Lf rea

1 $ 13 " 8 3 1 !E 1 5 $ 5

1 $ 13 " 8 3 1 !E 1 5 $ 5

1 !

1 !

1 !

1 !

1 !

1 2 3 4 5

[^_+yb - TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f+2 7 8

e'T'[]gY )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1y TZ'[i1 _'e, d+b'T 7 <

yc T',Y+f 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e. 7 57 1e*Z]yi TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. Y+T ['3[]gf +[ 'a'`'f+2 7 66 e'Y'('['T'y[ - U'c'd'2 1bdc'4'\[^1[ 7 7>

1W(Z]ge[+e1 f'[T

7 75

',Y1 ce'D 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 )+W','e*c'4 _'dT+e. g\'*e]g/Z]g[D Y]2+T]g2[+e1 A Y]2+T]g2'Z1[ Y+3'[1,Y[+e1 +a'^'h Y]*+2[+e. _'e,+fc'4 +[ A *e'[f U'e'(+e'T'[ ^'h+e. bd]gZ) ^+[B 5 2010 WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA 2]2]e 1e'c]g[i[+e. _'\d_'[c'4 +[ Z'[i1 4')]gY.D U1[) U'efE ]e 'e0+ i[[+2 e'd'e'T1^[+eS WATCHTOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF NEW YORKE INCD BrooklynE New YorkE UDSDAD 6>5> /D Ue'd'e'T]g/Z]g[ 1Zb )ei]gZT. c'X'ai1 U'Y'e ^-B 1Z[ j0'[*'T]gY - 1bdc'4'\[^1 U'Y'\3'eU'Z1[ Te/'T'[ )]e4]g[+]g/Z'[.E ]e[ 1e'T'['fc]gY - U]0'e'T'Y [c1e'(+e]g/Z]g[[+e1 \[]eU1cB 5/+ 'Z2 T+e_ [\c'4 ^-E 1bdc'4'\[^1 Y+`(+e]gY[+e. c+efc'4 +[ w ]e '\3'eUx /'e)Y'[]g/Z]g[1fB Photo credits: Page 4: 5 Petit FormatNPhoto Researchers, Inc.; page 5: 5 SPLNPhoto Researchers, Inc.; page 22, tree of life: Image courtesy of Biodiversity Heritage Library; page 27, skull: 5 PhotolibraryNage fotostock; Ida: 5 Martin ShieldsNAlamy; page 28, skulls: 5 MedicalOonOLineNAlamy; page 29, Java Man reconstruction: 5 The Print CollectorNAlamy

The Origin of LifeP Five Questions Worth Asking Armenian Llf-REAM Made in Britain by Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Britain LRegistered in England as a CharityM

]gZb - d+b+2 +4 2e1d'[1'Z]gY

5 8 1 $ 1 1 4'b1 0'Y -B 1d+e. \'d '[U'[)1bd -B ' 'Z[i'[ 2'ec'4 -E ]e bd'Y]ib. bTb]gY - f'c+2B [^]ygB gb]gf^]gU1[E ]e1[ [' U'e)]gY -E i1^ 'a'` ('f'de+fE /+ 1[^_+b - 'e2, 4'ec1[. A [e' d+b]g/Z]g[. [_'bd+2 )1d]g/Z'[ 'a'`.[/'f1[ A ','d+2 Y'e*T'[f b[]d1'_'\d'T'[ U'Y],Y]g[i[+e1fB 1Z0Y [' Ue'c1e]gY '\'T+ed[+e1[ 'ed'U'Zd+2]g 1e+[f T'e41i.B 1d+e. +eT.[de'[i1 'a'` - T'[)['4B []W[+e. b]c]e+fe+2 +[ [e'[E ]e 1bdc'4 - bd+W4+2 +eT1e. A 'Y+[ ('[E ]e T' +eTe1 ce'B e'[i ['A ('f'de+2 +[E ]e 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[. cbd'U+21 -E 1bT -c]2Z]gf1'[ .[*'Y+[. Y1 d+b]g/Z]g[ -E ]e. U1Y[c'4 ^- h'bd+e1 ce'B [^ 3]biE /+R ]gb]gf^]gU1[E /+R 4[]W[+e. ]g,]gY +[E ]e 1d+e. X1\d[ 1Y'['B 'T'Z[ ]ygY _+di U'c'd' ['B 1\3'eU1 d'e(+e c'Ze+e]gY '_e]W U'O ,'e'c]e +e+3'[+e *_e]f]gY U'Zd[c]gY +[ [Y'[ 1e'c1X'T]gYB [^_+yb c'ec+2B 'Y'Y1d ^+ybE ]e TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ c+e'O (+eZ'2 Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge. _+di - 1e '[V['O T'[ T'e41i[ ]g[+['B gbd1 U'eT'c]e i[[+2 (]2]e h'bd+e. -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 A 'e'eO ^')]e4]g/Z'[ c+e'(+eZ'2E 'Z[]gU+dA ]e]O \+2E /+ 1[^1[ _+di - U'c'd'2B e'T'[]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^. ^1 3e'3]gO b]gY T]ge]e+[ U'c'd'2 'Z[ 'Y+[1[E 1[^ b]O c]e+f[]gY +[ i+,B w1[h]eV. U'c'd]gY 'Y+[ 3]bi1EP 'b+2 - 1bdc'4'\[^1 )e]WO [+e1f Y+T.EP ('Zf 3]e')+d. T\a'*'O d]gY - 1e i'Z2+e.x L1a'T[+e 58B59MB ]ge( 31ei. U]e*]e]gY - (]2]e1b )]e41 *[+2 Y+e w('['T'[]g/Z]g[.x A U'c'bd1'['2E /+ ]e[ - X1\d. L a]Y+'f1[+e 56B5E 6MB 1Zb )ei]gZT. /1T]g[i ^1 T'[)[]gY 'Z[ Te]['T'[ 3Y(+e1 d+b'T+d[+e1[E ]e][i ]g,]gY +[E ]e *_e]f[+e]gY 'e'e^')]e4]g/O

Z]g[ *'b'c'[*c1B 3ei]gZT1 [_'d'T[ i[[+2 'Z[ Y'e*T'[f _[*]gY[+e.E ]ci+e b]c]e+f[]gY +[E /+ TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[ A /+ 'e'e^')]e4]g/O Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/O Z]g[. 'a'b_+2 -B +e ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. TbTb+[i (``1 T'a]gfc'4i1fE i'[1 ]e 'Z[ TZ'[i1 T'O eA]e')]gZ[ Y1'c]e[ -B [+eT'Z'fc+[ (``1 T'a]gfc'4i1 ,'eY'['Ue'\ 'a'[V['O U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e1f Y1 i'[1b.B i[[+i ['A 'Z[ c'eT'4[+e.E ]e][i /1T]g[i +[ T'[)O []gY -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[.B 1[\]g\dE (]2]e1b -2 U+d'ieie]gY - U+O dAZ'2 U'ef1 _'d'b3'[.D w Z'[i. bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'y[ 'e*Z]g[i -E /+y -c]2O Z]gf1'Z1xB 9+eAb *]g 'e*+[ Yd'4+2 +b 'Zb Y'b1[B 3ei]gZT]gY [+eT'Z'fc]gY +[ .[*'O Y+[. Y1 i'[1 h'bd+eE ]e][f U1Y'[ ce' \'d+e. bTb+2 +[ U'c'd'2E ]e TZ'[i.

1e'T'[]gY bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B 5 8 1 $ 1 1

3

1

5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

#]ie 0'Y'['T /+eAb U'efe+2 +b 4[]W[+e1*D w ed+W1yf +Y +bxB 'c'['('e bT,(]gY [e'[i '['T[T'21 +[ +T+2E U+d] U'\c1 'a[+2]c d'e1i*S )]gf+ ]e]\+2 +[ ^_'d'b3'[+2 i] U'ef1[ T'Y U'_X+_ 1[^O]e ('[ +[ 'b+2B 'Y -2 U+d'iei1e _'dY]g/Z]g[[+e +[ _'dY+2E ('Zf U+d')'Z]gY U'bT'f+2 +bE ]e *e'[i U]e1[c'4 +[B 1Y+[ *+_i]gYE *]g \'d T'eA]e U'ef +b dc+2 Y'Ze1T1* ]g U'Ze1T1*E i'[1 ]e ]g\ /+ \]gd Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge. _+di - 1Y'['E /+ 1[^ Ue'\i]c - 2]gZb '\3'eU +T+2B [^_+b ]e \'d 4[]W[+e '[U'eY'e +[ ,)]gY A 3]gb'h]gY +[ 'Zb /+Y'Z1 \]ge` 3]b+2]gfE 'Z[_+b -2 ]e]\ )1d['T'[[+e ^+[ ]g,]gY 3]b+2E /+ TZ'[i[ 1[^_+b 'a'`'f+2B 9+eAb U'Y'V'Z[c+bE ]e b' 'c+21 T'eA]e U'ef -E i'[1 ]e *e' _'d'b3'[1f - T'3c'4E /+ 1[^_1b1 c+e'(+eY]g[i T]g[+[' '[U'd. 1e 1bT TZ'[i1 U'[*+_ A /+ 'aU'b'e'T TZ'[i. 1[^ 'e0+i T]g[+[' 1e U'Y'eB ge+Y[ 1[^_+yb TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f+2B

2+WY['c]ec'4 Vc'(`1` LY+4'fc'4 - <>> '[)'YM

4

1 $ 13 " 8

y[^ +[ 'b]gY \'d )1d['T'[[+eB e'[iE ]ci+e U'c'd]gY +[ -c]2Z]gf1'Z1[E 'b]gY +[E ]e Y121'e*'c]e d'e1[+e 'a'` TZ'[i. bT1,( - 'a+2 ['3['T'[ jcT1'[]b1 `e+e]gYB e'[f T'e41i]cS 'Z* Y1`'c'Ze]gY i1Y1'T'[ Y1'O f]g/Z]g[[+e. 1[i['(+e'('e 3Y('c]ec+2 +[ A 'a'`'fe+2 T'/12'[Y'[ T'a]gfc'4i[+e ]g ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+eB 4e'[i -2 1e+[f U+e/1[ bTb+2 +[ T1bc+2 ]g \'d'['2B e'[i 'b]gY +[E /+ 5eTe1 ce' TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y+T T'Y Y1 i'[1 'Z*_1b1 ['3['T'[ w_'e,x (`1`[+e1fB e]\ '[c'[1 )1d['T'[[+e -2E ]ci+e []gZ[O _+b T]WY['T1f +[ -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[.E U'O Y'V'Z[ ^+[ 'Zb c'eT'41[B e'[i +[/'*O e]gY +[E ]e ['3['T'[ (`1`[+e. T'Y 'a[c',[ *e'[f ('W'*e1^[+e. d1+,+ei1f +[ .[T+2 5eTO e1 ce'B [^]yg +[ [e'[i 'Z*_+b Yd'4]gYB 'dX'a[ 'Z[ -E ]e ^['Z'4 1e+[f (]2]e `'[i+O e1[S )1d['T'[[+e1[ ^1 U'`]Wc+2 '_'f]gf+2E ]e TZ'[i. T'e]W -e 'a'`'['2 '[T+[*'[ Y]O 2+T]g2[+e1 Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e1fB 6>></DO1[ T+[b'O ('['T'[ )1d]g/Z]g[[+e1 _e]k+b]e 12+iO b'[*e +[+,. .[*)4+f 'Zb *12+Y'[S [\+2]cE ]e c+e`1[ 9> d'e1[+e1 .[/'fi]gY wh]eV+e1 ]g

]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i[+e. /1T]g[i ^+[ T'[)[]gY 'Z[ U1_]/+,1[E /+ 5eTe1 ce' TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 U'[T'e4'T1S d'e(+e Y]O 2+T]g2[+e1 Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e1fE 1[^_+b ['A 0'O Y'['T'T1f )1d]g/Z'[. U'Zd[1 ]eA- ('[ ^1 YW]gY Y+, Yd'4+2]gE ]e *' U['e'c]e -x5B y[^ +[ f]gZf d'21b h'bd+e.B T'd1 'aO [+[i U+dAZ'2 h'bd.D TZ'[i. bT1,( - 'a[]gY 'e*+[ 1bT )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W TZ'[i1fB gbd1 'Z[ U'ef1[E /+ ]ed+W1f +[ +e+3'[+e.E T' 2'c U1Y['c]ec'4 ]g U'Y],1^ _'d'b3'[B 2'Zf U'ef - 'a'`'[]gYS Y1y/+ Y121]['c]e d'e1[+e 'a'` d+W1 - ]g[+f+2 Y1 ('[E ]e. U+eO i+2 - 'Zb X\Y'ed]g/Z]g[.B 1y/+ TZ'[i. T'O e]W -e bT1,( 'a[+2 '[T+[*'[ i1Y1'T'[ Y1'O f]g/Z]g[[+e1 1[i['(+e'('e 3Y('c]ec+2]gfB ei'[]yc - U'c'['T'[E ]e [Y'[ ('[ T'e]W -e d+W1 ]g[+f'4 21[+2B $[[+[i Y1 i'[1 h'bO d+eB 31d['T'[[+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e (``1 )]Z]g/Z'[ U'Y'e _+di - U'Y')]e4'Tf+[ 'a[c',[ +e+i d'e(+e ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+eS 4 9 L*+,jib1a1(][]gT2+1O ['//]gME 9 La1(][]gT2+1['//]gM A b_1d'O T]gf[+eB 1Zbje \'d i1^ )1d['T'[[+e TU'Y'O V'Z[c+[ 'Z[ _[*Y'[.E /+ 'Y(]W`'T'[ T+[O *'[1 (`1`. _'d'U'T'[]e+[ - 'a'`'f+2 '[O T+[*'[ i1Y1'T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e1 3'a[]geO *1fB bT *]g 1y[^ +b T'e4]gYE 'e*Z]i 9O[ T'Y b_1d'T]gf[+e. T'e]yW -1[ 'a'`'['2 _'d'U'('e1B 5=97/DO1[ d+[21 122+e1 T'd'e'4 )1d'O h]eV1 'e*Z]g[i[+e. YW+f1[ \'d )1d['T'[O [+e1 Yd'4+2]gE ]e TZ'[i. T'e]W -e 'a'`'O ['2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[B 3',+e]c 2fc'4 h]eO V'[]/1 Y+` -2+Tde'T'[ _'e_]gY bd+W4+2]cS 122+e. 'b+b c+e'T'[)[+f 5eTe1 ce' )]Z]g/O Z]g[ ]g[+f]W ['3['T'[ Y/[]2]ed. A T'e]W'O f'c b1[/+,+2 ]e]\ 'Y1['//]g[+eS b_1d'T]gO f1 \W/'Z1 jW'T[+eB +d')'Z]gY 'Y1['//]gO [+e U'Zd['(+ec+f1[ ['A Y1 +eT['i'e1 ce'B 1e*Z]yi 'Zb U'Zd[')]e4]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e TZ'[i1 U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d (]2]e U1YO ['T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e. T'e]W -1[ 'a'` )'2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[B Z]g ]ei1 U'Y'2b'e'[1 ['3T1[ _e]k+O b]e i1Y1T]b ](+ed '_1e][ 'b]gY -D w9+A ]e]\ )1d['T'[[+e )e]gY +[E ]e TZ'[i1 U'Y'e 1 w yc T',Y+f 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e.x ('0[]gY L7Oe* ('01[M Ti[['eTc1E /+ ]ei'[]c - U'c'['T'[E ]e 4 9O[ 'a'`'['e _'d'U'('eB

5

5 E 5=97

'[Ue'0+\d (]2]e Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e. T'e]W +[ U+\d]g/Z'Y( 'a'` )'2E 1[^_+b +W'c 122+e1 )1d'h]eV+e1 0'Y'['TE A ('f1 'Z*E _[*]gY +[E ]e *e'[i 'aT' +[ ['A +eT['i'e+e1 ce'E b'T'Z[ 1e'T'[]gY *' 'Z*_+b ^-x 61B 1Z0Y i[[+[i 9O1 Y]2+T]g2.B 1Z[ T',Yc'4 - 'c+21 h]ie Y]2+T]g2[+e1fE ]e][i T]^c]gY +[ []gT2+]d1*[+eB 4e'[i h]ieO1[^ 'c+21 ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+e +[E i'[ 'Y1['//]g[[+e.B g\')O e'c - 'Z[E ]e 1[^_+b [\]gY - '_1e][E w]^ Y1 d+b'T1 []gT2+]d1* ^1 'a'`'f+2 -2+Tde'T'[ _'e_Y'[ )1d'h]eV+e1 'e*Z]g[i]gY T'Y ^1 U'Zd['(+ec+2 +eT['i'e+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/O Z'[ 0'Y'['Tx72B +d')'Z]gY [' U'bd'd+fE ]e i1Y1'T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e]c 21 ['3['T'[ jcT1'[]b1 `e+e]gY 9O1 1[i['c+e'ed'O *.ec]W Y]2+T]g21 _'d'U'('e 'a'`'['2]g U'c'['T'[]g/Z]g[[ w'Z[i'[ '[[\'[ -E ]e +/+ []gZ[1bT ]W` d1+,+ei]gY +e(A- [Y'[ ('[ d+W1 ]g[+f'4 21[+eE '_' *' T21[+e ('f'a1T ]g +,'T1 U'`]W]g/Z]g[x8B bT 1y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 b_1d'T]gf1 Y]2+T]g2O [+e1 Y'b1[B 4e'[i T'a]gfc'4 +[ 9>O1f Y1[O ^A Y1 i'[1 U','e1 U'b[]W 'Y1['//]g[+e1fE 1 e]k+b]e '_1e][ ^1 .[*]g[]gYE ]e TZ'[i. bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B e' T'e41i]cS TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 Y1 \'ei _'d'U'T'[ 1e'O *'eV]g/Z]g[[+e1 U+dA'[i]cE ]e][i *+aAb 21]c1[ _'e, ^+[B 2 6>>= /DO1[ '[^+bde1 U'Y'2b'e'[1 L1[)21'M )1d['T'[[+e. U'Zd[+f1[E ]e 1e+[f 2'(]e'd]O e1'Z]gY T'e]W'f+2 +[ b1[/+,+2 ]e]\ []gT2+]d1*O [+eB 'T'Z[ '_1e][ [\+fE ]e [e'[f w('W'*e'O d]Yb.x w('f'eV'T'_+b ^1 U'Y'_'d'b3'[]gY 1e T]WY1f b'UY'[c'4 'Z[ _'U'[`[+e1[E ]e][f ('c'e'e+2]cS TU'`]Wc+e U'W/'['T'4 Yd[+2 9O1 '\3'eUxB

5 5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

5

2

_1d'T]gf[+e. – b1[/+,c]gY +[ 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 — j)[]g/Z'Y(E 1bT 9O1 Y]2+T]g2.S b_1d'T]gf[+e1 Y'b['Tf]g/Z'Y(B 'e]yW -1[ *e'[i 'a'`'['2 _'d'U'O ('eB 1(]b]Y[+e1 ˜ Y'b1[ T3]bc1 6Oe* ('0[]gYB

1

3 ]e][i 1e'e Y1'f'4 +[ 31bd ]e]\'T1 T'e)]cB w 'e,x (``]gY )d[c]W Y1`1[ ^'h1 b_1d'T]gO f. ('WT'f'4 - 6>> 'Y1['//]g[+e1fB 1[)'Y 'Zb (``]gY T'[ U','e'c]e b_1d'T]gf[+eB '\c'eT[+e1 U'Y'V'Z[S ['3['T'[ `e+e]gY .[*'Y+[. 5>> 'Y1['//]g[+e1f T',Yc'4 Y+T b_1d'T]gf1 _'d'U'T'[]e+[ 'a'`'f'4 21O [+2]g U'c'['T'[]g/Z]g[. U'c'b'e - 5B5>59 LY+T1 U'e'(+e]g/Z]g[. Y+T Y121][ '[)'Y Y+T Y121'e*1MB 31d['T'[ Z]g(+ed ]T1[E ]e. -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[ T]WY['T1f -E 'b]gY -D w [U['e -E ]e bT,(]gY 'a'`'f'4 21[+1[ b_1d'T]gf[+e.

A U+d] *e'[f1f 4')+e TZ'[i.x9B 2'[[ 'Z[ -E ]e b_1d'T]gf[+e. b1[/+,c]gY +[ 9O1 5/+ 2'(]e'd]e1'Z]gY ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+e b1[/+,+O 2]g U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d +[ UY]gd )1d['T'[[+eE Y1y/+ (``1 Y+` )d[c]W 'c+21 ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+e.

