Edición del 21 de Febrero 2010

Page 1

J[dZ[dY_Wi

Feb‡j_YW

Fh[]edW [b LWj_YWde Wkc[dje Z[ '- [d ik \[b_]h[i‡W [d ( W‹ei f|]_dW '/

>_bZW 9[XWbbei Yh_j_YW ikX[`[hY_Y_e Z[ bW <[Z[hWY_ÂŒd f$ ''

9^_lWi _cfed[ cWhYW Yed i_[j[ l_Yjeh_Wi [d Ă… bW1 l[dY[ )#( Wb Fk[XbW

D@C<E@F

8zF +# EèD<IF (+)- +$&& *) G�>@E8J

:FC@D8 ;FD@E>F )( ;< =<9I<IF ;< )'('

mmm$c_b[d_eYeb_cW$Yec f[h_eZ_iceYedYWh|Yj[h

;b Z_h[Yjeh Z[ bW Feb_Y‡W ;ijWjWb Fh[l[dj_lW Wi[]khW gk[ [d 9eb_cW ^Wo ]hkfei `kl[d_b[i l_eb[djei

FWdZ_bbWi kiWd WhcWi [nYbki_lWi Z[b [`ƒhY_je š Kd f_ijebW Z[ /cc \k[ kj_b_pWZW [d bW XWbWY[hW ZedZ[ ckh_Œ kd ^ecXh[ Z[ (' W‹ei š >ƒYjeh 8Wkj_ijW L|pgk[p Wi[]khW gk[ [b Z[i[cfb[e fheleYW kd Wkc[dje [d bei _b‡Y_jei š H[bWY_edWd W _dj[]hWdj[i Z[ XWdZWi Z[ XWhh_e Yed WYj_l_ZWZ[i Z[ dWhYec[dkZ[e f|]$ . I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

9eb[YjW IYekj$ ;d

kd WYje Wbjhk_ijW o [YebÂŒ]_Ye" bW Fhel_dY_W IYekj 9eb_cW h[Wb_pÂŒ" Yece YWZW W‹e" kdW Yeb[YjW Z[ bWjWi Z[ Wbkc_d_e Yed [b eX`[j_le Z[ X[d[Ă… Y_Wh kdW YWkiW deXb[$ ;d [ijW eYWi_ÂŒd i[ h[kd_[hed (("/*& bWjWi [d [b FWhgk[ >_ZWb]e Z[ bW Y_kZWZ Z[ 9eb_cW$ 7‘d de i[ Z[Ă… d[ i_ [b X[d[Ă… Y_Wh_e Z[ bW Yeb[YjW i[h| kdW YWiW ^e]Wh" [b fk[Xbe Z[ 7d]Wd]k[e e >W_j‡

:_h[Yj_lW Z[ bW 9;:>

C_deh‡Wi i[ gk[`Wd feYe Wdj[ :[h[Y^ei >kcWdei I[]‘d =kj_ƒhh[p 8Whh_ei bei _dZ‡][dWi de iWX[d gk[ bW Z_iYh_c_dWY_Œd oW [i kd Z[b_je f[dWZe ?dl[ij_]WZeh Z[ bW KZ[9 Wi[]khW gk[ de ^Wo hWpŒd fWhW _cf[Z_h WZefY_Œd W ]Woi ff$ ,#-

9W[d -& feh Y_[dje bWi [`[YkY_ed[i [d Zei c[i[i I[ Yk[b]W [b ;`ƒhY_je C[n_YWde kdW c[ZWbbW [d J_`kWdW" 8W`W 9Wb_\ehd_W

>eo [iYh_X[d Ifd}e I\ml\ckXj# =\[\i`Zf 9\iil\kf# E„jkfi Fa\[X F|]i$(%) 8m\c`ef >�d\q >lqd}e# <ei`hl\ :XdXZ_f F|]$'( Cl`j G\k\ij\e =XiX_# Df`j„j IfqXe\j KXjjc\i F|]$')

f|]_dWi ', o '-

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

:;<;DIEH :;B B;9JEH

$BOUPT EF TJSFOBT

>\eXif Q\ek\ef 9 ihl\q

BM GSFOUF

;iYh XWb[ Wb Z[\[dieh Z[b b[Yjeh0 Z[\[dieh6c_b[d_eYeb_cW$Yec$cn feh \Wn )',)(-& feh Yehh[e ehZ_dWh_e0 7bZWcW ++(" 9eb_cW" (.&&&

I[]k_cei [cf[ WZei [d YW[h Wdj[ bei cWhWl_bbeiei YWdjei Z[ bWi i_h[dWi" i_d [dj[dZ[h gk[ de i[ jhWjW Z[ Yh[[h [d bWi Z[b_Y_Wi Z[ bei ik[ ei" i_de Z[ [i\ehpWhdei o jhWXW`Wh ZkhWdj[ c[i[i o W ei fWhW Yh[Wh bWi YedZ_Y_ed[i fWhW gk[ i[ YkcfbWd @]n afailhk jk ao h] lnej_el]h i]jan] `a ejbhqen aj hko `ai o7 ao h] je_] =h^anp Aejopaej

$

kjpn] ie lanajja _ko) pqi^na `a ejoeopen aj `a`e_]nha i o pejp] u aol]_ek ] hko pai]o bqj) `]iajp]hao mqa hk iana) _aj( ah l]o]`k ie n_khao -3 `a ba^nank `a .,-, ia hh]i h] ]paj_e j h] i]jan] aj mqa ao lkoe^ha afailhebe_]n( aj qj]o _q j) p]o h ja]o( qj] `a h]o bkni]o `a ]^qok `a ]qpkne`]` mqa p]jpk l]`a_aiko( lknmqa ]o hk laniepeiko* Aj ah ]l]np]`k Î`ko lkn pnaoÏ( lq^he) _]`k aj h] oa__e j Î]h bnajpaÏ( ha iko6 ÎAj h] ej]qcqn]_e j `ah lnkcn]i] A_k) ^e_e( I]n_ahk A^n]n` oa l]o _q]pnk oai bknko aj nkfk _kj oq ^e_e_hap]* Oe hk dq^ean] da_dk qj _eq`]`]jk _ki j( h] iqhp] ] l]c]nÅ oan ] `a6 -(-05 laoko( oac j ah nach]iajpkÏ* Ao qj] i]jan] iqu _h]n] `a `aiko) pn]n( qj] rav i o( mqa oe ^eaj pk`ko okiko ecq]hao ]jpa h] hau( d]u ]hcqjko Îi o ecq]haoÏ mqa kpnko7 oa lqa`a l]o]n lkn ah Î]n_k `ah pneqjbkÏ _q]hmqean jkni]( i teia oe oa peaja( _kik lnapatpk( qj] h]^kn aj_kie]^ha u+k ]hpnqeop]( aj aopa _]ok( a_kh ce_]* Oe ^eaj h] _kjpn]`e__e j ao are`ajpa( p]i^e j laniepa l]hl]n mq p]j ]nn]e) c]`] peajaj h] _kopqi^na jqaopnko bqj_ekj]neko `a ailnaj`an ]__ekjao pailkn]hao l]n] ]l]najp]n mqa oqo ejpaj_ekjao okj h]o iafknao( _q]j`k aj na]he`]` b]hh]j aj hk aoaj_e]h6 _qilhen ] _]^]he`]` _kj h]o hauao( p]jpk l]n] lkjan ah afailhk _kik ]qpkne`]`ao mqa okj( _kik l]n] lk`an atecen ]h naopk `a _eq`]`]jko mqa h]o k^oan) raiko* =jpao `a mqa `ec]j mqa ao qj] _n pe_] ] qj ck^anj]jpa `a qj l]npe`k `apan) iej]`k( ]`reanpk mqa afailhko _kik opko ]^qj`]j aj pk`] h] cak) cn]b ] j]_ekj]h7 ej`a) laj`eajpaiajpa `a hko _khknao mqa hhar]nkj ] hko ejbn]_pknao ]h lk`an( `eobnqp]j `a hko lnerehaceko mqa `e_aj iana_an lkn ck^anj]njko* Qj

` ] o u kpnk p]i^e j( jqaopnko ]cajpao lkhe_ ]_ko $`a pk`]o h]o _knlkn]_ek) jao( ej_hquaj`k h]o ba`an]hao% Ìmqa ]`ai o ja_aoep]j qncajpaiajpa _h]oao `a i]jafkÌ ejbnejcaj ah nach]iajpk `a pn joepk _q]hmqean _]jpe`]` `a ra_ao( ej_hqok oej pajan ah lnapatpk `a Î]paj) `an qj] aiancaj_e]Ï* Aok l]o] p]i^e j ajpna `eranoko lnkbaoekjeop]o( mqa `a^ean]j _kj_a) ^enoa ] o ieoiko _kik ah afailhk ]jpa _eajpko `a ]iecko u _khac]o7 p]ilk_k _qilhaj _kik `a^ean]j _kj ah naolapk iana_e`k ] hko hqc]nao l]n] h] cajpa _kj _]l]_e`]`ao `ebanajpao( je ] hko hqc]nao lnkde^e`ko l]n] aop]_ekj]noa lkn `eranoko ikperko( u] jk `ec]iko ] h]o hq_ao nkf]o `a hko oai ) bknko( lknmqa h]o ]i]nehh]o h]o raj _]oe ran`ao( _kik oe bqan]j Î]i]nehhk hei jÏ* Ah ]oqjpk ao mqa h] ]qpkne`]` oa c]j] lna_eo]iajpa ia`e]jpa ah afailhk( d]_eaj`k h]o _ko]o ^eaj aj hqc]n `a oeilhaiajpa ]l]najp]n mqa ]o oa d]_a bnajpa ] h]o _ i]n]o( _q]j`k ah naopk `ah peailk jk oecqaj jejcqjk `a hko namqaneieajpko `a oacqne`]` re]h( u] jk `ec]iko `a _ereoik k `a i jei] _knpao ]* Aop]iko p]j ]_kopqi^n]`ko ] mqa hko cn]j`ao lanok)

;ijWcei jWd WYeijkc# XhWZei W gk[ bei ]hWdZ[i f[hiedW`[i ^W]Wd o Z[i^W]Wd Z[ bWi ikoWi" gk[ bW cWo# eh W Z[ Yed# Y_kZWZWdei d_ i_gk_[hW i[ \_`Wd [d [ijei ºZ[jWbb[i»

j]fao d]c]j u `aod]c]j `a h]o oqu]o( mqa h] i]ukn ] `a _kj_eq`]`]jko je oemqean] oa bef]j aj aopko Î`ap]hhaoÏ* Hk ieoik k_qnna( aj ah kpnk atpnaik u _kik l]npa `a h] ieoi] _qhpqn] ]qpk) nep]ne] mqa jko `kiej] u `apaniej]( _kj h] ]_pepq` mqa oa ]oqia ]h Îla`enÏ ] h]o ]qpkne`]`ao mqa naoqahr]j h]o `ebe_qhp]`ao _kik oe `a `ekoao oa pn]) p]n]( _kik oe bqan]j _kj_aoekjao `a hko lk`ankoko mqa jk oa d]j okhq_ekj]`k oaj_ehh]iajpa lknmqa ]hcqeaj jk hk d] mqane`k* Reiko h] iqaopn] i o na_eajpa ah fqarao -4 `a ba^nank _q]j`k aj h] l cej]

-2 `a IEHAJEK ?KHEI= oa lq^he_ h] jkp]6 ÎFq]najoao ha le`aj `a pk`k ] ?]h`an jÏ* =lnkra_d]j`k h] lnaoaj_e] `ah lnaoe`ajpa `a h] nal ^he_] l]n] nalh]jpa]n h] aopn]pace] `a oacqne`]` aj ?eq`]` Fq nav pn]o h] i]o]_na `a r]neko f rajao h] oai]j] ]jpal]) o]`]( Î]h i]j`]p]nek oa ha le`eankj ]lkuko l]n] lnkua_pko lnk`q_perko( pnacq]o beo_]hao( lanieoko l]n] lh]j) p]o _aiajpan]o( oq ejpanraj_e j aj qj _kjbhe_pk `a peann]o aj Hki]o `a Lkhak( ]uq`] i `e_] l]n] qj fkraj mqa oqbne qj ]__e`ajpa( ^a_]o l]n] aopq`e]jpao ej` caj]o `a Ah ?d]iev]h u qj] vkj] a_kj ie_] he^na7 ]`ai o `a h]o `ai]j`]o lnkle]o `a oacqne`]` u _ki^]pa ] h] rekhaj_e]Ï* Jk o aj mq cn]`k naoqhp] i o bnqopn]jpa ah afailhk ]jpanekn( oe lkn ah _ iqhk `a ja_aoe`]`ao ejo]peoba_d]o aj h] qn^a bnkjpanev]( k lkn h] ]_pepq` mqa oecqa lnar]ha_eaj`k `a aopenk h] i]jk l]n] mqa ia `aj( aj hqc]n `a har]jp]nh] l]n] kbna_an _kjpne^qen ] h] okhq_e j `a hko lnk^hai]o `a i]jan] _kkn`ej]`] u _kil]npe`]* P]h u _kik hk oa ]h ?]nhko I]n j aj oq Î]o]hpk ] h] n]v jÏ ]l]na_e`k aj h] lknp]`] `a aoa ieoik ` ] ^]fk ah p pqhk Î?]np]o ] hko nauao `a Fq navÏ6 Î?kik aj ah naopk `ah l] o( ]bhkn]nkj h] b]hp] `a oanre_eko( ah `aolkfk `a panna) jko( ah napn]ok aj ah `ao]nnkhhk `a oa_pknao a_kj ie_ko7 h] _knnql_e j `a h]o ]`iejeopn]_ekjao l ^he_]o u hk _kilhe_]`k `a ]^nen qj jack_ek u hhac]n ] h] qjeranoe`]`* Ok^na hko f rajao ]oaoej]`ko u h]o r _pei]o mqa hao lna_a`eankj oa eilqok qj] _qhpqn] `a h] lape_e j( h] ajn]ev]`] _kopqi^na `a na_h]i]n ]h ck^eanjk h] okhq_e j `a pk`ko hko lnk^hai]o `a pk`ko hko fq]najoao $¼lkn mq jk `a pk`ko hko iate_]jko;%* Oacqeiko aila ]`ko aj _]an ]jpa hko i]n]rehhkoko _]jpko `a h]o oenaj]o( oej ajpaj`an mqa jk oa pn]p] `a _naan aj h]o `ahe_e]o `a hko oqa ko( oejk `a aobknv]njko u pn]^]f]n `qn]jpa iaoao u ] ko l]n] _na]n h]o _kj`e_ek) jao ja_ao]ne]o l]n] mqa opko oa _qi) lh]j( oej ejpania`e]neko mqa atef]j lna^aj`]o ] _]i^ek `a kpknc njkohko `a i]jan] ]qpki pe_]( i ce_] a ejo) p]jp ja]* .

BM GSFOUF

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

5SBTDFOEJu gk[ bWi fWbWXhWi Z[b l_[hd[i Z[b

][d[hWb i[Yh[jWh_e Z[ bW :[\[diW DWY_edWb" =k_bb[hce =Wbl|d" ieXh[ bW d[Y[i_ZWZ Z[ gk[ [b ;`ƒhY_je de f[hcWd[pYW ckY^e j_[cfe c|i [d bWi YWbb[i" ^_Y_[hed gk[ Wb]kdei b[]_ibWZeh[i Z[il[bWhWd Wo[h kd i[Yh[je W leY[i0 bei c_b_jWh[i gk_[h[d [ijWh [d bei YkWhj[b[i W c|i jWhZWh [b ‘bj_ce Z‡W Z[b (&''$

B7 I;C7D7 :; HECĂŽD H;LK;BJ7I

&O MPT QBSUJEPT IBZ RVF PCFEFDFS 1VOUP

De i[h| bW fh_c[hW l[p gk[ i[ YWij_]k[ W kd c_b_jWdj[ Yed _Z[Wi fhef_Wi$ BWi W]hkfWY_ed[i feb‡j_YWi i[ fWh[Y[d W bei [`ƒhY_jei0 iÂŒbe _cfehjW bW Ye^[i_ÂŒd o [b [if‡h_jk Z[ Yk[hfe$ I[ fh[c_W bW ikc_i_ÂŒd" f[he i[ iWYh_Ă…YW bW b_X[hjWZ _dZ_l_ZkWb$ B‡W B_cÂŒd dkdYW lW W ^WY[h YWhh[hW [d [b F7D Wb d[]Whi[ W Ă…hcWh [b h[Ykhie Z[ _dYedij_jkY_edWb_ZWZ YedjhW bei cWjh_ced_ei ]Wo$ Gkƒ f[dW H;Dx IEJE%7H9>?LE

?dYbkie kde Z[ [bbei Yec[djŒ gk[ [d [b [dYk[djhe Z[b cWhj[i Z[b ]WX_d[j[ Z[ I[]kh_ZWZ DWY_edWb Yed bei i[dWZeh[i" i[ b[ fh[]kdjŒ Wb ][d[hWb =Wbl|d i_ i[ cWdj[d‡W bW _Z[W Z[b (&''" W be gk[ [b \kdY_edWh_e ^WXh‡W Wi[dj_Ze Yed bW YWX[pW$

gk[ ieXh[ [i[ j[cW o ejhei

h[bWY_edWZei ^WXh| Xk[d Wd|b_i_i o Z[XWj[ ^eo" W bWi - Z[ bW deY^[" [d bW <[h_W ?dj[hdWY_edWb Z[b B_Xhe Z[b FWbWY_e Z[ C_d[h‡W" YkWdZe i[ fh[i[dj[ ;b Y|hj[b Z[ I_dWbeW$ KdW ^_ijeh_W Z[b kie feb‡j_Ye Z[b dWhYe" Z[ dk[ijhe YecfW‹[he :_[]e ;dh_gk[ Eiehde$ FWhj_Y_fWh|d jWcX_ƒd @kWd L_bbehe" HeX[hje PWcWhh_fW o 9_he =Œc[p B[olW$

gk[ feh c|i fehhWi gk[ bei

fWhj_Y_fWdj[i b[ [Y^Whed W bW H[kd_ÂŒd ?dj[hfWhbWc[djWh_W Cƒn_Ye#9kXW" YWb_Ă…Y|dZebW Z[ Âş[dYk[djhe cko jhWiY[dZ[dj[Âť" Yed Wi_ij[dY_W Z[ Âşb[]_ibWZeh[i Z[ fh_c[h d_l[bÂť" bW h[Wb_ZWZ fWh[Y[ Z_ij_djW$ FWhW [b ]eX_[hde YkXWde" bW h[kd_ÂŒd \k[ jWd ÂşjhWiY[dZ[dj[Âť gk[ [b fh[i_Z[dj[ HW‘b 9Wijhe d_ i_gk_[hW i[ jecÂŒ bW ceb[ij_W Z[ [djh[l_ijWhi[ Yed bW Z[b[]WY_ÂŒd c[n_YWdW$ O bW Z[YbWhWY_ÂŒd Yed`kdjW de fWiÂŒ Z[ i[h kdW b_ijW Z[ Xk[dWi _dj[dY_ed[i" Yece ÂşYedjh_Xk_h Yed bW feb‡j_YW ][d[hWb Z[ dk[ijhei ]eX_[hdei o W bW l[hZWZ[hW dehcWb_pWY_ÂŒd Z[ dk[ijhWi h[bWY_ed[iÂť" e ÂşYecXWj_h [b Yh_c[d eh]Wd_pWZe" [b dWhYejh|Ă…Ye o [b j[hheh_ice Yed WYY_ed[i Yed`kdjWi XWiWZWi [d [b h[if[je W bW ieX[hWd‡WÂť$

gk[ C?B;D?E J[b[l_i_Œd h[]_ijhŒ [d [d[he bei d_l[b[i Z[ WkZ_[dY_W c|i Wbjei [d iki '+ c[i[i Z[ ^_ijeh_W$

BW jhWdic_i_Œd [d l_le Z[ bW fh[i[djWY_Œd Z[ bei l_Z[ei Z[b WjWgk[ W IWblWZeh 9WXW‹Wi" [d C?B;D?E Dej_Y_Wi Z[ bWi '& Z[ bW deY^[ Z[b bkd[i (+ Z[ [d[he" WbYWdpŒ bei /, c_b j[b[^e]Wh[i o \k[ bW i[]kdZW i[‹Wb Z[ j[b[l_i_Œd Z[ fW]W c|i l_ijW [iW deY^[ W [iW ^ehW$ 7 `kp]Wh feh bei d‘c[hei fh[b_c_dWh[i Z[ bWi Zei fh_c[hWi i[cWdWi Z[ [ij[ c[i" \[Xh[he f_djW c[`eh$

&

h _]ok `a h] ]o]i^haÂŽop] HÂŽ] Hei“j atde^a( aj pk`] oq `eiajoe“j( h] `eĂš_qhp]` aoaj_e]h `a iehep]n aj qj l]npe`k lkhÂŽpe_k l]n] ]mqahhko ej`ere`qko `eolqaopko ] ao_q_d]n lneian]iajpa h] rkv `a oq _kj_eaj_e] aj rav `a okiapanoa ej_kj`e_ekj]hiajpa ] h]o lnƒ_pe_]o eilan]jpao* Aop] iqfan( `elqp]`] hk_]h lkn ah `eopnepk TER aj h] _]lep]h `a h] Nal˜^he_]( oa jac“ ] Ăšni]n ah na_qnok `a ej_kjopepq) _ekj]he`]` mqa ah L=J ejpajp]^] ejpanlkjan l]n] naranpen h]o nabkn) i]o ]h ?“`eck ?ereh mqa h] =o]i^ha] Haceoh]per] lnkikre“ _kj ah Ăšj `a mqa lqa`]j _]o]noa hac]hiajpa h]o lanokj]o `ah ieoik oatk u( oe hao reaja aj c]j]( ]`klp]n jeÂ’ko $]dkn]( ao je iƒo je iajko mqa h] Beo_]hÂŽ] `a h] j]_e“j h] mqa d] pki]`k h]o neaj`]o `ah ]oqjpk lank( ieajpn]o p]jpk( ah L=J ha d] mqep]`k ] HÂŽ] h] re_alnaoe`aj_e] `a h] ?kieoe“j `a Receh]j_e] aj h] =H@B( ajpna kpn]o nalnao]he]o7 ]d( u r]neko nalnaoaj) p]jpao l]jeop]o mqeanaj a_d]nh] lqn] u oeilhaiajpa `ah l]npe`k%* Iqu ^eaj( jk oanÂŽ] h] lneian] rav mqa qj] i]mqej]ne] l]npe`eop] oa lkja aj bqj_ekj]ieajpk l]n]

_]opec]n ] qj iehep]jpa _kj e`a]o lnkle]o* H]o ]cnql]_ekjao lkhÂŽpe) _]o( aj aopa oajpe`k( oa l]na_aj ] hko afŠn_epko6 eilknp]( lkn aj_ei] `a pk`]o h]o _ko]o( h] _kdaoe“j u ah aolÂŽnepq `a _qanlk* Ao _eanpk mqa h] `elqp]`] Hei“j jk d] rekh]`k jej) cqjk `a hko lnej_eleko bqj`]iaj) p]hao `a qj l]npe`k mqa `aĂšaj`a( ]jpao mqa j]`]( hko `ana_dko `a h] lanokj] dqi]j]* Lank( fqop]iajpa( ah ]oqjpk aj _qaope“j jk oa naĂšana ] ao] `eranoe`]` `a e`a]o u klejekjao mqa _]^nÂŽ] aolan]n aj qj ajpknjk `a pkhan]j_e] oejk ] h] ian] k^a`eaj_e] `a^e`] ] hko i]j`]pko `a hko fan]n_]o k( lkn hk iajko( ] h] najqj_e] ] h]o lkopqn]o ej`ere`q]hao l]n] o]hr]) cq]n`]n h] o]_nko]jp] ĂŽqje`]`Ă? `a qj l]npe`k* Aop] _ann]v“j `a hko iehep]jpao jko iqaopn] ecq]hiajpa h] `a_nalepq` `a jqaopnk ia`ek lkhÂŽpe_k* Lknmqa( oaÂ’kn]o u oaÂ’knao( aj qj ajpknjk `a ik`anje`]` `a^a lna`kiej]n h] ok^an]jÂŽ] `ah ej`ere`qk _kik lnej) _elek aoaj_e]h `a h] ok_ea`]` ]^eanp]* =mqÂŽ( lkn ah _kjpn]nek( lnar]ha_a h] pn]ojk_d]`] reoe“j `a ]mqahhko l]n] mqeajao h] `erancaj_e] nalnaoajp] qj] ]qpkiƒpe_] ]iaj]v] u mqa( lkn ahhk ieoik( lnerehace]j( `a i]jan]

ÂŤ:ÂŒdZ[ i[ [dYk[djhW [b fWhj_Ze WX_[hje o jeb[hWdj[ ZedZ[ i[ fk[ZWd [nfh[iWh bei _dZ_l_Zkei W fWhj_h Z[ iki Yedl_YY_ed[i" [b cel_c_[dje ZedZ[ bW f[hj[d[dY_W de i_]d_\_gk[ kdW h[dkdY_W eXb_]WZW Wb [`[hY_Y_e Z[ bW ieX[hWd‡W f[hiedWb o kd WYje Z[ iec[# j_c_[dje5

ej`eo_qpe^ha( ah lnej_elek `a ]qpkne) `]`* Ao ah ik`ahk fan]nmqev]`k `a hko oeopai]o ]qpknep]neko `kj`a hko `kci]o eilknp]j iƒo mqa h]o lanokj]o* Lank( ]`aiƒo( aopa aleok`ek iqaopn]( `a h] ieoi] i]jan]( h] cn]j `eop]j_e] mqa jko oal]n]( ] jkokpnko hko _eq`]`]jko( `a hko l]npe`ko lkhÂŽpe_ko* Aj hk lanokj]h( _kiqhck( lkn afailhk( _kj iq_dko `a hko lnej_eleko `ah L]npe`k =__e“j J]_ekj]h* Ia cqop]( oej ai^]nck( h] lkopqn] `ah LN@ aj hk mqa oa naĂšana ] hko `ana_dko `a h]o iejknÂŽ]o u ]lk) uk ej_kj`e_ekj]hiajpa oq lkopqn] he^an]h* Oqlkjck( `a h] ieoi] i]) jan]( mqa ah LNE d]^nƒ `a c]n]jpev]n ej_kj`e_ekj]hiajpa h] h]e_e`]` `ah Aop]`k iate_]jk oeaj`k mqa aopa lnej_elek ia l]na_a ejjack_e]^ha `ao`a oqo n]ÂŽ_ao* Lank( aj jejcqjk `a hko pnao lnej_el]hao l]npe`ko aj_qajpnk qj] iav_h] amqehe^n]`] `a he^an]heo) ik u ik`anje`]`6 h] evmqean`] u h] `ana_d] aj_]nj]j( oal]n]`]iajpa( r]hknao mqa ia l]na_aj lanba_p]) iajpa ]_alp]^hao lank mqa oa _kj) pn]lkjaj( `a i]jan] ennaia`e]^ha( aj ah ƒi^epk l]npe`eop]* Âź@“j`a aopƒ( lqao( ah l]npe`k mqa lqa`] lnkikran hko lnej_eleko `ah he^na ian_]`k( h] lnklea`]` lner]`]( h] chk^]hev]_e“j( h] ok^an]jÂŽ] `ah ej`ere`qk( ah eilanek `a h] hau u( ] h] rav( h] lkoe^ehe`]` `a mqa oa ]`iep]j lnƒ_pe_]o _kik h] aqp]j]oe] nacqh]`]( hko i]pneikjeko ajpna dkikoatq]hao( h] `aolaj]) hev]_e“j `ah ]^knpk u kpnko `a aoko ]oqjpko mqa p]jpk ejmqeap]j ] hko _kjoanr]`knao; ÂźU( `“j`a oa aj_qajpn]( ]oeieo) ik( ah l]npe`k ]^eanpk u pkhan]jpa( ah aol]_ek `a `eranoe`]` `kj`a oa lqa`]j atlnao]n hko ej`ere`qko ] l]npen `a oqo _kjre__ekjao( ah ik) reieajpk `kj`a h] lanpajaj_e] jk oecjeĂšmqa qj] najqj_e] k^hec]`] ]h afan_e_ek `a h] ok^an]jÂŽ] lanokj]h u qj ]_pk `a okiapeieajpk; Aoa hqc]n jk ateopa( aopei]`ko ha_pknao* U( _q) neko]iajpa( hko lneianÂŽoeiko `]i) jeĂš_]`ko Ă?]l]npa `a h] _eq`]`]jÂŽ]( `ao`a hqack( mqa l]c] `ena_p]iajpa hko _kopko `a h] l]npe`k_n]_e]Ă? okj hko lnkleko iehep]jpao* L]n] i]uknao oaÂ’]o( ra]j qopa`ao hko lnk_aoko l]n] ahacen ejpanj]iajpa ] hko _]j`e`]) pko6 _]oe jqj_] okj `aoecj]`ko hko iafknao( hko mqa lkoaaj hko iŠnepko iƒo reoe^hao k( ej_hqoera( hko mqa d]j hkcn]`k _kja_p]n _kj hko _eq`]`]jko( oejk mqa okj ahace`ko hko iƒo _an_]) jko ] h] ]hp] fan]nmqÂŽ] l]npe`eop] aj lnk_a`eieajpko p]j ko_qnko _kik ej_kilnajoe^hao l]n] hko oeilhao iknp]hao* Ah `aolan`e_ek `a p]hajpko ran`]`anko ao eilan`kj]^ha* Oa lna) ie] h] k^a`eaj_e]( `ao`a hqack* Lank oa o]_neĂš_]( `ao]bknpqj]`]iajpa( h] he^anp]` ej`ere`q]h* HÂŽ] Hei“j( _nak uk( jqj_] r] ] d]_an _]nnan] aj ah L=J* MqŠ laj]* .D h[lk[bjWi6cWY$Yec

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

/BEJF IBDF DBTP

BM GSFOUF

LK;BJ7 FHE>?8?:7

-B GBSTB EF MBT BMJBO[BT

=\[\i`Zf 9\iil\kf

DEJ?C;N%7H9>?LE

;i kh][dj[ gk[ [b 9ed]h[ie Z[ÅdW kd f_ie b[]Wb fWhW bW _dj[hl[dY_ d Z[ bWi \k[hpWi WhcWZWi [d cWj[h_W Z[ i[]kh_ZWZ _dj[hdW$ De i[ jhWjW Z[ WY[fjWh bW fhefk[ijW Z[b Fh[i_Z[dj[" i_de Z[ Z_iYkj_hbW o c[`ehWhbW" o Yed [bbe Wj[dZ[h kde Z[ bei j[cWi c|i Z[b_YWZei gk[ i[ [d\h[djWd0 [l_jWh gk[ bW Z[i[if[hWY_ d feh bW _di[]kh_ZWZ bb[l[ W W\[YjWh bWi b_X[hjWZ[i o%e W bei c_b_jWh[i >x9JEH JxBB;P

