Massachusetts
Winter 2013
FAMILYBUSINESS Official magazine of the
FBA Awards for Massachusetts 2012 Family Businesses Honored for Endurance, Community Ties
Inside:
Technology and the Family Firm Recruiting Beyond the Family New Health Insurance Rules A Supplement to Banker & Tradesman
New England
FAMILYBUSINESS Conference
SaVE thE datE P r esented by
May 16 & 17, 2013 MGM Grand at Foxwoods Resort & Casino Massachusetts Family Business magazine, the Family Business Association, and The Warren Group are dedicated to honoring and educating family businesses throughout the region. This is your opportunity to meet face-to-face with more than 100 family business owners and managers who will gather to learn from their peers, hear from experts, study a variety of best practices, and network. The program will feature a high-impact keynote speaker and a selection of educational breakout sessions with panels of family business owners sharing their knowledge and experience. Plus, all attendees will receive breakfast and lunch, a chance to win great raffle prizes and more! for additional inforMation Call 617-896-5344
Massachusetts Family Business Official magazine of the
CONTENTS
12 FBA AWARDS FOR MASSACHUSETTS 2012 From first generation businesses just getting started to a company celebrating 125 years, here are their stories. 12
4
from the advisory council
Behind the Scenes: A Successful 140 Years
6
health care reform
Employers, Now is the Time to Prepare
8
when all you have is a hammer
Technological Literacy is the Key to Survival
10
smooth cyber criminals Tips to Avoid Becoming a Victim of Cyber Crime
18
looking ahead
Can Life Insurance Plans Help Your Family Business?
20
outside hiring
When – and How – to Look Outside the Family
22
the key three
Tips for Acquiring Another Company or Merging Yours
20
6
8 3
From the Advisory Council
The Story Behind the Story By Timothy M. Warren Jr.
O
ur company, The Warren Group, celebrates its 140th birthday this year. Throughout our history, we have adhered to my great-grandfather’s entrepreneurial spirit and his essential idea for the business. We have worked hard to carry it forward. A visitor to our conference room sees shelves upon shelves of bound volumes of our newspapers, which contain property records dating back to 1872. Every page T IMOT H Y WA R R E N in the volumes yields a picture within the sweep of time of regional commercial transactions. A reader today might not be able to tell from the constancy of nearly a century and a half of these volumes of the behind-thescenes business activity that has kept our company alive. In the 1930s, my grandfather reduced operations and issued company scrip. That brought us through the Great Depression, ensuring the survival of our two flagship newspapers. After World War II, the publishing business rebounded, but was somewhat stanched by the high overhead costs of maintaining the printing plant, which was sold in the mid-1950s at my father’s behest. The transition to a computerized database in the 1980s brought a multitude of business opportunities for our company.
Property ownership records online debuted in 1989, sparing real estate professionals the need to scour back issues of our newspapers to find the records of relevance. Computer data-driven products such as Real Estate Record Search and data licensing have created new possibilities, as well as the custom publishing division established in 1995. As a member of the Family Business Advisory Council, I have been impressed by the commonality of problems and solutions, across all lines of business, which our members share. It always reverts back to how to keep the core values in force by making decisions – some painful, some bold and creative – on how to best serve the long-term needs of a family-owned business.
As the fourth-generation leader of The Warren Group, I am proud and honored to uphold our company’s core values. They are: To treat customers and team members as members of our own family; to earn customer and team member trust by holding ourselves strictly accountable for our actions and commitments; and to use technology and creativity to innovate new products and ensure continuous improvements in our operations. I wish the same for every member of the FBA. ■ TIMOTHY M. WARREN JR., CEO OF THE WARREN GROUP AND FOURTH-GENERATION FAMILY MEMBER, SERVES ON THE FAMILY BUSINESS ASSOCIATION ADVISORY COUNCIL.
Massachusetts
FAMILYBUSINESS
Official magazine of the Family Business Association. Inc.
Editorial | Advertising | Design A Family-Owned Business Since 1872
DIRECTORS 101 Huntington Ave., Suite 500 Boston, MA 02199 fbaedu.com
4
Jeffrey S. Davis, Mage, LLC Al DeNapoli, Tarlow, Breed, Hart & Rodgers, P.C. Brian Nagle, BNY Mellon Wealth Management
VICE PRESIDENT Catherine Watson, Tarlow, Breed, Hart & Rodgers, P.C.
PRESIDENT
TREASURER
Edward D. Tarlow, Tarlow, Breed, Hart & Rodgers, P.C.
Richard A. Hirschen, Gray, Gray & Gray, LLP
280 Summer Street, Boston, MA 02210 Phone 617-428-5100 Fax 617-428-5119 www.thewarrengroup.com ©2013 The Warren Group Inc. All rights reserved. The Warren Group is a trademark of The Warren Group Inc. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the publisher.
