DEVELOP3D August / September 2021 by X3DMEDIA

NX 7.0 Automotive interiors P32 Siemens True-to-scale ARP40 P36

Sketching P42

TECHNOLOGY FOR THE PRODUCT LIFECYCLE

AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 | £6 | € 7 | $10 | DEVELOP3D.COM

ZUMA’S LIGHTBULB MOMENT Rethinking smart gadgetry for the connected home

RESPONSIVE FURNITURE 3D-PRINTED SPARE PARTS p01_D3D_AUGSEP2021_Cover-flash.indd 1

E D I S N I E E FR N TIO A T KS OR W GE A -P 38

T OR P E LR A I EC SP

16/08/2021 16:04

W NE TE 022 DA ril 2 Ap

m fro ion pt ru dis to ue ,d led du he sc Re

19 DVI CO

2022

OPTIMISE YOUR ENTIRE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS 6 April 2022 University of Sheffield UK develop3dlive.com

PLATINUM SPONSOR

GOLD SPONSORS

SILVER SPONSORS

BRONZE SPONSORS

D3D AUG SEPT 21 A4 ad.indd 2

17/08/2021 08:42

WELCOME EDITORIAL Editor Stephen Holmes stephen@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)20 3384 5297 Managing Editor Greg Corke greg@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)20 3355 7312 Consulting Editor Jessica Twentyman jtwentyman@gmail.com +44 (0)20 7913 0919 Consulting Editor Martyn Day martyn@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)7525 701 542

DESIGN/PRODUCTION Design/Production Greg Corke greg@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)20 3355 7312

ADVERTISING Group Media Director Tony Baksh tony@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)20 3355 7313 Deputy Advertising Manager Steve King steve@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)20 3355 7314 US Sales Director Denise Greaves denise@x3dmedia.com +1 857 400 7713

SUBSCRIPTIONS Circulation Manager Alan Cleveland alan@x3dmedia.com +44 (0)20 3355 7311

ACCOUNTS Accounts Manager Charlotte Taibi charlotte@x3dmedia.com Financial Controller Samantha Todescato-Rutland sam@chalfen.com

s I take my place as Editor of DEVELOP3D, it’s been playing on my mind just how formal I should make this initial hello. Should I make it a business-like firm handshake, without breaking eye contact; or more of a slap on the shoulder while we queue up at the bar? After all, it’s not like I’m a complete newcomer to these pages. For some of you, we’ve probably met before. I’d nervously hope, too, that others might have read something I’ve scribbled here over the years. For everyone else: I’d like to apologise in advance for my language. Having thrown in my lot with DEVELOP3D some 13 years ago now, this is far from my first rodeo. Part of the reason I’ve hung around this long is the people I’ve met and the stories they’ve told me. I’ve always wanted this to be a place for these characters – from Bangalore to Barnsley – and have hoped this magazine would give them a voice and encourage others to share the projects they’ve worked on, too, whatever their scale or capacity. So far, it seems to be working. As if to prove the point, we have a fully stacked issue for you, spearheaded by some excellent design and engineering from Zuma, a company aiming to simplify our various connected home gadgets by parcelling seemingly incompatible hardware into a tiny, slick package. Chris Cheung digs into the art of sketching and explains why this skill is still so important to design in the digital age. Elsewhere, we look at how the age-old baseball glove is being transformed for the twenty-first century, and at office furniture being reimagined for a new breed of workspace. This is followed up with a wholehearted slab of workstation goodness – the type of reading that will steer you well, should you be looking at what the very latest computer hardware can offer you. Finally, it’d be daft of me not to say thanks to my forebearer, Al Dean, for all he’s done for both DEVELOP3D and myself over the years. He is genuinely one of a kind. And with that we begin an exciting new chapter. Hello! (I don’t do hugs.)

ABOUT DEVELOP3D is published by

X3DMedia 19 Leyden Street London E1 7LE, UK T. +44 (0)20 3355 7310 F. +44 (0)20 3355 7319 © 2021 X3DMedia Ltd All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or part without prior permission from the publisher is prohibited. All trademarks acknowledged Opinions expressed in articles are those of the author and not of X3DMedia. X3DMedia cannot accept responsibility for errors in articles or advertisements within the magazine

Stephen Holmes Editor, DEVELOP3D Magazine, @swearstoomuch

Join our online community DEVELOP3D.com

facebook.com/DEVELOP3D

@DEVELOP3D

groups/DEVELOP3D

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 3

p03_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Editor.indd 3

18/08/2021 16:03

RUN FULL BEV SAFETY SIMULATIONS OVERNIGHT AMD EPYC™ 7003 Series Processors together with Altair’s industry-leading solvers,, allow you to simulate automotive crash events, road debris impacts and shocks at the speed of your vehicle development program. AMD EPYC 7003 Series Processors are the new standard for the modern data center.. With high frequencies, high core-counts, high memory bandwidth and capacity, and up to 256MB of L3 cache, AMD EPYC 7003 series processors enable exceptional HPC performance. Altair and AMD give you the insight and processing power needed to help improve safety and reliability for the next generation of electric vehicles. Learn more at web.altair.com/amd_radioss and amd.com/hpc

Altair Engineering, Inc. All Rights Reserved. / altair.com / Nasdaq: ALTR AMD, the AMD logo, EPYC, combinations thereof are trademarks Altairand Engineering, Inc. All Rights Reserved. / altair.com / Nasdaq: ALTR / Contact Us of Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.

altair.indd 2

08/06/2021 20:09

altair.indd 3

08/06/2021 20:09

www.driveworks.co.uk

Automate SOLIDWORKS manufacturing processes & sell digitally using DriveWorks DriveWorks is ﬂexible and scalable. Start for free, upgrade anytime. DriveWorksXpress is included free inside SOLIDWORKS or start your free 30 day trial of DriveWorks Solo.