T'e]W -1[ 'a'` )'2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[

Y]2+T]g21 j)[]g/Z'Y(E 1bT 9O1 Y]2+T]g2.S b_1d'T]gf[+e1 Y'b['Tf]g/Z'Y(B 5/+ .[*]gO [+[iE ]e b_1d'T]gf[+e. A 9O[ 'a'`'f+2 +[ Y1'0'Y'['T ]g Y1A[]gZ[ d+W]gYE 1[^. \'d '[U'c'['T'[ -E '_' U'ef - 'a'`'[]gYS 1[^_+ybB ei'[]yc - U'c'['T'[E ]e *e'[i TU'Y')]e4'Tf+1[ A 'a'` T(+e+1[ TZ'[iE ]e. ]^ Y1'Z[ T\'e]g['T1 1e 1[i[]ge]gZ[ )]Z]g/O Z]g[.E 'Z2A 1[i[]ge]gZ[ Tc+e'ed'*ec1B w 'c'O ['T'[]g/Z]g[.E ]e L 9O1 A b_1d'T]gf1 Y]O 2+T]g2[+e1 _'d'U'T'[ 3'a[]ge*]gYM 'Zb_1O b1 +eA]gZ/ - d+W1 ]g[+f+2E 4'Ze'bd1X'[ h]ie -xEP 'b]gY - *]Td]e 'e]2 2+2'[*.1E ]e.

1 4]Td]e 2+2'[*. Te+'f1][1bd ^-B e' T'eO 41i]cS TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 Y1 \'ei _'d'U'T'[ 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+e1 U+dA'[i]cE b'T'Z[ 'Zb +O eA]gZ/. *+aAb 21]c1[ _'e, ^-B

6

1 $ 13 " 8

1 1O1 'bdW'T+[b'('[]g/Z'[ 1[bd1d]gO d1 '[*'Y -B ' \'e]g['T]gY -D w1Z*]gU'[O *+eVE \'d )1d['T'[[+e Yd'4]gY +[E ]e +/+ b_1d'T]gf[+e. A 9O1 Y]2+T]g2[+e. 1[i['O (+e'('e +[ 'a'`'f+2 bT,(['T'[ Y/[]2]eO d]gYE '_' [e'[f U'Y')]e4'Tf]g/Z]g[[ -2 1[^O ]e T+e_ T'e]W -e 1[i['(+e'('e 21[+2xB +O d'iei1e - 'e]2 2+2'[*1 Y+T['('[]g/Z]g[.

TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d Y1'f]g/O Z]g[[+e1 1[i['(+e'('e 'a'` )'2]g c+e'(+eO Z'2 (]2]e c'eT'4[+e1 Y'b1[B ' 'b]gY -D w1Z* c'eT'4[+e1f ]^ Y+T. 3+2'Y1d _'d'bO 3'[ ^1 d'21b 'Z[ U'ef1[E /+ 1[^_+b - *' d+W1 ]g[+f+2x:B [^]yg +[ T'eA]e 'Zb d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e.B 1Z[ )1d['T'[[+e.E ]ci+e Yd'4]gY +[E /+ TZ'[i. _'d'U'T'[]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -E 1e]i ]e Y+4 3[*e1 'a'` +[ T'[)['4B 1\d -E [e'[i )d+2 +[ ]e]\ 'Y1['//]g[+eE ]e][i 'aT' +[ ['A T+[*'[1 (`1`[+e]gYB '(]e'd]O e1'[+e]gY Y'[e'TeT1d _2'['c]ec'4 A 1e'O T'['fc'4 )1d'h]eV+e1 0'Y'['T [e'[f U'`]Wc+2 - bd'['2 'c+21 ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+eB e'[i U]gZb ]g[+[ b1[/+,+2 (]2]e Y1'f]g/Z]g[O [+e.E ]e '[Ue'0+\d +[ w_'e,x (`1` bd'['O 2]g U'Y'eB 'T'Z[ 'Zb 'Y+[. [T'd1 ]g[+['O 2]cS 1y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ T'e+21 - )'2B 5[/'O *e+[iS Y1 )1d['T'[ c+ef[]gY - ([]g/Z'[ Y+` U'[*1_]W ]e]\ -2+Y+[d[+e A *e'[f1f _'dO e'bd]gY - _]W_'dE _2'bdY'bb'E b121T][E Y+d'W'2'eE 'Z[]gU+dA Y1 a](]d - b'ei]gYB +d] a](]d1 Y+` 'Z[_1b1 4e')1e - d+W'*O e]gYE ]e 'Z[ T'e]W'[' bd+W4+2 1e TeT[je1['O T.B y[^ T'e]W - 'Z*_1b]c '_'f]gf+2 )1d['O T'[.B 'c')]gZ[ *+_i]gY 'Z[E ]e [Y'[ ('e* Y+3'[1,Y T'e]W - bd+W4+2 Y1'Z[ ('['T'[ -'T.B

#'bd]e+[E +/+ )1d['T'[[+e1[ U'`]Wc+e (`1` bd+W4+2E ]e[E '[\]g\dE Y+4 V+ai(+e]gY T21[+eE Y1y/+ *e'[]c [e'[i T'_'f]gf+1[E ]e 'Z[ T'e]W -e _'d'U'('e 'a'`'['2B e'O T'[]gY [e'[i X1\d U'T'a'T. Th'bd+1[B ye[ - i] T'e41i.B 31d'T'[ (]2]e h'bd+O e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e TZ'[i. bT1,( - 'a[]gY 'e*+[ 1bT )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W TZ'[i1fB 1a[.O c',[ T]gZe U'c'd - _+di .[*]g[+2]g U'Y'e 'Z[E ]e '[)'Y w_'e,x (`1`. 'a'` - +T+2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[S '[T+[*'[ i1Y1'T'[ Y1'O f]g/Z]g[[+e1 3Y('c]e]gY1fB 1Zb (]2]e d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e[ 1 Yd1 ]g[+['O 2]cS TU'c'd'yb Y1 ('[1E ]e1 U'Y'e h'bd+e ^T'[B 4]g *+a T'e]W +b Yd'4+2E 1bT 'Z* .[O /'fi]gY T]gb]gY['b1e+[i (``1 T'a]gfc'4O i.B 1Z[]gU+dA 1[i* T]e]\+bS TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ c+e'(+eZ'2 ]e]\ )1d['T'[[+e1 c'eT'4[+e. de'Y'('['T'y[ +[E /+y [Y'[ +[ 'Z[ U]e1[O c'4 _'dY]g/Z]g[[+e1[E ]e][i 4[]W[+e. _'dO Y]gY +[ 1e+[f +e+3'[+e1[B 5/+ 4e')e'c]ec'4 a](]d1[ ('['T'[ -'T - bd+W4]gYE '_' 1y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 T+[*'[1 (`1` A 'aU'b'e'T Y'e* 'e'O e'4 bd+W4+2]g Y'b1[

#1 5 5 1 !5 #'bdB 31d'T'[ (]2]e U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e TZ'[i. ^1 T'e]W 'a'` )'2 _'O d'U'T'[]e+[S '[T+[*'[ Y'd+e1'Z1fB

Ë&#x203A;

'efB y[^ )1d'T'[ h'bd T'E ]e 'a'`1[ (`1`. 'a'`'f+2 - '[T+[*'[ [Z]g/+e1 3'a[]ge*1f T'Y 3Y('c]e]gY1fB #'bdB '(]e'd]e1'Z]gY )1d['T'[[+e. bd+W4+2 +[ 'Z[_1b1 _'ZY'[[+eE ]e][iE [e'[f T'e41i]cE )]Z]g/Z]g[ +[ ]g[+f+2 +eTe')[*1 ce' TZ'[i1 4')]gY1f 'a'`B 1Zb h]eV'eT]gY[+e1 0'O Y'['T [e'[i bd'f+2 +[ ]e]\ Y]2+T]g2[+eE ]e][i U'Zd['(+ec+2 +[ ['A T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e]gYB

Ë&#x203A;

'efB 5/+ h]eV'eT]gY[+e1 0'Y'['T bd+W4c'4 _'ZY'[[+e. A j)d')]e4c'4 -2+Y+[d[+e. [+eO T'Z'f[]gY +[ ['3['T'[ jcT1'[]b1 `e+e.E 1bT bd'fc'4 Y]2+T]g2[+e.S TZ'[i1 )]Z]g/Z'[ U'O Y'e '[Ue'0+\d w\1['[Z]g/.xE '_' ]ygY T'Y 1y[^

- [+eT'Z'f[]gY h]eV. T'd'e]W )1d['T'[.S ('O ['T'[ '[V['c]e]g/Z'[E /+y T]gZe _'d'U'T'O []g/Z]yg[B Ë&#x203A; #'bdB _1d'T]gf1 A 9O1 Y]2+T]g2[+e. _+di - wU'Y')]e4'Tf+[x 1e'e U+dE ]e_+b,1 (`1`. T+[*'[1 Y['B 31d['T'[[+e[ .[*]g[]gY +[E ]e \'d '[U'c'['T'[ -E ]e 9O[ 'a'`'O f'4 21[+e _'d'U'T'[]e+[B +[f 'Z[_+b []gZO [1bT Y+T b_1d'T]gf ^-e T'e]W 'a'` )'2B 'eO ,'_+b '[U['e -E ]e 9O[ ]g b_1d'T]gf[+e. 'a'`'['Z1[ _'d'U'T'[]e+[ Y1'0'Y'['T A Y1A[]gZ[ d+W]gY ]g ('f1 'Z*E wb]c]e+1[x U'Y'O )]e4'Tf+2 'Z*i'[ [+e*'\['T]e+[B 'efB [^1y U'Y'e - 'c+21 Y+4 U'c'd '[Ue'O 0+\dS .[*]g[+2]g U'Y'eE ]e (``1 Y121]['c]e ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+e1 U'Y')]e4'Tf]g/Z]g[. _'d'U'T'O []e+y[ - 'a'`'f+2E /+y ]e (`1`. ('['T'[]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B 5 5y 7 1 $ 1 1 1!5

7

2

1 1 " 3 "9 " " y 1 $ 1 6 5 1

$] Y'eY1[. d1+,+ei1 'Y+['('e* T'a]gfc'4i[+e1f Y+T[ -B 1Z[ T',Yc'4 'c+21 i'[ 6>> d'e(+e d+b'T1 Y1Te]bT]_1T (`1`[+e1fE je1['TE ]bT]e1E 'eZ'[E ]gW+W1 ;B 4e'[f /1c. U'b[]gY - Y]d 5>> de121][1 <B 2`1`[+e. 31bd d'e(+ec]gY +[ 1e+[f VA]c A k]g[Tf1'Z]cB 4e'[i Y1 ('e* A 'Y(]W`'T'[ U'Y'T'e) +[B %e1['TS Y121]['c]e 'e')')]e4 U'Y'T'e)1^[+e1f A T'_]gW1[+e1f T',Yc'4 [d+e[+d[ '[)'Y (`1`[+e1 'Zb U'Y'T'e)1 U'Y+Y'd]g/Z'Y( *'[*'W - A ]^ 'e*Z]g['c+dB 'e*]g T]WY1f bd+W4c'4 ]^ Y1 d+3[1T' ^1 T'e]W Yef+2 []gZ[1bT 'Y+['_'e, (`1`[+e1 Y+` )]e4]W wY+3'[1,Y[+e1x U+dB bT 1[^_+yb +[ 'a'`'f+2 Y'e*]g Y'eY[1 (`1`[+e.B y[^ +[ 'b]gY \'d )1d['T'[[+eB 2`1`[+O e. ('0'[c]gY +[ +eT]g 3Y(1S T]e1,'Z1[ A '[T]e1,B 'e*1TE T+[*'[1[+e. A (]gZb+e. ]g[+[ T]e1,'Z1[ (`1`[+eE 1bTE je1['TE ('TO d+e1'[+e. ^]g[+[ VA'c]ec'4 T]e1,B ]O e1,'Z1[ (`1`[+e. T]^c]gY +[ -]gT'e1]dE '[T]e1, (`1`[+e.S _e]T'e1]dB e]T'e1]d (`1`[+e. T',Y]g/Z'Y( U'Y+Y'd'('e 'c+O 21 _'e, +[E i'[ -]gT'e1]d (`1`[+e.B 1Z* _'dX'a]c \'d+e. T'e4]gY +[E ]e T+[*'O [1[+e1 A (]gZb+e1 (`1`[+e. 'bd1X'['('e 'a'` +[ +T+2 ('Td+e1'[+e1 (`1`[+e1fB e'T'[]gY \'d )1d['T'[[+e b]c]e+fO []gY +[E ]e Y121]['c]e d'e1[+e1 .[/'fO i]gY ]e]\ _e]T'e1]d (`1`[+e T]g2 +[ 8

1 $ 13 " 8

3 " 5 2

1 $ 2 5

1 2

1 1 2 5

1 1 1 2 5

1y/+ i] Y'eY[]gY )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W 'c+21 i'[ 6>> d+b'T1 (`1`[+e. 'a'` +[ +T+2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[

1y/+ '[)'Y w_'e,x (`1`.

T'e]W -e 'a'`'['2 '[T+[*'[ i1Y1'T'[ Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e1f

dc+2 YZ]gb _'e, (`1`[+e1[E ('Zf ^+[ Y'eb+2 *e'[iB 8bd d+b]g/Z'[S ('['T'[]g/Z]g[ ^]g[+f]W ([]g/Z]g[. wYd'4+2 -x ]^ Y1'Z[ 'eO Y'd'T'[ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e Ydf[+2 w)+e1 .[T'4x (`1`[+e1 k]g[Tf1'Z1 Y+`E 'Z2A 'eO *+[ U'eY'ec'4 (``1[ _'U+2 w')e+b]e1x [+eb]gYE +e( c+e`1[b c+e'ed'*ec]gY - = 1B y[^ - 'b]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B 1bdc'4'O \]g[^. [\]gY -E ]e TZ'[i. ('['T'[]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B g\'*e]g/Z]g[ *'eVe]g U+dAZ'2 de'Y'('['T'[ Ydi1[D w1[\]g\dE 'Y+[ d]g[ 1[^O]e Y+T1 T]WY1f - T'a]gfc]gYE ('Zf ]c (]2]e ('[+e. T'a]gf+fE 1bdc'4 -x L5(O e'Z+f1[+e 7B8MB +T ]ge1\ 'bdc'4'\[^Z'[ U'Y'e]gY T'e*]gY +[iD w ei'z[ \'d +[ i] )]e4+e.E ]Rc 5U]c'E (]2]e. 1Y'bd]g/Z'Y( +b 'e+2B 5eT1e. 21 - i] bd+W4')]e4]g/Z]g[O [+e]cEDDDD /1c ^T' \'e0c]W ('[+e1[E T+[*'O [1 -'T[+e1[S /+R h]ie+e1[E /+R Y+4+e1[x L 'WY]b 5>8B68E 69MB y[^ +[ f]gZf d'21b h'bd+e.B '[e-'O ('[]g/Z'[ ,'e)'f]gY. U['e'c]e]g/Z]g[ dc+f )1d['T'[[+e1[ ('f'U'Zd+2]g 'Y+O ['_'e, _e]T'e1]d (`1`[+e1 '_\+f]gf1^ T'a]gfc'4i.B 7c]2Z]gf1][1bdO)1d['T'[O [+e. +[/'*e]gY +[E ]e 'a'`1[ T+[*'[1 (`1`[+e. [Y'[ +[ +W+2 'Zb _'e, (`1`[+O e1[5>B 5/+ -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. X\Y'ed]g/O Z]g[ -E '_' _+di - U'Y],1^ ('f'de]g/O Z]g[ [+eT'Z'f[1E /+ 1[^_+b - _'d'U'T'O []g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i]gY 1 U'Zd +T+2 'a'`1[ w_'e,x (`1`.B bT +/+ TZ'[i. bd+W4')]eO 4]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -E '_' []gZ[1bT 'Y+['O h]ie bd+W4')]e4]g/Z'[ Y+` _+di - 'T[O U'Zd 21[1 U,]e ('['T'[]g/Z'[ V+a')1e.B 1Z0Y Ue'c1e]gY +[i i+, Y'b['Tf+2]g Y1 \'d U+d'iei1e -ibT]geb1'Z1E ]e. T'[fO T'fc1 _e]T'e1]d (``1 [+eb]gYB 7ibT]geO b1'Z1 .[/'fi]gY Yd'41e U+dAZ'2 U'ef1 1 ^ Y1 )1d'h]eV ^1 h'bd+2 'Zb +eA]gZ/1 U['O e'c]e 21[+2.B

\]ge`D w1Zb (`1`. T'e]yW -e _'d'U'T'[]O e+[ 'a'`'['2xB

1 " 1

'3 'b+[iE ]e (`1` Y]gdi )]e4+2]g U'O Y'e _+di - h]ie'['[i ]g *'a['[i T+d1 Y+T U'eZ]ge+e]e*'T'[1 ^'hB 1Z0Y _+di - '[f[+[i 'Y]geE ('Zf Y1A[]gZ[ 0'Y'['T -2'bd1T (``'/'W'[/1 Y1`]cE ]e. _'e.bO _1 [Y'[ _'\d_'[]gY - (`1`O)]e4'e'[.B 1Zb /'W'[/[ 1e'T'[]gY 'Z[i'[ ('e'T -E ]e 5> >>> /'W'[/[+e1f ('WT'f'4 \+ed1 U'bd]g/Z]g[. U'c'b'e T21[1 b]c]e'T'[ /W/1 U'bd]g/Z'[.B 'T'Z[ (``'/'W'[/. \'d 'c+21 ('e* T',Y]g/Z]g[ ]g[1E i'[ i'O e1f ]g f+Y+[d1f \1[c'4 _'e1b_.B 1Zb /'W'[/. _'\d_'[]gY - (`1`. '[O ('e+[_'bd Y1`'c'Ze1 ',*+f]g/Z]g[1fB 3]e4'e'[. _'\d_'[]W _'eb_1 _+bS (``'/'W'[/. 'e)+2]gY - ('e*E .bd -]g/O Z'[ c['b'T'e Y]2+T]g2[+e1 Y]gdi. (`1`S 'a'[f c+e`1[1b /]gZ2dc]g/Z'[B 'T'Z[ /]gZ2 - d'21bE ]e h]ie Y]2+T]g2[+e.E je1O ['TE //c'41[.E U+\d]g/Z'Y( [+e/'h'[O f+[ (`1` T'Y *]geb )'[ 'Z[d+W1fB 2'f1 'Z*E 'Z[ T'[3]gY - j)d'T'e Y]2+T]g2[+e1 +2i.B d'4+y2 +b +e(A-E /+ 1[^_+b - d+W1 ]g[+[]gY 'Zb ,'eY'['Ue'\ '\3'd'[i.B 3]e4'e'[. ]g[1 ['A _'U'T[+eE ]e][i UbT]gY +[ A bd]g)]gYE /+ 1[^ - Yd[]gY )]eO 4'e'[ A 1[^ - *]geb )'21b 'Z[d+W1fB ]gZ[ VA]c -2 (`1`. ]g[1 _'U'T[+e1 A *'e_'bO [+e1 *+e T'd'e]W U'd]gT b_1d'T]gf[+eE ]e][i Yd[]gY +[ (``'/'W'[/1 T',Y]g/Z'[ Y+`B

6 1 1 " 3 "9 " " y 1 $ 1 6 5 1

9

3 2

4

1

2``'/'W'[/1 ce' T'[ w_'U'T[+exE ]e][i /]gZ2 +[ d'21bE ]e Y1'Z[ ]e]\ d+b'T1 Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e [+eb ]g *]geb '[+[

1Zb b_1d'T]gf[+e1f Y1 i'[1b. /]g[+21 [Y'[ +[ L5ME ]e][i /]gZ2 +[ d'21b ]e]\ d+b'O T1 Y]2+T]g2[+e1 ','d [+eb ]g *]geb '[+2B Z]gb b_1d'T]gf[+e. ('f +[ Y1'Z[ Y1 T]WO Y1f L6MB 4e'[i ]g[+[ 'Z[_1b1 3]a]^[+e L7ME ]e][f Y+` T'e]W +[ Yd[+2 Y1'Z[ U'Y'_'O d'b3'[ VA ]g[+f]W Y]2+T]g2[+e.B 5e( c+eO `1[[+eb [+eb +[ Yd[]gYE b_1d'T]gf1 YZ]gb 4'Ze. ('fc]gY -E A [e'[i '['e)+2 '[f]gY +[ (``'/'W'[/1 Y1`]c L8MB 1Zb _e]f+b[+O e. d+W1 +[ ]g[+[]gY []gZ[1bT 'Y+['_'e, (``1 /'W'[/]gYB