9eWb_Y_ d [d :khWd]e

% <k[hW Z[ bW b[o$ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

1

nacqjp] ?]nhko Lqec ok^na mqe j d]_a _]ok ]h hh]i]`k `ah cajan]h oa_nap]nek `a nabkni]n h] Hau `a Oacqne`]` J]) _ekj]h( l]n] `]n ^]oa u _anpe`qi^na hac]h ] h] ]_pq]_e j `a h]o bqanv]o ]ni]`]o aj k_]oe j `a mqa^n]jpk k ]ba_p]_e j ] h] oacqne`]` ejpanekn* J]`ea d]_a _]ok( ?]nhko* J]`ea* H] eje_e]per] `ah Afa_qperk oa lna) oajp ]h ?kjcnaok aj ]^neh l]o]`k* @eav iaoao( qj lanek`k `a oaoekjao kn`ej]ne]o u oai]j]o `a kpnk u pk) `]r ] j]`]* Jk oa pn]p] `a ]_alp]n h] lnklqaop] `ah Lnaoe`ajpa( oejk `a `eo_qpenh]( `a^]penh] u( `a oan ah _]ok( iafkn]nh] l]n] rkp]nh] u _kj ahhk ]paj) `an qjk `a hko pai]o i o `ahe_]`ko mqa ajbnajp] ah Aop]`k iate_]jk6 arep]n mqa h] `aoaolan]_e j lkn h] ejoacqne`]` hhara ] ]ba_p]n h]o he^an) p]`ao u+k ]h Af n_epk* Ah `a^]pa j]_ekj]h oa r] d]_e] h]o ]he]jv]o k ok^na C iav Ikjp7 h] kleje j l ^he_] aj h] cnehh]( _q]j`k ah pai] `a h] ejoacqne`]` mqai] h]o i]jko `a ok_ea`]` u ck^eanjk* Ah Af n_epk iana_a ]paj_e j* Jk oa ha lqa`a `aoc]op]n lkn _]qo] `ah bn]_]ok k ej_kilapaj_e] `a h]o ]qpkne`]`ao _erehao u oqo ejopnqiajpko( _kik okj h]o lkhe_ ]o k hko pne^qj]hao* Ah cajan]h oa_nap]nek qnca jqa) r]iajpa ] haceoh]n* Ah lnaoe`ajpa ?]h`an j aj ` ]o l]o]`ko lnaoaj) p qj] eje_e]per] ok^na oa_qaopnk u qj] lnklqaop] `a Hau `a Oacqne`]` L ^he_] l]n] h] ?eq`]` `a I te_k( ]h peailk mqa La ] Jeapk na_kjk_a h] ejpanraj_e j `a h]o bqanv]o ]ni]`]o( aj ]qtehek ] h] lk^h]_e j ]ba_p]`] lkn h]o ejqj`]_ekjao `a oai]j]o l]o]`]o* Aop ^eaj( lank hk qncajpa ao mqa ah ?kjcnaok `aÚj] qj leok hac]h l]n] h] ejpanraj_e j `ah Af n_epk aj i]pane] `a oacqne`]` ejpanj]* J]`ea d]_a _]ok lknmqa ah ?kjcnaok u hko

b]_pknao mqa aj opa ej_e`aj ]j`]j aj kpnko iajaopanao* Hko da_dko n]peÚ_]j mqa h] l]n) pa i o nao_]p]^ha `a h] eje_e]per] `a nabkni] lkh pe_] `ah lnaoe`ajpa ?]h`an j ao h] `a b]_qhp]n ]h Lk`an Afa_qperk l]n] mqa lqa`] lnaoajp]n ]h ?kjcnaok `ko eje_e]per]o lnabanaj) pao( h]o mqa `a^an j rkp]noa ]jpao `a mqa _kj_hqu] ah lanek`k7 aj _]ok _kjpn]nek( op]o oa _kjoe`an]n ]j ]lnk^]`]o* Bnajpa ]h aop]`k `a _k) o]o ao ]^oqn`k mqa aj ah LNE `ec]j mqa hk lnklqaopk ejpajp] naoq_ep]n ah lnaoe`aj_e]heoik ]qpknep]nek*Oa pn]p] `a k^hec]n ]h ?kjcnaok ] mqa oa lnkjqj_ea( mqa pn]^]fa aj hko pai]o `a lnekne`]` `ah l] o `a ]_qan`k _kj h] `apaniej]_e j `ah lnaoe`ajpa aj pqnjk* ¼Mq iqara ]h LNE( ah l]npe`k lnaoe`aj_e]heop] iafkn lkoe_ekj]`k l]n] c]j]n aj .,-.( ] jac]n qj _]i^ek `a p]h i]cjepq`; H] naolqaop] aop aj ah Oaj]`k u( l]npe_qh]niajpa( aj ah oaj]`kn >ahpnkjao( mqeaj lnapaj) `a mqa ah ln teik lnaoe`ajpa aop okiape`k( aola_e]hiajpa oe ao `ah LNE u peaja i]ukn ] aj h]o ? i]n]o ba`an]hao( lkn aok ao ah lnkikpkn i o `a_e`e`k `ah ck^eanjk `a c]^ejapa u h] n]peÚ_]_e j l]nh]iajp]ne] `a h]o `aoecj]_ekjao lnaoe`aj_e]hao* Ah _]i^ek p]i^e j peaja narano]( _kik lqa`a _kjop]p]noa aj _]l pqhko eilknp]jpao `a h] nabkni] aha_pkn]h `a .,,3* H] lnkde^e_e j `a lq^he_e`]` lanokj]hev]`] hhar]^] `a`e_]pkne]( p]i^e j ah n ceiaj naopne_perk `a h]o he^anp]`ao( mqa ah aolkpeoik u jk ah `a^]pa bqan] na_qnok lnerehace]`k `a _]il] ]( mqa ah EBA oa ejopepquan] aj lkhe_ ] `a h] n]`ek u h] pr( ]o _kik at_hqen ] hko l]npe`ko `a h] hac]he`]` `aik_n pe_]( ejopepqen h] ejamqe`]` aha_pkn]h `apaniej]j`k hko `ejanko u ah ]__aok ] h] lq^he_e`]` lkn ah naoqhp]`k `a h]o `aoecq]hao u lk_k receh]`]o aha__ekjao ejpania`e]o u(

;b ;` hY_je c[h[Y[ Wj[dY_ d$ De i[ b[ fk[Z[ Z[i]WijWh feh YWkiW Z[b \hWYWie e _dYec# f[j[dY_W Z[ bWi Wkjeh_ZWZ[i Y_l_b[i o iki _dijhk# c[djei" Yece ied bWi feb_Y Wi e bei jh_XkdWb[i

l]npe_qh]niajpa( mqa hko ejpacn]jpao `ah ?kjoafk Cajan]h `ah EBA ajpaj`ean]j mqa lqa`aj oan naikre`ko* = lao]n `a hko ]r]j_ao _kik na`q_en peailko `a _]il] ] u nacqh]n lna_]il] ]o( h]o nach]o u hko nc]jko aha_pkn]hao ]^naj h] lqanp] ] h] ej_anpe`qi^na( ] h] ejamqe`]` u( _kjoa_qajpaiajpa( ] h] _kjpnkranoe]* J]`ea d]_a _]ok ]h cajan]h oa_nap]) nek lknmqa jk _qaop] ecjkn]nhk( lknmqa hko _eq`]`]jko aop j `aolnkreopko `a hko ia`eko u `a hko na_qnoko l]n] na_h]i]n ] hko haceoh]`knao( lknmqa h] hau jk k^hec] mqa opko d]c]j ah pn]^]fk l]n] ah _q]h bqankj aha_pko* @a h] ejraopec]_e j ] h] `ah]_e j* H] _]he`]` `a h] lkh pe_] aop _kj`e) _ekj]`] lkn h] _]he`]` `a h] _n pe_]* ¼= mqe jao naj`eiko _qajp]o hko ao_ne) ^]jko k _kj`q_pknao _kj ah lnerehacek `a oan ]paj`e`ko lkn ah l ^he_k( mqa jk oa]j h]o iajp]`]o `a hko pnkhao `ah Pseppan; ?kj h] pn]jol]naj_e] `ah ck^eanjk u i]uknao he^anp]`ao hko aol]_eko `a eilqje`]` lanek` ope_] oa d]j ]ilhe]`k* Pailhk I]ukn u >]fk Naoanr]( `ko eilknp]jpao _khqij]o( oeiqhp ja]iajpa bqankj k^fapk `a ajc] k ]h nalnk`q_en qj] iajpen] mqa ejpajp]^] ]ba_p]n ]h amqelk `a La ] Jeapk( lkn qj oqlqaopk re]fa ]h Oqlan >ksh ]h peailk `a h]o ejqj) `]_ekjao7 bqa lkoeperk mqa ]i^ko aol]_eko na_peÚ_]n]j ] oq ik`k ]h ` ] oecqeajpa* Aj ` ]o l]o]`ko( O]hr]) `kn C]n_ ] Okpk lq^he_ _kj lnqa^] `k_qiajp]h mqa qj oaj]`kn( lna_]j) `e`]pk ] qj] cq^anj]pqn]( aop]^] oeaj`k ejraopec]`k lkn r j_qhko _kj ah j]n_kpn Ú_k( ranoe j b]ho] u `k_qiajpk ]l _nebk ]h `a_en `a h] LCN* Hko ia`eko hk iajko mqa `a^aj d]_an ao `ao_q^nen ah jki^na `a mqeaj ajc] ]h _khqijeop] u mqa lean`]( `a qj] rav lkn pk`]o( h] _kj`e_e j `a Îpaopeck lnkpace`kÏ* .D \X[hhk[jef6]cW_b$Yec

qn]jpa aopa iao hko iate_]) jko jko daiko paje`k mqa _dqp]n ah h]iajp]^ha `a^]pa ok^na h]o ]he]jv]o mqa d]j lnkp]ckjev]`k l]jeop]o( lneeop]o u lanna`eop]o* Oa pn]p] `a ]hck mqa o hk lqa`a oan _]hebe_]`k `a ]omqanko] atde^e_e j( _kj h] _q]h( ejbnq_pqko]iaj) pa( ah L=J u ah LN@ lnapaj`aj raj`anha ] h] ok_ea`]` qj] Î_k]he_e j `aik_n pe_]Ï _kjpn] ah LNE* =h ieoik peailk ao_q_d]iko ] hko rk) _anko lneeop]o mqa Újcaj d]^an j]_e`k ]uan u ]_qo]j ] oqo _kjpnej_]jpao `a ejpajp]n d]_anoa l]o]n lkn he^anp]neko u `ai _n]p]o( _q]j`k aj na]he`]` oa _kilknp]j _kik ln]ci pe_ko u pn]ilkoko* Aj .,,2 reiko _ ik hko lanna`eop]o u lafeop]o mqeoeankj eila`en h] pki] `a lnkpaop] ] Bahela ?]h`an j _kik lnaoe`ajpa aj qj] oqanpa `a oaq`kckhla `a Aop]`k `a h] evmqean`] l]hqn`]( u ]paopecq]iko h] r]_eh]jpa `abajo] `a h] hac]he`]` `a hko oa_pknao i o _erehev]`ko aj_]^av]`ko lkn hko lneeop]o u ]hcqjko cnqlko `ah LN@* =dkn]( aj .,-,( ]jpa ah ]jqj_e]`k na) cnaok `ah LNE ] Hko Lejko Íoac j h]o aj) _qaop]oÍ( raiko h] ranckjvko] i]nki] `ah L=J l]n] ]he]noa _kj ah ieoik LN@ mqa ejpajp `annk_]n ] ?]h`an j( _kj h] oeilha u hh]j] ejpaj_e j `a eila`en mqa c]jaj h]o cq^anj]pqn]o aj .,-, u h] Lna) oe`aj_e] aj .,-.* =jpao `ah pneqjbk `a Bkt aj .,,,( iq_dko oej `q`] oqo_ne^eiko mqa h] `aik_n]_e] aj I te_k l]o]^] lkn h] `annkp] `ah LNE* Lank ajpkj_ao hhac h] ]hpanj]j_e] u _]i) ^e]nkj hko _ h_qhko* @aolq o `a qj oatajek bkteop] u ia`ek _]h`ankjeop]( hko l]jeop]o are`ajpaiajpa jk _kjb ]j aj ah afan_e_ek `a ck^eanjk `a oqo lnaoe`ajpao u `a_e`aj d]_an ] hko la) nna`eop]o oqo ]he]`ko( ] lao]n `a d]^anhko hh]i]`k d]op] h] o]_ea`]` ckhleop]o( j]_ko u narajp]`knao* Hk mqa aop]iko reaj`k jk ao qj] ]he]jv] `a lnej_eleko je `a lnkua_pko* Okiko paopecko `a _ ik( ]jpa hko b]hhe`ko ck^eanjko `a L=J u LN@( u h] `a_eoe j `a hko _eq`]`]jko `a rkhran ] rkp]n lkn ah LNE( l]jeop]o u lanna) `eop]o d]_aj `a h]`k lnkua_pko u lnej_eleko l]n] _ann]nha ah l]ok ]h lneeoik* Hko _eq`]`]jko jko r]iko ] pajan mqa oklh]n kpnk lhaepk ajpna l]npe`ko( `ah mqa oej `q`] jk r]iko ] o]hen ^ajaÚ_e]`ko* .D d[ijeh$e`[ZW6c_b[d_e$Yec

E jkfi Fa\[X

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

&M UFNB

P

c_deh Wi" [ijWZe o ]WhWdj Wi

BW 9ec_i_ d ;ijWjWb Z[ :[h[Y^ei >kcWdei YedijWj gk[ [n_ij[d l_ebWY_ed[i W bWi ]WhWdj Wi _dZ_l_ZkWb[i [d [b 9 XWde

Bei ]hkfei lkbd[hWXb[i i[ gk[`Wd feYWi l[Y[i0 9;:> "

9eb_cW3: jXi 9Xii\iX M}qhl\q

lao]n `a mqa ah ] k l]o]`k $`ah - `a `e_eai) ^na `a .,,4 ]h ., `a jkreai^na `a .,,5% h] ?kieoe j Aop]p]h `a @ana_dko Dqi]jko $?A@D% na_e^e qj pkp]h `a /53 mqaf]o( je qj] `a op]o bqa lnaoajp]`] lkn l]npa `a cnqlko rqhjan]^hao Ì_kik okj ej` caj]o( fknj]hanko ]cn _kh]o k lanokj]o _kj `eo_]l]_e`]`Íaj nah]_e j _kj ]hcqj] rekh]_e j aj oqo `ana_dko dqi]jko* Aj aopa oajpe`k( h] oa_nap]ne] afa) _qper] u p _je_] `a h] ?A@D( Jkai Cqpe nnav >]neko( atlhe_ mqa aopk oa `a^a ] mqa iq_dko `a aopko cnqlko rqhjan]^hao( u lnej_el]hiajpa hko nalnaoajp]`ko lkn ej` caj]o( jk peajaj qj _kjk_eieajpk _]^]h ok^na oqo `ana_dko* =oeieoik( _kiajp mqa p]i) lk_k aopa cnqlk iejknep]nek( hko ej` caj]o( lnaoajp ]hcqj] mqaf] ] h] ?A@D lkn oan k^fapk `a `eo) _neiej]_e j* U i]pev mqa qj] `a h]o n]vkjao lkn h]o mqa jk d]u iq_d]o mqaf]o aj nah]_e j ] h] `eo_neiej]_e j( ao Îlknmqa iq_d] cajpa pk`]r ] jk aop ajpan]`] `a hk mqa ao h] `eo_neiej]_e j( iq_d] cajpa `af] l]o]n h] `eo_ne) iej]_e j u je oa ajpan] `a mqa u] ao `ahepk aj ah aop]`kÏ* ?kik qj] ia`e`] l]n] _kj) pn]nnaop]n aopk( Cqpe nnav >]nneko oa ]h mqa _kj h] bej]he`]` `a ejo) pnqen ] h]o lanokj]o l]n] mqa oa]j i o _kjo_eajpao `a oqo `ana_dko( h] ?A@D aop na]hev]j`k reoep]o ] cnqlko rqhjan]^hao l]n] ejbkn) i]nhao ok^na hko `ana_dko mqa peajaj _kik oanao dqi]jko*

;d bei bj_cei *

c[i[i de i[ ^Wd fh[i[djWZe gk[`Wi [d [ijW eh]Wd_pWY_ d 9eb_cW3:9M

&

h lnaoe`ajpa `ah ?kiep `a hko @ana_dko Dqi]jko Jk Cq^anj]iajp]h( Abn] j J]n]jfk ?knp o( ej`e_ mqa qj] `a h]o n]vkjao lkn h]o mqa jk okj iq_d]o h]o mqaf]o mqa lnaoajp]j hko cnqlko rqhjan]^hao ao lknmqa u] d]u i o ejopepq_ekjao mqa hko nalnaoajp]j u o]hr]cq]n`]j oqo `ana_dko* Aj aoa oajpe`k( pki _kik afailhk ] h]o lanokj]o _kj `eo_]) l]_e`]`( u `aop]_ mqa ah Ejopepqpk ?kheiajoa `a h] @eo_]l]_e`]`

KdW Z_h[Yj_lW Z[ [ijW Z[f[dZ[dY_W W\_hcW gk[ i[ Z[X[ W kdW \WbjW Z[ YedY_[dj_pWY_ d" fk[i ^Wo i[Yjeh[i Yece bei _dZ ][dWi gk[ W d de [ij|d _d\ehcWZei Z[ gk[ bW Z_iYh_c_dWY_ d [i kd Z[b_je

I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

Bei _dZ ][dWi ied [b i[Yjeh gk[ c|i ik\h[ Z_iYh_c_dWY_ d o [b gk[ c[dei WYkZ[ W Z[dkdY_Wh [b ^[Y^e = lnkl oepk `a aopk( h] oa_nap]ne] afa_qper] `a h] ?A@D oa ]h mqa d]_a qj]o oai]j]o oa reoep]nkj hko ]h^ancao `a _knp]`knao `a _] ] q^e_]`ko aj

ah iqje_elek `a ?q]qdp ik_( aj h] _kiqje`]` `ah ? ^]jk( `kj`a oa `apa_p]nkj _eanpko ]ola_pko `a rekh]_e j ] hko `ana_dko bqj`]iaj)

p]hao( naola_pk ] mqa jk peajaj qj] rereaj`] `ecj] u hko je ko mqa reraj ]d jk na_e^aj qj] a`q_]_e j _kj h] _k^anpqn] ]`a_q]`]*

Fh[i_Z[dj[ Z[b 9ec_j Z[ :[h[Y^ei >kcWdei De =kX[hdWc[djWb

7^ehW ^Wo c|i Wfeoei fWhW c_deh Wi0 DWhWd`e $Ej_k`eo% d] _kjpne^qe`k( aj _eanp] i]jan]( ] naokhran hko lnk^hai]o mqa h]o lanokj]o _kj `eo_]l]_e) `]` lq`ean]j pajan7 lkn hk mqa _kjoe`an mqa ] pn]r o `a aop] ejopepq_e j oa d]j naocq]n`]`k hko `ana_dko dqi]jko `a h]o lan) okj]o( aj aopa _]ok hko `ana_dko `a hko `eo_]l]_ep]`ko* ÎUk _kjkv_k ]iecko i ko( ejre`ajpao( mqa r]j ]h Ej_k`eo(

mqa okj l]npa `a aoa ejopepqpk( u ]jpao jk d]^ ] j]`] lkn ah aopehk( je qj ejopepqpk mqa ]uq`]n] ] h]o lanokj]o _kj `eo_]l]_e`]`* U d]_a -1 ., ] ko jk d]^ ] ejo) pepq_ekjao mqa ]uq`]n]j ] hko `eo_]l]_ep]`ko( k hko ]`qhpko i]uknaoÏ( i]jebaop J]n]jfk* ?]^a `aop]_]n mqa ]h ecq]h mqa h] ?kieoe j Aop]p]h `a @ana_dko Dqi]jko $?A@D%( ah ?kiep `a

@ana_dko Dqi]jko Jk Cq^an) j]iajp]h p]ilk_k d] na_e^e`k je qj] mqaf] ejpanlqaop] lkn ]hc j cnqlk rqhjan]^ha `ajpnk `ah aop]`k `a ?khei]( lkn hk iajko aj hko hpeiko 0 iaoao* =o hk ejbkni J]n]jfk ?knp o( mqeaj ]cnac mqa ah hpeik ]jpa) _a`ajpa aj aopa _kjpatpk bqa ah _]ok `a qj] l]naf] `a ]`qhpko i]uknao( h] _q]h bqa `aolkf]`]

ÎDaiko aj_kjpn]`k mqa aop j rereaj`k $hko fknj]hanko ]cn _k) h]o% `a qj] bkni] jk _ ik`]( jk peajaj rereaj`]o `ecj]o7 ej_hqok aj ]hcqjko ikiajpko daiko `apa_p]`k( aj ah ? ^]jk l]npe_q) h]niajpa( mqa jk peajaj `ana_dk ] h] a`q_]_e j $Å%( lknmqa naoqhp] mqa ]qjmqa peajaj qj] ao_qahep] _kj `ko o]hkjao( peajaj qj okhk i]aopnk l]n] ]paj`an `a lneiank ] oatpk `a lnei]ne]( u ]o jk oa lqa`a `]n h] _k^anpqn]Ï* ?]^a `aop]_]n mqa aj h] _kiqje) `]` `ah ? ^]jk reraj i o `a /,, fknj]hanko ej` caj]o( u naola_pk ] aopk Jkai Cqpe nnav ej`e_ mqa jk k^op]jpa `a mqa aop]o lanokj]o o hk oa mqa`]j oaeo iaoao aj ah aop]`k `a ?khei]( u hqack nacna) o]j ] Cqannank $aop]`k `a `kj`a lnkreajaj ]hcqjko%( aok jk ao qj ikperk l]n] mqa hko je ko jk na_e) ^]j qj] _knna_p] a`q_]_e j( u] mqa op] ao qjk `a hko `ana_dko lneikn`e]hao mqa _kik oanao dqi]jko okiko ]_naa`knao* Ok^na h] _]jpe`]` `a cnqlko rqhjan]^hao mqa d]u aj ah aop]`k `a ?khei]( >]nneko oa ]h mqa jk oa peaja qj] _q]jpebe_]_e j at]_p] `a opko( u] mqa h]o lanok) j]o mqa hko _kjopepquaj jk aop j nalnaoajp]`ko( aj oq i]ukn ]( lkn qj] ]ok_e]_e j _knna_p]iajpa nacqh]`]* Bej]hiajpa( h] `ena_pkn] afa_qper] u p _je_] `a h] ?A@D( Cqpe nnav >]nneko ]`ah]jp mqa h]o reoep]o `a _kj_eajpev]_e j ok^na `ana_dko dqi]jko ] cnqlko rqhjan]^ha ailav]nkj aj ?q]q) dp ik_( lank oa atlh]u]n j ] pk`k ah aop]`k `a ?khei] `qn]jpa hko ln teiko iaoao*.D `a oq l]pneikjek lkn h]o ieoi]o ]qpkne`]`ao* Ah ]_pereop] ok_e]h ]oaran mqa okj lk_]o h]o mqaf]o `a aopa pelk ejpanlqaop]o lkn cnqlko rqhja) n]^hao( u] mqa aj oq i]ukn ] okj lnaoajp]`]o lkn lanokj]o mqa jk nalnaoajp]j je qj] iejkn ]( u oa ajbk_]j lnej_el]hiajpa aj `apaj) _ekjao ]n^epn]ne]o u aj ah ]^qok `a ]qpkne`]`ao `a hko pnao jerahao* ÎJkokpnko lani]jajpa aop]) iko he`e]j`k _kj h]o `apaj_ek) jao ]n^epn]ne]o u ah ]^qok `a h] ]qpkne`]` iqje_el]h( ]^qoko `a h] ]qpkne`]` aop]p]h u ]hcqjko ]^qoko `a h] ]qpkne`]` ba`a) n]hÏ* Lkn hpeik( J]n]jfk ?knp o lna_eo mqa ah ] k l]o]`k( aj ah ?kiep mqa nalnaoajp] oa na_e) ^e qj ]lnktei]`k `a ., mqaf]o ranebe_]^hao lkn rekh]_ekjao ] hko `ana_dko dqi]jko* .D

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

FM UFNB

?iWWY Kh_X[ 7blWhWZe" _dl[ij_]WZeh Z[ bW <WYkbjWZ Z[ Fi_Yebe] W KZ[9

Yh d_YW

De ^Wo Wh]kc[djei fWhW _cf[Z_h WZefY_ d W ]Woi

QPS $lTBS #BSSFSB 7f[RVF[ ;IF;9?7B

;IF;9?7B

;b YedY[fje Z[ \Wc_b_W ]eX[hdWZW feh kdW fWh[`W ^[j[hei[nkWb [i Y[hhWZe

TBW ieY_[ZWZ [ij|

YWcX_WdZe" feh be gk[ bWi b[o[i i[ j_[d[d gk[ WZ[YkWh 9eb_cW3 :9M

&

h lnkbaokn ejraopec]`kn `a h] B]_qhp]` `a Loe_khkc ] `a h] Qjeranoe`]` `a ?khei]( Eo]]_ Qne^a =hr]n]`k( `efk mqa d]op] ah ikiajpk jk oa d] na]hev]`k jejcqj] ejraopec]_e j _eajp be_] ok^na mq ]ba_p]_ekjao lqa`a pajan qj je k ]h oan _ne]`k lkn l]`nao `ah ieoik oatk( lkn hk mqa oa ]h mqa h] ]ncqiajp]_e j mqa aocneiaj h]o

l]npao mqa aop j aj _kjpn] `a aopa `ana_dk jk peajaj ^]oao k^faper]o l]n] bqj`]iajp]nhk* Aj aopa oajpe`k( Qne^a =hr]) n]`k klej mqa h]o lkopqn]o mqa aop j aj _kjpn] `a mqa h]o l]naf]o dkikoatq]hao lqa`]j ]`klp]n( naolkj`aj ] qj] oanea `a lnafqe_eko ajpknjk ] h]o lnabanaj_e]o oatq]) hao( h]o _q]hao( lkn hk p]jpk( jk oa lqa`aj qpehev]n l]n] ]ncqiajp]n fqn `e_]iajpa aj _kjpn] `a h]o l]naf]o `ah ieoik oatk* =oeieoik( ej`e_ mqa h]o _]n]_pa) n ope_]o `a h]o hauao `a^aj naolkj`an ] h]o `ai]j`]o `a h] ok_ea`]`( Îu ah da_dk `a mqa ateopa aj I te_k qj] hau mqa hao kpkncqa ^ajabe_eko hac]hao ]h i]pneikjek ] lanokj]o `ah

ieoik oatk( u mqa aop]o lanokj]o lqa`]j ]`klp]n qj iajkn cn]_e]o ] ahh]( ia l]na_a ]_alp]^haÏ* Oej ai^]nck( ah lnkbaokn ejrao) pec]`kn `a h] B]_qhp]` `a Loe_k) hkc ] i]pev mqa ao eilknp]jpa( _kik aj _q]hmqean b]iehe]( mqa oa _qilh]j _eanpko ahaiajpko u _]n]_pan ope_]o( l]n] mqa ah iajkn lqa`] `ao]nnkhh]n oq re`] aj qj ]i^eajpa he^na `a rekhaj_e] u _kj l]`nao mqa hk ]lkuaj* = ]`e mqa oe oa oecqean] h] h ce_] `a h]o lanokj]o mqa oa klkjaj ] aopa pelk `a haceoh]_ekjao( p]i^e j Îpaj`n ]j mqa klkjanoa ] mqa h]o i]`nao okhpan]o aop j _ne]j`k ] oqo defko( lknmqa ]h bej]h `a _qajp]o jk peajaj qj] b]iehe] dapankoatq]h7 ao `a_en( mqa jk aop _kjopepqe`] lkn qj dki^na u qj] iqfanÏ* Qne^a =hr]n]`k `aop]_ mqa ah _kj_alpk `a b]iehe] peaja qj aola_pnk `a `abeje_e j iqu ]ilhek( lkn hk mqa ateca mqa oa] na)_kj_alpq]hev]`k( Îu ] aok ao ] hk mqa naolkj`aj h]o hauao mqa( ]_pq]hiajpa( aop j kpknc]j`k hko `ana_dko `a h]o lanokj]o mqa peaja qj lnabanaj_e] oatq]h `ebanajpa ] h]o `a h]o i]ukn ]oÏ* Ej`e_ ( lkn hpeik( mqa ao i o lnk^]^ha mqa h] ok_ea`]` ieoi] oa] h] mqa _]qoa qj] ]ba_p]_e j ] hko je ko mqa okj ]`klp]`ko lkn qj] l]naf] dkikoatq]h( `a^e`k ] mqa lqa`aj oan k^fapko `a _n pe_]o u lnafqe_eko lkn oqo Îecq]haoÏ* .D

H[l[bW [b fh[i_Z[dj[ Z[b ?dij_jkje 9eb_c[di[ Z[ bW :_iYWfWY_ZWZ

;b ?dYeZ_i de ^W _dj[hfk[ije gk[`Wi feh Z_iYh_c_dWY_ d YedjhW Z_iYWfWY_jWZei ;b \kdY_edWh_e Z_Y[

gk[ [d 9eb_cW bW ieY_[ZWZ ^W [ijWZe [lebkY_edWdZe 9eb_cW3 :9M

&

h lnaoe`ajpa `ah Ejopepqpk ?kheiajoa `a h] @eo_]l]) _e`]` $Ej_k`eo%( Bn]j_eo_k L nav Ia`ej]( oa ]h mqa d]op] ah ikiajpk jk oa d] lnaoajp]`k qj] oepq]_e j aj _kjpn] `a qj] lanokj] _kj `eo_]l]_e`]` mqa ]ianepa ejpanlkjan qj] mqaf] aj h] ?kieoe j Aop]p]h `a @ana_dko Dqi]jko `a ?khei] $?A@D%* Î=bknpqj]`]iajpa( aj hk mqa hhar]iko aj h] ]`iejeopn]_e j( jk d] d]^e`k qj] mqaf] k ]hc j ]oqjpk mqa lq`ean] _kjoe`an]noa l]n] ejpanlkjan qj] mqaf] aj h] ?kieoe j Aop]p]h `a hko @ana_dko

Dqi]jko( _kik cnqlk rqhjan]^ha ]h d]^an oe`k `eo_neiej]`kÏ* Aj aopa oajpe`k( Bn]j_eo_k L nav klej mqa aopk oa `a^a ]h lnk_aok `a i]`qn]_e j `a h] ok_ea`]` _kheiajoa( aj i]pane] `a `ana_dko ok_e]hao( u] mqa Îao qj aop]`k mqa peaja qj] i]`qnav eilknp]jpa aj _q]jpk ] h] ok_ea) `]`( u hko `ana_dko `a pk`]o h]o lanokj]o( ej_hquaj`k ] hko mqa peajaj `eo_]l]_e`]`Ï* Oa ]h mqa hko _eq`]`]jko( lank lnej_el]hiajpa ah ck^eanjk( `a^aj ]paj`an _kj qj] lkh pe_] l ^he_] ] lanokj]o mqa l]`a_aj `a qj] `eo_]l]_e`]`* Î?q]j`k raj ] qj] lanokj] _kj `eo_]l]_e`]`( lqao _kjoe`an]j mqa _kik cnqlk rqhjan]^ha are`ajpaiajpa peaja qj] `aorajp]f] mqa ]paj`an( lkn hk p]jpk hko _eq`]`]jko _kik ah ck^eanjk `a^aiko ]paj`anha _kj qj] lkh pe_] l ^he_]( lna_eo]iajpa l]n] lk`an ^nej`]n ecq]h`]` l]n]

h]o lanokj]oÏ( ]_kp ah lnaoe`ajpa `ah Ej_k`eo* L nav Ia`ej] ej`e_ mqa hko lnej) _el]hao lnk^hai]o mqa ]ba_p]j ] h]o lanokj]o _kj `eo_]l]_e`]` Ìu] oa] reoq]h( ikpnev a ejpaha_pq]hÍokj h]o ^]nnan]o mqa h] ieoi] ok_ea`]` d] lqaopk( u] aj ah i^epk ]nmqepa_p je_k $nabanajpa ] mqa jk d]u qj] ejbn]ao) pnq_pqn] ]`a_q]`] aj pk`]o h]o _]hhao u a`ebe_eko%( u] aj hko napko lanokj]hao mqa ajbnajp] _]`] qj] `a h]o lanokj]o mqa oqbna `a qj] `eo_]l]_e`]`* Klej mqa p]jpk hko _eq`]`]jko u h]o ]qpkne`]`ao d]j ajpaj`e`k mqa qj cnqlk p]j rqhjan]^ha _kik ah oa_pkn ok_e]h `a hko `eo_]l]_ep]`ko( iana_a qj pn]pk `ecjk* Lkn hpeik( ah lnaoe`ajpa `ah Ej_k`eo naepan mqa `a^e`k ] aopk Î]bknpqj]`]iajpa jk d] d]^e`k qj] okh] _]qo] mqa dq^ean] ]ia) nep]`k lnaoajp]n qj] mqaf] aj h] _kieoe j aop]p]h k aj h] j]_ekj]h `a @ana_dko Dqi]jkoÏ*.D

/$, /$* F_[ Z[ \eje f_[ Z[ \eje

-P NfT EJGpDJM GVF BDFQUBSNF B Np NJTNP Bei _dikbjei [d bW YWbb[ ied Yece f[ZhWZWi Wd d_cWi Z_ifWhWZWi Z[iZ[ kdW l[djWdW

&

ne_ Echaoe]o( aopq) `e]jpa `a h] Qjeran) oe`]` `a ?khei]( jk oa ]_kilhaf] ]h `a) _en aj rkv ]hp]6 oku dkikoatq]h* Aopk ] lao]n mqa `ao`a iqu lamqa k( u] aop]^] _eaj lkn _eajpk oacqnk `a oqo ej_hej]_ekjao oatq]hao* =beni]( aj ajpnareop] l]n] IEHAJEK ?K) HEI=6 ÎUk na_qan`k mqa `ao`a lamqa k oeailna oqla _ ik oku( hk mqa e^] oan7 o]^ ] mqa an] `ebanajpa( aop]^] _kjo_eajpa `a mqa jk an] _kik hko `ai o( _kik h] ok_ea`]` pa hk aopelqh]Ï* L]n] h( qj ejoqhpk aj h] _]hha ao ]hck mqa oa `] `a rav aj _q]j`k( lank oa `]* Ao ]hck mqa bkni] l]n) pa `a oqo ]_pere`]`ao _kpe`e]j]o( _kik en ]h f]n` j u oajp]noa aj qj] ^]j_] ] _kian l]hkiep]o* Hko ej) oqhpko( oa ]h]( okj _kik la`n]`]o ]j jei]o mqa ha `eol]n]j `ao`a qj] rajp]j]( `ao`a qj _]nnk aj ikreieajpk( lank hko ]_alp] _kj a_q]jeie`]`* Oej ai^]nck( _kjbeao] mqa hk i o `qnk `a ]bnkjp]n d] oe`k ]_alp]noa ] o ieoik( u] mqa h] ok_ea`]` jk hk ]_alp]^] ] h k hk ien]^] _kj na_ahk* ÎBqa `eb _eh ]_alp]nia ] i ieoik( _kik aj h] ]`khao_aj_e] mqa qjk r] _]i^e]j`k( _q]j`k rao ] pqo ]iecko u ]iec]o mqa pea) jaj oqo jkre]o u jkrekoÏ* @a ao] bkni]( p]i^e j _kiajp] mqa hk i o `eb _eh mqa d] ajbnajp]`k aj oq re`] bqa h] pn]joe_e j `a oatpk `a lnei]n] ] oacqj`k `a oa_qj) `]ne]( Îlknmqa pqra mqa ]_alp]n) ia ] i ieoik* @]npa _qajp] `a mqa anao `ebanajpa u ]bnkjp]nhk*

