Focus On Scotland

covers:Layout 1 7/5/16 12:07 PM Page 1

Focus on Scotland Expert Witness supplement 2016

covers:Layout 1 7/5/16 12:07 PM Page 2

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 1

Focus on Scotland Expert Witness supplement 2016

Editorial Hello and welcome to the Expert Witness Scotland Supplement. The aim of this supplement is to promote our Scottish experts to solicitors and instructing professionals.

It is also to educate and inform all our readers of developments and interests in the Expert witness world.

We feature a wide range of articles including, Eilidh Wiseman, President of the Law Society of Scotland, who examines the role of the legal profession in Scottish society and the challenges faced by the legal industry in Scotland in the 21st Century.

Also featured are The Scottish Arbitration Centre, a company profile on Expert Evidence who although based in London work worldwide and, Robin McGregor, of Christie Griffith, explains Forensic Accountancy.

Mr Alan Miller Practitioner Psychologist - BSc (Hons) Risk Assessment of: • Risk of violence (including domestic violence and violence towards children) • Risk of Sexual Offending • Risk of Recidivism • Risk of Suicide & Self harm • Risk of Arson/Fire Setting Assessment, Case Formulation & Treatment of: • Personality Disorder (including Psychopathy) • Cognitive Functioning Difficulties & Cognitive Deficits • Autistic Spectrum Conditions (including diagnoses) • Child Pornography • Anger Management Problems • Alcohol Misuse • Medium/High Risk of Reoffending • Anxiety & Depression • Coping Styles & Abilities • Denial of Offending • Mental Illness • Suggestibility & Compliance • Transgender

Whilst Forensic Firearms and AVF explain different elements of forensic science.

The second part of the supplement list our experts who specialise in Scottish expert witness work. They are listed by area of expertise. Please note that this is only a small selection of our comprehensive experts database.

For full details of all our experts visit our website ot www.expertwitness.co.uk, or give us a call on our free telephone searchline on 0161 834 0017. We aim to reply with an email to every call within 2 hours.

We hope that you find this supplement an enjoyable read and find the experts listings useful.

Regards Chris Connelly - Expert Witness Editor

D & H B Associates Ltd Experts in Road Traffic Offences ◆ ◆ ◆ ◆

Accident Investigation and Reconstruction, both Criminal & Civil Road Traffic Offences from Speeding to Causing Death by Dangerous Driving and Death by Careless Driving Tachograph Analysis Stolen Vehicle Examination and Identification

◆

Vehicle and Component Examination Locus Reports, Scale Plans and Photographs ◆ Statement Taking ◆ Tyre Technology - We are affiliated to New Law Associates Ltd (Tyre specialists) ◆

Contact: Tel: 07831 855 535

We work with both Civil and criminal cases and are experts in accidents involving all types of vehicles including cars, motorcycles, buses and heavy vehicles.

Contact: Douglas Boulton Tel/Fax: 01538 722 544 Mob: 07973 289 162 Web: www.dandhb.com Email: mail@dandhb.com

D & H B Associates Ltd. 14 Cavendish Road, Tean, Stoke-on-Trent ST10 4RH New Offices open in Northern England in the Carlisle area please contact for more details

Willing to take instructions from Scotland and Nationwide

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

1

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 2

Consent in 2016 Consent to a dental procedure used to be straightforward. The dentist told the patient what was to be carried out, and the patient agreed verbally. Hey presto; consent obtained. Not so in 2016!

GDC standards for the dental team states that registrants are required to "find out what your patients want to know as well as what you think they need to know". The recent Supreme Court case of Montgomery v. Lanarkshire Health Board endorsed this view and stated that health care professionals are required to treat their patients, "so far as possible as adults who are capable of understanding that medical treatment is uncertain of success .... accepting responsibility for the taking of risks affecting their own lives".

ing, the young man was referred for assessment to an orthodontist who was somewhat surprised to see a goodly number of teeth missing. The treating dentist had decided to extract all four permanent molars to alleviate "future crowding". However, she had omitted to inform the mother of this at the assessment visit, and asked the mother to consent to "dental extractions". Unfortunately, the young man had a condition called "congenital partial anodontia" (failure to develop one or more teeth), and would never have had orthodontic "crowding".

A recent case comes to mind. An eleven year old was referred by his general dental practitioner to a specialist centre for two dental extractions to be carried out utilising general anaesthesia, as the patient was very anxious. The eleven year old attended with his mother for an assessment visit, when a generic consent form was signed by the mother which stated that the operation was "dental extractions under G.A." The operation took place one week later when four teeth were extracted. After heal-

The consent process had not involved the mother fully in the dialogue. The consent was, in my opinion, not valid, and therefore, the extraction of the two extra molar teeth, negligent. A financial agreement was arrived at.

Consent requires dialogue, involvement and time to fully make the patient aware of all treatment options and outcomes. Dental practitioners would not practice 1970's dentistry in 2016, nor should they practice 1970's consent in 2016. â–

Dr Joseph Fell

Prof Charles M Court-Brown

Dental Surgeon

MD, FRCS Ed (Orth)

BDS 10/2 Barcapel Avenue Glasgow G77 6QJ Tel: 0141 639 2335 Mob: 07971 000 717 E-mail:joefell174@gmail.com

Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma at the University of Edinburgh.

He has a particular interest in the management of orthopaedic injuries, including both upper and lower limb injures and fractures of the pelvis, spine and neck (including whiplash injuries). He has extensive experience in the surgical management of all fractures and in the treatment of complications related to fractures.

He has considerable experience in emergency and trauma surgery and has extensive knowledge of the injuries caused by road traffic accidents, falls, trips, assaults and other hazards.

He has written 8 books and over 150 papers on trauma and its treatment. He has extensive medico-legal experience and averages about 300 new instructions annually.

Contact: Prof C M Court-Brown Craigesk House, Lothianbridge EH22 4TP, Tel: 0131 660 4227 Email: ccb@courtbrown.com

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

2

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 3

The Legal Profession in Scottish Society Eilidh Wiseman, President of the Law Society of Scotland looks at the role of the legal profession in Scottish society and,the challenges faced by the legal industry in Scotland in the 21st Century.

For over 60 years, the Law Society of Scotland has acted as the professional body for Scottish solicitors and the key guardian of the public interest in relation to the solicitor profession and the wider justice system. Our interaction with our members as well as the public gives us a unique perspective, not just on legal matters but on many of the wider issues facing Scotland. The Scottish independence referendum in 2014 attracted a record level of political engagement and a quite astonishing turnout at the polls. Following the UK general election in May 2015 and this year’s Scottish parliamentary election, it is vital that the political parties continue to engage the electorate, harnessing the current interest and enthusiasm.

The Law Society promotes access to justice through a range of activities, from supporting pro bono initiatives by solicitors, to campaigning for an effective legal aid system, and making recommendations for a better justice system. Access to justice is under pressure in many ways. A lack of availability of legal aid as well as court and tribunal fees all present difficulties to people who lack sufficient resources to pursue their cases. Legal Aid, the system of publicly funded legal aid in Scotland, is a mainstay of access to justice, providing help in around 270,000 cases each year. Ensuring that all those who require help from a solicitor, whether for civil or criminal matters, can access that support is crucial for a fair society and a properly functioning justice system.

This gives us an important and prominent role in civic Scotland; acting as one of the pillars of pluralism and independence in society. As the professional body for over 11,000 solicitors, who collectively engage with millions of people and across a wide spectrum of issues, we are able to access a broad base of experience and expertise.

In our 2015 recommendations paper on legal aid, we stated that the system needs simplification so the public can understand it more easily and it is more effective for practitioners. It needs revision to deal with developing human rights in Scotland. It also needs proper funding, having declined significantly in real terms over the last two decades. Public funding is an issue for all frontline services, but given the high prevalence of justice problems and the social, emotional and financial cost of leaving these unresolved, investment to halt the ongoing real terms decrease in legal aid funding is crucial. A cost-benefit analysis demonstrates that legal aid spending results in substantial savings to the public purse and the wider economy further down the line. A 2010 Citizens Advice report estimated that for every £1 spent on legal aid in England and Wales, the state saved £2.34 on housing advice, £2.98 on debt advice, £8.80 on benefits advice, and £7.13 on employment advice.

Our Council and committees are made up not just of legal practitioners, but also academics and other experts from outside the profession.

As the statutory regulator of the legal profession, we work to ensure the highest possible standards. We also have a duty of care to the public to ensure they have an awareness of their rights and how they can access the Scottish justice system. For these reasons, we have a particular interest in good governance and the creation of good law. We respond to public consultations and recommend detailed amendments to political representatives during the legislative process.

We are a strictly non-partisan organisation and engage regularly with the Scottish Parliament’s committees and with individual MSPs from across the political spectrum. Our objective is to assist in making good law that is coherent, practical and easy to understand.

Lack of investment in legal assistance has made it increasingly difficult to maintain a sustainable, high-quality legal aid system across Scotland. A failure to fund the system properly will lead to advice deserts.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

3

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 4

Significant developments in online dispute resolution have taken place in other countries. In England and Wales, for instance, it is already possible to access telephone mediation for small claims, and the facility to conduct this online is being developed.

For less complex disputes, we believe that this would be an effective use of technology in Scotland. The legal services market is undergoing dramatic change.

Legal services are being delivered in new and innovative ways. There are more cross-border firms, an increasing internationalisation of legal services, changing demands of clients and advances in technology. All are impacting on the Scottish legal profession, businesses and consumers. The legal profession and legal services market is critical to Scotland's economy and society and to the maintenance of the rule of law.

Trust in the Scottish legal sector remains high.

Independent public polling has shown that 90% of the Scottish public are satisfied with the services provided by their solicitor and 82% would recommend their solicitor to others.To ensure this is maintained and built upon, it is important that the solicitor profession has the ability to meet the evolving expectations and demands of clients within a modern flexible framework which can meet the unprecedented, and unforeseen, changes we have seen over recent years and those ahead of us in the future. Regulation of the legal services market is an essential component which contributes to the rule of law, the proper functioning of the justice system, the economy and society in general. Central to any regulatory framework is consumer protection.

The present legal framework surrounding the Scottish legal profession is, in effect, a patchwork of legislation. The underpinning and central piece of regulatory legislation is now over 30 years old.

The legal, economic and social landscapes have significantly evolved since the Solicitors (Scotland) Act 1980 was introduced. Solicitor numbers have more than doubled, with a third of solicitors now employed in-house. They are also working in a much more diverse legal sector, where larger firms have materialised over recent years to exploit the opportunities of the globalised legal market. Although large commercial and international firms are more prominent, smaller private and general law practices still continue to operate, many serving rural communities. These smaller private practices are key in providing important and much needed legal services to members of the community who may have difficulties in accessing legal services otherwise.

Although many of the provisions of the 1980 Act continue to work well, the law needs to be modernised to support and facilitate the evolution of new business structures and advances in technology.

The current legal services market requires a modern, transparent, responsive and adaptable regulatory framework to ensure that, through the Law Society, the Scottish solicitor profession can continue to deliver a competitive world-class service to Scottish,UK and global businesses and consumers.

The legal sector in Scotland now contributes over £1.2 billion to the Scottish economy each year. It is responsible for over 20,000 highly skilled jobs. The services provided by solicitors are critical to the smooth running of the economy, not least in the property market and helping people to set up their own businesses.

The growing numbers of in-house solicitors also make a critical contribution to the success of the companies and organisations that employ them.

Many of the sectors upon which Scotland depends so heavily including energy, financial services, the life sciences, food and drink all rely on high-quality, expert legal services to thrive, whether they are provided in-house or through private practice.

Put simply, a successful Scotland needs a successful Scottish legal profession. Following a pronounced and protracted economic downturn, there is strong evidence to show that the Scottish economy is on the road to recovery. Nevertheless, external challenges in the Eurozone and other international economies, along with the recent significant reductions in the price of oil, demonstrate how the economic recovery cannot be taken for granted. One of the most welcome developments of recent years has been the growing recognition within government of the importance of our legal sector, not just to civic Scotland but as a significant economic generator in its own right. Many firms are now looking to expand – at home and internationally - and recent initiatives such as establishing the Scottish Arbitration Centre have served to highlight Scotland as an effective location for international dispute resolution.

In the legal sector, the Scottish Government has encouraged a spirit of partnership between professional bodies, business groups and government agencies to support law firms and to promote the Scottish legal jurisdiction throughout the world.

The Scottish Government’s economic strategy is critical. It already has important powers to encourage entrepreneurship and innovation and support businesses to grow and create new jobs. This is especially significant for the legal sector given that the vast majority of our legal firms have three partners or fewer, with half of those working as sole practitioner businesses. The Scotland Act 2016 has given additional powers to the Scottish Government which will allow it to support a growing economy. We will be looking to what they do with close interest. ■

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

4

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 5

Company Profile Expert Evidence

by Expert Evidence Limited is a specialist in dispute resolution with financial institutions and over the last few years and has been involved in cases with the following themes Interest Rate Swap mis-selling cases.

Expert Evidence has been involved in a number of cases involving the mis-selling of Interest Rate Swap Agreements (‘IRSAs’) both to private individuals and also small and medium sized enterprises (‘SMEs’).

The IRSAs come in a whole range of different types from Collars, Caps and Fixed Rate agreements which use the derivative markets to produce the results over a fixed period of time. In the majority of cases the agreements do not match the time period of the underlying loans they were seeking to reduce the risk on. In general the agreements come under the legislation relating to investments and so the Financial Services Authority Conduct of Business Rules apply.

Internet banking and vishing attacks – dispute with bank concerning responsibility for fraudulent payments.

The concern here was the duty of care expected from banks when fraudulent payments had been made from a customer’s internet banking system after it had been compromised by external fraudsters (‘vishing‘) obtaining access to genuine profiles.

Our expert reviewed the papers and concluded it was relevant for them to discuss with their bank the level of care a bank should take when highly unusual transactions pass across a business account and the timely action the bank should take to minimize any loss.

This is becoming an increasing problem both for customers and banks. Customers need to be aware to the internal bank procedures which are aimed at reducing the risk of such frauds being successful. It is not just the customer who has responsibilities.