Y'T'e)^'Z1[ 4e')1e[ - c+e'UbT]gY )]eO 4'e'[1 '\3'd'[i.E 'Z[_+b -2 4 9O1 L9M T]*[ - c+e'UbT]gY (``1 [+eb]gY d+W1 ]g[+f]W \'d _e]f+b[+eB 4 9O[ a1(]b]O Y1[ L:M ]gW'eT]gY - Y'[e'Y'b[ Ue'U'[)[+O e1 _'dX+[.E ]ed+W [\c'4 -E /+ 1[^ b_1d'O T]gf _+di - _'de'bd+2 A 1[^_+b L;MB 1[^ 'Z* _'de'bdc]gY +[ b_1d'T]gf1 \W/'O Z1 jW'T[+e.S Y]d 6> d+b'T1 'Y1['//]gO [+e.B 1_' *e'[i d'ec]gY +[ a1(]b]Y[+e1 Y]dB 1cd]Y'd Y+i+['[+e1 [Y'[S a1(]b]YO [+e. 'Y1['//]g[+e1 'Zb jW'T[+e[ 1e'e +[ Y1'f[]gY ]e]\'T1 U'`]e*'T'[]g/Z'Y( A bd'[]gY +[ '[Ue'0+\d d+b'T1 b_1d'T]gO f.S U+dA+2]c Ue'U'[)[+e1[B 5e( 'e*+[ b_1d'T]gf1 \W/'[ _'dO e'bd -E Y1 ,'eY'['21 ('[ - d+W1 ]g[+[]gYD 'Z[ bTb]gY - 4'2c+2 1e d+b'T1[ ([]e]\ ]e]O \'T1 VA]c A V+ai - (+e]gY +a'^'h T'a]gfO c'4i L<MB +[f 'Zb T'a]gfc'4i1f -2 T'3O c'4 -E /+ 1[^ k]g[Tf1' _+di - T'd'e1 b_1d'T]gf. 1 B %e1['TS _'dT+e'fe]g Y1 'ed'*e'Y'bE ]ed+W \'e01^1 Y'b+e +[ U'c'i]gYB ]ge'i'[^Z]ge Y'b _+di - X1\d _'de'bdc'4 21[1E ]e_+b,1 \'e01^. '\O 1 &+eY+[d[+e. L-[,1Y[+e.M b_1d'T]gf1 d+b'T +[ A _'de'bdc]gY +[ (``1 [+eb]gYB ]ge'i'[^O Z]ge k+eY+[d 4'2c]gY - U'd]gT VA]cE ]e 'e'O )'f[1 T][Te+d ]eA- d+b'T1 i1Y1'T'[ a+'Tf1'O Z1 .[/'fi.B 2``1 )]e4]g[+]g/Z'[. Y'b['Tf]gY +[ U'eZ]ge'c]e k+eY+[d[+eB

6

3 1 1 5 "

+[i 'e*+[ '[f'[i w_'U'T'T+d1fx A 'Z0Y )d[c]gY +[i (``1 [+eb]gYS f1d]_2',O Y'Z1 Y+`E ]e. (``1 T1b'U+W]gT [+ei1[ Y1O `'c'Ze[ -B 1Z[ U'e]gbd - b[[*'[Z]g/+O e]cE 'W+e]c A 'Z2 Y1'f]g/Z]g[[+e]cB 2`1`. *e'[i j)d')]e4]gY - '[Ue'0+\d b_1d'O T]gf[+e b1[/+,+2]g U'Y'eB 1Zbd+W 'Y+[ ('[ T'e) ]g T'[][]c - .[/'[]gYE 1[^_+b ]e 'e*Z]g['c+d]e+[ '\3'd]W )]e4'e'[]gYB 8bd b'UY'[c'4 )e'k1T1S ]e]\'T1 U'`]eO *'T'[]g/Z'Y( d+W1 +[ ]g[+[]gY U','e'O c]e i1Y1'T'[ a+'Tf1'[+eB 2`1`. 1e 0'Y'['T1 Y+4 Y'b. de'Y'O *e]gY - b_1d'T]gf[+e 'ed'*e+2]g[B [^O _+yb - d+W1 ]g[+[]gY 'Zb _e]f+b.B '3 [\+[iE ]e 1[^_+b T+[de]['T'[ U'O 10

1 $ 13 " 8

7 8

5

3'd1B Y'['_+bE b_1d'T]gf. _+di X1\d T'a]gfc1 A 4'2c1E U'T'a'T *+_i]gY 'Z[ ^1 T'e]W 1[^_+b U'eT[ - T'd'e+2 1e k]g[Tf1'[ A U['e'c]e - []gZ[1bT c['b1 (``1[B bT 1[^_+yb - b_1d'T]gf. )d[]gY 1e X'O ['_'eU. A U'b[]gY 'Z[d+WE ]ed+W '[Ue'O 0+\d -B ]ge'i'[^Z]ge b_1d'T]gf1 ce' [\c'4 - wU'bf+xB 9+A 'Y+[ e]_+ U','O e'c]e b_1d'T]gf[+e +[ _'de'bdc]gY ]g 'a'ic]gYE b'T'Z[ wU'bf+1x \[]eU1c [e'[i Y1\d ('e+U'`]W U'b[]gY +[ 1e+[f [\'['T+d1[B [^]yg +[ T'eA]e 'Zb d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e.B 1[)'Y 'Y+['_'e, T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y1 ('e* Y]2+T]g2[+e. ^+[ T'e]W 1[i[]ge]gZ[ c+e'ed'*ec+2B 2``1f *]geb *e'[i i'ZO i'Zc]gY +[E 1bT (``1 [+eb]gY ^+[ T'e]W c+e'ed'*ec+2 'a'[f YZ]gb ('e* Y]2+O T]g2[+e1 j)[]g/Z'[B %e1['TS k+eY+[d[+e +[ '[Ue'0+\d U'd]gT d+b'T1 Y]2+T]g2[+e b1[/+,+2]g U'Y'eE ]e][i '_'U]c]gY +[ (`1`. -[+e)1'Z]c A T]^c]gY +[ '*+[],1[O +ak]bk'd L15&ME b'T'Z[ 15&O1f bd'O f'4 -[+e)1'[ -2 _+di - k+eY+[d[+e 'eO d'*e+2]g U'Y'eB Y'['_+bE 4 9O1 Y]O 2+T]g2 - '[Ue'0+\d k+eY+[d[+e bd'['O 2]g U'Y'eE A k+eY+[d[+eS 4 9 b1[/+,+O 2]g U'Y'e L7Oe* ('0[]gY i[['eTc]gY 'Zb Y]2+T]g21 Y'b1[MB 1c+21[E d'e(+e

(`1`O)]e4'e'[. [^_+b +[ b_1d'T]gf[+e. 'ed'*ec]gY 1cd]Y'd'fc'4 )]e4'e'[1 [Y'[S (``1 [+eb]gY )]e4]gY +[ d'e(+e Y+3'[1,Y[+eE ]e][i _'de'bd]gY A 'a'i]gY +[ ('e* w'ed'*e'[i.x

$1y 1 13 1 7 2 8 $ 1 5 1 14 5

e]\ ('Td+e1'[+e 6> e]_+[ Y+T T'e]W +[ TeT[je1['Tc+2B ]ge'i'[^Z]ge (`1` TeT[je1['T]gY - 1e Y+` )]e4]W (]2]e wU'Y'O T'e)^'Z1[ 4e')e+e.xE 'Z[]gU+dA T1bc]gY -B g\')e'c -E ]e +/+ (`1`. ]g[+['e '[b_'a wc'a+2'[Z]g/xE '[c+e` T(',Y'['e 'Z[i'[ 'e')E ]e .[*'Y+[. +eT]g je]gY 'ed'*.eO c'4 (`1`[+e1 i'\. 6 9>> '[)'Y 'c+2 T21[+e +eTe')[*1 i'\1f59B 2'e* (`1`[+e. []gZ[O _+b T'e]W +[ 'e') (',Y'['2B %e1['TS +e( *]g VA'c]ec]gY -1e i] Y]e 'e)'[*]gYE ]gW+O W1* (`1`[+e. T',Y'c]ec]gY -1[ '_\+f]gf1^ 'e')]g/Z'Y(D Y+T e]_+]gY 69> >>> (`1` -e 'ed'*ec]gY5:B 5/+ Y'e*. [Y'[ 'e')]g/Z'Y( 1[^O]e ('[ bd+W41E '[\]g\d ]e'T. Td]g01B 1Z* *+_i]gY 1[^_+yb - U['e'c]eE ]e (`1`[+e. 1[i['c+O e'ed'*ec+[ 'Zbi'[ 'e') ]g T'd'eZ'2 X\)ed]g/Z'Y(E +/+ 1e'T'[]gY *e'[i Y1 \'ei ,]g)'*1_]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i +[ U'O Y'ec]gYB

[^_+b +eT['i+e. Th2]g,c1 'a'[f U1Yi1E 'Z[_+b -2 -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[.E ]e. ^1 T'e]W'[]gY _'d'b3'[+2 TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ c+e'(+eZ'2 U'ef+e1[E TU+eic1

b_1d'T]gf[+e T'e]W +[ b1[/+,c+2 Y1'Z[ (``1 T]WY1fE Y1[^*+a (`1`[ 1[i[ 1e+[ )]O Z]g/Z]g[ ^1 T'e]W ]g[+['2 'a'[f b_1d'O T]gf[+e11B '[e-'('[ '*]g ]_'[ ^1 .[*]g[]gY 1 'e*]g je)'[1,Y]gY ]e]\ (`1`[+e T',Yc'4 +[ Y]d 5> >>> >>> >>> b_1d'T]gf1 Y]2+T]g2[+e1f55E ]e][i Y1 i'[1 U'eZ]ge U','e d+b'T1 +[56B

#1 5 5 1 !5 Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 2'e* Y]2+T]g2[+e.S 4 9O[E 9O[E b_1d'T]gf[+e.E ]e][f1f T',Yc'4 - (`1`.E 'b+b ['3')4c'4 +[ Y1'b1[ '\3'd+2]g U'Y'eB

'efB $] T'e41i]cS ]^ ('['T'[ -c]2Z]gf1'y[ - 'a'` (+e+2 5>Oe* -`]gY _'dT+ec'4 ('e* T'a]gfc'4i[+e.E /+y *e'[i U'[X'e+W Ydi1 'e*Z]g[i +[B #'bdB e]\ U+W1['T'c]e )1d['T'[[+e 'b]gY +[E ]e []gZ[1bT w_'e,x (`1`. 'Z[i'[ ('e* -E ]e 'Z[ ^-e T'e]W _'d'U'T'[]e+[ 'a'` )'2B

Ë&#x203A;

'efB 5/+ ]e]\ )1d['T'[[+e .[*]g[]gY +[E ]e TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 )+e(['T'[ 'W(Z]ge1fE '_' 1y[^ U1Yi+e ]g[+[i ('f'a+2]gE ]e 'Z* 1W(Z]ge.

1bdc'4 -B

12

1 $ 13 " 8

'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[.B 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE 6>>8 /D [' 'b+2 -D w5/+ Y'[e'Y'b[]e+[ ['3'O _'de'bd'4 A 1e'T'['fe'4 )1d'h]eV+O e1 0'Y'['T Y+, ^U'`]Wc+f TZ'[i bd+W4+2E '_' 1[^_+yb *' U'`]Wc+f ([]g/Z'[.x57B ' ['A 'c+2'fe+2 -D w +[*'[1 (``1 )]e4]gO [+]g/Z'[ U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d Y+3'[1,Y[+e[ 'Z[i'[ ('e* +[E ]e *e'[f Y1'0'Y'['T A _'d'U'T'[]e+[ 'a'` )'2. '[U['e ('[ /c]gYx58B ye[ - i] T'e41i.B 7c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]gO [. h]eV]gY - ('f'de+2E /+ 1[^_+b - 'a'[f 1bd4]g Y1`'Yd]g/Z'[ +eTe1 ce' TZ'[i 'a'`'f+2B 'T'Z[ ]ei'[ \'d ('[ +[ 1Y'O []gY )1d['T'[[+e.E 'Z[i'[ i1^ U'c'['O T'[ - /c]gYE ]e TZ'[i. T'e]W -e 'a'`'['2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[B 1Zb *12+Y'Z1f 3]gb'h+O 2]g U'Y'e ]e]\ -c]2Z]gf1][1bdO)1d['T'[O [+e ]g,]gY +[ TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ U'ef. U'[+2 -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[1fS U'Y'e+2]cE ]e *' 'a'[V1[ /+Y' -B e'Y'('['T'y[ - 'e*O Z]i i+, U'Y'e [Y'[ Y]d+f]gY.B 7c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[ U'Y'V'Z[S TZ'[i. 'a'` - +T+2 Y1 \'ei _'d'U'T'[ 1e'*'eO V]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i]gYB bT U+d')'Z]gY 'Z2 _'d'U'T'[ 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*O Z]g[i]gY 'a'` +[ +T+2 T+[*'[1 je)'[1,YO [+e1 ,'[','[ A ('e* d+b'T[+eB 'T'Z[ +/+ -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. U1Yi ^]g[1E 1y[^ d+W1 T]g[+[' YZ]gb d+b]g/Z]g[[+e1 U+dE ]e][i U1Y[c]gY +[ *e' ce'B 'd'b3'[[ 'T[U'Zd -B [^_+b +eT['i+e. Th2]g,c1 'O a'[f U1Yi1E 'Z[_+b -2 -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/O Z]g[.E ]e. ^1 T'e]W'[]gY _'d'b3'[+2 TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ c+e'(+eZ'2 U'ef+e1[E T.O U+eic1B w 'e,x (``1 T'a]gfc'4i. A k]g[Tf1'[ ]gb]gY['b1e+2]gf U+d] 1y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ +T'eS 'Z* 'Y+[. _'d'U'T'[]g/Z'y[E /+y U'[X'e+W Ydi1 'e*Z]g[i -B 5/+ *+a T'bO T'4[+e ]g[+bE +T ]gb]gY['b1e+[i 'Z[ ('e* 4e')1e.E ]e. UYd]e+[ W+T'c'e]gY - (``1 )]e4]g[+]g/Z]g[.B

3

y 16 5!

1 1 1 3 5 8 [^]yg *]g U+[f 'Z*_1b1 'ed'i1[ ]g[+bB [^]yg +[ i] '^i+e.E Y',+e. A Y'\T. U+[f 'Z* )]gZ[1B y[^[ - ]e]\1^ *+e ]g[+f+2 i] U'b'T1 ]g T',Yc'4i1 VA'c]eY'[ Y+`B [^]yg +b [Y'[ 4[]W[+e1*B 5c .[*U'[e'_+b 1y[^[ - _'dX'a.E ]e je1['TS Y'd1 4'Ze. [+eb1 T]WY1f h'h]gT -E 1bT *eb1 T]WY1f 4'4Tc'4 - _1[* +W]g[)]cB

'e2, 4'ec1[1 0'Y'['T[+e]gY 'Zb U'ef+e1 _'d'b3'[[+e[ '[U'Zd -1[B 4'ec1[[ 1[i[ -2 U1'[]gY -eE /+ 1[^_+b +[ d+b'T[+e1 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e. h]3'[fc]gY 0'a'[)'('eB 'T'Z[ [' i1^ ('[ )1d+e 0'a'[)'T'[]g/Z'[ A 'a'c+2 Ab *e' Y1`]f]c W+T'c'ec]W Y+3'[1,Y[+e1 Y'b1[E ]e][i )]e4]gY +[ (``1 [+eb]gYB 31d['T'[[+e. 'e*+[ d'b[Z'T d'e1[+e -E 1[^ ]gb]gY['b1e]gY +[ )+[+d1T'[ A 4 9O1 ,'eY'['Ue'\ Y]2+T]g2.E ]e1 Y+` _'U_'[c]gY +[ (]2]e Y'[e'Y'b[ Ue'U'[)[+e. T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y1 )]e4]g[+]g/Z'[ c+e'(+eZ'2B 2'Zf U'ef - 4')]gYS ]yc T',Y+f 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e.B y[^ +[ 'b]gY \'d )1d['T'[[+eB 'd )1d['T'[[+eE 'Z* /c]gY T+[b'('[[+e _[*]gY +[E ]e 4 9O[ A [e' 4'4T')ec'4 Ue'U'[)[+e. 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y1 \'ei _'d'O U'T'[ 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+e1 U+dA'[i]cE ]e d+W1 +[ ]g[+f+2 Y121]['c]e d'e1[+e1 .[/'fi]gYB e'[f T'e41i]cS ]^ Y1 h'bd ^T'E ]e 'Zb Y]2+T]g21 T'a]gfc'4i.E dcZ'2O [+e1 _'U_'[Y'[ A h]3'[fY'[ T'e]W]g/O Z]g[.E 1[^_+b ['A )]e4]g[+]g/Z]g[. ['O 3')4c'4 +[5;B y[^ - 'b]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B 1bdc'O 4'\]g[^. U'Zd[]gY -E ]e Y+e je)'[[+e1 Y'b1[ (]2]e d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e. A []gZ[1bT *e'[f T',Y'c]eY'[ bd]gZ) 0'Y'['T. )ec'4 - Y1 w)ei]gYxE ]e1 U+W1['T. 1bdO c'4 -B g\'*e]g/Z]g[ *'eVe]gE /+ 1[^ 'b'f 4'c1/ /')'c]e. 1bd4]g[ Y+e Y'eY[1

T'a]gfc'4i1 Y'b1[D w$] '^i+e. d+b'[ 1Y b'WY.E A i] )ei]gY )ec'4 -1[ 'Z[ je+O e.E +e( [e' (]2]e Y'b+e. T',Y'c]ec+f1[E /+A *e'[f1f *+a Y+T[ -2 ^T'ex L 'WY]b 57=B5:MB y[^ +[ f]gZf d'21b h'bd+e.B 5/+ -c]2Z]gO f1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. X1\d -E 'Z* *+_i]gY 'aO [c',[ de'Y'('['T'[ T21[+e Yd'4+2E ]e 4 9O[ T'e]W -e 'a'` )'2 _'d'U'O T'[]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i]gYB 'T'Z[ +/+ 1bdc'4'\[^]gY [\c'4 d+W+T]g/Z]g[[ X1\dE '_' 4 9O[ U'Y],1^ '_'f]gZf _+di - [+eT'Z'f[1E ]e w1[i.x U,]e ('['O T'[]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B 5e( _'e, ('a+e]c ('f'dec]gY -E /+ 1[^ - 4 9O[E '[Y1`'_+b U'bT'[]gY +[i A U1'fY]g[i]c 2fc]gYB bT +e(A- Yd'4+y2 +bE /+ 1[^ - T'd'ec]gY (``1 [+eb]gYB 1Zb 7 y 16 5! 1 1 1 3 5 8

13

'[)'Y +T Y1'b1[ ]gb]gY['b1e+[i Y'e*]g (`1`.B 'dT+e'fe]gS )[]gY +b Y1 /'[)'O e'[E ]e. [Y'[ - 57 >>> >>> '[)'Y Y+4'fO c'4 (``1 A ,('W+f[]gY - ;> >>> d+W'[]f Y1 UbT' Y'e,'*'\d1 ^'h d'e'4iB 1Zbd+W f]gf'*ec]gY -E /+ 1[^_+b - )]e4]gY (`1`.B d[]gY +b /'[)'e'[ A '_\]gYS d+b[+O 2]c d'eje1['T T'a]gfc'4i[+eB +[de]O []gY (``'T]e1,[ -E ]e. 6> U'eT'[1 \+[i1 ('eVe]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W Y1 )]g[* -B $'Z2+e* ]gWW]gY +b 'Z* T]WYB d[]gY +b T]e1,1 /'W'[/1f [+eb ).dO [.c]W be'U A ['Z]gY \]ge`*B 1[Y1`'_+b ]gO \'*e]g/Z]g[* )e'c]gY +[ 8: ie]Y]b]Y[+e.B 4e'[iE .bd 1e+[f ^'h+e1E \'d U'Y'_'O d'b3'[ ,]gZ)+e +[ T',Y+2B $+, 'Y+['O Y]d ,]gZ). ]g[1 56 U'eT'[1 \+[i1 ('eVe]g/O Z]g[ A UbT' 4'a1 ([1 ^'h U'bd]g/Z]g[ L5MB ]ge'i'[^Z]ge ie]Y]b]Y1 )e+/+ Y+`d+O W]gY T' b+WYc'4iE ]e. 1e'e T_'4 +eT]g [e(+e\1T[+e1 d+bi - d'21b [e'[B 4e'[i 'b+b Y+4 h'/]gZ/[+e +[B 5e( 'c+21 Y]d1O T1f +b ['Z]gYE d+b[]gY +bE ]e Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge U]e1,]['T'[ h'/]gZ/ ('0'[c'4 - ]gWO W'U'Z'f )4+e]cE ]e][f 'e'[i[+e]gY 'c+O 21 Y'[e U]e1,]['T'[ )4+e T'[ L6MB 1y/+ *e'[i 1e'e ce' *'ebc'4 )ei+e +[B R^B 4e'[i 'c+21 Y'[e b_1e'2'VA )'2'e[+e +[E ]e][i *'ebc'4 +[ 1e'e ce'B 4]g i'O \]gY +b *e'[f1f Y+T. A 1 ,'eY'[b i+,S 'Z[ U+\d]g/Z'Y( *]geb - )'21bB 5e( 'c+21 ]gO \'*1e +b ['Z]gYE d+b[]gY +bE ]e b' -2 1e U+e/1[ _'e]ge'VA T',Y]g/Z]g[ ]g[1E ]e1 jW'T[+e. 31d *'b'c]ec'4 +[ 1e'e T]WO i1 L7MB +b[]gY +bE ]e 1 c+e`] 'Zb 'Y(]W`.