Lank pajck mqa atpanj]nhk( u] jk lqa`k _kj aop] _]nc]( lknmqa oku l]npa `a h] ok_ea`]` u pajck mqa `a_enhk* @a h] ok_ea`]` d]^h]j`k `a ie b]iehe]( `a h] ok_ea`]` d]) ^h]j`k `a ieo ]iecko( `a h] cajpa _kj h] mqa ia iqarkÏ( _kjbeao] Ane_( reoe^haiajpa _kjikre`k* Jk k^op]jpa( ah aopq`e]jpa `a h] Qjeranoe`]` `a ?khei] ]oara) n] mqa jk pk`k aop i]h( mqa jk pk`k ao ejoqhpko( u] mqa p]i^e j d]u ikreieajpko mqa oa aop j caop]j`k `ajpnk `a h] ieoi] ok_ea`]` _kheiajoa ] b]rkn `a h] _kiqje`]` dkikoatq]h* Aj aopa oajpe`k( ej`e_] mqa u] oa d]j na]hev]`k i]n_d]o aj h] _eq`]` _]lep]hej] ] b]rkn `a h] `eranoe`]` oatq]h u h] pkhan]j_e] ] h] _kiqje`]` c]u( ]o _kik qj] _]il] ] mqa oa aop knmqaop]j) `k( ]_pq]hiajpa( lkn ia`ek `ah B]_a^kkg l]n] mqa aj ?khei] p]i^e j oa eilhaiajpaj h]o ieoi]o ia`e`]o haceoh]per]o ] b]rkn `a hko dkikoatq]hao mqa aj ah @eopnepk Ba`an]h* Jk k^op]jpa( ah laoeieoik ] ra_ao _]ila] aj ah jeik `a Ane_( u oa atlnao]6 ÎUk oeajpk mqa ?khe) i] jk aop lnal]n]`k l]n] mqa k_qnn] ]hck _kik aj ah @B( _kik aj hko l] oao lneian iqj`eop]o( aqnklako* Lknmqa ?khei] ao iqu lamqa k( ao ?kheiep]6 ao lqa^hk _de_k ejbeanjk cn]j`a* Oan ] iqu n]nk mqa l]o]n]Ï* = lao]n `a mqa lna_eo] mqa d]u qj oa_pkn eilknp]jpa `a dkik) oatq]hao( Îjk oa d]j da_dk hauao ] b]rkn `a jkokpnko6 da reopk qj] `k^ha ikn]h ajpna hko d]^ep]jpao `a ?khei]Ï* .D

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

$PMJNB ;b Z_h[Yjeh Z[ bW F;F WÅhcW gk[ [d 9eb_cW ^Wo ]hkfei `kl[d_b[i gk[ ied l_eb[djei

YbWl[i

FWdZ_bbWi kiWd WhcWi [nYbki_lWi Z[b [` hY_je

7Yjei Z[ l_eb[dY_W 9 ;b cWhj[i" Wbh[Z[Zeh Z[ bWi

J7F?HE

Bei ` l[d[i gk[

9BWi Wkjeh_ZWZ[i ieij_[d[d

bWi _dj[]hWd j_[d[d [djh[ ', o )+ W ei o [ij|d [d [b dWhYe

gk[ bWi fh_c[hWi _dl[ij_]WY_e# d[i WfkdjWd W gk[ [i kd fb[_je [djh[ fWdZ_bbWi1 bei \Wc_b_Wh[i Z[ bWi l Yj_cWi Z_Y[d gk[ de$ Kde Z[ bei W]h[ieh[i fehjWXW kd WhcW / cc Z[ kie [nYbki_le Z[b [` hY_je" bW FheYkhWZkh W oW be j_[d[ _Z[dj_\_YWZe$

F;F h[YedeY[ gk[

^Wo _di[]kh_ZWZ f[he f_Z[ W bW feXbWY_ d fWY_[dY_W o Yeef[hWY_ d

9;b W e fWiWZe [d bW Yebed_W ;b OWgk_" [d L_bbW Z[ ÎblWh[p" kd ]hkfe Z[ fWdZ_bb[hei WjW# YWhed W kd c[deh Z[ [ZWZ" be ]ebf[Whed Yed kdW f_[ZhW [d bW YWX[pW o be Z[`Whed ^[h_Ze" c|i jWhZ[ \k[ jhWibWZWZe Z[ [c[h][dY_W Wb >eif_jWb H[]_e# dWb Kd_l[hi_jWh_e$

9eb_cW3?\`[` [\ C\ e >lk` ii\q

&

h `ena_pkn `a h] Lkhe) _ ] Aop]p]h Lnarajper] $LAL%( D _pkn >]qpeop] R vmqav( na_kjk_e mqa ah l]j`ehhaneoik ao qj lnk^hai] mqa oa paj`n mqa _ki^]pen ejpajo]iajpa( ok^na pk`k aj h]o _khkje]o `a Ah Iav_]hepk( Ien]`kn `a h] ?qi^na( Jqark Iehajek u Ah Perkh ( aj h] _]lep]h _kheiajoa7 u H] Chkne] u O]j Eoe`nk( aj Rehh] `a ãhr]nav* Aj aopa oajpe`k( ]Úni mqa ah l]j`ehhaneoik ao qj lnk^hai] mqa d] ateope`k `ao`a oeailna( oej ai^]nck( ] `ebanaj_e] `a d]_a r]neko ] ko( d]u l]j`ehh]o mqa u] aop j ]ni]`]o u aj ]hcqjko _]oko h]o leopkh]o mqa qpehev]j okj `a qok at_hqoerk `ah af n_epk( _kik oq_a`e ah i]npao l]o]`k( _q]j`k qj lnaoqjpk l]j`ehhank ]oaoej ] qj fkraj a dene ] kpnk i o* ÎHko dkie_e`eko mqa d]j oq_a) `e`k aj ?khei] okj ]ni]o `a qok at_hqoerk `ah af n_epk( p]j o hk $aj% ah ]oaoej]pk `ah i]npao( ah lnaoqjpk ]cnaokn ao qj fkraj `a .0 ] ko mqa lknp]^] qj] 5 ieh iapnko( oac j hko _]omqehhko mqa aj_kjpn]iko aj ah hqc]nÏ( atlhe_ ah bqj_ekj]nek lkhe_ ]_k*

9eb_cW3D`c\e`f

&

h fqav oacqj`k `a hk laj]h `a h] _eq`]` `a ?khei] `a_nap ]qpk `a bkni]h lneoe j ] `ko lanokj]o `ah oatk i]o_qhejk mqa naolkj`aj ] hko jki^nao `a =`ne j Danj j`av @ahc]`k( $]% ÎAh ?dkhkÏ( ]o _kik ] I]nek =npqnk Aolejkv] Rah]o_k( $]% ÎAh ?dknaÏ( lkn oq lnk^]^ha naolkjo]^ehe`]` laj]h aj h] _kieoe j `ah `ahepk `a nk^k _]hebe_]`k( aj ]cn]rek `ah l]pneikjek `ah lnkleap]nek `a h] c]okhejan] mqa oa q^e_] lkn h] =r* Je ko D nkao u Re_ajpa Cqannank* ?kik oa na_kn`]n hko lnk^]) ^hao naolkjo]^hao bqankj `apaje) `ko aj ` ]o l]o]`ko lkn ]cajpao `a h] LLFA( u _kj ahhk oa hkcn ah

/0 )& Z[ bW deY^[" kd ]hkfe Z[ ` l[d[i XW` Z[ kdW YWc_ed[# jW o W]h[Z_ W XWbWpei W ejhe ]hkfe gk[ i[ [dYedjhWXW feh bW YWbb[ B[hZe Z[ J[`WZW" [d [b Y[djhe Z[ 9eb_cW$ KdW f[hiedW ckh_ o ejhW c|i h[ikbj ^[h_# ZW feh [i[ ^[Y^e$

> Yjeh 8Wkj_ijW L|pgk[p Wi[]kh gk[ [b Z[i[cfb[e ^W ^[Y^e gk[ Wkc[dj[d bei _b Y_jei W fb[dW bkp Z[b Z W >]qpeop] R vmqav ]oacqn mqa oa nabknv]n h] aopn]pace] l]n] _ki^]pen ah l]j`ehhaneoik( lank jk mqeok ]`ah]jp]n `ap]hhao l]n] jk ]hanp]n ] hko `ahej_qajpao( jk k^op]jpa i]jebaop mqa peajaj ^eaj q^e_]`ko hko hqc]nao u _khkje]o aj `kj`a ateopaj i]uknao lnk^hai]o `a l]j`ehhaneoik* Ah `ena_pkn `a h] LAL oajpaj_e mqa h] i]ukn ] `a hko l]j`ehha) nko okj f rajao mqa peajaj ajpna -2 u d]op] /1 ] ko `a a`]`7 qj ]hpk lkn_ajp]fa okj dki^nao u

aj iajkn ia`e`] oa aj_qaj) pn]j iqfanao( hko _q]hao aop j ejianoko aj ah j]n_kiajq`ak u h] lnkopepq_e j* ÎDaiko reopk mqa ah `aoailhak d] da_dk mqa ]qiajpaj aopko eh ) _epko( lknmqa( ] lhaj] hqv `ah ` ] u] aop]^]j oq_a`eaj`k ]o]hpko )] h]o -,( -- `a h] i] ]j])( lank h] LCFA u h] LAL hkcn]iko h] `apaj_e j `a r]neko h]`nkjao mqa aop]^]j ` j) `kha _neop]h]vko ] hko ]qpki rehao( nk^]^]j h]o c]okhejan]o( gekogko( kttkoÏ( `efk

Ah bqj_ekj]nek na_kjk_e mqa d]u `ahej_qajpao he^nao( lank okopqrk mqa oa aop j pki]j`k h]o ia`e`]o lanpejajpao l]n] lnkjpk `apajan ] mqeajao aop j pn]opnk_]j`k h] pn]jmqehe`]` `a hko _kheiajoao* Ok^na h] ^]h]_an] `ah i]npao lkn h] jk_da( aj ah _ajpnk `a h] _eq`]` _]lep]h `ah aop]`k `a ?khei]( ah `e) na_pkn `a h] LAL ej`e_ mqa h] _]hha Han`k `a Paf]`] aj aop] `ai]n_]_e j( aop _kjoe`an]`] _kik qj hqc]n `kj`a ateopa h] rekhaj_e] fqrajeh( ]h ecq]h mqa aj h] _khkje] ah Iav_]hepk(

Kde Z[ [bbei fh[ij Z_d[he W ik l Yj_cW Yed [b Xej d eXj[d_Ze

:[Yh[jWd \ehcWb fh_i_ d W jh[i _dZ_l_Zkei feh heXe YWb_ÅYWZe ao_h]na_eieajpk `a 3 nk^ko( `a hko _q]hao `ko _kiapeankj aj Gekogko( - Kttk( / c]okhejan]o( ]o _kik ] qj =n_a `a Rehh] `a ãhr]nav* P]i^e j oa ao_h]na_e qj] paj) p]per] `a dkie_e`ek aj ]cn]rek `a qj iajkn mqa lkn k^re]o n]vkjao oa kiepa oq jki^na* <_hc ik i[dj[dY_W Yed (& f[iei Lkn kpn] l]npa( ah ieoik fqav oacqj`k `a hk laj]h `a h] _eq`]`

`a ?khei]( hqack aj_kjpn]n la) j]hiajpa naolkjo]^ha `ah `ahepk `a nk^k _]hebe_]`k ] Cqehhanik Nerank J av( hk oajpaj_e ] _ej_k ] ko `a aj_annek _]noa) h]nek lkn da_dko k_qnne`ko ah l]o]`k iao `a i]nvk `a .,,1( aj ]cn]rek `a qj] lanokj] `ah oatk baiajejk* Ah oajpaj_e]`k bqa `apaje`k ah l]o]`k iao `a i]nvk `a .,,5( aj _qilheieajpk ] qj] kn`aj

`a ]lnadajoe j he^n]`] aj oq _kjpn] lkn ah fqvc]`kn `a h] _]q) o] lkn ah `ahepk u] oa ]h]`k* Aj oq _kjbaoe j Cqehhanik oa ]h mqa ]lnkra_d mqa oq r _pei]( qj] oa kn] `a 4, ] ko khre` aj r]ne]o k_]oekjao oqo hh]rao lac]`]o aj h] _d]l] `a h] lqan) p] u aj qj] `a o]o h]o pki u bqa _kj qj _ann]fank l]n] o]_]n qj] _kle] l]n] hqack iapanoa ] nk^]n*

Îu `ao`a d]_a 2, ] ko peajaj ao] _]n]_pan ope_]( lank aop]iko _kj) pn]nnaop]j`k hko aba_pkoÏ* >]qpeop] R vmqav le`e ] h] lk^h]_e j l]_eaj_e] u _kh]^kn]) _e j( lqao ]_alp mqa ah aop]`k `a ?khei] p]i^e j d] oe`k _kj) p]iej]`k lkn h] `ahej_qaj_e] mqa eilan] aj kpn]o ajpe`]`ao( Îp]j o hk d]_a qjko ` ]o `apqreiko ] qj] ^]j`] `a Cq]`]h]f]n] mqa aop]^] ]iaj]v]j`k ] h]o lanokj]o mqa pn]^]f]j ]bqan]o `a h]o peaj) `]o `al]np]iajp]hao _qe`]j`k hko rad _qhkoÏ( `efk* >]qpeop]( ]beni mqa ]qj _q]j`k aj pk`k ah l] o aop `ao]p]`] h] rekhaj_e]( aj ?khei] h] `ahej_qaj_e] jk d] na^]o]`k ] h]o ]qpkne`]`ao Îaop]iko d]_eaj`k aobqanvko l]n] c]n]jpev]n h] pn]jmqehe`]`( o hk ha la`eiko ] h] lk^h]_e j l]_eaj_e] u p]i^e j mqa _kh]^knaj( lknmqa d]u cajpa mqa oa ikhaop] _q]j`k `apajaiko oq i]n_d] l]n] nareo]n oq rad _qhkÏ( _kj_hqu * .D

Oa `enece ]h _q]npk `kj`a `qan) ia h] r _pei] u k^oanr qj] _ ik) `] mqa paj ] qj]o hh]rao lac]`]o lkn hk mqa h] cen u k^oanr mqa aj ah ejpanekn d]^ ] qj ok^na `a qj] ejopepq_e j ^]j_]ne] u aj oq ejpanekn . ieh 0,, laoko aj aba_) perk( ]o _kik qj _kjpn]pk `a qj] ejranoe j* =cnac mqa `a ejia`e]pk o]he `ah `al]np]iajpk u oa `enece ]h `a h l]n] `knienoa( dkn]o i o p]n`a oa aj_kjpn ] h] ]ba_p]`] hhkn]j`k u ha _kiajp mqa ha d]^ ]j nk^]) `k . ieh 0,, laoko( mqa e^] ] en ] lkjan h] `ajqj_e] lank mqa jk paj ] `ejank* I]jebaop mqa ]jpa `e_d] oepq]_e j o]_ `ejank `a oq ^kho] u ha `efk Îha rku ] lnaop]n ., laokoÏ( l]n] mqa h] oa kn] oa pn]oh]`]n] aj qj p]te* .D

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

;b fh[i_Z[dj[ Z[b 9edi[`e 9_kZWZWde Z[ FWhj_Y_fWY_ d IeY_Wb h_dZ_ Wo[h ik _d\ehc[ Z[ bWXeh[i

º;b ]eX_[hde Z[X[ ^WY[h c|i gk[ _d\hW[ijhkYjkhW» I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

;b _d\ehc[ [ijkle

_dj[hhkcf_Ze feh Y_kZWZWdei gk[ [nj[hdWhed gk[`Wi

;d [b [l[dje \k[

dejeh_W bW Wki[dY_W Z[b ]eX[hdWZeh [ijWjWb" CWh_e 7d]k_Wde 9eb_cW3@mfee\ 9XiXaXj

'

n]j_eo_k æ ecqav ?a^]hhko( lnaoe`ajpa `a h] ?kjoafk ?eq`]`]jk `a L]npe_el]_e j Ok_e]h( h]jv r]ne]o okhe_epq`ao aj ah i]n_k `a oq _q]npk ejbkn) ia `a ]_pere`]`ao mqa oa _aha^n ]uan6 Mqa oa ja_aoep] qj ck^eanjk lnak_ql]`k jk o hk lkn ej]q) cqn]n k^n]o `a ejbn]aopnq_pqn] qn^]j]( oejk qj ck^eanjk mqa ]peaj`] h]o `ai]j`]o ok_e]hao6 ]oqjpko nah]_ekj]`ko _kj h] lk) ^nav]( h] o]hq` u h]o _]naj_e]o a`q_]per]o* Ah ?kjoafk ?eq`]`]jk lnklqok d]_an ]he]jv]o _kj ah ck^eanjk aop]p]h6 ÎQj] ]he]jv] _kjpn] h]o ]`e__ekjao( _kjpn] h] ejbh]_e j(

<hWdY_iYe Ñ _]k[p 9[XWbbei Z_`e gk[ Z[X[ i[h fh_eh_ZWZ Z[b ]eX_[hde [b Wj[dZ[h bWi Z[cWdZWi ieY_Wb[i

$PMJNB

_kjpn] hko lnk^hai]o `a o]hq`( lank ] b]rkn `a h] _qhpqn]( h] pn]jol]naj_e] u h] naj`e_e j `a _qajp]oÏ( oq^n]u æ ecqav ?a^]hhko* =oacqn mqa ?khei] naj`en ] qj ikjqiajpk `ah p]i] k `a h] ao_qhpqn] `ah n^kh ÎAh HeikjankÏ ] hko `elqp]`ko ba`an]hao mqa( `ao`a oqo _]ncko( hkcnaj ]lku]n h]o ik`ebe_]_ekjao ]h ]np _qhk 2. ^eo `ah EB=L6 ÎAopk ^ajabe_e]n ] iq_d oeik lknmqa d]u cajpa mqa _kj `a^an -,, ieh laoko lean`aj lnklea`]`ao mqa r]haj iehhkjao `a laoko u oe hkcn]n]j naokhran aop] oepq]_e j oan ] i]n]rehhk) okÏ( _kjoe`an aj ajpnareop] l]n] IEHAJEK ?KHEI=* Fko Fq nav =h_]n]v( nalna) oajp]jpa `a h] ok_ea`]` _ereh( ]oacqn 6 Î=h ck^eanjk aop]p]h jk hk r]iko ] `af]n okhk( lank p]ilk_k `af]naiko mqa jko `afa okhkÏ u ajoacqe`] h]jv ]hcqj]o nabhatekjao aj pknjk ] h] _kopqi) ^na mqa peajaj ]hcqjko lkh pe_ko mqa( ] _]`] _]i^ek `a pneajek k oatajek( `afaj pnqj_ko lnkua_pko `a h] ]jpanekn ]`iejeopn]_e j6 ÎAo dkn] `a lajo]n aj hko ^aja) be_eko ] h]nck lh]vk( jk o hk aj hko ejia`e]pkoÏ( ]cnac * Ah arajpk lnkpk_kh]nek( aj mqa oa naoejpe h] ]qoaj_e] `ah ck^an) j]`kn I]nek =jcqe]jk Iknajk( bqa ejpannqile`k aj qj l]n `a k_]oekjao lkn _eq`]`]jko mqa ]lnkra_d]nkj ah bknk l]n] ran) pan oqo `ai]j`]o i o oajpe`]o6 qjko `ajqj_e]nkj d]^an oe`k `aolkf]`ko ejfqop]iajpa `a oqo ^eajao( ieajpn]o mqa kpnko atecea) nkj pn]jol]naj_e] aj ah i]jafk `a h]o bej]jv]o l ^he_]o* Bn]j) _eo_k =jv]n Dannan]( oa_nap]nek `a Lh]ja]_e j( oa _kilnkiape ] hhar]n pk`]o h]o `ai]j`]o ] hko k `ko `ah ck^anj]`kn*.D

I_ i[ W`kijW W bW b[o" be _dj[djWh|d" Wi[]khW B[edWhZe =kj_ hh[p 9^|l[p

>WXbWd b Z[h[i i_dZ_YWb[i Z[ WcXei ckd_Y_f_ei

7dWb_pWd gk[ ;b CWdY^ d lk[blW W i[h Z[b ckd_Y_f_e

FW]ei Z[ f[di_ed[i" [d 9eb_cW [ij|d X_[d1 [d L_bbW Z[ ÎblWh[p j_[d[d h[jhWie

;ije W hW p Z[ gk[ [b

^eif_jWb Z[ Fk[hjW Z[ >_[hhe feZh W [Z_ÅYWhi[ [d ejhe i_j_e Z[ bW Y_kZWZ 9eb_cW3@9

4

e oa ]fqop] ] hko heja]ieaj) pko hac]hao( oa ejpajp]n naranpen h] laniqp] `ah pa) nnajk Ah I]j_d j lkn ah lna`ek `ah bn]__ekj]ieajpk ?khej]o `a O]jp] > n^]n] ]_kn`]`] ajpna ah ]uqjp]ieajpk `a ?khei] u ah Ck^eanjk `ah Aop]`k7 `a p]h i]jan] mqa ah lna`ek `ah I]j) _d j rqahr] ] oan lnklea`]` `ah ]uqjp]ieajpk _]lep]hejk* Ah lnaoe`ajpa `a h] ?kieoe j `a L]pneikjek Iqje_el]h( Hakj]n`k ? o]n Cqpe nnav ?d rav ]oacqn mqa `ao`a d]_a `eav ` ]o aop j aopq`e]j`k hko `e_p iajao u hko lnk_aoko ^]fk hko _q hao oa `ek aop] laniqp]6 ÎAj h] ?kieoe j `a L]pneikjek Iqje_el]h( `a h]

J7F?HE

mqa bknik l]npa( pajaiko mqa okiapan ]hcqjko ]ncqiajpko ] h] `a_eoe j `a _]^eh`k l]n] o]_]n qj ]_qan`k7 lkn oqlqaopk paj`n ]) iko mqa ]j]hev]n h]o _qaopekjao hac]hao l]n] `e_p]iej]n aj aopa ]oqjpkÏ* U] d]j pn]jo_qnne`k `eav `a hko _q]najp] ` ]o `a hko mqa `eolkja ah _]^eh`k `ah ]uqjp]ieajpk `a ?khei] l]n] d]_an ah `e_p]iaj Új]h `a aopa ]oqjpk6 ÎH] atla_) p]per] ao mqa pk`k oa ]lacqa ] h] hac]he`]`( `a ]_qan`k ] aok ^eaj lqa`a naranpenoaÏ* Ah lnaoe`ajpa `a h] ?kieoe j `a L]pneikjek Iqje_el]h atlhe_ mqa( ]h d]^an h] lkoe^ehe`]` `a mqa ah lnkua_pk `ah Dkolep]h Lqanp] `a Deannk oa ejop]ha aj kpn] vkj] `a h] _]lep]h( lk`n ] lajo]noa aj h] lkoe^ehe`]` `a mqa ah pannajk q^e_]`k aj Ah I]j_d j rqahr] ] oan lnklea`]` `ah ]uqjp]ieajpk `a ?khei]* Aj aopa lqjpk Hakj]n`k Cqpe ) nnav ]oacqn mqa oa paj`n j mqa na_qnnen ] h] nareoe j `a hauao `a bkiajpk a_kj ie_k( ]o _kik h]

;b WZ[kZe [d LZ[7

[i Z[ /&& c_b f[iei Wfhen_cWZWc[dj[1 fhedje i[h| b_gk_ZWZe 9eb_cW38c\o :XiYXaXc 9\iY\i

.

I_]k[ Z_\kiW bW i_jkWY_ d Z[b fh[Z_e iqje_el]h u h] aop]p]h7 lank lnaÚne jk ]rajpqn]noa ] ikopn]n qj lk) oe_ekj]ieajpk Îd]op] nareo]n mq jko laniepa d]_an h] hauÏ*.D

eajpn]o aj ah iqje_elek `a ?khei] ah h `an oej`e_]h( D _) pkn =npqnk Ha j( `aop]_ mqa _kj h] ]_pq]h ]`iejeopn]_e j jk d]u jejc j nav]ck aj _q]jpk ]h l]ck `a lajoekjao ] hko oej`e_]he) v]`ko( aj Rehh] `a ãhr]nav d]u qj napn]ok aj ah l]ck `a hko iaoao `a `e_eai^na u ajank( mqa lk`n ]j oan hemqe`]`ko aj ` ]o ln teiko* Panao] N]i nav( he`anao] oej`e_]h `ah iqje_elek rehh]hr]najoa( ejbkni mqa aba_per]iajpa d]u qj ]pn]ok lkn l]npa `a h] ]_pq]h ]`iejeopn]_e j( u] mqa b]hp]j lkn l]c]n hko iaoao `a `e_eai^na u ajank* ÎHko na_qnoko mqa b]hp]j lkn l]c]n _knnaolkj`aj ] aopko `ko iaoaoÏ( u aj _ebn]o oa aop]n ] d]^h]j`k `a qjk

5,, ieh laoko( u] mqa oa _]h_qh] mqa ah j iank `a lajoekj]`ko lkn l]npa `a Rehh] `a ãhr]nav ]o_eaj`a ] 0,, at pn]^]f]`knao* Oej ai^]nck( h] he`anao] ej`e_ mqa aopa napn]ok oa _q^nen ] Új]hao `a aopa iao `a ba^nank( u] mqa u] dq^k qj ]_qan`k _kj h] lnaoe`ajp] iqje_el]h( >naj`] Cqpe nnav Rac]( ]qjmqa ah iao `a ba^nank oan _q^eanpk d]op] u] ajpn]`k ah iao `a i]nvk* Lkn oq l]npa( D _pkn =npqnk Ha j( `enecajpa oej`e_]h `ah ]uqj) p]ieajpk `a ?khei]( `aop]_ mqa _kj h] ]_pq]h ]`iejeopn]_e j jk d]u jejc j napn]ok o]h]ne]h( Îjk d] d]^e`k aj`aq`]ieajpkÏ( `efk* Atlhe_ mqa aopa hqjao d]^n qj] naqje j _kj h] lnaoe`aj_e] iqje_el]h l]n] lkjanha ba_d] ] qj l]ck mqa d]^ ] mqa`]`k nav]c]`k( lkn hk mqa le`e aolan]n d]op] _kj_hqe`] aop] naqje j l]n] mqa oa lqa`]j `]n ba_d]o( `]pko u `ap]hhao ]h naola_pk `a aop] oepq]_e j( u _q j`k oan _q^eanp]* Bej]hiajpa( `aop]_ h] ^qaj] `eolkoe_e j `a h]o l]npao l]n] hhac]n ] qj ]_qan`k*.D

$PMJNB

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

J7F?HE

IWd <[b_f[ Z[ @[i i o iki fhej[]_Zei h[Y_X[d ZedWY_ d [Yed c_YW

9ec_i_ d Z[ IWbkZ

Bei Yb_[dj[i Z[ bWi j_[dZWi Z[ Yed# l[d_[dY_W Enne [d 9eb_cW gk[ ^Wd WY[fjWZe h[ZedZ[Wh iki Yk[djWi ^_Y_[hed fei_Xb[ [b ZedWj_le Z[ ')/".,/$,* f[iei gk[ [d [ijW eYW# i_ d \k[ [djh[]WZe W EXhWi IeY_W# b[i IWd <[b_f[ Z[ @[i i$ ;b Y^[gk[ \k[ h[Y_X_Ze feh [b fh[i_Z[dj[ Z[b fWjhedWje" > Yjeh <[hd|dZ[p [d h[# fh[i[djWY_ d Z[b FXhe$ H_YWhZe L|p# gk[p BWhW" gk_[d Z_h_][ [ijW bW Wie# Y_WY_ d Y_l_b gk[ WfeoW W f[hiedWi Y_[]Wi" iehZeckZWi" Yed i dZhec[ Z[ :emd o Z_iYWfWY_ZWZ[i lWh_Wi$ ;d [b [l[dje" ºBkf[»" _dl_Z[dj[ []h[iWZe Z[ bW _dij_jkY_ d" h[bWj ik ^_ijeh_W Z[ l_ZW o Y ce ºEXhWi IeY_Wb[i» b[ WokZ fk[i j_[d[ () W ei jhWXW`WdZe o / ^_`ei$ ;b Z_d[# he i[h| Z[ij_dWZe fWhW WYjkWb_pWh bW j[Ydebe] W Z[b ºY_X[h#YW\ »" gk[ [i kdW Z[ bWi jWdjWi \ehcWi Yed gk[ [b eh]Wd_ice fheYkhW ][d[hWh _d]h[iei fWhW iki W]hkfWZei$

F[i[ W bWi ceb[ij_Wi gk[ YWkiW bW eXhW" l[Y_dei Z[b bk]Wh l[d X[d[\_Y_ei W bWh]e fbWpe

?dijWbWd dk[lWi jkX[h Wi [d bW YWbb[ fh_dY_fWb Z[b XWhh_e ;b PWbWj d <EJEI0 I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

BW Yebed_W Yeb_cejW

ieb W _dkdZWhi[ feh \WbbWi [d [b Zh[dW`[ o [b WbYWdjWh_bbWZe

9ed [b YWcX_e Z[ bWi

jkX[h Wi i[ Z[if_Z[ kd ebeh Z[iW]hWZWXb[ gk[ YWkiW Z_i]kijei 9eb_cW3@mfee\ 9XiXaXj

.

]mqej]ne] lao]`] u qj amqelk `a pn]^]f]`knao hhac]nkj ah hqjao ] h] _]hha I]nc]nep] I]v] `a Fq nav( aj Ah V]h]p j( l]n] d]_an qj _]i^ek `a pq^an ]o* H] ejpaj_e j ao arep]n mqa h] vkj] oa oec] ejqj`]j`k Ì_kik okh ] l]o]nÍ`a ]cq]o jacn]o* =qjmqa hko ra_ejko na) _kjk_aj mqa hao ej_kik`] ah lkhrk u h]o ikhaope]o mqa pn]a h] k^n]( oa ]jei]j ]h lajo]n aj hko ^ajaÚ_eko `a h] ieoi]* ÎJk ao ]cn]`]^ha mqa d]u] lkh) rk _en_qh]j`k pk`k ah ` ] aj ah ]i^eajpa( je p]ilk_k ao ]cn]`]^ha ao_q_d]n h] i]mqej]ne] pk`] h] i] ]j]( lank o]^aiko mqa aop] k^n] r] ] r]han h] laj]Ï( _kej_e) `eankj I]n ] >nevqah]( =`ne]j] Aolneahh] u Cq]`]hqla R vmqav( mqeajao h]^kn]j aj qj _ajpnk `a pn]^]fk q^e_]`k ok^na h] _]hha I]nc]nep] I]v] `a Fq nav* Hko lnafqe_eko i o are`ajpao ao mqa jk lqa`aj ejcnao]n oq rad _qhk ]h aop]_ekj]ieajpk `ah a`eÚ_ek `a oqlanreoe j `a lnaao_kh]n `ah aop]`k( `kj`a pn]^]f]j( oejk mqa `a^aj `a aop]_ekj]nhk aj hko ]hna) `a`knao `ah hqc]n6 ÎOkj lamqa ]o ikhaope]o aj _kil]n]_e j _kj hko ^ajaÚ_eko mqa r]iko ] na_e^en $Å%

;iei l_[`ei ZkYjei #feh ZedZ[ Æko[ jeZe Z[i[Y^e ^kcWde o ikijWdY_Wi \ j_ZWi gk[ fheZkY[d bWi WYj_l_ZWZ[i Yej_Z_WdWi [d jeZei bei Wi[djWc_[djei khXWdei# ied h[delWZei [d [ijW Yebed_W Z[ bW YWf_jWb Yeb_c[di[ ]jpao( d]op] jko ejqj` ^]iko `a ]cq]o jacn]o lknmqa h]o pq^an ]o an]j k^okhap]o lank aolan]iko mqa ao]o oepq]_ekjao jk rqahr]j ] nalapenoaÏ( ]cnac =`ne]j] Ao) lneahh]( mqeaj ]cnac mqa lkn Új oa aop j pki]j`k _]np]o aj aopa ]oqjpk mqa ]ba_p `qn]jpa p]jpko ] ko ] h] _khkje]* Eni] ?]nn]o_k( ]i] `a _]o] u kpn] `a h]o ra_ej]o `ah hqc]n(

]oacqn mqa oq jack_ek `a rajp] `a _kie`] d] oqbne`k ]ba__ek) jao lkn h]o k^n]o6 ÎHko _]nnko jk lqa`aj l]o]n( jk d]u ` j`a aop]_ekj]noa u ]`ai o oa `ao) lnaj`a qj khkn ] ]cq]o jacn]o mqa ] j]`ea oa ha ]jpkf] mqa`]noa ] _kian7 p]i^e j ia lnak_ql] mqa oa aop j bkni]j`k aop]j) mqao `a ]cq] mqa ]qiajp]j h] lkoe^ehe`]` `a mqa oa `ao]nnkhha

ah iko_k `ah `ajcqaÏ( atlhe_ aj ajpnareop] l]n] IEHAJEK ?KHEI=* Hko ra_ejko `ah V]h]p j aolan]j mqa h] k^n] `a ejop]h]_e j `a pq) ^an ]o panieja ] h] ^nara`]` l]n] mqa pk`k rqahr] ] h] jkni]he`]`( _kj ah ^ajaÚ_ek ] ]`e`k `a mqa( aj r]neko ] ko( jk rkhran j ] pajan lnk^hai]o _kj h] na` `a `naj]fa u ]h_]jp]nehh]`k*.D

BW YWcfW W li Z[d]k[ [d 9eb_cW i[h| c|i _dj[diW 9eb_cW38c\o :XiYXaXc 9\iY\i

.