Tax Case – Compulsory Purchase Order.

A compulsory purchase order compensation case where the claimant sought not only the price but the Capital Gains Tax (‘CGT‘) arising on the forced sale, because in a normal sale, the tax could have been avoided. Overturning previous case law authority, the Upper Tier Tribunal agreed that in theory the CGT is claimable provided the loss is shown, i.e. the statutory roll over relief is not available and the tax could have been avoided or passed on to the purchaser.

Tax Case – Stamp duty or not? (settled) A Professional Indemnity Insurance (‘PII‘) claim against advisers for a reclaim of stamp duty reserve tax. This can be reclaimed within 6 years if the

contract fails. However, the advisers incorrectly paid stamp duty, which is harder to reclaim and has a 2 year time limit in any event. Once it became clear to the lawyers what had occurred the case was resolved.

Inappropriate actions by offshore trustees on behalf of beneficiaries.

Over the years many clients have used the facility of a trust structure usually based in an offshore location.

It is important that the Trustees act in a fiduciary capacity for all the beneficiaries and frequently some of the beneficiaries believe that the Trustees have not acted appropriately. At Expert Evidence we have advised on how Trustees have undertaken their role and whether a case exists for compensation of those which have been disadvantaged. It frequently involves the investment actions taken by Trustees on the funds held in the Trust. Consideration of the investment environment and basis of the investment decisions is highly pertinent to the consideration of the evidence.

Professional Indemnity cases brought against surveyors and independent financial advisors (‘IFAs‘).

Given the traumas of the investment markets over the 2007-2009 period, a number of clients and banks have lost substantial funds which are considered caused by the actions by professionals who have provided advice. Expert Evidence has considered a number of cases on behalf of the Banks and also Professional Indemnity insurers and determined if there is a cause for action or not. Professional advisors can include Solicitors, Surveyors, Independent Financial Advisors and Investment Managers which need to act in an appropriate fashion to avoid charges of negligence. Consideration of the investment environment and basis of the professional decisions is highly pertinent to the consideration of the evidence.

Derivative mis-selling cases.

Derivatives, including Puts, Calls, Futures, Options and complicated structures are frequently provided as a risk mitigation strategy to clients. While they may also have substantial benefits, sadly they frequently carry other risks which may result in financial loss in certain circumstances. However it is important that clients understand what they are doing and the risk associated with the investment instruments provided.

In many cases this would require the clients to be

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

5

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 6

providing financial institution ensures that this duty is carried out correctly under the rules. Expert Evidence has advised on a number of cases where the clients have realised substantial losses and the determination of the appropriateness of the strategy proposed needs to be considered.

Contract for differences cases.

Contracts for Differences are much used investment instruments due to the ease of dealing, ability to gear the exposure and the favourable taxation treatment.

As a result many clients have chosen to deal through this medium. However they also can have additional risks particularly as the liability under the management agreement can be very substantial. Where there have been major movements in the underlying stock market, so clients have sometimes found that the risk level has been under-estimated and returns have not met their expectations. Insider dealing and normal investment requirements for clients still apply.

A case which was brought against a firm of accountants which had been involved with a client who had taken out a multi-currency mortgage.

Multi-Currency mortgages have been popular with some clients due to the lower interest rate environment for a number of other of the international traded currencies particularly the Swiss Franc, Yen and Euro. At Expert Evidence we have been requested to provide advice on the appropriateness and suitability of the product as well as the on-going supervision of the mortgage loan during its life. Once again the products carry their own risks particularly in the area of currency exposure which clients need to appreciate and can cause significant loss.

Situation where a client had provided an order which was misinterpreted by the Investment Manager.

The relationship between a bank and their clients can take many forms and usually involves a specially appointed person to represent the financial institution with the client. This can lead to a high level of service but it also has got risks where a Relationship Manager misinterprets a client instruction. The result is that an order may be not executed as a client may have required and when substantial loss occurs the situation can be examined with greater scrutiny.

Investor Classification.

Expert Evidence has been involved with a large number of cases which have primarily been determined by the investment sophistication of the clients and whether the work conducted by the financial institution was “suitable” and “appropriate” as required under the FSA Conduct of Business Sourcebook. The UK regulatory environment has strict rules determining the way that investors are categorised into Retail and Professional investors at the outset of a relationship to provide investment services. Expert Evidence has advised on a range of

situations involving Unit Trusts, Structured Products, Interest Rate Swaps and Derivatives to determine the knowledge level of the underlying clients and the investment institutions responsibilities.

International Cases.

Expert Evidence has a wide international experience and has advised on cases being heard in England, the offshore islands (being Jersey Guernsey and Isle of Man), Ireland and also the Caribbean, the Americas, the Middle East (including the DIFC), and Australasia. Each jurisdiction has its own regulatory environment as well as the requirements on experts giving evidence to their courts. Expert Evidence is pleased to have a wide range of experts familiar with all the above, after all banking if often an international and global activity.

Offshore Clients which had a Portfolio and were represented by Offshore and Onshore Banks, Investment Advisors and Managers.

It is frequently the case that clients will have their investment account with an offshore bank although the account will be managed and/or advised by managers in one of the world’s main financial centres. This is intended to provide the benefits of tax efficiency yet also that the managers are near the heart of the financial community. In some cases the clients will have their custody arrangements in a third location and also the facility of onshore bank accounts and credit cards for their day-to-day expenditure requirements. Whilst highly beneficial in theory, these arrangements have been seen to cause issues for some clients and in a minority of cases they have believed that this will give them a cause for action. Expert Evidence has advised in a number of cases where problems have been brought to light and sought to advise both the banks and clients on the merits of the case.

A portfolio which had been managed with an inappropriate risk profile and substantial costs had been incurred through investment in over risky assets.

The turmoil in the world’s financial markets during 2008 caused many asset classes to react in a way that was highly unpredictable. Whilst every effort was made to invest the funds correctly, the losses incurred may have been totally different to those that clients were led to believe was possible. In some cases the losses have been highly substantial and clients have sought to seek redress. The cases will be decided by the detail of the advice given to clients and the investment experience of the clients themselves. In cases where the concentration of investments in highly risky areas do not fit the clients risk profile, then there may well be a case of negligence by the investment manager in discretionary managed portfolios. For advisory portfolio, it will depend often on where the investment idea was initiated. The normal FSA rules needed to be obeyed in all cases.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

6

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 7

Tax Case – Commercial dispute (unreported) The parties had swapped high value cars and some equality monies. However what is a car for Value Added Tax (‘VAT‘) purposes and was VAT chargeable? Our expert reviewed the papers and concluded it was not relevant to the dispute. The Judge agreed and the Defendants counterclaim for the extra VAT failed because even if VAT was due, the contract made it clear the price was not VAT exclusive.

Investment Managers obligations in the provision of advice.

Since the introduction of the Conduct of Business Sourcebook Rules (‘COBS‘) on the 1st November 2007, the requirements on investment manager has become significantly more onerous on understanding the particular circumstances of the clients and their background in relation to the investment markets. This is normally referred to as Appropriateness and Suitability which needs to be satisfied for all retail clients. The investment requirements in the case of more sophisticated clients, usually called intermediate clients, is significantly less but then the investment institution must be able to show that the client has appropriately classified. This area has led to many cases over the years and Expert Evidence has advised in a number of situations where the case has been decided on these requirements.

Independent Financial Advisors obligations to Clients.

The role of the independent financial advisor (‘IFA‘) has been very general and can include almost any area where the finances of their clients are concerned.

The majority of IFAs deal with clients who are looking for advice in the fields of investment and insurance. Many of the IFAs have traditionally received their income from the product providers and this is thought to have led to a conflict of interest between the IFAs and their clients. As a result many IFAs are looking to move to a fee based approach paid by the clients. The IFAs role has now been additionally complicated by the introduction of the Retail Distribution Review. All these areas are where disputes between the IFA and their clients can arise.

Clients which had suffered loss through foreclosure of a loan arrangement.

Banking relationships with clients are very different to investment relationships but have some of the underlying requirements. The issues of Payment Protection Insurance (‘PPI‘) insurance have been highly material in recent years but whatever the situation the Bank retains a duty of care to its clients.

The issues found in the termination of banking facilities or even the foreclosure are fraught as the bank is by this stage seeks to protect its position and it can have a material detrimental effect on the clients.

This process needs to be managed correctly by the bank and clients should normally be provided with

an opportunity to correct an adverse situation and be treated fairly through the process. Expert Evidence has been involved with a number of tricky situations, particularly where it involves a largely illiquid market for the asset collateral.

Investment managers obligations in execution of client instructions.

Client instructions to an investment manager need to be executed promptly and professionally at the best price available in the market at that time (Best Execution Requirements of Conduct of Business Sourcebook (‘COBS‘)). Occasionally an order can be lost or delayed which can be highly frustrating to clients in a fast moving market. The situation becomes more complex when it involves a limit order that may sit on the market for an extended period (sometimes many days) although these types of error have become rarer with more sophisticated dealing room software.

A reporting error in the quarterly valuations sent to the client, which showed a grossly inflated valuation.

Occasionally some of the highly complex investment instruments are not correctly recorded by the investment institution and so continual errors can be made in the periodic reporting that is sent to clients. Whilst these situations can be highly upsetting for the clients and cause significant distress, it is normally not a situation where a liability for redress would be made.

Expert Evidence has advised in relation to a number of situations which have arisen and sought successful resolution of the case.

Deduction for US income tax made when client had not completed appropriate documentation.

International tax has become ever more complicated and financial institutions usually have a responsibility to deduct some withholding tax at source. This has become much more important in recent years with the introduction of the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (‘FATCA‘) legislation by the US. This follows the parallel regime set up to create Qualified Intermediaries (‘QIs’) which related to investments. Clients may object to not receiving their income gross but institutions have their own requirements from their National Governments which have to be applied.

Civil case on liability where a Ponzi scheme was being operated.

Expert Evidence has provided advice to a trial involving a Ponzi scheme which was conducted alongside and within a trading company. Very large sums of money were invested in a non-existent business ideas and bank statements and invoices were fabricated to make it appear that all was proceeding according to plan. Expert Evidence advised on the point at which the bank which was providing corporate banking facilities to the company should have realised that criminal activity was being perpetrated and on the liability of the bank. Although the core of

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 8

the issue was criminal activity, this case was brought under the civil procedure rules and focused on the responsibility of the bank to investors in a company rather than the actually account holders and authorised individuals from the company.

Our experts include; Thomas Walford Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Expert thomas.walford@expert-evidence.com

Confiscation of assets where no criminal case had been successful.

The case focused on the ability of the authorities to confiscate assets where various banking instruments had been presented to financial institutions. Expert Evidence advised on the normality of the banking instruments which included Bills of Lading, Conditional Guarantees, and Banking Purchase Orders. Some of the documents contained either errors and/or red flags and/or contained conditions which made them worthless. The authorities sought confiscation of assets held in the UK through the English Courts.

Paul Smart - Specialist in Construction paul.smart@expert-evidence.com

Criminal cases involving Fraud, Confiscation of Assets, Money Laundering and Insider Dealing.

Expert Evidence also has a wealth of experience in dealing with a whole range of Criminal cases and determining the advice to the court on the precise situations which have been uncovered. Sometimes in the cases of Fraud the case may be brought as a Civil matter to then follow the Criminal hearing. We are able to act for both the prosecution or defence and investigate the circumstances of the case under either the CPR 35 requirements for Civil cases or CrimPR 33 rules for Criminal cases.

Robert Schon - Taxation Expert robert.schon@expert-evidence.com Colin Cumberland - Banking & Financial Expert collin.cumberland@expert-evidence.com David Griffiths - Banking & Financial Expert david.griffiths@expert-evidence.com Jonathan Pitman - International Trade Expert jonathan.pitman@expert-evidence.com Nigel Brigden - Banking & Wealth Management Operations Expert, IT and Online Fraud nigel.brigden@expert-evidence.com Mervyn Iles - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert mervyn.iles@expert-evidence.com James Penman - Commercial, Lending and Property Finance Expert james.penman@expert-evidence.com Matt Clarke - Loans and Derivatives Expert matt.clarke@expert-evidence.com Expert Evidence www.expert-evidence.com Tel: +44 20 7884 1000

About us Expert evidence are Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts.

Expert Evidence Limited covers all the main areas of dispute resolution and consultancy in litigation and resolving issues between clients. We act as joint appointed or party appointed experts and have substantial experience in providing assistance to clients in dispute.

Our areas of expertise covers; Banking, Building and Construction, Criminal, Investment Banking, Investment Management, Lending, Private Banking & Wealth Management, Regulation and Taxation.

We have substantial experience in being appointed by banks, financial institutions, professional indemnity insurers and investment managers as well as their clients to advise on cases. We act for both UK cases and international situations, particularly in the offshore locations such as Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man plus many of the ex-British colonies such as Gibraltar, Malta, Cyprus, Bermuda, Singapore, Hong Kong and Bahrain. We have also acted in a number of cases in Criminal Trials with such aspects as Money Laundering, Insider Dealing, Confiscation of Assets and Tax Trials.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

8

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 9

Bringing Business Valuation into the Light

by Robin McGregor, Director, Christie Griffith, Forensic Accountants My two favourite sayings about business valuation are first, that it is a black-art and second, that the value of a business is what someone will pay for it.

Unfortunately, neither of these statements are true.

The first statement is often accompanied by a casual shrug of the shoulders to discourage further examination of why the valuation that had been placed on a business is very different from what is offered to the seller. The second statement is simply a fundamental error in understanding the valuation process.

A valuation is an objective estimate of the worth of a business at a point in time and is based on the factors that the valuer has chosen to be representative of likely purchasers. However, the price paid by a purchaser may be more or less than the value placed on the business for a great many reasons, some that should have been considered by the Valuer and others that are known only to the purchaser. A business valuation does include elements of subjective judgement, but these should be clearly stated and supported by evidence. If valuers adopt these principles then it is easy for those comparing valuations to see and understand the impact of changes in the valuation assumptions and for valuers to agree between themselves the areas of disagreement in a constructive fashion.