Y1 +eT'eE \'d +eT'e _'e'[1f - T',Yc'4B y[^ _'e'[ - *'B

61 1 1 1 5 "

1 "! 1 $8

'e'[.E 1[^_+b ]e '[c'[+f1[i ie]Y]O b]Y1 Y]*+21 'Zb Y'b.E ]g[1 Y]d 6E: b'[d1O Y+de U'bd]g/Z]g[B 1Z[ 31d h'/'/c'4 T]X+e1 ce' L8M E ]e][i U['e'c]e]g/Z]g[ +[ d'21b _'e'[1 )'2'e[+e1[ *'b'c]eO c+2 b_1e'2'VAB 1Zb )'2'e[+e. T_'4 +[ Y1 U+[i1E ]e. *e'[f _'U]gY - 1e+[f d+W]gYB 4]g U'Y],c]gY +bE ]e _'e'[. a'f1]['2 T+e_]c - h'/'/c'4E 1[^_+b [\c'4 - Y]O 14

1 $ 13 " 8

d'T' f]gf'['T1 ce'B 5/+ ie]Y]b]Y1 'Zb Y]*+2. 'Y(]W`]g/Z'Y( i'[*+bE '_' _'O e'[. TV)c1 +eTe')[*1 Y1 4'Ze1f YZ]gb. 1B 31d'T'[ Y1 )ei]gY 'Zb a'f1]['2 *'O b'c]e]g/Z]g[[ '[c'[c+2 - w1[0+[+e'T'[ 'ed'b]c]e )2]g3)]e4]fx5<B y[^ +b T'eO 4]gYE 'Zb )2]g3)]e4]f. 1[i['(+e'('ye 'a'` +T+2E /+y 1[0+[+e[ - bd+W4+2 'Z[B 5/+ 'Zb /'[)'e'[]gY 21[+e U]g\'[c+e[+O e1 Y1 Y+4 3'[]g/E ]ed+W Y121]['c]e Y'[eO Y]g[e '_e'[i[+e +[ c'X'ac]gYE A *e'[i 'Z[_+b *'b'c]ec'4 21[+1[E ]e T'e]W'O ['Z1e U+\d]g/Z'Y( )d[+2 i] ]g,'4.E 'e*O Z]i TYd'4+1yeE ]e 'Z* (]2]e 'a'eT'[+e.

1[i['(+e'('e +[ *'b'c]ec+2B 1[\]g\d ]^B 'T'Z[ 'Zb 3'[]g/1 '_e'[i[+e1 *'O b'c]e]g/Z]g[. \'d _'e, -S U'Y+Y'd'4 4 9O1 _'e]gZe1 *'b'c]e]g/Z'[ U+dB 1 ]2+T]g2'Z1[ T+[b'('[]g/Z'[ *'b')ei]gY (+ec]gY - Y+T 'Z2 U'Y+Y'd]g/Z]g[ LMolecular Biology of the CellMB 1Z[d+W [\c]gY -E ]e +/+ (``'T]O e1,. /+[1b1 )[*'T1 ^'h 21[+eE '_' 4 9O1 _'O e]gZe[+e. Y1'b1[ U'c'b'e T21[+1[ 8> T12]Y+de +eT'e]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W \'d ('e'T /+21E ]e[ 'Z[O _+b - d+W'c]ec'4 )[*'T1 Y+`E ]e /+21 f'[T'O f'4 U'dc'4 U+\d]g/Z'Y( T'e+21 - )d[+2B

1 1

+d] d+b[]gY +b Y+T ]ge1\ f]gf'['TE ]e1 ce' [\c'4 -S w +efe+i _'e'[. A 'c+21 Y]d1T1f ]gb]gY['b1e+i 'Z[x L9MB 5e( _'O e'[. 'h1* Y+` +b 'a[]gYE d+b[]gY +bE ]e *' b]c]e'T'[ _'e'[ ^-B 1Z[ T',Yc'4 - 1e'e h'/'/c'4 +eT]g /+2+e1fE ]e][i Y1'f'4 +[ 1e'e1f U'c'b'e U+a'c]e]g/O Z'[ ce' )d[c]W h]ie T'Ye`'T[+e]cB 1Zb _'e]gZe. [Y'[ - ]2]ec'4 b'[*]gWi1 L:MB '[T'e4 i'e'[]gY +bD i] V+ai]gY 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 Y]*+2[ -S TZ'[i1 'Y+['Y+4 'O a+W4c'4[+e1f Y+T.B 4 9O1 Y+T Y]2+T]g2. 1e (]2]e )'2'e[+O e]c ]g h'/]gZ/[+e]c T',Y]gY - Y1 ie]Y]O b]YB 4 9O1 b'[*]gWi1 'bd1X'[[+e. T]^O c]gY +[ U1Yi+e1 ,]gZ)+e L;M B bT 1y[^ +[ *e'[i A 1y[^ *+e +[ T'd'e]gYB

1 5 1 1 1 35 6 1 1 1 3

4 9O1 )'Wd[1i[+e. ('f'U'Zd+2]g U'O Y'e ['3 _+di - ]gb]gY['b1e+[i b'[*]gWO i1 T'Ye`'T[+e.S 'bd1X'[[+e.B 4e'[i T',Yc'4 +[ ^]eb d'e(+e Td]e[+e1fB 5/+ b'[*]gWi. Y+`d+W1f 'a'[V['f[+[iE Z]gO e'i'[^Z]ge /+21 ce' TY[' 'bd1X'[1 Y1 Td]eB 31d['T'[[+e. *e'[f1f Z]ge'i'[^O Z]ge. [\'['T+2 +[ Y1 d'a]cS 1E 3E !E 9B e'[i '_\+2 +[E +e( U'Zd['(+e+2 +[E ]e 'Zb d'a+e1 U'`]e*'T'[ *'b'c]e]g/Z]gO [. 1e'T'[]gY T]* -E ]e. T'e]W - dcZ'2[+e h]3'[f+2B 'c'['('e i+, 4'[]/ - ]e,+1 'ZO (]g(+[.E ]e. bd+W4c+f d'b[1[[+e]e* *'O e]gYB 1Z[ U['e'c]e]g/Z]g[ dc+f Y'e*T'[f

5

w1[0+[+e'T'[ )2]g3)]e4]fx [^_+b - h'/'/c'4 4 9O[

2

2``'T]e1,]gY 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g2. [Y'[ /+[1b1 )[*'T1 Y+` d+W'c]ec'4 8> T1O 2]Y+de +eT'e]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W ('e'T /+21B #'/]gZ/1 'Zb T'a]gfc'4i. U'O Y'ec]gY - 1[0+[+e'T'[ )2]g3)]e4]f

3

6 4 7

U'W]e*'Tfc+2]g U+a')e1 Y1`]f]cB 9+A 'ZO (]g(+[[ ]g[1 .[*'Y+[. +eT]g wd'axS T+d A )14E 'Z*]gU'[*+eV *e'[f]c T',Yc]gY +[ '[/1cO'[U'Y'e ('a+e A ['3'*'b]gO /Z]g[[+eB bT 4 9O[ ]g[1 ^]eb d'aB 1Zb d'a+e]c T',Yc'4 ('a+e. T]^c]gY +[ +aO Z'T[+e Lde1_2+d[+eMB 5aZ'T[+e. Y1'b1[ T',Y]gY +[ w_'dY]g/Z]g[[+exE ]e][i T]^O c]gY +[ )+[+eB ]ge'i'[^Z]ge )+[ _'e]gO ['T]gY - Y1`1[ U'\c]c 6; >>> d'aB 3+[+e.

A *e'[i 1e'e Y1'f[]W +eT'e U'dc'4[+O e. Y1'b1[ T',Y]gY +[ 'a'[V1[ ie]Y]b]YO [+eS w)ei1 )2]g3[+exB bT 'Y(]W` w)1ei.xE ]e. ('WT'f'4 - 67 ie]Y]b]Y[+e1fE _'e]gO ['T]gY - Y+e je)'[1,Y1 (]2]e dcZ'2[+e.S )+[]Y. 1B e'T'[]gY )+[]Y. 'b+b Y1 )e'*'e'[ 21[1E ]e[ '[b'UY'['h'T 1[k]eY'f1' _'e]g['T]gYB 8[*U'[]ge U'\c]c Y'e*]g )+[]Y. T',Yc'4 - Y]d +e+i Y121'e* U1Yi+O e1 ,]gZ)+e1fS 4 9O1 b'[*]gWi1 'bd1X'[O [+e1f5=B 3+[]Y1 ]W` d+W+T]g/Z]g[. Td+W'O c]ec1 U'[e')1d'e'[1 U','e -` ]g[+f]W 86< U'd]e1 Y+`B 5/+ U'\c1 'a[+[iE ]e Z]gO e'i'[^Z]ge (``]gY T' )+[]Y1 +eT]g je1['TE '_' U'd]e[+e1 .[*U'[]ge /1c. TT',Y1 <9:B bT +/+ h]eV+b '[V'Y( 'ed')e+2 )+O []Y1 ]W` 1[k]eY'f1'[E '_' _+di - )e+b Y]d <> d'e1S 'a'[f 'eV'T]ge*1S 2e1c '\O 3'd'[i'Z1[ je]cB 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE +/+ []gZ[1bT i+, U'`]WO c1 'ed')e+2 'Z* ]W` 1[k]eY'f1'[E '_' Yd'4+y2 +bE /+ 1[^_+b +b 3d'f[+2]g U'eO Z]ge'c]e U'bd'h]e U'd]e[+e1 1[k]eY'O f1'[ A d+W'c]e+2]g i] Y'eY[]gY )d[c]W 5>> de121][ Y1Te]bT]_1T (`1`[+e1f Z]ge'O i'[^Z]ge]gYB 1[\]g\d TU'Y'V'Z[c+bE ]e *' 'Z[i'[ '[U['e1[ -E ]e _'dT+e'f[+2[ '[O )'Y c+e - Y+e +eA'T'Z]g/Z]g[1fB ]2+T]g2'Z1[ T+[b'('[]g/Z'[ A 1[k]eO Y'd1T'Z1 Y1 _e]k+b]e 'b+2 -D w +T )e'Y 4 9O[E ]e. ^]e c1X'T]gY T]g[+['e Y+T 3]O e'['e* b'[d1Y+de 4'c'2E T'e]W - _'U+2 'Z[i'[ 1[k]eY'f1'E ]ei'[ Y+T de121][ b+WY'_['T[+e.x6>B y[^ - b' [\'['T]gYB [^_+b [\+f1[iE 4 9O[ ('WT'f'4 - )+[+O 1 ]ge'i'[^Z]ge (``]gY T' 'Zb )ei1S )+[]Y1 +eO T]g je1['TE 'Zb1[i[S 8: ie]Y]b]YB

16

1 $ 13 " 8

e1fS 'Z[ Ue'U'[)[+e1fE ]e][f Y1`]f]c wT'O a]gfc]gY -x '[,]g)'T'[ Y'e* 'e'e'4.B ]ge'i'[^Z]ge (``]gY T' 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e1 'Y(]W`'T'[ U'c'i'4]g[B 4 9O]gY dcZ'2O [+e[ 'Z[i'[ 31d +[E ]e .[*'Y+[. Y+T /+Z1 )*'2 Y]2+T]g2. T'e]W - _'e]g['T+2 'Z[O i'[ \'d 1[k]eY'f1'E ]e ('c'e'e T21[+e wT'a]gf+2]gx 79> '[)'Y 'c+21 \'d Y'e*E i'[ T' 'ZbjeB 1[^*+a +eTe1 ce' )]Z]g/O Z]g[ ]g[+f]W Z]/ Y121'e* Y'e*T'[f 4 9O[ U',1c ('e'T \+ed]c T4'4T+e 'Z* /+Z1 )*'2. 65B

3 $ 1 1 ! 5 1 y

['Z'4 Y1Te]d+3[1T'Z1 ,'e)'fY'[.S dcZ'2[+e1 _'U_'[Y'[ ]^ Y1 b'ei 1e T'O e]W]g/Z'Y( ^1 T'e]W U'Y+Y'dc+2 'Zb Y]O 2+T]g21 U+dB T'd1 'a[+[i U+dAZ'2 je1O ['T.D b+WY'_['T. d_'c]e]gY - Y+, 1e U'Y'^'h T'a]gfc'4i]cE U'e/ ]g h'Z2]g[ Y'T+e+b]cB 'bT'4 ^T'E ]e 3+2'f1 Y'e* - _'de'bd+2 'Z[B '\c1 'a[+[i ['AE ]e b+WY'_['T1 'e0+i. _'ZY'['c]ec'4 [e'[]cE /+ 1[^ 1[k]eY'f1' T' [e' Y+`B 1c+2'f[+[i ['AE ]e dcZ'2[+e1 4'c'2. ]^ Y1 VA]c ^1 '[*e'*'a[]gY b+WY'_['O

TeT['_'dT]gY [^_+b - 'a'`'[]gY 4 9O1 TeT[je1['T.

– &+eY+[d[+e1 Y+i+['Z1 'Zb U'dc'4. 'a'[V['f[]gY 4 9O1 +eT]g /+2+e.

— +i+['Z1

'Zb U'dc'4[+e.E ]e_+b U1Yi j)d')]e4+2]c 4 9O1 'a'[V1[ /+2+e.E []e \W/' +[ UZ]gb]gY TeT['T1 _'e]gZe VA'c]e+2]g U'Y'e

˜ 'U]W jW'T'VA 'if'[[+e. 'a'`O []e*]gY +[ k+eY+[d[+e1 Y+i+['[ A T'Z]g['f[]gY [e' '\3'd'[i.

™ 1e*Z]g[i]gY VA'c]ec]gY +[ 4 9O1 +eT]g 'Y(]W`'T'[ _'e]gZe[+e

T1 i'\1 A ^'h1 ce'B y[^ T+,e'T'f[+1eE +/+ 'Z* b+WY'_['T. _'e]g['T+e ]^ /+ '['e0+i 1[k]eY'f1'E 'Z2 Ubd'T ]g Y'[O e'TeT1d Ue'U'[)[+eE /+ 1[^_+b _+di T'a]gf+2E _'U_'[+2 ]g c+e'[]e])+2 Y1 ('e* Y+3'[1,YB 1y/+ ^-1e Yd'41E ]e 'Z[ ('['T'[]g/Z'[ 'e*Z]g[i -B ge+Y[S +/+ T'[ Ue'U'[)[+eE T' ['A Y+T.E ]c T',Y+2 *e'[iB 3'2 ^- 4 9O[ U'Y+Y'd+2 b+WY'_['O T1 T'Y )ei1 U+dB 3+[]Y1 Y'b1[ Y1 '\3'O d]g/Z'[ Y+` [\c]gY -D w1b+2E ]e )+[]Y. )1ei -E ]^ /+ h]3'(+e]g/Z]g[ -E 'Z2 X\Y'eO d]g/Z]g[B 1Zb )ei1 (]2]e dcZ'2[+e. T'O e+21 - U+\d]g/Z'Y( /c'Z['f[+2xB +W1['T[ 'c+2'f[]gY -D w3+[]Y. \'d w3+2'f1x )1ei -E ]e]cU+dA U'Y'_'d'b3'[ _'ZY'[[+O e]gY T'e]W - 1e ['3'V+a[]g/Z'Y( _'dX+O ['U'[c+2 A .[/+efc+2x66B 1U' 4 9O1 Y+T 'Z2 T'eA]e 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[B

1 5 1 6 5

9'[)'e'[]gY 2a]g/Z]g[ - d1e]gYE A *]g bTb]gY +b Yd'4+2E /+ 'e*Z]i (``'T]e1O ,1 Y+` 'Y+[ ('[ '[\'e0 -B '[T'e4 [T'O d]gY +b Y1 'Z2 f]gf'[Y]g\S 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g21

Y1 h]ie Y]*+2E ]e. )d[c]gY - '_'TZ' 'eTO W1 Y+`B e' c+eA]gY T' Y1 )e]g/Z]g[D w +WO Y+i T]X'T.xB +WY]gY +b T]X'T. A bTbc]gY - f]gf'*e]g/Z]g[.B +W1['T. _'dY]gY -D w4 9O[ T'd'e]gY - 'a[c',[ +eT]g T'O eA]e '\3'd'[iB 1a'`1[S 'Z[ TeT['O _'dTc]gY -E ]e_+b,1 Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge []e (`1` ]g[+[' )+[+d1T'T'[ dcZ'2[+e1 Y1 'Y(]W`'T'[ je1['TB 41d+[i f]gf'*e]g/O Z]g[.xB '[T'e4 U'Zd[c]gY - Y1 ('e* T'a]gfO c'4i ]g[+f]W Y+i+['E ]e. a](]d[+e1 Y1 3]gY( -B 1Zb Y+i+['[ Y]d+[]gY - 4 9O1 TeT['T1 _'e]gZe1[E Y1'[]gY - *e' 4'Ze1[ A \'e0c]gY - 'a'`E 1[^_+b )['fi.S a+2b+O e1 ce'Z]cB +i+['[ 'Z[i'[ 'e') - \'e0O c]gYE ]e ^+b T'e]W'[]gY d+b[+2E /+ 1[^ '[]gYE b'T'Z[ [T'd]gY +bE ]e 1e U+dA]gY /]W[]gY - ]^ /+ Y+TE 'Z2 +eT]g []e TeT['T1 _'e]gZeB +W1['T. \'e]g['T]gY -D w 'e,+fc'4 f]gf'*eY'[ Y1`]f]c *]gi d+b[]gY +iE /+ 1[^ - d+W1 ]g[+[]gYE +e( 4 9O[ TeT['O _'dTc]gY -B 1 3]gY( Y]2+T]g2[+eE ]e][i

3 4

3 2 5/+ 4 9O1 b'[*]gWi. 1e ^'O h+e]c U'c'b'e 21[+e )['fi1 a+2b+e1[E '_' 'Zb Y+i+['[ [e' ce'Z]c T'[f[+e 'c+21 i'[ <> T12]Y+deO0'Y 'e')]g/Z'Y(

1 3 4

2

17

+T )e'Y 4 9O[ T'e]W - _'U+2 'Z[i'[ dcZ'2[+eE ]ei'[ Y+T de121][ b+WY'_['T[+e.