]n ] I]npd] C]n_ ] H]neko( nace`kn] _]lep]hej] `ah LNE u lnaoe`ajp] `a h] ?kieoe j `a O]hq` aj ah _]^eh`k( ]Úni mqa _kj h] ejpaj_e j `a mqa oa lnarajc] ah ]qiajpk `a _]oko `a `ajcqa aj h] _eq`]`( aj ln tei]o ba_d]o d]n j ^nec]`]o aola_e]hao l]n] arep]n mqa d]u] hqc]nao `kj`a oa lqa`] lnkl]c]n aop] ajbania`]`* ÎL]n] ]uq`]n ] h] _eq`]`]j ] l]n] mqa oa lnarajc] `ah `ajcqa aop] pai) lkn]`] mqa oa reaja bqanpa aj hko ln te) iko iaoao lkn ah _]hkn( oa pn]^]f]n aj amqelk _kj hko _kiep o `a ^]nneko `a h]o vkj]o nqn]hao u `a h] _]lep]h( `a ecq]h bkni] ] pk`]o h]o _kkn`ej]`kn]o `a h] o]hq`( aj `kj`a oa d] ikopn]`k ejpan o `a h] _eq`]`]j ]Ï* Atlhe_ mqa aj h] ]_pq]he`]`( `a^e`k ] h]o hhqre]o na_eajpao( h] vkj] kneajpa ao h] i o ]ba_p]`] Î`kj`a aop h] _khkje] Hko Ien]`knao `a h] ?qi^na( H v]nk ? n`aj]o u H] Aop]j_e]( jk k^op]jpa ah lnk^hai] `ah `ajcqa aop _kjpnk) h]`k( lknmqa jk d]u ej`e_]`knao `a qj ej_naiajpk aj ahhkÏ* Aj ah iqje_elek( `efk( Îd]u 3, _]o]o _ann]`]o( ]^]j`kj]`]o aj h] vkj] kneajpa mqa nalnaoajp]j bk) _ko `a ejba__e j( lkn hk mqa oa aop ejrep]j`k ] hko ra_ejko ] ejbkni]n ok^na h] e`ajpeÚ_]_e j `a aopa pelk `a _]o]o( l]n] hhar]n ] _]^k ]__ekjao l]n] ann]`e_]n lkn _kilhapk `e_dko bk_ko `a ejba__e jÏ* Lkn aopko ikperko( h] _kiqj] _]lep]hej] knc]jev]n ] lnej_eleko `a i]nvk qj] jqar] Î_]il] ] `a `ao_]_d]nnev]_e j( aj _kkn`ej]_e j _kj ah Ck^eanjk `ah Aop]`k( ] pn]r o `a h] Oa_nap]n ] `a O]hq`Ï* =`ai o( oa ejrep]n ] h] lk^h]_e j aj cajan]h ] mqa `aoikjpaj hko hkpao ^]h` ko* Aj aopa ieoik pajkn( h] nace`kn] _]lep]hej] `efk mqa aop]n j heile]j`k hko n ko `a h] _]lep]h( lqao `af aj _h]nk mqa oej ah ]lkuk u h] l]npe_el]_e j `a h] cajpa jk oa lqa`a ]r]jv]n aj aopa lnk^hai] `a `ajcqa* C]n_ ] H]neko ]cnac mqa p]i^e j d]u qj lnkcn]i] _]haj`]nev]`k `q) n]jpa pk`k ah ] k( Îl]n] nareo]n mq _kiqje`]`ao lnaoajp]j lnk^hai]o `a `ajcqa u na]hev]n h]^knao `a ]^]pev]_e j( aj `kj`a l]npe_el]n j pn]^]f]`knao `ah =uqjp]ieajpk u hko h `anao `a _]`] _khkje] u] aop j ajpan]`koÏ* =qjmqa ah `ajcqa ao qjk `a hko lnk^hai]o `a o]hq` mqa i o oa `a^aj arep]n( d]u kpnk pelk `a lnk^hai ) pe_]o mqa r]j ] ]paj`an( ] lape_e j `ah ]h_]h`a Ecj]_ek Lan]hp] O j_dav( mqeaj Înaol]h`] ] hko nace`knao l]n] mqa ahhko oec]j _qe`]j`k h] o]hq` `a h] _]lep]hÏ( `efk* Ejbkni mqa Îoa aop _kjbkni]`k qj lnkua_pk p]i^e j l]n] pn]^]f]n aj h] a`q_]_e j ]heiajpe_e] `a hko je ko pk`k ah ] k( l]n] mqa pajc]j qj] iafkn jqpne_e j u _kj ahhk `eo) iejqen hko j`e_ao `a k^aoe`]`( mqa pn]aj _kjoeck lnk^hai]o ] h]nck lh]) vk `a `e]^apao a delanpajoe j* Aopa lnkcn]i] oa `]n ] _kjk_an aj hko ln teiko ` ]oÏ( ]_h]n *.D

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

$PMJNB

BW 7I< Z[j[Yj gk[ [b ]eX_[hde \[Z[hWb j_[d[ kd ikX[`[hY_Y_e Z[ ** c_b cZf

>_bZW 9[XWbbei Yh_j_YW bW efWY_ZWZ gk[ ^Wo [d [b ]eX_[hde \[Z[hWb BW Z_fkjWZW fh__ijW

bWc[djW gk[ 9WbZ[h d ^WoW [d]W WZe W bW feXbWY_ d Z[ C n_Ye BW [n fh_c[hW ZWcW

Z_`e gk[ f[Z_h| gk[ ^WoW jhWdifWh[dY_W fWhW _dl[ij_]Wh [b YWie 9eb_cW3?\`[` [\ C\ e >lk` ii\q

>_bZW 9[XWbbei Bb[h[dWi [i Z_fkjWZW fbkh_dec_dWb \[Z[hWb Z[b FH?

Feh bWi eXi[hlWY_ed[i ^[Y^Wi Wb [ijWZe Z[ 9eb_cW

;b FH? Z[iYWhjW gk[ bW 7I< iWdY_ed[ W [n \kdY_edWh_ei I;H=?E 9;HL7DJ;I

9eb_cW3?C>

&

h `enecajpa aop]p]h `ah LNE( I]np j Bhknao ?]op] a`]( `ao_]np mqa ]hc j bqj_ek) j]nek `a h] l]o]`] ]`iejeopn]_e j _]r]_eop] lqa`] oan o]j_ekj]`k lkn h]o k^oanr]_ekjao `a 4. iehhkjao `a laoko mqa h] =q`epkne] Oqla) nekn `a h] Ba`an]_e j $=OB% `apa_p aj hko nq^nko `a o]hq`( oacqne`]` l ^he_] a ejbn]aopnq_pqn]* Ah h `an lneeop] ]oacqn mqa pk`]o h]o k^oanr]_ekjao mqa oa d]j da_dk ] hko na_qnoko ba`an]) hao mqa afan_e ?khei] aj .,,4 oan j okhrajp]`ko oej i]uknao lnk^hai]o( p]h u _kik hk ejbkni ah ck^anj]`kn I]nek =jcqe]jk Iknajk* I]np j Bhknao ?]op] a`] oa ]h mqa h]o k^oanr]_ekjao oa ]paj`a) n j aj peailk u bkni]( u aj hko /, ` ]o mqa i]n_] h] =q`epkne] Oqlanekn `a h] Ba`an]_e j $=OB% l]n] okhrajp]nh]o( oa aop]n d]) _eaj`k* Ah lneeop]( i]jebaop mqa jk peaja jejcqj] `q`] `a mqa h]o _ko]o mqa`]n j _h]n]o aj _q]jpk ] hko na_qnoko ba`an]hao mqa afan_e ?khei] aj .,,4* Ah reanjao oa ejbkni mqa h]o ]qpkne`]`ao `ah ck^eanjk aop]p]h d]^n ]j lnkrk_]`k qj `] k ] h] D]_eaj`] l ^he_] ba`an]h lkn qj ikjpk `a 4. iehhkjao `a laoko(

CWhj d <beh[" b Z[h [ijWjWb jh_Yebeh o hk aj hko nq^nko `a oacqne`]` l ^he_]( o]hq` u k^n]o `qn]jpa ah lanek`k Úo_]h mqa _knnaolkj`a ]h afan_e_ek .,,4* =o hk narah ah ejbknia `a naoqh) p]`ko `a h] Úo_]hev]_e j oqlanekn `a h] _qajp] l ^he_] .,,4( ah]^k) n]`k lkn h] =q`epkn ] Oqlanekn `a h] Ba`an]_e j $=OB% `a h] ? i]n] `a @elqp]`ko( _kj ^]oa aj h]o na) reoekjao _kjp]^hao ln]_pe_]`]o ]h afan_e_ek `a hko n]iko ./ u // aj h]o ajpe`]`ao ba`an]per]o* Ah ieoik reanjao( ah ck^an) j]`kn I]nek =jcqe]jk Ikna) jk lqjpq]hev mqa h] =OB d]_a k^oanr]_ekjao ]`iejeopn]per]o u aj jejc j _]ok oa ]h] mqa dq^k `aore `a na_qnoko lkn l]npa `a ]hc j bqj_ekj]nek* .D

] `elqp]`] ba`an]h lneeop] Deh`] ?a^]hhko Hhanaj]o( _ne) pe_ ah oq^afan_e_ek k_qhpk `ah ck^eanjk ba`an]h lkn 00 ieh 1/0 laoko mqa `apa_p h] =q`epkne] Oqlanekn `a h] Ba`an]_e j $=OB%( u ]oacqn mqa aop]n receh]j`k mqa oa _qilh] _kj h] pn]jol]naj_e] u oa Újmqaj naolkjo]^ehe`]`ao* Aj nqa`] `a lnajo] aj h] oa`a aop]p]h `ah oq l]npe`k( h] haceoh])

`kn] `ah pne_khkn( h]iajp mqa ah lnaoe`ajpa Bahela ?]h`an j ha d]u] iajpe`k ] h] lk^h]_e j `e_eaj`k mqa ah ck^eanjk ba`an]h jk paj ] na_qnoko oqÚ_eajpao l]n] _kiln]n h]o r]_qj]o _kjpn] h] ejÛqajv] dqi]j]( eilqho]n ah ailhak k _ki^]pen h] lk^nav]( _q]j`k paj ] qj oq^afan_e_ek mqa u] bqa `apa_) p]`k lkn h] =OB* Ej`e_ mqa ah k_qhp]n ejbkni]) _e j p]i^e j ao _knnql_e j( ok^na pk`k _q]j`k ?]h`an j le`e ah ]lkuk l]n] ej_naiajp]n hko eilqaopko aj aopa ] k( u] mqa( oac j `efk( o] an] h] je_] i]jan] l]n] k^pajan na_qnoko Új]j_eanko mqa ha lan) iepean]j okhrajp]n hko lnk^hai]o mqa paj ] ah l] o* Î=dkn] aop]iko reaj`k mqa ateopa kl]_e`]` aj ah i]jafk `a hko na_qnoko( _kjoe`ank mqa aop] ejbkni]_e j mqa oa d] `]`k ] _kjk_an ao qj] dqiehh]_e j l]n] ah lqa^hk `a I te_k( lknmqa d]u iq_dk `aoailhak u ah ck^eanjk lnaÚana pajan qj oq^afan_e_ek aj

rav `a ejranpen aoa `ejank aj ah `ao]nnkhhk `ah l] oÏ( `efk* H] =OB nalknp mqa aj .,,4( hko /1/ bkj`ko u Ú`ae_kieoko naceopn]`ko lkn D]_eaj`] paj ]j `eolkje^ehe`]`ao Új]j_ean]o ]_qiqh]`]o lkn 1,1 314 iehhkjao `a laoko( hk mqa oecjeÚ_ qj ej_naiajp `ah 10 lkn _eajpk aj _kil]n]_e j _kj hko /.3 ieh iehhkjao mqa pqreankj aj .,,3* H] =q`epkn ]( `aop]_ mqa h] `eo) _na_ekj]he`]` `a hko bqj_ekj]neko l ^he_ko aj ah i]jafk `a hko na_qn) oko oa `apa_p aj h] ]lhe_]_e j `a hko at_a`ajpao lnaoqlqaop]hao( ah kpknc]ieajpk `a `kj]perko( aop ) iqhko Úo_]hao( lanieoko( _kj_a) oekjao u he_aj_e]o* Lkn oq l]npa ah `enecajpa aop]p]h `ah LNE( I]np j Bhknao ?]op] a`]( `efk mqa ah `ejank `ah oq^afan_e_ek oa lq`k d]^an qpehev]`k aj h] _]il] ] lkh pe_] `a .,,5* Le`e ] pk`ko hko `elqp]`ko ba`an]hao lkn ?khei] mqa oa qj]j ] la`en pn]jol]naj_e] Îlank `kj`a `a^a `a oan( aj h] ? i]n] `a `elqp]`koÏ( _kj_hqu *.D

"DFOUPT

PQJOJuO

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

;IF;H=;I?7 87?B787 7l[b_de = c[p =kpc|d 9eb_cW

%PT CVFOBT EFDMBSBDJPOFT

;i YWi_ i[# ]khe gk[ [d bei fh n_cei )& Z Wi CWh_e ^WXh| Z[ Yed# l[hj_hi[ [d [b YedjWZeh fWhj_YkbWh Z[ I_bl[h_e 9W# lWpei0 j_[d[ gk[ YkWZhWh# b[ bWi Yk[djWi ik Wc_]Wpe

* = `a_en `ah ck^anj]`kn I]nek =jcqe]) jk( h]o k^oanr]_ekjao mqa h] =q`epkn ] Oqlanekn `a h] Beo_]hev]_e j devk ]h ck^eanjk `a Oehranek ?]r]vko lk`n j oan oq^o]j]`]o aj ]laj]o qj nahej_dk* Hko 4. iehhkjao `a laoko( lnkrajeajpao `a lnk) cn]i]o ba`an]hao u mqa oqlqaop]iajpa bqankj i]h afan_e`ko `qn]jpa .,,4( jk oecjebe_]j cn]j _ko] l]n] I]nek =jcqe]jk* Lk`n ]j oan annknao Î]`iejeopn]perkoÏ( `efk( oqo_alpe^hao `a oan ]_h]n]`ko aj hko /, ` ]o `a lh]vk* Aok oqaj] ^eaj6 ia l]na_a mqa aopk `a^an ] `]njko pn]jmqe) he`]` u( ok^na pk`k( h] _kjbe]jv] `a mqa( aj aba_pk( jqaopnk at bqa ej_]l]v `a `] ]n h] D]_eaj`] L ^he_]* Oe jqaopnk ]_pq]h ck^anj]`kn `e_a mqa oq Îdan) i]jkÏ Oehranek ao ^eaj Îl n]pa)_] jÏ( lqao d]u mqa _naan) ha* Na_kn`aiko mqa I]nek =jcqe]jk( ]`ai o `a pajan h]

<; O IE9?;:7: ;dh_gk[ 9WcWY^e L[bWiYe 9eb_cW

1PS TBMVE NFOUBM

/

k d]_a b]hp] oan qj atlanpk aj @ao]) nnkhhk Dqi]jk l]n] _kjraj_anjko `a mqa aj aop] re`] ah oa_napk `a jqao) pnk tepk aop aj h] d]^ehe`]` l]n] nah]_ekj]n) jko a ejpan]_pq]n _kj h]o lanokj]o `a bkni] _knna_p] u abe_]v* Jk ao b _eh `abejen hk mqa ao o]hq` iajp]h u] mqa ah dki^na( ] hk h]nck `a oq deopkne]( d] ^qo_]`k lkn pk`ko hko ia`eko i]jpajan ah amqehe^nek `a oq lanokj]he`]`* =hcqjko loe_ hkcko `abejaj h] o]hq` iajp]h _kik h] _]l]_e`]` `a ]`]lp]_e j `a hko oanao dqi]jko ]h iqj`k u ] h]o lanokj]o _kj qj i teik `a abe_]_e] u bahe_e`]`7 u mqa ateopaj _q]pnk _nepaneko `a o]hq` iajp]h6 ]_pepq`ao bnajpa ]h uk( _kjp]_pk _kj h] na]he`]`( ejpacn]_e j `a h] lanokj]he`]` u ]`]lp]_e j ]h ia`ek*

;ijWh Y[d# jhWZe [d bei Z[c|i i_]# d_\_YW ^WX[h Wfh[dZ_Ze W jhWjWh W jeZe [b ckdZe Yece W kd ^[hcWde e ^[hcWdW [d [ij[ ckdZe dk[ijhe

atpn] ] u r]j] d]^ehe`]` l]n] d]_an ^]eh]n qj _]^]hhk( p]i^e j ao iqu ]lhe_]`k aj h]o _qaopekjao _kjp]^hao* Lkn aok ao _]oe oacqnk mqa aj hko ln teiko /, ` ]o I]nek d]^n `a _kjranpenoa aj ah _kjp]`kn l]npe_qh]n `a Oehra) nek ?]r]vko6 peaja mqa _q]`n]nha h]o _qajp]o oq ]iec]vk* =o mqa( lkn qj iao( ao lnk^]^ha mqa jk pajc]iko ck^anj]`kn aj bqj_ekjao* U aok oecjebe_] mqa lkn aoa h]lok jk hk ranaiko aj _]^]hc]p]o( pnal]`k aj oq beah _]^]hhk ]h]v j hq_ank* ½H opei] .* Ah ]h_]h`a Ecj]_ek Lan]hp] O j_dav peaja lnk^hai]o l]n] `eo_anjen ok^na lnk) ^hai pe_]o ok_e]hao* =jpa h] ej_]l]_e`]` l]n] atlhe_]noa k atlhe_]n ] hko `ai o ah ]oqjpk `a h]o ^]h]_an]o aj lhajk _ajpnk `a h] _eq`]`( Lan]hp] O j_dav a_d] i]jk `a pakn ]o ] af]o u oqlkoe_ekjao pkjp]o* D]_a `ko ` ]o `a_h]n ( _kik aj oq ikiajpk hk de_ean] jqaopnk ejpahecajpa u dkjaopk at ck) ^anj]`kn( Oehranek ?]r]vko( mqa ao Îh] cajpa `a bqan] $mqeaj% reaja u _kiapa aoko da_dko `ahe_perkoÏ* ¼Oa oqlkja mqa aok `a^a oan qj _kjoqahk l]n] hko _kheiajoao; ¼Lk`aiko pki]n oqo l]h]^n]o _kik qj] `a_h]n]_e j kbe_e]h l]n] `ao_kjbe]n `a pk`k ]mq h mqa

pajc] b]_d] `a bqana k; Ecj]_ek( ]h ecq]h mqa Oehranek( d] `a lajo]n mqa hk lnabane^ha ao _ann]n jqaopn]o bnkjpan]o aop]p]hao u jk laniepen h] ajpn]`] `a j]`ea( ]o jk paj`n ]) iko lnk^hai]o `a ejoacqne`]`* ?kik r]( ia paik mqa Ecj]_ek paniej]n `af j`koa ah ^eckpepk ]h aopehk Pa_ki j* Lkn hk `ai o( _kj aopa pelk `a `a_h]n]_ekjao Lan]hp] _knna ah neack `a mqa hk pkiaj lkn qj ck^anj]jpa pkjpk* U ia l]na_a mqa ah pelk iana_a i o mqa aok $o ( sd]paran%* &=lnkra_dk aopa aol]_ek l]n] bahe_ep]n ] h] lanek`eop] Chaj`] He^ean I]`nec]h( mqeaj bqa oaha__ekj]`] l]n] k_ql]n ah _]nck `a rk_an] `ah Ejopepqpk Ba`an]h Aha_pkn]h* H] _]l]_e`]` u lnkbaoekj]heoik `a Chaj`] mqa` `a i]jebeaopk `qn]jpa ah lnk_aok `a oaha__e j* Chaj`] jk o hk ao qj] `a h]o iafknao lanek`eop]o `a ?khei]( p]i^e j ao `qa ] `a qj] lkopqn] pe_] ennalnk_d]^ha* U ao j]pqn]h mqa h]o klknpqje`]`ao h]^kn]hao oa ha ]^n]j ] ]hcqeaj _kik ahh]* R]u]( oq aop]pqn] lnkbaoekj]h ao p]j ]hp]( mqa _kiajp]neop]o `a ¼h] p]hh]; `a I]t ?knp o atde^eankj oqo _kilhafko `a ejbanekne`]` ]h d]_an ^annej_dao l ^he_ko ok^na hko hkcnko `a h] lanek`eop]* L]n] `ao]heajpk `a hko jeieko( iq_dko lk) `aiko d]^h]n i o ]hpk u iafkn naola_pk ] h] _]nnan] lnkbaoekj]h u _]he`]` dqi]j] `a Chaj`]* .

Ah lqjpk `a l]npe`] oan o]^an ejpan]_) pq]n _kj hko `ai o* Lknmqa ejpan]__e j oecjebe_] ]i]n u oan ]i]`k( `]n u na_e^en( ao_q_d]n u naolkj`an* U( ah je_k namqeoepk l]n] ]h_]jv]n qj] nah]_e j lhaj] u ]qp j) pe_] _kjoeopa aj hhar]n qj] re`] _ajpn]`] aj hko `ai o( qj] re`] mqa cena aj pknjk ] h]o lanokj]o( jk ajpknjk ] h]o _ko]o( je oemqean] hko e`a]hao* Qj] _h]ra l]n] o]^an oe _ajpn]iko jqaopnk lajo]ieajpk u jqaopn]o ]__ekjao aj h]o lanokj]o( ao oe pajaiko qj] k r]ne]o `a h]o oecqeajpao _q]he`]`ao k r]hk) nao6 `aoejpan o( dqieh`]`( _kil]oe j( lnak_ql]) _e j( ail]p ]*** Iq_d]o ra_ao aop]iko aj qj hqc]n l ^he_k( hh iaoa _eja( pa]pnk( echaoe]( ]q) pk^ o( ap_ pan]7 u lk`aiko aop]n oajp]`ko _an_] `a iq_d]o lanokj]o u jk _nqv]iko l]h]) ^n]* U oej ai^]nck p]j oaj_ehhk mqa lqa`a oan o]hq`]n( k qj] okjneo] ]h `ao_kjk_e`k mqa pa) jaiko _k`k _kj _k`k* Mqev oa _kjreanp] aj qj cn]j ]ieck* = hk h]nck `a jqaopn]o re`]o jko jac]iko ] lnkikran ah _kil] aneoik lkn _qaope j `a kncqhhk k iea`k*

Aop]n _ajpn]`k aj hko `ai o oecjebe_] d]^an ]lnaj`e`k ] pn]p]n ] pk`k ah iqj`k _kik ] qj dani]jk k dani]j] aj aopa iqj`k jqaopnk* L]n] hkcn]n aopk `a^aiko pajan qj oajpeieajpk `a bn]panje`]`* H] dqi]je`]` ao qj] cn]j b]iehe] aj h] mqa jqaopnko ra_ejko okj jqaopnko dani]jko( oa]j _q]hao oa]j oq _khkn( _na`k( j]_ekj]he`]`( aopn]pk ok_e]h( _kjre__ekjao u lna) k_ql]_ekjao* Qj ]qpkn ]j jeik ao_ne^e 6 Jk eilknp] hk cn]j`a mqa oa] pq _]o]( hk mqa eilknp] ao hk ]_kca`kn] mqa naoqhpa ] hko ]iecko mqa l]oaj ]hh h] p]n`a* Jk h] fqvc]n j lkn oq `a_kn]_e j oejk lkn ah p]i] k `a pq _kn]v j* Je h] cn]j`av] `a pq p]hajpk( je h] ejiajoe`]` `a pqo nemqav]o pa `]n j h] bahe_e`]`* Oan o `e_dkok oe d]_ao bahev ] h] cajpa _kj h] mqa pn]p]o* C]j]n `ejank jk ao `eb _eh( lank o]^an reren ao pk`k qj ]npa* ? ik pa mqa) nn j( _ ik pa ]lna_e]n j hko `ai o `alaj`a `ah p]i] k `a pq _kn]v j * .

domingo 21 de Febrero de 2010

NUESTRA SALUD MENTAL

Moisés Rozanes Tassler

Luis Petersen Farah

Colima

La escuela del “no se puede”

Feliz, feliz no cumpleaños

N

o dijo nada nuevo. “Redescubrió la rueda”, comentaba alguien en internet. Y es cierto, no será nuevo, pero lo dice la ONU en la voz de su relator especial sobre el derecho a la educación, Vernor Muñoz Villalobos. Fue claro, más claro que lo que comúnmente oímos: el SNTE está más metido de lo que debe en las decisiones del sistema educativo, dijo. Manda y estorba. La relación “inexplicable y no recomendable” entre el sindicato y la SEP impide que alguien se haga realmente responsable de la escuela en México. Claro que lo sabemos, tanto que hasta nos hemos acostumbrado. En esta mezcla de direcciones, la escuela mexicana carece de intencionalidad. Si hace falta formar y seleccionar mejores maestros, no se puede. Si hace falta recortar la brecha entre la educación pública y la privada, o entre la escuela urbana y la rural, no se puede. Si hace falta mejorar la capacidad de lectura de nuestros escolares, no se puede; o la capacidad para plantear problemas, o las habilidades matemáticas, de cualquier manera no se puede. Si se trata de mejorar las condiciones de vida con educación, no se puede. Parece que el moroso sistema educativo tiene suficiente con mantenerse en pie, y mientras tanto el “no se puede” se convierte en la enseñanza básica para los niños de México. Ya sabemos también que los grandes desafíos de la educación se reducen como mandamientos a dos: dejar de ofrecer una educación pobre a los pobres y elevar la calidad en todos los niveles escolares y grupos de población. Y sabemos, todos sabemos, que la Alianza por la calidad de la educación naufragó en las aguas de la política, que no fue producto de “una discusión abierta ni pareciera responder a un acuerdo ciudadano”, como denunció Muñoz. El relator, que dio una rueda de prensa antes de terminar su visita al país, presentará en junio su informe definitivo. Dirá tal vez lo mismo y de nuevo no pasará nada, pues cualquier movimiento tendría, como siempre, claras consecuencias electorales. Por lo pronto, lo que dijo ya tuvo respuesta del SNTE: ¡Cómo! ¡Si ellos son “pioneros en democracia sindical”. Si alguien se ha distinguido por estar a la altura es el SNTE, dijo su secretario general. Con lo cual sólo confirma la crítica. Nada nuevo, tampoco. Pero ojalá al menos la de la ONU sea una presión más para que maestros y papás tengan una idea de que pueden aspirar a mucho más. Y que lo exijan para los educandos. pm luis.petersen@milenio.com

GRUPO EDITORIAL MILENIO FRANCISCO A. GONZÁLEZ FRANCISCO D. GONZÁLEZ A. JESÚS D. GONZÁLEZ A. CARLOS MARÍN CIRO GÓMEZ LEYVA HUGO CHAPA GAMBOA VALERIA GONZÁLEZ RAFAEL OCAMPO ROSA ESTHER JUÁREZ CARLOS BENÍTEZ

(+) JESÚS D. GONZÁLEZ FUNDADOR PRESIDENTE PEDRO GONZÁLEZ DIRECTOR ADMINISTRATIVO Y FINANZAS DIRECTOR GENERAL JAVIER CHAPA DIRECTOR DE NEGOCIOS DIRECTOR GENERAL ADJUNTO ADRIANA OBREGÓN DIRECTORA COMERCIAL DIRECTOR GENERAL EDITORIAL LUIS REZA DIRECTOR RELACIONES INSTITUCIONALES DIRECTOR EDITORIAL ADJUNTO ANÍBAL ABARCA DIRECTOR INTERNET DIRECTOR EJECUTIVO MAURICIO MORALESDIRECTOR DESARROLLO CORPORATIVO DIRECTORA CREATIVA FERNANDO RUIZ DIRECTOR PRODUCCIÓN SUBDIRECTOR EDITORIAL ADRIÁN LOAIZA DIRECTOR SISTEMAS DIRECTORA ENLACE EDITORIAL ÁNGEL CONG DIRECTOR SERVICIOS CORPORATIVOS DIRECTOR SOFT NEWS MARCO A. ZAMORA DIRECTOR PROYECTOS ESPECIALES MIGUEL ÁNGEL VARGAS DIRECTOR PROYECTOS EDITORIALES

MILENIO COLIMA

BERNARDO CORVERA HÉCTOR BARBA SÁNCHEZ

DIRECTOR DIR. DE OPERACIONES

HEIDI DE LEÓN GUTIÉRREZ JEFATURA DE MARIANO APARICIO COORD. FOTOGRAFÍA MARIO ALBERTO SOLÍS ESPINOSA INFORMACIÓN IRERI GONZÁLEZ CÁRDENAS DISEÑO JOSUÉ SOLÍS HERNANDEZ JEFE DE CIERRE ALEX CARBAJAL BERBER LA AFICIÓN FRANCISCO GARDUÑO IRENE SELSER/HORACIO BESSON HORACIO SALAZAR

NACIONAL FRONTERAS TENDENCIAS

MARÍA ISABEL MELCHOR MIGUEL ÁNGEL ARRITOLA

PUBLICACIONES MILENIO ROBERTA GARZA JAVIER SEPÚLVEDA JAIME BARRERA MA. EUGENIA GONZÁLEZ MARCELA MORENO DIANA MANCILLA PABLO CÉSAR CARRILLO GABRIEL PÉREZ

M SEMANAL MONTERREY GUADALAJARA TAMPICO TORREÓN ESTADO DE MÉXICO LEÓN HIDALGO

TELÉFONO

NEGOCIOS

HEY!

TELÉFONOS CONMUTADOR SUSCRIPCIONES REDACCIÓN FAX PUBLICIDAD ATENCIÓN A CLIENTES

5140-4900 5140-4999 5140-4982 5140-4903, 5140-4904 5140-2950 5140-4999

31 632 70

Milenio Colima, Publicación Diaria • año 4 • No. 1426. Febrero 21, 2010 • Número de Certificado de Reserva otorgado por el Instituto Nacional de Derechos de Autor: en trámite. • Número de Certificado de Licitud de Contenido: en trámite • Número de Certificado de Licitud de Título: en trámite • Otorgados por la Comisión Calificadora de Publicaciones y Revistas Ilustradas de la Secretaría de Gobernación • Publicado y distribuido por periódico MILENIO DIARIO S.A. de C.V. • Domicilio de la Impresión y Publicación: Avena No. 17, Col. Granjas Esmeralda, C.P. 09810, México D.F. • Tels: 54-45-29-89 • Distribución Unión Nacional de Expendedores de Periódicos de México • Precio: $ 5.00 • El contenido de los artículos es responsabilidad exclusiva de los autores • Todos los derechos están reservados • Queda prohibida la reproducción parcial o total del material publicado sin consentimiento por escrito de los editores • La información contenida ha sido obtenida de fuentes que se consideran fidedignas.

He encontrado lo que tienen en común una buena columna de periódico y el amor—me dijo. –¿Qué? –Tanto el amor como la columna periodística deben satisfacernos en el momento, pero la belleza y la fuerza de ambos se miden por su capacidad de no dejar nuestra mente. El museo de la inocencia, Orhan Pamuk (2009)

S

obre el fondo oscuro del espeso chocolate aparecía, en altorrelieve y en cursivas de merengue, una simple e inocente palabra: Felicidades . La llama titubeante y solitaria de una vela diminuta, situada en un improbable centro geométrico, resumía el fin de su tercera década de existencia. En ese instante se detuvo a reflexionar sobre el carácter excesivamente dramático, aunque en apariencia trivial y acelerado, de los recientes acontecimientos. Algunos días después (en circunstancias en las que resultaba imposible saber, no digamos precisar, el tiempo transcurrido) descubrió que le faltaban las dos últimas letras al mensaje desiderativo original, por lo que sobre la cremosa superficie, dulce y amargosa a la vez, quedaba -vulnerable y a la deriva- la palabra: Felicidad. Sin saber bien por qué, el inesperado descubrimiento comenzó a producirle un punzante malestar en la boca del estómago. Casi de inmediato, se vio a sí misma -desde una neblinosa distancia- avanzando cuchillo en mano y movida por un extraño e inapelable impulso. De pronto se detuvo y dando un grito brutal y desgarrador se lanzó con todas sus fuerzas a destajar tan solo una minúscula rebanada de su pastel de cumpleaños. El llanto incontenible y una sofocante sensación de vacío en el pecho la despertaron en medio de la noche. No habían pasado siquiera dos semanas desde el accidente carretero. El hombre con quien, desde varios años atrás tenía cifrado el porvenir, había muerto de la manera más estúpida e inexplicable que cualquiera pudiera imaginarse. El automóvil fue encontrado prácticamente sin huellas del impacto. Parecía como si nada hubiera ocurrido ahí, como si nadie siquiera se hubiera rasguñado. Nadie lograba explicar la manera en que salió proyectado por el parabrisas.