What is Value?

There are different measures of value and different approaches to the measurement of those values, which is why the first question that a valuer often asks is, what is the purpose of the valuation. The answer to that question is likely to influence the choice of valuation methodology that is appropriate. For an active trading business, a commonly used metric is ‘fair market value’ and this can be defined as: the highest price, expressed in terms of cash or cash equivalents, at which property would change hands

between a hypothetical willing and able buyer and a hypothetical willing and able seller, acting at arm’s length in an open and unrestricted market, when neither is under any compulsion to buy or sell and when both have reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts. Fair market value implies a calculation that should be carried out in light of the prevailing market conditions at the specific date of the valuation, whereas, ‘Fair Value’, is generally interpreted to cover a broader period of time around the date of the valuation, so that temporary dips or increases in value are discounted.

Value is determined at a specific point in time. As such, it is a function only of facts known and forecasts available at that point in time. This reflects the reality that businesses are fluid and the future is uncertain.

The commercial world is in a constant state of flux. A management team can influence or control few of these factors and the wider economic conditions are likely to affect customers and suppliers in different, unpredictable ways. Any of these changes will have an impact on the business and hence on its value.

The value that a potential purchaser ascribes to a business is prospective and reflects the return that they expect to make on their investment. These returns are measured in cash terms so, should be adjusted for any taxes that may be due. Therefore, a purchaser is interested in the future after-tax profitability of a business rather than in its past performance. However, for valuation purposes and business planning generally, past performance is generally regarded as a reasonable basis upon which to base forecasts of future profitability. In assessing the value of a business, a valuer will discount the expected future profitability based on their evaluation of the risks that are likely to either improve or hinder the forecast level of profitability.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

9

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 10

Value and Price In the terminology of valuation, ‘price’ is factual and can only be established by offering an asset for sale and concluding a bargain. In contrast, value represents the worth of an asset, given the economic and business conditions prevailing at the time. These principles apply to all valuations, whether for prospective actual valuations or to a notional valuation being prepared in relation to some date in the past. The variation between value and price arises because, in theory and in practice, each potential purchaser will have different intentions for a business and its assets; a different financing structure; a different tax position and perhaps even a different tax rate. Therefore, the post-acquisition after-tax cash flow is likely to vary been potential purchasers and consequently, the value that each purchaser places on a business will be influenced accordingly.

Additionally, the market for a business is not a perfect one. So, the price that a purchaser is willing to pay is likely to be affected by a range of subjective factors.

The starting point will, of course, be the value that the potential purchasers have calculated, but will also reflect the length of time that the business is marketed, the aims and intentions each purchaser has for the business post-acquisition, the level of interest in the business and of course, the respective negotiating skills of the parties. A price can also be heavily influenced by the degree of compulsion on either the buyer or the seller.

Valuation Methodologies There are many different approaches to valuation, but broadly these recognise that any asset has either a capital value or a potential to generate recurring income. The recognition of the capital value is reflected in ‘net assets’ approaches and the income is used in ‘earnings’ approaches. A net assets approach focuses on the balance sheet of the business and adjusts the ‘book values’ of the assets and liabilities to a current fair market value. This approach would be relevant to businesses that have a high level of assets but have low turnover or profitability. One example might be a property-holding company. This approach is not suitable for businesses that have few physical assets such as a service business, for instance an estate agency. The restated fair market value of the assets less the liabilities gives the value of the business.

An earnings valuation is based on the profitability of a business. Using historical profit trends and future projections if available, a valuer will make an assessment of the likely future performance of the business. That figure is known as Future Maintainable Earnings and the valuer will then capitalise that future income stream to reach a conclusion on the value of the business. The most common ways of

capitalising the value of the business is either to use an earnings multiple (obtained by comparing the value ascribed to other similar businesses) or to calculate the level of return that a potential purchaser is likely to target to compensate them for the risk associated with the business. This approach is based on the assumption that a rational investor will balance greater risk by seeking an appropriately higher rate of return. Hence a risk- averse investor might be happy to receive only a few percent interest on a cash deposit, certain in the knowledge that the capital value is not going to be eroded. So, an investor buying a business where there is a greater risk of losing some or all of the capital invested should be seeking much higher rates of return.

For comparative purposes, the risk-free rate of return is the generally taken to be equivalent to the return on a 10-year government bond, presently around 1.2%. An average risk premium above the risk-free rate that an investor might expect from investing in the UK Stock Market might be in the range 5% to 7%, with certain industries and specific companies being perceived as lower or higher risk outwith this band.

The valuer will then consider other specific risks to the business being valued. Therefore, it is possible to build-up a picture of the level of risk that a particular company should be carrying based on broad market, industry and general economic conditions. Hence, a rational investor should seek to compensate that level of risk by requiring an appropriate level of return, otherwise they should choose to invest in a different less risky asset. These approaches are illustrated in the example below.

In each of the illustrations below assume that the Company has been estimated to have post-tax Future Maintainable Earnings of £100,000.

Purchaser A expects the Company to perform well and considers the published price-earnings (P/E) ratios of similar companies. The published P/E ratios are based on profits after tax and an analysis of these reveals that an average multiple of 7 times is reasonable. Therefore, the value that Purchaser A attaches to the Company is simply £100,000 x 7 = £700,000.

Purchaser B also expects the company to perform well and thinks that the risk associated with investing in the Company is only slightly higher than that of a Stock Market investment. So Purchaser B has calculated that the required rate of return is 10% (risk free rate of 1.2% + equity risk premium of 7% + specific company risk of 1.8%). Therefore, Purchaser B’s valuation of the business is £100,000 divided by 10% = £1,000,000.

Purchaser C considers that the Company is poorly positioned in relation to its competitors. Therefore,

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

10

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 11

Purchaser C considers that an investment in the Company is at least twice as risky as investing in the Stock Market and then there is an additional competitive risk. Consequently, Purchaser C has calculated the rate of return required to be 20% (risk free rate of 1.2% + equity risk premium of 7% + specific company risk of 11.8%). Therefore, Purchaser B’s valuation of the business is £100,000 divided by 20% = £500,000.

In conclusion, in my view it is time to recognise that business valuation is not a black-art and should be conducted using an evidence based approach.

Consequently, a business valuation should be set-out in an open and transparent way that demonstrates that it is well-reasoned. If these basic principles are adopted, then the valuation report will withstand challenge in Court as it will be both theoretically sound and practically robust.

Robin McGregor is a principal in Christie Griffith, an independent niche practice specialising in forensic accounting, corporate finance and business valuation matters. Christie Griffith is led by Gordon Christie and Robin McGregor each of whom have specialist forensic expertise and are accredited as expert witnesses by both the Law Society and the Law Society of Scotland. They both have experience in the Court of Session and Sheriff Courts. Christie Griffith provides litigation support and forensic accounting services that are designed to present complex financial transactions and information in a clear and focused way. Christie Griffith cover all types of disputes and represent clients from all sectors. ■

Christie Griffith FORENSIC ACCOUNTANTS Christie Griffith, an independent niche practice specialising in forensic accounting, corporate finance and business valuation matters Expertise in: Business Valuation Insolvency Litigation Compensation Quantification Business Interruption Insurance Disputes Matrimonial Loss of Profits Loss of Earnings Fraud Investigation Professional Negligence Shareholder Disputes Pension Employer Covenant Review Contact Gordon Christie or Robin McGregor www.christiegriffith.co.uk Tel: 0141 225 8066 19 Woodside Place, Glasgow G3 7QL

Allied Surveyors Scotland PLC is one of Scotland's largest independent firms of chartered surveyors.

We have 30 offices in Scotland which cover every postcode.

We provide a complete range of professional property services including residential and commercial property valuations, Home Reports, energy reports, building surveyors, quantity surveyors and project management.

The extent of our office network allows our surveyors to specialise in the property market in their area meaning that you get the very best advice based on local knowledge.

The company is regulated by The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS). All of our surveyors are fully qualified through RICS and are subject to continual review under the RICS operated 'Valuers Registration Scheme' designed to maintain the highest standards of property valuation.

We act for all major lenders including Royal Bank Of Scotland, Lloyds TSB, Bank of Scotland, Clydesdale Bank, HSBC, Barclays, Santander, Nationwide, Halifax and Woolwich.

HEAD OFFICE Allied Surveyors Scotland, Herbert House, 24 Herbert Street,Glasgow, G20 6NB T: 0141 330 9950 F: 0141 330 9955 E: info@alliedsurveyorsscotland.com W: www.alliedsurveyorsscotland.com

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

11

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 12

The Scottish Arbitration Centre Scotland has a modern arbitration system and can offer the best in legal and dispute resolution services for both domestic and international businesses. The Scottish Arbitration Centre has been at the forefront of the campaign to promote arbitration in Scotland, and Scottish arbitration to the world. It actively encourages international business to Scotland by promoting Scotland as a jurisdiction of arbitration in international disputes; working to put Scotland on the international arbitration map.

Established in March 2011 following the introduction of the Arbitration (Scotland) Act 2010 as a long term investment to develop arbitration in Scotland, the Scottish Arbitration Centre is a not-for-profit organisation made up of five member bodies; the Law Society of Scotland, the Faculty of Advocates, the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators, the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, and the Scottish Ministers. Their hope, and indeed their expectation, is that the Centre’s work will lead to a significant boost in work for members of these professions, as well as other key professionals involved in dispute resolution, including expert witnesses.

Andrew Mackenzie, Chief Executive of the Scottish Arbitration Centre, explains why Scotland has become the place to arbitrate and why bringing the ICCA Congress to Edinburgh in 2020 will be a game changer for Scotland in international arbitration.

What is arbitration?

“Arbitration is a form of alternative dispute resolution (ADR); a legal technique for the resolution of disputes outside the courts, where the parties to a dispute refer it to one or more persons (the “arbitrators” or “arbitral tribunal”) by whose decision (the “award”) they agree to be bound.

Above, Arbitration Board Room

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

12

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 13

Arbitration can be either voluntary or mandatory (although mandatory arbitration can only come from a statute or from a contract that is voluntarily entered into, where the parties agree to hold all disputes to arbitration, without knowing, specifically, what disputes will ever occur).

Arbitration is often used for the resolution of commercial disputes, particularly in the context of international commercial transactions. The use of arbitration is also frequently employed in consumer and employment matters, where arbitration may be mandated by the terms of employment or commercial contracts.

Arbitration differs from mediation in that an arbitrator will issue a final decision on the dispute, which is called an arbitral award. An arbitral award is binding on the parties to the dispute and is legally enforceable. However in mediation, a mediator may only guide the parties toward a mutually agreeable settlement by helping them clarify their underlying interests and concerns and encouraging compromise.

However, if no agreement is reached, the mediator is unable to issue a binding decision on the dispute.”

Why arbitrate in Scotland?

“Arbitration has a long history in Scotland, spanning some seven hundred years, and yet in the Arbitration (Scotland) Act 2010 (“the Scottish Act”), Scotland has one of the most modern systems of arbitration in the world.

The Scottish Act is similar to the 1996 Act in use in England and Wales, and will feel instantly familiar to international arbitration practitioners. Indeed, the Scottish Courts have held that English case law applying to the Act in force there since 1996 can be used to interpret the Scottish Act. This provides predictability and certainty to the Scottish regime.

However, there are some key differences and benefits to arbitrating in Scotland. Arbitration in Scotland is a confidential process, and unlike the position in most jurisdictions, the duty to treat proceedings as confidential is backed up by legislation. Confidentiality is of course one of the attractions of arbitration to parties whose dispute is commercially sensitive. The obligation to treat all matters relating to the arbitration confidentially is enshrined in the Scottish Act, and is has been strongly backed by the Scottish courts. Where a party to an arbitration suffers loss as a result of another party breaching the duty of confidentiality, the aggrieved party can bring an action for damages. Furthermore, and unlike anywhere else, the anonymity provisions ensure that where there is an appeal to the Court parties can request that their names do not appear on the decision. If a challenge is made to court in respect of an arbitration, the courts will keep the parties’ names, and details of the case anonymous, so as to preserve confidentiality. It is possible to persuade the Court that the case should not be reported at all.

There are also no appeals on points of law where the arbitration is an international arbitration. Where the arbitration is ‘domestic’ (concerns two parties based in Scotland), the parties can exclude ‘legal error’ appeals by agreement, thus reducing recourse to the Courts. To reduce unnecessary court challenges, the Scottish Act limits appeals to the Court, and from the Court to the appeal court (the Inner House). There is no appeal to the UK Supreme Court.

Scotland is, in arbitration terms, separate from England – this neutrality may be attractive to foreign parties in dispute with English firms. Scots law is a hybrid or mixed legal system, containing civil and common law elements, making it attractive to companies trading in both these jurisdictions. We also

Above, Castle view from Terrace and Binnie Room

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

13

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 14

have a mature legal system that backs arbitration, with judges who appreciate the need to support the arbitral process. Scotland itself is a very attractive venue in which to arbitrate, with good transport links and accommodation, and with arbitration costs roughly half of those of London and New York.”

What we’ve achieved so far: “Scotland is driving to become a serious contender on the international arbitration stage, and the results of the Centre’s promotional work over the past five years are easily seen.

We understand that arbitration business is generally on the increase in Scotland, with the Centre’s rules increasingly being used as the default dispute clause in business contracts. The Scottish Building Contract Committee has announced it will move to arbitration in contracts and Scottish Government has Scottish arbitration, and the Centre as an appointing body, as the default dispute resolution clause in their goods and service contracts. The Centre has also received a steady number of bookings for its arbitration suites since moving to new premises overlooking Edinburgh Castle on Princes Street in September 2014, including bookings for mediations and arbitration hearings.

We have made a huge impact internationally. We now over 4,300 subscribers to our quarterly newsletter, with over half of these subscribers located outside of the UK. We have also been shortlisted for awards by

Global Arbitration Review for the past two consecutive years.