GOLD SPONSORS FINANCIAL NETWORK
SILVER SPONSORS
BRONZE SPONSORS
Founding Sponsors
Media Supporters
Academic Supporters
5
Learning from Others’ Mistakes
Avoid These Common Employee Benefit Plan Issues By Anthony T. Carideo
A
s a family business owner, you as an employee benefit plan trustee or administrator have responsibilities to comply with Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) regulations to prudently monitor the investments of the plan, ensure that the plan is operating in accordance with the plan document, and to exercise oversight over third-party record-keepers. Non-compliance can result in serious consequences impacting your business and, in some cases, your employees. However, ANTHONY T. CARIDEO most plan administrative and operational issues can be averted or corrected by enhancing internal monitoring procedures or, if necessary, by entering into voluntary correction programs offered by the IRS and DOL. This is not a comprehensive compliance checklist, but it is a great place to start in making a preliminary assessment of your compliance with IRS and DOL regulations. Problems such as these described below can result in fines or a change to the exempt tax status of your plan, so learn from others’ mistakes and avoid these common pitfalls. Timely remittance: A common problem with potentially serious consequences relates to the timeliness of the remittance to the plan of your employees’ plan contributions, that is, employee compensation deferrals or withholdings, each pay period. Delaying the deposit of employee withholdings is a serious issue in the eyes of the DOL. Delays are interpreted by the DOL as the employer’s use 6
of employee funds, and, if uncovered by the DOL, are likely to trigger significant scrutiny by the DOL. Employers sponsoring plans with fewer than 100 participants have a safe harbor in this regard. Participant contributions must be made within seven days of the payroll date. For larger plan sponsors there is no safe harbor, and the DOL generally holds these employers to a more stringent standard. Without a safe harbor or rule of thumb for large plan employers, the require-
ment to remit as soon as is reasonably practical, is often determined by the DOL in reference to time frame within which sponsors are able to remit payroll tax withholding which often is within one to three business days of the pay date. Eligible compensation refers to what compensation is subject to employee deferral and company matching funds. We see quite often that employee deferrals and company matches are not being applied to compensation consistent with
the plan document. Most commonly, we see these inconsistencies as it relates to bonuses, overtime and shift differentials. It is not safe to presume that your outsourced payroll service provider is applying employee deferral percentages and company matching contributions to compensation as defined in the plan. This is your responsibility as the plan sponsor. Auto enrollment features have become increasingly popular. A family business owner’s best intentions can be negatively impacted by improper implementation of auto enrollment. The two most common implementation errors that we have observed involve failure to notify employees of opt-out provisions and failure to commence employee deferrals on time. Vendor controls: Many family business owners engage third-party vendors to administer their plans. At least annually, the family business employee charged with oversight of that vendor relationship should read your vendor’s Report on Internal Controls or SSAE 16 (formerly known as SAS 70) for any findings or testing exceptions that may be of concern to you as plan trustee. It is also very important that “user controls,” most of which are explicitly defined in your vendors SSAE 16, are in place. User controls refer to controls that the vendor has determined should be in place at your organization to work in concert with vendor controls. Investment strategy: Are you aware that plan trustees have a fiduciary duty to understand the plan’s investment strategy and why investments have been selected? This fiduciary duty requires that trustees carefully monitor fund performance and raise questions with administrators over funds that are underperforming or perceived as involving exceptionally high levels of risk. These actions are required of trustees to adequately discharge their duty to prudently select investments, and to minimize any liability for fund failures or underperformance. Meet quarterly or no less than annually with your administrator to review fund performance and assess, with their input, the plan investment offerings. Be sure to maintain minutes of these meetings. Fee structure: The fee structure as-
sociated with the plan’s investment offerings is another area that is often not understood nor carefully scrutinized by plan administrators and trustees. This too can undermine the family business owner’s best intentions. It is not necessary to go with the low-cost provider, but plan trustees need to ascertain that the plan receives appropriate value commensurate with the fees charged. In 2012, 401k plans were required for the first time to disclose all of the investment fees assessed to a plan participant. Plan administrators and trustees should monitor these fees and consider fees in their assessment and selection of different investment offerings. Plan documents: We frequently find that critical plan documents have not been legally executed. Plan administrators should confirm with the plan’s legal counsel that all plan documents have been properly executed. Low-balance accounts: Generally speaking, when a plan participant leaves his employer, he may either keep his employee contributions in the employer’s plan as an inactive participant or he may
rollover those assets to another qualified plan. Many plans permit the pay-out of low-balance inactive participant accounts. In order to minimize plan administrative expenses, it is generally advisable to take advantage of such plan provisions. Check your plan document for such a provision, and in the event that such pay-outs are permitted, consider adding to your employee departure administrative checklist the review of plan account balances so that low-balance participant accounts can be removed timely to minimize administrative costs of the plan. This list of common pitfalls arose in the context of first-time plan audits and transaction due diligence. Even if neither such event is in your near future, the DOL may come in at any time to audit your plan’s compliance. As with most family business owners, you make a conscious effort to treat your employees like family. Don’t let unintended consequences undermine your commitment to them. ■ ANTHONY T. CARIDEO JR., CPA, IS A MEMBER OF WOLF & CO.
WARNING Attention Business Owners, CEOs, CFOs & HR Mgrs: Don’t even think about renewing your group benefits, changing your health plan design, or changing your current broker
until you’ve reviewed this free, no obligation, informative web site. www.HRandBenefitAdvice.com Find out how you can identify your compliance risk (from State and Federal Agencies), discover holes in your benefits design and find ways to stretch your company dollar.
7
Taking Control How to Stop Worrying and Learn to Love IT By Jeffrey Davis
H
ere’s a proverb many of us remember:
For Want of a Nail For want of a nail the shoe was lost. For want of a shoe the horse was lost. For want of a horse the rider was lost. For want of a rider the message was lost. For want of a message the battle was lost For want of a battle the kingdom was lost. And all for the want of a horseshoe nail.
Today’s technology is far higher up in the intelligence food chain than a horseshoe nail. But that doesn’t prevent 8
some of its designated users from trying to implement it with a hammer. How well your kingdom – your family business – utilizes it, has a critical impact on the business’ health and wellbeing. Corporate giants have been stymied by poor and/or outdated use of technology that was supposed to make them more efficient. There have been several examples of this over the last five years. The risks of failure happen much faster for a smaller family business. Technological literacy is the key to
survival, but it must be combined with an institutional knowledge of how the business works. Buying the latest management or operational system won’t help your business if people within the organization don’t input the critical data to make it work. We spoke with two regionally-based technology experts to give their input on the subject. Konrad Martin is president and CEO of techKnowledge Advisors Inc. Frank Cincotta is CEO of MTP Software LLC. Here is what they said:
In a multi-generational and/or multi-disciplinary family-owned business, who gets to decide what to buy and how to use it? Konrad Martin: Our business is unique when it comes to who makes the decision on what and when to buy new technologies. We are an outsourced IT comKONRAD MARTIN pany, and my brother’s primary role is to deal with all the technologies we support. As our company needs new servers, workstations etc. my brother presents what technologies he feels we should purchase, and then we look at the budget and make a financial decision. Frank Cincotta: Regardless of the type of business, it is important to engage all the functional areas of your business in order FRANK CINCOTTA to develop a requirements document that serves your business need. The “who” in the purchasing decision is far less important than the “what” and the “why” for the purchasing decision. Have you considered Greco-Roman wrestling or pistols at 50 paces? How to address the problem of all the IT knowledge in a company being concentrated in the minds and hands of one or two people? KM: Being an outsourced IT company, we come across this type of situation all the time. We require that user names, passwords and login information be kept in a central location so other authorized members of the company can have access as needed. FC: This is a very common problem with small businesses, where the business owners feel like they are held hostage by the IT resource. There is always a risk when 1 person is given the full IT authority for your company. My approach to mitigate this risk is to have a family member maintain overall administrative access, while creating a sub account that enables the IT person to perform his du-