“En una ocasión leí que en realidad nadie sabe que está viviendo el momento más feliz de su vida mientras lo vive”

opinión 13

A escasos días de la boda, por motivos de trabajo, él tuvo nuevamente que viajar como tantas otras veces durante el largo y complicado noviazgo. Esta vez, sin embargo, ella no volvería a verlo jamás. Al menos no como seguía recordándolo en algún lugar de su mente, como un hombre joven vivo y entusiasta-, de quien tanto se había enamorado. Ella ahora está por descubrir que por ser una de las escasas enfermeras especializadas, asignada a una de las áreas más delicadas del hospital general, deberá mantener su intenso ritmo de actividad como quien se aferra a una pieza flotante en la mitad del océano. Las veces en que se ha sentido más agobiada por la reciente pérdida, pero sobre todo cuando más solitaria e incomprendida se ha descubierto, ante demandas absurdas de fortaleza por parte de aquellos -que al querer protegerla- sólo consiguen ahondar su pesadumbre, ha comprobado que son precisamente esas prolongadas horas de trabajo los momentos en que su mente logra descansar y hallar algo de sosiego. –En una ocasión leí—decía la enfermera con aquella intensidad en la mirada que únicamente concede el dolor inexplicable—que en realidad nadie sabe que está viviendo el momento más feliz de su vida mientras lo vive. Una de las tareas más desafiantes para los psiquiatras en realidad no es tanto el diagnosticar y tratar a personas con enfermedad mental, sino más bien saber distinguir entre un auténtico trastorno psiquiátrico (depresión severa) y una condición donde el sufrimiento y malestar intensos son una respuesta lógica y necesaria de seres humanos “normales”, ante las situaciones terribles e inesperadas de la vida (proceso de duelo). La enfermera fue llevada al servicio de urgencias por sus familiares. La nota ponía que la paciente no dejaba de sollozar y el diagnóstico de ingreso fue “Depresión con riesgo suicida”. Se solicitaba a la mayor brevedad consulta con psiquiatría y “para no perder tiempo”, se habían prescrito ya tranquilizantes y antidepresivos. –Al dar la primera mordida en el trozo de pastel que decía Felicidad me detuve sobresaltada. Como si fuera una “Alicia” desconcertada no pude dejar de preguntarme sobre el significado de mis deseos. ¿Acaso al comer ese trozo de pastel estaría facilitando el regreso a la normalidad, volverían los días felices, la felicidad interrumpida a consecuencia de la muerte de mi novio?, o por el contrario, ¿en el momento de incorporar en mi cuerpo, en un proceso natural de digestión, aquel pedazo oscuro y amargo de pastel, la única cuota de felicidad disponible, sería consumir para siempre la última porción de alegría y optimismo que aún quedaban en mi vida? A final de cuentas la pregunta que me hacía era pavorosamente sencilla: ¿Y ahora, qué voy hacer? Dígamelo ya. ¿Acaso la psiquiatría no sirve para eso? p rozanes@prodigy.net.mx

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

/BDJPOBM

P

;Z_jeh0 'SBODJTDP (BSEVtP feb j_YW6c_b[d_eZ_Wh_e$Yec$cn

H;Dx IEJE%7H9>?LE

C n_Ye3I\[XZZ` e

&

j .,,5 ah `ahepk `a h] len]pan ] cajan c]j]j_e]o lkn 30 ieh 255 iehhkjao `a ` ) h]nao( mqa eilhe_]j 5 lkn _eajpk `ah lnk`q_pk ej) panjk ^nqpk( `a ]_qan`k _kj h] pan_an] Aj_qaop] `a d ^epko `a _kjoqik `a lnk`q_pko len]) p] u b]hoebe_]_e j aj I te_k `a h] ? i]n] =iane_]j] `a ?kian_ek* Aop] ]_pere`]`( ]beni ah `elq) p]`k lanna`eop] =npqnk O]jp]j] =hb]nk( _na_e Îej`eo_neiej]`]) iajpa oej mqa h] ]qpkne`]` lqa`] naranpen aop] oepq]_e j( ]qj _q]j`k oa d]j hhar]`k ] _]^k `eranoko klan]perko l]n] _ki^]pen hko `a) hepko mqa ]pajp]j _kjpn] h] Hau Ba`an]h `a @ana_dko `a =qpkn u h] Lnklea`]` Ejpaha_pq]hÏ* Nabene mqa `a ]_qan`k _kj h] Lnk_qn]`qn ] Cajan]h `a h] Nal ) ^he_]( ]hcqj]o `a h]o ik`]he`]`ao `a aopa `ahepk oa d]j ej_naiaj) p]`k d]op] -/- lkn _eajpk `a qj ] k ] kpnk( Îhk mqa jko laniepa k^oanr]n mqa h]o laj]he`]`ao mqa oa aj_qajpn]j aop]^ha_e`]o d]o) p] aopa ikiajpk jk ejde^aj aj ]^okhqpk ]h `ahej_qajpaÏ* Aj h] cn]j i]ukn ] `a hko klan]perko aj hko mqa oa _]pa] _q]hmqean aol]_ek aj ah mqa ]oacqn]j ian_]j_ ] len]p] k hko ejopnqiajpko _kj hko mqa h] nalnk`q_aj( jk oa hhar]j ] _]^k `apaj_ekjao( lknmqa jk oa d]hh] lanokj] ]hcqj] aj ah hqc]n k lkn jk _kjp]n _kj hko na_qnoko dqi]jko ja_ao]neko l]n] ]qtehe]n ] hko ]cajpao `ah Iejeopanek L ^he_k( oa ]h * Î=`ai o `a mqa aopko `ahepko oa paj`n ]j mqa i]jaf]n aj oa_na_ ] l]n] arep]n h] bqc] `a ejbkni]) _e jÏ( ]oacqn ah `elqp]`k* Lkn p]jpk( l]n] pn]p]n `a bnaj]n aopa `ahepk ah `elqp]`k lanna`eo) p] lnaoajp]n qj] eje_e]per] mqa nabkni] u ]`e_ekj] hko ]np _qhko 0.0 >eo u 0.5 `ah ? `eck Laj]h ba`an]h l]n] eilkjan qj] laj] `a oaeo ] -1 ] ko `a lneoe j u `a `ko ieh ] ., ieh ` ]o iqhp] ] mqeaj lnk`qv_]( nalnk`qv_]( ejpnk`qv_] ]h l] o( ]hi]_aja( pn]jolknpa( `eopne^qu]( raj`] k ]nneaj`a len]pan ]* Ah p niejk len]pan ]( ]_h]) n ( oa qpehev] l]n] `ao_ne^en h] pn]jocnaoe j `a hko `ana_dko `a ]qpkn ] qj jerah naiqjan]) perk7 ejrkhq_n] ] cn]j _]jpe`]` `a lanokj]o mqa d]j da_dk `a aop] ]_pere`]` oq ia`ek `a re`] ]h nalnk`q_en `a i]jan] ehac]h pk`k pelk `a i]pane]hao mqa oa aj_qajpn]j lnkpace`ko lkn h] Hau `a @ana_dko `a =qpkn* >]fk ah _kj_alpk `a lnklea) `]` ejpaha_pq]h oa ]il]n]j k^n]o iqoe_]hao( _ejai]pkcn be_]o( he) pan]ne]o( bkpkcn be_]o( ]np ope_]o( lnkcn]i]o `a _ ilqpk( ajpna kpnko( ]o _kik l]pajpao( i]n) _]o l]n] lnk`q_pko( oanre_eko k ik`ahko ej`qopne]hao* Oq^n]u mqa aop] ]_pere`]` ao ]_alp]`] lknmqa aj iq_d]o `a h]o k_]oekjao jk oa _qajp] _kj hko na_qnoko a_kj ie_ko ja_a) o]neko l]n] ]`mqenen lnk`q_pko

;d ckY^Wi eYWi_ed[i" bk[]e Z[ bei ef[hWj_lei de i[ be]hW bW YWfjkhW Z[ dWZ_[

I[] d bW 9|cWhW 7c[h_YWdW Z[ 9ec[hY_e h[fh[i[djW / feh Y_[dje Z[b fheZkYje _dj[hde Xhkje

;d (&&/ bei f_hWjWi ]WdWhed -* ccZZ :[ WYk[hZe Yed bW FheYkhWZkh W =[d[hWb Z[ bW H[f Xb_YW" Wb]kdWi Z[

bWi ceZWb_ZWZ[i Z[ [ij[ Z[b_je i[ ^Wd _dYh[c[djWZe ^WijW [d ')' feh Y_[dje Z[ kd W e W ejhe1 [b FH: oW fh[fWhW kdW _d_Y_Wj_lW Z[ h[\ehcW knecej]hao( Îu h] daiko hhac]`k ] ran u ]_alp]n _kik qj] ]_pere`]` h _ep] oej oanhkÏ* Ah `ana_dk `a ]qpkn ao ah na_k) jk_eieajpk mqa d]_a ah Aop]`k aj b]rkn `a pk`k _na]`kn `a k^n]o hepan]ne]o u ]np ope_]o( ]h mqa kpkn) c] lnkpa__e j l]n] mqa ck_a `a lnannkc]per]o `a _]n _pan lanokj]h u l]pneikje]h( oqopajp * =cnac mqa aopa `ana_dk ao ah mqa ha kpknc] ] h] ]qpkne`]` h] lkpaop]` `a hhar]n ] _]^k ]__ek) jao mqa _ki^]p]j h]o _kj`q_p]o `ahe_per]o `a ^]j`]o knc]jev]`]o mqa _kle]j u `eopne^quaj i]pane]h oej h] ]qpknev]_e j `a hko mqa peajaj h] pepqh]ne`]`* ÎL]n] mqa eje_ea qj] ]rane)

cq]_e j lnare] ok^na aopa da_dk `ahe_perk( `a^a ia`e]n h] mqanahh] `ah pepqh]n `ah `ana_dk rqhjan]`k( oepq]_e j mqa aj h] i]ukn ] `a hko _]oko jk k_qnna u mqa pn]a _kik _kjoa_qaj_e] mqa h] `apaniej]) _e j mqa na_]a ok^na h] ej`]c]pkne] aj iq_d]o `a h]o k_]oekjao jk ao o]peob]_pkne] ]h jk lnaoajp]noa ] bkniqh]n oq mqanahh] ah pepqh]n `ah `ana_dk rqhjan]`k k oq nalnaoaj) p]jpa hac]h* Î?kjoe`ank ja_ao]nek `ao]haj) p]n _q]hmqean _kj`q_p] `ahe_pe) r] nah]_ekj]`] ] hko `ana_dko `a ]qpkn u aj`qna_an h]o laj]o l]n] ]mqahhko `ahej_qajpao mqa oa aj_qajpn]j ]h bnajpa `a aop]o ^]j`]oÏ( ajb]pev * .D

9ecfWhWj_le H[i[hlWi Z[b 8WdYe Z[ C n_Ye

F_hWj[h W

H[c[iWi

/) c_b *(, cZZ -* c_b cZZ (' c_b '.' cZZ

<K;DJ; 8Wdn_Ye" I>9F o 9|cWhW Z[ 9ec[hY_e 7c[h_YWdW

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

OBDJPOBM I7H7 ;I9E87H

I[ Z[X[ Z[j[hc_dWh Yk|b[i Ykcfb[d ºh[gk_i_jei Z[ceYh|j_Yei»" _dZ_YW [b j_jkbWh Z[ bW I[]eX

ºH[]bWc[djWh Wb_WdpWi»" fhefed[ = c[p Cedj EIM7B:E H7CÑH;P

JeZWl W ^Wo j_[cfe

fWhW ^WY[hbe Wdj[i Z[ bW fh n_cW [b[YY_ d" h[ifedZ[ [d kd Y^Wj

;b b Z[h dWY_edWb Z[b WbX_Wpkb

;ijhWj[]_W [d (&'&

7D Wfk[ijW feh fWYjei fWhW ]WdWhb[ W bei fh__ijWi

ºBW fhefk[ijW Z[

h[\ehcW feb j_YW [i b[Wb o de [i jhWcfeiW1 feh [bbe ^Wo gk[ h[]kbWhbW» C n_Ye3JljXeX ?\ie}e[\q

&

h oa_nap]nek `a Ck^anj]_e j( Banj]j`k C iav Ikjp( oa `a_h]n lkn Înach]iajp]nÏ h]o ]he]jv]o aha_pkn]hao l]n] `apan) iej]n _q hao okj h]o mqa _qilhaj _kj hko Înamqeoepko `aik_n pe_ko `a _kjcnqaj_e]( _kjoeopaj_e] u pn]o_aj`aj_e]Ï( ] Új `a c]n]jpe) v]n _h]ne`]` aj h]o kbanp]o lkh ) pe_]o* = _]oe `ko oai]j]o `a oq o]he) `] `a h]o Úh]o `ah L=J pn]o i]je) baop]noa _kjpn] h]o ]he]jv]o ajpna L=J u LN@( u `a ]`iepen mqa l]_p _kj ah LNE l]n] mqa ah ^h]jmqe]vqh jk _kj_nap]n] _k]he_ekjao _kj h] evmqean`]( ah aj_]nc]`k `a h] lkh ) pe_] ejpanj] `efk mqa oan ] _kjra) jeajpa oq nach]iajp]_e j u `af aj _h]nk mqa ]h Új]h aj i]pane] aha_pkn]h ah cn]j haceoh]`kn ao ah _eq`]`]jk* Î@aolq o `a pk`k ah `a^]pa `a h]o hpei]o oai]j]o oan ] _kjra) jeajpa nach]iajp]n h]o ]he]jv]o l]n] `apaniej]n _q hao _qilhaj hko namqeoepko `aik_n pe_ko `a _kj) cnqaj_e]( _kjoeopaj_e] u pn]o_aj) `aj_e] l]n] c]n]jpev]n h] _h]ne`]` `a h]o kbanp]o lkh pe_]o* Lkn kpnk h]`k( ah cn]j haceoh]`kn aj i]pane] aha_pkn]h ao ah _eq`]`]jk* R]iko ] ran mq `e_aÏ( lqjpq]hev * @qn]jpa qj _d]p aj h] l cej] `a ejpanjap sss*nabkni]lkhepe_]*ck^* it Í_kik l]npa `a h] _]il] ] `a Ck^anj]_e j l]n] eilqho]n hko ^ajaÚ_eko `a h] nabkni] lkh pe_]

C n_Ye3GXcfdX 8cZ}ekXiX

& ;b i[Yh[jWh_e Z[ =eX[hdWY_ d h[ifedZ_ bWi ZkZWi Z[ bei Y_kZWZWdei ieXh[ bW h[\ehcW feb j_YW [d kd Y^Wj `ah lnaoe`ajpa Bahela ?]h`an jÍ( C iav Ikjp _kjoe`an mqa ] j d]u peailk l]n] nacqh]n h]o ]he]jv]o aha_pkn]hao ]jpao `a hko _kie_eko `a .,-.* ÎUk aopku _eanpk mqa `aolq o `ah narqahk `a h]o hpei]o oai]) j]o( ah pai] `a h] nacqh]_e j `a h]o ]he]jv]o p]n`a mqa pailn]jk oan nareo]`k* Pk`]r ] d]u peailk l]n] d]_anhk ]jpao `a h] ln tei] aha__e j ba`an]hÏ( ao_ne^e l]n] hko i o `a 4, _e^anj]qp]o mqa ]__a`eankj ] h] l cej]* C iav Ikjp na_d]v aop]n aj _kjpn] `a _q]hmqean pelk `a ]he]jv]o a ej`e_ mqa hk mqa d] i]jebaop]`k ao oq Îlnak_ql]_e j( lknmqa oa _kjopnqu]j `a i]jan] `aik_n pe_]Ï* Ah pepqh]n `a Ck^anj]_e j na) _kjk_e mqa oe ^eaj ah ck^eanjk peaja qj l]lah _h]ra l]n] naokhran lnk^hai]o mqa ]mqaf]j ] hko _eq) `]`]jko( _kik pai]o `a oacqne`]` u a_kjki ]( l]npa `a hko ieoiko

ºJ[d[cei Yed\_WdpW [d bW l_Yjeh_W Z[b FH?»" Z_Y[

FWh[Z[i c_d_c_pW bWi YeWb_Y_ed[i [ijWjWb[i BW >WXWdW38e^ c`ZX D\iZX[f

-

] `enecajpa j]_ekj]h `ah LNE( >a]pnev L]na`ao( ejoeope aj mqa ahh] jk aop janreko] lkn h]o ]he]jv]o u( aj ah _]ok `a Oej]hk]( d]u _kjÚ]jv] aj h] i]`qnav `a hko iehep]jpao* Ajpnareop]`] ok^na h]o ]he]jv]o mqa oa d]j _kj_nap]`k ajpna h] evmqean`] u ah L=J( oa ha lnacqjp oe lk`n ] d]^an qjekjao aha_pkn]hao

_kj ah L]npe`k `ah Pn]^]fk( ] hk _q]h naolkj`e 6 ÎPajaiko _kjÚ]jv] aj h] re_pkne] `ah LNE* Ao qj pai] `ah mqa oa d] d]^h]`k `ai]oe]`k( h] _eq`]`]j ] lk`n klp]n u aj ah l]n) pe`k pajaiko _kjbe]jv]( lnklqaop]o _h]n]o mqa jk cajan]j _kjbqoe j u lh]jpa]iko _]j`e`]pqn]o mqa naolkj`aj ] h]o atla_p]per]o `a h] ok_ea`]`Ï* I]jebaop mqa jk peaja oajpe`k ]^qj`]n aj qj pai] mqa oa d]

oqnceankj lkn h] l]n heoeo aj h] lk) h pe_] bnajpa ] hko _eq`]`]jko( lkn hk mqa oa d]_a ja_ao]nek ]lnk^]n h] nabkni] lkh pe_]* ÎIafkn]n h] i]jan] _kik _kjopepqeiko ah ck^eanjk( ao `]nha iafknao dann]ieajp]o l]n] mqa _qilh] iafkn _kj oq pn]^]fk* Mq jk _naao mqa l]npa `a jqaopnko lnk^hai]o oqnca `a h] l]n heoeo aj h] lkh pe_] k `a h] b]hp] `a pn]jol]naj_e] u `a naj) `e_e j `a _qajp]o `a hko lkh pe_ko bnajpa ] h] _eq`]`]j ]Ï( naolkj`e ] lnacqjp] atlnao]* Pn]o naepan]n mqa h] lnklqaop] jk lnapaj`a `a^ehep]n ]h ?kjcnaok( ]lqjp mqa h]o _]j`e`]pqn]o ej`a) laj`eajpao peajaj mqa are`aj_e]n qj i jeik oqopajpk ok_e]h u lnk^]n mqa _qajp]j _kj qj ]lkuk lklqh]n ^ oe_k l]n] _kilapen( ieajpn]o mqa ok^na h] eje_e]per] lnabanajpa( _kiajp mqa `a^a oan nacqh]`] `a i]jan] mqa jk oa qpehe_a aj Îbkni] pn]ilko]Ï*

H] i]jan]( ]cnac ( ao mqa ah Afa) _qperk ba`an]h ajre oqo eje_e]per]o lnabanajpao Í`ko ] h]o mqa peaja `ana_dkÍ ]h eje_ek `ah lanek`k kn`ej]nek `a oaoekjao( l]n] arep]n Î]_knn]h]nÏ ]h ?kjcnaok* Î@a ran]o ao qj] lnklqaop] ha]h u jk ao pn]ilko]7 lkn ahhk d]u mqa nacqh]nh] ^eajÏ( _kiajp ah oa_nap]nek `a Ck^anj]_e j* =h nabanenoa ]h pai] `a h] naaha_) _e j `a haceoh]`knao u lnaoe`ajpao iqje_el]hao( atlhe_ mqa ao qj] i]jan] `a mqa h] _eq`]`]j ] i]) jeÚaopa ] hko l]npe`ko lkh pe_ko oq `aoak `a bknf]n qj _kjpn]pk ajpna ah aha_pkn u ahace`k pajeaj`k _kik _ajpnk `a oq `a_eoe j( ah `aoaila k* ÎU] jk i o `eo_qnoko aj ah r]_ k* Oe hko l]npe`ko lkh pe_ko jk hk d]j ]lnk^]`k ]jpao( ]dkn] ao peailk l]n] arep]n qj i]ukn `apaneknk `a h] lkh pe_]* Ao aj ^ajabe_ek `a pk`koÏ( ]_kp C ) iav Ikjp* .D

pk_]`k u] aj hko hpeiko ., ` ]o( ok^na pk`k lknmqa h] _eq`]`]j ] lk`n klp]n lkn mqeajao peajaj lnklqaop]o _h]n]o u jk cajan]j _kjbqoe j* ÎJkokpnko pajaiko _kjÚ]jv] aj h] re_pkne] `ah LNEÏ( ]cnac * ͼOacqen j ejpajp]j`k h] lkoe^ehe`]` `a mqa oa `ao]n) iaj h]o ]he]jv]o `ah L=J _kj h] evmqean`]; ÍUk da oe`k ejoeopajpa aj mqa ] mqeaj ha `a^a lnak_ql]n ao ] hko iehep]jpao `a aoko l]npe`ko* Hko iehep]jpao `a aoko l]npe`ko `a^aj aop]n iqu `ao_kj_anp]`ko( lkn) mqa bqanv]o lkh pe_]o mqa d]_a ]laj]o qjko ] ko u aj ]hcqjko pai]o( ] j ]dkn]( oa `ao_]heÚ_]j `n]i pe_]iajpa d]u]j pki]`k ao]o `a_eoekjao*

ͼJk hao lkja janrekoko; ÍJk l]nav_k janreko] ¼ran`]`; Jk* @aÚjeper]iajpa _nak( lkn ah _kjpn]nek( mqa h]o iehep]j_e]o `a ]i^ko l]npe`ko lkh pe_]o `a^aj aop]n iqu `ao_kj_anp]`]oÏ* Ok^na h] lkoe^ehe`]` `a qj nao) mqa^n]f]ieajpk aj Oej]hk] $`kj`a ah oaj]`kn I]nek H lav d] `e_dk mqa lh]pe_] _kj h] klkoe_e j kbanp]o `a oan oq _]j`e`]pk oe ah LNE jk hk lkopqh]%( L]na`ao ]oacqn mqa pn]^]f]j aj ao] ajpe`]` _kj qj l]npe`k bqanpa( l]npe`k i]uknep]nek u _kj ajknia lnaoaj_e] aj pk`]o h]o nacekjao* ͼLank lqa`a d]^an `ereoekjao ]d ( nkileieajpko; ÍJkokpnko pajaiko _kjÚ]jv] aj h] i]`qnav `a hko iehep]jpao `ah LNE aj Oej]hk]* .D

h aop]^ha_eieajpk `a ]he]jv]o _kj l]npe`ko `a klkoe_e j bkni] l]npa lnej_el]h `a h]o aopn]pace]o mqa ah L]npe`k =__e j J]_ekj]h aop]^ha_e aj oq `a_ hkck `a ]__ekjao l]n] _ki^]pen ]h LNE aj aopa ] k aha_pkn]h* @aolq o `a oaeo iaoao `a mqa ah h `an `ah ^h]jmqe]vqh( ? o]n J]r]( `a_e`ean] _na]n qj] ?kieoe j `a NaÛate j( _kkn`ej]`] lkn Fko Hqeo ?kej`na]q( mqa aopq`e]n] h]o n]) vkjao lkn h]o _q]hao ah l]npe`k d]^ ] paje`k h] `annkp] aha_pkn]h aj h]o l]o]`]o aha__ekjao `a .,,5 h] ]dkn] ?kieoe j `a Oacqeieajpk u] peaja ba_d]o u naolkjo]^hao l]n] _]`] ]__e j* L]jeop]o ]oeopajpao ] h] naqje j `ah ?kjoafk J]_ekj]h( mqa oa _aha^n ah -/ `a ba^nank( _kiajp]nkj mqa oa `eankj ] _kjk_an ]hcqjko ]r]j_ao u naoqhp]`ko `a h] _kieoe j p]hao _kik6 hko `ahac]`ko aola_e]hao l]n] aop]n ]h p]jpk `a h]o aha__ekjao u h] ejop]h]_e j `ah oeopai] L=J* Ao qj ia_]jeoik `a _kkn`ej]) _e j ajpna pk`ko hko l]jeop]o mqa aop j aj ah ck^eanjk u aj lqaopko haceoh]perko _kj h] Új]he`]` `a `]nha _kjpejqe`]` ]h lnkua_pk aj _]`] ajpe`]` ba`an]per]* Î$H]o ]he]jv]o% okj qj] l]npa( lank h]o ]__ekjao _kj h]o mqa oa _kj_nap]j aoko k^faperko okj iq_d]o( jk ao _kj qj] okh] ]__e j k lnkcn]i] mqa oa _kjoec] ah k^faperk( ao qj] _ki^ej]_e j `a r]ne]o _ko]o u aopa ao qjk `a hko ahaiajpkoÏ( `ap]hh]nkj l]jeop]o _kjoqhp]`ko* Lkn ahhk( aj h] atlkoe_e j `a hko pai]o ?kej`na]q atlhe_ ] hko ]oeopajpao mqa u] oa _qajp] _kj qj `k_qiajpk _kj ba_d]o u naolkjo]) ^hao( mqeajao _kiajv]nkj ] pn]^]f]n aj hko pai]o `ao`a ajank* Bqa aj jkreai^na _q]j`k ah ?AJ l]jeop] _kiajv _kj lh]ja]_e j ^]o j`koa aj ah `a_ hkck u ]r]j) v aj qj] oanea `a lnklqaop]o u ]__ekjao aj _kj_napk ] na]hev]n l]n] _kjoacqen aoko -, lqjpko* =o ( h] ?kieoe j `a Oacqeieaj) pk ha `ek bkni] ] aoa lh]j `ah ?kiep J]_ekj]h _kj naolkjo]) ^hao( ej`e_]`knao u ba_d]o h iepa l]n] _]`] ]_pk aj _kj_napk( ah _q]h _kiajv ] ]lhe_]noa ] l]npen `a ajank* .D

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

.1

P

C_d_ij[h_e ;Z_jeh0 'SBODJTDP (BSEVtP F‘Xb_Ye cf6c_b[d_eZ_Wh_e$Yec$cn

Bei h[ikbjWZei i[ l_[hed [d Zei c[i[i" Wi[]khW [b YecWdZWdj[ Z[ bW I[]kdZW PedW C_b_jWh

;`ƒhY_je0 YWo[hed -& bWi [`[YkY_ed[i [d 89 :[ijWYW gk[ bW fh[i[dY_W Z[ iebZWZei [d bWi YWbb[i" bW YebWXehWY_Œd Z[ P YbWl[i bW ieY_[ZWZ c[Z_Wdj[ Z[dkdY_Wi WdŒd_cWi o bW YeehZ_dWY_Œd Z[ bei jh[i d_l[b[i Z[ ]eX_[hde Yedl_[hj[d W [iW [dj_ZWZ [d kd [`[cfbe fWhW [b fW‡i ;IF;9?7B

8W`W 9Wb_\ehd_W3@m}e G\[iXqX

"

n]ÂŽv `a hko ckhlao mqa oa d]j `]`k _kjpn] h] `ahej_qaj_e]( h]o afa) _q_ekjao aj >]f] ?]he) bknje] oa na`qfankj 3, lkn _eajpk `qn]jpa hko ˜hpeiko `ko iaoao( ]oacqn“ ah cajan]h =hbkjok @q]npa I˜fe_]( _ki]j`]jpa `a h] Oacqj`] Vkj] Iehep]n* ?kil]n]`k _kj `e_eai^na `a .,,5( ĂŽpajaiko qj] na`q__e“j `a 3, lkn _eajpk aj aopa pelk `a `ahepko( aola_ÂŽĂš _]iajpa aj afa) _q_ekjao aj >]f] ?]hebknje]* Aopk jko iqaopn] mqa oecqa ]r]jv]j`k ah pn]^]fk mqa aop]iko d]_eaj`k( `kj`a ok^nao]ha h] _kjĂš ]jv] `a h] lk^h]_e“j _erehĂ?( lqjpq]hev“* Laoa ] mqa r]j _]oe .,, afa) _qp]`ko aj ah pn]jo_qnok `a aopa ]Â’k( ah faba iehep]n ]oaran“ mqa oa d] naceopn]`k qj] _kjoe`an]^ha ^]f] aj ah ÂŽj`e_a `a dkie_e`eko( h] _q]h( `efk( oa `ek ] l]npen `a h] oacqj`] mqej_aj] `ah l]o]`k iao `a ajank* @a ]_qan`k _kj ah na_qajpk iaj) oq]h `a IEHAJEK( aj `e_eai^na `ah ]Â’k l]o]`k dq^k aj h] ajpe`]` 55 afa_q_ekjao7 aj ajank( p]i^eŠj 55 u aj hk mqa r] `a ba^nank( 01* @a ao] i]jan]( h] na`q__e“j `a afa_q_ek) jao oa `ek aj ah ˜hpeik iao u ao `a ]hna`a`kn `a 01*0 lkn _eajpk* @q]npa I˜fe_] ]beni“ mqa h] `eoiejq_e“j `a afa_q_ekjao peajaj mqa ran _kj ah _ki^]pa

+

:‡W Z[b ;`ƒhY_je" ik j_jkbWh" =k_bb[hce =Wbl|d" WĂ… hcÂŒ gk[ W dWZ_[ Yedl_[d[ gk[ bW bkY^W YedjhW [b dWhYejh|Ă… Ye i[ fhebed# ]k[ _dZ[Ă… d_ZWc[dj[$ WfheXWh bWi h[\ehcWi W bW B[o Z[ I[]kh_ZWZ DWY_edWb Wdj[ bei [cXWj[i Z[b Yh_c[d eh]Wd_pW# Ze" gk[ Z[l_[d[d oW [d Wc[dW# pWi W bW i[]kh_ZWZ _dj[h_eh$

97Zl_hj_Œ gk[ Z[ [nj[dZ[hi[ [d Z[cWi‡W [b YecXWj[ YedjhW [b Yh_c[d" de iŒbe i[ _dYh[c[d# jWh| [b d‘c[he Z[ l‡Yj_cWi _deY[dj[i" i_de gk[ jWcX_ƒd bW feXbWY_Œd feZh‡W WYeijkcXhWh# i[ W bW YkbjkhW Z[ bW l_eb[dY_W$

7b\edie :kWhj[ C‘`_YW bbWcÂŒ W de jeb[hWh d_d]kdW WYY_ÂŒd _b[]Wb ] hko cnqlko _neiej]hao( ]`aiƒo `a h]o ]__ekjao mqa d] paje`k ah AfŠn_epk _kj lnaoaj_e] aj h] _]hhao aj `ahac]_ekjao _kj ]hpko ÂŽj`e_ao `ahe_perko _kik Oƒj_dav P]^k]`]( H] Iao] u H] Lnao]* Aj aopko naoqhp]`ko( `aop]_“( d] oe`k ej`eolajo]^ha h] _kh]^kn]_e“j `a h] ok_ea`]`( aola_ÂŽĂš _]iajpa aj i]pane] `a `ajqj_e] ]j“je) i] mqa hao laniepe“ e`ajpeĂš _]n da_dko `ahe_perko*

Lqjpq]hev“ mqa d]^an _kjok) he`]`k h] _kkn`ej]_e“j _kj h]o ]qpkne`]`ao `a hko pnao jerahao `a ck^eanjk bqa ej`eolajo]^ha aj aop] p]na]( lkn hk mqa h] ajpe) `]` oa _kjrenpe“ aj qj afailhk ] ao_]h] j]_ekj]h* =oeieoik( ]Ú ni“ mqa h] _k) h]^kn]_e“j `ah ck^eanjk `a Ao) p]`ko Qje`ko aj ah _ki^]pa ] h] `ahej_qaj_e] laniepe“ ]r]jv]n aj aopa oajpe`k( h]^kn mqa ao ja_a)

o]ne] lkn oan Pefq]j] qj] _eq`]` bnkjpanev]* Ah _ki]j`]jpa okopqrk mqa jk oa lqa`a d]^h]n `a qj pneqj) bk `apaniej]jpa( lqao ]hcqj]o _Šhqh]o `ahe_per]o oecqaj klan]j) `k( ]qjmqa _kj i]ukn `a^ehe) `]` ]h d]^an oe`k bn]ciajp]`]o aj `eranoko klan]perko( `kj`a bqankj `apaje`ko ]hcqjko `a oqo hŽ`anao* =hanp“ ] h] ok_ea`]` ok^na ah

J_`kWdW f_Z[ W ;K YedYbk_h Wb[hjW knca N]iko Danjƒj`av( lnaoe`ajpa iqje_el]h `a Pefq]j]( ejbkni“ mqa u] caopekj]j ]jpa h] nalnaoajp]_e“j `elhkiƒpe_] `a AQ aj IŠte_k ah napenk `a h] ]hanp] ok^na qj lkoe) ^ha ej_naiajpk `a h] rekhaj_e] aj aop] _eq`]`* Ah ]h_]h`a lqjpq]hev“ mqa aj Pefq]j] ateopa c]n]jpŽ] pkp]h `a

9:khWdj[ bW Y[b[XhWY_ÂŒd Z[b

9Feh [ie" ^_pe kd bbWcWZe W

BW Y_kZWZ [i i[]khW fWhW jkh_ijWi o h[i_Z[dj[i [njhWd`[hei" Wi[]khW [b WbYWbZ[ @eh][ HWcei

8W`W 9Wb_\ehd_W3@m}e G\[iXqX

B_c_jWh bW bkY^W

oacqne`]` l]n] hko iƒo `a ./ ieh aop]`qje`ajoao mqa naoe`aj ]dŽ ]oŽ _kik l]n] hko pqneop]o `ah l]Žo ra_ejk( u `a pk`k ah iqj`k( mqa reoepaj ah iqje_elek * N]iko Danjƒj`av naolkj`e“ ]oŽ aj nah]_e“j ] h] ]`ranpaj_e] mqa `ebqj`e“ aj oq lknp]h `a ejpanjap ah _kjoqh]`k `a AQ aj Pefq]j] ok^na lkoe^hao ^]h]_an]o aj aop] ajpe`]`( pn]o h] _]lpqn] `a Pak`knk C]n_Ž] Oeiajp]h( ]he]o Ah Pak*