However, our biggest win to date has certainly been our successful bid to bring the International Council for Commercial Arbitration (ICCA) Congress, the largest international arbitration conference in the world, to Edinburgh in 2020. ICCA is a worldwide nongovernmental organisation (NGO) devoted to promoting the use and improving the processes of arbitration, conciliation and other forms of resolving international commercial disputes. Its activities include convening international arbitration congresses and conferences, sponsoring authoritative dispute resolution publications, and promoting the harmonisation of arbitration and conciliation rules, laws, procedures and standards.

An ICCA Congress is held every second year for the presentation and discussion of papers on different aspects of international dispute resolution. These meetings attract a large number of participants from all parts of the world, and have made significant contributions to the development of dispute resolution theory and practice. The next ICCA Congress will be held in Sydney in 2018 and then in Edinburgh in 2020.

Hosting such a prestigious event is a unique opportunity to attract international attention and business to Scotland. Bringing ICCA to Scotland will allow the international arbitration community to

Above, Arbitration Board Room

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

14

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 15

forge relationships with a wide cross-section of the Scottish arbitration community, not just those few who attend international conferences in other countries. It will also enable us to showcase Scotland as a destination, and to crystallise the concept of Scotland as a possible arbitral seat in the minds of those deciding where to arbitrate.

There are also wider benefits from bringing ICCA 2020 to Scotland. Scottish solicitors will be obvious beneficiaries from an increase in arbitrations seated in Scotland as a result of incidental court work. With additional arbitrations and incidental court work will also come an increase in work for expert witnesses and other professionals involved in dispute resolution proceedings. There is also the angle of marketing Scottish firms as a bridge between common law and civil law jurisdictions. More generally, the conference will put Scotland in the spotlight over the next four years, and in particular, in the two years between the 2018 and 2020 conferences. It will give Scotland an unprecedented profile in the international legal sphere. There is also the economic benefit that will flow from having over 1,000 international lawyers descending on Edinburgh for a week. There will be a very significant boost to the local economy, and to the wider Scottish economy, estimated to be worth more than £2 million.”

How to support us: “Firms or individuals can join our membership programme to receive advertising on our website, discounts off room hire and training events at the Centre, and our quarterly newsletter. Current members include international construction and law firms, as well as London chambers.

The Centre is also currently welcoming expressions of interest from firms or businesses wishing to sponsor or support the ICCA 2020 Congress.

Should you be interested in joining the Centre as a member, or sponsoring ICCA 2020, please contact us.“ About the Scottish Arbitration Centre: The Board of the Centre comprises ten directors; two directors from each of the member bodies, and is chaired by Brandon Malone. Sir David Edward QC is the Centre’s Honorary President, and Hew Dundas is Honorary Vice President. The Centre’s executive team is led by Andrew Mackenzie, a solicitor on secondment from Scottish Government.

Arbitral appointments: The Centre’s independent arbitral appointments service was unveiled in 2014. On request, the Scottish Arbitration Centre can appoint an arbitrator through its Arbitral Appointments Committee. The Arbitral Appointments Committee is an independent

committee that acts separately from the Centre’s Board and has complete discretion to choose the most suitable arbitrator for the dispute from leading international and domestic arbitrators.

The Centre also established two sub-committees within its Arbitral Appointments Committee; one specialising in international appointments, and the other in domestic appointments. The Centre has appointed Juliet Blanch as Chair of the international committee, and James Wolffe QC as Chair of the domestic sub-committee. The full list of committee members is below: • David Carrick, Hill International, Edinburgh • Thomas Halket, Halket Weitz, New York • Kaj Hobér, 3 Verulam Buildings, London and Stockholm • Elie Kleiman, Freshfields, Paris • Lindy Patterson QC, CMS Cameron McKenna, Edinburgh • James Wolffe QC, Faculty of Advocates, Edinburgh • Sandra Cassels, Brechin Tindal Oatts, Edinburgh • Juliet Blanch, Weil's International Dispute Resolution, London • Alice Leggat, SSE PLC, Perth • Olufunke Adekoya, ǼLEX, Nigeria • Eliana Baraldi, De Vivo, Whitaker & Castro, Brazil • Joyce Cullen, Brodies, Edinburgh The Directions and Guidance for the appointment of an arbitrator by the Arbitral Appointments Committee and user forms for the service are available on the Scottish Arbitration Centre’s website.

Hearing rooms: The Scottish Arbitration Centre is located on Princes Street in Edinburgh, in the heart of Edinburgh’s central business district. The Centre’s state of the art hearing rooms and meeting rooms overlooking Edinburgh Castle offer a modern, centrally located and affordable venue for arbitration, mediation and other dispute hearings, and for conferences, events and meetings. Details on room hire are available to view on our website.

Training: The Scottish Arbitration Centre holds an annual arbitrator training day. The training day involves the provision of practical guidance on acting as an arbitrator in a dispute under the Scottish Arbitration Rules (forming Schedule 1) to the Arbitration (Scotland) Act 2010. Leading practitioners provide guidance on how to apply the Rules to common problems; how to deal with difficult cases; and how to avoid challenges to awards.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

15

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 4:00 PM Page 16

Energy Project: The Centre is also involved in a joint energy arbitration project with the Centre for Energy, Petroleum, Mineral Law and Policy at the University of Dundee.

Following the launch of the International Centre for Energy Arbitration (ICEA) by former First Minister Alex Salmond MSP in 2013, the Centre commenced a survey in April of relevant professionals within the energy sector to identify current trends and desired requirements in respect of dispute resolution within the industry. The results of the consultation were published in a report in May 2015, generating much local and international press coverage and interest from arbitration professionals worldwide. Following the publication of the report, the ICEA will now work towards developing bespoke arbitration rules.

The Scottish Arbitration Centre is a long term investment to create a new industry of arbitration in Scotland to support growth and increase business.

We believe this will lead to significant benefits for relevant practitioners now and into the future. â–

Below, Scottish Arbitration Centre's hearing rooms

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

16

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 17

Gunshot Residue Evidence – A Loose Canon?

by Angela Shaw - The Forensic Firearms Consultancy Ltd 2016 The Forensic Science Service (FSS) was the largest employer of gunshot residue (GSR) experts in England and Wales with an impressive array of instrumentation required for round the clock analysis of the samples taken from suspects of gun crime. Since its closure in 2012 the GSR criminal casework load was split between three main private forensic providers depending on their success or failure at tendering for the work being offered by the police forces in England and Wales. Less than half of the number of GSR experts from the FSS now work for these providers and the majority of the remainder left the profession. Scotland, Northern Ireland and Ireland have their own publicly funded forensic science providers.

The existence of GSR as an evidence type came about almost by accident when in 1974 Robin Keeley, a senior scientist at the Metropolitan Police Forensic Science Laboratory, was conducting a study of particles collected on air filters during a survey of lead levels in the atmosphere of indoor firing ranges. He noticed whilst observing the lead using scanning electron microscopy and x-ray spectrometry, discrete particles composed of lead, antimony and barium and that they appeared to occur only in percussion primer residue; there was no non-firearms source.

For the first time scientists had a method for conclusive identification of gunshot residue. At about the same time, and independently, a similar project was undertaken by the Aerospace Corporation in California. The findings were confirmed by other workers and are still valid today.

When a gun is fired the hammer strikes the percussion cap at the base of a cartridge. The primer

detonates and sends a stream of hot gases into the main charge of propellant, which ignites, generating large volumes of gaseous products, which force the projectile down the barrel of the gun. The high temperature inside the cartridge creates conditions in which the individual components of the primer can fuse together. These particles are emitted from the end of the barrel of a gun and from any gaps or openings in the gun’s action and can be deposited on the firer, any persons sufficiently close to the firer, and the gun itself. After the material has cooled discrete particles remain containing combinations of the elements of the original primer and contributions from the gun barrel, cartridge case and the bullet.

The recovery and identification of GSR on clothing or hand samples can help address questions such as, “has the suspect fired a gun?” GSR is not a conclusive evidence type such as DNA or fingerprints. It is a corroborative evidence type but the usefulness of GSR should not be underestimated as its presence or absence in crimes involving firearms can be crucial to the overall strength of evidence when a case comes to trial.

It is rarely contested that GSR originates from a firearm. What is of far more interest is how the particles came to be present on a suspects clothing, skin or hair. This can only be evaluated within the full circumstances of the case taking into account both the prosecution and defence hypotheses. The type of firearm and ammunition used in the crime is also important information to the GSR expert as it can have an impact on the amount of GSR that may be deposited onto the suspect or their surroundings.

GSR is one of the most heavily scrutinised trace evidence types in criminal investigations and the

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

17

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 18

expert must ensure that police officers, solicitors, barristers and ultimately the court understand the strength of the evidence. With any trace evidence the possibility of cross-contamination should always be uppermost in the mind. In the UK GSR is rare in the general environment and the expectation is that one would not expect it to be present on a suspect with no connection to firearms. However, studies in the UK have discovered that single particles can be found, albeit infrequently, on public transport.

Probably the most well known case involving gunshot residue was the murder of Jill Dando on April 26th 1999 when she was shot once in the head. Police searched the home address of Barry George just over a year later and recovered a coat amongst other items.

A single particle of gunshot residue was found inside one of the pockets. The particle had a similar composition to the residue found on Ms Dando’s hair, her raincoat and the spent cartridge case recovered at the scene of the shooting. There were four strands of evidence put forward at the original trial in 2001 pertaining to identification evidence, potential lies told by Mr George regarding his knowledge of Ms Dando, a false alibi and the single particle of gunshot residue. The jury found Mr George guilty of Ms Dando’s murder.

Picture above opposite, GSR particle found in Barry George’s coat pocket (BBC News online, 7th November 2007)

The Criminal Case Review Commission (CCRC) in 2006 requested a review of the oral and written evidence in relation to the significance of the single particle and the way in which the case would have been reported today. While employed at the FSS I carried out this review in conjunction with a colleague. We concluded that the GSR evidence was inconclusive; it was no more likely that the particle had originated from the shooting of Ms Dando than it had come from another source. This was based on the information that the coat in which the particle had been found was not recovered until a year after the shooting. The CCRC referred the case to the Court of Appeal stating that the GSR particle that was given great significance by the Prosecution at the trial in 2001 was, in reality of no probative value. The

FORENSIC FIREARMS CONSULTANCY CONSULTANT FORENSIC SCIENTISTS www.forensicfirearmsconsultancy.com

FFC offers bespoke, customer-led solutions to all firearms and GSR-related investigations.

Forensic Firearms Consultancy (FFC) Ltd is an innovative company led by two world-renowned experts.

During their time at the UK Forensic Science Service (FSS), Mark Mastaglio and Angela Shaw became the most senior scientists working in forensic firearms and gunshot residue (GSR) respectively. It is the only UK-based private consultancy offering this level of expertise, experience and worldwide reputation in firearms and GSR. FFC can undertake work at every level of forensic firearms and GSR examinations and has extensive experience of complex, sensitive cases from across the globe.

The FFC directors are two of the most senior and experienced practitioners in the UK, with over 35 years of combined court going experience.

FFC’s Expert Witness service includes: ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖ ❖

Examination of the full range of cases, from the alleged illegal possession of firearms and ammunition to complex interpretation of fatal shooting incidents In-depth knowledge of firearms legislation involving complex classification issues – an insider’s knowledge of firearms law policy Antique firearm evaluation Air gun classification Computer aided simulations of crime scenes and projectile trajectories Potential for accidental discharge Trajectory reconstruction analysis, including scene visits Determination of the type of gun used Determination of how many guns used Range of fire determination Interpretation of autopsy findings, including autopsy examination attendance Interpretation of GSR findings (incorporating SEM-EDX results) Critical analysis of GSR contamination issues

If you need immediate advice, please contact either Mark Mastaglio on +44 7919 217 848 or Angela Shaw on +44 7919 392 397.

Otherwise please email us at: enquiries@forensicfirearmsconsultancy.com. Our website is at: www.forensicfirearmsconsultancy.com

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

18

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 19

Appeal Court ruled that it was impossible to know what weight, if any, the jury attached to the particle and as such the verdict was ruled unsafe and the conviction quashed. In a retrial in 2008 at the Central Criminal Court the GSR evidence was ruled inadmissible prior to the commencement of the trial.

Mr George was acquitted.

This case has generated much discussion among GSR experts around the world and in the main in the UK no significance is placed on the finding of a single particle. The decision on whether or not to admit single GSR particles as evidence rests with the court.

In this case both arguments were put before the court but in some jurisdictions single particles are reported as supporting the contention that a suspect has either handled or fired a gun. Additionally in these jurisdictions prosecution experts offer no interpretation to assist the court or jury and do not include an assessment of the possibility of contamination.

One of the many cases that FFC Ltd. have been involved in was that of the Glasgow gangland murder of Kevin Carroll in 2010. A single particle of GSR was identified on a jacket recovered from the home address of the suspect, Ross Monaghan, more than six months after the shooting. The address had been searched by armed police officers that were likely to be contaminated with GSR. The prosecution expert stated that a lack of information about the

source of the particle precluded her saying anything more about how the particle was deposited however after hearing both the prosecution and defence evidence during a voir dire the judge at the High Court in Glasgow ruled the particle inadmissible as evidence citing the possibility that it arrived on the jacket through secondary transfer from the armed police officers clothing. Mr Monaghan was acquitted.

Numerous studies for the presence of GSR on armed police officers, their vehicles and equipment, police officers not associated with firearms and occupational environments have found that sources of contamination do exist. Reporting an unqualified finding of the presence of gunshot residue can ultimately mislead the court. They cannot appreciate the significance of the potential for contamination if it is not mentioned in the results and the case may go ahead with the gunshot residue findings being unchallenged.

The interpretation of GSR is complex and should only be carried out by highly experienced experts knowledgeable in all the facets of the evidence type.

FFC Ltd has a proven track record in this regard having been commissioned in cases from all corners of the globe. Get it wrong and miscarriages of justice result; the innocent are convicted and the guilty walk free.

Angela Shaw Š The Forensic Firearms Consultancy Ltd 2016

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

19

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 20

by Iain Mc Arthur of AVF In May 2010, Suzanne Pilley disappeared on her way into work in the centre of Edinburgh. Four years on, the 38-year-old has never been found.

