTe1 ce' _'U_'[O c]gY - TZ'[i.B

/[]2]ed. _'\d_'[]gY - Y+, +eT['i'e+e1f

1e*Z]i _'d'U'T'y[ -E ]e Y+e Y]2]e'T. _'dc'4 - +eT\+ed ,e'U]c

2['T'[ h]g2+e

'dT+e'fe+i Y1 d]g[E ]ed+W ^T' /'eY j*E `e1 Y'O d'T'e'e]gY. *'*'e+fc+2 -E T]Z]gW1[ ^1 '\3'd]gYE 'W([ -2 ^1 /'hc]gYB U'Y'V'Z[c+iE ]e 'Z* d'[[ '_e+2. '[U['e T21[+eB +e Y]2]e'T. ]e]\ 'a]gY]c [Y'[ - 'Zb_1b1 Y1 d'[E ]e. *eb1fS d1+,+ei1fE /'eY j* A Y'i]ge `]ge ^1 bd'[]gY A ]^ -2 1e 'W([ - *]geb U'[]gYB 1Z* *+_i]gY 1[^_+yb - +eT1e. Y'i]ge Y[]gY A \'e]g['T]gY TZ'[i1 U'Y'e ('e+[_'bd _'ZY'[[+e '_'U]c+2B 3'Wd[1i. (['T'[ h]g2+e[ +[E je1['TE `e1E '43'4[1E //c'4[1 A ',]d1 \e`'h]g2+e.B

e1 \e`'_d]gZd.B ]ge. T+[b'T'[ U+W]gT -B ^ Y1 Y'e* Y1 i'[1 je1f 'c+2 ^1 T'e]W '_e+2 'a'[f `e1B e1 \e`'_d]gZd. [_'bd]gY -E ]e 'Y(]W` Y]2]e'T[ ]g[+[' /'eY A Y'i]ge `]geB 1Zb \e`'_d]gZd. d+W1 - ]g[+[]gY +e+i h]g2]cB 5D 1eA1 -[+e)1'[ )]2]e\1'fY'[ _e]f+b1 Y1`]f]c `]ge. ('eVe'f[]gY - Y/[]2]edB 6D 'iec'4 `e1 )]2]e\]g 3d'f]gY. 'a'`'f[]gY - 'Y_+eB 7D 1YO _+e[ 1e+[f U+e/1[ 'a'`'f[]gY +[ '[VeAE T'eO T]gdE VZ]g['3'a[ '[VeA T'Y VZ]g[B 9'hc+2]c +eTe1 Y'T+eA]gZ/1 ce'S `]ge. _'de'bd - []e1f )]2]e\1'['2]g A c+e'*'a['2]g 'Z[d+WE ]ed+O W1f bT1,( - 'a+2B bT ]ei'y[ `]ge - \e`'_d]gZd1 Y+` Yd[]gY 'Y+[ d'e1B '\c'eT[+e1 U'Y'V'Z[S 'Z[i'[E ]e 'c+21 i'[ <> b'[d1Y+de \+ed]c U['O e'c]e 21[+e U'c'b'e'_+b 4'4T+2 +eTe1 Y'T+O eA]gZ/.8B

6

7 5

6

9/c'41[

143'//]g )',

8

5

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

143'4[1 A //c'4[1 \e`'_d]gZd.B [^ 3]biE ]e_+b,1 '_e+[iE Y+[i \[^]gY +[i //c'41[ A 'ed'\[^]gY +[i '43'//]g )',B 121'e*'c]e Y'e*1T A T+[*'[1[+e '[.[*U'd T'd'e]gY +[ 'Zb _e]f+b.B 1Z* *+_i]gY 1[^]yg //c'41[. +eO (+i ^1 b_'ac]gYE A Y/[]2]ed. ^1 2fc]gY '43'//]g )',]cB 'd'b3'[. \'d _'e, -D //c'41[. \e`'['a]g/Z'[ Y+` -B 5D &]d]b1[/+, T]^c]W Ue'\'21 _e]f+b1 0'Y'['T (]gZb+e. T2'O []gY +[ '43'//]g )',E ]e. Y+[i 'ed'\[^]gY +[iE A 'eA1 -[+e)1'Z1 Y1`]f]c 'ed'*e]gY +[ '43'`e+e ]g //c'41[B 6D 5c +e( Y+[i \[^]gY +[i //c'41[E \e`'['a]g/Z]g[. 'Y(]W`'fc]gY -B 1ZbO _1b]cS je)'['T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e1 A //c'4[1 'ed'*e]g/Z]g[. T'd'ec]gY - 'e*Z]g['c+d]O e+[E '['WY]gT A 'a'[f /'h][[+e1B

5eTe1 Y/[]2]ed1 ;< d]T]b. ',]d -

1 2'Td+e1'[+e

%e)'['T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e

3

2 1,]d1 ('W'*e1^[+e

2'Td+e1'[+e

1,]d1 \e`'_d]gZd.B 5eTe1 ce' TZ'[i. T'3c'4 - ['A 'Z[_1b1 je)'['T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[O [+e1fE 1[^_1b1i +[ b_1d'T]gf[+e.B _1d'T]gf1 Y]2+T]g2 'ed'*e+2]g U'Y'e ',]d - '[O Ue'0+\dB 2'e+('3d'('eE Y+e Y/[]2]ed. U'e]gbd - 'Zb )',]cD 'Z[ T',Y]gY - j*1 Y]d'O c]e'_+b ;< d]T]b.B 1D 'Z4'T. A ('Td+e1'[+e. ',]d. c+e'4]gY +[ 'Z[_1b1 ('W'*e1^[+O e1E ]e (]gZb+e. T'e]W +[ T2'[+2B 2D 1Z[]gU+dA (]gZb+e. 'Zb ('W'*e1^[+e1 j)[]g/Z'Y( je)'O ['T'[ Y]2+T]g2[+e +[ _'de'bd]gYB +[*'[1[+e. ',]d bd'[]gY +[ (]gZb+e1fB 3D 5e( (]gZb. T'Y T+[*'[1[ Y'U'[]gY -E ('Td+e1'[+e1 ',*+f]g/Z'[ d'T [e'[f Y'eY1[. i'Zi'Zc]gY -B #dY'[ 'Zb _e]f+b1 \[]eU1c 'ed','dc'4 ',]d. []e1f '[f[]gY - U]W1 A Y/[]2]ed1 Y+`S 'Z*_1b]c 'Y(]W`'f[+2]c \e`'_d]gZd.B

31d'd+3[1T'T'[ 'a'`.[/'f1 U+O dA'[i]c 'Y+[ d'e1 d][['[+e]c /]g['O c]e [Z]g/+e +[ 'ed'*ec]gYE ]e][i U['O e'c]e ^- c+e'Y\'T+2B 1[^*+a ,'eY'['O 21 i1Y1'T'[ _e]f+b[+e1 \[]eU1c Y+e Y]2]O e'T[ 'Y(]W`]g/Z'Y( c+e'Y\'T]gY - 1e (]O 2]e w/'h][[+e.xB +e T'e41i]cS ]ed+W1yf +eTe1[ 'Zb T'e]O W]g/Z]g[.B e][')1d'T'[ '\3'd]g/Z]g[O [+e1 U+W1['T 'Zi2 $]e1[ 'b]gY -D w5/+ 5eTe1 -T]U'Y'T'e). 1bT'_+b 'a'` +T'4 21[+e _'d'U'T'[]e+[E '_' \e`'T' Y1O `'c'Ze1 [Y'[ T'd'eZ'2 [+e*'\['T]g/Z'[ U'b[+2. '[U['e T21[+ex9B 'Y'Y1yd +i [e' +,e'U'[)Y'[.B

Stockbyte/Getty Images

*+'2'T'[ c+e'Y\'T]gY

[^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i 5eT1e Y]2]e'T1 'Zb (]2]e 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e. Y1y/+ [_'d'T'Z1[ )]e4]g[+]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i ^+[B +e. [\c'4 h'bd+e1f ]ye[ - 'Y+['U'Y],1^. V+, U'Y'eB Ë&#x203A; 'Y'Y1yd +i 'Z[ _[*Y'[.E /+ 5eT1e. ]^ Y1 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[ ^]g[1E 'Z[ .[*'Y+[. Y1 c'Ze -E ]ge TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 U+dA'[i]cB Ë&#x203A;

5 41 1

9

5eT1e. 21 - TZ'[i]c ^ ]i ^)1d1E /+ +eTe1 ce' T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e1 1[^i'[ d+b'T[+e )]O Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+[B '\c'eT[+e1 U'Y'O V'Z[S 6 Y121][1f Y1[^A 5>> Y121][ :B bT ]ei'y[ .[*)eT]g[ - Y+e Y]2]e'T.B

]WB 8[*'Y+[. 5>> )e'Y U]W. _'O e]g['T]gY - ('Td+e1'Z1 5> >>> d+O b'TS *+a ^U'\c'4 Y'[e-[+e1 .[*U'O []ge /1c.;B 2'Td+e1'[+e1 ]e]\ d+O b'T[+e )d[c+2 +[ '[)'Y U]W1 Y'T+O e+b1f 7 T12]Y+de 3]e]g/Z'[ ce'<B %*B %*]gY /a^]gY +[ d'e(+e d+b'T1 /a^]g[[+eE ^W`1T[+e A Y1`'d[+eE b'O T'Z[ Y+e Y/[]2]ed. 2fc'4 - ['A 4'WO d]e)+d[Z' ('Td+e1'[+e T'h]\]cE b_]e[+e]cE b+eY['U'd1TO [+e]c A U','e'c]e d+b'T1 Y'[e-[+O e]cB [^_+b [\c]gY - w 'Z+[/1k1i 'Y+e1i.[x U'[*+b]gYE j*1 Y+` wY'[e-O [+e[ 'Z[i'[ (',Y','[ +[E ]ei'[ U]W1 Y+`x=B ]geB %cT1'[]b[+e. 1bT'T'[ 'a+W4O

'WT'h]\1

1[+Y][

c'4 +[D jcT1'[]b1 3]ei. ]gb]gY['b1O e+2]g U'Y'e )1d['T'[[+e. U'X'3 _+di - Y+4 4'3b+e _'U'[`]W d+3O []2])1' j)d')]e4+[B 5[/'*ec]gY -E ]e '[)'Y T]e'2'Z1[ 3]g/+e.E ]e][i U'Y+Y'd'('e 3]ei+e]gY ^+[ A 'c+O 21 2'c +[ ]gb]gY['b1ec+2E ]g[+[ Y121]O ['c]e d+b'T[+eE ]e][i *+a U'Zd[1 ^+[ Y'e*T'[fB

1y/+ TZ'[i1 'Zb ,'eY'['Ue'\ (',O Y','[]g/Z]g[. _'d'U'T'[]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B 'd+e. TU'Y'V'Z[c+[ U[]gY '_e'4 Y1 _]+d1 U+dE ]e. )e+2 -D w ei'z[ \'d +[ i] )]e4+e.E ]Rc 5U]O c'E (]2]e. 1Y'bd]g/Z'Y( +b 'e+2B 5eO T1e. 21 - i] bd+W4')]e4]g/Z]g[[+O e]cx1 L 'WY]b 5>8B68MB 1 1bdc'4'\[^]gY )ec'4 -E ]e 1bd4]g '[]g[. 5U]c' - L 'WY]b <7B5<MB

10

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

Bacteria: Penn State University, laboratory of Jean Brenchley, and with kind permission from Springer Science Business Media: Extremophiles, Novel ultramicrobacterial isolates from a deep Greenland ice core represent a proposed new species, Chryseobacterium greenlandense sp. nov., January 2010, Jennifer Loveland-Curtze; pollen: 5 Fotosearch

yc - ['3')4+2 'a'`1[. +e`1[ d'e1[+e1[ )1d['T'[[+e[ ]g 1[0+[+e[+e. ('a1b (]g[ 1Y'bd]c b]c]e]gY +[ (]gZb+e1f ]g T+[*'[1[+e1f L ]( 56B;E <MB e'[i ]gb]gY['b1e]gY +[ ([]g/Z'[ Y+` 'Y+[ ('[ A TeT[je1['T]gY *e'[f T'a]gfc'4i.S h]eV+2]c bd+W4+2 []e Y+3'[1,Y[+e A ,'e)'f[+2 d+3[1T'[B 31d]g/Z'[ 'Zb XZ]gW. U'Zd[1 (1][1T' '[]g[]cB +dAZ'2 je1['T[+e. i[[+21b U'efe+i 1[i[+e* V+,D w e'T'[]gY ]yc - 'e0'[1 h'ai1 'Zb w['3')4+e1x U'Y'exB