ties, but eliminates the possibility of them locking you out of your own systems. Another option to consider is outsourcing the IT function altogether. This approach may cost a bit more in the long run, but it will provide you with a team of technical resources instead of an individual IT resource. What are the biggest challenges of updating legacy systems – particularly, convincing the legacy people that go with them that it’s time to update? KM: Change is tough, especially when it comes to technology. We assure our clients that we will be there before, during and especially after the conversion to help the end user understand how things may look differently but the same functions that they are used to are still available. FC: As Konrad has pointed out, change is always a difficult undertaking. It is extremely important that you include the legacy people in the technological selection process from the very beginning and make them feel like they are a part of the decision process. What about companies whose elder IT folks are about to retire – how to translate their knowledge of legacy systems into today’s tech environment? KM: Documentation is the key to a clean transition. The process that may only lie in their own heads, needs to be documented in order to make the transition to a new technology environment as seamless as possible. FC: You may want to take full advantage of the generation of IT folks considering retirement. The transition from a potentially outdated legacy environment to a more modern environment would likely be met by less resistance when it is impacting fewer technical resources. How does a family business recover if a major tech purchase doesn’t deliver the hoped-for result? KM: Before making that purchase planning is key to the success of implementing any new technology. Of course sometimes the results of implementing a new technology may not live up to the ex-
pectations of the company. It is important that the decision makers get together and identify where the shortcomings are and why they did not meet their expectations. Then they will need to create a plan that addresses those shortcomings. FC: Given that businesses make major technology purchases about once every seven to 10 years, and that major advancements in technology occur about every three to five years, business owners cannot expect to be well versed in the technology selection process or the technology options available. Making the wrong decision can be devastating to a business. For all these reasons, it is best for a family business to outsource the technology selection process to a company that has expertise in uncovering the key business processes, identifying the best candidate systems, engaging key company personnel, and working with the selected vendor right through implementation, user training and post-go-live support. Information technology puts competitive information into everyone’s hands. How does that change the family business game? KM: This is a great question. With technology being so much cheaper and more widespread these days it sometimes seems like there is more competition out there. Family businesses need to address this but not to panic about it. The reason is simple: they also benefit from the new technologies that are out there. Planning, execution and implementation are keys to moving forward with your IT. One rule of thumb we like to use is, “never buy technology until you need it.” This way the technology is not out of date by the time you are able to take advantage of all aspects of the newest technology. FC: Advances in the field have enabled businesses of all sizes to take advantage of emerging technology. One consideration is the cost of not having a technology platform that will ensure that key processes and key decision-makers have visibility into the information needed in a timely fashion. This would put your company at a significant competitive disadvantage. ■ JEFFREY DAVIS IS CHAIRMAN AND CEO OF MAGE, LLC. 9
Combating Today’s Relentless Cyber Attacks By Matt Lidestri
T
en years ago, the Code Red, SQL Slammer and “I Love You” viruses overloaded servers, defaced websites and created headaches for the IT community at large. While these attacks were clever and had a significant impact, they generated more noise than outright theft. Today’s cyber-criminals aren’t so innocent. Their probes for vulnerabilities in operating systems, web browsers, and other third-party applications have one goal: to make money. Cyber-criminals can leverage these vulnerabilities to deploy advanced malware packages, such as Zeus or TDSS. With annual cybercrime losses estimated as high as $20.7 billion in the U.S. and $110 billion globally, it’s little wonder why cyber-criminals are so persistent. Criminals have also complicated the situation by developing methods to evade detection from security countermeasures. A prime example is the Black Hole exploit kit – one of the most prevalent and successful tools available to cyber-criminals today. Black Hole’s approach is relatively simple – convince users to click on a malicious link embedded in an email or a compromised webpage from a known and trusted website. The initial URL will often redirect the user’s browser to several compromised servers until it reaches 10
a malicious Black Hole server. There the exploit kit detects the browser and plugin versions and exploits known vulnerabilities. Next thing you know, the victim’s PC is sniffing sensitive information or joining a botnet. How can a business protect itself in a cost-effective manner? Here are few suggestions: Filtering Your Traffic If anyone doubts whether they need a firewall, let me emphasize – you do! A router with network address translation may offer some protection from inbound threats, but this is minimal protection at best. Consider using a business-grade firewall to block both inbound and out-
bound access from your network. Cisco, Fortinet, Juniper and Palo Alto have solid solutions that fit in a variety of environments. A robust web filtering solution is also helpful for blocking malware infections and phone-home traffic. With criminals using tactics such as rapidly changing their attacking domains, it has become more challenging to block malicious sites. Bluecoat, McAfee and Websense have excellent solutions. Patch, Patch, Patch! In order to successfully compromise a system, it must first be vulnerable. An effective way to identify, track, and remove vulnerabilities in a timely manner is a for-
mal patch management strategy. Patches for Windows, Apple and Linux operating systems may receive the most attention, but we can’t forget about popular applications like Adobe Reader, Flash, Oracle Java, Word, Excel and more. Patching these applications is just as important as patching the operating systems, since they are often the initial attack vector in packages like the Black Hole Exploit Kit. A vulnerability management solution can help with this process. Companies like Lumension, Secunia and GFI provide professional software that can scan devices on your network, identify vulnerable applications, and automate the patching process. For smaller environments on a more limited budget, Microsoft WSUS is an excellent option for managing Windows patches. However, WSUS is limited to Microsoft products, so you may need to have a more manual process for updating non-Microsoft applications and platforms. Drop Unnecessary Permissions Each additional layer of authority helps reduce risk. The most important layer is the “administrator” – the all-powerful computer user that has the authority to add, delete and change programs. To increase your security, require your users to run their computers as “regular” users instead. This will make it much more difficult for malware to alter the computer. If malware takes control of a regular user without administrative rights, it is much more difficult to install more malicious software. That’s good news for the good guys. Another benefit to preventing regular staff from running as administrators – your staff can no longer install random applications on their PC. These selfinstalled applications are often harder to track for vulnerabilities. They are not being vetted by an experienced IT analyst or administrator for safety. Disable the user’s admin rights and you will dramatically improve your control of third party apps in your company’s computing environment. Training With so many malware infections starting with a social engineering pitch,
it makes sense for everyone to view any email with an unusual link or attachment as a potential phish, and any physical visitor capable of leaving an infected USB drive for an unsuspecting user to find. These attacks may be simple, but also they’re also effective. Security awareness training is an important first line of defense against these attacks. While some argue that the human factor is the hardest to control, I would counter that this increases the training’s value. Security systems can’t protect us
against everything, unfortunately. Of course, training is just one of many layers that help us protect our organizations. In light of today’s persistent attacks, it makes sense to periodically review and question the effectiveness of our defenses. Viewing security as a process rather than a checklist helps everyone focus on optimization wherever and whenever we can. ■ MATT LIDESTRI, CISSP, IS INTERNET AND SECURITY PRODUCT MANAGER FOR AVON, CONN.-BASED COCC, INC., WHICH SPECIALIZES IN NEXT-GENERATION INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND SUPPORT.
Building Family Trust for Generations For almost 150 years, generation after generation of New England’s family businesses have turned to Hemenway & Barnes for trusted advice about complex estate, tax and succession issues, charitable planning, and more. Our clients turn to us to help protect and preserve their assets, to ensure the well-being of their families and to distribute assets in accordance with immediate and long-term needs and goals. Meeting the challenges of sustainable family prosperity and unity requires great thought, care and planning. Whatever the challenge, families trust Hemenway & Barnes to help them find solutions.