U'eZ]ge'c]e 'Zb_1b1 Y+i+['[+eB e'[i ]W` )+[]Y. _'dX+['U'[]gY +[ .[*'Y+O [. ]g/ 0'Y]gYx68 Ld+Rb w ]2+T]g2E ]e .[O /+efc]gY A _'dX+['U'[c]gY -x \e`'['T.E -` 6>MB

5y 7 8 95 ! " 4 9O T]^c]gY +[ k+eY+[d[+eE Y1'b1[ '[f[]gY +[ 4 9O1 _'e]gZe1 ]W` +eT'Z[i]cB 4e'[i ['3 +eT]g Y'b1 +[ ('0'[]gY 4 9O1 b'[O *]gWi.S '[`'d+2]c T'Ye`'T[+e1fE '_' Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge T]WY. ]e_+b U1Yi j)d')]eO 4+2]cS bd+W4]gY +[ []e U'Y'_'d'b3'[ 2e'f]gYB +[i ^+[i T'e]W [+eT'Z'f[+2 'Zb Y+i+['Z1 (]2]e Y'[e'Y'b[+e.E je1['TS 'Z[ h]ie1T )]e41i.E ]e. '[f[]gY - Y+i+['O Z1 'a`A]c A 'a'[V['f[]gY b'[*]gWi1 T]WO Y+e. 'Z[_+bE ]e *e'[i ]^ /+ 3XXc]gY +[E 'Z2 ','d ]2]ec]gY +[ A bd'[]gY _'e]gZO e1 d+biE ]^ -2 T'e]W +[i f]gZf d'2E /+ 1[^O _+b +[ Y1 i'[1 '[)'Y be(')ec]gY 4 9O1 []e Y]2+T]g2[+e.B +d'iei1e - b'T'Z[E ]e b3'2[+e[ '[Y1`'_+b U'Zd['(+ec]gY +[ A ,'eY'['21 X\)ed]g/Z'Y( ]gWWc]gYx Ld+Rb 5:E 5; -`+e1 [T'e.MB +W1['T. \'e]g['T]gY - 1e 3]bi.D w2'Zf Y+[i T'e]W +[i Ubd'T f]gZf d'2E /+ 1[^ 'e')]g/Z'Y( - '\3'd]gY 'Zb Y+i+['[B [^_+b [T'd+f1iE 'Z[ \'d 'e') - .[O /'[]gYB e'T'[]gY k+eY+[d[+e1 Y+i+['[ Y+T c'ZeTZ'[]gY '[f[]gY - 4 9O1 5>> 'bO d1X'[S U1Yi+e1 ,]gZ)+e67 B 5/+ 'Zb Y]2+O T]g21 b'[*]gWi. 1e ^'h+e]c U'c'b'e 21O [+e )['fi1 a+2b+e1[E '_' Y+i+['[ [e' ce'Z]c T'[f[+e <> T12]Y+deO0'Y 'e'O )]g/Z'Y(B bT ('Td+e1'[+e1 Y+` Y+i+O ['[ \'e0c]gY - d'b. '[)'Y 'c+21 'e')B 'e*]g (``]gYS 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 d'e(+e Y'b+e]gYE Y1'[)'Y1f )]e41 +[ '[f[]gY

3

18

4 9O[ _'dX+['U'[]W Y+i+['[ U+a'O []gY -B +b'*'\d]gY U'Zd[c]gY - Y+T ]gO e1\ Y+i+['B ' []gZ[_+b '[f[]gY - 4 9O1 Y1 U'dc'4]cE ('Zf 'c+21 *'[*'WB 4 9O1 _'e]gZe. Yd[]gY - 'Zb Y+i+['Z1 Y1 T]WY1f A *]geb - )'21b YZ]gb T]WY1fS 'a'[f ]eAh]h]3]g/Z]g[ Te+2]gB '[T'e4 [T'd]gY +bE ]e Y+i+['Z1f *]geb - )'21b Y1 'a'[V1[ /+2B y[^ - *'B +W1['T. \'e]g['T]gY -D w4 9O1 +eTO e]e* '\3'd'[i. de'[bTe1_f1'[ -B 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g2. +e(+i *]geb ^1 )'21b 1e '_'U]c (['T'e'[1fS (``'T]e1,1fB 1Z* *+_i]gY 1[^_+yb +[ .[/+efc]gY A j)d'O )]e4c]gY )+[+e.S ('W'*e'd]Yb+e. 'Z[ (]2]e b_1d'T]gf[+e1E ]e][f1f T',Yc'4 - Y'e*]g Y'eY1[.B &+eY+[d[+e1 Y+i+['[ 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 ce' )d[]gY - 'Z[ )+[.E ]e[ 'Td1c'f+2 - (``1f +T]W i1Y1'T'[ ',*'O [\'[[+e1 ',*+f]g/Z'[ U+dA'[i]cB +d] Y+i+['[ 'ed')e]gY - dcZ'2 )+[. 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 ce'E ]e[ 1e T'a]gfc'4i]c [Y'[ - 4 9O1 Y1 /+21[B &+eY+[d[+e1 Y+i+['O Z1 j)[]g/Z'Y( 9O[ 1e ce' - wU'c'i]gYx 4 9O1 )+[+e]gY T]*'c]ec'4 Ue'U'[)[+O e.B 1Z[]gU+dA *]geb - )'21b (``'T]e1,1f A \'e0c]gY - *+_1 a1(]b]Y[+eE ]e][i -2 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e1 U'Y'V'Z[S )]e4]gY +[ '[O Ue'0+\d b_1d'T]gf1 \W/'[xB

Z]ge U','e'c]e d'e'd+b'T b_1d'T]gfO [+eE ]e][f1f T',Yc'4 - i] Y'eY1[.S k+eO Y+[d[+e.E UZ]gbc'4i[+e.E je)'[[+e. A 'Z2[B +[f U1Y' i] 4 9O[ TeT[je1['Tc]gY - A be(')ec]gYE ]e Ue'U'[)[+e1 Y1 /'eY U'c'i'4]g _'de'bd 21[1 []e (``1 Y+` .[O /+efc+2]gB

!]gf'*e]g/Z]g[. *1d+21b U1'fY]g[i]c +b 2fc]gYB 9+eAb *]g 'Zb_1b1 /'[)'e'[ +e(+i ^-1e d+b+2D '[^'h d_'c]ec'4 +b 'Z[ )Z]gd'e'e[+e1 '\3'd'[i]cE ]ci+e bd+W4+2 +[ 'Zb 'Y+[.B bT +/+ (]2]e f]gO f'[Y]g\[+e. bTb+1[ \'e0c+2 Y1'0'Y'['TS [+eT'Z'f[+2]c 'Z[ U'eZ]ge U','e'c]e _e]f+b[+e.E ]e d+W1 +[ ]g[+[]gY Y'e*]g (``1 Y+`E 1z[^ '_\+f]gf1^ d+b'e'[ T21[+eB 'T'Z[ 'Y+[1f '_\+f]gf1^[ 'Z[ -E ]e 'Zb (]2]e _e]f+b[+e. d+W1 +[ ]g[+O []gY i] je)'[1,Y1 'c+21 i'[ 5>> de1O 21][ (`1`[+e]gY U+[f 'Zb _'U1[B $] 4 9O[ .[/+efc]gY - A d'21b - U'Y'_'d'b3'[ Ue'U'[)[+eE ]e_+b,1 _'de'bdc+[ U'eO

y" 5 1 5 1 5 5 "9 " 5 8

1[*e'*'a['[i c+e[')e1 U'ef1[D w yc T',Y+f 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e.xB 1bdc'4'O \]g[^[ 'b]gY -E ]e 'Zb w)1ei.x A [e' Y+` _'Uc]W Ue'U'[)[+e. )ec+2 +[ U,]e ('O ['T'[]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W +W1['T1 T]WY1fB

de'[bTe1_f1' [^_+b - 4 9O[ w.[/+efc]gYx

â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4 9O1 'Zb U'dc'4. i'[*c]gY -E A 'eV'Tc'4 /+2+e1f Y+T. dcZ'2[+e. h]3'[f]gY - 9O1[

â&#x20AC;&#x201D; 9O[

wT'e*]gY -x 4 9O[ A c+ef[]gY )+[1 T]*.B 4 9O1 T]*. U'Zd[]gY - de'[bTO e1_d'f[]W Y+i+['Z1[E /+ ]ed+W1f _+di bTb1 1e )]e4. A ]ed+W c+e`'f[1

Ë&#x153; e'U'[)[+e]c (+a[c'4 9O[ *]geb - )'O

21b (``'T]e1,1f A \'e0c]gY - *+_1 a1(]b]Y[+eE ]e][f _+di - h]3'[f1 b_1O d'T]gf1 ('e* \W/'[ UZ]gb+2]g w)'Wd[1i.x

â&#x201E;˘ e'[bTe1_f1'[ 1e'T'['f[]W Y+i+['[ 1

4 2

19

5 " E 8 95 ! " 5 1 5 1 1 " -

!

3

9

1

!

3 9

1

3

!

[^_+yb - 4 9O[ T'e]W'[]gY TeT[je1['Tc+2 'Zbi'[ X\)ed]g/Z'Y(B 4 9O1 _'e'['b'[*]gWi. ]g[1 ^]eb d+b'T1 U1Yi+eS 1 L'*+[1[ME 3 L)]g'[1[ME ! Lf1d],1[M A 9 L/1Y1[MB $1Y1'T'[ 'Zb ^]eb U1Yi+e. T',Y]gY +[ b'[*]gWi1 'bd1X'[O [+e.B 4e'[f1f Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge. Y1\d []gZ[ ,]gZ)]c - U'[*+b )'21bB 5/+ 'bd1X'[1 Y1 Y'b]gY 1O[ -E '_' YZ]gb Y'b. Y1\d 9O[ - 21[]gYE 1bT 3O[ Y1\d !O1 U+d - ,]gZ) T',Y]gYB +dA'O ('e +/+ T' b'[*]gWi1 Y1 T]WY.E 'e*+[ _'e, -E /+ 1[^_1b1[ - YZ]gb T]WY.B 5/+ b'[*]gWi1 Y1 T]WY]gY 39!1 U1Yi+e[ +[E '_' *e'[f *1Y'f !139 U1Yi+e[ +[B 1Yi+e. d'e(+ec]gY +[ 1e+[f +eT'e]g/Z'Y(E b'T'Z[ *e'[f ,]gZ)+e1 +eT'e]g/Z]gO [[+e. 1e'e U'c'b'e +[B 1Zb Ue'\'21 Y]2+T]g21 T'a]gfc'4i1 ('f'U'Zd]gY. Y+T ]ge1\ U'Zd[')]e4]g/Z'[ *]ga ('f+fD 4 9O[ T'e]W - '[.[*U'd T'd'e+2'_+b _'dX+['U'[c+2B &+eY+[d[+e1 Y+i+['[E ]e.

T'd'e]gY - 'Z* )]e4.E c+ef[]gY - (``1 T]e1,]gY ','d 2]W'O f]W 'Zb ^]eb U1Yi+e. A *e'[f]c UZ]gb]gY - 4 9O1 ('0'[c'4 b'[*]gWi1 U'Y'e []e T]WY+eB 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g2[ 1bT'_+b [Y'[ - Y1 )ei1E ]e. T'e]W - .[/+efO c+2 ]g _'dX+['U'[c+2B 5c b' '[.[*U'd TeT[c]W _e]f+b -B 'e*]g TZ'[i1 Y1`1[ dA]W]g/Z'[ .[/'fi]gY 4 9O1 Y]2+T]gO 2. _'dX+['U'[c]gY - Y]d'c]e'_+b 5> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> '[)'Y A 'Z[ -2 T'd'eZ'2 X\)ed]g/Z'Y( 6<B

1e*Z]yi 'Zb 3]bi+e. 0'Y'['T'ce+_ +[ A U'T'O b]gY +[ )1d'T'[ h'bd+e1[B ]eU1e U+dAZ'21 Y'b1[D T'e]yW +[ 'Zbje Y'eO *1T T'a]gf+2 'Z[_1b1 /'[)'e'[E ]e [+eT'Z'fO c+f 'Zb U]*c'4]gYB 5/+ []gZ[1bT h]eV+[ [Y'[ ('[ T'a]gf+2E TU'bT'['[E ]e \'d *0c'e]g/Z]g[[+e1 'a'` TT'[)[+[B +di - [\+2 ['AE ]e \'d ('[ *+aO Ab U'Zd[1 ^- )+[]Y1 A [e' )]e4]g[+]g/Z'[ Y'b1[B 31d['T'[[+e. \'e]g['T h]eV]gY +[ T'e*'2 (]O 2]e )+[+e. A U'bT'['2E /+ *e'[f1f Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge[ 1[^ *+e - T'd'e]gYB 1[^*+a )+[+e. ,('W+f[]gY +[ 4 9O1 Y]2+T]g21 .[*'Y+[. Y1 h]ie Y'b.B bT 1y[^ *+e +[ T'd'e]gY 'Z[ +eT'e U'dc'4[+e.E ]e][i 1e'e +[ Y1'f[]gY )+[+e.B 31d['T'[[+e. Y]2+T]gO 21 'Zb U'dc'4[+e. '[c'[]gY -1[ w3'e'Yx LT]WYO ['T1 '[_+di [Z]g/+eMB 'T'Z[ c+e`+eb [e'[i h]3+f1[ 1e+[f d+b'T+d.B 8bd +eA]gZ/1[E 'Zb U'dO c'4[+e[ +[ c+e'UbT]gYE /+ 1[^_+b A ]ei'[ +[ j)O d')]e4c]gY )+[+e.B 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE +/+ )1d['T'[O [+e[ '[)'Y T'e]W'['Z1[ bd+W4+2 4 9O1 Y]*+2. A Y+i+['[+e.E ]e][i 'ed')e]gY A be(')e]gY +[ 'Z[E

'e*Z]i [e'[f TU'`]Wc+ye 'Z[_+b '[+2E ]e 'Z* Y]*+2[ '\3'd1 wT+[*'[1x Y]2+T]g21 [Y'[B '[e'U'Zd k1,1T]b 1^'e* &1[Y'[. 1e Y'U1f T'eX 0'Y'['T 'a'` )e'd'3d'O T1[ )e+f U+dAZ'2 _'e, 3]bi+e.E ]e][i f]gZf +[ d'21b [e' 3]['eU]g/Z]g[.D w5b ^+Y T'e]W bd+W4+2 'Z[E 1[^ ^+Y U'bT'[]gYx69B 1Zb bT,(]g[i. U'dT'_+b T1e'a+21 -E +e( 3]bi. 4 9 bd+W4+2]g Y'b1[ -B 31d['O T'[[+e. '[)'Y ^+[ T'e]W bd+W4+2 4 9O[ TeT['_'dT]W ]g de'[bTe1_d'f[]W )][+ Y+T Y+i+['E i'[1 ]e 'Y(]W`]g/Z'Y( ^+[ _'dT+e'f[]gYE /+ 1[^_+b +[ *e'[i )]eO 4]gYB 1Z[]g'Y+['Z[1cE [e'[f1f ]Y'[i U'O Y],c'4]g/Z'Y( _[*]gY +[E ]e 'Zb 'Y+[. 'a'`'f+2 - Y1 \'ei T]gZe _'d'U'T'[]g/O Z]g[[+e1 'e*Z]g[i]gYB 1e*Z]i U]*c'4]gY [+eT'Z'fc'4 d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e. /1T]g[i T'[)[]ygY +[ 'Zb c'eT'41[B e]\ ('[1Y'f Y'e*1T +T+2 +[ 'Z[ +,O e'T'f]g/Z'[E ]e h'bd+e[ 'Z2 ('[ +[ cT'O Z]gYB %e1['TS )1d['T'[ &e+[b1b $e1T.E ]e. U'Y'd+W '\3'd'[i1 'e*Z]g[i]gY U'Zd['(+e+f 4 9O1 TeT['T1 _'e]gZe1 T'a]gfc'4i.E 'b+2 -E ]e 'Zb Y]2+T]g2. ^'O h','[f 2'c - T',Y'c]ec'4 A '[U.['e -E ]e 'Z[ 'a'`'['e Y1 \'ei '[[_'O d'T 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+e1 U+dA'[i]cB ' 'a'` - i'\]gY 'Z[ c'eT'4.E /+ ,'e)'O f'4 Y1di ]g[+f]W 'Z2Y]2]e'T'Z1[[+e[ +[ 4 9O[ ]gW'eT+2 +eT1eE ]e_+b,1 'Zbd+W TZ'[i 'a'` )' 6:B bT U'[e'U'Zd h121b]h' 7[/.[1 &2]g[E ]e. 9> d'e1 '/+1,Y1 `'d')]c - +W+2E c+e`+eb Tde]gT h]3+f 1e d+b'T+d.B <5 d'e+T'[]gY [' bTb+f U'c'd'2E ]e TZ'[O i. U'[X'e+W Ydi1 'e*Z]g[i -B [^]ygB 'dO X'a. 4 9O1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[[ -eB 5e( [e'[ 'b'f1[E ]e 1e []e U'Y],Y]g[i. )]gO f+ )1d['T'[[+e1 U'Y'e '[.[*]g[+21 21[1E [' _'d'b3'[+fD w1c+21 c'd [e'[f U'O Y'eB 5b ]W` TZ'[i]gY 'a'`[]e*c+2 +Y 'Zb bT,(]g[i]cS DDDD U+dA+2 h'bd+e1[E ]ge -2 ]e *e'[i 'a'`[]e*+[x6;B ye[ - i] T'e41i.B bT ]yge +[ 'a'`[]eO *]gY h'bd+e.B 'dT+e'fe]gS Y1 UbT' )]eO 4'e'[E ]ed+W '\3'd'[i. 1e'T'['fO

c]gY - 'cd]Y'd'fc'4 VA]cB 'Y'T'eO )1^. )]e41 - )f]gY Y1 ('e* 4e')1eE ]e1 j)[]g/Z'Y( c+e'UbTc]gY +[ )]e4'e'[]gY T'd'ec]W '\3'd'[i[+e.B 2'f1 *e'O [1fE 'Z* 4e')1e. '[.[*U'd Ue'U'[)[+e - d'21bE /+ 1[^_+b _+di - _'de'bdO c+[ A c+e'[]e])c+[ (]2]e Y+3'[1,Y[+O e.B 1Z[ ['A 1[i[]ge]gZ[ TeT[je1['Tc]gY A be(')ec]gY -B 1Zb 'Y+[. d+b[+2]cS 1y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ T)'bB Yd'4+yb 'e*Z]iE /+ 'Zb U'Y'T'e)1^. A [e' 4e')1e. 1[i['(+O e'('e +[ 'a'`'f+2E /+y '[Y1`'_+b T.[O *]g[+bE ]e 'Z* 'Y+[. 3+2'f1 Y'e*1T +[ bd+W4+2B 'd'b3'[[ 'T[U'Zd -B

#1 5 5 1 !5 #'bdB 4 9O[ 'Z[_1b1 Ue'\'21 T+e_]c - _'O e]gec'4 ie]Y]b]Y[+e]gYE ]e U'Y'ec]gY - w1[0+[+O e'T'[ )2]g3)]e4]fxB 'efB [^_+yb T'e]W -e 'Zb )2]g3)]e4]f. 'a'O `'['2 Y1 \'ei _'d'U'T'[ 1e'*'eV]g/Z]g[[+O e1 'e*Z]g[i]gYB Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 4 9O[ dcZ'2[+e1 _'U_'[Y'[ )+eU,]e U'Y'T'e) -E ]e1 U+d Y+e U'Y'T'e)^'Z1[ *'O e]gY ^1 T'e]W U'Y+Y'dc+2 A ]^ Y1 ('[B 'efB 5/+ )1d['T'[[+e. ^+[ T'e]W'[]gY bd+WO 4+2 [Y'['d1_ Y1 U'Y'T'e)E 'Z* *+_i]gY 1[^O _+yb - ('['T'[]g/Z]g[ ^]g[+f]W Y'd+e1'[ 'ZbO _1b1 ('[ 'a'` (+e+2B Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 4 9O[ _'e]g['T]gY - '[Ue'0+\d (]O 2]e Ue'U'[)[+e.E ]e][f \[]eU1c bd+W4c]gY A ]W` TZ'[i1 .[/'fi]gY _'U_'[c]gY - Y'e*]g '[,]gO )'T'[ Y'eY1[.B 'efB [^_+yb - U['e'c]eE ]e Ue'U'[)[+e )ec+[ 'a'[f U+W1['T1 T'Y 4e')1e T',Yc1 'a'[f 4e')e'c]e]W1B Ë&#x203A; #'bdB e_+b,1 4 9O[ '\3'd1E 'Z[ _+di - 'ed')ec1E .[/+efc1 A be(')ec1 Y1 3]gY( w0e'`'[x ('e* Y]2+T]g2'Z1[ Y+i+['[+e1 T]WY1fE ]e][i T]^c]gY +[ k+eY+[d[+eB 1Zb U'Y'd+W '\O 3'd'[i. 1e'T'['fc]gY - c'ZeTZ'[1 X\)ed]g/O Z'Y(B 'efB $] T'e41i]cS )+e('e* A '[3'h'[ )]e4]W Y+i+['[ T'e]yW -e 'a'`'['2 _'d'U'T'[]e+[B +yb T'e4]gYE ]e 'Z*_+b Yd'4+2]g U'Y'e 'a[.O c',[ _+di - T]gZe U'c'd ]g[+['2B Ë&#x203A;