Despite never recovering a body, a detailed police investigation revealed she had been murdered in the basement of her workplace by her colleague and exlover, David Gilroy.

Police believe David Gilroy went to the basement of the office with Suzanne as she arrived at work. He the murdered her, leaving her body in a stairwell.

He then brought his car to work, putting in the boot of his silver Vauxhall Astra.

Before doing so, he arranged a meeting which would require him to drive about 130 miles to Lochgilphead in rural Argyll the next day.

Through CCTV and mobile phone analysis, police believe that during that journey on Wednesday 5 May 2010, Gilroy disposed of Suzanne’s body.

Despite extensive searches of the remote forests in Argyll, Suzanne’s body was never recovered.

Nevertheless, in April 2012, Gilroy was sentenced to life in prison for her murder.

CCTV analysis of Gilroy’s movements and use of his car was pivotal in this case and securing a conviction.

What’s caught on camera is increasingly being used to secure convictions and identify criminals. As this BBC Crimewatch episode re-construction demonstrated, audio and video ‘clips’ are central to the investigative process.

As any viewer will be aware, Crimewatch depends on these clips to stimulate the memories of the public and piece together a jigsaw of evidence.

In what has become part of our diet of media consumption, a typical episode will have a series of CCTV clips of suspects in crimes up and down the country.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

20

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 21

There are occasion however, when the authenticity of audio visual evidence comes into question; Notable ones that have arisen are 1. The Daily Mirror pictures of a soldier allegedly urinating on an Iraqi published in 2005.

After a complex investigation by the SIB Military Police and AVF, markings on the truck, the weapon, the camouflage pattern on the uniform and even the moles on the soldiers arm were compared to the newspapers images and it was proven beyond doubt that the photographs had been carefully staged to create proof of alleged mistreatment of prisoners. As a result of this, Piers Morgan lost his job as editor of the newspaper.

2. The News Of The World published a story (from covert video material on their website) of the then world snooker champion John Higgins apparently making a deal to throw a match whilst in the Ukraine.

AVF were engaged by Mr Higgins and after close scrutiny it was apparent that thevideo had been incorrectly subtitled and the order of the footage had been changed, this changed the outcome of the hearing as the video had been biased towards the allegation 3. Expressen Newspaper in Sweden had an image supplied to them that allegedly showed the king of Sweden 20 years earlier in a strip club with agroup of scantily clad women. At the time the picture was submitted, the King had a book published about him that tarnished his reputation and AVF was tasked with authenticating the images. After detailed analysis the image was deemed highly suspect due to differences in shadow angles and the amount of manipulation that had already occurred on it.

One nation under CCTV Whatever the crime, burglary or murder, a CCTV camera will never be far away.

The British Security Industry Authority (BSIA) has estimated there are up to 5.9 million closed-circuit television cameras in the country, including 750,000 in “sensitive locations” such as schools, hospitals and care homes.

Their survey’s maximum estimate works out at one for every 11 people in the UK, although the BSIA said the most likely figure was 4.9 million cameras in total, or one for every 14 people.

According to the BSIA, “Effective CCTV schemes are an invaluable source of crime detection and evidence for the police. For example, in 2009, 95 per cent of Scotland Yard murder cases used CCTV footage as evidence.”

The scale and penetration of CCTV and the evidence it can contain is all very fine. But images can be grainy and of poor quality to the extent that material won’t stand up in court.

Investigators need help with recordings to enhance images and get a better picture of the criminal party, whether on sound or vision. This is where specialists such as Audio Video Forensics Ltd come in.Audio Video Forensics has worked with UK Legal Firms, Police agencies & military clients for over 19 years as an enhancement bureau & in expert witness capacity at Crown Court & Old Bailey level.

Using some of the most cutting edge technology available the company has successfully enhanced & transcribed previously thought impossible recordings.

It has extensive experience in assisting the investigation of serious crime including murder, paedophilia, arson, robbery, fraud, military crimes, rape, GBH, aggravated burglary etc. And it has conducted many crime reconstructions from on-site height estimations to video preparation for the aforementioned BBC Crimewatch.

Whereas DNA analysis takes centre stage in many investigations, audio and video analysis can be just as incontrovertible.

Separating the grit from the gruesome The analytical eye and ear of Audio Video Forensics has unravelled both audio and video evidence from mobile phones to multiplex video tapes in highly complex and high profile cases such as the Rhys Jones murder enquiry, the Milly Dowler Murder enquiry, the Mark Duggan Case (for BBC news), the Raoul Moat case (for SKY News), the Baha Mousa enquiry (Iraq) and the Daily Mirror Iraq fake photo enquiry (for ITN).

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

21

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 22

For example, the company‘s insights were behind the high-profile coroner ruling that Terry Lloyd - the ITN reporter shot dead in Iraq - was unlawfully killed by American troops. Video footage filmed just after the incident showed American tanks and soldiers inspecting the wreckage of Mr Lloyd and cameraman Daniel Demoustier's 4x4 in Iraq.

The footage was shown at Mr Lloyd's inquest at Oxford Coroner's Court. It was taken by a cameraman attached to the tank unit alleged to have fired on Mr Lloyd's convoy.

The video was released to the Royal Military Police some months after the incident by American authorities. Audio Video Forensics looked at the tape and estimated that 15 minutes of film may have been cut from the beginning.

The Coroner said: "Part of the footage appears to have been edited... around the time perhaps that Mr Lloyd may have been involved in the incident."

In another high-profile criminal case, a "wannabe gangster" was jailed for life for the murder of a pregnant neighbour in a cold-blooded execution following a parking row. An Old Bailey jury took three hours to find Thomas Hughes guilty of murdering Krystal Hart. Hughes had denied the shooting, saying another man was responsible. But parts of the incident - including the sound of two shots and Hughes hurrying away - were caught on CCTV.

When Daily Mirror editor Piers Morgan published photos of British soldiers supposedly abusing an Iraq, little did he know that his job was on the line.

The Queen’s regiment demonstrated to reporters aspects of uniform and equipment which it said proved the photographs were fake. The regiment's Brigadier Geoff Sheldon said the vehicle featured in the photographs had been located in a Territorial Army base in Lancashire and had never been in Iraq.

Once again AVF was able to uncover the truth Sound & Vision Iain Mc Arthur who heads up the company says his success is based on the convergence of technologies and enhancement processes. Sound came before vision, but the two were soon to converge.

Starting out, Iain worked for 15 years in recording studios as a sound engineer and a producer in the fields of music and commercial/television work.

Whilst working in the field of CD mastering he progressed into the field of forensic audio enhancement particularly since CD mastering involves equalisation, compression and noise reduction; all processes involved in audio enhancement. He holds an OND in Sound recording technology (Acoustics/electronics/ studio techniques) and has worked in the Research & Development Department of renowned Pro-Audio manufacturer AMS-Neve, developing audio mixing desk technology for the film industry.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

22

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 23

He was Lead Software Test Engineer on their flagship product the DFC Digital Film Console (Over 70% of the world's blockbuster films are mixed on D.F.C.) where his responsibilities were in Software Development and Testing, Training and Customer Support.

A great deal of his work involves video & audio enhancement/transcription assignments received from various Police Services or Independent Legal Representatives.

only privately owned system outside the USA • Unsurpassed audio enhancement & analysis • Damaged audio, video & Dictaphone tape recovery • Detailed transcription of noisy recordings for court presentations • Voice pitching to disguise witness • Analysis of audio & video recordings for signs of editing or tampering • Subtitled transcriptions on DVD of telephone calls & video recorded conversations • Still image & DVD copies from VHS or digital CCTV • Video de-multiplexing of up to 128 cameras • Vehicle, clothing, facial & object comparison • Face blurring of witnesses & number plates • Computer graphics (CGI) simulations

These often arrive accompanied by partial transcriptions, and invariably the material needs enhancement for clarification, independent transcription and verification that no editing has taken place.

Testimonial I am writing to you by way of providing a testimonial/ recommendation for work undertaken by an expert witness approved by the National Crime Faculty.

Reflecting the significance of this type of evidence, Iain is contracted for all forensic audio and video work for the UK Military Police (worldwide).

AVF came recommended through the Crime Faculty during 2003 when we were investigating a murder committed by a convicted prisoner during a period of temporary pre-release parole. There was no useful eye-witness evidence and no conventional forensic evidence to connect the suspect to the crime.

Iain now has over 19 years’experience working as an Independent Forensic Audio/Video Enhancement and Transcription Specialist. This has enabled him to take on high-profile jobs such as the aforementioned death of ITN journalist Terry Lloyd and the Daily Mirror's Iraqi fake photograph story.

As continuous improvement is part and parcel of the personal development process, Iain has trained with Intergraph Public Safety in Huntsville, Alabama in video enhancement techniques; and he is now the European trainer of Intergraph video enhancement software in Europe. This is Video Analysis software and has been used on the Space Shuttle disaster and on all US Government analysis of Osama Bin Laden video footage.

Iain is also one of only two users of Digicleen specialised audio enhancement software in the UK. This software is used by over 100 offices of the Federal Bureau of Investigation in the US and is highly regarded due to its advanced noise reduction capabilities.

These credentials and technological maturity are the main reasons Iain’s client base has grown to include the cream of private legal firms, HM Customs, MET Police (& Special Ops.),GMP. Strathclyde, Cheshire, West Mids., West Mercia, Transport Police, Derbyshire, PSNI, Royal Military Police (S.I.B.).

Summary of expertise • 20 years' experience as a professional sound & video technician • 19 years' experience in field of audio, video & still image enhancement & analysis • Advanced enhancement, tracking & stabilising of shaky & poor quality video using Video Analyst software - a NASA-designed system used to analyse the Columbia Space Shuttle disaster & the

However, police later inserted a covert audio recording device in prison after the suspect had returned to gaol. We then recorded his conversations with visitors who were also suspected conspirators in the murder. The prison’s internal security cameras were also trained on the suspect and his visitor’s during the audio recording process.

Unfortunately, the quality of the audio was very poor and required considerable enhancement. AVFs services were secured and they set about lip-synching the audio track with the separate video material. AVF then enhanced the quality of the audio recording before finally producing a high quality series of DVD’s with sub-titled dialogue.

The final product contained incriminating statements and admissions including a confession to the murder.

The S.I.O., Detective Superintendent Hugo Frew and Senior Prosecuting Counsel in the case, Mr. Terence Mooney Q.C. have both been highly impressed with the results of AVFs work. They provide a wide range of services for both audio and video forensic work and is regularly used by UK police services.

I cannot recommend Audio Video Forensics highly enough.

Paul McParland - Detective Sergeant, Police Service of Northern Ireland, Belfast.

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

23

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 24

Focus on Scotland Expert Witness supplement 2016

Areas of Expertise Over the following pages we have listed some of the areas of expertise that we provide experts for. Please note that this is only a selection of our experts database.

You may notice that a few of the experts reside outside scotland, this does not mean that they do not undertake or understand Scottish Law, in fact quite the opposite.

We provide a free telephone service on 0161 834 0017. We aim to reply with an email to every call within 2 hours.

Alternatively visit our website at www.expertwitness.co.uk

If you require further information on any of the experts or would like to order a full 1,200 page hardbacked directory please contact myself or any of our team at info@expertwitness.co.uk Regards Chris Connelly Expert Witness Editor

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

24

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 25

Focus on Scotland Expert Witness supplement 2016 Abatement Notices

Disputes Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Abdominal Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Accident & Emergency Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire)

Accidents Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Assessment of Injuries Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Fitness to Work Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Injuries Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Low Velocity Impact Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Accountancy Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Christie Griffith - Forensic Accountants - (Scotland) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Embezzlement Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

False Accounting & Theft Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Financial Planning Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Forensic Accountancy Christie Griffith - Forensic Accountants - (Scotland)

Customs & Excise/VAT Fraud Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Tax/Subsidy Fraud Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Fraud Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland) Christie Griffith - Forensic Accountants - (Scotland)

Loss of Earnings Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland) Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Matrimonial Issues Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Personal Injury Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland) Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Taxation Business Disputes

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide)

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide)

Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Assessment Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Benefits of Crime Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Chartered Accountant Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Confiscation of Assets

Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Business Taxation/Corporation Tax Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

25

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 26

Personal Taxation Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Tax Investigations/Appeals Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

VAT/Customs & Excise Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide)

Air Conditioning Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Alcohol GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Alcohol Related Accidents Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Alcoholism GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Substance Abuse

Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Acoustics Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Acquired Perinatal Brain Injury Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Acute Medicine Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Actuaries Punter Southall Limited - Actuaries - (Nationwide)

ADR Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Aeronautical Engineering Bradley Brian Captain - Aviation and Pilot Training Consultant - (Area of work Nationwide)

Agriculture Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Accidents Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Farm Accidents Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Machinery Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Anderson Ian Dr - Registered Psychologist, Psychologist Practitioner, Clinical Psychologist, Counselling Psychologist, Occupational Psychologist, Forensic Psychologist (grandparenting application pending), Neuro-Psychologist Chartered Psychologist, Chartered Scientist.