11

]c]e]gY +[ T+d1 2]W'/1'T[+e1f

y[^ T'e]W +[ 1[i['/1a ['3')4]W[+O e. b]c]e+2 b'_'d'c]e T+d1fB 'd ('[B '_'d'c]e T+d. T\a]gY - Y]d 7> d][O ['E 'Z[i'[E ]ei'[ (+a['c]ec'4 (+a['O d'e Y+i+['[B 'eY1[. 'a'V)'T'[ ^-E 1bT 2]W'/1'T[+e. [Y'[ +[ /a^[1 /A+e1B 56 Y+de +eT'e]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 'Zb T+[*'O [1[ `e1 d'T ('c'T'[1[ \'e0]g[ -B +d',]d]W[+e1[ U'dT'_+b '_\+fO []gY -e 'Z[E /+ ]^ 'a'V)'T'[ Y'eY1[ ]gO [+f]W 'Zb 'e'e'4. 1[^_+b - \e`'*'eV T'd'e]gY '[U['e1[ /c'f]W h]ie de'O Y')4]cB e'[i U'Zd['(+e+f1[E ]e )'WdO [1i. 2]W'/1'T[+e1 T'a]gfc'4i1 Y+` -B 4e'[f 'a`A1 Y'b. U'e/ ^-E 1[^_+b 1[iO ['/1a1 /A.E 'Z2 'd'Y['c]e - A [Y'[ *]geb ffc'4 _'2'e[+e1 \'e'[1B 1[^ T+d. X+Wi]gY - `]ge.E 'Z* _'2'eO [+e. Y+4'f[]gY +[ c+e'Y('eV ]g0. A [c'O ,+f[]gY `e1 *1Y'*e]g/Z]g[.B [^_+ybB 1 _'e(+e')e]gY ('f'dec]gY -E ]e _'2'eO [+e1 \[]eU1c `]ge. 'a'[f 3]^.[*]d[+e1 _ddc]gY - 2]W'/1'T[+e1 c+eA1 Y'b]gY []gZ[1bT 'Z[ 0'Y'['TE +e( T+d. ]gWW'V1) *+_1 c+e - b2'[]gY 5>LNatural HistoryMB y[^ j)]gd T'e]W - d'2 'Zb U'Zd[')]eO 4]g/Z]g[.B 5/+ 1[i['/1a1 /A+e. T'a]gfO c+[ [Y'[ VA]cE j*1 U]b'[i1 ]gWW]g/Z]gO [. h]3+2]g U'Y'e 'c+21 i1^ -2+e][[+O e1 LT]W'/+iY'[ W+T+e1M T'Y 'Z2 Y+O 3'[1T'T'[ b'ei+e1 T'e1i T21O [1B 1Zb_1b1 /A+e. 'c+21 U]gO

12

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

b'21 T21[+[E A *e'[i b'ei1[ c1X'T]gY _'U+2. 'c+21 U+\d T21[1B 21]Y+3'[1T'O Z1 Y'b[')+d ][ ][). T'e4]gY -E ]e Y]d '_')'Z]gY wf'[T'f'4 UbT' 1[i['/1a b'_'d'c]e T+d1 2]W'/1'T[+e1 [Y'[ /A+e T]g[+['x55B

eT[je1['T]gY +[ 4]c'Z1[ ]e]e1 /A+e.

1[T'bT'4E 1[i['/1a1 /A+e. 'e*+[ 1bT /a^]g[[+e1 /A+e1 TeT[je1['T[ +[B 'T'Z[ c+e`+eb 1[0+[+e[+e[ 'Zb TeT[je1O ['T]gY. 'Z2 ('eV]g[i1 +[ U'bfe+2B w Z]g b'Z+[/1bdx U'[*+b]gY 'bc]gY -D w&2]O e1*'Z1 U'Y'2b'e'[1 U+d',]d]W[+e. bd+W4+2 +[ U+a'T'a'c'ec]W 1[i['/1O a1 Y]*+2E ]e. 4]c'Z1[ ]e]e1 [Y'[ T'e]W /a^+2E Tde]gT 1`[+2 A 'e')]e+[ c+e ('eVO e'['2x56B ]c'Z1[ ]e]e[+e[ 1e+[f d_'c]e1^ Y'[Z]ce[+e. T'd'e]gY +[S 4'2+2]c /A+e. 'eY]g[T[+e1 A ]gb+e1 U'dc'4]gYB eT[je1['T+2]c /A+e1 'Zb *Z]ge'/+i T'O a]gfc'4i.S Y'b[')+d[+e. bd+W4+2 +[

]c'Z1[ ]e]e. ^1 b'a^]gYE []gZ[1bT +e( T'[)['4 - b'a]gZf1 ce'B +d'iei1e -E 1[^_+yb - [e' Y'eY[1 `+eY]g/Z]g[. _'UO _'[c]gYB 3'Wd[1i. U'T'a'T ]gWW]g/O Z'Y( .[/'f]W U]bi1 `+eY'h]3'['T]g/O Z'[ Y+` -E ]e]c j0dc'4 +[ f]ged \e`'[[+O e]gY '_e]W Y1 \'ei T+[*'[1[+eB y[^ - *' [\'['T]gYB 'dT+e'f[+[i +eT]g `e'd'e 3]W]c'T[+eE ]e][i T_'4 +[ 1e'eB 'i `]ge. U]b]gY - Y1 3]W]c'O T]cE 1bT b'a. `]ge.S YZ]gb]cB 5/+ d'i A b'a. `e+e. []gZ[ ]gWW]g/Z'Y( +[ U]b]gY *+_1 [+eiAE d'i `e1

+eY]g/Z]g[. h]3'[fc]gY A Y[]gY Y'eY[]gY 'a[]g/Z]g[.

Y[]gY - ]di+e1 Y+`

Plane: Kristen Bartlett/University of Florida

1'[]gY +[ 4]c'Z1[ ]e]e1 ]di+e]c

5 Fotosearch

w:5 b'[d1Y+de +eT'e]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 1[iO ['/1a1 Y1 Y]*+2E ]e. h]ie \'e01^1 j)O []g/Z'Y( T'a'c'e]gY - Y1 \'ei Y+d'W+ V]W+eE ]e][i \'e0]gY +[ /A+e.xEP )ec'4 - c+e][\Z'2 _'e(+e')e]gYB Y'bd[]e+[ ['3')4c'4 'Zb /A+e. h]ie 1[i['/1a1[ U['e'c]e]g/Z]g[ +[ d'21b /a^+2 ('eVO e'U'eT \1[]g/Z]g[[+e1 Y1`]c A ]gWW'V1) c'Ze-`i T'd'e+2B ',Y'Qj*'Z1[ ]g0+e. \'U')e)ac'4 +[ bd+W4+2 'Zb_1b1 XT]g[ \'e0]gY[+e T'd'e]W 1[i['/1aE ]e. T'O e]W - Y+4 i'W'i[+e]gY i1Y1'T'[ A T+[O b'('['T'[ ,+[i+e h[de+2B

`+eY]g/Z'[ Y]d T+b[ - h]3'[fc]gY b'a. `e1[B 'T'Z[ +/+ d'i A b'a. `e+e. U]O b]gY +[ U'T'a'T ]gWW]g/Z]g[[+e]cE '_' d'i `e1 )e+/+ ]W` `+eY]g/Z]g[[ - h]O 3'[fc]gY b'a. `e1[B 5e( 4]c'Z1[ ]e]e. T'[)['4 - b'a]gZO f1 ce'E `+eY'h]3'['T]g/Z'[ \[]eU1c *+_1 /'/+e. U]b]W 'eZ]g[. b'a^]gY -E 1bT *+_1 Y'eY1[ c+e'*'eV]W b'a'4 'eO Z]g[. d'i'[]gY -B +eY'h]3'['T]g/Z]gO [. _'U_'[]gY - /a^[1 Y'eY[1 `+eY]g/Z]gO [. A ^1 /]W[]gYE ]e 'Z[ *]geb )' ]di+e1fB 1c1'1[0+[+e 1e/]ge &e'b. 'Zb U['eO i. '[c'[+2 - w'\3'eU1 'Y+[''e*Z]g['O c+d a+)+[+e'd1c `+eY'h]3'['T]g/O Z'[ U'Y'T'e)+e1f Y+T.x57B 9a^[1 ]di.

'Z[i'[ U'[X'e+W T+e_]c - ['3')4c'4E ]e 1[0+[+e[+e. TeT[je1['T+2 +[ 'Z[B

1Zb 'cd]Y+i+['Z1 T'a]gfc'4i. TeT[je1O ['Tc'4 - d]gh1 VA ]g[+f]W VT1f

4+2k1[[+e1 -3]2]T'f1'[ )+e','[f]gY - Y'e*]g TeT[je1['T'4 Y+3'[1,Y.

1 Q1 1bdW'['c]e*]g/Z'[ A d1+,+O e'T'[ d'e'4]g/Z'[ ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z'[ ',)'Z1[ c'e^]g/Z]g[. h]eV]gY - bd+WO 4+2 (',Y]d'[1 a](]dE ]e. Ti'Z21 T'e1X1 [Y'[E 1bT &1[2'[*1'Z]gY 1[0+[+e[+e. 'eO *+[ bd+W4+2 +[ c+f '[1c ]g[+f]W de'TO d]eE ]e. U'W/'U'e]gY - X'['_'eU1 ce' +W'4 'e)+2i[+e.E 1[^_+b '[]gY +[ Y1O `'d[+e.B 1Z2 U+d',]d]W[+e ]gb]gY['b1O e+2]c b]X]g T]['VA _d]gW.S bd+W4+2 +[ 'Z[_1b1 )]e4c'4iE ]e. T',Yc'4 - Y'[e /+h]gT[+e1fB 4e'[i Y'eY[1 `+eY'bd1O X'[1 h]h]3]g/Z'[. ,]g).[/'f ('fc]gY

yc - ([]g/Z'[ b+h'T'['d+e.

T'Y h'Tc]gY +[E 1[^_+b ]e T][[ - ('fO c]gY T'Y h'Tc]gYS U'eY'ec+2]c +W'['O T1 h]h]3]g/Z'[.B 1 .[T+e]g/Z]g[ 'Z[_1O b1 'cd]Y+i+[' - 'ed'*e+2E ]e1 T'a]gfO c'4i. TeT[je1['Tc'4 - d]gh1 VA ]g[+O f]W VT1fB 4e' \[]eU1c .[/'fi1 0'Y'['T j*1 *1Y'*e]g/Z]g[. ,'eY'['21]e+[ [c'O ,]gY -B bT ]ge1\ Y'b[')+d[+e ]gb]gY['O b1e]gY +[ 4]c'T'[`1 Lh'hT'Y]e/M 3+f]g U'ec'4'Y+WY1^ U'dT'[1\[+e.E ]e_+b,1 T'e]W'['[ bd+W4+2 'c+21 /+/A A 'c+21 'Y]ge ,e'UB 2[]g/Z]g[1f 'Z[i'[ \'d Yd'UW'f]gYO [+e +[ h]3'ac+2E ]e U+d',]d]W[+e. U1YO 14