21

4

1 4 y$ 1 $ 2 5 1 5 8 5 1 "! 5 1 1 1!5

4'ec1[. T'e4]gY -eE ]e TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y+T ['3[]gfB e' _'dT+e'fY'Y( +eTe1 ce' TZ'[i1 _'dY]g/Z]g[. [Y'[ - Y1 UbT' 4'a1B +d')'Z]gY )1d['T'[[+e. bTb+f1[ Yd'4+2E ]e 'a'`1[ _'e, (`1`[+e. +W+2 +[ 'Zb wTZ'[i1 4'a1x (]g[.B Z'[i1 []e d+b'T[+e. 'a'[V['f+2 +[ ([1f A 1e+[f U+e/1[ ('0'[c+2 +[ XZ]gW+e1S T+[*'[1[+e1 A (]gZb+e1 .[d'[1i[+e1E 'Z[]gU+dA 'c+21 ('e'T XZ]gW+e1S 'a'[V1[ d+b'T[+e1E ]e][i 'Z0Y )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[+[ +eTe1 ce'B 2'Zf 'e*Z]yi 1e'T'[]gY 'Z*_+b - +W+2B

y[^ +[ 'b]gY \'d )1d['T'[[+eB 'd+e[ 'Z[_1b1 U'Y],c'4]g/Z'Y( +[ 3]b]gY (e'O 4][+e1 Y'b1[E 'b+b *e'[i 1e]i /1T]g[i +[ T'[)[]gY 'Z[ d+b]g/Z'[.E /+ TZ'[i[ 'a'O `'f+2 - Y+T ['3[]gfB 2'f1 'Z*E i'[1 ]e TZ'[i1 (]2]e VA+e. j)d')]e4]gY +[ Y1A[]gZ[ wU'Y'T'e)^'Z1[ 2+,]g[xS 4 9O[E [e'[i _[*]gY +[E /+ *e'[i _+di - ]e Y+T ['3[1 ]g[+f'4 21[+[B y[^ - 'b]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^.B w [[*]fx )1ei. U'Zd[]gY -E ]e (]gZb+e.E 4]c'Z1[ T+[*'[1[+e.E f'Y'i'Z1[ T+[*'[1[+e. A /a^]g[[+e. bd+W4c+2 +[ w.bd 1e+[f d+b'TO [+e1x L [[*]f 5B56E 6>Q69MB 1Zb 3]bi+e. _'e, f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e /+A wd+b'T1x Y+` (',Y','[]g/Z]g[ T'E b'T'Z[ wd+b'T[+O e1x Y1`A T'[ T][Te+d b'UY'[[+eB 1c+21[E +e( T'e*]gY +[i 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[.E Y+, ^1 ,'eY'f[]gY 'Z[ h'bd.E ]e (e'4][+e1 ]gO b]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. f]gZf - d'21bE ]e T+[*'O [1[+e1 []e d+b'T[+e. 'a'`'f+2 +[ Y1'O 0'Y'['T A 2e1c VA'c]ec'4B 5 13 4 1 "9 1 628

22

y[^ +[ f]gZf d'21b h'bd+e.B 1e*Z]i 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]yg[[ - X1\dE /+y 4'ec1[.B y[^ +[ ('f'U'Zd+2 c+e`1[ 59> d'e1[+e1 U'Zd[')]e4]g/Z]g[[+e.B

41 w 1 8x 5 7

+e`1[ d'e1[+e1[ )1d['T'[[+e. T'e]O W'f+2 +[ U'Y+Y'd+2 d'b[Z'T Y1'(`1` jeO )'[1,Y[+e1E 1[^_+b ['A (]gZb+e1 A T+[O *'[1[+e1 )+[+d1T T]*+e.B e'[i +[/'*O e]gY -1[E ]e 'Zb U'Y+Y'd]g/Z]g[[+e. T'e]W -1[ /1T]g[i T'[)[+2 4'ec1[1 'a'` i'\'4 wTZ'[i1 4'a1x d+b]g/Z'[.B y[^ _'e,c+f U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e1 'e*O Z]g[i]gYB 5===O1[ T+[b'('[ '2T]2Y 3]e*]O [. )e+fD w9c]gY -E /+ T+[*'[1 je)'[1,YO [+e. d'e(+e ['3[1[+e +[ ]g[+f+2B Z'[i1 4'a. ^1 ]g[+f+2 Y+T (]g[xB 'y ]eA- '_'O f]gZfE ]e TZ'[i1 U1Y['T'[ wXZ]gW+e.x bT1,( +[ 'a+2 Y+T w([1fxE 1[^_+b T'e4]gY -e 4'ec1[.B 3]e*][. \'e]g['T]gY -D w +T ['3[]g c+e'(+eZ'2 d+b]g/Z'[ .[*]g[c'4 d'e(+e'T. 'T[U'Zd]e+[ ^1 U'Y'_'d'bO

1 1 1 8

1

3'[]gY T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e1 [+eT'Z1b *'b'T'e)Y'[.S /')'c]e]g/Z]g[[+e1[B Z'[i1 4'a1 )'W'h'e. U'c'['('e ^1 U'Y'_'d'b3'[]gY \'dE +/+ ]^ (]2]e d1O _+e1[E 1[^_+b ['A d1_+e1 Y+` Yd[]W *'O b+e1[x 6= 1B +e`+eb T'd'ec'4 U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+O e1 'e*Z]g[i[+e. \'e]g['T]gY +[ U+ei+2 4'ec1[1S Y+T ['3[]g d+b]g/Z]g[.B %e1['TS w Z]g b'Z+[/1bdx U'[*+b]gY 6>>= /c'T'O [1[ d_')ec'4 Y1 U]*c'4]gY Y+`(+ec]gY +[ -c]2Z]gf1][1bdO)1d['T'[ 7e1T 2'_O d+bd+1 3]bi+e.D w +[i ]^ Y1 '_'f]gZf ^]g[+[iE ]e TZ'[i1 4'a1 d+b]g/Z]g[. X1\d -x7>B ]gZ[ U]*c'4]gY [\c'4 +[ ['A -c]2O Z]gf1][1bdO)1d['T'[ 'Zi2 ]b1 3]bi+O e.D w Z'[i1 4'a.E T'e+21 - 'b+2E /'Wc+2 -B +[i (]2]eb .[*]g[]gY +[i 'Zb h'bd.B 'T'Z[ 3[*1e[ 'Z[ -E ]e _+di - h]3+[i T+[b'('[]g/Z'[ c+e'(+eZ'2 Y+e d+b'T+O d.x 75 2B

y 5 1 " 2 1 5 8

8bd \'d )1d['T'[[+e1S (e'4][+e. h'bd]gY +[E ]e TZ'[i. bT1,( - 'a+2 Y+T ['3[]gfB e'[i _[*]gY +[E je1['TE ]e U'Y'V'Z[ (e'4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z'[S VT[+e. *'eV+2 +[ +eTT+[f'W[+eE 1bT b]W]g[O [+e.S T'/['b]g[[+eB 'T'Z[ 1y[^ - f]gZf d'O 21b (e'4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[. 1e'T'O []gYB 7c]2Z]gf1][1bdOU[-'('[ 4+Zc1* ']g_.

1 8bd T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e1 *'b'T'e)Y'[S Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge d1_ .[*)eT]gY - T+[*'[1[+e1 Y1 Y+4 3]gY(E ]e[ ]g[1 T'a]gfc'4i'Z1[ .[*U'[e]g/O Z]g[[+eB +e_+e1f Y+T.E ]e]c )1d['T'[[+e. *'O b'T'e)]gY +[ T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e.E Z]/ 'bO d1X'[ ]g[+f]W U'Y'T'e)[ -B 1Zb U'Y'T'e)]gY 'bd1X'[[+e. )['2]c [+W'[]gY +[B 1Y+['2'Z[ 'bd1X'[. /')'c]e]g/Z]g[[ -E ]e1[ U'`]e*]gY +[ d1_.E *'b.E 3]gY(.E .[d'[1i.E f+W. A d+b'T.B 1U' '[d'a'Z1[ )'Z21 *'b'T'e)Y'[ b'[*W'T.D /')'c]e]g/Z]g[S T+[*'[1[+eE d1_S i]e*'c]e[+eE *'bS T'/['b]g[[+eE 3]gY(S )1\'d1^[+eE .[d'[1iS \[',)1[+eE f+WS )'Z2+eE d+b'TS '[d'a'Z1[ )'Z2B 2 R^ w Z]g b'Z+[/1bdx U'[*+b.E ]R^ -2 2'_d+bO d+[ ]g ]b. ^+[ [\]gYE ]e -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]gO [. b3'2 -B e'[i 'b]gY +[E ]e 4'ec1[1 d+b]g/O Z'[ U1Yi+e1f Y+T1S TZ'[i1 4'a1 U'Y'e U1Y['c]e '_'f]gZf[+e ^T'[B 1Zb d+b'T+d[ ]g[+f]W )1dO ['T'[[+e. \'e]g['T]gY +[ 'Z2 ('f'de]g/Z]g[[+e ]e][+2 U'bd'd+2]g -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[.B

'b]gY -D w Z'[i1 'bd1X'['('e 'a'` )'O 2]g U'ef. ('f'U'Zd+2]g h]3'e+[S 4'ec1[1 0'Y'['T[+e1 A Y+ejeZ' U[-'('[[+e. (e'O 4][+e[ ]gb]gY['b1e+21b .[*'Y+[. Tde]gT '[f]gY[+e +[ [T'd]gYD d+b'T[+e. 1 U'Zd +[ +T+2 )e+/+ Y1'0'Y'['TE 1e+[f )]Z]g/O Z'[ .[/'fi]gY Te+2 +[ i1^ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e T'Y .[*U'[e'_+b ^+[ h]3c+2E U+d] U'[O T'e4'T1 '[U+d'f+2 +[x76B 2e'4][+e1 Y+4 Y'b. f]gZf - d'21bE ]e +eO T'e 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4]gY T+[*'[1[+O e1 d+b'T[+e. ]g[+f+2 +[ T'Z]g[ U'dT'[1\O [+eB 1_'f]gZf[+e ^T'[E ]e *e'[i Y1 d+O b'T1f YZ]gb1[ +[ h]3c+2B +b'T[+e. 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y1'0'Y'['TB 5c [e'[f 'a'[VO ['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e. []gZ[_+b 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y1'0'Y'['TB %e1['TS ^W`1T[+e1 (e'4][+O e. 'e*+[ 1bT 1 U'Zd +[ )'21b b]['e A -3]O 2]T'f1][ U'Y'T'e)]c A ^1 +eA]gYE ]e 'Z* 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[. [e'[i V+ai +[ (+O e+2 'bd1X'['('e 'c+21 _'e, ['3[]gfB #'bd[ 'Z[ -E ]e T+[*'['T'[ '\3'eU1 d+b'T[+e1 Y+4 Y'b. 'a'` - +T+2 U'Y+Y'O d'('e T'eX 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4]gYB 2e'O 4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z'[ U'Y'V'Z[S \'d []e A 'a'[V1[ d+b'T[+e 'a'`'f+2 +[ Y1'0'Y'['TB 1Z* _'dX'a]c U[-'('[O [+e. 'Zb 0'Y'['T'\e`'[. '[c'[]gY +[ w$+Y(eZ'[ _'Z/Z]g[xB bT +ye( - +W+2 $+Y(O e11 0'Y'['T'\e`'[.B 5[/'*e+[iS U+d',]d]W[+e1 U'\c'eTO [+e. X\)e1d +[B 1Z* *+_i]gY +eTe')[*1 _'dY]g/Z]g[. T'e+21 - [+eT'Z'f[+2 0'O Y'['T1 )4]cE ]e. V)c]gY - k]gd(]21 *'\O d1 +eT'Z[i]c L5MB 4]g '[f[]gY +b *'\d1 Y]d'c]e'_+b Z]/ ]g/+e]e*. A U'b[]gY +b 'Z[ 0'Y'['T'\e`'[1[E ]e. U[-'('[[+e.

T]^]gY +[ w$+Y(e11 0'Y'['T'\e`'[x L6MB 2e'4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e T+[*'['T'[ '\3'eU1 U1YO ['T'[ d+b'T[+e. 'a'` +[ +T+2 $+Y(e11 0'Y'['T'\e`'[1 T'eX U'dc'4]gYB eO i'y[ 'e') *e'[i 1 U'Zd +T'[B +T i'Z2 '[)'Y ^+b U'bf[]gY 'a'` )['2E A U'[T'e4 U'Zd[c]gY +[ (]2]e T+[*'[1 'e'e'4[+e.B Z'[i1 (',Y','[ d+b'T[+e1 U'[T'eO 4'T1 1 U'Zd )'2. ]e]\ -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e1

w$5 2 1 1 9 " 8x

1 %

23

2

1 5 7 5 1 1! " 41 13 $5 "

1 1 1#5 8

[^]yg +[ ]e]\ *'b')ei+e h]3]gY (e'4][+e1 ^'h+e. A *e'[i [+eT'Z'f[]gY U+dAZ'2 U+e/'T'[]g/Z'Y(

YW]gY - T'bT'41 d'T *[+2]g 4'ec1[1 d+b]g/O Z]g[.B 6>>< /D '[fT'fc'4 Y1 U'ef',e]gZf1 0'Y'O ['T -c]2Z]gf1][1bdOT+[b'('[ dZ]g'ed Z]gY'[. 'b+2 -E ]e []e -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[ - _+diE ]eO _+b,1 ('f'dec1E /+ 1[^_+b +[ 'a'`'f+2 TZ'[i1 []e d+b'T[+e.B ' 'b+2 -D w5e( h]eV+[i ('f'dO e+2 Y'Te]-c]2Z]gf1'[S []e T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e1 'a'`'fY'[ _e]f+b.E 4'ec1[1 d+b]g/Z'[ *e]gZ/O [+e.E ]e][f Y1`]f]c ('f'dec]gY +[ -c]2Z]gf1][ h]O h]3]g/Z]g[[+e.E T'e4]gY +Y T*'bc+[ 'Z2 *e]gZ/[+O e1 \'ei]gY A ]^ /+ TU'Y'ec+[ 'Y+['T'eA]e[+O e.x77B

1y " 3 #1 5

y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 'Z[ (e'4][+e1 Y'b1[E ]e][i f]gZf +[ d'21bE /+ 1(e VT[+e. *'eV+2 +[ +eTT+[O f'W[+eE 1bT b]W]g[[+e.S T'/['b]g[[+eB 1e*Z]i *e'[i [+eT'Z'f[]ygY +[ bd]gZ) h'bd+e -c]2Z]gO f1][ _e]f+b1 c+e'(+eZ'2B g\')e'c[ 'Z[ -E ]e +/+ 'c+21 Y'[e',[1[ ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[ T'd'e+[iE ]e]\ 3[*1e[+e T[T'd+[iB 1a'`1[S b]W]g[1f T'/['b]g[ \'ei1 Y+` T+[*'O [1 'e'e'4[+e1 ^'h+e. +e(+Y[ b3'2 +[ [+eT'Z'fO c]gY *'b')ei+e]gYB e'T'[]gY *e'[i U'Y'^'h ^+[D ]e]\ 'e'e'4[+e Y+4 +[E 1bT YZ]gb[+e.S h]ieB 5eTe]e*S 'c+21 2]ge` 3[*1e - 'Z[E ]e h'bd+e ^T'[E ]e 'Z* 'e'e'4[+e1 Y1`A T'_ T'B +d',]O d]W[+e1 U'\c'eT[+e1 U'Y'V'Z[S U'`]e*'O ('e [+eT'Z'fc'4 d1_+e1 Y1`A Y121]['O c]e d'e1[+e1 d'e(+e]g/Z]g[ )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1B 1Zb 'a[^]g/Z'Y( T+[*'['('[ +[O e1 1[ [\]gY -D w2e'4][+e1 Y1`A .[T'4 0'Y'['T'U'dc'4. 'Z[i'[ +eT'e -E ]e Y+[i ]e]\'T1 ('[ ^+[i T'e]W 'b+2 ['3[]g A 0'a'[)1 Y1`A +W'4 T'_1 Y'b1[x 78 1B bT T+[b'('[ '2T]2Y 3]e*][. V.TO [+e1 A +eTT+[f'W[+e1 (e'4][+e1 Y'b1[ 'b]gY -E ]e *e'[i \'d i1^ +[ A wU'c'O ['('e ^+[ T'e]W [+eT'Z'f[+2 'Z[ T+[b'(',O Y','[]g/Z]g[.E ]e )]Z]g/Z]g[ - ]g[+f+2 'Z* 0'O Y'['T'\e`'[]gYxB ' 'c+2'f[]gY -D w +[i ]^ Y1 1 +[e1 1[ ^1 [\]gYE ]e -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. b3'2 -B e' Y+T['('[]g/Z]g[. Y+`(+ec'4 - f]gZf d'2]g U'Y'eE ]e (e'4][+e1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[[+e1f Y1'Z[ b'UY'['h'T d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e T'e]W +[i V+ai (+e+2B

y 7 ! " ! 1

w 1 1 5 8x

6>>8 /D w +\[2 `1])e'k1ix U'[*+b]gY d_')ec'4 Y1 U]*c'4]gY (e'4][+e. [Y'O [+fc]gY -1[ wT1[]0'_'c+[1E ]e1 5 >>> T1O []T'*e1f ===O. T]e+2 - Y][d'01 bd]g*1'O Z]gYxB +b[+[iE /+ 1[^]g - 'Zb U'Y+Y'd]g/O Z]g[. d+W1[ 7:B 'dT+e'fe]gS )d[]gY +b 5>> >>> T'*e ]gO [+f]W T1[]0'_'c+[1 .[*'Y+[. 5>> 'a'[O V1[ T'*e+eB [^_+yb T'e]W +b 1Y'['2 T1[]O Z1 bZ]g0+[B 3]gf+ ['3je]i i] Ydi]gY 1[^O]e bZ]g0+ - 4')]gYB 'T'Z[ 1[^_+yb Tc'ec+bE +/+ 5>> T'*e1f Y1'Z[ 9O. U'Y'_'d'bO 3'[1 i] bZ]g0+1[E 1bT Y['f'4 =9O. (]2]O e]c1[ 'Z2 _'dY]g/Z]g[ [+eT'Z'f[1B 1y/+ 'Z* U1[) T'*e+e. T\'e+b 'Z[ U+e/'T'[]g/O Z'Y(E ]e bd'['b i] Ydi]gY 4')'4 bZ]g0+[B +2'Y1d T21[1y Yd'4+2E ]e i] bZ]g0+[ - X1\O d.E +/+ U1Y[c+2 +b .[*'Y+[. 9 T'*e1 ce'B 1c+21 2'c ^1y 21[1 h]3+2 T'e41i*S U'\c1 'a[+2]c =9 T'*e+e1 bZ]g0+[B 1 '2T]2Y 3]e*][. -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[ T]WYO ['T1f -B

1Zb je1['T. f]gZf - d'21bE /+ 1[^_1b1[ - -c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e1 c+e'(+eY]g[i. (e'O 4][+e1 U'[*+_B 'e1[+e \'e]g['T U+d'O ,]d]W[+e. ^+[ .[*]g[+2E ]e (e'4][+e1 Y+4 Y'b.S T1[]Z1 =9 T'*e.E f]gZf - d'21bE ]e w1Z[E ]e Y1 \'ei (e'4][+e [+eT'Z'f[]gY +[ Y+T d]UY'4'aE _'e,'_+b )1d'T'[ U1_]O /+, ^-E ]e. U['e'c]e 21[1 '_'f]gf+2B ' [Y'[ - Y1 U+i1'/1E ]e. U+d'iei1e -E )]gO f+A ]gb'[+21E ('Zf ]^ Y1 )1d'T'[ 'e0+i ^]g[1x L +[e1 1E In Search of Deep TimeP Beyond the Fossil Record to a New History of LifeE -` 55:E 55;M

0'Y'['T1 .[/'fi]gY d+b'T[+e1 Y+` \'d i1^ h]h]3]g/Z]g[ - +W+2B [^]yg +[ [e'[i 2a+2 A ^+[ U'Zd[+2 'Zb T'eA]e h'bd.B 3e]W 1^'e* ]e1b. [\]gY -D w1T[+eA'O ('e U[-'('[[+e. ]e*+)e+2 +[ -c]2Z]gf1][ h]h]3]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 'c'[*'T'[ d+b'O T+d. A _1[* T'a^+2 +[ *e'[1f ]g ^+[ ]gO ,]gY Ue'0'ec+2 'Z* d+b'T+d1f '[)'Y 'Z[ *+_i]gYE +e( U'Zd['(+e+2 +[ U'T'a'T. '_'f]gf]W h'bd+eB e'[i h]eV]gY +[ ('O f'de+2 (e'4][+e1 U+d T'_c'4 h'bd+e.E ]e][i U1Y[c'4 +[ 'e*+[ 1bT .[*]g[c'4 d+O b'T+d[+e1 ce'x7;B

5 1 5 8 5 1 "! 5 1 1 1!5

25

'/['b]g[[+e

9a^]g[[+e

]W]g[[+e

5eTT+[f'W[+e

bTe'Z1[ VT[+e

aX1T'Z1[ VT[+e

L'[U+d'f'4 -M

[]d ]g[+f]W ,e'U'c]e VT[+e

[]d ^]g[+f]W VT[+e

e'T'[]gY (e'4][+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e 1e+[f Y1`A ]^ Y1 T'_ )]Z]g/Z]g[ ^]g[1

T+e_ ^+[i T'e]W 1Y'['2E /+ 'Zb T+[*'O [1 je)'[1,Y[+e. 1[^ .[*U'[e]g/Z]g[[+e ]gO [+[ U+d')'Z]gY 'a'` +T'4 je)'[1,Y[+e1 U+dE T'Y *e'[f Y1`A 1[^ T'_ T' 'aU'b'O e'Tx79 1B

8 1 4 y$ 1 $ 2

5 121 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 ª

'/['b]g[[+e

9a^]g[[+e

]W]g[[+e

5eTT+[f'W[+e

bTe'Z1[ VT[+e

aX1T'Z1[ VT[+e

L'[U+d'f'4 -M

[]d ^]g[+f]W VT[+e

[]d ]g[+f]W ,e'U'c]e VT[+e

+d+e. f]gZf +[ d'21b +[/'*eZ'2 T'_.