Ah a`eh ]Â’]`e“ mqa h] _kiqje_]) _e“j _kj ah _“joqh aop]`qje`ajoa( Oparaj G]odgapp( u ah ai^]f]`kn ?]nhko L]o_q]h ĂŽao iqu ^qaj]Ă? u mqa ah ck^eanjk iqje_el]h caopekj] u] mqa napenaj h] ]hanp]* N]iko Danjƒj`av na_kn`“ mqa ah lnklek ai^]f]`kn L]o_q]h aj qj] reoep] ] aop] _eq`]` devk qj na_kjk_eieajpk ]h aobqanvk `a h] lkhe_ÂŽ] iqje_el]h( ah AfŠn_epk u h]o _knlkn]_ekjao `a hko pnao jerahao

`a ck^eanjk( lkn hk mqa( `efk( jqj) _] na_kiaj`]nÂŽ] mqa `af]n]j `a reoep]n h] _eq`]`* Ah _kjoqh]`k `a AQ aj Pefq]j] i]jpeaja `ao`a ah -0 `a ajank aj oq lknp]h qj ĂŽiajo]fa Cq]n`eƒjĂ?( ia`e]jpa ah _q]h ]hanp] ] oqo _eq) `]`]jko `a qj lkoe^ha ej_naiajpk aj h] rekhaj_e] aj aop] _eq`]`* Aj oq ]reok( h] nalnaoajp]_e“j `elhkiƒpe_] ]_kjoaf] ] hko _eq`]) `]jko mqa naoe`aj k re]f]j ] >]f]

lahecnk `a ]_kopqi^n]noa ] h] rekhaj_e]( lkn hk mqa ]`renpe“ mqa jk oa `a^a pkhan]n jejcqj] ]__e“j ehac]h* U nao]hp“ h] eilknp]j_e] `a h] `ajqj_e] ]j“jei] ok^na _q]h) mqean ennacqh]ne`]`* A devk oqu]o h]o l]h]^n]o `a Cqehhanik C]hrƒj( pepqh]n `a h] @abajo] J]_ekj]h6 ĂŽj]`ea `aoa] mqa aop] hq_d] oa lnkhkjcqa( ] j]`ea ha _kjreajaĂ?* Oej ai^]nck( ah cajan]h ]oacqn“ mqa ah AfŠn_epk oacqenƒ l]npe_el]j`k `a i]jan] ]_per] aj ah _ki^]pa ] h] ejoacqne`]` aj ah l]ÂŽo( ^]fk h]o ejopnq__ekjao `ah lnaoe`ajpa Bahela ?]h`an“j* @q]npa I˜fe_] _kjĂš “ aj mqa aj aopa ]Â’k oa ranƒj iƒo naoqhp]`ko lkoeperko aj h] nace“j* .D ?]hebknje] aop]n ]h p]jpk `a qj ]q) iajpk `a hko ]p]mqao rekhajpko aj ah ƒna] `a Pefq]j]( h] i]uknÂŽ] `a hko _q]hao aop]nÂŽ]j nah]_ekj]`ko _kj ah j]n_kpnÂƒĂš _k( hqack `a h] `apaj_e“j `a ĂŽqj eilknp]jpa j]n_kpn]Ăš _]jpa aj H] L]v >]f] ?]hebknje] OqnĂ?( aj nabanaj_e] ] h] _]lpqn] `a Ah Pak* =qjmqa _kjoe`an] mqa hko _eq`]`]jkoaop]`qje`ajoao jk oanƒj ah k^faperk _kj_napk `a aoko ai^]pao _neiej]hao( na_kieaj`] pajan lna_]q_e“j _q]j`k oa re]fa lkn aoko aop]`ko* N]iko Danjƒj`av lqjpq]hev“ mqa d]op] h] ba_d] jk d] d]^e`k qj okhk pqneop] mqa d]u] oe`k ]ba_p]`k lkn h] hq_d] _kjpn] h] ejoacqne`]`* .D

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

.1

7o[h" )+ Wi[i_dWjei

<k[hed ZWZei Z[ XW`W ) c_b /). Wbkcdei Z[ [ZkYWY_ d X|i_YW

Feh ebW l_eb[djW" Y_[hhWd ', [iYk[bWi [d @k|h[p &

Ejhei Y_dYe [`[YkjWZei [d IWbl|hYWh C n_Ye3I\[XZZ` e

7Xh_h|d [d bW YWf_jWb

Z[ 9^_^kW^kW kd fWh Z[ i[YkdZWh_Wi fWhW h[YedjhWjWh W cW[ijhei

=hWdWZW [d WkjeX i BK?I 97H87BBE%9K7HJEI9KHE

C n_Ye3D\c`jjX [\c Gfqf

%

a^e`k ] h] kh] `a rekhaj_e] mqa l]`a_a ?dedq]dq]( aj ao] ajpe`]` bqankj _ann]`]o -4 ao_qah]o l]n] ah _e_hk ao_kh]n .,,5).,-,( `a h]o _q]hao -2 oa aj_qajpn]j aj ?eq`]` Fq nav* Ah faba `ah @al]np]iajpk `a Ao) p]` ope_] `a Oanre_eko A`q_]perko `ah aop]`k( =j`n o Iav]( atlhe_ mqa h] _h]qoqn] `a h]o ao_qah]o oa `a^e ] h] `eoiejq_e j `a h] i]) pn _qh] aj hko jerahao `a lnaao_kh]n u lnei]ne]* ÎH] rekhaj_e] d] lnkrk_]`k ah _eanna `a i]mqeh]`kn]o( ieoi]o mqa `af]j `a klan]n lknmqa hko ailha]`ko aiecn]j ] kpn]o _eq) `]`ao _kj oqo defko u h] _]naj_e] `a aopq`e]jpao jko d] k^hec]`k ] _ann]n ao_qah]oÏ( ]Úni * ?]^a `aop]_]n mqa `a h]o -2 ao_qah]o mqa bqankj _ann]`]o aj ?eq`]` Fq nav( -/ okj `a a`q_]_e j ^ oe_]( `kj`a oa paj ]j ejo_nepko / ieh 5/4 ]hqijko* H]o kpn]o pnao okj _ajpnko `a _]l]_ep]_e j l]n] ah pn]^]fk( `kj) `a lanokj]o `a pk`]o h]o a`]`ao an]j lnal]n]`]o l]n] ailha]noa aj `eranoko kÚ_eko* Iav] lna_eo mqa d]op] aopa _e_hk ao_kh]n( / ieh .0/ aopq`e]j) pao `a lnei]ne] aj ?eq`]` Fq nav ]^]j`kj]nkj h] ao_qah]( ieajpn]o mqa 251 je ko `a lnaao_kh]n bqankj `]`ko `a ^]f]* Aj _kjpn]opa( `efk( ah j iank `a aopq`e]jpao `a ^]_dehhan]pk oa ej_naiajp aj 3,, ]hqijko naola_pk ]h _e_hk .,,4).,,5( ieajpn]o mqa ]h oeopai] lnkba) oekj]h ia`ek $^]_dehhan]pk p _) je_k% oa oqi]nkj /.5 lanokj]o u hko ]hqijko aj _]l]_ep]_e j

;d 7j_pWf|d" ;ijWZe Z[ C n_Ye" kdW ]hWdWZW Z[ \hW]c[djWY_ d" YWi_ b_ijW fWhW [nfbejWh" \k[ [dYedjhWZW [d [b _dj[h_eh Z[ kd WkjeX i Z[ fWiW`[hei o Z[iWYj_lWZW feh kd ]hkfe Z[ [nf[hjei Z[ bW 7][dY_W Z[ I[]kh_ZWZ ;ijWjWb$ BW feb_Y W beYWb h[fehj gk[ W][dj[i [ijWjWb[i o ckd_Y_fWb[i h[l_iWhed c_dkY_eiWc[dj[ [b l[^ Ykbe o Z[iYkXh_[hed gk[ bW ]hWdWZW ^WX W i_Ze YebeYWZW Z[ jWb cWd[hW gk[ Yed YkWbgk_[h cel_c_[dje XhkiYe [ijWbbWhW$ ;b YWie h[YWo [d [b C_d_ij[h_e F Xb_Ye \[Z[hWb$

l]n] ah pn]^]fk $p]hhanao `a pn]) ^]fk aj hko mqa jk oa namqeanaj aopq`eko% l]o]nkj `a 4 ieh 211 ] 5 ieh 00* Oa ]h mqa( laoa ]h ]qiajpk `a aopq`e]jpao `a ^]_dehhan]pko( ah lnkia`ek `a f rajao mqa `af]nkj aopko aopq`eko ] iep]` `a ] k ]q) iajp ] /,*4. lkn _eajpk* * Ah bqj_ekj]nek `aop]_ mqa -.*,2 lkn _eajpk `a hko je ko aj ?eq`]` Fq nav _qno] lnaao_kh]n( 1. lkn _eajpk aop aj h] lnei]ne]( -5*. lkn _eajpk aj h] oa_qj`]ne]( ieajpn]o mqa --*2 lkn _eajpk _qno] aopq`eko `a ^]_dehhan]pk u o hk

9kcfb_h| Yecfhec_iei fh[i_Z[dY_Wb[i

:[ij_dWh| I;F *- cZf W [i[ WokdjWc_[dje C n_Ye3EXp\c` Ifc[}e

-

] Oa_nap]n ] `a A`q_]_e j L ^he_] $OAL% ejranpen 03 iehhkjao `a laoko l]n] hko lnkcn]i]o Ao_qah] Oacqn] u `a Peailk ?kilhapk( mqa oa ej_hq) uaj aj h] aopn]pace] Pk`ko okiko Fq nav* =o hk ejbkni ah oq^oa_nap]) nek `a A`q_]_e j > oe_]( Banj]j) `k Ckjv hav( ]h _kilnkiapanoa ]

hkcn]n h] eilhaiajp]_e j `a aoko lnkcn]i]o aj hko ln teiko -,, ` ]o( _kik hk kn`aj ah lnaoe`ajpa Bahela ?]h`an j* Aj ajpnareop]( Ckjv hav atlhe_ mqa Ao_qah] Oacqn] $mqa u] bkni]^] l]npa `a h] aopn]pace] Heileaiko I te_k% lnapaj`a bkni]n iafknao _eq`]`]jko( ]qjmqa hko naoqhp]`ko jk oan j ejia`e]pko* Ah bqj_ekj]nek ]oacqn mqa aopa lnkcn]i]( mqa _kjoeopa aj

-*2 lkn aop ejo_nepk aj ao_qah]o p _je_]o* =oacqn mqa /5 lkn _eajpk `a h] i]pn _qh] a`q_]per] `ah aop]`k oa _kj_ajpn] aj ?eq`]` Fq nav( n]v j lkn h] _q]h hko lnkcn]i]o _kik Ao_qah] Oacqn] oa nabknv]n j* Kpnk ./ lkn _eajpk `ah ]hqi) j]`k aop aj h] _eq`]` `a ?de) dq]dq] u .- lkn _eajpk aj kpnko iqje_eleko qn^]jko Hko je ko u f rajao mqa naoe) `aj aj iqje_eleko `a h] oeann] na) lnaoajp]j -. lkn _eajpk( ieoiko `kj`a oa d]j ej_naiajp]`k h]o afa_q_ekjao u har]jpkjao*

Lkn aok( =j`n o Iav] lqj) pq]hev mqa aj aopko lk^h]`ko oa `]n j p]hhanao u _h]oao ok^na h] eil]npe_e j `a fqope_e] u oa) cqne`]`( ]`ai o `a hko lnkcn]) i]o ba`an]hao* =oeieoik( ah bqj_ekj]nek ]beni mqa aj aopa ] k o hk oa ]^nen j `ko oa_qj`]ne]o aj h] _eq`]` `a ?dedq]dq] oe oa _qaj) p] _kj h] i]pn _qh] ja_ao]ne] u _kjbe aj mqa oa] na_kjpn]p]`k lkn hk iajko ., lkn _eajpk `a hko i]aopnko mqa lan`eankj oq pn]^]fk lkn ah _eanna `a lh]jpa) hao ao_kh]nao* .D

_]l]_ep]n ] i]aopnko ok^na h] okhq) _e j `a _kjÛe_pko u lnaraj_e j `a ]`e__ekjao ajpna hko je ko ] pn]r o `a cq ]o( jk namqeana `a iq_dk `ejank l]n] eilhaiajp]noa( lank mqa oa `aopej]n j -3 iehhkjao `a laoko o hk l]n] ?eq`]` Fq nav* Aoko na_qnoko oa `aopej]n j ] h]o ieh ao_qah]o `a a`q_]_e j ^ oe_]* D]op] ah ikiajpk 2,, lh]jpahao aop j ej_hqe`ko aj Ao_qah] Oacq) n] u h] lnkiao] `ah Lnaoe`ajpa ao ]ilhe]nhk ]h naopk* ÎJk ao qj lnk_aok `a `ejank( $lank% bnajpa ] qj lnk^hai] `a aop] i]cjepq`( jejc j lnkcn]i] ]eoh]`k lqa`a naokhranhk* Ao_qah] Oacqn] lkja jb]oeo aj hko ajpknjko ao_k) h]nao u aj ah ]i^eajpa* Oa namqeana lnarajen rekhaj_e]( qj i]n_k `a r]hknao `eopejpkoÏ( oa ]h *

Ok^na h]o Ao_qah]o `a Peailk ?kilhapk( Banj]j`k Ckjv hav ejbkni mqa oa ]lhe_]n j /, ie) hhkjao `a laoko( lnej_el]hiajpa l]n] _kilajo]n ] hko i]aopnko mqa `a^an j atpaj`an oq fknj]`] `a pn]^]fk* Pk`]r ] jk oa `apaniej] ah j iank `a ao_qah]o mqa oa ej) _hqen j( lknmqa oa `a^a ]j]hev]n mqa h] ejbn]aopnq_pqn] oa] ]`a) _q]`] l]n] na]hev]n ]_pere`]`ao atpn]_qnne_qh]nao* ?kik l]npa `a h] _kjpne^q_e j mqa `ao`a ah i^epk a`q_]perk lqa`a d]_anoa _kjpn] h] rekhaj_e] aop h] ejpacn]_e j `ah lnkcn]i]( aj lneiank u oacqj`k `a oa_qj`]ne]( `a bkni]_e j _ re_] u pe_] u h] lnal]n]_e j `a `k_ajpao( ej`e_ Ckjv hav* .D

j oeapa ajpe`]`ao bqankj nalknp]`]o /1 lanokj]o afa_qp]`]o( `a h]o _q]hao -1 rer ]j aj ?eq`]` Fq nav =qpkne`]`ao `a ?dedq]dq] ejbkni]nkj ]uan `a h] afa_q_e j `a ./ ej`ere`qko* Aj ?eq`]` Fq nav oa naceopn]nkj _ej_k afa_q_ekjao aj h] _khkje] O]hr n_]n( `kj`a na) _eajpaiajpa bqankj i]o]_n]`ko -1 f rajao* Kpn]o -, lanokj]o bqankj ]oaoe) j]`]o aj aoa bnkjpan]( ajpna ahh]o qj] iqfan mqa bqa ]_ne^ehh]`] fqjp _kj oq l]naf] aj >kqhar]n` Ej`a) laj`aj_e] u =raje`] Fq]j L]^hk Oacqj`k* =`ai o( qj aopq`e]j) pa iqne u kpnk naoqhp dane`k ]h oan ]_ne^ehh]`ko aj h] _khkje] Rehh] Daniko]* Ieajpn]o( ahaiajpko `ah Af n_epk oepe]nkj ah iqje_elek `a Fei jav( ?dedq]dq]( hqack `a mqa oa naceopn qj] ^]h]_an] aj h] mqa oa de_eankj aop]hh]n r]ne]o cn]j]`]o mqa _k) ^n]nkj h] re`] `a `ko lnaoqjpko oe_]neko* Aj ?]i]nck _]uankj ]^]pe`ko pnao f rajao aj h]o ejia`e]_ekjao `a h] D]_eaj`] N k `ah L]nn]h( u kpnk bqa nai]p]`k aj ah atpanekn `a qj dkolep]h `a aop] hk_]he`]`7 aj >aheo]nek @ki jcqav bqa ]fqope_e]) `] qj] iqfan aj ah ejpanekn `a qj jack_ek u aj h] _]lep]h ?dedq]dq] bqa ]^]pe`k qj oqfapk* Lkn kpn] l]npa( pnao lanokj]o bqankj afa_qp]`]o aj h] _eq`]` `a Pefq]j]( >]f] ?]hebknje]* Qj dki^na jk e`ajpeÚ_]`k( _quk _qanlk bqa hk_]hev]`k aj qj lna`ek `a R]hha Na`kj* Lkn kpnk h]`k( ]^kn`k `a qj rad _qhk bqa ]_ne^ehh]`k qj oqfapk( mqeaj _en_qh]^] ok^na ah ^qhar]n ?]o] >h]j_] Bej]hiajpa qj fkraj bqa ]^]pe`k ] mqai]nnkl] lkn `ko leopkhanko mqa hk ejpan_alp]nkj _q]j`k `ao_aj` ] `a qj p]te aj h] _khkje] Pann]v]o `ah R]hha* Aj C iav L]h]_ek( @qn]jck( oa ejbkni `ah ]oaoej]pk `a `ko lanok) j]o7 aj ]i^ko _]oko hko _]` ranao lnaoajp]^]j dane`]o `a ^]h]* Ieajpn]o( aj ah iqje_elek `a Han`k bqa aj_kjpn]`k ah _qanlk `a qj ej`ere`qk aj qj pn ehan mqa oa aj_kjpn]^] _an_] `ah lk^h]`k _kjk) _e`k _kik Aop]_e j ?dk_kh]pa* =oeieoik( ]qpkne`]`ao `a Pk) nna j nalknp]nkj ah d]hh]vck `a qj _]` ran bnajpa ] hko pannajko `a h] _khkje] Nkrenko] S]`a( ] h] ]hpqn] `ah ha_dk oa_k `ah N k J]v]o* Aj =_]lqh_k pnao dki^nao bqa) nkj afa_qp]`ko( ] `ko `a ahhko oa hao `af]nkj j]n_kiajo]fao _kj h] Úni] `a `c]n R]h`av Rehh]nna]h( ]he]o H] >]n^ea( `enece`ko ] D _pkn >ahpn j Haur]* Aj Okjkn]( qj lkhe_ ] aop]p]h iqne u `ko i o bqankj dane`ko pn]o oan ai^ko_]`ko lkn oe_]) neko* Ieajpn]o( aj I]p]iknko( P]i]qhel]o( qj ajbnajp]ieajpk ajpna _erehao u iehep]nao bnajpa ] qj naop]qn]jpa `af qj iqanpk u `ko dane`ko* .D 9ed _d\ehcWY_ d Z[ bW Yehh[ifediWb W

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

'SPOUFSBT

P

;Z_jeh[i0 *SFOF 4FMTFS )PSBDJP #FTTPO \hedj[hWi$Z\6c_b[d_e$Yec

7B;@7D:HE ;HD;IJE%;<;

9kXW$ =hWdcW W\_hcW gk[ =W_] D[bbo \k[ ÂşWZl[hj_ZeÂť Wb bb[]Wh W bW _ibW

BW >WXWdW WYkiW W ;K Z[ ÂşfheleYWY_ÂŒdÂť ;b ]eX_[hde YkXWde YedZ[dÂŒ bW [djh[l_ijW Z[

kd Wbje \kdY_edWh_e [ijWZkd_Z[di[ Yed efei_jeh[i Wb WYWXWh bWi Yedl[hiWY_ed[i ieXh[ c_]hWY_ÂŒd BW >WXWdW3DXel\c AlXe JfdfqX

$

q^] _]hebe_“ ]uan `a ĂŽlnkrk_]`knĂ? ah ejpan_]i^ek okopa) je`k ah reanjao ]mqÂŽ lkn ah Oq^oa_nap]nek ]oeopajpa `ah @al]np]iajpk `a Aop]`k( C]ec Gahhu( u `a_aj]o `a klkoepknao ]h lnaoe`ajpa N]˜h ?]opnk( `aolqŠo `a paniej]n h] oacqj`] nkj`] `a lhƒpe_]o ie) cn]pkne]o ajpna S]odejcpkj u H] D]^]j]* Jk k^op]jpa( ah pepqh]n `ah l]nh]) iajpk j]_ekj]h( Ne_]n`k =h]n_“j( ]_h]n“ lkn oq l]npa mqa hko hÂŽ`anao _q^]jko ĂŽaop]iko lkn _kjpejq]n h]o _kjrano]_ekjao _kj AQ( jk okhk ok^na aop]o _qaopekjao iecn]pkne]o( oejk ok^na _q]hmqean pai]( ok^na h] ^]oa `ah naolapk iqpqkĂ?* Aj qj _kiqje_]`k kĂš_e]h mqa nalnk`qfk ]uan ah kĂš_e]h `e]nek Cn]ji]( hko _q^]jko `efankj mqa Gahhu ĂŽbqa ]`ranpe`kĂ? ] oq hhac]`] ah ieŠn_khao `a mqa qj ejpan_]i) ^ek `a p]h j]pqn]hav] oanÂŽ] ĂŽ]fajk ]h aolÂŽnepq `a h]o _kjrano]_ekjao iecn]pkne]oĂ?*

P YbWl[i :[iZ[ Cƒn_Ye 9Kdei (&& YkXWdei _dZeYk# c[djWZei \k[hed h[fWjh_WZei Z[iZ[ Cƒn_Ye jhWi bW Ă…hcW Z[b WYk[hZe c_]hWjeh_e [djh[ bei Zei fW‡i[i [d (&&." [b YkWb Âş[ij| \kdY_edWdZe cko X_[dÂť" Z_`e [b [cXW`WZeh c[n_YWde [d 9kXW" =WXh_[b @_cƒd[p H[cki$

9Âş>W ^WX_Ze kdW YebWXehWY_ÂŒd h[Y‡fheYW" ^Wo gk[ Z[Y_h gk[ [ij| \kdY_edWdZe cko X_[dÂť" Z_`e @_cƒd[p" o fh[Y_iÂŒ gk[ [d Zei W‹ei \k[hed Z[fehjWZei W bW _ibW Âşc|i Z[ -& YkXWdei feh XWhYe o c|i Z[ '&& feh Wl_ÂŒdÂť$

@a ]dÂŽ mqa h] naqje“j aba_pq]) `] aj h] naoe`aj_e] `ah faba `a h] `elhki]_e] aop]`qje`ajoa ]mqÂŽ( Fkj]pd]j @* B]nn]n( oa ejpanlnap]) n] lkn ah ck^eanjk j]_ekj]h _kik _kjĂšni]_e“j `a mqa ĂŽoecqaj aj reckn hko ejopnqiajpko `a h] lkhÂŽpe_] oq^ranoer] _kjpn] ?q^]Ă?* Oac˜j ah

_kiqje_]`k kbe_e]h( aoa da_dk ĂŽlkja `a i]jeĂšaopk h] b]hp] `a rkhqjp]` na]h `a AQ l]n] iafkn]n hko rÂŽj_qhko _kj jqaopnk l]ÂŽo u l]n] `af]n ]pnƒo h]o ]__ekjao `a ^qn`] ejfanaj_e]( mqa deop“ne_]iajpa d]j oe`k ah i]ukn k^opƒ_qhk ] h] jkni]hev]) _e“j `a h]o nah]_ekjaoĂ?* Hko aop]`qje`ajoao ]hac]nkj mqa ah aj_qajpnk _kj hko klkoe) pknao( mqa jk peajaj aop]pqo ha) c]h aj h] eoh] u okj _kjoe`an]`ko ĂŽian_aj]nekoĂ? lkn h]o ]qpkne`]`ao hk_]hao( bkni] l]npa `a ĂŽqj] lnƒ_) pe_] `elhkiƒpe_]Ă? `a S]odejcpkj( `enece`] ] ĂŽi]jpajan _]j]hao `a _kiqje_]_e“j _kj nalnaoajp]jpao `a h] ok_ea`]` _erehĂ? `a _q]hmqean l]ÂŽo( jk okhk `a ?q^]* Bqajpao `elhkiƒpe_]o _kjbeni]nkj ]uan ] IEHAJEK mqa Gahhu ]^]j`kj“ h] eoh] aj h] i]Â’]j] `a ]uan u jk oa aolan]^]( `a ikiajpk( qj] naolqaop] ] h] `ajqj_e] _q^]j]* Oej ai^]nck( kpn]o bqajpao _kiajp]nkj mqa qj _kjpnkranpe`k _q^]jk)aop]`qje`aj) oa( mqa d]^nÂŽ] bkni]`k l]npa `a h] `ahac]_e“j `a aoa l]ÂŽo ] h]o lhƒpe_]o iecn]pkne]o( oa i]jpaj`nƒ aj H] D]^]j] d]op] i]Â’]j]*

:_bcW Hekii[\\ jecW [b h[b[le Z[ BkbW [d [b FJ ;H7B:E F;H;I%7F

;b FWhj_Ze Z[ bei JhWXW`WZeh[i FJ" _pgk_[hZW fheYbWcÂŒ \ehcWb# c[dj[ Wo[h W bW c_d_ijhW :_bcW Hekii[\\ Yece fh[YWdZ_ZWjW W bWi [b[YY_ed[i fh[i_Z[dY_Wb[i Z[ eYjkXh[ fWhW ikY[Z[h Wb WYjkWb cWdZWjWh_e o b‡Z[h Z[ [i[ fWh# j_Ze" Bk_p ?d|Y_e BkbW ZW I_blW$ Âş@Wc|i f[diƒ gk[ bW l_ZW c[ fedZh‡W Wdj[ i[c[`Wdj[ Z[iW\‡e" f[he be [d\h[dje Yed ^kc_bZWZ" i[h[d_ZWZ o Yed\_WdpWÂť" Z_`e Wb ^WXbWh oW Yece YWdZ_ZWjW" fWhW W]h[]Wh gk[ [d ik [l[djkWb ]eX_[hde Âşde ^WXh| h[jheY[iei d_ Wl[djkhWiÂť$ ;Yedec_ijW Z[ \eh# cWY_ÂŒd" Hekii[\\ [i WYjkWbc[dj[ bW `[\W Z[b =WX_d[j[ c_d_ij[h_Wb Z[ BkbW o i[]‘d bWi [dYk[ijWi ]epW Z[ (& W (. Z[ Wfeoe$

;b fh[i_Z[dj[ Z[b fWhbWc[dje YkXWde" HeX[hje 7bWhYÂŒd Ejpannkc]`k ]h ia`ek `ÂŽ] `a ]uan aj _q]jpk ] oe ah jqark aj) _kjpnkj]vk ^eh]pan]h _ann]nÂŽ] ah `eƒhkck lqjpq]h ]^eanpk ajpna h]o ]`iejeopn]_ekjao `a >]n]_g K^]i] u N]˜h ?]opnk( ah pepqh]n `a h] =o]i^ha] J]_ekj]h( Ne_]n) `k =h]n_“j( i]jpqrk h]o lqanp]o ]^eanp]o* ĂŽJk( uk jk _nak mqa pajc] mqa ejpannqilenoa( o]hrk mqa aj oq rk_]_e“j `a _]i^ek ah oaÂ’kn K^]i] bqan] ] d]_an hk ieoik mqa devk ah oaÂ’kn Caknca S* >qod ]jpanekniajpa $Ă…%( ao dkn] u] `a mqa aj S]odejcpkj d]u] cajpa _]) l]v `a _]i^e]n $h] lkhÂŽpe_] d]_e] h] eoh]% u ]_pq]n _kik ah iqj`k ajpank atecaĂ?( naolkj`e“ =h]n_“j ] h] lnajo] atpn]jfan]*

?kjoe`an“( ]`aiƒo( mqa h] ajpna) reop] _kj hko klkoepknao( mqa oac˜j hko _q^]jko bqankj pn]jolknp]`ko lkn ia`eko aop]`qje`ajoao ] h] naoe`aj_e] `a B]nn]n( ĂŽao narah]`kn] `a _“ik _kj h] ]_pq]h ]`iejeo) pn]_e“j( lk_k d] _]i^e]`k aj h] ]_pepq` d]_e] ?q^]Ă?* H] oq^oa_nap]) ne] `a Aop]`k >eo] Sehhe]io( mqeaj re]f“ ] H] D]^]j] aj oalpeai^na u jack_e“ _kj hko _q^]jko h] _k) iqje_]_e“j lkop]h `ena_p] ajpna hko `ko l]ÂŽoao( p]i^eŠj oa naqje“ _kj klkoepknao ]h ck^eanjk( lank ah ejpan_]i^ek okhk pn]o_aj`e“ ] h] lnajo] `ko `ÂŽ]o `aolqŠo `a mqa ahh] ]^]j`kj]n] h] eoh]( u jk cajan“ qj] na]__e“j _kik h] `a ]uan aj ah ck^eanjk _q^]jk* .D

;7K$ 7\_hcW [b `[\[ Z[ feb_Y‡W

9edjWYjei j[b[\ÂŒd_Yei _cfb_YWd Wb CeiiWZ [d Wi[i_dWje0 :kXW_ 7Xk :^WX_3<=<

&

h faba `a h] Lkhe_ÂŽ] `a @q^]e( cajan]h @]de F]hb]j P]iej( `efk ]uan mqa hko _kjp]_pko pahab“je_ko `a hko okola_dkoko _kj) Ăšni]j h] eilhe_]_e“j `ah Ikoo]`( ah oanre_ek oa_napk atpanekn eon]ahÂŽ( aj h] iqanpa `ah `enecajpa `a D]) i]o I]diq` ]h I]^dqd* Oac˜j `a_h]n]_ekjao nalnk`q) _e`]o aj h] lƒcej] sa^ `ah `e]nek cq^anj]iajp]h =h >]u]j( ah faba lkhe_e]h ]lqjp“ ] mqa h] ejraopec]) _e“j `a h]o hh]i]`]o `a hko oqlqao) pko eilhe_]`ko aj ah ]oaoej]pk `a

I]^dqd( _quk _]`ƒran bqa d]hh]`k aj qj dkpah ah l]o]`k ., `a ajank( eilhe_]j ]h Ikoo]`* Oej ai^]nck( jk `] iƒo `ap]hhao ok^na aop]o laomqeo]o u jk ]_h]n] oe oa naĂšan] ] hh]i]`]o na]hev]`]o aj hko `ÂŽ]o lnareko ]h ]oaoej]pk k lkopaneknao ]h ieoik* =Â’]`e“ mqa lkoaa p]i^eŠj ejbkni]_ekjao mqa _kjĂšni]j h] _kiln] lkn l]npa `a ]hcqjko `a hko eilhe_]`ko `a ^ehhapao `a ]re“j `a qj] _kil]Â’ÂŽ] ]Šna] `a qj pan_an l]ÂŽo ]`mqene`ko _kj p]nfap]o `a _nŠ`epk _kj hko ieoiko jki^nao `a hko l]o]lknpao `a `eopejp]o j]) _ekj]he`]`ao aqnkla]o* . D

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

5FOEFODJBT

j[dZ[dY_Wi6c_b[d_e$Yec

P YbWhWXeoW DK;LE :?DEI7KH?E

Pi_Y$$$ 7F

9h|d[e Z[ kd c[jhe Z[ bed# ]_jkZ gk[ f[hj[d[Y[ W kdW dk[lW \Wc_b_W Z[ J_hWdeiWkh_e h[n bbWcWZe Âş8_ij_ 8[ij_WÂť" ƒij[ i[ Z[iWhhebbÂŒ [d [b f[h_eZe Z[b 9h[j|Y_Ye Ikf[h_eh [d bW pedW Z[ Dk[le Cƒn_Ye" [d ;K$

‰&TUB JOTJHOJB FT FTQFDJBM QPS TFS EF QMBUB &T DBTJ TFHVSP RVF GVF VUJMJ[BEB QPS VO DBCBMMFSP EFM TlRVJUP EFM SFZ 3JDBS EP RVF BOEVWP DPO FM NPOBSDB IBTUB TV NVFSUF FO TV zMUJNB DBSHB EF DBCBMMFSpBŠ =b[d <eWhZ" _dl[ij_]WZeh Xh_j|d_Ye gk[ Wi[]khW ^WX[h [dYed# jhWZe [b bk]Wh [nWYje Z[ bW ck[hj[ Z[b h[o _d]bƒi H_YWhZe ???$

P l[djWdW NJM [nf[hjei [d j[Ydebe]‡W" fWhj_Y_fWhed ZkhWdj[ [b 9ed]h[ie CkdZ_Wb Z[ J[b[\ed‡W CŒl_b" be gk[ h[fh[# i[djW kd Wkc[dje Z[ ) c_b Wi_ij[dj[i h[if[Yje W (&&/" f[he kdW Z_ic_dkY_Œd Z[ + c_b fWhj_Y_fWdj[i [d YecfWhWY_Œd Yed (&&.$

I7H7 ;I9E87H

H[fh[i[djWd '-$* feh Y_[dje Z[ bW feXbWY_ÂŒd ckdZ_Wb" h[fehjW

>Wo '"',, c_bbed[i Z[ YWjŒb_Yei0 LWj_YWde 7kc[djWhed [d '- c_bbed[i h[if[Yje Wb ‘bj_ce Y[die Z[ (&&-1 WZ[c|i" \k[hed Z[i_]dWZei ',/ dk[lei eX_ifei [djh[ (&&- o (&&.