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

[+2 +[ dcZ'2[+e1 Y1 \d+Y'e'[E ]e1 Y+` *'b'c]e+2 +[ 'Z* (',Y'/1c T+[b'('O ['T'[ U'Y'T'e)+e.B w7T][]Y1bdx U'[O *+b]gY 'bc]gY -E ]e )1d['T'[[+e. T'O e]W +[ U+d',]d+2 'Z* dcZ'2[+e.E ]e_+bO ,1 w1e+[f ['3')4c'4 b'ei+e1 U+d T'_O c'4 3[*1e[+e. 2]g4+2]g (['T'[ VA+ex )d[+[B 1Z* \d+Y'e'[]gY .[*)eTc'4 T+[b'('['T'[ U'Y'T'e)+e. U'Zd[1 +[ wT+[b'('['T'[ 'ed][')e+ex '[]g[]cB ]c]e'('e 'ed][')e1 1e'c]g[i. _'dO T'[]gY - 'Z[ '[U'd1[ T'Y .[T+e]g/Z'[.E ]e[ je1['T'[ T+e_]c )e'[f]gY - 1e []e )'W'h'e. T'Y U'Zd[')]e4'4 Y+3'[1,O Y.B gb]gY['b1e+2]c T+[b'('['T'[ 'eO d][')e+e1 'Zb \d+Y'e'[.S w7T][]Y1bdx U'[*+b[ 'b]gY -D w2[]g/Z]g[1f TeT[je1O ['Tc'4 U['ei[+e[ '[c'[+2]c wT+[b'O ('['T'[ 'ed][')e+exS U+d',]d]W[+e. .[*)4]gY +[E ]e 'Z* 'ed][')e+e1 1bT'O T'[ b+h'T'['d+e. ([]g/Z]g[[ -x58B ed+W1yf - ([]g/Z]g[. V+ai (+e+2 'Zb (]2]e Ue'\'21 )'W'h'e[+e.B 'd U+O d',]d]W[+e ([]g/Z]g[1f TeT[je1['Tc'4 U['ei[+e. c+e')e]gY +[ Y121]['c]e d'O e1[+e1 -c]2Z]gf1][ wh]eV+e1[ ]g b3'2[+O e1[xB 'T'Z[ ]ge1\ U+d',]d]W[+e 'Z2 +,O e'U'[)Y'[ +[ )'21bB '[e-'T+[b'('[ 'Zi2 21U1[ w Z]g ]ei 9'ZY,x /+e/1 6>>9 /D h+dec'e1 ;Q1 U'Y'e]gY )e+2 -D w 2[]g/Z'[ Y+`Â&#x20AC; 'Zb [_'d'T'Z1[ ['3'O )4+e. _'e, ]g U'Y],1^ h'bd+e +[D +/+ Y1

Boxfish and carB MercedesOBenz USA

yc - 'e0'[1 h'ai1

31d['T'[[+e. ]gb]gY['b1e]gY +[ 4]c'T'[`1 3+f]g U'ec'4'Y+WY1^ U'dT'[1\[+e.

Gecko footB 5 Fotosearch; hummingbirdB Laurie ExcellNFogstockNage fotostock

('[ [Y'[ - ('*1E i'Z2]gY - ('*1 [Y'[E TaTa]gY - ('*1 [Y'[ A U'T'a'T[ '_'O f]gf+2]g U'Y'e 'Z2 h'bd'eT[+e )]Z]g/O Z]g[ ^]g[+[E '_' (]2]e U1Yi+e[ ]g[+[i +,O e'T'f[+2]gE ]e 'Z* T+[*'[1[ ('* -xB y[^ +,e'T'f]g/Z]g[ - '[]gY ['B w5/+ 'T[O U'Zd -E ]e dcZ'2 ('[. ['3')4c'4 -E ]gO e+Y[ Y+e 'a'` T'[ h'bd+eE ]e][i ^+[i T'e]W '[d+b+2x59B 1Z[ 1[0+[+e.E ]e[ '[cd'[) A ]e'TZ'2 1[i['/1a1 /A - ['3')4]gYE 1[^ 3]biE _'dc1 - 'e0'[1B Y'['_+bE 'Z[ )Z]gO d'e'e.E ]e. bd+W4]gY - 'c+21 U'eY'e'O c+d )]e4c'4i T'Y 'c+21 2'c 'cd]Y+i+O ['E _'dc1 - 'e0'[1 1e ['3')41 U'Y'eB bT 'Z[ Y'e*.E ]e. TeT[je1['T]gY - ]ge1O \1 ['3')14.E b'T'Z[ ^1 .[*]g[]gY A _'dO c1 ^1 'e0'['f[]gY ['3')4]W1[E T'e]W U'Y'ec+2 U'[f')]e4B gbd1 de'Y'('['T'y[ - 'e*Z]iE ]e 'T'['c]e )1d['T'[[+e.E ]e][i 1[0+[+O e'T'[ *0c'e 3[*1e[+e 2]g4+2]g U'Y'e h]eV]gY +[ TeT[je1['T+2 ([]g/Z'[ Y+` )]e4]W U'Y'T'e)+e.E ([je1['T1 U'[X'O e+W ['3')14. c+e')e]gY +[ ('['T'O []g/Z]g[ ^]g[+f]W -c]2Z]gf1'Z1[B 5/+ TeT[jO e1['T+2]g U'Y'e ('['T'[ ['3')4]W _'U'[`c]gYE '_' 1y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 ([jO e1['T. bd+W4+2]g Y'b1[B e'T'[]gY ]yc 'e0'[1 'c+21 Y+4 _'dc1S c'e_+yd.E /+y '\'T+ed.E ]e. _'e,'_+b TeT[je1['T]gY - [e' ['3')14.B

3+TT][. Y')2f]gY _'d+e1 ce'Z]c A T_^]gY - f'[T'f'4 Y'T+e+b1S j)d')]e4+O 2]c Y]2+T]g2'Z1[ ]g0+e

e'Y'('['T'[ +,e'U'[)]gY

1Z]RE T'[ \'d h'bd+eE ]e][i cT'Z]gY +[E ]e ([]g/Z]g[. ('['T'[ '3')4]W - ]g[+f+2B '[]/'['2]c 'Z* h'bd+e1[S \'d+e. ]g[+[]gY +[ 'Z[ ,)'f]gY[+e.E ]e ]g[+f'c 1bdc'4'\[^1 )e]W[+e1f Y+T.S ]W]b.D w 1bd4]gÂ&#x20AC; '[d+b'[+21 U'dT]g/O Z]g[[+e.E 'Zb1[i[S [e' U'c+e0'T'[ ,]O e]g/Z]g[[ ]g 'bdc'4]g/Z]g[.E Ubd'T +O eA]gY +[ '\3'eU1 'e'e]gY1f 1 c+eE ]e]cO U+dA *e'[i d+b[c]gY +[ bd+W4c'4 ('[+O e1 Y1`]f]cx L a]Y+'f1[+e 5B5=E 6>MB

[^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i e'Y'('['T'y[ 'e*Z]i U'c'd'2E ]e ([]g/Z'[ 1[0+[+e'T'[ Ue'\'21 ['3')4+e[ 1 U'Zd +[ +T+2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[B Ë&#x203A; [^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i 'Z[ _[*Y'[.E ]e1 U'Y'V'Z[S .[*'Y+[. /c]gY -E /+ TZ'[i.

'3')4]W - ]g[+f+2B Ë&#x203A;

y 7 1 13 5 1 1 8

15

1e*Z]i _'d'U'T'[]g/Z]yg[ 5/+ TeT[je1['T. U+W1['T ]g[1E 'Z* *+_i]gY 1y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 ([je1['T1 Y'b1[B

'[e'/+2+e

Ë&#x203A; eT[je1['TB +c2'e. Y'e*]g T]WY1f bd+W4c'4 T'e4e Y'[e'/+2 -E ]e. j)O d')]e4c]gY -E je1['TE ,e'U'('XT][O [+e _'de'bd+2]g U'Y'eB +c2'e 'eO d'*e+2]g U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d +[ /]g['O c]e 2]g41^[+e A ('eVe `+eY'bd1X'[B Ë&#x203A; 2[je1['TB 1e'[+Z*'Z+ .[d'[1i1[ _'dT'[]W b'e*+e. LAraneidaeM 'ed'*O e]gY +[ Z]/ d+b'T1 ]bd'Z['/+2E T'YS Y+d'ibB 4e'[f1f 'Y+['_1[*. ('Y('O T1f /+/A -E b'T'Z[ 'c+21 _1[* -E i'[ []gZ[ U'bd]g/Z'[ _]W_'d'2'e. A 'c+21 T'e4e -E i'[ +c2'e.B %e1['TS +/+ Y'e*. T'e]W'['e 5 b'[d1Y+de U'bO d]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W Y+d'ib'/+2]c )]e4+2 k]gd(]21 *'\d1 ^'h Y1 f'[fE ]e1 /+2+e.

1e'e1f U+a]g +[ 8 b'[d1Y+de]cE '_' 'Z[ TT'[)[+f[+e UbT' j*'['c. /a1^i1 .[/'fi]gYB 'e*+e. 'Z* ]bd'Z['/+2.

T'e]W +[ 'ed'*e+2 b+[Z'T'Z1[ `+eY'bO d1X'[]gYS ]e_+b 2]g41^ j)d')]e4+2]c `]ge.B T'e]gY _'dT+ec'4 -E /+ 1[^_+b - ]bd'Z['/+2 'ed'*ec]gY LY'[e'*1d'T'Z1[ _'dT+eM

Copyright Dennis Kunkel MicroscopyE IncD

16

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

+W]e]\Y'[ U'Y'T'e)

Ë&#x203A; eT[je1['TB e]\ 'c1']gW1[+e 1[i['/1a[+O e]gY j)d')]e4]gY +[ 'cd]_12]d1 'Z[_1b1 U'O Y'T'e)E ]e. ]^ Y1'Z[ W+T'c'e]gY - j*'['c. Y1 +eTO e1f YZ]gb.E 'Z2 ['A c'Ze - 1`+f[]gY 'Z[B 1Zb_1b1 Y1 U'Y'T'e)E ]e. *+a h]eV'eTY'[ h]g2]gY -E 1[0+[+eO [+e. d+W'c]e+2 +[ Y]d'c]e'_+b c'eT'i'ed1 ^'h ]g[+f]W Y1 U'Y'T'e)^]gYB Ë&#x203A; 2[je1['TB g[+['2]c )e^1 4'Ze1 ^'h h]ie ]gW+WS Y]['e3 /1/+a. LDanaus plexippusM '['*'Z1f T'O e]W - /a^+2 Y1[^A 7 >>> T12]Y+de U+a'c]e]g/Z'[ ce' )d[c]W +ib1T'Z1 h]ie '[d'a[+e1f Y+T.B 91/+a[ 1e wU]gZb.x *[]gY - 'eA1 ce'E ]e[ j)[]gY - [e'[ X'['O _'eU]e*+21bB 6'eY'['Ue'\ 'Zb Y1`'d1 d+W]e]\O Y'[ U'Y'T'e). U'\c1 - 'a[]gY ['A jec' .[/'fi]gY 'eA1 *1ei1 h]h]3]g/Z]g[. +eT[i]gYB

b_[Z'T

Ë&#x203A; eT[je1['TB [0+[+e[+e. bd+W4+2 +[ 'eU+bd'T'[ Y1 ('e* '^iE ]e[ ]g[1 < 9>> ]b_[Z'T[+eE ]e][i T'e+21 - d+W'c]e+2 )[*'b+W1 )231T1 ^'h1f ]^ Y+4 Y'T+e+b1 ce'B 1Zb_1b1 ]b_[Z'T[+e. T'e]W +[ j)d'O )]e4c+2 Y+4 'e')]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W *+d+Td]eO [+e A ]g2de'('e'TE (',Y'T]WY'[1 '_'e'd[+e bd+W4+2]g U'Y'eB Ë&#x203A; 2[je1['TB _]ga1 '^i. T',Yc'4 - 7> >>> _'e, '^1T[+e1fS ]b_[Z'T[+e1fB 1Z[ _'dT+e[+e.E ]e d+bO []gY - '^1T[+e1f Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge.E Y1'c]ec]gY +[ A bd+W4]gY Y1 .[*'eV'T 3X'[T'eE ]e1 \[]eU1c Y1`'d.

U1'['21 T+e_]c [T'd]gY - f'[T'f'4 \'e0]gYB

y 7 1 13 5 1 1 8

17

7c]2Z]gf1' c'eT'4[+e A h'bd+e

w7c]2Z]gf1'[ 'Z[i'[]c - h'bdE ]ei'[]c ]e 'eA1 `+eY]g/Z]g[.xEP 'b]gY - _e]k+b]e 1^'e* 4]i1[b.S -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[ U'Zd[1 )1d['T'[[+e1f Y+T.5:B [^ 3]biE h]eV+e. A ]gWW'T1 *1d]gY[+e. '_'f]gf]gY +[E ]e 'eA. `+eY]g/Z'[ Y+4 'W(Z]ge -B 2'Zf 'e*Z]yi h]eV+e[ ]g ]gWW'T1 *1d]gY[+e. '_'f]gf]gY +[E ]e -c]2Z]gf1][ ]gbY]g[i. []gZ[_+b '[U+ei+21 h'bd -B

'e2, 4'ec1[.