DriveWorks Pro Modular SOLIDWORKS® automation & online product configurator software

30EEDTARIYAL

DriveWorks Solo

Complete SOLIDWORKS part, assembly and drawing automation

SOLIDWORKS® part, assembly and drawing automation add-in

DriveWorksXpress

Automatically generate manufacturing and sales documents

Automate SOLIDWORKS parts, assemblies and drawings

Configure order specific designs in a browser on desktop, mobile or tablet

Generate production ready drawings, BOMs & quote documents automatically

Show configurable design details with interactive 3D previews

Entry level SOLIDWORKS part and assembly automation

Enter product specifications and preview designs inside SOLIDWORKS

Integrate with SOLIDWORKS PDM, CRM, ERP, CAM and other company systems

Create a drawing for each part and assembly

Free online technical learning resources, sample projects and help file

Scalable and flexible licensing options

Entry level design automation software included free inside SOLIDWORKS®

Sold and supported by your local SOLIDWORKS reseller

Find under the SOLIDWORKS tools menu

Sold and supported by your local SOLIDWORKS reseller

Try examples online at www.driveworkslive.com One time setup

Connect sales & manufacturing

Save time & innovate more

Integrate with other systems

Eliminate errors

Intelligent guided selling

Set up once and run again and again. No need for complex SOLIDWORKS macros, design tables or conﬁgurations.

Automate repetitive SOLIDWORKS tasks and free up engineers to focus on product innovation and development.

DriveWorks rules based SOLIDWORKS automation eliminates errors and expensive, time-consuming design changes.

Validation ensures you only offer products that can be manufactured, eliminating errors and boosting quality.

DriveWorks Pro can integrate with other company systems, helping you work more efﬁciently and effectively.

Ensure your sales teams / dealers conﬁgure the ideal solution every time with intelligent rules-based guided selling.

CONTENTS AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 ISSUE NO. 129

9 NEWS Nvidia launches ray tracing GPU for tiny workstations, Desktop Metal acquires ExOne, Altair announces winners of the Enlighten Awards 2021, plus lots more... 12 14 18 20 28 32 35 36 40 42

FEATURES Comment: Erin McDermott praises hidden heroes Comment: SJ on luck and preparation in job-hunting Visual Design Guide: Rawlings REV1X baseball glove COVER STORY: Zuma’s smart home spotlight Joyride Design’s response to stylish seating needs Formation’s audacious approach to automotive interiors Spare change: 3D printing spare parts at Miele BMW puts true-to-scale augmented reality to the test New simulation tools take flight at Airframe Designs Sketchy business: why doodling still has a place in design

44 THE LAST WORD At the tail end of an engrossing summer of sport, Stephen Holmes reflects on the role that product development technology now plays in determining athletic outcomes PLUS

WS02 WS04 WS10 WS14 WS15 WS16 WS18 WS20 WS26 WS28 WS32 WS37 WS38

FREE INSIDE WORKSTATION SPECIAL REPORT Desktop workstation buyer’s guide Intel Core vs AMD Ryzen Talking heads: Multicore for CAD Review: Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R Review: Workstation Specialists WS-184 CAD workstation round-up Best lightweight workstation laptops Review: AMD Radeon Pro W6800 GPU Review: AMD Radeon Pro Viewport Boost Review: Nvidia RTX A4000 / A5000 GPUs Graphics boost for CAD applications Hybrid working: What does it mean for design firms? Cloud workstation round-up

The wood used to produce this magazine comes from Forest Stewardship Council certified well-managed forests, controlled sources and/or recycled material

FREE SUBSCRIPTIONS Register your details to ensure you get a regular copy register.develop3d.com

Sheffield, 6 April 2022 develop3dlive.com

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 7

p07_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Contents.indd 7

18/08/2021 14:08

NEWS NEWS

NVIDIA RTX A2000 'RAY TRACING' GPU LAUNCHES FOR TINY WORKSTATIONS » Costing $450 and compatible with both small form factor and tower workstations, Nvidia's new pro desktop GPU promises to bring ‘real-time’ ray tracing to the masses

he Nvidia RTX A2000, the company's first ‘real-time’ ray tracing and AI acceleration GPU designed specifically for small form factor workstations (SFF), has launched. With an estimated street price of $450, the RTX A2000 marks a big step forwards in bringing RTX technology into the mainstream workstation segment. According to Nvidia, it opens up RTX to many more designers, who may have been working on small assemblies and now need to ray trace them. SFF workstations like the HP Z2 SFF and Dell Precision 3450 SFF are extremely popular with design and engineering firms, because they take up significantly less space than standard desktop towers. However, because of their size, they are limited to ‘low-profile’ form factor GPUs. Historical low-profile GPUs like the Nvidia Quadro P1000 are not RTX-enabled and are only suitable for mainstream 3D CAD workflows (although some SFF workstations offer a custom version of the Nvidia Quadro RTX 3000, an MXM form factor GPU typically found in mobile workstations). The Nvidia RTX A2000 is low profile, but a lot thicker than others. It takes up two slots on

the motherboard, something typically associated with high-end GPUs like the Nvidia RTX A5000 or Nvidia RTX A6000. However, The Nvidia RTX A2000 is not limited to SFF workstations. When the GPU is purchased separately (that is, not as part of a fully configured workstation), it also comes with fullheight ATX

bracket, so it can be fitted in a standard tower. Specifications include 6 GB GDDR6 of ECC memory, four Mini DisplayPort connectors and a max power consumption of 70W. It features 8 TFLOPS of single precision performance (double that of the previous generation 5 GB Nvidia Quadro P2200), 15.6 TFLOPS of RT Core Performance and 63.9 TFLOPS of Tensor Performance. These specs are a fair way behind the more powerful $999 Nvidia RTX A4000 (16 GB), which is available in mini towers, and features 19.2 TFLOPS of single precision performance, 37.4 TFLOPS of RT Core performance and 153.4 TFLOPS of Tensor performance (see page WS28 for a full review). The Nvidia RTX A2000 will be available starting in October, in workstations from manufacturers including ASUS, BOXX Technologies, Dell Technologies, HP and Lenovo, as well as Nvidia’s partners. nvidia.com