- (Nationwide)

Substance Misuse Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Alternative Medicine Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Homeopathy Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Amputation Chalmers Roderick T A Mr. - Consultant Vascular Surgeon - (Nationwide)

Anaesthesia Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

General Anaesthesia Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Intensive Care Medicine Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Medico-legal Reports Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Surgery Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Antiques Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Restoration Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

26

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 27

Arbitration

Arson

Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Art Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Identification Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Valuation Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Arthritis Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Arbitration Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Arboriculture Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Accident Reports Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Forestry Operations/Safety Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Treatment Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Wrist, Finger and Thumb Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Asbestos Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Laboratory Services Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Architecture Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide) Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Adjudication Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Building Contracts Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Chartered Architect Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Historic Buildings Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Listed Buildings Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Professional Negligence Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Asperger Syndrome The Educational Psychology Practice - Chartered Psychologists and Education Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Audio Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Audio Restoration/Enhancement Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Audio Transcription Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Fitness for Purpose Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Forensic Audio Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Recorded Speech Transcription Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Signs of Editing/Tampering Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

N E E D A N E X P E R T FA S T C A L L 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 28

Sound Evidence (Audio) Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Sound Forensic Analysis Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Speech Quality Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Tape Examination Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Transcription Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Audio Authentication Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Signs of Editing/Tampering Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Audiology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Hearing Assessment Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Hearing Loss Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Noise Induced Deafness Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Autism Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol) The Educational Psychology Practice - Chartered Psychologists and Education Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Automotive Engineering Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Internal Combustion Stinton Calvert Dr. - Consulting Engineer - (Area of work Nationwide)

Back Injury

Whiplash Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Bacteria Casey Michael Mr - Water Treatment Consultant - (Herts)

Ballistics Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Air Gun Classification Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Analysis Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Antique Firearm Evaluation Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Computer Aided Simulations of Crime Scenes and Projectile Trajectories Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Deactivated Guns Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

GSR Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Gunshot Residue Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Identification Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Shooting Reconstructions Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Weapons Testing Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Wound Ballistics Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Back Pain Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

N E E D A N E X P E R T FA S T CALL FREE ON 0161 834 0017

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

28

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 29

Banking Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Commercial Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Financial Documentation Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Investment banking Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Lending Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Practice and Procedures Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Blood Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Boats Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Body Fluids Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

DNA Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Forensic Biology Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Boilers Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Breasts Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Breast Reconstruction Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Cosmetic Surgery Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Plastic Surgery Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Bridges Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Brownfield Sites Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Building Contracts Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Building Regulations Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Ross Lidell - Property Experts - (Scotland)

Building Services Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Ross Lidell - Property Experts - (Scotland)

Building Surveyors Ross Lidell - Property Experts - (Scotland)

Body Fluids Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

DNA Profiling Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Building-Construction Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Ross Lidell - Property Experts - (Scotland) Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire)

F O R A L L E X P E R T S D E TA I LS V I S I T W W W . E X P E R T W I T N E S S . C O . U K

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 30

Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Accidents Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Accommodation Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Acoustics Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Environmental Assessment Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Adjudication Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Building Contracts Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Contract Disputes Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Forms of Contract Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Building Defects Applied Geotechnical Engineering Ltd - Consulting Geotechnical and Foundation Engineers - (UK)

Building Disputes Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide) Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Claims Preparation Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide) Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Disabled Living Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Personal Injury Claims Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Dispute Resolution Applied Geotechnical Engineering Ltd - Consulting Geotechnical and Foundation Engineers - (UK)

Foundations Applied Geotechnical Engineering Ltd - Consulting Geotechnical and Foundation Engineers - (UK)

Insurance Claims Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Investigations Applied Geotechnical Engineering Ltd - Consulting Geotechnical and Foundation Engineers - (UK) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Risk Assessment/Management Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide))

Negligence Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Project Management Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Adjudication Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide))

Arbitration Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide)) Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Specification Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Civil Engineering Defects

Burns Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Business Valuations Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Cancer Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Head

Remedial Measures - Quantum (Costs of Remedy)

Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide))

Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire)

Malignant Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

30

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 31

Neck Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow) Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire)

Dr Duncan Dymond MD FRCP FACC FESC

Consultant Cardiologist

Skin Cancers Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire) Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Capacity Assessment Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol) Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Neuropsychological Assessment Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Carbon Monoxide Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Dr Duncan S Dymond has been a consultant cardiologist at St Bartholomew's Hospital, now a part of Barts Health NHS Trust since 1987.

He has been undertaking expert witness and medicolegal work for more than 5 years and has completed his Cardiff University Bond Solon expert Witness course.

Dr Dymond currently completes 1-2 medicolegal reports per week, for personal injury and medical negligence, with roughly a 60/40% split claimant/defendant.

He has also completed expert witness work for the General Medical Council, the Medical Defence Union and the Crown Prosecution Service as well as accepting private instructions directly for solicitors. He has also provided mediolegal opinions for cases in Singapore.

T: 0207 079 4260 E: debbie@drduncandymond.com W: www.drduncandymond.com 110 Harley Street, London, W1G 7JG

Cardiac Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Cardiac Rhythm Management Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Cardiology Chalmers Roderick T A Mr. - Consultant Vascular Surgeon - (Nationwide) Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide) Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Anaesthesia Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Angina

Cardiac Surgery Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Cardiomyopathy Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Cardiothoracic Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide) Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Cardiovascular Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide)

Chest Pain

Angiography Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide) Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas) Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Angioplasty

Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Chest Surgery Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Clinical Negligence

Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Coronary Artery Disease

Arrhythmia Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide) Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

F O R A L L E X P E R T S D E TA I LS C A L L 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 32

Coronary Heart Disease Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide) Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Diagnostic Techniques in Cardiology Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Heart Failure Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide) Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Child Protection Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Child Psychiatry Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Childhood Sexual Abuse Claims Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Civil Engineering

Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Interventional Cardiology Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Research Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Structural Heart Disease Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Care Expert N-Able Services Ltd - Occupational Therapists - (Area of work Nationwide)

Cerebral Palsy Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland)

Challenging Behaviour Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Chemical Engineering Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Health & Safety Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Child Care/Custody Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Child Neglect Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Child Physical and Emotional Abuse Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

Traffic Impact Assessments Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

Civil Engineering - Construction Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Civil Engineering Applied Geotechnical Engineering Ltd - Consulting Geotechnical and Foundation Engineers - (UK)

Clinical Error Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Clinical Governance Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Clinical Negligence Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Combustion Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Commodities Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

32

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 33

Communication Systems MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Complex Learning Needs Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol)

Computers Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England) Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Computer Communication Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Computer Evidence Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England) MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Computer Forensic Investigation MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Computer Forensics

Software Packages Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Computer Systems Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Computer Technology Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Data Recovery Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Digital Evidence MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Forensic Computing Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England) MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Fusion Corporation Research & Development - Specialist Analysis, Enhancement and Identification of Audio-, Video-, Telephone- and Computer-based Evidence & Data - (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Computing

MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Fraud Investigation

Computer Fraud Investigation MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Computer Hardware Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Personal Computers Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Computer Misuse Investigation

MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Informatics Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Concrete Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Condensation & Dampness Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Computer Software Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Fitness for Purpose Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Construction Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Construction Planning Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK) Construction Planning (Time & Resource Management)

Construction Project Management Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

N E E D A N E X P E R T FA S T C A L L 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 34

Consultant Surgeon Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Contaminated Land Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Environment Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Environmental Monitoring Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Remediation Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Contracts Rothman James Mr. - Independent Marketing and Research Consultant - (London)

Copyright Rothman James Mr. - Independent Marketing and Research Consultant - (London)

Corrosion Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Crime Scene Investigations Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Criminal Courts Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Criminal Injury Compensation Claims Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Criminal Issues Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Criminal Work Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Deafness Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Deep Vein Thrombosis Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Defects Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Dental Negligence Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Dental Treatment Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Dentistry - Dento-legal Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Anaesthetics Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee) Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Assessments Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Bridges Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Conscious Sedation Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Crowns Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Dental Reports Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Dental Trauma Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Dento-Facial Trauma Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Disputes Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Endodontics Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Implants Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Periodontology Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Personal Injuries Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Dentures, Crowns, Bridges Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

34

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 35

Restorative Dentistry Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Dental Implantology Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Treatment Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Unnecessary Dental Treatment Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Depression Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide) Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Clinical Negligence Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Dermatology Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Housing Needs Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Immediate Care Needs Assessment Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Loss of Earnings Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Quantum Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Disability Discrimination Act Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Dispute Resolution Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Skin Cancer Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Skin Complications Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Dispute Resolution

Disability Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Access Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Assessment Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Disability Audit Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Disabled Accommodation Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Educational Assessment Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Employment Prospects Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Divorce Anderson Ian Dr - Registered Psychologist, Psychologist Practitioner, Clinical Psychologist, Counselling Psychologist, Occupational Psychologist, Forensic Psychologist (grandparenting application pending), Neuro-Psychologist Chartered Psychologist, Chartered Scientist.

- (Nationwide)

Documents Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Anonymous Letters Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Document Authentication Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

F O R A L L E X P E R T S D E TA I LS C A L L 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 36

Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Document Examination Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

Forensic Document Examination Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Documentary Fraud Detection Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Faxes/Photocopies/Computer Generated Documents Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Document Examination Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Document Handling Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Handwriting Examination Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

FHDI Mrs Kathryn Thorndycraft-Pope Forensic Document Examiner Kathryn Thorndycraft-Pope is a Forensic Document Examiner, her expertise in in examining handwriting and documents to determine if they are genuine or fraudulent. She uses specialised equipment which can decipher alterations, erasions and indentations.

Kathryn started her career as a Forensic Document Examiner by joining the Identification Bureau of Grampian Police over 20 years ago.

After initial training which included a short experience at the Home Office in Birmingham, and training in all aspects of ‘Identification’ of the crime such as Scene of Crime, Forensic Photography and Fingerprints.

She was authorised as a Forensic Document Examiner by The Secretary of State for Scotland, to report on Handwriting and Document Examination, and attend Court as an Expert Witness. In 1998 she started her own Company - FHDI (Forensic Handwriting & Document Investigation) undertaking casework from all over the UK Europe and Worldwide.

Kathryn has given Expert Witness evidence on many occasions, including many High Courts, Sheriff and District Courts. She was involved in a case which made Scottish legal History when £100 million of cocaine was brought into the West Coast of Scotland. Kathryns’ expertise was vital in establishing the importers connections and proving their guilt. She also has media experience having appeared on BBC Scotland and Gaelic TV.

FHDI The Coach House, 4 Fetteresso Castle Stonehaven, Aberdeen AB39 3UR - Area of work Nationwide Tel: 01569 764 508 Mobile: 07710 655 838 Email: kt@fhdi.co.uk Web: www.fhdi.co.uk

Forgeries Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Fraud Investigations Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

Handwriting Comparison Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

Identifying Counterfeits Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Questioned Documents Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Signature Authentication Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Wills Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Drainage Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Drink Driving GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

Driving Aldbar - Road Traffic Experts - (Scotland) Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide) GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

36

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 37

Drugs GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Drug Abuse

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Drugs of Abuse GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Substance Abuse GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Substance Misuse GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

E-Disclosure MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Effluent Treatment Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Elderly Care Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Elderly Care Medicine

Employment Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Punter Southall Limited - Actuaries - (Nationwide)

Careers Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Employers Liability Claims Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Employment Disputes Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Equal Opportunities Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Pay & Benefits Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Punter Southall Limited - Actuaries - (Nationwide)

Loss of Earnings Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Punter Southall Limited - Actuaries - (Nationwide)

Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Electrical Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Emergency Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Emergency Trauma Care Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Emerging Markets

Self-employed Loss of Earnings Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Endometriosis Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

DGEC Ltd Douglas Govan

Employment Consultant & Career Coach Experienced in providing employment and loss of earnings reports to support litigation in personal injury, clinical negligence, criminal injuries and fatal accident cases.

Contact by email: doug@douglasgovan.co.uk or mobile telephone: 07825 325579 Web: www.douglasgovan.co.uk 19 Dundee St, CarnoustieAngus, DD77PB

Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

NEED AN EXPERT SEE OUR WEBSITE WWW.EXPERTWITNESS .CO.UK

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 38

Energy Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Energy Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) D N V - Managing Risk - (London) Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire)

Fuel Quality Stinton Calvert Dr. - Consulting Engineer - (Area of work Nationwide)

Gas Pipework & Equipment D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Oil

Rhinology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Tinnitus Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Environment D N V - Managing Risk - (London) Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Conservation Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Compensation Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Stinton Calvert Dr. - Consulting Engineer - (Area of work Nationwide)

Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire)

Engineering Services Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Health & Safety Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

ENT Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Balance Disorders Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Clinical Negligence Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Deafness Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Laryngology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Otolaryngology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Otology

Environmental Statements Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh) Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Environmental Impact Assessment Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh) Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Noise Nuisance Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Public Enquiries Archaeology Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Face Injuries Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire)

Family/Child Issues Anderson Ian Dr - Registered Psychologist, Psychologist Practitioner, Clinical Psychologist, Counselling Psychologist, Occupational Psychologist, Forensic Psychologist (grandparenting application pending), Neuro-Psychologist Chartered Psychologist, Chartered Scientist.

- (Nationwide) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Child Abuse Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Child Sexual Abuse Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

38

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 39

Child Custody / Access The Educational Psychology Practice - Chartered Psychologists and Education Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Financial Services Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Feet Chalmers Roderick T A Mr. - Consultant Vascular Surgeon - (Nationwide)

Ischaemic Feet Chalmers Roderick T A Mr. - Consultant Vascular Surgeon - (Nationwide)

Fibres Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist

Finance Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Broker/Client Disputes Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Forensic Goodyer Grahame Mr - Investment Consultant and Performance Analyst - (Hampshire (& Nationwide))

Fraud Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide)

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide)

Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Corporate Finance Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Financial Investment Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Investment Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Goodyer Grahame Mr - Investment Consultant and Performance Analyst - (Hampshire (& Nationwide)) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Money Laundering Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

N E E D A N E X P E RT C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 40

Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Risk Goodyer Grahame Mr - Investment Consultant and Performance Analyst - (Hampshire (& Nationwide))

Risk Management Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Goodyer Grahame Mr - Investment Consultant and Performance Analyst - (Hampshire (& Nationwide)) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Securities Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Goodyer Grahame Mr - Investment Consultant and Performance Analyst - (Hampshire (& Nationwide)) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Fire Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Fire Investigation Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Fire Protection Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Protection Systems Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fire Risk Assessment D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Fire Safety Management Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Safety Enforcement Management Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Safety Building Regulations Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Guidance Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Regulations Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Reports Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fire Damage Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fire Doors Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire)

Analysis Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Audits Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Extinguishing Systems Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fire Consultancy Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fire Investigation Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fire Risk Assessments Fire Risk Design - Fire Safety Management Consultancy - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Firearms & Ammunition Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

40

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 41

Ammunition Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Analysis Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Shooting Reconstructions Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Weapons Testing Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Fatal Shootings Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Firearm Legislation Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Firearms Examination Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Firearms Identification/Testing Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Firearms Residues Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Investigation Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

GSR Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Identification Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Injury from Military Weapons Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Scene of Crime Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Shots Fired Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Fitness to Plead Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Flooding Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Food Safety Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Meat Products Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Foot Surgery Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Footpaths Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Forensic Accountancy Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland)

Forensic Biology Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Forensic Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Forensic Firearms Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Investigation Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Medicine Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Clinical Forensic Medicine Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Forensic Science Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide) GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow) Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Blood/Breath Technical Defence GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

Body Fluids GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

NEED AN EXPERT SEE OUR WEBSITE WWW.EXPERTWITNESS .CO.UK

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 42

Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Computers & Telecommunications Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Data Recovery Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Forensic Computer Examination Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Forensic Mobile Phone Examination Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

DNA Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Handwriting Analysis Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

General Medicine Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide) Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

General Practice Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner (Edinburgh)

Clinical Negligence Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

General Medical Practice Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

General Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Handwriting Examination Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Weaponry Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Fraud Detection Systems Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

Gas Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

General (Internal) Medicine Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist

Blood Pressure Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

Hypertension

Dr Norman Wallace Independent Expert General Practitioner BSc, MBChB, MRCGP Dr Wallace was a Principal in General Practice from 1980 to 2011. He has wide clinical experience and was Senior Partner in an eight doctor practice and a Trainer from 1984.