A [e' )1ei.S w +b'T[+e1 4')]gY.x

1e+[f ['3[1[+e. 1B e]\ )1d['T'[[+e 'Z* h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e[ '[c'[]gY +[ Y1TO e]-c]2Z]gf1'B 7c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[ T]WY['T1f[+e[ 'b]gY +[E ]e 'Z* '[[\'[ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+O e. Y121'e*'c]e d'e1[+e1 .[/'fi]gY T]gO d'Tc+2 +[ A *'eV+2 Y+4 h]h]3]g/Z]g[O [+e1 _'dX'aB 1Zb_+b V]gT. c+e'4c+2 +eTT+[f'W1E 1bT T'_1T.S Y'e*]gB 1Z* +[O /'*eZ'2 Y+4 h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e[ '[c'[]gY +[ Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1'B 'e2, 4'ec1[.E je1['TE b]c]e+f[]gY -eE ]e Y+, U'Y'e d+b'[+21 h]ie h]h]O 1 +2+Tf1][+e[+e1 T]WY1f \[+e1 ce' T'd'ec'4 h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e. ]e]\ )+[+e1 k]g[Tf1'Z1 3'[O )'eY'[ 'e*Z]g[i +[B %e1['TS d'ib' d+b'T1 \'[ h]ie ^'h. _'ZY'['c]ec'4 - [e'[]cE ]e TaX1T. []eY'2 ^1 ,'e)'[]gYE 1[^. A 'a'` - (+e]gY )'X'O X]g/Z]g[B

Darwin: From the book Origin of Species, 1902; book: AbeBooks.com

'3i'[ 'Zb U'ef1[ _'d'b3'[+2.

U'eT'c]e - _'e,+2 1e]W]g/Z]g[.B 'd )1d['T'[[+e [\]gY +[E ]e 0'Y'['T1 .[O /'fi]gY T+[*'[1 'e'e'4[+e1 b+e]g[*O [+e. T'e]W +[ ]e]\'T1 h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+O e1 +[/'eTc+2B %e1['TS Y'e*1T T'e]W +[ .[de]W'('e \[+e1[ 'Z[_+b ,]g)'c]e+2E ]e 1 c+e`] *e'[f b+e]g[*[+e. 'c+21 T'eX ]di+e A 'c+21 +eT'e Y',+e ]g[+['[E i'[

3]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e +W+2 +[ ['A Y+4 h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+eE /+A *' ]^ ]i ^1 d+b+25;B ' 'b]gY -eS 0'Y'['T1 .[/'fO i]gY 'Zb ['3['T'[ T'Y 'Zb_+b T]^c'4 TZ'[i1 _'e, VA+e. w^'h','[f '[[\'[ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e1x \[]eU1c 'bd1X'['O ('e h]3'T+e_c+2 +[ TZ'[i1 Y121]['c]e ('e* VA+e15<B 1Zb _[*]gY. \'d+e1[ - de'Y'('['O T'[ /c]gYB e'[i Yd'4]gY +[ 'Zb_+bD w5/+ d+b'T[+e1 [+eb]gY h]ie h]h]3]g/O Z]g[[+e T'e]W +[ d+W1 ]g[+['2E ]ge+Y[ +eO T'e d'e1[+e1 .[/'fi]gY -c]2Z]gf1'[ T'O e]W -e Y+4 h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e 'a'` (+e+2xB e'T'[]gY -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. U1Y[.O c'4 - +e+i c'eT'4[+e1 ce'B $[[+[i 'Z* c'eT'4[+e.B 'eT'4 5D ]gd'f1'[+e. '[Ue'0+\d U]gYi +[ []e d+b'T[+e1 'a'`'fY'[ U'Y'eB e'T'[]gY Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1][ ]gbY]g[i. U1Y[c'4 - 'Z[ ('[1 ce'E ]e Y]gd'f1'[+e.S (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 )+[+e1 '[[\'[ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e.E T'e]W +[ 'a'` (+e+2 ]^ Y1'Z[ []e d+b'T[+eE 'Z2A (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 (]2]e]c1[ []e .[d'[1i[+e 5=B #'bd+eB 2]gZb1 T'Y T+[*'[]g je)'O [1,Y1 T'a]gfc'4i. ]e]\c]gY - )+[+d1O T'T'[ T]*]gY _'e]g['Tc]W (',Y'/1c d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e]cB cZ'2[+e1 'Z* (','[ )d[c]gY - Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge (``1 T]e1,]gY 1B +d',]d]W[+e. U'Zd['(+e+2 +[E ]e Y]gO d'f1'[+e.E h]3+2]c ]e]\ dcZ'2[+eE h]O h]3]g/Z]g[[+e Ydf[+2 (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1O [+e1 b+e]g[*[+e1 Y+`B 2'Zf Y1y/+ *e'[i T'e]W +[ 'a'` (+e+2 (]2]e]c1[ []e d+O b'T[+eB y[^ +[ ('f'U'Zd+2 )+[+d1T'O Z1 ([')'c'a]gY 5>> d'ec' ]gb]gY['b1O e]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i[+e.B 5=7>Q'T'[[+e1 c+e`1[ )1d['T'[[+e. ])A]e]g/Z'Y( .[*]g[+f1[ 'Z[ Y1di.E ]e (['T'[ .[de]g/Z'[ LY1 _e]f+bE ]e1 U+O dA'[i]c )]Z'dA]gY A 1e+[f1f U+d] b+O e]g[* +[ /]W[]gY 'a'c+2'_+b dcZ'2 _'ZO Y'[[+e]gY j)d'T'e 0'a'[)'T'[ h]O h]3]g/Z]g[[+e ]g[+f]W 'a'[V[Z'T[+e.M 'e*Z]g[i]gY Y]gd'f1'[+e1f T'e]W +[ 'a'`'['2 (]gZb+e1 []e d+b'T[+eB +O

dA'('e [e'[i +,e'T'fe1[E ]e 'eU+bO d'T'[ T'Y Y'e*]g T]WY1f c+e'UbTc]W Y]gd'f1'[+e1 .[de]g/Z]g[. _+di - ]e 'c+21 'e*Z]g['c+d 21[1B w8[*U'[]ge 'aO Y'Y( T+[b'('[[+e. A U'dT'_+b )+[+O d1T[+e[ ]g b+2+Tf1][+e[+e. Y+4 ]ge'3]g/O Z]g[ -1[ '_e]gYxEP 'b]gY - ]g2k 7TT+O U'e* Z][1).S 3+eY'[1'Z]gY (]gZb+e1 b+O 2+Tf1][ U+d',]dY'[ )4]c 'ib #2'[T 1[bd1d]gd1 )1d['T'[[+e1f Y+T.1B ye[ -e 'Z* ]ge'3]g/Z'[ _'dX'a.B Z][1).E ]e. Y]d 7> d'e1 ]gb]gY['b1e+2 - (]gZO b+e1 Y]gd'f1'[+e.E 'b]gY -D w1Zb U+O d',]d]W[+e. T'e4]gY -1[E ]e +T+2 - 0'O Y'['T. h]3+2]g (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+O e1 b+2+Tf1'Z1 'c'[*'T'[ Y+/]*[+e.B e'[i T'e4]gY -1[E ]e .[de]W'('e Y]gO d'f1'[+e T'd'e+2. T'e]W - [_'bd+2 (]gZb+e1 ]g T+[*'[1[+e1 []e A 'c+21 2'c d+b'T[+e1 'a'`'fY'[.x6>B e'T'[]gY 1 Z][1). U'c'd]gY -E ]e TZ'[i. bd+W4')]eO 4]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B 1Zb U]*c'4]gY Y+`(+ec'4 [e' '[V['T'[ T'e41i. A ^1 [+eT'Z'fc]gY (]gZb+O e1 b+2+Tf1][ U+d',]dY'[ )4]c 'ib #2'[T 1[bO d1d]gd1 d+b'T+d.B

dW'X'[X1T1 Y]gd'[d[+e. /+A /+e,'e)'f'4 +[E 'Z[]g'Y+['Z[1c _dW'X'[X1T +[ ]gd'f1'[ T'e]W - b'UY'['h'T h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e 'a'`'f[+2 (]gZb+e1 Y+`E 1[^_+b je1['TS Y+4 4'W1T[+e ]g[+f]W 'Zb Y]gd'[d.

]eY'2

1 +d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e (``1 f1O d]_2',Y'[E /'W'[/. A je)'[]1*[+e. []gZ[_+b Y+4 *+e +[ 3'W]gY je)'[1,Y1 VA'c]eY'[ Y+`B

7 "! 1D 1 1 5

5 #1 5

19

]eY'2

]Y'[i U]gZb ]g[+1[ (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'TO [+e 'a'` (+e+2B 1'fZ'2 'U'[)[+e1E 1b1'Z1 ]g 5ce]O _'Z1 )1d['T'[[+e. bTb+f1[ 1e'T'['fO [+2 UbT'Z'T'[ k1['[b'T'[ [+e*e]gYO [+e _'U'[`]W U+d',]d'T'[ 4e'O )e+eS T1e'a+2]c Y+/]*[+eE ]e][i 3]bd'O []gY -1[ 'e')'f[+2 (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+O e1 -c]2Z]gf1'[B [^_1b1y[ +W'[ 'e*Z]g[iO [+e. 'c+21 i'[ 8> d'ec' 2'ec'4 '\O 3'd'[i[+e1f U+d]B +[b'('['T'[ )1O d]g/Z]g[[+e1 _e]k+b]e 1d+e 6+[)(]gO \. 'b]gY -D w ['Z'4 k1['[b'T'[ 'Ua+O 21 4'3b+e1[S X'a')'Z/Y'[ Y1`]f]c Y]gO d'f1'[+e 'a'` (+e+2]g U'Y'e 'c+21 'e*Z]g['c+d d+b'T[+e bd+W4+2]g h]eV+O e. V'3]Wc+f1[x65B bT )1d['T'[ Z][1O ). 'c+2'f[]gY -D w5=<>Q'T'[[+e1[ )1dO ['T'[[+e1 U]gZb+e. Uj*b f[*+f1[E 1bT Y+4 ]ge'3]g/Z]g[. Y'e+fB e_+b U+d',]O d]g/Z'[ 'a'[V1[ XZ]gWS 1eAYdZ'[ +eT.eO [+e]gY Y]gd'f1'[+e T'd'e+2. *'*'e+fO c+fB 3e+/+ (]2]e Y]gd'[d[+e.DDDD Y'U'O f'[E T'Y 'c+21 /]gZ2 -1[E i'[ *e'[f c'ZO e1 d+b'T[+e.x1B ]gZ[1bT 'Z* *+_i]gY .[*U'[]ge 'aO Y'Y( 5>> d'ec' .[/'fi]gY T'd'ec'4 Y]gd'f1][ U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e1 A Y'b['O c]e'_+b ;> d'ec' (]gZb+e1 ]g T+[*'O [1[+e1 Y]gd'f1'[+e1 dcZ'2[+e. )1dO ['T'[[+e1[ U['e'c]e]g/Z]g[ +[ d'21b +,e'T'f]g/Z]g[[+e '[+2 []e d+b'T[+e 'a'` (+e+2]g Y]gd'f1'[+e1 T'e]W]g/Z'[ c+e'(+eZ'2B #'bd+e. i[[+2]gf U+d] Z]O [1). +,e'T'f[]gY -D w ]gd'f1'[+e. ^+[ T'e]W (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 bT,(['O T'[ d+b'T[+e. c+e'h]3+2 21]c1[ []e d+b'T[+e1B 1Zb +,e'T'f]g/Z]g[. U'Y'O _'d'b3'[]gY - Y]gd'f1'Z1 ([')'c'O a]gY 6>Qe* *'e]gY T'd'ec'4 (]2]e h]eO V+e1[ A bd'fc'4 'e*Z]g[i[+e1[E 1[^_+b ['A U'c'['T'[]g/Z'[ je+[i[+e1[xB 1 ]gd'f1'[+e T'd'e+2]g (',Y'/1c h]eV+e. f]gZf dc+f1[E ]e []e Y]gd'[d[+e bd'['2]g U'c'O ['T'[]g/Z]g[. 'bd1X'['('e [c',]gY -E 1bT 'eO *+[ )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W Y]gd'[d[+e. 'c+21 U'X'3 'a'` +[ (+e]gY 1e+[f [Y'[ d+b'T[+eB 2'f1 'Z*E (]gZb+e1 Y]gd'f1'[+e1 Y+T d]T]b1f i1^[ - +[/'O T' U+d')' U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e1E A 'Zb 3Y(1f -2 )e+/+ Y+T d]T]b[ - U'eY'e T]Y+ef1][ )]e4'4]g/O Z'[ U'Y'eB 'T'Z[ +e(+i (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'TO [+e ^bd+W4c+f1[B bT T+[*'[1[+e1 Y]gd'f1'[+e1 'e*Z]g[i[+e. \'d 'c+21 c'd[ -1[E i'[ (]gZb+e1O [.E A 'Z* Y+/]*. 'Z2Ab ^T1e'ac+fB