(Above) The dual-slot, low-profile design is a first for pro graphics (Below left) Come October, we expect the Nvidia RTX A2000 will be offered as an option in the HP Z2 G8 SFF workstation

WHAT DEVELOP3D MAGAZINE THINKS This is a very smart move from Nvidia as the company looks to extend the reach of its RTX technology among design, engineering and architecture firms. It’s also one that took us completely by surprise. We had expected Nvidia to launch an RTX A2000

GPU, but had no idea that it would have a low-profile form factor, using a dual-slot design to deliver required levels of performance. By doing so, Nvidia not only brings RTX technology into the mainstream, but also makes it compatible

with millions of small form factor workstations already in the market. The hope is that firms previously unable to widely adopt RTX-enabled workflows without swapping out a whole fleet of workstations can now do so with a relatively simple and

low-cost upgrade. Nvidia will be keen to drive adoption of its Nvidia Omniverse collaboration and simulation platform, although there are plenty of other RTX-enabled applications out there, such as KeyShot, Unreal Engine and Solidworks Visualize.

Beyond RTX, the Nvidia RTX A2000 should also help give extended CADfocused teams access to other real-time viz tools and, of course, VR. We’re excited by this announcement and look forward to testing out the GPU later this year.

The one question mark we have is whether 6 GB be too limiting for some pro users, even those considered entry-level? For a GPU of this capability, we would have expected 8 GB, especially as it’s quite a big step up to the 16 GB Nvidia RTX A4000.

8 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p08_D3D_AUGSEPT21-NEWS.indd 8

16/08/2021 18:46

When we didn’t have capability in-house we were actually able to use Solid Solutions as a resource on some of our thermal and CFD capabilities. Julian Swan, Engineering Director | PLASMATRACK

MUCH MORE THAN SOFTWARE PROFESSIONAL DESIGN SOLUTIONS

CHECK OUT THE VIDEO NOW SCAN ME

From initial design concept through to full life-cycle management, our Professional Services care for every stage of growth and development, from start-ups to established businesses. Tel: 01926 333 777

solidsolutions.co.uk/professional-services

NEWS

DESKTOP METAL TO ACQUIRE METALS AM RIVAL EXONE

CamWorks gets PrimeTurning tech

andvik Coromant's PrimeTurning technology will be integrated with software from HCL CAMWorks, in a new partnership recently announced between the two companies. The PrimeTurning method and supporting tools are designed to deliver what Sandvik refers to as the first true “all-directional turning” solution. In contrast with conventional turning operations, this means that machine shop operators are able to complete longitudinal (forward and back), facing and profiling operations, all using a single tool. sandvik.com | camworks.com

esktop Metal has announced it is to acquire ExOne, a leader in binder jet 3D printing technology. The deal, valued at $575 million, brings to its new owner ExOne's expertise in metals, ceramics, composites and sand and in using its technology to build precision parts, metal-casting moulds, cores and tooling solutions. Desktop Metal has been in the headlines regularly since going public at the end of 2020, a move that opened the doors to acquisition. Since then, it has bought polymer 3D printing vendor Envisiontec, in a $300 million deal that closed in February 2021. ExOne has been pretty busy, too. In 2020, the company built out its product offering, adding nanoparticle technology to its

binder jetting capabilities, and a raft of 15 new materials, including M2 Tool Steel, Silicon carbide, Aluminium and Inconel 718 – all with serious functional properties. “We are thrilled to bring ExOne into the Desktop Metal family to create the leading additive manufacturing portfolio for mass production,” said Desktop Metal CEO Ric Fulop. “This transaction is a big step in delivering on our vision of accelerating the adoption of additive manufacturing 2.0.” Desktop Metal will combine ExOne’s direct sales force with its own global distribution network of over 200 channel partners, giving it “broader access to additive manufacturing solutions for businesses of all sizes, while delivering increased materials innovation to provide customers with more choice and drive new application discovery.” desktopmetal.com

ExOne brings new nanoparticle and binder jet technologies to Desktop Metal

haos has released V-Ray 5 for Unreal, a new update to its production rendering plug-in that is designed to import V-Ray scenes, bake lighting and render ray-traced images and animation in Unreal Engine. Updates in this release include new levels of control over light baking, augmenting production presets with the ability to completely customise the rendering settings. Users can now finetune global illumination, sampling and noise levels, so that they’re always optimised for the project at hand. chaosgroup.com

Siemens adds new design capabilities to NX

iemens Digital Industries Software has announced the release of NX Automation Designer software and NX Industrial Electrical Design software, with the aim of helping manufacturers of production systems to manage design complexity, shorten development lifecycles and increase design quality. Direct integration with Teamcenter PLM software and the entire NX design software portfolio comes as standard, to help keep a unified multidisciplinary design environment for production systems engineering. NX Industrial Electrical Design provides new functions, with enhancements to connection handling and reporting, new OOTB symbols for IEC, ANSI and fluidics and 2D cabinet dimensioning. Automation

Chaos releases V-Ray 5 for Unreal

Hänssler's FDM printing benefits

H Designer, meanwhile, aims to extended software generation capabilities for sequences and safety programmes. Interestingly, these latest releases enable customers to get started in the world of functional design, without needing to use Teamcenter. sw.siemens.com

Production systems engineering is the focus of new software from Siemens Digital Industries Software

änssler Group has revealed its strategy for qualifying more parts for end use, using Ultimaker S5 3D printers and Kimya’s specialist ABS-ESD filament to produce highly accurate sealant parts with antielectrostatic properties. The German company has over 30 years of experience in producing industrial products such as seals and O-rings, typically by CNC machining. But experimentations with 3D printing have resulted in Hänssler being able to create accurate and more complex parts at a lower pre-part cost and with much less waste, according to company marketing manager Adrian Heinrich. dicht.de