Estate and Tax Planning | Professional Trustee Services Trust and Estate Administration | Charitable Planning Retirement Planning | Family Business | Family Office
Trustees l Counselors at Law
www.hembar.com
www.hemtrust.com 11
FBA Awards 2012
A Toast to Extraordinary, Everyday People
O
ne remarkable aspect of the FBA Awards for Massachusetts is the group of incredibly capable family business owners who come to our attention each year. For every honoree, there are many other family businesses with rich histories of success, fortitude and philanthropy – to be sure, future FBA Award honorees. This year’s crop continues to represent the resiliency of family-owned businesses. Their independence brings as many rewards as it does risks. From seemingly spontaneous starts as first-generation businesses, whose founders had the acuity to see a new opportunity when it arose, to succeeding generations, who have had to make adjustments in their marketing plans as markets change, the lessons learned from their experience are invaluable. So we are proud to honor the 2012 award winners. Their stories follow. And we encourage all family business owners who read this to consider applying for the awards for 2013.
PROUDLY CELEBRATING FIFTY YEARS AS THE EXCLUSIVE NEW ENGLAND DISTRIBUTOR OF CARRIER AIR CONDITIONING AND HEATING PRODUCTS
WE CONGRATULATE EACH ONE OF THIS YEAR’S DESERVING WINNERS OF THE FBA AWARD AND WISH THEM CONTINUED SUCCESS. THE KOLLIGIAN FAMILY
MALDEN, MA 02148 • (800) 347-8804 • WWW.DCNE.COM BRANCH LOCATIONS IN: PLYMOUTH, MA; WESTWOOD, MA; SALEM, NH; WESTBROOK, ME AND CRANSTON, RI
12
Large Business Award Blount Fine Foods, Fall River
Third Generation Todd Blount, president Ted Blount, chairman Founded 1946 Food manufacturing and processing
T
his business-to-business company, founded as Blount Seafood Company, got its first business boost by selling clams to Heinz and to Campbell Soup Co. after World War II. Today, it sells high-quality, handmade gourmet soups, salads, dips and spreads to business customers whose names are well known, Panera Bread and Legal Sea Foods among them. It generates over 60 million servings of hand-crafted gourmet soups each year, is the largest manufacturer of lobster bisque in America and produces more than 350 proprietary soup recipes, including 75 varieties of clam chowder. The Blount family’s contributions to the New England sea food industry actually predates the company’s founding by about 60 years, going back to the 1880s. Blount Seafood Company was itself the result of a merger of three seafood-related businesses in which Blount family members had a hand. From its inception, it has been a constant state of reinvention while staying true to its roots. In fact, the Blounts comment in the video made for the 2012 FBA Awards that the company’s outlook is couched in the long-term. Its leadership has retained the freedom to make good investments that may not show results in the first or second year, but which deliver results in the fifth or 10th year. An example: Blount created a market for quahogs in New England in the post World War II years by selling to the military, and grew that market through the booming postwar 1950s and 1960s. But by the 1970s, clams were becoming a high-volume, low-margin business. The company responded by adjusting its market focus. A round of innovation in the 1990s saw it switch to high-value, high-margin products – including quality gourmet soups. In 2009, Blount Seafood Company was renamed Blount Fine Foods, and through mergers and acquisitions, branched out into dips, spreads and wet salads. In an industry in which sustainability of stock is critical to business survival,
Blount Fine Foods remains an active advocate for conservation and protection of the oceans. President Todd Blount sits on the board of the Greater Fall River Development Corp. and serves as president of the Fall River Industrial Park Association. The company gives back to the community in the form of product donations for a diverse group of local community, youth and civic organizations and all denominations of religious organizations. An expansion begun in 2010 is expected to continue Blount Fine Foods’ strong tradition of quality products and community involvement. The company’s current leadership sees the opportunity to take the legacy it was given and to carry it forward into the next4.75x4.75 generation. ■ AM Page 1 BFM ad v2_Layout 1 8/9/11 11:11
Offering comprehensive investment counsel and estate and planning services to financially successful individuals, families and endowments for over 35 years.
— We invite you to contact Mike Brown at MikeB@BFMinvest.com —
ONE WINTHROP SQUARE, BOSTON, MA 02110 617-338-8108
www.BFMinvest.com
13
Midsize Business Award Snow’s Home & Garden, Orleans
Fifth Generation Sidney Snow, president; James Snow, vice president; Susan Snow, garden center manager Founded 1887 Home and garden supplies, home heating oil, and LP Gas
A
s is the case with many multigenerational business-to-customer companies, Snow’s Home & Garden started out in a shed, selling needful things to its local customer base. In the 1870s, merchant ship Captain Aaron Snow began an informal drygoods business out of a shed and wharf that he owned. In 1887, his son and daughter-in-law made room in their next-door home to sell coal, wood, nails, gardening tools and other supplies. The company’s website includes an anecdote about the second generation: customers coming to the store when a shopkeeper was not present would find a note on the door, reading: “If you need anything, call out the back – I’ll be in the garden.” What retailer could better relate to its customer base than a proprietor who would write a note like that? The store underwent several enlargements in the 20th century and was considered the go-to place to find anything related
to the care and maintenance of property. When the old building could expand no more, a new store was built next door. When it opened in 1971, the old store closed and the new one opened on the same day. The fourth generation marked the year 1983 with another new addition, and the business celebrated its centennial in 1987. In November 2000 came the largest expansion yet, with a 12,000-square-foot addition
Adversity Award
and a 3,000-square-foot greenhouse. The family business consists of Snow’s Fuel Company and Snow’s Home & Garden, a retail store and garden center, both in Orleans, and a satellite home and garden retail store in Harwich, opened last year. In the video prepared for the FBA Awards, Sidney Snow says, “We really have the passion for the business. My grandfather did a great job passing that on to us.” ■
B-C-D Metal Products Inc., Malden Third Generation Karin Carlson, president Founded 1935 Aerospace/manufacturing
T
his company transitioned from a blacksmith shop to an aerospace supplier under its secondgeneration leader Ralph Carlson, then teetered on the brink of extinction three years after his unexpected death in the early 1990s. The third generation, led by Ralph’s daughter, brought it back. This year B-C-D Metal Products takes the honor for the adversity award, granted to a family-owned business which has overcome hard times and emerged the stronger for it. To save the company, third-generation leadership had to take some drastic Continued on page 16 14
Small Business Award Williamson Corp., Concord
Second Generation William Barron Jr., president Founded 1956 Manufacturing, engineering and consulting
W