20

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

#'bd]e+[E T'e]yW +[ Y1 d+b'T1 Y]gO d'f1'[+e. c+e'h]3c+2 A *'a['2 (]2]O e]c1[ []e d+b'TB 'd'b3'[[ 'T[U'Zd -B Z][1)1 T'd'e'4 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[O [+e. YW+f1[ [e'[ +,e'T'f[+2]gE ]e wd'eO (+e )+[]d1_ ]g[+f]W d+b'T[+e. 1e'O e1f b'UY'[','dc'4 +[E A Y]gd'f1'[+O e. ^+[ T'e]W ]^[^'f[+2 T'Y 3'3d+2 'Z* b'UY'[[+e.x66B g\'*e]g/Z]g[ *'eVe+i c+e]U1\Z'2 h'bd+e1[B 5/+ ('eVe'bd1X'[ )1d['O T'[[+e. ^+[ T'e]W []e d+b'T[+e 'a'` (+e+2 'eU+bd'T'[]e+[E 'Zb1[i[S 1e+[f .[de]g/Z'Y( Y]gd'f1'[+e T'd'e+2]cE 'e*Z]i U['e'c]ye -eE ]e ]^ ('['T'[ +O eA]gZ/.S -c]2Z]gf1'[E 1[i[1[ []e d+b'TO [+e 'a'` (+e1B 5/+ U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e Y]gd'f1'[+e. ^+[ T'O e]W (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 bT,(['T'[ d+b'T[+e. c+e'4+2 (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'TO [+e1E '_' 1[^_+yb T'e]W -e Y'Te]-c]2O Z]gf1' d+W1 ]g[+f'4 21[+2B 'eT'4 6D 2['T'[ .[de]g/Z]g[. []e d+b'T[+e - 'a'`'fe+2B 4'ec1[. U'c'O d]gY -eE ]e (['T'[ .[de]g/Z'[ \[]eU1c )]Z'dA]gY -1[ TZ'[i1 'Z[ VA+e.E ]e][i U'eY'ec]gY -1[ Y1`'c'Ze1 _'ZY'[[+e1[E Y1[^*+a T+[b'_'ZY'[[+e1[ ^U'eY'eO c]W VA+e. 1 c+e`] Y'U'[]gY -1[B 7c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e. b]c]e+f[]gY +[E ]e +e( d+b'T[+e. d'e'4c+f1[ A Y+T]gb'O f'[E b+2+Tf1'[ .[de+f 'Z[ d+b'T[+e.E ]e][i 1e+[f )+[+e]gY +W'4 h]h]3]g/Z]g[O [+e1 \[]eU1c 'c+21 2'c -1[ U'eY'ec+2 []e Y1`'c'Ze1[B +dA'('e -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+O e. _[*]gY +[E ]e 'Zb Y+T]gb'f'4 3Y(+e[ 1 c+e`] c+e'4c+2 +[ (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'TO [+e1B #'bd+eB [^_+b [\c+fE U+d',]d]g/O Z]g[[+e. _'e, f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e Y]gd'O f1'[+e. ^+[ T'e]W 'a'` (+e+2 (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'T[+eB 1ZO []g'Y+['Z[1cE 1y[^ h'bd+e1 U1Y'[ ce' +[ -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e. _[*]gYE ]e (['O T'[ b+2+Tf1'[ .[de]gY - 'Z[_1b1 Y]gd'O f1'[+eE ]e][i []e d+b'T[+e +[ 'a'` (+O e]gYB 5=== /DQ1[ 1'fZ'2 'U'[)[+e1 31d]g/Z]g[[+e1 ',)'Z1[ 'T'*+Y1'Z1 L311M Ue'd'e'T'4 )ei]gZT[+e1f Y+O T]gY 'bc]gY -eE ]e 'Z* _[*]gY. U1Y[c'4 - wb+e1[]b[+e1 57 d+b'T[+e1 ]gb]gY['O b1e]g/Z'[ ce'E ]e. 4'ec1[. T'd'e+2 -

'c')]gZ[ *+_i]gY 4'ec1[1 b+e1[]b[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e d+b'T[+e. T'e]W +[ U'eY'ec+2 h]h]3c]W T21Y'Z1[

['A [T'd+f1[E ]e b+e1[]b[+e1 d'e(+e wd+b'T[+ex ,]g)'c]ec]gY -1[ A 'a'` (+O e]gY 'Z[_1b1 b+e]g[*[+eE ]e][i 'c+21 2'c -1[ U'eY'ec]gY Y1`'c'Ze1[E i'[ [e'[f 4[]W[+e.B gbd1 U+d',]d]W[+e. +,e'O T'fe1[E ]e +/+ 'Z* 3'^'b+e]gY. \'e]gO ['Tc1E '_' 'e*Z]g[i]gY b+e1[]b[+e1 +eO T]g wd+b'T[+e.x Tc+e'4c+[ Y+T d+b'O T1 69B ei'[]yc - de'Y'('['T'[ +[/'*O e+2E ]e (['T'[ .[de]g/Z]g[. 'a'` - (+O e]gY (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'T[+eB 'b['YZ'TO [+e 'a'` -c]2Z]gf1][1bdQT+[b'('[ ]e` $e1bd]k+e 12Z'Yb. T'bT'41 d'T *e+f 'Z[ d+b'T+d.E ]e (['T'[ .[de]g/Z]gO [. []e d+b'T[+e 'a'`'f[+2]g ,]e]g/O Z]g[ ]g[1 6:B 7c]2Z]gf1][1bd +ke1 c'eO f. 5=== /DQ1[ )e+fE ]e (['T'[ .[de]g/Z]gO [. j)[]gY - d+b'T[+e1[ U'eY'ec+2]g h]O h]3c]W _'ZY'[[+e1[E b'T'Z[ ]eA- []e ('[ ^1 bd+W4]gY 6;B e'T'[]gY 4'ec1[1 b+e1[]b[+e. w[]e ('[x ^+[ *'a[]gYB e'[i Y[]gY +[ b+e1O []b[+eB 5c 'Z[ h'bd.E ]e [e'[f d'eO (+e d+b'T[+e. 3'^'b+ec]gY +[E T'bT'O 41 d'T - *[]gY 'Z[ ^'h'[1\[+e.E ]e][O f]c ]e]\ -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e b'UY'[]gY +[ d+b'T[+e.B 1c+21[E 'Zb /a^]g[[+e1 Y'b1[ d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e. ('f'U'Zd]gY +[E ]e []gZ[1bT U+W1['T'c]e )1d'T'[

7 "! 1D 1 1 5

5 #1 5

21

Beak drawings: From the book Journal of Researches, by Charles Darwin L1873M, image courtesy Biodiversity Heritage Library

3'2'_')]b TW,1[+e]gYB 1Z* /a^]g[[+e[ 'Z0Y U'Zd[1 +[ 4'ec1[1 b+e1[]b[+e '[O c'[]gY]cx67B 5=;>Q'T'[[+e1[ Y1 3]gY( U+d',]d]WO [+e 1d+e A ],Y'e1 3e'[d[+e1 )23'O c]e]g/Z'Y( bTb+f1[ ]gb]gY['b1e+2 'Z* b+O e1[]b[+e1[ A U'Zd['(+e+f1[E ]e Y+T d'eO c' +e'\d1f U+d] 'Z[ b+e1[]b[+e.E ]e][i U'Y+Y'd'('e Y+4 Td]gf[+e +[ ]gO [+f+2E 'c+21 U+\d]g/Z'Y( +[ c+e'_e+2E i'[ h]ie Td]gf ]g[+f]W[+e.B 1Zb U'Zd['O )]e4]g/Z]g[. Y+4 [\'['T]g/Z]g[ ]g[+O f'cE i'[1 ]e Td]gf[+e1 ^'h[ ]g VA. b+O e1[]b[+e1 57 d+b'T[+e. ]e]\+2]g U1Y['O T'[ T+e_+e1f +[B 311Q1 )ei]gZT]gY 'bO c]gY -D w3e'[d[+e. +,e'T'fe1[E ]e +/+ Y]d'c]e'_+b 5> d'e1[ Y+T 'Z* TW,1[+O e]gY +e'\d d+W1 ]g[+['E '_' .[*'Y+[.

6>> d'e1 U+d] b+e1[]b[+e1 []e d+b'TO [+e T'e]W +[ 'a'`'['2x68B 'T'Z[ 31d]g/Z]g[[+e1 ',)'Z1[ 'T'O *+Y1'Z1 )ei]gZT]gY ^1 U1\'d'Tc]gY 'Z[ h'bd.E ]e +e'\d1[ U'`]e*]W d'e1[+O e1[ h]ie Td]gf ]g[+f]W b+e1[]b[+e1 /1c.

TeT1[ )+e'T\a+f Y+4 Td]gf ]g[+f]W[+O e1 /c1[B +d',]d]W[+e. _'e,+f1[E ]e TW,]gY +W'['T'Z1[ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e1[ ,]g).[/'f Y1 d'e1 )+e'T\a]gY +[ +eT'e Td]gf ]g[+f]W b+e1[]b[+e.E 1bT U'`]e* d'e1S h]ie Td]gf ]g[+f]W[+e.B e'[i

'T'*+Y1'[+e. h'bd+e. [+eT'Z'f[]gY +[ T'[3'T'2 VA]cB 'eT'4 7D 2e'4][+e. '_'f]gf]gY +[ Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1][ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e.B +e. [\c'4 311Q1 )ei]gZT. .[/+ef]W1 Y+` 'Z[_1b1 d_'c]e]g/Z]g[ - bd+W4]gYE /+ )1d['T'[[+e1 U'Zd['(+e'4 (e'4]O [+e. ('c'e'e +[ h'bd+2]g Y'Te]-c]2Z]gO f1'[B 3ei]gZT]gY [\c]gY -D w1Z[i'[ \'d (e'4] '[f]W1T VA+e +[ U'Zd['(+ec+2 VT[+e1 A +eTT+[f'W[+e1E +eTT+[f'W[+O e1 A b]W]g[[+e1E b]W]g[[+e1 A T'/['b]g[O [+e1 ]g _e1Y'd[+e1 b+e]g[*[+e1 Y1`AE ]e U'X'3 *0c'e - ]e]\+2E /+ T][Te+d +e( '[f]gY d+W1 ]g[+f+2 Y1 d+b'T1f YZ]gb.x6<B #'bd+eB 1Zb 1[i['cbd'U U'Zd'e'O e]g/Z]g[. ,'eY'[i - 'a'`'f[]gYB [^]ygB 7c]2Z]gf1][1bd 12, 72*e1`. 'b]gY -E ]e (e'4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. f]gZf - d'O 21bE ]e h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e ^+[ wT]gd'Tc+2xE

2e'4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. f]gZf dc+2E ]e T+[*'[1[+e1 (]2]e Y+4 3Y(+e[ 'a'`'f+2 +[ Y1'0'Y'['T A Y['f+2 +[ )e+/+ '[h]h]3

7c]2Z]gf1'[ .[*]g[+2]g U'Y'e wU'c'dx - '[Ue'0+\d

[^]yg +[ \'d U'Zd[1 -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e _[*]gYE ]e Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1'[ h'bd -B +O 1 1[)'Y (e'4][+e1 Y1 i'[1 je1['T[+eE ]e][i U+d',]d]W[+e. U'Y'e]gY +[ -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 '_'O f]gZfE c1X'U'e]gZf U'ef +[ *'eV+2B +Rb w Z'[O i1 4')]gY.D U1[) U'efE ]e 'e0+ i[[+2x )ei]gZT. L-` 66Q6=MB e'd'e'Tc+2 - 5U]c'Z1 cT'[+e1 T]WO Y1fB

22

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

1 'd+e1'21,Y. 'Zbd+W c+e'(+e]gY - 'Z[ d+O b]g/Z'[.E .bd ]e1S d1+,+ei]gY 'Y+[ 1[^E [+e'aZ'2 TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. 'a'`'f+2 +[ 'a'[f ]eA)+e(['T'[ Y1`'Yd]g/Z'[B

Ë&#x153; 5 Juan Carlos Mu nozNage fotostockE and courtesy of Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology

'Z2 +eT'e 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4]gY w\'d d+b'T[+e Te+2 +[ i1^ -c]2Z]gf1][ h]h]O 3]g/Z]g[[+e T'Y [e'[f Y+` .[*U'[e'_+b ]^1[^ ^1 h]3c+2x16=B 1[^ jeb '\3'eU1 )1d['T'[[+e.