10 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_NEWS.indd 10

18/08/2021 09:43

ALTAIR ANNOUNCES WINNERS OF ENLIGHTEN AWARDS 2021

ROUND UP Canvas GFX has launched Canvas Envision, which aims to bridge the gap between technical and commercial documentation. The goal is to help document creators in a business sidestep the need to ask CAD operators to capture and supply screenshots on their behalf canvasgfx.com

inners of the Altair Enlighten Awards 2021 have been announced, featuring some incredible weight-reducing technologies and designs that aim to curb automotive carbon footprints, while also minimising water and energy consumption and promoting material reuse and recycling. Presented in partnership with the Center for Automotive Research (CAR), the Altair Enlighten Awards 2021 recognise the automotive industry’s most impressive sustainable engineering initiatives, focusing on lightweighting and the use of innovative materials, technologies and techniques to cut CO2 emissions. In the sustainable products categories, the award for sustainable vehicle went to the Ford Motor Company, for the 2021 Ford Mustang Mach-E, an all-electric car that boasts a 100% vegan interior. The award for sustainable component, meanwhile, was scooped by Magna International, for its 2019 RAM 1500 active air deflector and grille shutters, which use lightweight, 78% recyclable plastics and reduce drag by 9%. And the sustainable process award went to Faurecia, for NAFILean Stiff, a polypropylene compound that uses 20% bio-sourced contents and is 100% recyclable. In the lightweighting categories, the award for lightweighting enabling technology was won by Arcelor Mittal for its Fortiform 980GI next-generation steel, which offers potential weight savings of up to 20%. Stellantis, meanwhile, was awarded the prize for module lightweighting, for its composite

tunnel reinforcement for the Jeep Grand Cherokee, which achieves a 40% weight savings on the component itself, and a further 20% on the subsystem. Finally, the Future of Lightweighting award was won by American Axle & Manufacturing (AAM) for its electric drive unit. This saves more than 25% in mass compared to similar units on the market and combines electric machine, gearbox and inverter in a compact package with a higher power-to-weight ratio than competing products. “The 2021 Enlighten Award shines a light on the inspiring work of automotive engineers worldwide. Now more than ever, sustainability and emissions reduction are critical challenges not just for the automotive sector, but society as a whole,” said Altair CEO James Scapa. “ altair.com

Ford Motor Company was a winner at the Altair Enlighten Awards for the 2021 Ford Mustang Mach-E

Essentium has announced it is to acquire Collider, a start-up that has created a system that combines DLP 3D printing with common injection moulding materials, which it calls ‘programmable tooling’. Collider CEO Graham Bredemeyer will join the Essentium team as director of its photopolymer group essentium.com

Epic Games has acquired Sketchfab, which is home to some 4 million 3D assets. The company's technology offers integration with pretty much all major 3D creation tools and publishing platforms and compatibility across all major browsers and mobile/ desktop operating systems epicgames.com

Corona Renderer 7 gets a materials boost

orona Renderer 7 for 3ds Max has been refreshed, receiving updates for greater realism, new physical material options and improvements to rendering performance. Diffuse calculations have been switched from Lambertian to Oren-Nayar, so even simple materials will look better and be more physically correct, while changes to the user interface should boost user confidence that materials will appear realistic once rendered. New physical material options cover coatings, sheens, glass, metals, wood and the entirely new category of masonry. Creating brand-new materials in Corona Renderer 7 has a better starting point now, too, with 35 presets for a range of common materials to speed up user workflows by instantly setting up parameters.

New optimisations and speed-ups are claimed to offer improvements in render times of between 6% and 50%, depending on the scene. A pass can now be calculated in a 32 x 32 pixel block, in order to offer an overall 5% speed-up on average, and up to 15% in some scenes. corona-renderer.com

New industry-specific composite materials for the aerospace sector, Onyx FR-A and Carbon Fibre FR-A, have been launched by MarkForged, after successfully passing a qualification programme conducted by the National Institute for Aviation Research (NIAR) markforged.com

Visualisations created in Corona Renderer 7 are now more life-like than ever

Theorem-XR has made new enhancements to its data- and device-neutral software, Extended Reality Suite, enabling users to view 3D CAD and PLM assets in context and at full scale, using augmented, mixed and virtual reality technologies on the device of their choice theorem.com

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 11

p10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_NEWS.indd 11

18/08/2021 09:43

COMMENT

A brilliant product typically owes a great deal to a whole cast of unsung heroes who don’t get the praise and appreciation they deserve for their hard work and smarts. It’s time that changed, writes Erin McDermott

any brilliant products only exist because of critical work done by ‘little guys’ in the development ecosystem. Yet suppliers, machine shop pros, line workers and hardware start-ups often get little credit, while the reputations (and egos) of giant-sized players continue to inflate. So, let’s take a moment to appreciate the unsung heroes! When it comes to talking about the suppliers and service providers of all sizes that feed the Apples, Amazons, Fords and SpaceXs of the planet, I speak from experience. Formerly, I designed optics for headlamps at a Tier 1 automotive supplier. After that role, my boss at my next, unrelated job mentioned to me that all companies like GM, Ford and Chrysler have their own in-house optical engineering expertise, enabling them to develop illumination without outside assistance. I said that wasn’t true. He said I didn’t know what I was talking about. Then, I reminded him that designing optical systems for these companies was literally my previous job, precisely because they didn’t have the knowledge to do it themselves. Later, as the owner of a service provider to leading manufacturers, I learned that vendors are often contractually forbidden from mentioning what work we do. Sometimes, we can’t even hint at who our clients are without facing a lawsuit! The inability to show off our work makes it difficult for us small fries to grow. What’s more, it lends to the false impression that the Goliaths are gigantic because they gobbled up all the best talent in the world. In reality, lots of little experts stand in the giant’s shadow to prop them up.