illiamson Corp. didn’t start out as a family-owned business, but became so in 1994 when the then-principle owner retired and William Barron Sr., who had joined the company in 1969, replaced him. William Sr.’s son, William Jr., joined the company in 1994 as vice president. He was followed by his wife Lib, who joined a year later. In the video clip shown at the 2012 FBA Awards ceremony, William Jr. remembers his father as spending many work hours at Williamson, but also being able to make time for his family during the day. He said he wanted that kind of experience for himself and his family, so when the opportunity beckoned in 1994, he answered the call. When William Barron Sr. joined the company in 1969, it was called Williamson Development Company. That year it became Williamson Corporation, coinciding with a move from engineering and consult-
ing to the development and manufacture of industrial infrared thermometers. Founder Don Williamson sold his interest in the company that year, making Ian “Nick” Nichols the principle owner. In 1977, Nichols retired, and Charles Langenhagen became president and majority owner. For the next 17 years, Langenhagen oversaw the company through the coming-of-age of the infrared thermometer industry. Bill Barron Sr. instituted a hands-on approach with customers, to assure that the company’s products were properly installed and used. His “solution selling” philosophy helped the company grow its expertise not only in product development, but in the processes in which they are used. In 1982, as usage of infrared thermometers expanded, the first of Williamson’s major competitors was acquired by a large multi-national corporation, beginning a trend in the infrared thermometer mar-
ket. Williamson Corp. bucked the trend, remaining a privately-held, independent company. According to its website, its independence has contributed to its ability to focus on technology and capability development. Today, it’s the largest privatelyowned manufacturer of industrial infrared thermometers. Despite the economic downturn, Willliamson has been able to increase sales to Europe, China, Asia Pacific and Latin America. In 2011, Williamson established six remote service centers worldwide to better support its growing international customer base. More service stations are planned for the near future. William Jr. and William Sr. have both served on the board of trustees for the Fenn School; Bill Jr. has been president of the Fenn School Alumni Association and serves on the board of trustees for the Nashoba Brook School. ■
First Generation Business Award Next Generation Children’s Centers, Sudbury First Generation Donna Kelleher, principle Founded 1993 Child care and education
F
ind a need and fill it. Or, let the need find you and then fill it. Donna Kelleher embarked on the latter road in her quest for high-quality day care for her granddaughter in the early 1990s. The company is now the 31st largest forprofit day care operation in the U.S., with 10 locations in Massachusetts, more than 500 employees, and serving about 2,000 children at any given time. Its curriculum targets age-specific development milestones to help children from infancy up to age 6 become better prepared for entry into school. It integrates early childhood philosophies and teaching methodology of Piaget, Montessori and Reggio Emilia. Over the long view, approximately 15,000 children going through the system have experienced a positive impact on their future.
Donna’s husband Walter joined the company as CFO early on. Their two sons, daughter and Donna’s sister are among the family members that have joined the company’s workforce. Daughter Kathleen DelPrete joined the company in 2004 after the birth of her second child, seeking a better work/life balance, and now serves as chief operating officer. Walter says the opportunity to work with his wife and family makes a crucial difference to him. Seven of Donna’s grandchildren have gone through the Next Generation Children’s Centers program. Three generations play key roles in the business. They have built a company that is not only big enough for all of them, but for many, many more. Every member of top management has had children enrolled in or who have gradu-
ated from Next Generation. For those who work for them, the company gives back generously. Its teachers get a 50 percent discount toward their own children’s attendance. A teacher training program establishes a career path for teachers who want to expand their skills and knowledge in the field of child care. In the community, Next Generation Children’s Center supports the Cradles to Crayons initiative, providing school supplies and gently used clothing to families in need. It also supports the Mass Department of Children and Families with an annual holiday gift drive. The company also reserves a percentage of slots for children on state-issued vouchers. Donna Kelleher serves on the FBA’s Advisory Council, in addition to many other key roles in the community. ■
15
Marketing Award
Humboldt Storage and Moving, Canton
Third Generation Howard and D’Arcy Goldman, principle owners Founded 1905 Transportation/Storage
A
s Howard Goldman likes to say, moving is the third most stressful life event for most people, right behind death and taxes. His company’s goal is to reduce the stress. Humboldt is greater Boston’s largest moving company and is an agent for United Van Lines, handling 60 percent of all of United’s volume in the Boston region. The company moves residential and corporate accounts locally, domestically and internationally. As did many of his peers in the FBA Awards, Howard Goldman grew up in the business. He remembers six- and sevenday weeks. “When you’re a kid, you don’t know any different,” he remarked in the video clip shown at the 2012 FBA Awards ceremony. But his warm, friendly attitude comes through loud and clear. A lifetime of understanding other people’s agita about moving – whether it’s a big corporate move, a family move or an individual move – percolates through the company’s mission statement and its operating ethos. The company is named for Humboldt Street in Boston, where it was formerly located. Founded in 1905 by Harris Goldman, the company started as an ice-delivery service to Boston’s North End. But as time went on, Harris’ friends and customers would call on him to use his ice wagon to help move their furniture to a new apartment. By the time ice boxes became a thing of the past, the business had transitioned into a service that moved items that wouldn’t melt. By the 1950s, Harris’ three sons, Abe, Morris and Samuel, were working for the company, and they assumed control at the Continued from page 14
steps – downsizing its facility size and its workforce, and selling 75 percent of its equipment. Within a year, a smaller, trimmed-down B-C-D regained profitability, and now services aerospace giants such as General Electric Aircraft Engines, Raytheon Corp., and various other U.S. government supply centers and Air Force bases. It has also achieved direct supplier status to Boeing Aircraft Co. 16
time of his premature death. In the 1990s, Howard and D’Arcy Goldman succeeded them and saw opportunities for growth. They moved the company to Canton, and expanded the business to include storage facilities. Its warehousing services include a 100,000-square-foot, climate-controlled facility near Routes 128 and 93, with 24hour surveillance. Over the last five years, the business has gone paperless, and has enhanced its commercial capabilities by implementing a warehousing system using barcodes to manage customers’ inventories. Its services include in-house crating services, biotech/lab moving services, and international moving. It offers a suite of information on not only logistics but also the paperwork involved in an international move.