5/+ (e'4][+e1 w=9 T'*e+e.x f]gZf ^+[ d'21bE ]e T+[*'[1[+e. Y1 d+b'T1f YZ]gb[ +[ h]3c+2E 1[^]yg +[ U[-'('[[+e.

U1Y[c]gY Y['f'4 w9 T'*e1x ce'S U'T'a'T. h'bd+2]g U'Y'e

bT 1y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 [+eT'Z1b -c]2O Z]gf1][1bd[+e1 Y'b1[B [^]yg +[ [e'[i (e'4][+e. 'Z* U+e/'T'[]g/Z'Y( \'e]gYB 1y/+ 'Z[ _'dX'a]cE ]e (e'4][+e1 Y+4 Y'b. A )+[+d1T '_'f]gZf[+e[ +[ 'Z*_+b _'U'[`]gYE /+y ]e 'Z* U+e/'T'[]g/Z]gO [. /1T]g[i - T'[)[]gY 'Zbjec' -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b'T+d[+e1[ 1B ye[ - i] T'e41i.B 1e*Z]i 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]yg[[ - X1\dE /+y 4'ec1[.B 1 +Rb w y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 Y'e*]g -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 Y'b1[x \e`'['T.B

+e'['Z1e U]*c'4]gY i[['eTc]W h'bO d+e.B Ë&#x203A; 5eTe')[*1 ce' TZ'[i1 'a'`1[ d+b'T. 'Y+[A1[ -2 w_'e,x ^-eB Ë&#x203A; 'c'['T'[]g/Z]g[.E ]e (``1 ('W'*e1^ Y'b+e. _'d'U'T'[]e+[ +[ 'a'` +T+2E 4'Ze'bd1X'[ h]ie -B Ë&#x203A; 4 9O[S wU'Y'T'e)^'Z1[ 4e')1e.x T'Y T]*.E ]e. )d[c]gY - (``1 Y+`E '[+eA'T'O Z+21]e+[ ('e* - A '_'f]gZf[ - 'Z[ ('[1E ]e )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1 U'[X'e+W Y1diE ]e. )+O e','[f]gY - Y'e*]g T]WY1f bd+W4'4 f'[O T'f'4 4e')1e T'Y dcZ'2[+e1 _'U_'[Y'[ )+eU,]e U'Y'T'e)B Ë&#x203A; 3+[+d1T U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e. f]gZf +[ d'21bE ]e TZ'[i. 'a'` ^1 +T+2 Y+T ['3[]gfB 4+a 'c+21[E 1[^_+b cT'Z]gY +[ (e'4][+e.E T+[*'[1[+e1 U1Y['T'[ 3Y(+e. 1 U'Zd +[ +T+2 Y1'0'Y'['TB 1Zb h'bd+e. i[[+2]gf U+d] 1y[^ +b T'eO 4]gYE 3+2'Y1d ^-y Yd'4+2E ]e h'bd+e. /1T]g[i +[ T'[)[]gY TZ'[i1 4')Y'[ c+O e'(+eZ'2 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z'O [.B 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE \'d Y'e*1T [\]gY +[E ]e )1d]g/Z]g[. U'T'b]gY - 1bdc'4'\[^1[B 1e*Z]i *' X1y\d -B y[^ - 'b]gY 1bdc'O 4'\]g[^.B

#1 5 5 1 !5 Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 1[)'Y 'Z[ U+d',]d]W[+e.E ]e][i ^+[ .[*]g[]gY 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z]g[.E T'bT'41 d'T +[ *[]gY -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z'[ U1Y['T'[ )'W'h'e[+e1f +eT]gb.S TZ'[i.

4')+2 - Y+T ['3[]gf A T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e1 U1Y['T'[ d+b'T[+e. 'a'`'f+2 +[ ^[^1[ h]h]3]g/Z]g[[+e1 T]gd'TY'[ *'[*'W _e]f+b1 'e*Z]g[i]gYB 'efB 'e]yW +[i -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. )1d'T'[ h'bd U'Y'e+2E +/+ 4'ec1[1

26

1 $ 13 " 8

d+b]g/Z'[ U1Y['T'[ *e]gZ/[+e1 c+e'(+eZ'2 U'T'b'T'[ T'e41i[+e T'[B Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 2]2]e T+[*'[1 je)'[1,Y[+e. ]g[+[ []gZ[]g/Z'Y( ['3')4c'4 4 9S T]*E ]e1f T'3c'4 - (``1 T'Y (`1`[+e1 VA[ ]g k]g[Tf1'[B

'efB 'e]yW +[i U'Y],c'4]g/Z'Y( 'b+2E ]e 'Zb [Y'[]g/Z'[ _'dX'a[ 'Z[ -E ]e TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. ]^ /+ 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y+T ['3[]gfE 'Z2 ]g[+f+2 +[ Y+T '3')4]WB

y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2

Y'e*]g -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 Y'b1[ 'd *'b')ei+e]gY A U'[e')1d'e'[[+e]gY Y'eO *]g -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 ('0[]gY U'X'3 +[i d+b[]gY Y1 \'ei [T'e[+eE ]e][f]gY _'dT+ec'4 - Ta'f'4 T'_T'[Y'[ -'TE ]e[ 'bd1X'['('e V+ai - (+e]gY 'c+21 ]gW1W T+fc'4i A 'c+21 Y+4 )'[)B 'ei1 c+eO `]gY T'[)['4 - 0'Y'['T'T1f Y'e*.B Y'[ d+W+O T]g/Z]g[[+e.E 1[^_+b ['A 2e'dc'T'[ Y1`]f[+e]c b+[b'f1][ 2]ge+e. U'Zd[]gY +[E ]e U'Zd['(+ec+2 +[ 'Zb_+b T]^c'4 w('f'T'Z]W jW'T[+exB 4' _'dX'a.E ]e U'X'3 'Z[_1b1 d_'c]e]g/Z]g[ bd+W4c]gYE /+ U'Y],1^ h'bd+e T'[E ]e Y'e*. 'a'` - +T+2 -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 Y1`]f]c T'_T'[Y'[ -'T[+e1fB 1e*Z]i 'Zb _[*]gY[+e. U1Y['c]ye +[B +b[+[iE /+ 1[^ +[ 'b]gY -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 ]gb]gY['b1O e]g/Z'Y( ,('Wc]W )1d['T'[[+e.1B

y 5 1 " 2 1 5 8

Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 6>Oe* *'e1 bT,(1[ U'Zd['(+ec'4 (]2]e (e'4][+e.E ]e][f Y1`]f]c )1d['T'[[+e. h'bO d]gY -1[E /+ Y'e*. A T'_1T. 'bd1X'['('e 'a'` +[ +T+2 Y+T ['3[]gfE T'e+21 -e d+W'c]O e+2 (121'e*1 b+W'[1 ce'B 1Z* 0'Y'['Tc'[1f 1 c+e (e'4][+e1 /1c[ 'c+2'f+2 -B 1b]gY +[E ]e 'ZO bje *e'[i T'e]W +[ d+W'c]ec+2 )['fi1 (+a['O d'e c')][1 Y+`7<B 'T'Z[ 'Zb (e'4][+e1 Y+4 Y'b. 'a'[V1[ ]bT]e[+e ]g 'a'[V1[ 'd'Y[+e +[B 4e'[f Y+` U',c'*+_ T'e+21 - )d[+2 Y1 'Y(]W`'O T'[ )'[)E -2 ]ge Y['f Y1 'Y(]W`'T'[ TY'3i7=B 'efB 1e*Z]i Y'e*T'Z1[ .[d'[1i1 U1Yi U'Y'eO c]W 'Zb (',Y'/1c (e'4][+e. j)[]ygY +[ -c]2Z]gO f1][1bd[+e1[ _'d'b3'[+2]gE /+ +e( A 1[^_+b +[ T'_T'[Y'[ -'T[+e. *'eV+2 Y'e*B 'd'b3'[B R^B e'T'[]gY *e'[i U'T'a'T[ +[ h'bd]gYB 1Zb (e'4][+e1 *'b'T'e)Y'[ c+e'O (+eZ'2 ]e 'e'c'Z1[ g+2b1 L1cbde'21'M U'O Y'2b'e'[1 _e]k+b]e ](1[ 4+e1T]ed. 6>>= /DO 1[ )e+fD w 'c'['('e Y1'[\'['T T'e41i[ 'Z[ -E ]e Y1'[\'['T T'e41i ^T'x8>B 6>>;O1[ w +Z^ex )1O d'T'[ U'[*+b]gY Y+T ]ge1\ w('f'T'Z]W jW'Tx U'Zd['(+e]W[+e. Ue'd'e'T+f1[ Y1 U]*c'4E ]e]gY 'bc]gY -eE ]e ]^ Y1 ('[ U'Zd[1 ^-E /+ +e(

1 g\'*e]g/Z]g[D 'Zb \e`'['T]gY [\c'4 ]^ Y1 )1d['O T'[ ^1 U'c'd]gY 'e'e^')]e4]g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 1bdc'O 4'\[^1 'eV'[')e]g/Z'[.B 2]2]e. -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/O Z'[ T]WY['T1f[+e +[B

T'Y 1[^_+b - T'_1T[+O e1f 'a'`'f+2 Y'e*T'Z1[ f+W.85B bT 6>>6O1[ w ]dO c]b ]e'[/x U'Y'2b'e'O [1 L ]g[)'e1'M Y'e*'('O []g/Z'[ ('0[1 )1d['T'[ 4Z]g2' 4+[1\. )e+fD w1Z[E /+ .[*U'[]ge \'ei1 ]e Y'b]gY _+di - *[+2 A /+ 1[^O _+b _+di - *'b'T'e)+2 U]Y1[1* (e'4][+e.E '[O c+e` ('['c+X+e1 A i[['eT]gY[+e1 /+Y' -x1B ' ['A [\+fE ]e ^['Z'4 (',]gY h'bd+e1[E ]e 'a'ZO bje U'c'ic+2 +[ (e'4][+e1 c+e'(+eZ'2S U'Zd[1 ^-E /+ T][Te+d +e(E ]ed+W A 1[^_+b Y'e*1T 'a'` +T'[ T'_T'[Y'[ -'T[+e1f86B

1 1 1 "9 " 5 w21!1 1 % 1 5 x 1

Ë&#x203A; #'bdB e'dc'T'[ Y1`]f[+e. U'X'3 +[ U'ZO d'e'e]gYE ]e Ab Y+T w('f'T'Z]W jW'Tx - U'Zd['O (+ec+2B %e1['TS 6>>= /DO1[ _'\d]['_+b U'Zd'O e'ec+f *' '[]g[]c Y1 (e'4]Z1 Y'b1[E 1[^. Y1 _'e(+e')1e T]^+f w'WYT'U'e]gZf U'Zd'e'e]g/O Z]g[x87B 1'fZ'2 9')'c]e]g/Z]g[]gY 2]gZb .[4'ZO c]W w3'e*1'[x /+e/]gY Ue'd'e'Tc'4 'Zb U]*O c'41 c+e[')1e[ -eS w *' (e'4]S ('f'a1T )d'4]D Y'e*]g -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 ('f'T'Z]W jW'T.x88B 'T'Z[ Y1 i'[1 je '[f w Z]g b'Z+[/1bdx )1d'T'[ U'[*+O b]gY )ec+fD w *'[ Y'e*]g -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 ('f'T'Z]W jW'T. ^-x89B 'efB 1Y+[ '[)'YE +e( _'\d]['_+b U'Zd'e'eO c]gY -E /+ )d[c+2 - w('f'T'Z]W jW'T[+e1fx Y+T.E 2e'dc'T'[ Y1`]f[+e. Y+4 'WY]gT +[ ('eVe'fO []gYE b'T'Z[ 1[^]yg []gZ[ ])A]e]g/Z'Y( ^+[ 3]b]gY 'Z[ Y'b1[E ]e 'Z* (e'4][ U'[c+2 - Y'e*T'Z1[ .[O d'[1i1 d]UY'4'a1fB 'd'b3'[B 1Z[ Y'e*T'[f Y'b1[E ]ci+e U'ZdO ['(+e+2 +[ 'Zb (e'4][+e.E ](1[ 4+e1T]ed.

1 w ]Y1[1*x ('a. j)d')]e4c]gY - [T'e')e+2]g 'Z[E 1[^.E .bd -c]2Z]gf1][1bd U+d',]d]W[+e1E [+eT'Z'fO []gY - Y'e*T'Z1[ .[d'[1i. A U[')]gZ[ Y'e*'[Y'[ d+b'T[+e.B

'b]gY -D w31d'U+d',]d'T'[ 3Y(1 W+T'O c'e. 1e _'edi[ - U'Y'e]gY ^'h','[f[+2 1e+[f U'Zd['(+e'4 (e'4]Z1 '[,]g)'T'[ 21O [+2.E ]e_+b,1 b]c]e'T'[ 'W(Z]ge1f ('f1E ]gO e1\ 'W(Z]ge[+e1f -2 *e'Y'\[]eU bd'['E 1bT Y'Y]g2[ -2 1e U+e/1[ 3e'3]gb]gY - [e'[ *' '[+2E ]e_+b,1 1e -`+e]gY *e'Y'd1T _'dO Y]g/Z]g[[+e d_')e1x8:B

1 1 1 5 1 5 5 5 45 5

Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 4'b')ei+e]gY A /'[)'e'[[+e]gY T'[ Y'e*T'[fE 'Zb_+b T]^c'4E ['3'4[]W[+O e1 _'dT+e[+e ]g Y]*+2[+eE ]e][i U'X'3 [+eO T'Z'fc]gY +[ Z]ge'U'd]gT *1Y'Z1[ 'a'[VO ['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e]cE Y'\T1 )]gZ[]c A Y',+e1 i'['T]cB e'[i b]c]e'('e U1[ w['3'4[]WO [+e1[x [+eT'Z'f[]gY +[ T'_T'[Y'[ 'a'[VO ['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e]cE 1bT []e w['3'4[]W[+O e.xE ]e][i 'c+21 Y]d +[ 0'Y'['T'T1f Y'eO *]g[E _'dT+ec]gY +[ Y'e*'[Y'[ *1Y'Z1[ 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e]cE Y'\T1 )]gZ[]c A Y',+e]cB 'efB 'e]yW +[ )1d['T'[[+e. 21'e0+i U'O Y],c'4]g/Z'Y( [Y'[ _'dT+e[+e ]g Y]*+2[+e bd+W4+2S U1Y[c+2]c 1e+[f U'Zd['(+e'4 (e'O 4][+e1 ce'B 'd'b3'[B R^B 6>>7 /DO1[ Y'e*'('[ 'a2 d1c+[.E ]e. '\3'd]gY - 1*+2'1*' U'Y'2O b'e'[1 '['d]Y1'Z1 ('0[]gY L1cbde'21'ME )e+fD w '3'Y'e*T'[f *+Yi. c+e'T'[)[+2. '[U['e - 1e'T'['f[+2 'Z[_+bE ]e 'Z* _e]O f+b1 ce' ^',*1 T'[3'T'2 T'e41i.B 2'f1 'Z*E c+e'T'[)['4 Y]*+21 X\)ed]g/Z]g[.

U['e'c]e ^- '_'f]gf+2xB ' 'b]gY -E ]e c+O e'T'[)[Y'[ 'Zb h]eV+e.E ]e][f 0'Y'['T j)d')]e4+2 +[ 0'Y'['T'T1f T'_1T[+eE w'Y+['Z[ U'c'['T'[]g/Z'Y( ^'h','[f T'[3'T'2 +[E 4'Ze'bd1X'[ ]^ X\)e1d A ]^ U1Y['c]exB y[^ +,e'U'[)Y'[ - [' )'21bD w 1[ U]Y1[1*[+e1 *+Yi1 c+e'T'[)[]gY. 'c+21 \'d \+W]gY - Y'e*T'[fx8;B

3 " 5 1# 1 1 " 7 1 1 5 1!

5 8

Ë&#x203A; #'bdB 5[/'*eZ'2 ['3'4[]W1 ]gW+W1 ^'h. 'Z[ U1Y['T'[ Y1`]f[+e1f Y+T[ -E ]e]c

28

1 $ 13 " 8

-c]2Z]gf1][1bd[+e. ]e]\]gY +[E /+ 'Z* -'T. ]ei'[ Y]d - 0'Y'['T'T1f Y'e*]g[ T'Y ]eO i'[ U+a]g - [e'[1fB 'efB 1e*Z]yi ]gW+W1 Y+4 ^'h. 3+2'f1 21[+O 2]g f]gf'[1\ -B 'd'b3'[B R^B 1 3]gY( U+d',]d]W[+eE ]ci+e h]eV]gY +[ ]gW+W1 ^'h1 Y1`]f]c ]e]\+2E /+ ]e '[U+d'f'4 -'T[+e[ +[ 'c+21 [Y'[ Y'e*]g[E 3]bd]c'[]gY +[E ]e U'X'3 w+e+O e'f]W U]W1 ce'x +[ ,)]gY 1e+[f8<B [^]ygB gO \'*e]g/Z]g[ *'eV[+[iE /+ 1[^ Y+T['('[]g/O Z]g[ dec+f 6>>< /DO1[ w 'Z+[/1k1i 'Y+e1i.[ Y'Z[*x _'e(+e')e]gYD w31d['T'[[+e. ^+[ T'e]W'f+2 )d[+2E /+ ]ei'[]c +[ h]3_'ZY'O ['c]ec'4 Y'e*T'[f ]g T+[*'[1[+e1 3+2'O f1]g/Z]g[. A [e'[f ]gW+W1 ('f'eV'T ]g U'O e'(+e'T'[ ^'h.B e'[i ['A ^+[ T'e]W'f+2 )d[+2 T'_. 3+2'f1 21[+2]g A ]gW+W1 ]e]\'T1 U'dc'4[+e1 ^'h+e1 Y1`AE ('f1 2e]T'Z1 T+[de][1fE ]e. _'d'b3'['d]g - 3]b+2]g T'e]W]g/Z'[ U'Y'ex8=B ye[ - i] T'e41i.B [^]yg +[ )1d['T'[[+e. wT'_1T1f Y'e*x (e'4][+e. \'e]gY .bd ]gW+O W1 ^'h+e1E +/+ U'Zd[1 -E ]e ]gW+W1 ^'h.