A HUGE BLIND SPOT While I find it wild that those of us working in product development don’t realize how many key players are hidden, I too had a huge blind spot until recently. Last year, I

interviewed the founder of Hooke Audio about his latest successfully crowdfunded product, a wireless lav mic. I asked Anthony Mattana, “This seems like such an obvious and relatively easy product for an Apple-sized company to make, so why don’t they?” That’s when Mattana enlightened me on something that should be obvious. Companies that first make a name for themselves by being innovative, daring and cutting-edge lose these traits as they age and get bigger. I thought about products I see gigantic manufacturers push out today versus at their beginning and had to admit that today’s new releases come with much less of a ‘wow factor’. This founder told me large companies with stockholders to satisfy often let smaller hardware start-ups take on the risk. They watch start-ups fail while taking careful notes. When a few start-ups succeed with a product that makes sense for their line, they can do one of two things. The big guy might offer to buy the small guy. More often, however, a big company throws its huge, unmatchable development budget at creating its own version of the vetted, market-tested product. In either case, the big manufacturer gets the credit that we actually owe to the original hardware start-up.

TIME TO SHINE Lastly, let’s shine some light on the most hidden champions: the lab techs, machine shop workers and line workers. These people have been on my mind lately, as my favorite former factory worker, my Dad, recently passed away. My father’s education was interrupted, and I often wonder where he might have otherwise ended up. He would have made a terrific ‘official’ and degreed engineer, as his father was. Unofficially, he already was one in my mind. He did a lot of clever things beyond his pay grade, and one was to design an adaptation for a machine he ran to keep it from



When it comes to Goliath companies, the reality is that lots of little experts stand in the giant’s shadow to prop them up



jamming. After engineers were shipped in from other facilities to fix the unfixable process, and failed, Dad out-engineered them all. Seeing this as a child, I knew not to take much stock in degrees from top universities and to appreciate all the players. This perspective aided me whenever I worked alongside line workers as an engineer. A line crew would first accuse me of being ‘fancy’ and snobbish, because of my position. I’d reply that I knew how hard they worked and how important their jobs were, because my Dad worked on a line, too. After that, I’d immediately be given the social OK from the group. However, there was more to it than lip service. While working in research, many times, the machine shop guys invented an ingenious prototyping hack when progress halted. In development, the lab technicians’ extra efforts often saved the day. When these heroes came through, I was always quick to give praise – in part, because I wasn’t in shock over where these key efforts came from. That recognition, in turn, helped us form more solid working relationships. So, the next time you appreciate something about a product, lend a thought to the little guys that made it possible. It might just indirectly help you in your own career one day!

GET IN TOUCH: Erin M McDermott directs optical engineering at Spire Starter, helping hardware engineers who don’t know that things using light (cameras, LED illumination, laser processes and so on) need competent design, optimisation and tolerancing, just like the rest of their widget. Get in touch at spirestarter.com or @erinmmcdermott

12 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p12_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Erin.indd 12

13/08/2021 09:57

3DEXPERIENCE® SOLIDWORKS for Makers The world’s best design tools — now for hobbyists and personal projects.

YOUR IDEAS

visit: discover.solidworks.com/makers

COMMENT

As a new academic year gets underway, our columnist SJ has some valuable advice for engineering graduates on the vital role that preparation should play in helping them to forge the career of their dreams

ately, I’ve been hearing the same line again and again from the young engineers who I mentor: “I don’t know if I want to go to grad school for another year, or if I want to get a job in industry and start working.” It’s by no means a new dilemma, but the pandemic has brought with it a whole new set of complications to take into consideration. Many of my mentees, for example, see staying at grad school as a safe stopover until the economy and job market lumber back to something we recognise as ‘normal’. I tell them what I always tell them: I’m a firm believer that luck is where preparation meets opportunity – so how prepared are they really for the world of work? I speak from experience here. My first job interview at a hospital as a young and impressionable engineer, fresh out of grad school and looking to make a career for myself in medical devices, wasn’t great. Sweating in my suit and tie, as cardiologists and orthopedic surgeons glanced at my resume over thin-rimmed glasses, their feedback crushed me. It took me almost two weeks to pluck up the courage to ask what skills or qualifications I would need to get a similar position at the hospital. I was told that my lack of medical terminology and inability to operate clinical equipment was a huge gap. Plus, I didn’t have the professional engineer (PE) licence that was a minimum requirement to bring a medical device from prototype to practice. Ultimately, I was able to make opportunities happen for me through hard work, consistency and a lot of legwork and networking. But was I prepared? My universities had led me to believe I was, but were they mistaken?

A GRAVE MISCALCULATION It took some painstaking analysis to see what was going wrong for me, based on comparing the educational requirements and minimum qualifactions for jobs I’d saved on online

jobs boards with my own resume. As an engineer, the gravity of my miscalculation hit hard: I wasn’t actually prepared for any of the medical jobs I wanted. What these employers were looking for was an engineer with some serious CAD skills, a strong medical background, and a solid track record in 3D printing. The next day, I switched tactics and started searching LinkedIn for positions focusing on CAD or 3D printing in general. For every job I applied for, I added the requirements to my list of objectives. If the qualification was easily obtainable – a simple CAD certification, for example – then I would sign up for the certification class using my student email. Over the course of 18 months, my skills expanded rapidly as I took advantage of free education programmes for students. It rounded out my resume, and as I added the skills to my LinkedIn profile, I began showing up on the radar of more and more recruiters.

GETTING LUCKY Again, I reiterate – luck is when preparation meets opportunity. One day, I was bumping around the internet when I spotted a metal 3D printing start-up in the next town over. I picked up the phone and gave the owner a call to ask if I could interview him about the industry as a recent graduate. We spoke for 30 minutes. He seemed not to mind my rabid curiosity and he gave me names of other people who might speak with me about the industry. A few days later, I got an email back requesting if, this time, he could interview me, for a new position opening on his team. The role focused on 3D printing metal implants for an orthopedic surgeon. I remember holding my breath as I said yes. Two months later, I was there on my first day as a biomedical engineer, 3D printing patient-specific implants. It may not have been in a hospital, as I’d always imagined, but I was surrounded by like-minded engineers who were just as passionate about 3D printing as I was.



I’m a firm believer that luck is where preparation meets opportunity – but how prepared are graduate students really for the world of work?



