12 | QSALTLAKE MAGAZINE | NEWS
Qsaltlake.com |
LDS Church opposes Equality Act The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints opposes a national nondiscrimination bill making its way through Congress, saying it would remove religious freedom protections. In a statement, church leaders wrote that the Equality Act lacks balance and does not meet the “standard of fairness for all.” The bill has passed the House, but is likely to stall in the U.S. Senate. “The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is deeply concerned that the ongoing conflicts between religious liberty and LGBT rights are poisoning our civil discourse, eroding the free exercise of religion and preventing diverse Americans of good will from living together in respect and peace,” church leaders wrote in a statement. “Lawmakers across the nation, including members of Congress, are working to enact or strengthen laws that ensure LGBT persons fair access to important rights, such as nondiscrimination in areas like housing, employment, and appropriate public accommodations. The Church is on record favoring reasonable measures that secure such rights.” “At the same time, we urgently need laws that protect the rights of individuals and faith communities to freely gather, speak out publicly, serve faithfully and live openly according to their religious beliefs without discrimination or retaliation, even when those beliefs may be unpopular. This includes the right of religious organizations and religious schools to establish faith-based employment and admissions standards and to preserve the religious nature of their activities and properties,” the statement continued. “Conflicts between rights are common and nothing new. When conflicts arise between religious freedom and LGBT rights, the Church advocates a balanced ‘fairness for all’ approach that protects the most important rights for everyone while seeking reasonable, respectful compromises in areas of conflict. The Church affirms this as the best way to overcome sharp divisions over these issues. The Church supported the 2015 ‘fairness for all’ legislation in the Utah Legislature that successfully protected both religious freedom and LGBT rights in employment and housing and that has helped facilitate greater understanding and respect. “While providing extremely broad protections for LGBT rights, the Equality Act provides no protections for religious free-
dom. It would instead repeal long-standing religious rights under the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act, threaten religious employment standards, devastate religious education, defund numerous religious charities and impose secular standards on religious activities and properties. The Church joins other religious organizations that also strongly oppose the Equality Act as unbalanced, fundamentally unfair and a path to further conflict.” The Southern Baptist Convention, the Roman Catholic Church, and other religious organizations oppose the measure. The bill seeks to add “gender identity
Issue 300 |
MAY 24, 2019
and sexual orientation” to existing federal nondiscrimination laws covering such things as employment, housing, education, and public spaces and services. It has widespread Democratic support and passed the U.S. House, but faces serious opposition in the Republican-controlled Senate. Both Utah senators Mitt Romney and Mike Lee, who are both members of the LDS Church and Republicans, oppose the legislation. Lee released a statement calling the bill “seriously flawed” and that it would “dangerously undermine the First Amendment and the freedoms it was designed to protect.” Romney has told media outlets that the bill doesn’t contain “essential” strong religious liberty protections. Q
Rep. Curtis speaks against Equality Act Rep. John Curtis, R-Utah, spoke on the House floor Thursday to express his concerns with what he calls the “lack of balance” in the “Equality Act” between the absolute rights of both LGBTQ individuals as human beings and religious institutions protected by the first amendment. Curtis also explained his frustration that no consideration of amendments was allowed. He says he considers himself a “willing partner” who has introduced what he sees as common sense amendments that would help achieve a balance of protection for both interests and maintain the standards set by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The bill is widely expected to easily pass the Democratic-held House but is expected to fail in the Republican-controlled Senate. Curtis started his speech by saying he respects the LGBTQ community. “First and foremost, I must begin by saying that I believe the LGBTQ community is a critical part of the fabric of our country. They are deserving of our unequivocal love and respect, and their contributions to my home state of Utah are utterly invaluable,” he said. “As the mayor of Provo, I prioritized inclusion and love, and sought to ensure my administration did everything possible to recognize the intrinsic value of all our citizens, including our LGBTQ community. I fought hard against discrimination and was grateful for my association with organizations like Provo Pride, Equality Utah,
Encircle, and others who I was honored to stand with to ensure our policies in City Hall reflected the love in our hearts.” “With the Equality Act, we face a unique challenge of balancing needed protections for the LGBTQ community with the importance of protecting religious liberty — one of the fundamental rights enshrined at the founding of our nation,” Curtis continued. “I believe this compromise is possible because I’ve seen it before in my home state with something called the ‘Utah compromise,’ — historic legislation that effectively balanced the absolute rights of both LGBTQ individuals as human beings, and religious institutions protected by the first amendment. “The Equality Act fails to strike that balance,” he asserted. “Instead, these two interests are treated as a zero-sum game and no good faith effort has been put forth to allow both sides to win. This bill would end long-standing religious liberties under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, a historic bipartisan legislative victory fought for by the current Democratic leader in the Senate, Chuck Schumer, my own Utah mentor Orrin Hatch, a Republican, and liberal lion Ted Kennedy. It was also signed into law by Democrat President Bill Clinton.” “I’m frustrated that House Democrat leaders have decided there will not be any consideration or even debate of amendments on the Equality Act. Instead, they have established a model of legislative gas-lighting.” Q