On the smaller, consumer oriented side, Humboldt also addresses family issues, such as helping children adjust to a new environment and making a move less traumatic for them. On the other end of the demographic scale is downsizing, a growing trend as more people age out of the need for a full-sized home and move into smaller spaces. Humboldt’s website includes a compassionate guide to the emotional aspects of letting go of a lifetime of memories when making such a transition. The company’s charity involvement is extensive, ranging from donating toys to a battered women’s shelter to participation in the Pan Mass Challenge. It has adopted an organization called More Than Words, which helps troubled youth learn how to manage a business. ■
Employee training is a critical part of staying competitive, as is continued investment in new equipment and operations systems. Best-practice programs include quality management systems based on international standards, lean manufacturing and Six Sigma Green Belt training. Three generations of family members now work in the business and keep close ties to their community as well. Organi-
zations served include the Boy and Girl Scouts, homeless initiatives launched by the United Methodist Church, and a Pop Warner football team and community square-dancing events. The company has also contributed to building the Malden YMCA and provides support to local churches and neighboring businesses. Family members in leadership say the ability to rely on each other gives the company its strength. ■
Community Ecellence Award Anton’s Cleaners, Tewksbury Third Generation Charles Anton, president and CEO Founded 1913 Dry cleaning and laundry service
T
he leadership at Anton’s cleaners sees clean clothes as more than just a livelihood. The company has embarked on two self-started initiatives to redistribute used clothing to help needy families free up their precious resources for other things. This year, Anton’s received the community excellence award for its self-started initiatives in clothing rejuvenation and redistribution, and also its environmentally responsible best practices. The Coats for Kids program, initiated in 1995, is a practical program addressing a basic need. “Anyone who needs a coat will have one,” is the program’s mission. While the concept of donating coats is not a unique idea, Anton’s goes a step further and makes a substantial investment in
cleaning each donated coat before redistributing it. Each fall, the drive collects more than 60,000 winter coats for infants, children and adults. More than 250 schools and more than 300 companies, clubs and organizations – as well as thousands of individuals – donate coats, and 90 social service agencies distribute the coats. Over the life of the program, more than 744,000 coats have gone to those who need them, free of charge. The company’s Belle of the Ball program recycles prom gowns. The program has collected, cleaned and donated more than 33,400 prom dresses to young women whose economic circumstances would have otherwise prevented them from choosing a gown they could call theirs. For those young women whose families
WILLIAMSON CORP. Two awards bestowed by the executive directors of the FBA:
Comcast Spotlight Hall of Fame Award Stephanie Sonnabend, president of Sonesta Hotels
Family Business Advocacy Award Dr. Louis J. Petrovic, University of Massachusetts – Dartmouth, Advanced Technology and Manufacturing Center Melinda Ailes, Massachusetts Small Business Development Center Network
Small Business Award (50 or fewer)
SNOW’S HOME & GARDEN
Midsized Business Award (51-150)
BLOUNT FINE FOODS
Large Business Award (More than 150)
cannot afford the steep retail markups on anything prom-related, Anton’s Belle of the Ball program has broken the barrier. ■
THANKS FOR KEEPING IT IN THE FAMILY.
NEXT GENERATION CHILDREN’S CENTERS
The partners and staff of Tarlow
First Generation Award
Breed Hart & Rodgers are pleased
B-C-D METAL PRODUCTS
to congratulate the winners of the
Adversity Award
2012 Family Business Association
ANTON’S CLEANERS
Awards for Massachusetts.
Community Excellence Award
HUMBOLDT STORAGE & MOVING Marketing Excellence Award
STEPHANIE SONNABEND
Comcast Spotlight Hall of Fame Award
MELINDA AILES DR. LOUIS PETROVIC
Family Business Advocacy Award
Tarlow Breed Hart & Rodgers, P.C. Prudential Center, Boston MA 617.218.2000 www.tbhr-law.com 17
Insurance
Using Life Insurance to Meet Business and Personal Objectives An Affordable, Tax-Efficient, and Often Overlooked Financial Strategy By Richard Bowers
A
s the owner of a business, you know better than anyone that running your business seldom leaves you enough time to address important financial planning questions, such as: Is my business moving in a direction with which I’m happy? Am I doing all I can for my key people? Have I structured things such that my family won’t be saddled with business debts if I die prematurely? What about taxes and retirement? Am I doing what’s necessary to assure the success of my business and my personal financial security? Finding time to reflect on how you’re doing, where you’re going, how you’re going to get there, (and keeping your key people happy along the way) is more than just important – it may also be critical to R ICHARD B O W E R S your business’ longterm success and your family’s financial security. Unfortunately, if you’re like most business owners, in addition to feeling squeezed for time, you probably feel squeezed for money. What’s more, you’re probably convinced that there’s not a lot you can do to address the above questions until you have the funds with which to address them. The reality is, that’s not true. You can get started. And the solution to whichever of those questions is highest on your priority list may be a financial product you have not only overlooked, but possibly even avoided – life insurance. How can life insurance help? There are all sorts of ways. For starters, life insurance provides both 18
lifetime and death benefits you can use to protect yourself, your key people and your family, while simultaneously accomplishing important business objectives such as rewarding and retaining key employees, reducing income taxes, accumulating funds for retirement, and assuring an orderly succession of your business at death, disability, or retirement. In many cases, you can use business dollars, often on a tax-deductible basis, to pay for the policies. You can also generally choose from a wide range of plans that allow you accommodate such variables as uneven (or seasonal) cash flow. And that’s just for starters. Following are just a few of the strategies that are available to you – right now, using life insurance – to meet your financial goals in a tax efficient and affordable manner. Qualified retirement plans – If your business offers a qualified retirement plan (for example a 401(k), profit sharing, or pension plan), your contributions/accumulations can be used to buy life insurance on the participants. Premiums would be income tax-deductible to your business, and participants would be taxed each year on a relatively small “economic benefit” provided by the death benefit. The immediate benefits to you include a tax deduction for your business, the ability to provide an extra benefit to yourself and your employees, and protection for loved ones in the event of premature death. Executive bonus plans – Under these plans, you and/or your key employees can purchase life insurance and your business can pay all or a portion of the premiums.