ASKING THE HARD QUESTIONS The road to success is never linear. I just hope that the new graduates who I mentor are currently asking themselves the hard questions. Are they prepared for the positions that they actually want, not the ones that their peers and professors have been spouting about? Do they have all the skills and training they need to get there? And, if not, do they have a plan to level up, to get the experience and qualifications they will need in order to advance in their careers? If having a graduate degree is a requirement for the job you want, then I say it’s a safe bet to pursue more education. But if you start looking at job descriptions and they don’t have an Master’s degree or PhD requirement, then it’s likely to be far more advantageous to get work experience as early on as possible. And I’d also like to add that it’s perfectly OK if unfortunate circumstances mean this isn’t your first attempt at launching your career. It’s not easy to navigate the workforce in the beginning. But please take unlucky breaks as opportunities to test your mettle and to learn more about your strengths and weaknesses, in order to prepare better for the future. So my advice to new grads trying to decide if this is the best time to fly the nest and start the journey? You simply won’t know until you try your luck.

GET IN TOUCH: SJ is a metal additive engineer aka THEE Hot Girl of Metal Printing. She currently works as a metal additive applications engineer providing AM solutions and #3dprinting of metal parts to help create a decarbonised world. Get in touch at @inconelle on twitter

14 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p14_D3D_AUGSEPT21_SJ.indd 14

13/08/2021 10:14

Let's Face It Data Management Is Important 86% of companies said they need to reduce errors caused by working on the wrong version of a design or receiving important project information too late. Sound familiar? Download a copy of The Engineering Leader’s Guide to Onshape PDM & Data Management Visit: https://bit.ly/pdm-ebook

0121 506 9720 | sales@concurrent-engineering.co.uk | www.concurrent-engineering.co.uk

Sponsored content

Identifying opportunities to use generative design A few questions we often hear are “Why should I use generative design?” and “What are the ideal applications for generative design?” Here is a quick checklist to help you spot the best opportunities: Are you looking to improve the performance of your product? • Lightweighting • Increased structural integrity • Extended durability Are you trying to improve your engineering ideation/productivity? • Explore design alternatives quickly • Expand beyond past references (tribal knowledge) • Save engineering time and iterations

Are you trying to reduce the cost of your product? • Part consolidation to reduce the number of parts in an assembly • Reduced raw materials • Evaluate different manufacturing methods If one or more of these factors are important to your design, then it’s likely a good candidate for generative design. As you can see from these examples, everyday engineers are using generative design to come up with practical designs that can be manufactured using traditional methods. So don’t be intimated by generative design—get started. Start identifying opportunities in your products and begin exploring various outcomes with generative design in Autodesk Fusion 360. Learn more: autodesk.com/products/fusion-360/overview

p16_17_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Advertorial.indd 3

Every gram we can remove helps. We want a machine that can handle a 250-pound person hanging on it but be light enough to give the perception of zero mass in free motion Ethereal founder Scott Summit

16/08/2021 19:05

VISUAL DESIGN GUIDE RAWLINGS REV1X BASEBALL GLOVE Baseball gloves have barely changed during the sport’s history, until Rawlings partnered with Fast Radius 3D printing technology company Carbon to produce the major baseball brand’s newest release, the REV1X glove

STRAP-INAn elasticated wrist strap removes the need for cumbersome laces, while a moisturewicking material helps maintain comfort, even when taking the field in Arizona

THUMB & PINKY A 3D-printed FPU 50 polymer lattice unit, built using Carbon’s DLS 3D printing technology, replaces felt and leather padding. That reduces weight and improves flex, making the glove more responsive for catching

18 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p18_19_D3D_AUGSEPT21_VDG.indd 18

12/08/2021 15:11

BACK BRIGHTER The ability to customise a glove has rarely gone beyond coloured leather panels and stamps. Now, players can incorporate personalised graphic designs, protected by a clear polymer shell

BREAK TIME Players can break the glove in faster – traditionally a process that involves pummelling the ‘heel’ of the glove with a round mallet. That means players can head onto the field wearing comfortable, customised versions sooner

LACES OUT Removing more of the traditional leather binding laces reduces the weight and stiffness found in a traditional glove

PRICE AND AVAILABILITY Available now, the Rawlings REV1X glove starts at $399.95 rawlings.com

DEVELOP3D.COM DEVELOP3D.COMAUGUST AUGUST//SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER2021 202119 19

p18_19_D3D_AUGSEPT21_VDG.indd 19

12/08/2021 15:11

LIGHTS, MUSIC, ACTION » Connected devices can now be found in every room of the house, from lights in the living room and speakers in the kitchen, to the security camera in the garage and the baby monitor in the nursery. Stephen Holmes meets Zuma, a company building a hardware platform that can incorporate all of these gadgets and more

Discreet, high-end sound and lighting, controlled at the click of an app is just the beginning for Zuma

20 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p20_21_22_23_24_25_D3D_AUGSEP21_CoverZuma.indd 20

17/08/2021 14:41

COVER FEATURE

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 21

p20_21_22_23_24_25_D3D_AUGSEP21_CoverZuma.indd 21

17/08/2021 14:41

ow connected are you? Be it by WiFi or Bluetooth, many of us are now the slaves of a vast range of smart devices: speakers, lights, cameras, heating controls and even pet monitors. The more of these gadgets we buy, the more platforms we add and the harder it becomes to operate them all, weighed down as we are by multiple different apps. And that’s without even mentioning the shelf-space needed to accommodate these products, or the inadequate functionality offered by some of them. Wouldn’t having just one, all-purpose – or at least multifunction – product be less of a burden? A little over three years ago, Morten Warren, founder of Native Design, approached a group of designers at the company’s London headquarters with an idea for his new house – a connected, high-end speaker system, built within the profile of a standard GU10 bulb light fitting, that would also provide lighting. Over 200 physical prototypes and one new company later, Zuma’s Lumisonic was launched. It now takes up a storefront in the busy heart of London’s West End retail district, where senior engineer Edward Rose greets us in front of a pyramid of glossy packaging. The first impression is of how much effort has gone into