Iej[he Ceh[de" j_jkbWh Z[ bW 7ieY_WY_Œd C[n_YWdW Z[ Fi_Yebe]‡W 9b‡d_YW 7F

9_kZWZ Z[b LWj_YWde3Efk`d\o

Fi_YŒbe]ei f_Z[d c|i [ifWY_ei [d [b i[Yjeh Z[ bW iWbkZ f‘Xb_YW

&

h R]pe_]jk nalknp“ mqa ah j˜iank `a _]p“he_ko aj ah lh]jap] ]o_eaj`a ] ieh -22 iehhkjao( hk mqa nalnaoajp] -3*0 lkn _eajpk `a h] lk^h]_e“j iqj`e]h u qj ]qiajpk `a -5 iehhkjao `a lanokj]o naola_pk ] .,,3* Ao]o _ebn]o bqankj lnaoajp]`]o ]h l]l] >aja`e_pk TRE fqjpk ] h] a`e_e“j .,-, `ah =jq]nek LkjpeĂš_ek( ah He^nk nkfk( mqa _kjpeaja pk`] h] ejbkni]_e“j nah]per] ] h]o ejopepq) _ekjao( lanokj]o u knc]jeoiko `a) laj`eajpao `a h] Echaoe] _]p“he_]* Aj qj _kiqje_]`k( h] o]h] `a lnajo] r]pe_]j] naĂšne“ mqa ah lkj) pÂŽĂš_a ĂŽikopn“ cn]j ejpanŠoĂ? lkn ah nalknpa `a h] KĂš_ej] ?ajpn]h `a Aop]`ÂŽope_] `a h] Echaoe]( oac˜j ah _q]h hko _]p“he_ko ]qiajp]nkj -5 iehhkjao bnajpa ] hko ieh -03 ie) hhkjao naceopn]`ko aj .,,3* ĂŽ?kil]n]j`k aopko `]pko _kj h] arkhq_e“j `a h] lk^h]_e“j iqj) `e]h aj ah ieoik lanek`k( mqa d] l]o]`k `a oaeo ieh 2., ] oaeo ieh 3,, iehhkjao( oa k^oanr] mqa h] ej_e`aj_e] `a hko _]p“he_ko ] jerah lh]jap]nek ]qiajp“ haraiajpa `a -3*// ] -3*0 lkn _eajpkĂ?( `ap]hh“* Ah ejbknia ikopn“ mqa `qn]jpa .,,5 bqankj anece`]o lkn ah L]l] k_dk jqar]o `e“_aoeo u qj] lnah]pqn]( ieajpn]o qj] `a h]o ]jpaneknao bqa ahar]`] ] h] _]packnÂŽ] `a `e“_aoeo l]n] ]h_]jv]n ah j˜iank pkp]h `a `ko ieh 501 `ai]n_]_ekjao a_ha) oeƒope_]o aj ah iqj`k* =cnac“ mqa ah ]Â’k l]o]`k bqankj `aoecj]`ko -25 jqarko k^eolko( ieajpn]o mqa ajpna .,,3 u .,,4 ah j˜iank `a fan]n_]o _]p“he_ko ]q) iajp“ -*-/ lkn _eajpk( l]o]j`k `a _q]pnk ieh 502 ] _ej_k ieh `ko* Ah ej_naiajpk bqa oecjeĂš_]pe) rk aj ĂŁbne_] $-*4/ lkn _eajpk% u aj =iŠne_] $-*13%( oacqe`ko lkn =oe] $-*,5% u Aqnkl] $,*3,%* Aj aopa _]i) lk K_a]jÂŽ] naceopn“ aj ah ieoik lanek`k qj] p]o] `a r]ne]_e“j `a

Ieb_Y_jkZ _dj[]hWZW feh +&& [if[Y_Wb_ijWi

Cƒn_Ye3D`eX JXek`X^f

-

;b FWfW i[ ceijhÂŒ Yedj[dje feh bW Y_\hW h[fehjWZW iajko / lkn _eajpk* Naola_pk ] h] oepq]_e“j jqiŠne_] `a hko o]_an`kpao( ah R]pe_]jk narah“ mqa oa d] lnaoajp]`k qj] ĂŽarkhq_e“j lkoeper]( lank ik`an]`]Ă?( _kj qj _na_eieajpk aj pknjk ] qj lqjpk lkn_ajpq]h `a .,,3 ] Ăšj]hao `ah .,,4( _q]j`k oqi]^]j qj pkp]h `a 0,5 ieh -22* H] `eopne^q_e“j `ah _hank lkn _kjpejajpao aopƒ _]n]_panev]`] lkn qj] bqanpa lnar]haj_e] `a hko o]_an) `kpao aqnklako _kj 03*- lkn _eajpk( ieajpn]o hko ]iane_]jko oqi]j /, lkn _eajpk( hko ]oeƒpe_ko -/*. lkn _eajpk( hko ]bne_]jko 4*3 lkn _eajpk u `a K_a]jÂŽ] -*. lkn _eajpk* Ajpna .,,, u .,,4 jk oa naceopn“ qj ]qiajpk oecjeĂš_]perk `a h] ej_e) `aj_e] `a hko o]_an`kpao `a K_a]jÂŽ]( _na_e“ ah laok `ah _hank ]bne_]jk( ]iane_]jk u ]oeƒpe_k( ieajpn]o mqa ah aqnklak `ao_aj`e“( ]h l]o]n `a 1-*1 ] 03*- lkn _eajpk*

Aj ah ]Â’k .,,, h]o ikjf]o _]) p“he_]o oqi]^]j 4,- ieh -41 aj ah iqj`k( lank oq j˜iank `eoiejqu“ `a i]jan] lnkcnaoer] d]op] pk_]n h] _ebn] `a 3/5 ieh 23 aj .,,4* Hko cnqlko iƒo jqiankoko `a naheceko]o oa aj_qajpn]j aj Aqnk) l] $0,*5 lkn _eajpk% u aj =iŠne_] $.3*1%( oeaj`k Šopko hko `ko _kjpe) jajpao mqa aj hko ˜hpeiko jqara ]Â’ko lan`eankj iƒo ikjf]o( _kj `a_na_eieajpko `a -3*2 u -.*5 lkn _eajpk `a i]jan] naola_per]* Aj ah ieoik lanek`k( aj K_a]jÂŽ] ah j˜iank `a naheceko]o _]u“ aj qj -0*5 lkn _eajpk( ieajpn]o aj ĂŁbne_] u =oe] oa naceopn“ qj ]qiajpk `a _kjo]cn]`]o aj .-*. u -2*0 lkn _eajpk `a i]jan] naola_per]* = jerah chk^]h ah j˜iank `a _]j`e`]pko ]h o]_an`k_ek ]qiajp“ l]o]j`k `a --1 ieh 5-5 aj .,,3 ] --3 ieh .0 aj .,,4( _kj qj] p]o] `a _na_eieajpk `a -*- lkn _eajpk* .D

] =ok_e]_e“j Iate_]j] `a Loe_khkcÂŽ] ?hÂŽje_] u `a h] O]hq` ao qj] knc]jev]_e“j _kjbkni]`] lkn iƒo `a 1,, aola) _e]heop]o mqa ]^kn`]j h] loe_khkcÂŽ] _hÂŽje_] `ao`a `erano]o ]neop]o( ]qjmqa aj aopa ikiajpk oa aj_qajpn]j ^qo_]j`k aol]_eko aj ah ĂŽdaniŠ) pe_k oeopai] `a o]hq` j]_ekj]hĂ?( u] mqa( ]oacqn]j( jk d] oe`k r]hkn]`] h] h]^kn `ah loe_“hkck _hÂŽje_k lkn h]o ejopepq_ekjao u( oej ai^]nck( ao bqj`]iajp]h l]n] nabknv]n hko oanre_eko `a ]paj_e“j lnei]ne]* Okpank Iknajk ?]i]_dk( ieai) ^nk `a h] ]ok_e]_e“j u _]pa`nƒpe_k `a h] QJ=I( naoqia h] lkhÂŽpe_] l˜^he_] `ah Aop]`k aj i]pane] `a o]hq` _kik `aĂš_eajpa u( `e_a( ao h] _]qo] `a mqa ĂŽaopaiko hhac]j`k oeailna p]n`a ] ]paj`an hko lnk^hai]o _q]j`k oa aj_qajpn]j bqan] `a _kjpnkhĂ?* ÂŤGkƒ fhefk[ijWi j_[d[d Yece WieY_WY_ÂŒd fWhW c[`ehWh [b i_ij[cW Z[ iWbkZ5 D]_aiko qj hh]i]`k _kjop]jpa ] h]o ejopepq_ekjao l]n] mqa oa ]_anmqaj ] hko cnqlko lnkbaoekj]hao lknmqa ao ]dÂŽ `kj`a aopƒj _kj_ajpn]`ko hko atlanpko mqa ajpeaj`aj mqa aj aop] `ejƒie_] `a ]ok_e]_e“j `a ok_ea`]` lnkbaoekj]h ao iq_dk iƒo bƒ_eh `]n okhq_e“j ] lnk^hai]o mqa oa lqa`aj aop]n lnaoajp]j`k ] jerah ok_e]h* ÂŤ9k|b [i ik fhefk[ijW fWhW bWi _dij_jk# Y_ed[i" ^Wd jhWXW`WZe [d Yed`kdje5 Jk d]j ateope`k lnklqaop]o `ena_) p]o( lank oeailna mqa d]u qj bknk d]_aiko lnaoaj_e] lknmqa iq_dko `a hko aol]_eko `a hko pki]`knao

`a `a_eoekjao jk okj atlanpko aj ah ƒna]( ]hcqjko oÂŽ peajaj qj lk_k `a p]hajpk( hk mqa d]_aj ao nk`a]noa `a qj cnqlk `a atlanpko mqeajao hao `e_aj _“ik bk_]hev]n( _“ik ia`e]n( mqŠ `a_en( ap_*7 aok aj ah iafkn `a hko _]oko( _q]j`k jk oa aopƒ nk`a]`k `a qj cnqlk `a atlanpko( oa pki]j aj cajan]h `a_eoekjao ann“ja]o* H] _qhpqn] `a o]hq` ao qj] b]) hh] mqa ateopa( oeailna aop]iko ^qo_]j`k ah l]he]perk* @ao]bkn) pqj]`]iajpa aj h] i]uknÂŽ] `a h]o ejopepq_ekjao lqa`a d]^an 1, iŠ`e_ko aj qj ƒna] u qj loe_“hkck l]n] pnao ƒna]o* ?q]j`k ah iŠ`e_k aola_e]heop] k ah iŠ`e_k cajan]h peaja h] _anpav] `a `a_en( ^qajk u] ha `eiko pn]p]ieajpk `a p]h _ko]( u qopa` oa oecqa mqaf]j`k( ] hk ia) fkn ao _kjrajeajpa mqa l]oa _kj ah loe_“hkck( lknmqa aopk l]na_ean] mqa oa o]ha `ah _kjpnkh ^ekh“ce_k( ajpkj_ao l]o]iko ] kpnk lh]jk mqa oanÂŽ] ah aik_ekj]h* ÂŤ9ÂŒce [ij| _dj[]hWZW bW WieY_WY_ÂŒd5 ĂŁna]o aola_ÂŽĂš_]o jk lk`nÂŽ] `aheie) p]n( lank okiko ]hna`a`kn `a 1,, lanokj]o aj ah @B( lnƒ_pe_]iajpa pk`] h] lh]jpehh] `a h] B]_qhp]` `a loe_khkcÂŽ] `eolqaop] ] _kh]^kn]n( ]`aiƒo hko `a hko aop]`ko* Ao qj cnqlk iqu cn]j`a mqa oe hko oeo) pai]o `a o]hq` lqoean]j ]paj_e“j ] hk mqa ] jerah ok_e]h hko loe_“hk) cko lqa`aj d]_an u hko jerahao `a eil]_pk mqa oa lqa`aj hkcn]n _kj oq pn]^]fk( aj h] ia`e`] aj mqa oa ]peaj`] h] o]hq` iajp]h `ah ej`e) re`qk `ao`a oqo ^]oao paj`naiko qj] lk^h]_e“j iƒo o]j]* .D

D@C<E@F

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

$VMUVSB

;Z_jeh0 "SJFM (PO[fMF[ YkbjkhW$Z\6c_b[d_e$Yec

P jec[ dejW

PZ[b_jei c[deh[i$$$

9ECF7yÑ7 :; :7DP7 ;I9xD?97 ;D DE9>;I :; 97<x

6OB PCSB EF &VHFOJP .FSJOP IB HFOFSBEP VOB JOUFOTB QPMlNJDB F JODMVTP MB SFQSPCBDJuO EF MB &NCBKBEB EF *TSBFM FO &TQBtB MB QJF[B EJDFO FT IJSJFOUF QBSB MPT KVEpPT &M BVUPS TJO FNCBSHP BTFHVSB RVF TuMP RVFSpB NPTUSBS UPMFSBODJB B UPEBT MBT SFMJHJPOFT "Z DPO MBT JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT

;b Âş;diWcXb[Âť 9ecfW‹‡W Z[ :WdpW ;iYƒd_YW gk[ Z_h_][ [b cW[ijhe >[dhho J[cW" [ijWh| [d [b jhWZ_Y_edWb fhe]hWcW ÂşDeY^[i Z[ 9W\ÂƒÂť" [b fhÂŒn_ce cWhj[i ()" W bWi (&0)& ^ehWi" [d [b fWj_e Y[djhWb Z[ 9WiW Z[ bW 9kbjkhW Z[ 9eb_cW$ ;b Âş;diWcXb[Âť 9ecfW‹‡W Z[ :WdpW ;iYƒd_YW" fWhj_Y_fÂŒ [d (&&-" [d [b <[ij_lWb <ebabÂŒh_Ye Z[ :WbbWi" J[nWi" o l_W`ÂŒ Wb <[ij_lWb Z[ bW Âş<_[ijW W bW =kWdjWdWc[hWÂť [d =kWdj|dWce" 9kXW" be]hWdZe Yedgk_ijWh W dk[lei f‘Xb_Yei Z[ ejhei fW‡i[i$

P fWhW l[h ;<;

J_je#\eje" [nfei_# Y_Œd gk[ ZW Yk[d# jW Z[ bW fWi_Œd Z[ @ei_f 8hep" J_je" fh[i_Z[dj[ Yeckd_ijW Z[ Ok]eibWl_W" feh bW \eje]hW\‡W

;d IWdjW 7dW P[]WY^[" Z[ifkƒi Z[ Wb]kdei W‹ei Z[ f[hcWd[Y[h [d [b ebl_Ze" kd ]hkfe [dYWX[pWZe feh ck`[h[i š\kdZWZe feh [b f_djeh eWnWgk[‹e HeZeb\e CehWb[iš h[ijWkhW kdW _]b[i_W Z[b i_]be NL??? `kdje Yed iki j[iehei Whgk_j[YjÂŒd_Yei EWnWYW3JXdl\c D\j`eXj

.

qu pailn]jk( ah oehaj_ek mqa aj) rqahra ] O]jp] =j] Vac]_da( aj K]t]_]( ao `eoel]) `k lkn ah nqe`k `a Hko P]hhanao ?k) iqjep]neko( q^e_]`ko aj ah _qn]pk `a h] echaoe] `ao`a -553( `kj`a h]o ]_pere`]`ao _kieajv]j `ao`a iqu pailn]jk* Pn]^]f]j aj ahhko -1 lanokj]o( `a ajpna -4 u /1 ]Â’ko `a a`]`* Oeapa iqfanao( k_dk dki^nao* Oq h]^kn ao na_qlan]n ah ]npa o]_nk mqa( lkn h]nck peailk( aopqrk ao_kj`e`k aj h] l]nnkmqe] lnej_el]h6 qj _k) hkne`k pailhk `kieje_k `ah oechk TREEE( nao_]p]`k lkn hko lej_ahao `ah lejpkn k]t]mqaÂ’k Nk`khbk Ikn]hao* O]jp] =j] Vac]_da oa aj_qaj) pn] ] lk_k iƒo `a qj] dkn] `a h] _]lep]h k]t]mqaÂ’]* Lanpaja_a ]h iqje_elek `a K_kphƒj( `kj`a j]) _e“ Ikn]hao( u ao qj] _kiqje`]` _kj ]laj]o . ieh 1,, d]^ep]jpao( ]ba_p]`] lkn h] iecn]_e“j* Ah lejpkn k]t]mqaÂ’k `a_e`e“ ajoaÂ’]n naop]qn]_e“j ] pn]rŠo `a aopko p]hhanao( _kj h] ejpaj_e“j `a mqa cajan]n]j ailhako ] h]o iq) fanao u h]o nah]_ekj]n] _kj lnk_aoko lnk`q_perko* I“je_] C]hrƒj ?nqv bqa qj] `a ahh]o* Oa ejo_ne^e“ ]h o]hen `a h] oa_qj`]ne] u ]dkn]( -/ ]Â’ko `aolqŠo( ao h] iƒo atlaneiajp]`] `a h]o l]npe_el]jpao* ĂŽ=h lnej_elek bqeiko `eav u pan) iej]iko oeaj`k -4* Ah i]aopnk lnabanÂŽ] ailha]n ] h]o iqfanao( lknmqa `a_ÂŽ] pajÂŽ]j iƒo d]^e) he`]`ao aj h]o i]jko ] h] dkn] `a ^kn`]n u ]h na]hev]n ah pn]^]fk iejq_ekok _kj hko lej_ahao u h]o lejpqn]oĂ?( na_qan`]*

J[iehe iWYhe =h k^oanr]n h] b]_d]`] `ah pailhk `a O]jp] =j] Vac]_da( `a ejia`e]pk ]l]na_a h] l]hap] `a _khkn `a Nk`kh) bk Ikn]hao* Aj hko je_dko( `kj`a `a^anÂŽ]j aop]n Ăš cqn]o `a ƒjcahao k o]jpko( ah ]npeop] _khk_“ f]nnkjao hhajko `a Ă› knao* U ] qj h]`k `a h]o _khqij]o cneac]o( `aheja“ qj l]n `a aolec]o mqa ]r]jv]j lkn h] l]) na` ] h] l]n `a bkni]o cakiŠpne_]o paÂ’e`]o `a ]vqh _eahk* = h] ajpn]`]( `ko leh]o ^]qpeoi]hao _kj Ăš cqn]o `a oan]Ăš jao ]h]`ko( na_e) ^aj ] hko bahecnaoao* =`ajpnk( ah oehaj_ek u h] ko_qne`]` nalko]j( ieajpn]o h] hqv j]pqn]h ehqiej] hko nap]^hko ailkpn]`ko ok^na h]o l]na`ao( hko _q]hao k_qhp]j h] lejpqn] iqn]h mqa `a_kn] pk`] h] aniep]*

H[iYWjWd Whj[

I7CK;B C;I?D7I

iWYhe Z[ j[cfbe Zec_d_Ye [d EWnWYW I7CK;B C;I?D7I

<WY^WZW Z[b j[cfbe [d IWdjW 7dW P[]WY^[" [d EYejb|d" EWnWYW

H[jWXbei XWhheYei" cWdkiYh_jei" f_djkhWi o [iYkbjkhWi Yed\ehcWd bW h_gk[pW Z[ [ij[ j[cfbe Ah paoknk `ao_q^eanpk lkn Ikn]hao oqi] `k_a nap]^hko ^]nnk_ko `ah oechk TREEE( i]jqo_nepko ]jpecqko `ah oechk TREE ]h TET( qj] _kha__e“j `a aolafko _kj oqo i]n_ko aopkb]`ko u qj] oanea `a lejpqn]o u ao_qhpqn]o naheceko]o* Oa leajo] mqa pk`] aop] k^n] bqa ao_kj) `e`] `ajpnk `a aop] echaoe] aj h] Šlk_] `a h] nabkni]( k aj h] cqann] _neopan]* Lank jk d]u mqeaj na_qan`a _“ik hhac]nkj7 oeilhaiajpa oa naiepaj ] nah]p]n h] ieo) i] deopkne]6 pk`ko hko k^fapko aop]^]j cq]n`]`ko aj _]i]o `a _]nnevk u kpnko ok^nalqaopko aj hko je_dko* ĂŽH] _kiqje`]` jk pajÂŽ]j e`a] `a hk mqa pajÂŽ]j( j]`ea r]hkn]^] h] ao_qhpqn]( h] lejpqn]( hko nap]^hko* Pk`k aop]^] aj nqej]o( da_dk la`]vko( p]l]`koĂ?( naiaikn] C]hrƒj*

H[WYj_lWd fheo[Yje Aj .,,-( Ikn]hao iqne“ u hko p]hha) nao `apqreankj oqo h]^knao7 ]hcqj]o ejpacn]jpao iecn]nkj( ieajpn]o mqa kpn]o pn]^]f]nkj aj h] naop]qn]_e“j `a O]jpk @kiejck u ah pa]pnk I]_a`kjek =h_]hƒ* Bqa d]op] .,,0( _q]j`k h] naop]qn]`k) n] Cakncej] O]h`]’] na]_per“ ah lnkua_pk ia`e]jpa h] ]uq`] `a r]neko ]_pknao ok_e]hao( ajpna ahhko h] Bqj`]_e“j D]nl Dah˜ u ah ]npeop] lhƒope_k @aieƒj Bhknao( mqeaj ejrkhq_n“ ] _na]`knao _kjpailk) nƒjako l]n] ejpanrajen hko aolafko _kj i]n_k `a aopkb]`k( l]n] `aolqŠo oan nalnk`q_e`ko aj hko p]hhanao u _kian) _e]hev]`ko l]n] na_]q`]n bkj`ko* Aj h] ]_pq]he`]` aj hko p]hhanao oa `] naop]qn]_e“j `a nap]^hko u k^n] _k)

hkje]h( oanre_eko `a naop]qn]_e“j p]jpk ] _kha__ekjao l]npe_qh]nao _kik `a kpnko pailhko `a h] na) ce“j* =oÂŽ( ia`e]jpa `]n qj] ^a_] a_kj“ie_]( oa cajan] ailhako ] iqfanao _kik Pki]o] Iao]( `a /2 ]Â’ko( i]`na okhpan]( mqeaj d] nacnao]`k ] oq _kiqje`]`* ĂŽIa cqop] aopa pn]^]fk lknmqa jqj_] lajoŠ hhac]n ] nal]n]n qj] k^n] `a h] echaoe]* Ha aj_qajpnk qj r]hkn mqa jk ao a_kj“ie_k( oejk mqa ao qj l]pneikjek l]n] jkokpnko( aopku _kjpajp] `a _kjpne^qen*Ă? H] naop]qn]`kn] `aop]_] h] l]npe_el]_e“j @aieƒj Bhk) nao _kik rep]h( ]h ejrkhq_n]n ] iƒo `a _ej_qajp] ]npeop]o( ĂŽmqeajao cajanko]iajpa d]j _kh]^kn]`k l]n] hkcn]n ah k^faperk lneikn`e]h6 mqa h] _kiqje`]` pkia _kj) _eaj_e] ]_an_] `ah bqpqnk nah]_ekj]`k _kj hko lnk^ha) i]o `a iecn]_e“jĂ?* U ok^na hko lnkua_pko ] bqpqnk( Cakncej] O]h`]) Â’] lh]jpa] naop]qn]n hko nap]^hko mqa naocq]n`] ah pailhk( d]_an qj] lamqaÂ’] o]h] `a atde^e_e“j `a k^n]o naop]qn]`]o `ajpnk `a qj] _]lehh]7 u aj ah _qn]pk qj _ajpnk `a na_qla) n]_e“j `a kĂš _eko6 da) nnanÂŽ] u repn]haoĂ?* ĂŽNk`khbk Ikn]hao _naÂŽ] mqa O]jp] =j] Vac]_da `a^ÂŽ] oan l]npa `a qj] nqp] pqnÂŽope_] lkn ia`ek `a h] _q]h lq`ean] _na_an aj qj ^qaj oajpe`k( r]hkn]j) `k oq deopkne] u l]pneik) jekĂ?( Ăš j]hev]* .D

Domingo 21 de febrero de 2010

21

cine FOTOS: AFP Y REUTERS

e d o s O l e a n a g i k s n a Pol n ó i c c e r i D r o j Plata por Me

polanski En abril de 1969 su esposa, la actriz Sharon Tate, con un embarazo de ocho meses, fue víctima de la banda de Charles Manson, en su casa en Los Ángeles mientras el director se encontraba en rodaje en Londres. En 1977, Samantha Gailey, de 13 años, acusó al director de haberla llevado a casa de Jack Nicholson para fotografiarla, y declaró que el cineasta le había dado bebidas alcohólicas y drogas, para posteriormente violarla.

E DPA Berlín

h _eja]op] Nki]j Lk) h]joge oa ]hv _kj ah Kok `a Lh]p] ] h] Iafkn @e) na__e j lkn Pda Cdkop Snepan aj h] 2,] a`e_e j `a h] >anhej]ha( oac j ]jqj_e dku ah fqn]`k lnaoe`e`k lkn ah `ena_pkn ]hai j Sanjan Danvkc* Ah aopnajk `a h] _ejp] `a Lkh]joge( lnkp]ckjev]`] lkn hko ]_pknao As]j I_Cnackn u Lean_a >nkoj]j( bqa qjk `a hko i o aolan]`ko `ah _anp]iaj _ejai]pkcn be_k ]jpa ah ikn^k ca) jan]`k lkn h] ]qoaj_e] `ah _eja]op]( mqa oa aj_qajpn] ^]fk ]nnaopk `kie) _ehe]nek aj Oqev]* Oej ai^]nck( je >nkoj]j je I_Cnackn q Khere] Sehhe]io( ]_pknao `a h] _ejp]( ]_q`eankj dku ] h] c]h] mqa lqok bej ] h] >anhej]ha u bqankj hko lnk`q_pknao `a h] _ejp]( Nk^ >aj) iqoo] u =h]ej O]n`a mqeajao oa aj) _]nc]nkj `a na_e^en ah c]h]n` j* O]n`a hau qj iajo]fa `a Lkh]jo) ge6 Î=qjmqa dq^ean] lk`e`k( jk d]) ^n ] e`k( lqao h] hpei] rav mqa ]_q) ` ] qj baoper]h ] na_e^en qj lnaiek( ]_]^ aj h] _ n_ahÏ* Aj Pda Cdkop Snepan( I_Cnackn rqahra ] iapanoa aj h] leah `a qj ao) _nepkn( _kik u] de_ean] aj Ikqhej Nkqca( lank aop] rav _kj qj aj_]nck iqu aola_e]h6 oan ah ]qpkn b]jp]o) i] mqa na`]_p]n h]o iaikne]o `ah lneian iejeopnk ^nep je_k* U ] opa( qj be_pe_ek Ð=`]i H]jcÑ( `] re`] ah at ]cajpa ,,3( Lean_a >nkoj]j* C]j]`kn `a qj Ko_]n lkn Ah le]) jeop]( ah oalpq]caj]nek _eja]op] bn]j) _klkh]_k rqahra ] oan `eopejcqe`k aj h] >anhej]ha( mqa aj -521 ha `ek ah Kok `a Lh]p] lkn Nalqhoe j u `ko ] ko `aolq o ah `a Knk lkn ?qh `a O]_* Lkh]joge bqa `apaje`k aj oalpeai) ^na `ah ] k l]o]`k aj Oqev] lkn qj `ahepk `a ]^qok oatq]h ] qj] iajkn( _kiape`k d]_a i o `a pnao ` _]`]o* =_pq]hiajpa( Lkh]joge oa aj_qaj) pn] ^]fk ]nnaopk `kie_ehe]nek aj oq _d]hap `a hko =hlao( aj `kj`a l]o] peailk _kj oq b]iehe] ieajpn]o h]o ]qpkne`]`ao naoqahraj mq d]_an _kj oq oepq]_e j*

Pierce Brosnan, Olivia Williams y Ewan McGragor no asistieron

Relata la historia del escritor de las memorias del primer ministro Ah pne^qj]h `a Hko ãjcahao mqa hha) r] oq _]ok na_d]v aj ajank oq okhe) _epq` `a oan fqvc]`k aj ]qoaj_e]*

La premiación H] >anhej]ha `eopejcqe _kj ah Kok `a Knk ] h] Iafkn Lah _qh] ] h] _ejp] pqn) _] >]h $Ieah%( `ah _eja]op] Oaied G]) lh]jkchq* ?kj >]h( aji]n_]`] aj hko l]eo]fao `a h] _kop] `ah I]n Jacnk( Pqnmq ] oa d]_a _kj ah i teik c]) h]n` j `ah Baoper]h Ejpanj]_ekj]h `a >anh j lkn lneian] rav aj 02 ] ko* H] lk pe_] _ejp] u oq ajpanja_a`kn lnkp]ckjeop]( qj je k oaie]qpeop](

_eann]j h] pnehkc ] `a G]lh]jkchq ok) ^na h] re`] `a Uqoqb( pn]o `ko lnk`q_) _ekjao( qj] hh]i]`] Acc $dqark% u h] oacqj`]( Iehg $ha_da%* Lkn oq l]npa( h] ]_pnev f]lkjao] Odejk^q Pan]fei] oa hhar ah Kok `a Lh]p] ] h] Iafkn Ejpanlnap]_e j Ba) iajej] lkn h] lah _qh] ]jpe^ ^he_] ?]panlehh]n( `a Gkfe S]g]i]poq( u hko nqoko Cneckne @k^nucej u Oancqae Lqogal]heo oa ]hv]nkj _kj ah ieoik c]h]n` j aj ah nq^nk i]o_qhejk lkn Dks E Aj`a` Pdeo Oqiian( `a =hatae Lklkcna^ogu* Ah Kok `a Lh]p] `ah Cn]j Lnaiek `ah Fqn]`k aj aop] 2,] a`e_e j `ah _anp]iaj _ejai]pkcn be_k bqa _kj) _a`e`k ]h `a^qp]jpa Bhknej Oan^]j lkn oq `n]i] fqrajeh Eb E S]jp Pk Sdeopha( E Sdeopha( _ejp] mqa p]i) ^e j na_kce =hbna` >]qan* Ah fqn]`k kbe_e]h( ajpna _quko ieai^nko becqn]j h] ]_pnev Naj a Vahhsacan u ah lnk`q_pkn aol] kh Fk) o I]n ] Ikn]hao( `a_e`e kpknc]n ah c]h]n` j ]h i nepk ]np ope_k `ao) p]_]`k ] L]rah Gkopki]nkr $Nqoe]% lkn oq `ena__e j ]np ope_] aj Dks E Aj`a` Pdeo Oqiian* Ieajpn]o p]jpk( ah lnaiek ]h Ia) fkn Cqe j bqa l]n] S]jc Mq]jÑ]j $?dej]% lkn Pq]j Uq]j $=l]np Pkca) pdan% u h] Aop]pqehh] `a Lh]p] ] h] Ia) fkn êlan] Lnei] na_]u aj h] oqa_] Oa^^a( `a >]^]g J]f]be* H] _ejp] ^nep je_k)^n]oeha ] S]opa H]j`( `a Hq_u S]hgan( qj `k_qiaj) p]h ok^na h] re`] `a mqeajao `alaj) `aj `a hko ajkniao ^]oqnanko `a h]o ]bqan]o `a N k `a F]jaenk( bqa `eopej) cqe`] _kj ah Lnaiek `ah L ^he_k `a h] oa__e j L]jkn]i] u _kj ah `a =i) jeop ] Ejpanj]_ekj]h* Ah l] o ]jbepne j( mqa _kjp]^] _kj pnao `a h]o ., lah _qh]o mqa _kila) p ]j aj h] Oa__e j Kbe_e]h u _q]pnk _klnk`q__ekjao( oa mqa` _kj h]o i]jko r]_ ]o* Hk ieoik ha oq_a`e ] h] je_] _ejp] aj aol] kh `a h] iqaopn]( h] ]ncajpej] Nkila_]^av]o `a h] `a) ^qp]jpa J]p]he] Oienjkbb( laoa ] h] ^qaj] ]_kce`] mqa pqrk ajpna h] _n ) pe_] u ah l ^he_k*

Polanski fue acusado. Se declaró culpable del cargo menor de tener relaciones sexuales ilícitas con una menor y fue condenado a 90 días de prisión, pero le dieron un permiso de otros 90 días para terminar un proyecto. El 1° de febrero de 1978 Polanski voló a Londres y de ahí a Francia, país en el que tiene nacionalidad, evitando su extradición. Desde entonces vivió en Francia y Polonia evitando naciones que pudieran detenerlo.

Aunque hubiera podido, no habría ido, pues la última vez que acudí a un festival a recibir un premio acabé en la cárcel” Roman Polanski

En comunicado oficial

Semih Kaplanoglu, el director turco que se llevó el premio a la Mejor Película por Honey (Bal)

El 26 de septiembre del año pasado, el cineasta fue arrestado, a petición de la justicia de EU, en Zúrich, lugar al que acudió a recibir un galardón.