The immediate benefits to you include a tax deduction for your business; the ability to provide an extra benefit to key employees; and the potential for supplemental retirement income (via cash values) down the road. You could also restrict your employee’s access to cash values for a stated period of time, thus creating “golden handcuffs” that make it more attractive for them to remain with your company. While participants will owe income taxes on the amount of premiums paid by the business, you could elect to pay those taxes yourself via a bonus in the amount of taxes due. Split dollar plans – Split dollar plans allow you to share the cost and benefits of a life insurance policy with key employees to whom you want to extend an extra benefit. Depending upon how the plan is structured, your employees may have access to the policy’s cash value, either immediately or at a designated future time; they may be able to name the policy beneficiary; the death benefit could be used to purchase the business interest of a deceased partner or co-owner; and the business may be able to recover all of the plan costs at the death of a covered employee. If your business owns the policy and pays the premiums, the IRS taxes the plan under an “economic benefit regime.” Premiums are not tax deductible; the “economic benefit” of the death proceeds is taxable to the employee; but the employee names the beneficiary for the death proceeds in excess of the cash value. If your business pays the premiums, but your employees own their policies, the IRS taxes your plan in the “loan regime” category,
and premium payments are essentially treated as a series of loans to your employees. Again, premiums are not tax deductible, but neither are they taxable as income to the employee. Employees, however, are responsible for loan repayment and interest on the loans. Under these plans, employees generally have full access to policy cash values for premium loan repayment. (Note: Withdrawals and policy loans will reduce the amount of the death benefit.) PASS Plus – A PASS Plus arrangement involves the creation of a partnership between you, your co-owners (if any), and your business for the purpose of owning life insurance on you and the other partners. Basically, you (and any co-owners) purchase life insurance policies and transfer them to the partnership; your business transfers cash to the partnership, which is used to pay the policy premiums. At the death of an owner, the partnership is dissolved; the business recovers its costs; and the balance of the proceeds is paid to the deceased owner’s estate, income tax free. If an owner is disabled or retires, the partnership is dissolved; the business is repaid its cash contributions; and the policy is trans-
ferred to the disabled/retired owner who can, in turn, access its cash values via income tax free loans. (Note: policy loans will reduce the amount of the death benefit.) Section 79 plans – If your business is set up as a C corporation, the IRS allows you to provide your employees with “group term life insurance” using individual cash value policies. Premiums paid by your company are tax deductible and participating employees will be taxed on the value of any insurance protection in excess of $50,000 as well as all “permanent benefits” provided by the plan. A large portion of the premiums will be considered income taxable to the participants, but because they own their own policies, they retain access to cash values via income tax free loans, and they can name their own beneficiary for the policy proceeds. (Note: Policy loans will reduce the amount of the death benefit.) Section 419 plans – The potential benefits of a 419 plan are many, and include life insurance, disability protection, severance pay, medical benefits, long term care, or illness and accident benefits. Premiums paid by your company are income tax de-
ductible and are not considered taxable as income to the employees. Death benefits are paid income tax free and, in certain cases (such as multi employer plans), there are no stated limits on contributions. (Note: Because of the significant tax advantages and benefits of these plans, they are receiving increased IRS scrutiny.) As a financial strategy, life insurance is often overlooked and sometimes even avoided. But in the right circumstances, it can be a tax efficient and affordable way to address the challenges you face in building and maintaining a successful business or practice. Whether it’s protecting your family, attracting and rewarding key employees, assuring business succession, or maintaining your business’ good credit rating, today’s life insurance contracts are worth a second look. This information should not be construed as tax advice. Please consult a qualified tax advisor regarding your individual circumstances. ■ RICHARD M. BOWERS IS THE INVESTMENT SPECIALIST AT LIFE SOLUTIONS GROUP IN BOSTON. HE CAN BE REACHED AT RICHARD.BOWERS@LSGNEWENGLAND.COM OR 617-722-4314.
26 years of being FORTUNE ® magazine’s “Most Admired…” It’s been an honor.
We are honored to be named FORTUNE ® magazine’s “World’s Most Admired” life insurance company. From our financial representatives who help clients achieve financial security to the Northwestern Mutual Foundation whose charitable donations help society at large, we are thankful to all who make everything we accomplish possible.
David C Mc Avoy Managing Partner The Boston Group (617) 742-6200 nmfn-thebostongroup.com 05-2779 © 2012 Northwestern Mutual is the marketing name for The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company, Milwaukee, WI (NM) (life and disability insurance, annuities) and its subsidiaries. Northwestern Mutual Investment Services, LLC (NMIS) (securities), a subsidiary of NM, broker-dealer, registered investment adviser, and member of FINRA and SIPC. David Charles Mc Avoy, General Agent(s) of NM. Managing Partners are not in legal partnership with each other, NM or its affiliates. David Charles Mc Avoy, Registered Representative(s) and Investment Adviser Representative(s) of NMIS. FORTUNE® magazine, March 21, 2011. 19
Recruiting Employees Beyond the Family By Maryann O’Connell
I
n a closely-held family business, it is sometimes difficult to admit that you cannot do it all. It may also be hard to imagine relinquishing control to individuals who are not within the family. Yet hiring employees from outside the family – perhaps those with very different backgrounds and experiences – can add vitality, new talents and a fresh perspective to the business. When a company decides to expand its workforce, whether by adding family or non-family members, it is critical to establish equitable and consistent procedures. Otherwise, those unrelated may feel that nepotism is hindering their progress and professional success. Similarly, family members may feel that the only reason they are successful is because they are related, rather than because they are making valuable contributions to the company. There are several steps companies can take to help ensure a smooth recruitment and hiring process: Conduct a Needs Analysis At the outset, management should have a clear understanding of why there is a need for additional employees. The U.S. Small Business Administration’s website poses the following questions: • Are you properly utilizing the skills and talents of your current employees? • Can your business growth support a new employee? • What are the job’s essential functions and key performance criteria? Assuming there are valid reasons for hiring, management should consider all associated costs such as recruitment ex20
penses, wages, benefits and training. If the company’s financial position is uncertain, a circumstance quite common in the current economic climate, it may be more practical to hire part-time employees or to outsource work to freelancers. Develop a Clear Job Description Job descriptions are a critical component of the recruiting process and can also serve as an important legal document and compensation tool. Companies often disregard them or fail to update the descriptions they already have in place. A good job description clearly outlines the details of the position, including the job title, tasks, expectations, goals, skills and education requirements, and working conditions. Since it may serve as a first impression of the organization for poten-
tial candidates, the job description also should be well written with information that is straightforward and simply communicated. Maximize Recruiting Tools Family-owned businesses often turn to the people they know, including relatives, when they need assistance. Although it is true that word of mouth can be helpful and chances are a family member can suggest a quality job candidate, it can also put employers in a potentially troubling situation that could lead to hiring out of obligation. To avoid this, businesses should consider all recruiting options, including recruiting firms and Internet tools such as blogs, LinkedIn and other social media resources. Industry organizations may also be helpful, as they often provide networking opportunities. Many maintain
websites with online job banks that offer members access to resumes from candidates within the field. Administer Background Checks It is human nature to assume that a prospective employee is providing honest information on a resume and during an interview. Unfortunately, that assumption may prove to be costly. According to research conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management, more than 53 percent of individuals provide false information on their resumes – everything from embellishing job responsibilities and length of time worked for a specific employer to fabricating educational degrees and accomplishments. Background checks are vital and costeffective measures that can help protect the company and its employees. This includes obtaining information on a job candidate’s work history, possible criminal record, credit history and personal references. Dismissing background checks as an unnecessary step in the recruiting process is risky, and can lead to multiple problems for a business, even financial ruin. Although employers cannot control the
integrity of a prospective employee, they have the right and the obligation to make sure the person they are hiring has legitimate qualifications. Job Offer and Onboarding Once it is determined that an employee is the right fit, he or she must be given a written job offer outlining the start date, parameters of the position, including hours, salary, and benefits, and stating to whom the individual will report. This document will help to avoid any ambiguity in the future. An employee orientation program is also a key component of the recruiting process, yet many businesses do not have a clear process in place. It is important to make sure new employees feel valued and welcomed from the moment they accept the position. This demonstrates to the employee that the company is committed to their success. Providing a company handbook, which outlines the company’s policies and procedures, and secures any necessary paperwork, such as tax, insurance and health forms, is also essential to the hiring process. Many companies lose good employees in the first six months because they fail
to offer guidance and support, essentially leaving newcomers on their own. Businesses should go the extra mile to reaffirm the employee’s decision to join the organization. This support should continue throughout the employee’s tenure. Often in a family-run business, non-family employees may feel, rightfully or not, that they are not in the inner circle when it comes to making decisions, that they are held to a different standard or that they are not valued equally. Management should consistently demonstrate that all employees are valued and rewarded for their individual and team contributions. Employees, whether in a family-owned business or not, are the lifeblood of the company. Although there are never any guarantees when it comes to hiring, developing solid recruiting and onboarding procedures can help ensure that the right people are on the team. Creating a positive work environment that motivates employees and rewards them for their contributions will help ensure that they remain loyal the company. ■ MARYANN O’CONNELL IS A MANAGER OF HR SERVICES AT INSPERITY, WHICH PROVIDES AN ARRAY OF HUMAN RESOURCE AND BUSINESS SOLUTIONS DESIGNED TO HELP IMPROVE BUSINESS PERFORMANCE.