1 1 The compact form setting up the sensory retail environment. The first room ● of Lumisonic packs in has a dozen Zuma units set into the ceiling. Connected LED lights, a high-end to Rose’s iPhone, all 12 begin playing music in unison, driver, antennas, without any hint of lag. A full-bodied blanket of sound, connectors and controls clear and bassy, coats you wherever you stand, while Rose simultaneously adjusts the room’s brightness. Other rooms showcase the product as part of a home cinema set-up, another as your personal wellness room, with pre-set combinations of ambient lighting and relaxing meditation soundscapes changing the room at the touch of a button. Everything is slick – from the app interface to the minimalist speaker grilles – and Rose exudes passion for the project, now operating as a standalone business from its Native Design beginnings. “It’s such a big effort, such a big lift, to deliver a piece of hardware,” says Rose, with a deep exhale. “So, while you’re at it, you might as well make it as full featured as possible and then roll in bits of those features you like best as you develop the software.” Without that approach, he adds, you would put yourself on a two- to three-year release cadence of producing new hardware and still not cover exactly what customers want. “By the time you’ve discovered [a need], it’s changing. So, we invested heavily upfront in producing as much functionality in the hardware as we could conceivably

22 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p20_21_22_23_24_25_D3D_AUGSEP21_CoverZuma.indd 22

17/08/2021 14:41

COVER FEATURE get away with, with a view that we can do whatever we want with software.”

THROWING IDEAS AT THE WALL The design process for Zuma began with lots of sketching and conceptual prototyping, as no one on the team quite knew what final architectural form the device would eventually take. Every element seemed to play against the other. Heat issues would arise around the placement of the LEDs. Ventilating the LEDs would interfere with acoustics. Running wires would discolour the sound. Says Rose: “We threw ideas at the wall for quite some time. The fruits of that actually didn’t stick in the end. For one reason or another, all of those variations had a weakness of some kind that we couldn’t overcome – mostly acoustic, because acoustic was the kind of the anchor for this. If we couldn’t deliver acoustically, then it wasn’t a product, as far as we were concerned.” The first challenge was to deliver a full-range drive unit, with the team spending months attempting to combine different loudspeaker components. “We never got what we wanted using off-the-shelf parts,” admits Rose. “And so, we just hit this wall. We realised we were going to have to do it from scratch, the whole thing.” At Native’s workshop, the initial team of three began to develop parts and processes for the entire unit in Solidworks, before physically prototyping the devices.

We ‘‘ invested

heavily upfront in the hardware, with the view that we could do whatever we wanted with software

’’

Native has long invested in its physical prototyping ability, something its engineers cite as really changing their ability to not only to prototype quickly, but also in the real materials. The team spent weeks forming 0.4mm anodised aluminium diaphragms, 3D printing the chassis on Formlabs desktop units and 5-axis machining steel motor surrounds. They also built custom magnets, customwound coils, hand-pressed rear suspensions and moulded polyurethane surrounds. “We had hundreds of different designs; nothing was going to work… except we then had this one eureka moment, where we’d basically got the configuration right,” says a still-excited Rose. “We’d got these arms. We’d got the LED in a ring that would fit around the tweeter at the centre. We’d got the horn to prevent the sound from getting out. We’d proved the shape of the drive unit was going to work.” Over one Christmas, the first 20 or so Lumisonics were hand-built, and the team assembled them into a roof space where they could showcase the prototype system – in a set-up not unlike the Zuma retail showroom of today. Turning on a Zuma speaker for the first time was a revelation, says Rose. “As soon as we heard it, we were like, ‘Okay, we’re off to the races!’ That was the unblocking point!”

2 Even the aluminium casing that will ● rarely be seen is anodised and laser-engraved 3 The brief was to fit the device into a ●

standard G10 light footprint

4 Physical prototyping was key to development ● 5 Initial sketches and Solidworks models ●

formed the basis for the design

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 23

p20_21_22_23_24_25_D3D_AUGSEP21_CoverZuma.indd 23

17/08/2021 14:41

COVER FEATURE READY, STEADY, IMPROVE

CLUTTER BE GONE

From here the challenge only grew. The audio had to be improved, with the team employing specialists in simulation, along with world-renowned acoustic engineer Laurence Dickie, previously the chief acoustician at audio company Bowers & Wilkins. On top of this came the task of making the speaker manufacturable. Zuma chose an audio manufacturer because of all the smart speaker elements, but the team had no idea about lighting or the kinds of complex thermals the Lumisonic would have to handle. It took persistence to overcome these problems, says Rose. With the speaker packed into the space, the LEDs had to be integrated with the aluminium casing and heat sinks, helping suck every bit of heat out the LEDs to maintain their lifespan. Custom-designed elements had to be refined, such as the doughnut shaped lens, and antennas to connect the WiFi, as well as the super-responsive, sub-100 microsecond RF connectivity (there are 1,000 microseconds to a millisecond), which links all the units in the system. The antennas had to be capacitively coupled to the aluminium chassis to achieve optimum performance while encased in metal. The light surrounds that sit on the inside of the room vary from inconspicuous to eye-catching. Native’s previous work for Bowers & Wilkins’ in-car audio brand meant the team had experience in designing audio-friendly speaker grilles and patterns. The final part of the development was the integration of sensors into these surrounds and a look to the future expansion of the platform beyond light and sound. With a computer already onboard, the team included a tiny connector on the front face of the unit, which acts as a USB. “What that means is we can now plug in cameras, sensors and all sorts of other things onto a bezel that will snap on to the front of your unit after you’ve installed it and expand the capability to do whatever you might imagine,” explains Rose.