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

QBTBUJFNQPT

[b j_[cfe Yehh[e6c_b[d_eYeb_cW$Yec$cn

YhkY_]hWcW

ikZeak

?dijhkYY_ed[i0

J[b \edei Z[ _dj[h i

FbWd[j IodZ_YWj_ed

IebkY_ d Z[b Wdj[h_eh

Bb[dW YWZW ikX#YkWZh YkbW Z[ )n) Yed bei d c[hei Z[b ' Wb / W fWhj_h Z[ bei gk[ oW [ij|d i[ WbWZei [d YWZW Y[bZW" f[he de h[f_jWi d_d] d d c[he [d kdW c_icW \_bW" YebkcdW e ikXYkWZh YkbW$ IebkY_ d Z[b Wdj[h_eh

>EH?PEDJ7B;I0 '$ =hWl[ZWZ o YecfeijkhW [d bW WYj_jkZ o [b i[cXbWdj[$ ,$ >ecXh[ W\[c_dWZe Wh][dj_d_ice $ '&$ 7X_[hje" [d _d]b i$ ''$ BW iWd]h[ Z[ bei Z_ei[i [d bei

Fe[cWi >ec h_Yei$ '($ @[Wd FWkb±" feb j_Ye h[lebkY_edWh_e \hWdY i" Wi[i_dWZe feh 9^Whbejj[ 9ehZWo [d '-/)$ '*$ =kWh_ZW Z[ eiei$ '-$ :_ei" [djh[ bei cW^ec[jWdei$ '.$

:_\[h[dj[i" Z_ij_djWi$ (($ :Wj_le b[YY_ d$ ',$ 9_kZWZ Z[b Y[djhe Z[b fhedecXh[ f[hiedWb Z[ Z[ ?jWb_W KcXh W $ 9[djhe jkh i# j[hY[hW f[hiedW$ ()$ 7hj Ykbe j_Ye o Z[ f[h[]h_dWY_ed[i$ '/$ d[kjhe$ (*$ IW]hWh_e±[ifeiW Okdgk[ f[gk[ e Z[ fbWj[hei$ Z[b \kjXeb_ijW ;dh_gk[ 8eh`W$ (+$ (&$ Lk[bl[d W Z[Y_h be gk[ Wdj[i B[jhW ]h_[]W gk[ Yehh[ifedZ[ oW ^WX Wd Z_Y^e$ ('$ 7l[ jh[fW# W bW F$ (,$ FWjh d" Zk[ e$ (.$ ZehW Z[ C n_Ye$ (-$ EdZW [d ;if[Y_[ Z[ l XehW cko l[d[# bW ikf[hÅY_[ Z[ bWi W]kWi$ (/$ deiW$ (/$ ;d cWoeh YWdj_ZWZ$ FhedecXh[ fei[i_le$ )'$ 7fW# )&$ 7b[he Z[b j[`WZe$ )($ 8k[o hWje Z[ cWZ[hW fWhW j[d[h bWi gk[ Yedi_Z[hWXWd iW]hWZe bei WhcWi fbkhWb $ ))$ ;ijhef[WZWi Wdj_]kei []_fY_ei$ )*$ Kj_b_pWh$ feh de i[h h[Y_[dj[i$ )*$ 9WdWb )+$ BW b[jhW ; bWh]W Z[ bei ]h_[# gk[ YedZkY[ bW eh_dW \k[hW ]ei$ )-$ 7]WhhWZ[hWi$ )/$ CeZe Z[ bW l[`_]W$ )+$ DecXh[ Z[ bW fWhj_YkbWh Z[ i[h e Z[ ^WY[h b[jhW D$ ),$ BWXh bW j_[hhW Yed [b kdW YeiW fbkhWb $ *($ H[^WX_b_jWh" WhWZe$ ).$ B_X_Z_deie" bWiY_le$ *&$ h[ijWXb[Y[h" h[[ZkYWh$ **$ C[jWb FbWpW f Xb_YW [d bWi Y_kZWZ[i fh[Y_eie$ *+$ Fe[cW Z[ij_dWZe Z[ bW =h[Y_W Wdj_]kW$ *'$ Ebeh W i[h YWdjWZe$ *,$ F[p cWh_de W]hWZWXb[" f[h\kc[$ *($ 9Wf_jWb gk[ i[ WZ^_[h[ W bei eX`[jei Z[ ?jWb_W$ *)$ 8WjhWY_e Wdkhe$ *-$ ÆejWdj[i$ *.$ FheY[Z[h" Z[h_lWh I cXebe gk c_Ye Z[b Wh] d$ *.$ kdW YeiW Z[ ejhW$ */$ 9eY_dWh FhedecXh[ f[hiedWb$ W \k[]e Z_h[Yje$ +&$ 9WdiWZW" BWkhW Jehh[i CWhj d[p i_d \k[hpWi$ IEBK9?ÕD 7B 7DJ;H?EH L;HJ?97B;I0 ($ 8[X_ZW WbYe# ^ b_YW ^[Y^W Yed cW p$ )$ ?dj[h`[YY_ d" lep fWhW [ij_# ckbWh W bei d_ ei W b[lWd# jWhi[$ *$ ;d\WZWh" [de`Wh$ +$ Fh[Å`e d[]Wj_le0 Wki[dY_W Z[$ ,$ 7ÅhcWY_ d$ -$ F[hi[# ]k_ZW Yed [cf[ e$ .$ =ehhe gk[ kiWXWd bei iebZWZei [ifW eb[i$ /$ 9h_XW ]hWdZ[ fWhW Wl[djWh [b jh_]e$ '($ LWb_`W Z[b Yehh[e \hWdY i$ ')$ 7hWi bW j_[hhW feh becei$ '+$ Lk[bl[ W [nfb_YWh kdW

8ecX[hei 9eb_cW )'(#+.+. 8ecX[hei L_bbW Z[ ÎblWh[p )''#,&,, 9hkp He`W 9eb_cW )')#.-.- 9hkp He`W J[Yec|d )(*#'&&' 9hkp He`W 7hc[h W )((#&-'& 9hkp He`W CWdpWd_bbe )),#+--& Fhej[YY_ d 9_l_b 9eb_cW )')#&)'' Fhej[YY_ d 9_l_b J[Yec|d )(*#&('+ Fhej[YY_ d 9_l_b C_dWj_jb|d )),#&&/' Fhej[YY_ d 9_l_b 9kWk^j[ceY )(.#&.&/ Fhej[YY_ d 9_l_b CWdpWd_bbe )),#-)&& F<F 9eb_cW )(.#&-(+ F<F J[Yec|d )(*#+&+& F<F CWdpWd_bbe )),# +,-- Feb_Y_W ;ijWjWb Fh[l[dj_lW )'(#(&/& 7d][b[i L[hZ[i 9eb_cW )),#,,&& Jh|di_je o L_Wb_ZWZ 9eb_cW )'*#/('( Jh|di_je o L_Wb_ZWZ 9egk_cWjb|d )()#&''' Jh|di_je o L_Wb_ZWZ CWdpWd_bbe )((#'/*, Jh|di_je o L_Wb_ZWZ L_bbW Z[ ÎblWh[p )',#))', Jh|di_je o L_Wb_ZWZ 7hc[h W )((#&'/'

Y_d[ <

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

Y _ d [

()

;IJH;DEI

9edj_d W [d YWhj[b[hW 7 7770 BW F[b YkbW IjWhZkij0 [b c_ij[h_e 7 @kb_[ @kb_W Z[ bW [ijh[bbW 8 7bcWi FWiW`[hWi

;ijW ^_ijeh_W Yec_[dpW [d kdW f[# 8 BbWcWdZe 7b 7ceh gk[ W Y_kZWZ Z[ ?d]bWj[hhW o gk[ j[hc_dW [d bk]Wh[i gk[ [n_ij[d 8 ;b 9kWhje 9edjWYje i be [d [b h[_de Z[ bW _cW]_dWY_ d$

[d 9eb_cW

9ec[djWh_ei o ik][h[dY_Wi Yehh[e6c_b[d_eYeb_cW$Yec$cn ;d YWhj[b[hW

;

7 D ? C 7 9 ? Õ D 7770 BW F[b YkbW 7

;

@kb_[ @kb_W 7

;

;d [b ckdZe Z[ bWi bkY^Wi Z[ 777 Jh_fb[ 7 bei eZ_ei [djh[ hkZei o j Yd_Yei ^Wd [n_ij_Ze Z[iZ[ i_[cfh[" f[he dkdYW iWb_[hed Z[ bei b c_j[i Z[b h_d]$$$ ¬^WijW ^eo JeZe Yec_[dpW ZkhWdj[ kdW deY^[ Z[ bkY^Wi" YkWdZe BW FWhaW b[ Whh[XWjW [b YWcf[edWje W 7X_ice D[]he" h[ikh]_[dZe Yed [ije bei Wdj_]kei h[dYeh[i o [b fbWd Z[ WYWXWh Yed bW 777$ 7feoWZe feh 9^[iicWd o 9oX[hd j_Ye" 7X_ice _d_Y_W ik l[d]WdpW$ :_h[Yjeh0 7bX[hje 9^_de HeZh ]k[p % = d[he0 7d_cWY_ d % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 7 % :khWY_ d0 -- % FW i Eh_][d0 C n_Ye % 7 e0 (&&/

8WiWZW [d Zei ^_ijeh_Wi l[h Z_YWi" @kb_[ @kb_W [djh[bWpW bW l_ZW Z[ Zei ck`[h[i gk[ Wkdgk[ [ij|d i[fWhWZWi feh [b j_[cfe o [b [ifWY_e" WcXWi i[ [dYk[djhWd i_d hkcXe±^WijW gk[ Z[iYkXh[d gk[ Yed bW YecX_dWY_ d Yehh[YjW Z[ fWi_ d" de j[d[h c_[Ze o cWdj[gk_bbW" jeZe [i fei_Xb[$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 @kb_[ @kb_W % :_h[Yjeh0 DehW F[h d % 7Yjeh[i0 C[hob Ijh[[f" 7co 7ZWci" IjWdb[o JkYY_" 9^h_i C[ii_dW" B_dZW ;cedZ$ % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 7 % :khWY_ d0'() c_d$ % FW i Z[ eh_][d0 ;$K$7$% 7 e0 (&&/

'-0&&%'/0&&%('0&& CWj_d [ :ec0 ''0)&%')0'+ 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 :E8 0 '+0'&%',0+&% '.0*&%(&0)& CWj_d [ :ec0 ')0'&

'/0)&%((0'+ CWj_d [ :ec0 ''0*+%'*0'+ 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 ',0(&%'.0++%('0)& CWj_d [ :ec0 ')0+&

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 :E8 0 '+0&&%

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 ',0+&%

9 ? ; D 9 ? 7 < ? 9 9 ? Õ D F[hYo @WYaied o Bei :_ei[i :[b Eb_cfe0 ;b BWZh d :[b HWoe 8 B[hcWd" kd d_ e WfWh[dj[c[dj[ dehcWb" Z[iYkXh[ gk[ [i ^_`e Z[ Fei[_Z d o gk[ ik c[`eh Wc_]e" =hel[h" [i kd i|j_he$ 7 fWhj_h Z[ W^ " h[Yehh[h|d bei ;ijWZei Kd_Zei fbW]WZei Z[ cedijhkei c_jeb ]_Yei fWhW h[ijWkhWh [b ehZ[d Y ic_Ye Wdj[i Z[ gk[ i[ fed]W [b ieb [d [b Z W c|i bWh]e Z[b W e$ F[hYo XkiYW WokZWh" h[Ykf[hWh bW fWp" h[iYWjWh W ik cWZh[ o Yecfh[dZ[h gk_ d [i b c_ice" WZ[c|i Z[ YedeY[h W ik fWZh[$ JeZe kd h[je" o fWhW Ykcfb_hbe i be Yk[djW Yed Wf[dWi '& Z Wi$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 F[hYo @WYaied J^[ Ebocf_Wdi0 J^[ B_]^jd_d] J^_[\ % :_h[Yjeh0 9^h_i 9ebkcXki % 7Yjeh[i0 F_[hY[ 8heidWd" HeiWh_e :Wmied" KcW J^khcWd % :khWY_ d0 ''. % FW i Eh_][d0 ; K%9WdWZ| % 7 e0 (&'&

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 :E8 0 ')0*+% ',0'+%'.0*+%('0'+ CWj_d [ :ec0 ''0(& 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 :E8 0 '+0&+%'-0*&%(&0'& CWj_d [ :ec0 '(0(& :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 ',0'&%'.0*&%('0'& CWj_d [ :ec0 ')0)&

7lWjWh 8 ;d bW f_YW Wl[djkhW º7lWjWh»" @Wc[i 9Wc[hed" [b Z_h[Yjeh Z[ ºJ_jWd_Y»" dei bb[lW W kd ckdZe [if[YjWYkbWh gk[ [ij| c|i Wbb| Z[ dk[ijhW _cW]_dWY_ d$ ;d bW Z_ijWdj[ bkdW Z[ FWdZehW" kd ^ he[ i[ [cXWhYW [d kdW jhWl[i W Z[ Wl[djkhWi o Z[iYkXh_c_[djei c_[djhWi gk[ [dYWX[pW kdW XWjWbbW ^[h _YW fWhW iWblWh W bW Y_l_b_pWY_ d$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 7lWjWh % :_h[Yjeh0 @Wc[i 9Wc[hed % :khWY_ d0 '+& % FW i Eh_][d0 ;K % 7 e0 (&&/

Fh_oW I^h_oW " kdW `el[d gk[ jhWXW`W [d j[b[cWha[j_d]" i[ [dWcehW f[hZ_ZWc[dj[ Z[ kde Z[ iki Yb_[dj[i" =hWd][h @[ii[ C[jYWb\[ " Yed jWd i be [iYkY^Wh ik lep$ :[Y_Z_ZW W YedeY[hbe" bW Y^_YW i[ lW Z[ l_W`[ W IWd <hWdY_iYe fWhW j[d[h kd [dYk[djhe Yed b1 i_d [cXWh]e" YkWdZe bb[]W bWi YeiWi h[ikbjWd c|i Yecfb_YWZWi fWhW Fh_oW Z[ be gk[ fkZe ^WX[h _cW]_dWZe$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 J^[ Ej^[h ;dZ E\ J^[ B_d[ % :_h[Yjeh0 @Wc[i :eZied % 7Yjeh[i0 @[ii[ C[jYWb\[" I^h_oW " C_Y^W[b 9^[d" BWhho C_bb[h % = d[he0 HecWdY[ % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 8 % :khWY_ d0 '&+ % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&&/

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '-0)&%((0&& CWj_d [ :ec0 '(0*+ 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '*0+&%'-0&&

:H7C7

;

HEC7D9; BbWcWdZe 7b 7ceh 8

: W Z[ Bei ;dWcehWZei 8'+

7bcWi FWiW`[hWi 8

Kd j[hh_Xb[ WYY_Z[dj[ W h[e Z[`W Z_[p fWiW`[hei ieXh[l_l_[dj[i$ 9bW_h[ Ikcc[hi [i bW fi_Y be]W [dYWh]WZW Z[ WokZWhbei W ikf[hWh [b j[hh_Xb[ jhWkcW W jhWl i Z[ i[i_ed[i ]hkfWb[i$ JeZe cWhY^W Yed dehcWb_ZWZ" ^WijW gk[ c_ij[h_eiWc[dj[ bei fWiW`[hei Yec_[dpWd W Z[iWfWh[Y[h$ 9bW_h[ [ij| Yedl[dY_ZW Z[ gk[ bW d[]b_][dY_W [d bW W[heb d[W j_[d[ gk[ l[h Yed [b WYY_Z[dj[" f[he [djh[ c|i _dl[ij_]W" c|i i[ WZ[djhW [d bW j[hh_Xb[ l[hZWZ Z[b ikY[ie" [d [b gk[ _dYbkie [bbW [ij| _dlebkYhWZW$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 FWii[d][hi % :_h[Yjeh0 HeZh_]e =WhY W % 7Yjeh[i0 7dd[ >Wj^WmWo" FWjh_Ya M_bied" 7dZh[ 8hWk]^[h" :_Wdd[ M[_ij % = d[he0 :hWcW % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 8 % :khWY_ d0 /) % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&&.

9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '-0'+%'/0'+%('0'+

?dl_Yjki 7

;ij[ \_bc[ Yed kd [b[dYe ckbj_[ij[bWh h[jhWjW lWh_Wi ^_ijeh_Wi Z[ Wceh0 kdW e\_Y_Wb Z[b [` hY_je gk[ WXWdZedW ?hWa o gk[ l_W`W ^WijW Bei Îd][b[i [d kd lk[be [d [b gk[ jWcX_ d lW kd ^ecei[nkWb1 [b Zk[ e Z[ kdW \beh[h W gk[ b[ fhefed[ cWjh_ced_e W ik Y^_YW o gk[ [d h[Wb_ZWZ [ij| [dWcehWZe Z[ ik Wc_]W$ JWcX_ d WfWh[Y[ kdW `kX_bWZW gk[ \k[ [d]W WZW feh ik cWh_Ze" kdW YWpWjWb[djei [dWcehWZW Z[ kd YWhj[he" o kdW fkXb_Y_ijW gk[ de [dYk[djhW [b Wceh o [ij| iebW [b : W Z[ IWd LWb[dj d$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 LWb[dj_d[ i :Wo % :_h[Yjeh0 =Whho CWhi^Wbb % 7Yjeh[i0 JWobeh BWkjd[h" 8hWZb[o 9eef[h" 7dd[ >Wj^WmWo" @[ii_YW 8_[b % = d[he0 HecWdY[ % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 8 % :khWY_ d0 '(+ % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&'&

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0

',0)&%'/0'&%('0*+ CWj_d [ :ec0 '*0&& 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 ',0*&%'/0&+%('0*& CWj_d [ :ec0 '*0&&

J > H ? B B ; H

;

;b 9kWhje 9edjWYje 8#'+

9 E C ; : ? 7

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0

:_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '+0'+%'/0*+ 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '*0+&%'-0'&%'/0*&%((0'&

;ijW dk[lW [djh[]W Z[b \Wceie f[hiedW`[ jhWdiYkhh[ [d bW ?d]bWj[hhW l_Yjeh_WdW" Wb _]kWb gk[ bW Y_djW eh_]_dWb Z[ '/*' gk[ YedjWXW Yed Bed 9^Wd[o @h$ [d [b heb [ij[bWh$ 7^ehW" 8[d_Y_e :[b Jehe _dj[hfh[jW W BWmh[dY[ JWbXej" kd ^ecXh[ gk[" jhWi ik h[]h[ie W ik Y_kZWZ dWjWb" [i cehZ_Ze feh kd ^ecXh[ beXe" Yed be YkWb Yec_[dpW kdW j[hh_Xb[ l_ZW deYjkhdW$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 J^[ Meb\cWd % :_h[Yjeh0 @e[ @e^dijed % 7Yjeh[i0 >k]e M[Wl_d]" 8[d_Y_e Z[b Jehe" ;c_bo 8bkdj" 7dj^edo >efa_di % = d[he0 J[hheh % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 8#'+ % :khWY_ d0 '&( % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&&/

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0

:_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '+0)&%'-0*+%(&0&&%((0(& CWj_d [ :ec0 ')0&& 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 :E8 0 ',0(&%'.0)&%(&0*& CWj_d [ :ec0 '*0'& :_Wh_e0 C79HEF7DJ7BB7 IK8 0 '+0'&%'-0'&%'/0(&%('0)&

7l$ CWh W 7^kcWZW Z[ = c[p o ;dh_gk[ 9ehedW Ceh\ d De$ )-'" 9eb$ 9Wcf[ijh[" FbWpW ºIeh_WdW»" L$ Z[ 7$" 9eb$

:_Wh_e ): IK8 0 '*0)&%'.0&&%('0)& 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e ): IK8 0 '+0)&%'.0*+%((0&& CWj_d [ :ec0 '(0'&

«$$$O : dZ[ ;ij|d Bei Ceh]Wd5 8

;b >ecXh[ BeXe 8#'+

CC9_d[cWi

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0

C[hob o FWkb Ceh]Wd ied kdW [n_jeiW fWh[`W Z[ CWd^WjjWd" YkoWi ºYWi_» f[h\[YjWi l_ZWi j_[d[d kd f[gk[ e \hWYWie" fk[i [ij|d Z_lehY_|dZei[$ F[he bW beYkhW Z[ ik l_ZW hec|dj_YW de fk[Z[ i[h YecfWhWZW Yed be gk[ lWd W l_l_h0 ied j[ij_]ei Z[ kd Wi[i_dWje o i[ Yedl_[hj[d [d XbWdYei Z[ kd Wi[i_de W ik[bZe$ Bei \[Z[hWb[i" fhej[]_ dZebei Yece j[ij_]ei" i[ bb[lWd W bei Ceh]Wd Z[ Dk[lW Oeha W kd f[gk[ e fk[Xbe [d Moec_d]" ZedZ[ jhWjWh|d Z[ WZWfjWhi[ W bW l_ZW beYWb$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 :_Z Oek >[Wh 7Xekj J^[ Ceh]Wdi5% :_h[Yjeh0 CWhY BWmh[dY[ % 7Yjeh[i0 IWhW^ @[ii_YW FWha[h" >k]^ =hWdj" IWc ;bb_ejj" CWho Ij[[dXkh][d % :khWY_ d0 '&) % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&&/

J ; H H E H

;ijW f[b YkbW" Z_h_]_ZW feh [b ]WdWZeh Z[b EiYWh" 9b_dj ;WijmeeZ" Yk[djW bW _dif_hWZehW ^_ijeh_W Z[ Y ce D[bied CWdZ[bW Ceh]Wd <h[[cWd ikcW \k[hpWi Yed [b YWf_j|d CWjj :Wced Z[b [gk_fe Z[ hk]Xo Z[ IkZ|\h_YW fWhW WokZWh o kd_h W ik fW i$ ;b fh[i_Z[dj[ CWdZ[bW" h[Y_ d [b[]_Ze" iWX[ gk[ ik fW i i[ cWdj_[d[ hWY_Wb o [Yed c_YWc[dj[ Z_l_Z_Ze feh [b Z[if[hjWh Z[b Wf[hj^[_Z$ 9h[o[dZe gk[ fk[Z[ `kdjWh W ik ][dj[ W jhWl i Z[b b[d]kW`[ kd_l[hiWb Z[b Z[fehj[" CWdZ[bW h[ d[ Wb Z[iWcfWhWZe [gk_fe Z[ IkZ|\h_YW c_[djhWi j_[d[d kdW _di b_jW fWhj_Y_fWY_ d [d bW 9efW Z[b CkdZe Z[ '//+" gk[ bei bb[lW Wb fWhj_Ze Z[ YWcf[edWje$ :_h[Yjeh0 9b_dj ;WijmeeZ % 7Yjeh[i0 Ceh]Wd <h[[cWd" CWjj :Wced" IYejj ;WijmeeZ" @kb_Wd B[m_i % :khWY_ d0 ')) % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&&/

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0

',0*&%'/0'+%((0&& CWj_d [ :ec0 '(0)& 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '/0'&%('0+&

J[b$ )'#'#)(#') mmm$ccY_d[cWi$Yec 7:C?I?ÕD0 =;D;H7B0 +& % C_ hYeb[i0 ), '§$ <kdY_ d % ;ijkZ_Wdj[i % D_ ei [ ?DI;D0 *(

9_d feb_i 9EB?C70 )[h$ 7d_bbe F[h_\ h_Ye De$ )&'" ;ig$ 7l$ ?]dWY_e IWdZelWb" FbWpW P[djhWb_W$ 9eb_cW C7DP7D?BBE0 FWi[e Z[ bWi =Wl_ejWi De$ *+&" IWbW]kW

J[b$ )( ),( () 9eb_cW )'* ))+ ,* +. IWbW]kW" Cpe$ mmm$Y_d[feb_i$Yec$cn 7:C?I?ÕD CWdpWd_bbe0 =[d[hWb */ C_ hYeb[i [nY[fje Z_Wi \[ij_lei 0 )( CWj_d [i" d_ ei" )[hW$ [ZWZ o [ijkZ_Wdj[i Z[ B#L Yed Yh[Z[dY_Wb 0 )Fhe^_X_ZW bW [djhWZW W c[deh[i Z[ ' W e 7:C?I?ÕD 9eb_cW0 :[ B#:" Z[ifk[i Z[ bWi '+0&& ^hi0 ++

C_bbW @elel_Y^ _dj[hfh[jW W bW ZeYjehW 7X_]W_b Job[h" gk_[d l_W`W W kd fk[Xbe Z[ 7bWiaW fWhW _dl[ij_]Wh _d[nfb_YWXb[i Z[iWfWh_Y_ed[i gk[ ^Wd ikY[Z_Ze Z[iZ[ ^WY[ *& W ei" [d bWi gk[ fWh[Y[ [ijWh _dlebkYhWZe [b =eX_[hde <[Z[hWb Z[ ;ijWZei Kd_Zei$ Kd \_bc[ XWiWZe [d ^[Y^ei h[Wb[i$ J_jkbe eh_]_dWb0 J^[ <ekhj^ A_dZ % :_h[Yjeh0 EbWjkdZ[ EikdiWdc_ % 7Yjeh[i0 C_bbW @elel_Y^" ;b_Wi Aej[Wi" M_bb FWjjed" 9eh[o @e^died % = d[he0 J^h_bb[h % 9bWi_\_YWY_ d0 8#'+ % :khWY_ d0 /. % FW i Eh_][d0 ;ijWZei Kd_Zei % 7 e0 (&&/

9_d feb_i CWdpWd_bbe0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0

',0&&%'.0'&%(&0'+%((0)& CWj_d [ :ec0 ')0)& 9_d feb_i0 :_Wh_e0 IK8 0 '+0)&%'-0)&%'/0+&%((0&&

C_ hYeb[i [nY[fje Z_Wi \[ij_lei 0 ). CWj_d [i Wdj[i '+0&&" d_ ei o )[hW$ [ZWZ ** ;ijkZ_Wdj[i Z[ B#L Yed Yh[Z[dY_Wb 0 ** Fhe^_X_ZW bW [jdhWZW W c[deh[i Z[ ) W ei IWbW Z_]_jWb0 7Zkbje -)% d_ ei o )hW [ZWZ ,.

=EB:;D 9?D;C7N <[b_f[ I[l_bbW Z[b H e (&'" BeYWb ,*" @WhZ_d[i Z[ L_ijW >[hceiW 9eb_cW" 9eb$

J[b$ )'#(#&'#-) mmm$c[jhefeb_iY_d[cWi$Yec$cn Fhe]hWcWY_ d ik`[jW W YWcX_e i_d fh[l_e Wl_ie

DWj[ HeX_died

Cel[Zeh Z[ bei Ad_Yai Z[ Dk[lW Oeha

9edckjWZeh0 )',#)(#-& [iYh XWdei 0 feh cW_b Yehh[e6c_b[d_eYeb_cW$Yec$cn feh \Wn )', )( -& feh YWhjW 7bZWcW ++(" 9eb_cW" (.&&& mmm$c_b[d_e$Yec Z[\[dieh6c_b[d_eYeb_cW$Yec$cn

;IF;9?7B

.*/6504

FOUSF OPT

&M CBKJUP SFZ EF MBT DMBWBEBT

Zec_d]e (' Z[ <[Xh[he Z[ (&'&

&M UFNB H] ?A@D( ah ?kiep `a @ana_dko Dqi]jko Jk Cq^anj]iajp]h u ah Ej_k`eo( d]^h]j `a h]o lk_]o `ajqj) _e]o mqa hko cnqlko iejknep]neko d]j lqaopk lkn `eo_neiej]_e j( hk mqa d]^h] `a qj ]r]j_a ok_e]h( k***

$PMJNB H]o l]j`ehh]o qpehev]j ]ni]o mqa okj at_hqoer]o `ah af n_epk( oac j ah `ena_pkn `a h] Lkhe_ ] Aop]p]h Lnaraj) per]* Hko cnqlko fqrajehao rekhajpko d]j da_dk r j_qhko _kj ah j]n_k( u aok ]cn]r] hko lnk^hai]o ok_e]hao*

/BDJPOBM =n] v `a hko ckhlao mqa oa d]j `]`k _kjpn] h] `ahej_qaj_e]( h]o afa_q_ek) jao aj >]f] ?]hebknje] oa na`qfankj 3, lkn _eajpk `qn]jpa hko hpeiko `ko iaoao( ]oacqn ah _ki]j`]jpa `a h] Oacqj`] Vkj] Iehep]n* 9eb_cW38c\o :XiYXaXc 9\iY\i

&

h nau `a h]o _h]r]`]o aola_p]) _qh]nao( J]pa Nk^ejokj( _kj) oecqe d]_a qj] oai]j] ah dkjkn `a _kjo]cn]noa _kik ah c]j]`kn `ah _kj_qnok `a _h]r]`]o aj ah Fqack `a Aopnahh]o `a h] J>= lkn pan_an] k_]oe j( oeaj`k ah lneian fqc]) `kn `a hko Gje_go `a Jqar] Ukng aj hkcn]n aop] d]v] ]* Nk^ejokj( mqeaj l]n] h] J>= ao qj fqc]`kn Î^]fepkÏ( lqao peaja -*30 iapnko `a aop]pqn]( oa ikopn aola_p]_qh]n aj oq _h]r]`] bej]h( _kj h] mqa hkcn aopa p pqhk( aj qj] _kilapaj_e] `kj`a jk rkhran ] l]npe_el]n( u `kj`a `af] qj] i]n_] mqa oan na_kn`]`] lkn ^]op]jpao ] ko* Ah fqc]`kn `a -1 ] ko( j]_e`k aj Oa]ppha( S]odejcpkj( na]hev h] lnal]n]pkne] aj pea) nn]o _]hebknje]j]o( l]n] `aolq o ajnkh]noa _kj hko Dqogeao `a S]odejcpkj( `kj`a devk oqo aopq`eko qjeranoep]neko( hhar]j`k ] oq ao_q]`n] ] r]ne]o bej]hao aopq`e]jpehao* J]pa jk an] okh]iajpa qj ^qaj ^]omqap) ^kheop]( p]i^e j `aop]_ aj ]phapeoik u aj bqp^kh ]iane_]jk( `kj`a ej_hqok devk qj] pailkn]`] ao_kh]n `a .- ]jkp]_ekjao( _kik qj] iqaopn] i o `a mqa ah oeopai] ao_kh]n `a Aop]`ko Qje`ko `ao]nnkhhk ]phap]o aj `erano]o `eo_elhej]o( ]qjmqa lnkbaoekj]h) iajpa oa `a_e`]j lkn okh]iajpa qj]* Oq ajpn]`] ] h] J>= bqa aj .,,1( _q]j`k bqa ahace`k lkn hko Okhao `a Ldkajet aj ah

;hW Yedi_]k_ ^WY[ kdW i[cWdW [b ^edeh Z[ YediW]hWhi[ Yece [b ]WdWZeh Z[b YedYkhie Z[ YbWlWZWi [d [b @k[]e Z[ ;ijh[bbWi Z[ bW D87 feh j[hY[hW eYWi_ d

hqc]n .- `ah @N=BP( l]n] hqack oan ejpan) _]i^e]`k( lkn hk mqa na_]h aj ah amqelk jakuknmqejk* Aj oq oacqj`k ] k( c]j ah lneian p pqhk `a _h]r]`]o aj ah Fqack `a Aopnahh]o `a h] J>=( _kjoecqeaj`k 1, lqjpko( `aolq o `a -0 ejpajpko lkn d]_an h] _h]r]`] i o aola_p]_qh]n* Aj .,,3 u .,,4 jk lq`k `abaj`an oq oacqj`k p pqhk aj aopa `al]np]iajpk( u bqa d]op] .,,5 _q]j`k _kjoecqe aopa ]joe]`k lnaiek* = hk h]nck `a oq _]nnan]( Nk^ejokj oa d] `eopejcqe`k lkn qj] ^qaj] _qkp] `a ]oeopaj_e]o( oej ai^]nck( l]n] .,-, `a_e`e mqa ^qo_]n ] oq pan_an p pqhk `a _h]r]`]o( ah _q]h hkcn aopa bej `a oai]j]( aj @]hh]o( Pat]o* Devk na^kp]n ah ^]h j aj ah p]^hank( hk ]c]nn ( `ek qj cenk aj ah ]ena( u `a aol]h`]o hk lqok ] `ko i]jko _kj oqi] rekhaj_e] aj h] _]j]op]* Ah ^]omqap^kheop] `a ]o_aj`aj_e] behe) lej]( oa qje ] hko c]j]`knao `a h]o kpn]o lnqa^]o `a h] jk_da( _kik L]qh Lean_a( `a hko ?ahpe_o `a >kopkj( mqeaj c]j h] _kila) paj_e] `a pnelhao( ah _]j]`eajoa Opara J]od( `a hko Oqjo `a Ldkajet( mqeaj oa eilqok aj h]o lnqa^]o `a d]^ehe`]`( ieajpn]o mqa ah amqelk `a Pat]o naoqhp raj_a`kn aj h] atde^e_e j `a penko _kjpn]nnahkf* H] pailkn]`] .,,5).,-, d]^ ] oe`k cneo l]n] Nk^ejokj( mqeaj aopqrk iq_dko fqacko aj h] ^]j_]( ]qjmqa ailav ] ran ]_pere`]` aj ah eje_ek `ah lnaoajpa ] k* .D

'SPOUFSBT ?q^] _]hebe_ ]uan `a Îlnkrk_]`knÏ ah ejpan_]i^ek okopaje`k ah reanjao lkn ah Oq^oa_nap]nek ]oeopajpa `ah @al]np]iajpk `a Aop]`k( C]ec Gahhu( u `a_aj]o `a klkoepknao ]h lnaoe`ajpa N] h ?]opnk*

5FOEFODJBT Ah R]pe_]jk nalknp mqa ah j iank `a _]p he_ko aj ah lh]jap] ]o_eaj`a ] ieh -22 iehhkjao( hk mqa nalnaoajp] -3*0 lkn _eajpk `a h] lk^h]_e j iqj) `e]h u qj ]qiajpk `a -5 iehhkjao `a lanokj]o naola_pk ] .,,3*

$VMUVSB Ah ÎAjo]i^haÏ ?kil] ] `a @]j) v] Ao_ je_] mqa `eneca ah i]aopnk Dajnnu Pai]( aop]n aj ah pn]`e_ek) j]h lnkcn]i] ÎJk_dao `a ?]b Ï( ah ln teik i]npao ./( ] h]o .,6/, dk) n]o( aj h] ?]o] `a h] ?qhpqn]*

-B "GJDJuO Ah amqelk `a bqp^kh `a h] oacqj`] `e) reoe j( Hknko $Q`a?% oa eilqok lkn 3). ] hko Iqn_e h]cko `a Cq]i _deh( aj qj `qahk `kj`a lq`k d]^an ]jk) p]`k i o ckhao( lqao ]`ai o b]hh qj laj]hpe aj ah oacqj`k peailk*

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.