(Whinpark Medical Centre - www.whinpark.org)

He has an interest in medico-legal matters having previously been a police surgeon with Lothian and Borders police force for nine years.

He gives independent expert opinions in cases where there is alleged medical negligence and has helped the Procurator Fiscal Service investigate sudden deaths by providing independent GP reports and giving evidence at Fatal Accident Inquiries.

Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist Pye Maurice Dr. - Consultant Cardiologist - (North Yorkshire)

20 Craigs Bank, Edinburgh EH12 8HD Tel: 0131 334 8833 Mob: 07800 634 733 Email: normanwallace@btopenworld.com

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

42

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 43

Geotechnical Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Glass Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

GP Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Gynaecological Surgery Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Gynaecology Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Dr Sikhar Sircar Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology MBBS, MD, DFFP, MRCOG Dr Sikhar Sircar is a Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology, at NHS Lanarkshire, Scotland. Working as an NHS consultant in a busy Maternity and Gynaecology division.

He has over 15 year’s clinical experience in Obstetrics and Gynaecology. With experience in risk management, clinical governance and Critical Incident Reporting. Experience/faculty in teaching and training for Foetal Monitoring in Labour, Birth Trauma, Obstetric Sphincter Injury, Minimal Access Surgery, Colposcopy and Gynaecological cancer.

He has been involved in post graduate and under graduate teaching and training for Medical, Nursing and Midwifery staff. Dr Sircar continues his professional development in form of Audits, published papers including works on Gynaecological cancer, Colposcopy, Laparoscopy, and Audits in Obstetrics and Gynaecology, and attending relevant CPD accredited meetings.

He also chairs the Obstetric Risk Management Group for the Trust.

Contact: Tel: 01698 366 215 Mob: 07984 647 345 Email: s.ssircar@gmail.com Wishaw General Hospital 50 Netherton Street, Scotland ML2 0DP Area of work Scotland and Nationwide

Acute Gynaecology Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Birth Trauma Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Caesarean Section Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Cancer Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Colposcopy Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Ectopic Pregnancy Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Endometriosis Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Foetal Monitoring in Labour Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Gynaecological Cancer Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Gynaecological Surgery Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Laparoscopy Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Minimal Access Surgery Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Obstetric Sphincter Injury Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Rape/Sexual Abuse (Gynaecological Aspects) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Haematology Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Hand Oliver Chris - Hand and Upper limb Expert - (Area of work Scotland) Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Hand Injuries Oliver Chris - Hand and Upper limb Expert - (Area of work Scotland)

N E E D A N E X P E RT C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 44

Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Hand Surgery Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Wrist Arthroscopy Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Hand/Arm Vibration Syndrome Chalmers Roderick T A Mr. - Consultant Vascular Surgeon - (Nationwide) Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Handwriting Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Anonymous Letters Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Forensic Handwriting Examination Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Signature Comparisons Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Signature Authentication Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Signature Identification Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Head Injuries Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Health & Safety Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Cooper David Eur Ing - Lift & Escalator Specialist - (London) D N V - Managing Risk - (London) Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire)

Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Handwriting Analysis Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Handwriting Analysis and Signatures Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Handwriting Identification Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide) Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Signature Authentication Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International) Thorndycraft Pope Kathryn Mrs - Questioned Document Examiner (Area of work Nationwide)

Forgery Detection Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Wills Authentication Gillies Evelyn Dr - Forensic Document and Handwriting Examiner - (Aberdeenshire and Nationwide)

Accident Investigation Cooper David Eur Ing - Lift & Escalator Specialist - (London) Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Accidents at Work Cooper David Eur Ing - Lift & Escalator Specialist - (London) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Assessments Cooper David Eur Ing - Lift & Escalator Specialist - (London) Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire)

COSHH Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Health & Safety Audits Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire) Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Industrial Health & Safety Rushbrook Consultants Ltd - Chartered Engineers - (Lanarkshire) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

44

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 45

Health Care Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner (Edinburgh)

Assessment Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Care Pathways MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Care Services Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Community Care Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Health Care Quality Control Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Health Policy/Administration Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Health Services Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Medical Accidents Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner (Edinburgh)

Prescribing/Dispensing Errors Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner (Edinburgh)

Medical Disputes Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner (Edinburgh)

Medical Records Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner (Edinburgh)

Regulatory / Legal Compliance Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Social Services Martin Mike Mr - Health and Social Care Consultant, Lecturer, Practitioner, Researcher and Trainer - (Perthshire)

Health Care, Medical, Therapy Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Medico-legal Services Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide) Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Heart Attack Murphy Conrad Dr - Cardiologist and General Physician - (Area of work Chichester and surrounding areas)

Heating Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Heating & Ventilation Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Hepatobiliary Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Bile Duct Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Gallbladder Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Laparoscopy Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Liver Diseases Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Oncology Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Pancreas Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Surgical Techniques Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Heritage Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Heritage Asset Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

REQUEST A FREE DIRECTORY EMAIL INFO@EXPERTWITNESS .CO.UK

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 46

Highway Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Highways Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

Histopathology Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Historic Buildings Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Cultural Tourism Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Heritage Tourism Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Homicide Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist

Horses Marsden Debbie Dr - Equestrian & Equine Behaviour Consultant - (Area of work Nationwide & International)

Housing Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Hypertension Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist

Hypnotherapy Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Psychotherapy Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Image Comparison Fusion Corporation Research & Development - Specialist Analysis, Enhancement and Identification of Audio-, Video-, Telephone- and Computer-based Evidence & Data - (Area of work Nationwide)

Incineration Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Industrial Accidents Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Industrial Accidents Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Infection Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Infections/Immunology MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

C Diff MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Infection Prevention MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

MRSA MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Viral Infections MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Information Systems Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Computer Crime Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Internet Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Systems Management Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Information Technology Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

46

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 47

Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Informatics

Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work ] Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England)

Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England)

Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Systems Development Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England) Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England)

Insulating Concrete Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Insulation Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Insurance Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Claims Investigation Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Personal Insurance Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Insurance Claims Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Insurance Dispute/Litigation

Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Investment Banking Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Kidneys Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist

Laboratory Services Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London) Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London)

Ladders Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Land Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Land Management Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Land Planning Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Strzelczyk Kate - Forensic & Questioned Document Examiner - (Area of work Nationwide and International)

Intellectual Property Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Passing off Rothman James Mr. - Independent Marketing and Research Consultant - (London)

International Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Internet MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Land Use Planning Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Land Values Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Landscape Architects (Chartered) Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Landscape Design Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Landscapes Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Rural Surveying Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Investment Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Soil Contamination Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

N E E D A N E X P E R T FA S T C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 48

Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Laparoscopic Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Law/Police Issues Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Dyson David W. - Firearms Consultant/Barrister - (Nationwide)

Expert Witness Provision Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland) Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Health & Safety Legislation Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Industrial Health & Safety Legislation Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Noise Legislation Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

Rights of Way Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Legionella Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Lifts and Lifting Equipment Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Lighting Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Listed Buildings Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK) Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Liver Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Loss of Earnings Davies Peter Mr - Employment & Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant (Scotland)

Lower Limb Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Surgery Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Machinery Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Manual Handling Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Cooper David Eur Ing - Lift & Escalator Specialist - (London)

Marine Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide) Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Marine Surveying D N V - Managing Risk - (London) Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Boats Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Insurance Claims Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Market Research Rothman James Mr. - Independent Marketing and Research Consultant - (London)

Materials Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Maxillofacial Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire)

Mechanical Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Mechanical Handling Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Mechanical Power Transmissions Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

48

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 49

Medical Negligence

Mediation Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Mediation Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide))

Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide) Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

Medico-Legal Reports Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee) Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow) Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow) Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire)

Medical Error Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Assessment Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Investigations Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide) Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Medical Negligence Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Dymond Duncan Dr - Consultant Cardiologist - (Area of work Greater London and Nationwide)

Medical Oncology Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Medico Legal Services Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Scott David H T Dr - Consultant Anaesthetist - (Nationwide) Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

Case Conference and Court Attendance Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide) Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Syndercombe Court Denise Dr. - Senior Lecturer in Forensic Haematology - (London) Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire)) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

Menopause Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Metallurgy Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Metals Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

N E E D A N E X P E R T FA S T C A L L 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 50

Microbiology MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Antimicrobial MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Clinical Infection MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Infection Prevention MacDonald Alan Dr - Infection Prevention Doctor/ Medical Microbiologist NHS Ayrshire & Arran - (Kilmarnock)

Midwifery Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Minimal Access Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Mining Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Money Laundering Adamson CA David W Mr - Forensic Accountant - (Scotland) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Motor Vehicles Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Naval Architecture Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Neck Injuries Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Neck Pain Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Whiplash Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Negligence Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Clinical Mr Anthony Palmer - Independent Nursing Consultant and expert witness with over 15 years experience. - (Nationwide)

Medical Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow) Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide) Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire)) Wallace Norman Dr - Independent Expert General Practitioner - (Edinburgh)

Neonatal Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland)

Brain Injuries Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland) Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Brain Injury Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Consequences Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland) Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Difficulties Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland)

Infections Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Intensive Care Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland) Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neonatal Paediatrician Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

50

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 51

Neonatal Reporting

William F Durward

Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Consultant General Neurologist MB ChB FRCP (Edin) FRCP (Glasg)

Preterm births Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland) Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Special Care Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Training Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neonatology Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neonatal Care Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland) Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neonatal Medicine Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Postnatal Care Becher Julie-Clare Dr - Consultant Neonatologist and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Neonatology - (Area of work Nationwide, Scotland & Ireland) Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Nervous System Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Neurology Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Acquired Brain Injury Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Nerve Injuries Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Nervous Diseases

Consultant General Neurologist ( appointed in 1977, retired in 2009), now practising exclusively as a Medico-legal expert in all aspects of physical disease affecting the nervous system.

I declare a particular interest in late and permanent complications of head injury which are often under-appreciated.

I have extensive Medico-legal experience and currently prepare between 125-150 Medical Reports annually, mainly for Claimants (70/30) and I am now a qualified mediator.

My Medico-legal practice is at The Nuffield Health Glasgow Hospital, but I am prepared (for a previously agreed ad hoc fee plus expenses) to travel any distance within the United Kingdom or overseas to visit individuals who are unable to attend my consulting rooms wherever domiciled, for example at home or in hospital or in prison.

Email: w.durward@ntlworld.com Tel: 0141 942 3143 Fax: 0141 339 1352 Mob: 07774 779 518 Overdale, 20 South Erskine Park Bearsden, Glasgow G61 4NA

Peripheral Nerve Injuries Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Neuropsychology Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Clinical Neuropsychology Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Malingering Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Neuropsychological Functioning Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Post-traumatic Stress Disorder Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Trauma Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main bases in Glasgow & London)

Neuroradiology

Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Nervous System Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Neurodisability Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow)

Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Noise Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

N E E D A N E X P E RT C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 52

Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Appeals Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Measurement

Offshore Investments Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Oil

Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK) D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Nursing Liability Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Obstetrics Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Birth Trauma Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Caesarean Section McLeod Fraser Neil Mr. - Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist (Bristol)

Childbirth Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Clinical Negligence

McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Accident Investigation D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Competence Assurance McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Drilling Operations McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Equipment Performance McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Practices & Procedures McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Well Engineering McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Design McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

Risk Management McAteer Peter Mr - Director - (Aberdeen)

McLeod Fraser Neil Mr. - Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist (Bristol) Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Foetal Screening Dalton Kevin J Prof - Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist - (Cambridge)

Miscarriage Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Obstetric Surgery Dalton Kevin J Prof - Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist - (Cambridge) McLeod Fraser Neil Mr. - Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist (Bristol) Sircar Sikhar Dr - Consultant in Obstetrics and Gynaecology - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Offshore Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Mr Richard W Nutton MB BS MD FRCS (Edin)

Consultant Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgeon Honorary Senior Lecturer in Orthopaedics and Trauma University of Edinburgh Preparation of expert reports in Adult Orthopaedics and Trauma with a special interest in Knee and Shoulder Injuries, Joint Replacement Surgery and Medical Negligence claims.

Membership of Professional Societies: British Orthopaedic Association (BOA) British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK) British Elbow and Shoulder Society (BESS) Consulting Rooms: Spire Murrayfield Hospital 122 Corstorphine Road Edinburgh EH12 6UD (Address for postal correspondence)

The Edinburgh Clinic 40 Colinton Road Edinburgh EH10 5BT

Personal Assistant: Mrs CB Kennedy (cbkennedy2@gmail.com) (Mobile) 07738260764 Email: info@richardnutton.com Website: richardnutton.com The Law Society of Scotland ‘Directory of Expert Witnesses 2016’ UK Register of Expert Witnesses (Registered)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

52

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 53

Oncology Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire) Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Medicolegal Orthopaedic Reports

Prof Chris Oliver MD, BSc, FRCS(Eng, Ed, Tr & Orth), FRCP(Ed), DMI RCSEd, FFSTEd

Orthopaedics Court-Brown Charles M, Prof - Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma (Edinburgh) Oliver Chris - Hand and Upper limb Expert - (Area of work Scotland) Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Accidents Court-Brown Charles M, Prof - Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma -

Special interest: hand and upper limb injuries 70% pursuer, 25% defence and 5% negligence.