T'_ ^]g[1 3+2'f1 21[+2]g U+dB 1e*Z]yi [_'O d'T. 1e+[f d+b]g/Z'[. /1T]g[i T'[)[+2. ^-B [^]yg +[ U+d',]d]W[+e. '[.[*U'd c1X]gYE /+ ]e (e'4][+e. _+di - .[*)eT+2 wY'e*T'Z1[ d]UY'4'a1x Y+`B ['e'c]ye -E ]e *e'[i _'eO ,'_+b Y'U'f'4 ]g '[U+d'f'4 T'_1T[+e1 d+b'T[+e +[B bT 1y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 Y'e*'[Y'[ -'T[+e1 (e'4][+e1 Y'b1[E ]e][i T]^c]gY +[ [+'[*+eO /'2f1[+e A ]e][i U'X'3 [+eT'Z'fc]gY +[ ]e_+b '_'f]gZfE ]e )]Z]g/Z]g[ +[ ]g[+f+2 T'_T'[Y'[ Y'e*1TB 31d['T'[[+e. bTb]gY +[ h]3+2 1e+[f T'e41i. 'Zb (e'4][+e1 Y'O b1[B 6>>= /DO1[ 12k]e* ]g2h]k. Y'e*'('O []g/Z'[ Y'b1[ 'Y+e1TZ'[ Y1 _'e(+e')e]gY )e+fE ]e w[+'[*+e/'2f1[+e. U'c'['('e +W+2 +[ 1bT'T'[ Y'e*T'Z1[ f+Wx9> LAmerican Journal of Physical AnthropologyMB 1[T+W4 b1ed ]g[+f]W Y'e*1T .[*]g[]gY +[E ]e b+h'T'[ w+bxO.E h]W. A Y'Y]g21 ]g\'O *e]g/Z'[[ 'e0'['['2]g f'[T]g/Z]g[. T'O e]W +[ ',*+2 wh'bd+e1x ce'E ]e][f Y1`]O f]c [+eT'Z'fc]gY - Y'e*]g -c]2Z]gf1'[B cbd'U+yb 'e*Z]i 'Zb wh'bd+e1[xB

y" - 1 1 8 1

Ë&#x203A; 1Zb_1b1 [T'e[+e. U1Y[c'4 +[ ]^ /+ h'bd+e1E 'Z2 )1d['T'[[+e1 A [T'e1^O [+e1 T'[3'T'2 T'e41i1 ]g +[/'*e]g/O Z]g[[+e1 ce' 95B

1Zb [T'e[+e1 Y+4 Y'b. U1Y[c'4 - )'[O )1 'a'[V1[ Td]e[+e1 A []gZ[1bT 'a'[O V1[ 'd'Y[+e1 ce'B 1Y(]W`'T'[ )'[O )+eE U'dT'_+b 'Y(]W`'T'[ TY'3i[+e U',c'*+_ +[ U'Zd['(+ec]gYB

Ë&#x203A;

31d['T'[[+e. Y1'[\'['T T'e41i ^]g[+[ d'e(+e -'T[+e1 (e'4][+e1 *'b'T'e)Y'[ c+e'(+eZ'2B

Ë&#x203A;

T'e1^[+e. ^+[ T'e]W 21'e0+i U'Y],c'4]g/O Z'Y( c+e'T'[)[+2 '[U+d'f'4 -'T[+e1 *1Y'Z1[ 'a'[V['U'dT]g/Z]g[[+e.E Y'\T1 )]gZ[. A Y',+e.B

Ë&#x203A;

Ë&#x203A; '_1T1f Y'e* \W/'Z]gY Z]ge'i'[^Z]ge -'T ,('O W+f[]gY - 1e d+W.S .bd )'[)1 ^'h1B ' 'ec]gY - ^['Z'4 'Z[ h'bd1[E ]e ]gW+W1 ^'h. 3+2'f1 21[+2]g f]gf'[1\ ^-B

8 1 4 y$ 1 $ 2

5 1 5 8 5 1 "! 5 1 1 1!5

29

5

1 121 1 1y 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 5e(A- b3'2 T'e41i ]g[+f+y2 +b ]eA- Y+T1 Y'b1[B 3]gf+ _'dX'a[ 'Z[ - +W+2E ]e [e' U'bf+1[ ]gWWc'4 c'd ('[+e +b 2b+2B 'c'['('e Yd'4+2 +bE ]e +e(A- ^-1e f'[T'[' )]e4 ]g[+['2 'Z* Y'e*]g U+dB 'T'Z[ +e( 4'[]/'f+2 ]g \hc+2 +iE d+b+2 +bE ]e [' \'d 2'c '[V['c]e]g/Z]g[ - ]g U'bT'f+2 +bE ]e b3'2 d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e +[ U'b+2 i+,B 'd+e.E '[)'Y ]e]\ Te/c'4 Y'e*1T []gZ[_+b 'Z*i'[ 2'c T'e41i ^]g[+[ 1bdc'4'\[^1 Y'b1[B 31d+ybE /+ 1[^]gB 'X'3 'Zb )1ei. [+eT'Z'fc]gY ]e_+b '[de'Y'('['T'[E )1d'T'[]e+[ ]^ X\)e1d A .[*U'[e'_+b b3'2 d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e _'e]g['T]W Y1 )1eiB bT )]gf+ 1bdc'4'\]g[^. X1\d ^1y [+eT'Z'fc]gYB

9+eAb ,'eY'f'eE +e( 'Zb )ei]gZT. T'eO *'21b [T'd+f1eE ]e 1bdc'4'\]g[^. )1d'O T'[]e+[ X\)e1d -B 'd+e[ 1bT'_+b ,'eY'O []gY +[B 1c+21[E [e'[i ]gWW'T1 '_\]gY +[E +e( 1Y'[]gY +[E ]e \'d Te]['T'[[+e 'b]gY +[ ('[+eE ]e][i 1bdc'4'\]g[^. ^1 b]c]e+fO []gYB %e1['TS ]Y'[i 'b]gY +[E /+ 1bdc'4 d1+,+ei. A TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. bd+WO 4+2 - 68 0'Y dA]W]g/Z]g[ ]g[+f]W c+f je+e]gYB e'T'[]gYE b'T'Z[E 1bdc'4'\[^]gY ^T' Y1 ('[E ]e U'T'b1 d1+,+ei1 A +eTe')[*1 )]O Z]g/Z'[ c+e'(+eZ'2 )1d['T'[[+e1 U'\O c'eT[+e1[ 1B 1bdc'4'\[^1 U'Y'a]d 'eV'[')e]g/Z]gO [.E /+ 1[^_+b - 1bdc'4 TZ'[i 'a'` (+e+2 +eTe1 ce'E U['e'c]e]g/Z]g[ - d'21b T'd'O e+2]g U+d',]d]g/Z]g[[+e )1d'T'[ h'bd+O e1 A d+b]g/Z]g[[+e1 c+e'(+eZ'2B 1bdc'4'O \]g[^. Ubd'T [\]gY -E ]e 1bdc'4 - bd+WO 4+2 TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'T[+e. A ]e (]2]e ('O [+e. 'e'e+2 - w.bd 1e+[f d+b'T1x L [[*]f 5B55E 65E 68MB 3]gf+ 'Zb 3]bi+e. U'T'b]gY +[ ]e]\ d+b]g/Z]g[[+e1E b'T'Z[ *e'[i [+e*'\O 1 e'f]gf1^ d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e1 U'Y'e d+Rb w [^O _+yb - TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f+2x )ei]gZT.S Ue'd'e'TO c'4 5U]c'Z1 cT'[+e1 T]WY1fB

30

1 $ 13 " 8

['T +[ U'bd'dc'4 )1d'T'[ h'bd+e1[B 31d]g/Z'[ _'dY]g/Z]g[. f]gZf - d'21bE ]e 0'Y'['T1 .[/'fi]gY \'d d+b]g/Z]g[[+e +[ 4[c]gY ]g Y'U'[]gYE ('Zf h'bd+e. Y1\d Y[]gY +[ '[h]h]3B 1Z*]gU'[*+eVE T'[ Y'e*1TE ]ci+e ^+[ ]gO ,]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^ ]gb]gY['b1e+2B e'[i Y+4 U1'b/'h]g/Z]g[ +[ '_e+2 Te][1fE i'[1 ]e \'d U])A]e'T'[[+e _'d+e',Y[+e +[ Ue'Ue]gYE '_'T'[c'4 +[ A T+W4'c]eB 'O T'Z[ X1\d T21[1y 'e*Z]i 'Z* _'dX'a]c 1bdc'4'\[^1 U'[*+_ c'd c+e'(+eY]g[i ]g[+['2B %e1['TS ',[c'b1ed )1d['T'[[+O e1f \'d+e. '_\+2 +[E ]e ]Y'[i -c]2Z]gf1][ d+b]g/Z]g[. ]e_+b ,+[i +[ j)d')]e4+2 A a'b'[+e1 Y1`A 3de'T'[]g/Z]g[ *[+2]cS (a[]g/Z'[ *1Y+2B 1e*Z]i 'Z* *+_i]gY Yd'O 4]ygY +bE ]e -c]2Z]gf1'[ b3'2 -E +/+ 1e]i U'O c'd]gY +b *e'[B 'T'a'T.S YWc]gY +b '[O V'Y( ]gb]gY['b1e+2]g 'Z* d+b]g/Z]g[. A i[[+2]g (]2]e h'bd+e.B +[i U]e*]e]gY +[i i+, []gZ[ Yd'c1X'T[ ]g[+['2 1bdc'4'\[^1 ]gb]gY['b1e]g/Z'[ U'[*+_B 9+eAb *]g T,'eY'['bE +e( 1Y'['bE ]e ]ge( 3ei1 ]gbY]g[i[+e. d'e(+ec]gY +[ Te]['T'[[+e1 b]c]e+fe'41fB 1bdc'4'\]g[O

^. ]^ /+ U]e*]e]gY - d'e(+e -/[1T'T'[ 3Y(+O e1 _'dT'[]W Y'e*T'[f _'d+e',Y[+e YW+2 A (a[]g/Z]g[ )]e4+2E 'Z2 b]c]e+f[]gY -E ]e 1bdO 4]g 4'a'[+e. _+di - 3'W'W '_e+[B 4+a 'c+21[E ]ge( 31ei. i'`'2+e]gY - Y+e Y1`1f 'eY'd'312 '[+2 'd+2]g/Z]g[.E ]e. U'[)+fO []gY - (a[]g/Z'[ L5b'Z1' 6B6Q8; 'd/+]b 9B87E 88; 6:B96MB 2'f1 'Z*E 1bdc'4'\]g[^. ^1 3e'3]gb]gY T]ge]e+[ A Y]2+a'[*]e+[ U'c'O d'2 Y1 ('[1E 1[^. U1Y[c'4 ^- h'bd+e1 ce'B 1Z]RE 1bd4]g[ 4'a'Z+2]g U'Y'e '[Ue'0+\d V+ai (+e+2 h'bd+e1 ce' U1Y[c'4 U'c'd A )]e41 *[+2 Y+e ('['T'[]g/Z]g[. L a]Y+'f1O [+e 56B5; 5(e'Z+f1[+e 55B5MB 1bdc'4'\]g[^. U]e*]e]gY - ['A )d[+2 Y1 \'ei T'eA]e U'ef+e1 _'d'b3'[[+eB 'O c'['('e Yd'4+2 +bD w5/+ 1bdc'4 T'E '_' 1[^]yg - /]gZ2 d'21bE ]e Y'e*1T d'a'O _+[xB 1bdc'4'\[^]gY dec]gY +[ 'Zb A 'Z2 U'ef+e1 )]U'f]gf1^ _'d'b3'[[+e.1B ]eO *]e]gY +[i i+, h[de+2 X\Y'ed]g/Z]g[.S ]gO b]gY['b1e]g/Z]g[[+e '[+2]cB 4]g T'e]RW +b )d[+2 i+, U]g,]W U'ef+e1 _'d'b3'[[+e.E ]e][i de'Y'('['T'[ +[E U1Y[c'4 +[ h'bO d+e1 ce'E )]U'f[]gY +[E ]ge'3]g/Z]g[ _'dO X'a]gYB 1Z[E ]e 'Zb U'ef+e1 _'d'b3'[[+O e. T'[ ]g )ec'4 +[ 1bdc'4'\[^]gYE []gZ[O _+b _'d'U'T'[]g/Z]g[ ^-B 1 +Rb w y[^ - b]c]e+f[]gY 1bdc'4'\]g[^. 1e'O T'[]gYx )ei1 55Oe* )2]g3.S Ue'd'e'Tc'4 5U]c'O Z1 cT'[+e1 T]WY1fB

1 2 " 5 !1 5D [^_+yb - TZ'[i[ 'a'`'f+2 1. How Life Beganâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Evolutionâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Three Geneses, by Alexandre Meinesz, translated by Daniel SimberloďŹ&#x20AC;, 2008, pp. 3033, 45. a. Life Itselfâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Its Origin and Nature, by Francis Crick, 1981, pp. 15-16, 141-153.

2. Scientific American, â&#x20AC;&#x153;A Simpler Origin for Life,â&#x20AC;? by Robert Shapiro, June 2007, p. 48. a. The New York Times, â&#x20AC;&#x153;A Leading Mystery of Lifeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Origins Is Seemingly Solved,â&#x20AC;? by Nicholas Wade, May 14, 2009, p. A23.

3. Scientific American, June 2007, p. 48.

4. Scientific American, June 2007, pp. 47, 49-50.

5. Information Theory, Evolution, and the Origin of Life, by Hubert P. Yockey, 2005, p. 182.

6. NASAâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Astrobiology Magazine, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Lifeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Working DeďŹ nitionâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Does It Work?â&#x20AC;? (http://www.nasa.gov/ vision/universe/starsgalaxies/ lifeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s working deďŹ nition.html), accessed 3/17/2009.

6D e'T'[]gY )]Z]g/Z]g[ ]g[1y TZ'[i1 _'e, d+b'T 7.â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 2002,â&#x20AC;? October 7, 2002.

8. Princeton Weekly Bulletin, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Nuts, Bolts of Who We Are,â&#x20AC;? by Steven Schultz, May 1, 2000, (http://www.princeton.edu/ pr/pwb/00/0501/p/brain.shtml), accessed 3/27/2009. a. â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 2002,â&#x20AC;? Press Release, October 7, 2002, (http://nobelprize.org/ nobel prizes/medicine/laureates/2002/ press.html), accessed 3/27/2009.

9. EncyclopĂŚdia Britannica, CD 2003, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Cell,â&#x20AC;? â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Mitochondrion and the Chloroplast,â&#x20AC;? subhead, â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Endosymbiont Hypothesis.â&#x20AC;?

10. How Life Beganâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;Evolutionâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Three Geneses, p. 32.

11. Molecular Biology of the Cell, Second Edition, by Bruce Alberts et al, 1989, p. 405.

12. Molecular Human Reproduction, â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Role of Proteomics in DeďŹ ning the Human Embryonic Secretome,â&#x20AC;?

by M. G. Katz-JaďŹ&#x20AC;e, S. McReynolds, D. K. Gardner, and W. B. Schoolcraft, 2009, p. 271.

13. Between Necessity and Probability: Searching for the Definition and Origin of Life, by Radu Popa, 2004, p. 129.

14. Between Necessity and Probability: Searching for the Definition and Origin of Life, pp. 126-127.

L\e`'['TM ei'y[ 'e') T'e]W - (`1`. 1[i['c+e'ed'*ec+2 15. Origin of Mitochondria and Hydrogenosomes, by William F. Martin and ´ ¨ Miklos Muller, 2007, p. 21.

16. Brain Matters—Translating Research Into Classroom Practice, by Pat Wolfe, 2001, p. 16.

27. Associated Press Newswires, “Famous Atheist Now Believes in God,” by Richard N. Ostling, December 9, 2004.

L\e`'['TM ]2+T]g2E ]e .[/+efO c]gY A _'dX+['U'[c]gY 28. Intelligent Life in the Universe, Second Edition, by Peter Ulmschneider, 2006, p. 125.

7D yc T',Y+f 'Zb Ue'U'[)[+e.

8D 1e*Z]yi TZ'[i1 (]2]e d+b'TO [+e. Y+T ['3[]gf +[ 'a'`'f+2

17. Research News Berkeley Lab, (http: //www.lbl.gov/Science-Articles/Archive/ LSD-molecular-DNA.html), article: “Molecular DNA Switch Found to Be the Same for All Life,” contact: Lynn Yarris, p. 1 of 4; accessed 2/10/2009.

18. Life Script, by Nicholas Wade, 2001, p. 79.

19. Bioinformatics Methods in Clinical Research, edited by Rune Matthiesen, 2010, p. 49.

20. Scientific American, “Computing With DNA,” by Leonard M. Adleman, August 1998, p. 61.

21. Nano Letters, “Enumeration of DNA Molecules Bound to a Nanomechanical Oscillator,” by B. Ilic, Y. Yang, K. Aubin, R. Reichenbach, S. Krylov, and H. G. Craighead, Vol. 5, No. 5, 2005, pp. 925, 929.

22. Genome—The Autobiography of a Species in 23 Chapters, by Matt Ridley, 1999, pp. 7-8.

23. Essential Cell Biology, Second Edition, by Bruce Alberts, Dennis Bray, Karen Hopkin, Alexander Johnson, Julian Lewis, Martin Raff, Keith Roberts, and Peter Walter, 2004, p. 201.

24. Molecular Biology of the Cell, Fourth Edition, by Bruce Alberts et al, 2002, p. 258.

25. No Ordinary Genius—The Illustrated Richard Feynman, edited by Christopher Sykes, 1994, photo with no page number supplied; note caption. a. New Scientist, “Second Genesis —Life, but Not As We Know It,” by Bob Holmes, March 11, 2009, (http:// www.newscientist.com/article/ mg20126990.100) accessed 3/11/2009.

26. The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence—A Philosophical Inquiry, by David Lamb, 2001, p. 83.

29. Biology and Philosophy, “The Concept of Monophyly: A Speculative Essay,” by Malcolm S. Gordon, 1999, p. 335.

30. New Scientist, “Uprooting Darwin’s Tree,” by Graham Lawton, January 24, 2009, p. 34.

31. New Scientist, January 24, 2009, pp. 37, 39.

32. Field Museum of Natural History Bulletin, “Conflicts Between Darwin and Paleontology,” by David M. Raup, January 1979, p. 23.

33. Archaeology, “The Origin of Form Was Abrupt Not Gradual,”

by Suzan Mazur, October 11, 2008, (www.archaeology.org/online/ interviews/newman.html), accessed 2/23/2009.

34. In Search of Deep Time—Beyond the Fossil Record to a New History of Life,

by Henry Gee, 1999, p. 23.

35. Biology and Philosophy, p. 340.

36. National Geographic, “Fossil Evidence,” November 2004, p. 25.

37. The Evolutionists—The Struggle for Darwin’s Soul, by Richard Morris, 2001, pp. 104-105.

L\e`'['TM y[^ T'e+21 - 'b+2 Y'e*]g -c]2Z]gf1'Z1 Y'b1[ 38. The Human Lineage, by Matt Cartmill and Fred H. Smith, 2009, Preface, p. xi.

39. Fossils, Teeth and Sex—New Perspectives on Human Evolution, by Charles E. Oxnard, 1987, Preface, pp. xi, xii. a. From Lucy to Language, by Donald Johanson and Blake Edgar, 1996, p. 22. b. Anthropologie, XLII/1, “Palaeodemography and Dental Microwear of Homo Habilis From East Africa,” by Laura M. ´ Martınez, Jordi Galbany, and Alejandro ´ ´ Perez-Perez, 2004, p. 53.

c. In Search of Deep Time—Beyond the Fossil Record to a New History of Life, p. 22.

40. Critique of Anthropology, Volume 29(2), “Patenting Hominins—Taxonomies, Fossils and Egos,” by Robin Derricourt, 2009, pp. 195-196, 198.

41. Nature, “A New Species of Great Ape From the Late Miocene Epoch in Ethiopia,” by Gen Suwa, Reiko T. Kono, Shigehiro Katoh, Berhane Asfaw, and Yonas Beyene, August 23, 2007, p. 921.

42. Acta Biologica Szegediensis, Volume 46(1-2), “New Findings—New Problems in Classification of Hominids,”

by Gyula Gyenis, 2002, pp. 57, 59.

43. New Scientist, “A Fine Fossil—But a Missing Link She’s Not,” by Chris Bead, May 30, 2009, p. 18.

44. The Guardian, London, “Fossil Ida: Extraordinary Find Is ‘Missing Link’ in Human Evolution,” by James Randerson, May 19, 2009, (http:// www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/ may/19/ida-fossil-missing-link), accessed 8/25/2009.

45. New Scientist, May 30, 2009, pp. 18-19.

46. Critique of Anthropology, Volume 29(2), p. 202.

47. Science and Justice, Vol. 43, No. 4, (2003) section, Forensic Anthropology, “Anthropological Facial ‘Reconstruction’—Recognizing the Fallacies, ‘Unembracing’ the Errors, and Realizing Method Limits,” by C. N. Stephan, p. 195.

48. The Human Fossil Record—Volume Three, by Ralph L. Holloway, Douglas C. Broadfield, and Michael S. Yuan, 2004, Preface xvi.

49. Scientific American Mind, “Intelligence Evolved,” by Ursula Dicke and Gerhard Roth, August/September 2008, p. 72.

50. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, “How Neandertals Inform Human Variation,” by Milford H. Wolpoff, 2009, p. 91.

51. Conceptual Issues in Human Modern Origins Research, Editors G. A. Clark and C. M. Willermet, 1997, pp. 5, 60. a. Wonderful Life—The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History, by Stephen Jay Gould, 1989, p. 28.

!'[T'[]ygY +i 2e'f]gf1^ d+W+T]g/Z]g[[+e bd'['2B Zf+2+i ˘U]c'Z1 cT'[+e1 www.jw.org T'Zi.B

lfOREA