U'Zd['(+e+2 A )e'[f+2 +[ Y]d 6>> Y121][ Y+4 (e'4][+e A Y121'e*'c]e h]ie (e'O 4][+eB 'd U+d',]d]W[+e U'Y'V'Z[ +[E ]e 'Zb Y+4 A Y'[e'Y'b[ d'e+)e]g/Z]g[. f]gZf - d'21bE ]e T+[*'[1[+e1 (]2]e Y+4 3Y(+e. U'Zd[c+2 +[ Y1'0'Y'['T A Y['O f+2 +[ )e+/+ '[h]h]3E 1bT \'d d+b'TO [+e '[U+d'f+2 +[ 'Z[i'[ U'[T'e4'T1E ]ei'[ ]e U'Zd[c+2 +[B

W1['T'c]e -c]2Z]gf1][1bd 1^'e* A][O /1[. )e+2 -E ]e \'d )1d['T'[[+e U'Tc'4 +[ .[*]g[+2]g 'Z[_1b1 )1d'T'[ _[*]gYO [+eE ]e][i U'T'a'T +[ ('['T'[]g/Z'[.E wi'[1 ]e Y'e*.Â&#x20AC; ]g[1 'a'`['Z1[ U'T]gYS U'T]gY *+_1 Y'd+e1'21,Y.x1 B 2',Y'O /1c )1d['T'[[+e []gZ[1bT ^+[ ]g,]gY .[O *]g[+2 ('['T'[ '3')4]W1 )]Z]g/Z]g[.B [^_+b )e]gY - A][/1[.E wY+[i ^+[i T'O e]W .[*]g[+2 'Z[ Y1di.E ]e 1bd4]g Y'd.

3'a[ - 'Y+[ 1[^]gYx7>B 1Zb 'a]gY]c b]f1]2]) ]*[1 /'eT.E 1[^_+b )ec'4 - w 'Z+[/1k1i 'Y+e1O i.[xQ]gYE 'b]gY -D w6>> d'e1 \'e]g['T 'Z[ )'W'h'e[ - 1\3+2E ]e +/+ f'[T'O []gY +b 21[+2 )1d['T'[E _+di - Y1di* ','d _'U+b Te]['T'[ T'_'[i[+O e1fxB 1Z[]gU+dA 'c+2'f[]gY -E ]e U+d',]O d'T'[ 1[bd1d]gd[+e]gY wTe]['b+e '[O U'd[+e. h'T +[ _'U]gY 1e+[f (+e'O [.x75B 5/+ Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1][ ]gbY]g[i. .[*]gO []gY +i ]e_+b X\Y'ed]g/Z]g[E ]ge+Y[ _+di - U'c'd'iE ]e )1d'T'[ U'Zd[')]e4]g/O Z]g[[+e1 Y'b1[ 3]b+21b ')[]bd1T T'Y '/+1bd )1d['T'[[+e. /]gZ2 ^+[ d'21bE ]e b+h'T'[ d+b'T+d[+e[ ',*+[ 1e+[f Y+T['('[]g/Z]g[[+e1 ce'B 4]gi _+di ['A U'c'd'iE ]e Y]gd'f1'[+e. A (['O T'[ .[de]g/Z]g[[ +[ 'a'` (+e+2 TZ'[i1 (]2]e ('e* VA+e.E ^['Z'4 'Z[ h'bd1[E ]e Y+T *'e1 .[/'fi]gY T'd'ec'4 U+d',]O d]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e Y]gd'f1'O [+e. ^+[ h]3'T+e_+2 ]eA- T][Te+d d+O b'T (]2]e]c1[ []e d+b'T1B 2'f1 'Z*E *]gi _+di - U'c'd'iE ]e (]2]e 'e'e'4[+O e. 'bd1X'['('e 'a'`'f+2 +[ Y+T ['3O []gfS '[d+b+2]c 'Z[ h'bd.E ]e (e'4][+O e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. Ubd'T f]gZf - d'O 21bE ]e (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 d+b'T[+O e1 Y+4 Y'b. 'a'`'f+2 - Y1'0'Y'['T A ^1 c+e'4c+2 'Z2 d+b'T[+e1E []gZ[1bT '[O /1cQ'[U'Y'e d'e1[+e1 .[/'fi]gYB 1e*O Z]i 'Zb_1b1 wU'c'd.x h'bd+e1y ce' U1Y[c'4E /+y c'eT'4[+e1B 9+eAb TU'Y'O V'Z[c+iE ]e -c]2Z]gf1'[ .[*]g[+2]g U'Y'e 1e]i wU'c'dx - '[Ue'0+\dB

[^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i ˛

[^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i 'Z[ _[*Y'[.E ]e Y1Te]-c]2Z]gf1'[ '_'f]gZf[ - 'Z[ ('[1E ]e Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1' - d+W1 ]g[+f+2B

˛

[^]yc - U'dT'[\'T'[ U+dAZ'2 h'bd.D (e'4][+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e d+b'T[+e1 Y+4 Y'b. +eT'e d'e1[+e1 .[/'fi]gY \'d i1^ h]h]3c+2B

31d]g/Z]g[. A w [[*]fx )1ei. 'd+e. _[*]gY +[E ]e )1d]g/Z]g[. U+ei]gY - 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ w [[*]fx )ei1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[.B 'T'Z[ U'T'b]g/Z]g[[ 1e'T'[]gY ]^ /+ )1d]g/Z'[ A 1bdc'4'\[^1 Y1`A -E 'Z2 )1d]g/Z'[ A ie1bd][Z' k]g[*'Y+[d'21bd[+e1 d+b'T+d[+e1B &]g[*'Y+[d'21bd'T'[ 3Y(+e1f Y1 i'[1b. 'a'[f U1Y['c]e h'bd+e1 _[*]gY +[E /+ .bd 1bdc'4'\[^1S (]2]e k1,1T'T'[ bd+W4')]e4]g/Z]g[[+e[ 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y]d'c]e'_+b 5> >>> d'e1 'a'`S c+f je+e1 .[/'fi]gYE ]e][f1f Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge. ('a'f1 68 0'Y dA]W]g/Z]g[ - ]g[+f+2B 'T'Z[ 1bdc'4'\]g[^. [Y'[ ('[ ^1 b]c]e+f[]gYE 'Z2'_+b '[f'4 U'eZ]ge d'e1[+e1 \'d )1d'T'[ U'Zd[')]e4]g/Z]g[[+e T'bT'41 T+[/'eT+1[ 'Z* )ei1 X\)ed]g/Z]g[.B 8[*U'T'a'T.S 1bdc'4'\[^1 Y'[e',[1[ ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. ('f'U'Zd]gY -E ]e ]^ Y1 U'T'b]g/Z]g[ ^T' ]ge( )ei1 A )1d'T'[ h'bd+e1 Y1`AB 4' - _'dX'a.E ]e 5U]c'Z1 cT'[+e. U'Y'V'Z[ ^+[ ie1bd][Z' k]g[*'Y+[d'21bd[+e1 A \'d Te+'f1][1bd[+e1 U+dB 1Z0Y +T+i d+b[+[iE /+ 1[^ - 1e'T'[]gY b]c]e+f[]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B

5ye( -e wbT1,(.x

24

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

ei'y[ +[ dA+2 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ je+e.

1e*Z]yi 'Z* je+e1f Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge. ('O a'f1 68 0'Y - dA+2B Y'[i 'Z*_+b +[ Yd'4]gYE i'[1 ]e U1Y[c]gY +[ 52i 6>B55 U'Y'e1 ce'B 1Zb U'Y'e]gY [\c]gY -E ]e ]cb+b. L[' - )e+2 w [[*]fx )1ei.M _'dc1e+f _'U+2 '('/. A ]e_+b je1O ['T (+e+f c+f 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ je+O e1[ U'`]e*]W Z]/+e]e* je.B 2'Zf 'e*Z]i w [[*]fx )1ei. /1T]g[i T'[)[]ygY - 'Zb d+b'T+d1[B R^B #'bd[ 'Z[ -E ]e +(e'Z+e+[ wjex ('a. T'e]W - [\'['T+2 ['A d'e(+e

Nebula: IAC/RGO/David Malin Images

1bdc'4'\[^1 w [[*]fx )ei1 'eV'O [')e]g/Z]g[. bTbc]gY - _'e,E b'T'Z[ ',*+f1T 3]bi+e]cD w T,(]gY 1bdc'4 bd+W4+f +eT1[i[ ]g +eT1e.x L [[*]f 5B5MB 1bdc'4'\[^')+d[+e1f \'d+e. U'Y'O V'Z[ +[E ]e b]ge()e'Z1[ 'Zb U'Y'e. [T'O e')e]gY - Y1 )]e4]W]g/Z]g[E ]e. T'_ ^]g[1 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ je+e1 U+dB 1Z* wje+O e1x Y'b1[ 3]bc]gY - +ee]e* U'Y'e1f bTb'4B Y'bd[ 'T[U'Zd -B 1bdc'4'O \[^1 'a'`1[ 3]bi+e1 U'Y'V'Z[S d1+,+eO i.E 'Z* /c]gY 5eT1e Y]2]e'T. )]Z]g/Z]g[ - ]g[+f+2 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ je+e. bTbc+O 2]gf \'d 'a'`B 5eTe'('[[+e. U'\c'eT+2 +[E ]e 5eT1O e. )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1 8 Y121'e* d'e1E 1bT .bd 'bdW')+d[+e1S d1+,+ei. )]O Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1 59 Y121'e* d'e1B 1e*Z]i 'Zb U'\c'eT[+e. T'Y U+d')' U['e'c]e X\)ed]gY[+e. 5eT1e Y]2]e'T1 A d1+,+eO

i1 )]Z]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ U'T'b]ygY +[ [[*]f 5B5Q1 3]bi+e1[B R^B 1bdc'4'\]g[^.