Over 20 years report writing experience Consultant Trauma Orthopaedic Hand Surgeon Edinburgh Orthopaedic Trauma Unit, Royal Infirmary Edinburgh

(Edinburgh) Oliver Chris - Hand and Upper limb Expert - (Area of work Scotland) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Orthopaedic Trauma Court-Brown Charles M, Prof - Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma (Edinburgh) Oliver Chris - Hand and Upper limb Expert - (Area of work Scotland) Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Shoulder Injury Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Shoulder Surgery Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Upper Limb Oliver Chris - Hand and Upper limb Expert - (Area of work Scotland) Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Hon Professor Physical Activity for Health University of Edinburgh Contact: Edinburgh Hand Surgery Clinic, Spire Shawfair Park Hospital 10 Easter Shawfair, Edinburgh EH22 1FE en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Oliver_(surgeon) Email: jenni.ehsc@googlemail.com

Neonatology Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Birth Asphyxia Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Birth Injury Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Care of Preterm Infant Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Encephalopathy Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Otolaryngology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Otology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Otorhinolaryngology Crowther John A Mr - Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon (Glasgow)

Infant Feeding Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Infection Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Intensive Care Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Jaundice Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Lung Disease Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Paediatrics Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Neonatal Problems Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neonatal Transport Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Newborn Examination Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

N E E D A N E X P E RT C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 54

Paediatric Neuroradiology Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Resuscitation Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Ventilation Stenson Benjamin Professor - Consultant Neonatologist - (Edinburgh)

Pain Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee)

Chronic Pain Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee)

Pain after Injury Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee)

Pain Management Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee)

Pain Management Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee)

Chronic Pain Bannister Jonathan Dr. - Consultant in Pain Medicine and Anaesthesia (Dundee)

Paint Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist

Pancreas Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Pancreatic Surgery Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Pathology Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Histopathology Kirkham Nigel Dr - Consultant Pathologist - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Paving Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Pelvic Twigg Jeremy Mr - Consultant Gynaecologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Perinatal Neurology Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neurology The Glasgow Expert Witness Service Limited

Dr. Stephanie Sharp Dr. Paul Skett Forensic Pharmacologists Specialising in the effects and clearance of alcohol and drugs.

Drink and drug driving, toxicity and effects of prescription drugs and drugs of abuse in criminal and civil cases.

Dr. Sharp: E mail: steph@gews.org.uk Tel: 07734 865 349 Dr. Skett: E mail: paul@gews.org.uk Tel: 07989 474 807

Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Neuroprotection Boardman James Dr - Consultant Neonatologist - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Personal Injury Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide) Punter Southall Limited - Actuaries - (Nationwide) Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Court Evidence Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Dental Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

54

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 55

Professional Negligence Mr Anthony Palmer - Independent Nursing Consultant and expert witness with over 15 years experience. - (Nationwide)

Personal Injury Claims Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Personality Disorders

Power Stations Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Pressure Vessels Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Process Engineering

Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Pharmacology GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

Drugs and Behaviour GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

Substance Abuse GEWS - Pharmacologist - (Glasgow)

Pipelines Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Planning Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Plant Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Plastic Surgery Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Plumbing Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Post-injury Mental State Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Post-traumatic Stress Disorder Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Post-trauma Assessment Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Psychological Trauma Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Power Generation Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Prosthodontics Fell Joseph Dr - Dental Surgeon - (Glasgow)

Psychiatrist Bell Paul, Dr - Consultant General Adult Community Psychiatrist (Belfast) Hill Simon Dr - Forensic psychiatrist - (Area of work Nationwide) Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Psychiatry Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Adjustment Disorders Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide)

Adult Attention Deficit Disorder Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol)

Adult Mental Health Bell Paul, Dr - Consultant General Adult Community Psychiatrist (Belfast) Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide) Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide) Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol)

Adult Psychiatry Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol)

Medico-legal Reporting Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London)

Neuropsychiatry Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London)

N E E D A N E X P E RT C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 56

Dementias & Alzeimers Disease Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Depression in Older Adults Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Elderly Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Fitness to Plead Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide)

Mental Capacity Act Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Mental Health Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London)

Mental Illness Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London)

Mentally Disordered Offenders Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London) Rajpal P Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist - (Area of work London and Bristol)

Occupational Stress Bell Paul, Dr - Consultant General Adult Community Psychiatrist (Belfast) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide)

Old Age Psychiatry Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Panic Disorders Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide)

Psychiatric Assessments Bell Paul, Dr - Consultant General Adult Community Psychiatrist (Belfast) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide) Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London)

Road Traffic Accidents Bell Paul, Dr - Consultant General Adult Community Psychiatrist (Belfast) Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Substance Misuse Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Trauma Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Trauma Sequelae Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide) Insight Psychiatric Services - Consultant Psychiatrists - (Area of work Nationwide) Isaac Michael T Dr. - Consultant Psychiatrist & Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine - (London)

Psychology Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Quantity Surveying Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex) Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Contractual Claims Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide)) Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide) Skerratt Thomas Andrew Mr - Accommodation Needs Specialist (West Sussex)

Professional Indemnity Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Professional Negligence Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Quantum Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Quantum Griffiths David Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Calculation of Leach Consultancy Ltd - Quantity Surveyors - (Wiltshire (& Nationwide))

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

56

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 57

Radiology

Emergency Vehicles Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Watt Andrew Dr - Consultant Paediatric Radiologist - (Area of work Nationwide)

Reconstructive Surgery Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Regulations Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Renal Medicine Cohen Simon L Dr - Consultant Physician & Nephrologist

Respiratory O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide)

Respiratory System O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide)

Restorative Dentistry Jauhar Sachin Dr - Consultant and Honorary Senior Clinical Lecturer in Restorative Dentistry - (Area of work Nationwide)

Road Traffic Accidents Aldbar - Road Traffic Experts - (Scotland) Boulton Douglas, - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide) Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Dalton Kevin J Prof - Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist - (Cambridge) Durward William F Dr - Consultant General Neurologist - (Glasgow) Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife) Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire)) Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Insecure Loads & RTAs Aldbar - Road Traffic Experts - (Scotland) Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide) Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

Low Speed Collision Aldbar - Road Traffic Experts - (Scotland) Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Pre-existing complaints Aldbar - Road Traffic Experts - (Scotland) Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Police Speed Traps/Radar Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Fatal Accident Claims Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Personal Injuries Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Road Traffic Offences Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Skid Mark Analysis/Investigation Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Speed Assessment/Analysis Aldbar - Road Traffic Experts - (Scotland) Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Tyres/Wheels Effects Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Vehicle Braking Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Vehicle Roll-over/Jack-knifing Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Accident Scene Reporting Photographs Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Plans

Vehicle Stability/Handling Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Roads & Highways

Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide) Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built

Reports

Environment - (Warwickshire)

Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Videos Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Death by Dangerous Driving Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Driving Accidents Boulton Douglas - Independent Accident Investigator - (Nationwide)

Roads and Highways Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Safety Wood David G Mr. - Health & Safety Consultant - (Dumfries and Galloway)

N E E D A N E X P E RT V I S I T O U R W E B S I T E W W W. E X P E RT W I T N E S S . CO. U K

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 58

D N V - Managing Risk - (London) Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Scars Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Scenes of Crime Investigations Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide) Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Firearms Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Gunshot Residue Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Schedule Delays Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Soft Tissue Injury Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire)

Spinal Injury Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Court-Brown Charles M, Prof - Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma (Edinburgh)

Sports Injuries Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Staircases Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Stocks & Shares Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Scientific Examinations

Stroke

Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist Willey Roger James Prof - Health and Safety / Environmental and Waste Management - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Scott Schedules Smart Paul Mr - Specialist in Dispute Resolution - (Area of work Worldwide)

Negligence Milligan Janey Louise Mrs - Chartered Quantity Surveyor and Construction Adjudicator - (Area of work Nationwide and Worldwide)

Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Structural Engineering Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide) D N V - Managing Risk - (London)

Surveying Allied Scotland - Charterd Surveyors - (Area of work Worldwide)

Sleep O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide)

Disorders O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide)

Narcolepsy O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide)

Sleep Apnoea O'Reilly John Dr. - Consultant in Respiratory and Sleep Medicine - (Area of work Nationwide)

Slipping, Tripping, Falling Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Ross Lidell - Property Experts - (Scotland)

Substance Misuse Morrison Fraser Dr - Clinical Neuropsychologist - (UK Availabillity with main base in Glasgow)

Taxation Expert Evidence Limited - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness and Dispute Resolution Experts - (Area of work Worldwide) Pitman Jonathan Mr - International Trade Expert - (Area of work Worldwide) Schon Robert Mr - Taxation Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Telecommunications MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

58

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 59

Mobile Phone Forensics MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Text Message Retrieval Geode Forensics Ltd - Digital Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, N. Ireland & N.England) Butler John Mr - Computer Forensic Specialist - (Scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England) MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Usage Mapping MD5 Ltd - Computer & Mobile Phone Forensics - (Nationwide)

Testing Sandberg Consulting Engineers - Consulting Materials & Testing Engineer - (London)

Tool/Instrument Marks Forensic Firearms Consultancy - Firearms and Gunshot Residue Experts - (Area of work Nationwide)

Town & Country Planning Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife) Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire) Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Agriculture Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife) Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Conservation

Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Planning Applications Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Planning Supervision Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Town Centre Regeneration Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Transportation Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

Trace/Contact Evidence Coyle Tiernan Mr - Forensic Fibre Specialist

Trade Finance Brigden Nigel Mr - Banking and Wealth Management Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Traffic Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire)

Impact Development Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Trauma Court-Brown Charles M, Prof - Professor of Orthopaedic Trauma (Edinburgh) Duxbury Mark Mr - Consultant Hepatopancreaticobiliary & General Surgeon - (Area of work Glasgow and Nationwide)

Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Livingston Hilary Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist with specific interest in Elderly Psychiatry - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Compensation Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Land Use Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh)

Noise & Vibration Saunders Alan Mr - Acoustic Consultant - (UK)

Planning Advice Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh) Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide) Williamson Kenneth - Architect - (Scotland/UK)

Planning Appeals Head Mann Associates Ltd - Engineering Consultants for the Built Environment - (Warwickshire) Ironside Fararr Ltd - Environmental Consultants - (Edinburgh) Munby Julian Mr. - Archaeology, Historic Buildings & Cultural Heritage Consultant - (Worldwide)

Parkhouse Nicholas - Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon (Area of work Nationwide)

Assault Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Children Morrison Katharine Dr - Forensic/General Medical Practitioner - (Area of work Nationwide)

Facial Trauma Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire)

Musculo-skeletal Trauma Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire)

N E E D A N E X P E R T FA S T C A L L O U R F R E E S E A R C H L I N E 0 1 6 1 8 3 4 0 0 1 7

Scott suppl 2016:Layout 1 7/5/16 1:02 PM Page 60

Orthopaedic Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Sequelae Tennex Services Limited Alan Scott Wylie Dr - Consultant Psychiatrist (Area of work Nationwide)

Shoulder Trauma Thomas Simon J Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic & Upper Limb Surgeon (Area of work Scotland)

Trauma Surgery Hislop William Stuart Mr - Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial / Head and Neck Surgeon - (Ayrshire) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Mr Roderick T A Chalmers Consultant Vascular Surgeon MB, ChB, FRCSEd, MD, FRCS (Gen) Mr Chalmers is a teaching hospital consultant vascular surgeon with a wide range of expertise in arterial and venous surgery, including; thoraco-abdominal aortic aneurysm, abdominal aortic aneurysm, carotid artery surgery, all aspects of lower limb ischaemia, varicose vein disease, lower limb ulceration and thorascopic sympathectomy.

Mr Chalmers has some experience in the management of vascular trauma.

Urgent Care Cronin Gerard Mr - Nursing Care Expert - (Area of work Essex and Nationwide)

Vascular Surgery Chalmers Roderick T A Mr. - Consultant Vascular Surgeon - (Nationwide) Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Contact: Muriel Alexander phone number Tel: 0131 242 3587 (Secretary) 0131 242 1056 Fax: 0131 242 1055 Mobile: 07768 277 835 Email: rod.chalmers@luht.scot.nhs.uk Address: Vascular Surgical Service Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh Old Dalkeith Road. EH16 4SU

Causalgia Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Vascular Neurosurgery Scurr John H Mr - Consultant General and Vascular Surgeon - Senior Lecturer - (Area of work Scotland and Nationwide)

Ventilation Cadogans - Forensic Engineers and Scientists - (Area of work Worldwide)

Vessels Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Boats Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Yachts Murray Cormack Associates - Naval Architects & Marine Surveyors (Area of work Nationwide)

Veterinary Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Video Audio Video Forensics Ltd - Forensic Audio, Video and Still image specialism - (Area of work Worldwide)

Wealth Management Cumberland Collin Mr - Banking and Financial Expert - (Area of work Worldwide)

Iles Mervyn - Private Banking, Investment and Wealth Management Expert Witness - (Area of work Worldwide)

Whiplash Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland) Crawford Rudy MR - Consultant in Accident & Emergency Medicine & Surgery - (Lanarkshire) Peyton OBE TD James William Rodney Mr - Consultant in Trauma and General Surgery - (Area of work Worldwide)

Back Injury Tait Gavin R. Mr - Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - (Glasgow (Lanarkshire & Ayrshire))

Injury Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Low Velocity Impact Burgin Mark Innes Dr - General Practitioner - (Area of work: Yorkshire, Midlands, N West and Scotland)

Wildlife Fletcher T John Dr. - Veterinary Surgeon, Deer Specialist & Deer Farmer - (Fife)

Conservation Garratt A H (Hugh) Mr - Rural Practice Chartered Surveyor - (UK)

Need an Expert fast?

Call our free searchline on 0161 834 0017 www.expertwitness.co.uk

E X P E R T W I T N E S S S C OT T I S H S U P P L E M E N T S U M M E R 2 0 1 6

60

covers:Layout 1 7/5/16 12:07 PM Page 3

covers:Layout 1 7/5/16 12:07 PM Page 4

Expert actuarial judgement Punter Southall provides expert witness services across a range of professional areas, specialising in matters relating to pensions and investments.

Pensions litigation is becoming increasingly complex and the quantification of loss requires the skills of an expert actuary.

Our specialists have worked on litigation cases with leading law firms. Our experience encompasses a broad spectrum of cases on a range of actuarial and investment matters relating to pensions.

We also regularly deal with loss of pension rights on divorce and accidental or industrial injuries.

Above all, our advice is founded on the experience and professional judgement of our senior people who serve as expert witnesses, led by Jonathan Punter, CEO of the Punter Southall Group.

Get in touch If you would like to discuss our services in person or obtain any further details, please contact one of the expert witness team by email or telephone.

Andy Scott FFA

Matthew Claisse FIA

0131 230 0331

020 3327 5296

andy.scott@puntersouthall.com

matthew.claisse@puntersouthall.com

Punter Southall has offices across the UK. For further information, visit our website at www.puntersouthall.com Accreditations, Awards, Affiliations and Sponsorships

© Punter Southall 2016. Punter Southall is a trading name of Punter Southall Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 3842603. Registered office: 11 Strand, London WC2N 5HR. A Punter Southall Group company

1606016_1