FBA Webinar Wednesdays is a complimentary program series presented live over the web from noon – 1:00. This programming allows you to conveniently participate in the privacy of your own office. The 2013 schedule will feature dynamic family business owners and professional experts. In 2012, George Mock, third-generation president of Nye Lubricants, shared his story of how an ESOP was used to achieve liquidity while retaining family control of a business. David Zoppo, president and co-owner of R. Zoppo Corp., a third-generation contracting firm, told of re-organizing the family business to keep pace with the market without changing its culture. Family business owner Ralph Crowley of Polar Beverages discussed the topic of growth equity – how to grow your business without giving up control. On January 23, 2013, Dr. Stephen Franson will be back by popular demand. As a family business owner himself, Dr. Franson will share his enthusiasm for wellness initiatives that pay dividends. Mark your calendars for all the 2013 FBA Webinar Wednesdays and watch for featured family business peers and topics that are of interest to you. January 23 February 20
March 20 April 17
May 15 June 19
July 17 August 21
September 18 October 16
November 20 December 18
The FBA would like to thank Wolf & Company, P.C. for underwriting FBA Webinar Wednesdays. 21
The Three Key Due Diligence Areas for M&As By George D. Shaw
T
he field of mergers and acquisitions has seen a recent uptick in activity. Flush with cash, corporate buyers are using acquisitions as an attractive alternative to organic growth, while financial buyers with record amounts of capital are looking for new investments. This increase in buyer interest has many business owners exploring liquidity options. Often these owners have worked for years building a business, and most of their wealth is tied up in non-liquid private company stock. To prepare for a liquidity event, owners frequently ask what they can do to improve the value of their company. As an experienced M&A advisor, we have found that sellers can improve their deal value by focusing on three key areas of financial due diligence – the quality of financial information, the sustainability of cash flow and management of tax issues – well before any letter of intent (LOI) is signed. Quality of Financial Information Buyers gain confidence in the target company when presented with quality financial information. To minimize cost, however, many business owners opt for reviewed or compiled financial statements rather than audited financial statements. Yet we have found that non-audited statements result in significantly more negative adjustments as a deal progresses. Since any surprise in the historical financial results puts downward pressure on price, business owners can avoid late renegotiation of the deal terms by getting audited financial statements two years or more before the liquidity event. Buyers also want to know the source and sustainability of revenue growth, including which customers, services and products generate the highest margins and cash 22
flow. That helps a buyer understand how the acquired business will integrate into their strategic plans. Often the highest multiples are paid when buyers get excited about the customer base and the ability to accelerate the growth post closing. Internal controls are becoming a bigger diligence issue as more public company buyers subject to Sarbanes Oxley (SOX) reporting are active in the M&A market. There is also increased interest in controls by financial buyers who want to know that the operating cash will be protected. An assessment of controls will identify areas of improvement that can be changed prior to a liquidity event. Sustainable Cash Flow Most businesses are sold based upon a multiple of cash flow or “EBITDA” (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization). The higher the EBITDA, the higher the price. A key focus of financial diligence is confirming whether the EBITDA is real and sustainable. Most failed deals are due to the fact that the EBITDA reported to the buyer did not hold up in a financial due diligence review post-LOI. Common trouble spots include inventory, the quality of accounts receivable, and unrecorded liabilities such as litigation. Moreover, the recent recession may have shifted the customer base as companies went out of business, changed suppliers and or consolidated. These changes can impact not only the quality of the revenue/EBITDA but also the quality of inventory and accounts receivable reported on the balance sheet.
Tax Issues The tax structure of the deal will have a significant impact on the after-tax proceeds. Taxes can erode between 20 percent to 55 percent of deal value. As advisors, we often assist business owners in structuring options that will net them the highest after tax amounts. Managing tax risk is increasingly important. With budget deficits and fiscal pressure many states are using audit compliance efforts to collect additional tax revenues from businesses. Advance tax diligence can identify risk areas and allow the business time to make voluntary disclosures or implement compliance mitigation plans. Buyers are not only concerned with historical liability risk, but also what tax liability will be incurred post closing due to bad tax management policies. Involving experienced M&A advisors early in the liquidity planning process can help improve deal value significantly. Pre-LOI financial due diligence is an important contributor to improved deal value. If a business owner can improve EBITDA by $300,000, it should result in a sale price increase of $1.5 million or more. Analysis of other areas such as infrastructure considerations, customer concentration, budget planning, key performance indicators and succession planning also lead to a smoother and more lucrative transaction. ■ GEORGE D. SHAW, CPA, IS THE PARTNER IN CHARGE OF TRANSACTION ADVISORY SERVICES AT DICICCO, GULMAN & COMPANY, A WOBURN-BASED CPA AND BUSINESS ADVISORY FIRM.
DEPOSIT & CASH MANAGEMENT • RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT & TRUST • COMMERCIAL BANKING
THIS IS
YOUR
TIME. THIS IS
YOUR
PRIVATE
BANK. SM
We want to congratulate our client, the Williamson corporation, winner of the 2012 Family Business association award for Massachusetts, Small Business category. Every day, Boston Private Bank works with people who are innovating, building and contributing in their careers and their lives. if you’re a business owner, individual, or nonprofit and want the individualized attention and expertise your financial needs deserve, maybe it’s your time to start a relationship with Boston Private Bank. Please call Mark Thompson, cEO, at 617-912-1919.
BostonPrivateBank.com
B O S T O N
•
S a N
F r a N c i S c O
•
L O S
a N G E L E S
investments are not FDic insured, are not a deposit, have no bank guarantee, and may lose value.
•
S E a T T L E
Our 100 years means that wherever you are going, we can guide you there.
JiM Kenney, CPA MeMBeR of THe fiRM AudiT & AssuRAnCe
At Wolf & Company, we pride ourselves on insightful guidance and responsive service. As a leading regional firm, our dedicated professionals and tenured leaders provide Assurance, Tax, Risk Management and Business Consulting services that help you achieve your goals. Hear about our experiences working at family businesses. Visit wolfandco.com/family.