T][Te+d ^1 [\]gYE /+ ]ei'[ d'e1 )]Z]g/O Z]g[ ]g[+[ w+eT1[i[ ]g +eT1e.xB gbd1 )1O d]g/Z'[ A 1bdc'4'\[^1 Y1`A U'T'b]g/O Z]g[[+e ^T'[B

w [[*]fx )1ei. ^1 b]c]e+f[]gYE ]e 5eT1e Y]2]e'T. A d1+,+ei. bd+W4c+2 +[ Y]d 5> >>> d'e1 'a'`S 68 0'Y dA]W]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W : je+e1 .[/'fi]gY

+T wjec'x .[/'fi]gY bTbc'4 )]e4]W]g/Z]g[[+e. \'e]g['Tc+2 +[ U'`]e* Y+T T'Y Y1 i'[1 wje+e1x .[/'fi]gY dA]W]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4O [+e A ]^ /+ Y1'Z[ ('a'f1 68 0'YB %e1['TS 'c'ed+2]c 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ _'dO Y]g/Z]g[.S ]cb+b. (]2]e c+f je+e1 Y'b1[ 3]b+f ]e_+b Y+T jec' L [[*]f 6B8MB bT +e( [T'e')e]gY -eE /+ 1[^_+b 2]gZb. ('O 0'[c+f 3'c'e1fE [' je T'Y f+e+T T]^+f 68 0'Yc' Y1'Z[ Y1 Y'b. L [[*]f 5B7Q9MB #'bd]e+[E ]ge( )1ei. U1Yi ^1 d'21b Yd'4+2]gE ]e Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge 'e'e^')]eO 4'T'[ je dA+2 - 68 0'YB 1Z* *+_i]gY ]ei'y[ +[ dA+2 'eO 'e^')]e4'T'[ je+e.B 1bdc'4'\]g[^. ]^1[^ ^1 'b]gYB 'T'Z[ w [[*]fx )ei1 'a'`1[ A +eTe]e* )2]g3[+e]gY )]e4'4O c'4 ('a+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e 3]bO i. 'c+21 Y+4 0'Y'['T'U'dc'41 Y'O b1[ -B

1e'e^')]e4'T'[ c+f h]g2+e

]cb+b. 1e 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[. )e+2 +(e'Z+e+[]c A 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+e. [T'O e')e+2 - +eTe1 ce' )d[c]W1 d+O b'[TZ]g[1fB 5/+ U'\c1 'a[+[i 'Zb +eT]g h'bd+e.E 1[^_+b ['A 'Z[E ]e d1+,+eO i. )]Z]g/Z]g[ - ]g[+f+2 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ je+e1f 'a'`E TT'e]W'['[i _'d'b3'O [+2 \'d c1X+21 U'ef+e1S T'_c'4 'e'eO ^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eO V'[')e]g/Z'[ U+dB [^_+ybB 26

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

w [[*]fx )ei1 'eV'[')e]g/Z'[ Y'[O e',[1[ ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. ('f'U'ZO d]gY -E ]e Y+T wjec'x .[/'fi]gY bTbc'4 )]e4]W]g/Z]g[[+e. \'e]g['Tc+2 +[ U'O `]e* Y+T T'Y Y1 i'[1 wje+e1x .[/'fO i]gYB %e1['TS ['3i'[ 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ 'a'`1[ je.E 'Y_+e1 U'bd \+ed. 3]^.[O *]d+2 -E ]e 2]gZb. 'e*+[ )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 'eA1f U'b[1 +eTe1 Y'T+eA]gZ/ L ]( 7<B=MB 1a'`1[ jec' .[/'fi]gY 'Z* \+ed. bTb+2 - ('e'T+2E A 2]gZb. 'bd1X'['('e [+e/'O h'[f+2 - Y/[]2]ed1B 5eTe]e* je. Y/[]2]ed. \'e]g['T+2 Y'iec+2S U'bd \+ed ]g[+f]W 'Y_+e1 A jcT1'[]b1 Y1`A bd+W4+2]c 2'Z[ d'e'O 4]g/Z]g[B bT ^]ee]e* je. Y/[]2]ed[ 'Z[O i'[ - _'e,c+2E ]e 'eA[ ]g 2]gb1[. d+b'O [+21 +[ *'eV+2 w+eT[i1 d'e'4]g/Z]g[]gYx L [[*]f 5B58Q5:MB 1Zb1[i[S 'eA. A 2]gb1O [. d+b'[+21 +[ *'eV+2 +eTe1fB 1Zb 'Y+[. d+W1 - ]g[+f+2 'bd1X'['('eB w [[*]fx )ei1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[. ['A f]gZf - d'21bE ]e Y1[^ Y/[]2]ed. \'e]g['O T+2 - _'e,c+2E U1[)+e]e* je. bd+W4c+2 +[ w/a^]g[[+e.x Lw/a^]g[[+ex /'e)Y'[O 1 T'e')e+2]g U'Y'eE /+ 1[^ d+W1 ]g[+f'c 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ 'a'`1[ je.E +(e'Z+e+[]gY )]e4'4c]gY - wjUex ('a.E ]e. Y'd['[\]gY 2]gZb[ 'aU'b'e'TE 1bT ^]ee]e* jec' U'Y'e j)d')]e4c]gY - +(e'Z+e+[ wY'jUex ('a.E ]e. [\'['T]gY - 2]gZb1 'W(Z]geB

c'4 +(e'Z+e+[ ('a. Y'd['[\]gY - ['A /a^]W Y1`'d[+e1[ A /'W'[/'/A'c]eO [+e1[MB y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ +[i )'21bB 1bdc'O 4'\[^1 2+,]g[ /]gZ2 - d'21b +[/'*e+2E ]e 'e'e^')]e4'T'[ h]g21 .[/'fi]gY bd+WO 4')]e4]g/Z]g[[+e1 Y+4 Y'b. 'bd1X'['O ('e - 'a'` +T+2 A ]^ /+ '[Y1`'_+bS \'d T'eX 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4]gYE 1bT ]e]\ ('O [+e -2 U'c'['('e bd+W4c+2 +[ 'e'e^'O )]e4'T'[ Y1 i'[1 je+e1 .[/'fi]gY 1B

8bd 1e+[f d+b'T[+e1

1e*Z]i (]gZb+e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 'bd1O X'['('e 1 U'Zd )'2. [\'['T]ygY -E ]e 1bdc'4 -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 Y1`]f]c - bd+W4+2 T+[*'[1 'e'e'4[+e1 Y+4 (',Y','[]g/O Z]g[.B R^B w [[*]fx )ei1 'eV'[')e]g/O Z]g[. _'e, f]gZf - d'21bE ]e 1bdc'4 1[i. bd+W4+f (]gZb+e1 ]g T+[*'[1[+e1 (]2]e U1Y['T'[ d+b'T[+e. L [[*]f 5B55E 56E 6>Q69MB 1e*Z]yi 'Zb bT,(['T'[ wd+b'O T1x (]gZb+e[ ]g T+[*'[1[+e. ['3')4c'4 -1[ 'Z[_+bE ]e U'eY'ec+[ Y1`'c'Ze1 h]O h]3c]W _'ZY'[[+e1[B y[^[ - ]e]\]gY wd+b'T1x b'UY'[.B 1bdc'4'\]g[^. 'Zb 1 %e1['TS c+f+e]e* jec' .[/'fi]gY 1bdO c'4 'a'`1[ ,]gZ)1[ 'b'fD w 'd'f+iE 2fe+i +eT1e.x L [[*]f 5B6<E 75MB 'T'Z[ 'Zb 3]bi+O e. bTb+f1[ 1e'T'['['2 Y1'Z[ U'`]e* wjec'x .[/'fi]gY L [[*]f 6B6MB

U'ef+e1 Y'b1[ ^1 3]b]gYB 'O T'Z[ 'Z[ \+\d]gY -E ]e T+[O *'[1 'e'e'4[+e. 'a'` +O T'[ w.bd 1e+[f d+b'T[+e1x L [[*]f 5B65MB 1Zb 3]bi+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e wd+b'T[+O e1x Y+` Yd[]W (',Y','[]g/Z]g[. b'UY'O ['h'T -B 9+R U[-'('['T'[ _+W]gY[+e.E /+R 0'Y'['T'T1f U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e. /1T]g[i +[ T'[)[]gY 'Z[ Ydi1[E ]e (]gZb+O e1 A T+[*'[1[+e1 U1Y['T'[ d+b'T[+e. '[b'UY'[ 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4]gY ^[^1[ h]h]3]g/Z'[ +[ +[/'eTc+2B w [[*]fx )1ei. ^1 b]c]e+f[]gYE ]e d1+O ,+ei.E 'Z* /c]gY ['A +eTe')]g[*. A [e' ce' '_e]W T+[*'[1 'e'e'4[+e. bd+W4O

[^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i Ë&#x203A;

1e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z'[ c+e'(+eZ'2 1y[^ b3'2 d+b'T+d[+e T'[B

Ë&#x203A;

[^]yc - [\'['T'21f 'Z[ h'bd.E ]e 1bdc'4'\[^1 A )1d]g/Z'[ Y1`A U'T'b]g/Z]g[[+e ^T'[B

28

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

c+2 +[ T'eX 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4]gY A U'O Y+Y'd'('e ]^ U+a]g '[fZ'2]gYE 1[^_+b ]e _[*]gY +[ ]e]\ ie1bd][Z' k]g[*'Y+[O d'21bd[+eB 1c+21[E w [[*]fx )ei1 'eO V'[')e]g/Z]g[[ 'Z[ Y'b1[E /+ 1[^_+b bd+W4c+2 d1+,+ei. A /+ 1[^_+b - TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f+2E [+e*'\['T - c+e`1[ d'e1[+O e1 )1d'T'[ U'Zd[')]e4]g/Z]g[[+e1[B 'd )1d['T'[[+eE U1Y[c+2]c b+h'O T'[ d+b'T+d[+e1 T'Y ]ge1\ )1d['T'[O [+e1 T'e41i[+e1 ce'E Y+e0]gY +[ 1bdc'O 4'\[^1 'Z[ _[*]gY.E ]e 1bdc'4 bd+W4+2 (]2]e ('[+e.B 'T'Z[ w [[*]fx )ei]gY ]cb+b. )e+2 -E ]e d1+,+ei. bT1,( - ]g[+f+2 A TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 'bO d1X'['('eS T][Te+d 0'Y'['T'U'dO c'4[+e1 .[/'fi]gYB [^_+yb T'e]W -e 7 9>> d'e1 'a'` ]cb+b. 1Y'['2 )1d'O T'[]e+[ X\)e1d 'Zb d+W+T]g/Z]g[.B 3]O Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1 Y+T de'Y'('['T'[ ('f'dO e]g/Z]g[B 1'Z[ 'Z[ 1[V['c]e]g/Z]g[.E ]e. +eT1[i[ ]g +eT1e. bd+W4+2]g ,]e]g/O Z]g[ A 1Y'bd]g/Z]g[ ]g[1E T'e]W -e ]cO b+b1[ d'2 'Z* X\)e1d d+W+T]g/Z]g[.B 5c U+[f b'E 1[^ 3]biE '_'f]gf]gY -E ]e 'Z* )1ei. w[+e\[^c'4 - 1bd4]gfx 1 L6 1Y]O /+]b 7B5:MB 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE )]gf+ U'ef[+iD w 'O eA]ye - U'c'd'2 bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[ c+O e'(+eZ'2 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z'O [.xB 1 i'[1 U'Y],1^ h'bd+e i[[+2]gf U+d] _'e, T*'a['E /+ 1[^]g - T'eA]e 1Y'['2 'Zb U'ef1 _'d'b3'[.B 1 e'f]gf1^ d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e1 U'Y'e d+Rb w31ei (]2]e1 U'Y'ex )ei]gZT.B e'd'e'Tc+2 - 5U]c'Z1 cT'[+e1 T]WY1fB

Penguins: By courtesy of John R. Peiniger

+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e.

U'bd'd]gY +[E ]e T+[*'[1 je)'[1,YO [+e. b+e]g[* +[ 'a'` (+e]gY w.bd 1e+[f d+b'T[+e1x

'eA]ye - 'e*Z]iE /+ 'eA]ye 1[^1[ +i U'c U'c'd 'd]gY ]gY '[V'Y( '[ V'Y( *]gi +e T'e41i]cS TZ'[i[ ]g[1y [_'d'TB 7c]2Z]gf1][1bd g12Z'Y #e]c1[. 'b]gY -D w1Z[E 1[^ 1Y'f+2 +[i -c]2Z]gf1][ _e]f+b[+e1 Y'b1[E Y+4 [\'['T]g/Z]g[ - ]g[+f+2 Y+, U'Y'eD 'Z[ ',*+2 TZ'[i1 1Y'bd1 c+e'(+eZ'2 Y+e ]g[+f'4 _'dT+e'f]gY[+e1 ce'xB y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ - [' +T+2B w5b ]^ Y1 -'T'[ 1Y'bd ^+Y d+b[]gY ]R^ Y'e*T'[f TZ'[i1 A ]R^ -2 d1+,+ei1 )]Z]g/Z'[ Y+`x76B

& Faunia, Madrid

5/+ TZ'[i[ 1Y'bd ^]g[1E '_' Y+e TZ'[i1 [_'d'T[ - ]e]\ ('e1 )]e4+e '[+2 A Y+e )+[+e. h]3'[f+2 U'`]e* b+e]g[*O [+e1[B 1Z[]gU+dA Y+[i TY'U'['[i ]g c+e`B 5c Y+e ]gW+W.E ]e[ ]g['T - Yd'4+O 2]gE de'Y'('[+2]g A 3]eUe*'4+2]g TZ'[O i1 1Y'bd1 \]ge`E Ab Y1 _'d'U'T'[]g/O Z]g[ T21[1B 'T'Z[ b' *+a 'Y+[. ^-B 7c]2Z]gf1'O Z1[ U'c'd'f]W \'d Y'e*1T _[*]gY +[E ]e 1bdc'4 ^T'E T'Y ]e [' ^1 T'e]W Y1O `'Yd+2 Y'e*T'[f )]e4+e1[B 5/+ 'Z*_+b -E '_' Y+e U]gZb. _+di - *[+[i T'RY i'O W'i'T'[ )]e41^[+e1E T'RY )1d['T'[[+O e1E T'RY -2 Te]['T'[ 'a'`[]e*[+e1 ce'B 5c +/+ U'\c1 'a[+[iE /+ 1[^ _'dY'T'[ h'bd+e T'[ 'Zb Y'e*T'[f c+e'(+eZ'2E T'e]W +[i cbd'U 21[+2E ]e U'b'e'T]g/O Z'[ Y+` Y1\d -2 T21[1 i']bE _'d+e',Y ]g U'[f')]e4]g/Z]g[B c+e`]E +/+ -c]2O Z]gf1'[ X1\d -E ]ge+Y[ U1Y['c]e _'dO X'a[+e ]g[+[i '_e+2]g U+dAZ'2 T'e)'O 3]b]cD w5T+i ]gd+[i ]g 3Y+[iE ]e]cU+O dA c'W. Y+a[+2]g +[ix L5 ]e[/'f1[+e 59B76MB 'T'Z[ 1bdc'4'\]g[^. b]c]e+f[]gY -D w Z'[i1 'W(Z]ge. 1bd4]g Y]d -x L 'WO Y]b 7:B=MB 1Zb 3]bi+e. T'e]W +[ Y+4 [\'O ['T]g/Z]g[ ]g[+['2 Y+, U'Y'e A h]3+2 TZ'[i1 1Y'bd1 c+e'(+eZ'2 Y+e d+b'T+O d.B y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ +[i )'21bB

5/+ 1bdc'4'\[^1 3]bi+e. X\Y'e1d +[E ]ge+Y[ TZ'[i[ ]g[1 1Y'bdD Y+e b1e'O a'd d+W41^. Y1 Y+4 [_'d'T ]g[1E ]e[ 'a[^c]gY - 'Z[ Y'e*T'[fE ]ci+e f'[T'O []gY +[ '_e+2 1e T'Yi1 U'Y'V'Z[ L ]W]O c]W 56B57MB 1Z* [_'d'T[ -S TZ'[i 'Z[_1O b1 '\3'eU]gYE ]ge ^T' i']bE _'d+e',YE U'[f')]e4]g/Z]g[ A []gZ[1bT Y'U L 'WY]b 7;B5>E 55; 5b'Z1' 69B:Q<MB ,]ge ^-E ]e '\3'eU1 d'e(+e c'Ze+O e]gY '_e]W Y121]['c]e Y'e*1T U'c'O d]gY +[E ]e 1bd4]g[ X'['^+2. A [e'[ U['O ,'[*c+2. 1e+[f TZ'[i1[ 1bT'T'[ 1Y'bd - U'W]e*]gYE Y1 ('[E ]e[ 'Z2 T+e_ U['e'O c]e ^- )d[+2 L ]cU'[[+b 5;B7MB e'[f U'O c'd. U1Y[c'4 ^- h]g^ +e','[i[+e1 ce'B #'bd+e[ 'T[U'Zd +[S TZ'[i. bd+W4'O )]e4]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B

[^_+yb T_'d'b3'[+i ˛

[^1y[ +i U'c'd]gYD Y+[i -c]2Z]gf1'Z1y 'e*Z]g[i +[iE /+y bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[B [^]yg +i 'Z*_+b _'d'b3'[]gYB

˛

[^]yg - T'eA]e i[[+2E /+ 1[^1 ce' +[ U1Y[c'4 V+e U'Y],Y]g[i[+e.B 29

W(Z]ge[+e1 f'[T +[*'[1 Y]2]e'T 1. Scientific American, Special Issue 2008 entitled â&#x20AC;&#x153;Majestic Universe,â&#x20AC;? p. 11.

2. Perfect Planet, Clever Speciesâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;How Unique Are We? by William C. Burger, 2003, pp. 24, 34.

3. Rare Earthâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Why Complex Life Is Uncommon in the Universe, by Peter D. Ward and Donald Brownlee, 2000, p. 224.

4. The Sacred Balanceâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Rediscovering Our Place in Nature, by David Suzuki, 2007, p. 102.

5. God and the New Cosmologyâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;The Anthropic Design Argument, by M. A. Corey, 1993, pp. 144145. wË&#x2DC;eT1e. 21 - TZ'[i]cx \e`'['T. 6. Wildlife in a Changing Worldâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;An Analysis of the 2008 IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, edited ´

by Jean-Christophe Vie, Craig Hilton-Taylor, and Simon N. Stuart, 2009, p. 6.

7. Journal of Industrial Microbiology, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Total Bacterial Diversity in Soil and Sediment Communitiesâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;A Review,â&#x20AC;? by V. Torsvik, R. Sørheim, and J. Goksøyr, Volume 17, 1996, pp. 170-178.

8. Science, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Environmental Genomics Reveals a SingleSpecies Ecosystem Deep Within Earth,â&#x20AC;? by Dylan Chivian, et al, Volume 322, October 10, 2008, pp. 275-278.

5 David Hawks

9. Scientific American, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Microbe Census Reveals Air Crawling With Bacteria,â&#x20AC;? by David Biello, http://www.scientificamerican.com/ article.cfm?id6microbe-census-reveals-ai. yc - ['3')4+2 'a'`1[.

10. Natural History, â&#x20AC;&#x153;As the Whale Turns,â&#x20AC;? by Adam Summers, June 2004, pp. 24-25.

11. Science, Random Samples, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Flippered Flight,â&#x20AC;? May 21, 2004, p. 1106.

12. New Scientist, Technology, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Is It a Bird, Is It a Plane . . . ,â&#x20AC;? September 3, 2005, p. 21.

13. Heat Exchanger Design, Second Edition,

by Arthur P. Fraas, 1989, p. 2.

30

Ë&#x203A; Ë&#x2DC;y $ !Ë&#x2DC;Ë&#x2021;

14. The Economist Technology Quarterly, Report, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Technology That Imitates Nature,â&#x20AC;? June 11, 2005, pp. 18-22.

15. The New York Times, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Design for Living,â&#x20AC;?

by Michael J. Behe, February 7, 2005, p. A21. c]2Z]gf1'D c'eT'4[+e A h'bd+e 16. Natural History, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Darwin & Evolutionâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;The Illusion of Design,â&#x20AC;? by Richard Dawkins, November 2005, p. 37.

17. Origin of Species, by Charles Darwin, First Edition, 1859, Sixth Edition, 1872, pp. 285-286.

18. Charles Darwinâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;The Origin of Species, Introduction by Sir Julian Huxley, 1958 for Introduction, First Signet Classic Printing, September 2003, p. 458.

19. Nobel Lectures, Physiology or Medicine 1942-1962, 1999, â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Production of Mutations,â&#x20AC;? by H. J. Muller, 1946, p. 162.

20. Mutation Breeding, Evolution, and the Law of Recurrent Variation, by Wolf-Ekkehard ¨ Lonnig, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Expectations in Mutation Breeding,â&#x20AC;?

2005, p. 48, and interview with Wolf-Ekkehard ¨ Lonnig.

21. Mutation Breeding, Evolution, and the Law of Recurrent Variation, pp. 48-51.

22. Mutation Breeding, Evolution, and the Law of Recurrent Variation, pp. 49, 50, 52, 54, 59, ¨ 64, and interview with Wolf-Ekkehard Lonnig.

23. Science and Creationismâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;A View From the National Academy of Sciences, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Evidence Supporting Biological Evolution,â&#x20AC;? 1999, p. 10.

24. Science and Creationismâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;A View From the National Academy of Sciences, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Evidence Supporting Biological Evolution,â&#x20AC;? p. 11.

25. Scientific American, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Natural Selection and Darwinâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Finches,â&#x20AC;? by Peter R. Grant, October 1991, p. 87; Nature, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Oscillating Selection on Darwinâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Finches,â&#x20AC;? by H. Lisle Gibbs and Peter R. Grant, June 11, 1987, p. 511; Science, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Hybridization of Bird Species,â&#x20AC;? by Peter R. Grant and B. Rosemary Grant, April 10, 1992, pp. 193-197.

26. Adaption and Natural Selection, by George C. Williams, 1966, p. 54.

27. Sudden Originsâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Fossils, Genes, and the Emergence of Species, by JeďŹ&#x20AC;rey H. Schwartz, 1999, pp. 317-320.

29. The Triumph of Evolution and the Failure of Creationism, by Niles Eldredge, 2000, pp. 49, 85.

30. The New York Review of Books, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Billions and Billions of Demons,â&#x20AC;? by Richard C. Lewontin, January 9, 1997, pp. 28-32.

31. Scientific American, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Scientists and Religion in America,â&#x20AC;? by Edward J. Larson and Larry Witham, September 1999, p. 91. 'eA]ye - 'e*Z]iE /+ 1[^1[ +i U'c'd]gY '[V'Y( *]gi 32. Science, Technology, and Social Progress, edited by Steven L. Goldman, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Evolution and the Foundation of Ethics,â&#x20AC;? by William B. Provine, 1989, pp. 253, 266.

Ë&#x203A; $ Ë&#x2021; Ë&#x203A;

NASA, ESA, and the Hubble Heritage LSTScl/AURAM OESA/Hubble Collaboration

28. Science and Creationismâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;A View From the National Academy of Sciences, Second Edition, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Evidence Supporting Biological Evolution,â&#x20AC;? p. 14.

ye )1ei[ -DDD Ë&#x203A;

U'e'dA bT,(]g[i[+e _'e]g['T]gY (]2]e Y'e*T'[f U'Y'e

Ë&#x203A;

'Zbi'[ 3]e ',*+f]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f+2 1e'c')1d]g/Z'[ ce'

Ë&#x203A;

])+\[^+2 Y'e*T'[f TZ'[i1 )[]c /'e)Y'[+2]g A 'ed')e+2]g 1e -`+e. w31ei (]2]e1 U'Y'ex 76 -`'[]f )ei]gZT]gY i[['eTc]gY +[ ['A 'Z2 h'bd+eE /+ 1[^]g 'e0+ T'e*'2 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B

4]gi T'e]W +i bd'['2 ['A U+dAZ'2 U'ef+e1 _'d'b3'[[+e.B

y 7 5! " 1 1 1 " 8 1e'T'[]gY

Ë&#x203A;

[^]yg +[i d'a'_]gYB

Ë&#x203A;

[^_+yb T'e]W +[i Y+e .[d'[+T'[ TZ'[i[ 'c+21 +e`'[1T *'eV[+2B

Ë&#x203A;

y[^ - 21[]gY Y'e*]g U+d Y'U1f U+d]B w y[^ - b]c]e+f[]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^. 1e'T'[]gYx 668 -`'[]f )ei]gY dec]gY +[ 'Zb A \'d 'Z2 U'ef+e1 _'d'b3'[[+eB

!'[T'[]ygY +i 2e'f]gf1^ d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e bd'['2B Zf+2+i Ë&#x2DC;U]c'Z1 cT'[+e1 www.jw.org T'Zi.B

Z'[i. bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'y[ 'e*Z]g[i -E /+y _'e,'_+b Y1 \'ei _'d'U'T'[ 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+e1 U+dA'[i -B Zb U'ef. \'d ('['c+X+e1 _'dX'a - +W+2B Z*]gU'[*+eVE _'d'b3'[[ 1Y'['2. \'d T'eA]e -B Zb )ei]gZT]gY i[['eTc]gY +[E je1['TE U+dAZ'2 U'ef+e.B ˛

˛ ˛

˛

s

+e Y]2]e'T. ['3')4c'y4 -e TZ'[i1 U'Y'eB ˛y[^ T'e]W +[i b]c]e+2 'Z[ 'Y+[1fE 1[^ d+b[]gY +[i ([]g/Z'[ Y+`B

1y/+ -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. U1Y[c'4 - h'bd+e1 ce'B 1d]g/Z]g[. U+ei+y2 - bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[.B 'eA]ye - 'e*Z]iE /+ 1[^1[ +i U'c'd]gY '[V'Y( *]giB

lc-REA 140514

˛