Zuma’s design enables it to remove clutter from the connected home and pack it into a discreet light fitting. A surround with a microphone can be clipped onto one of the units, while another can be fitted with a camera, creating a baby monitor or part of a wider home security system. With each Lumisonic unit containing the full array of technology – capable of acting as the main WiFi receiver and transmitting to the network – the cost is not cheap. However, the Zuma team has thought this through with its unique fitting mechanism. Traditionally, light fittings have butterfly springs that lock them into the ceiling cavity, Rose explains. “You force them up through the plasterboard, and they munch great holes out of it, and you can’t get them out again without pulling them harder than you want to.” Building a butterfly mechanism pivot into the tightly packed casing of the design would have eaten up another 20% of the space in a design already 100% smaller than the designers wanted it to be. “We were really restricted by the amount of air volume we had here. How well your loudspeaker can perform is directly related to how much air volume you can give it,” says Rose, producing a thin slip of metal with a short black plastic handle. “We came up with a concept for using these constant-force springs, which would allow us to trap the unit in the ceiling.” The slip of metal acts as a retainer for two springs on the sides of the new unit when taking it out of the box and fitting it. Once wired up and in the hole, the installer simply has to pull the handle on each retainer and, behind the plasterboard, the unrestricted springs coil to hold it in place. Replacing the retainer slip into each side of the unit pushes back the spring, allowing the unit to be removed. Everywhere you look with this product, attention to detail stands out. Even the casing that’s soon to be locked away in the ceiling is black-anodised and laser-etched to reveal a geometric pattern and Zuma branding. It has been designed not as a Bluetooth-connected consumable, but as a benchmark for the next evolution of connected devices. The design tackles so many engineering challenges that, until now, no other company has successfully achieved what Zuma has. Its success is as much down to how the project was funded – few audio companies would veer into lighting, and fewer still would do so in reverse. “It was so development-intensive and so expensive. You certainly wouldn’t have got favourable terms from seed funding, because for a long time, it was not entirely clear that it was going to work out,” says Rose. Backing from Native’s founder Morten Warren is what drove this. “He stayed absolutely committed,” says Rose. Proof, if proof were needed, that what makes for a successful product is often having the right connections.

We can ‘‘ now plug in

cameras, sensors and more onto a bezel that snaps on to the front and expands the capability

’’

zuma.ai

5 The Zuma App ●

allows control of sound and light, as well as a number of calming or energising presets 6 The discreet design ●

means the unit can fit into any style of interior

p20_21_22_23_24_25_D3D_AUGSEP21_CoverZuma.indd 24

17/08/2021 14:41

6 DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 25

p20_21_22_23_24_25_D3D_AUGSEP21_CoverZuma.indd 25

17/08/2021 14:41

SOME Engineering PROJECTS WON’T MOVE AHEAD WITHOUT YOU The AMD Radeon™ PRO W6800 GPU offers superior Hardware Raytracing performance of previous AMD professional graphics and the NVIDIA Quadro RTX 5000 in Dassault Systèmes’ SOLIDWORKS® Visualize 2021. (It even has twice the dedicated RAM of the RTX 5000.) Allowing you to focus on those projects that require even more from you. For everything else let AMD Radeon PRO graphics help.

amd.com/RadeonPRO

© 2021 Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. All rights reserved. AMD, the AMD Arrow logo, Radeon, and combinations thereof are trademarks of Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. SOLIDWORKS are commercial trademarks or registered trademarks of Dassault Systèmes, a French “société européenne” (Versailles Commercial Register # B 322 306 440), or its subsidiaries in the United States and/ or other countries. Source of Nvidia specifications is nvidia.com as of 01 June 2021. Testing as of March 23, 2021 by AMD Performance Labs on a test system comprised of an AMD Ryzen™ 9 5950X with AMD Radeon™ PRO W5700 / AMD Radeon™ PRO WX 9100 / AMD Radeon™ PRO W6600 (pre-production sample) / AMD Radeon™ PRO W6800 (pre-production sample) / Nvidia® RTX 5000. Benchmark Application: Dassault Systèmes SOLIDWORKS® Visualize 2021 SP3 (time to complete, seconds) measuring rendering test time of the Camaro default angle (ProRender low sample) test. Performance may vary based on factors such as driver version and hardware configuraton. RPW-383

R E A D Y C R E ATO R

PROFILE

FIRST RESPONDER

» Joyride’s ‘responsive furniture’ uses bespoke mechanisms to transform from compact to comfortable, using only the bodyweight of the sitter. We take a look at the company’s design process and the role played by PTC Onshape

he world is not exactly short of chairs, notes James Lucas, CEO of East Londonbased furniture company Joyride: “I would imagine that the chair is one of the most designed objects on the planet. There’s a lot of them!” What the vast majority of them lack are the responsive elements that Joyride strives to incorporate into its products. For Lucas and Joyride, responsive furniture for the office and home should save space and use clever mechanisms to transform compact stools into more comfortable seating with backrests. While Joyride’s design process has a lot in common with those associated with traditional furniture – ergonomic considerations, comfort, materials – the end results owe much more to mechanical ingenuity. When a user sits on Joyride’s Cuba chair, for example, the cushioned stool

responds to their weight, causing a backrest to rise up to offer extra comfort and support. The design was spawned from frustration, Lucas explains. A large office chair takes up too much space and the backrest only has a purpose when the seat is occupied. “From all my engineering experience and my love of transfer of movement and creating efficient systems, [I thought I] must be able to tap into this energy. This initially was what, and still does, excite me about it - the energy that’s wasted every time we sit down.”

CLEAR CONCEPT The concept for Joyride was clear: to do something fun, inspirational and practical with this energy and tackle office ‘chair management’. “If you have a stand-up meeting, typically, all the chairs end up around the outside of the room, and it’s just a pain

Joyride’s Cuba seating transforms from compact to comfortable with the weight of the person sitting on it

28 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p28_31_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Joyride.indd 28

17/08/2021 16:29

Join us on October 12-14 to unite with designers, engineers and manufacturing leaders and travel into the future of Design & Engineering with the world’s leading manufacturing brands at HxGN LIVE Design & Engineering 2021

hxgnlive-de2021.com

Six Of The Best FFF Filament 3D Printers Fusion F410

Funmat Pro 410

Zmorph i500

Omni500 LITE

Omni Factory 2.0NET

KEY:

LT = Low Temp

MT = Medium Temp

Materials:

PLA, TPU, PVA, PETG

ABS, ASA, PA, PC-ABS, PSU

HT = High Temp ULTEM, PEEK

Funmat Pro 610 HT

Single

Dual

Large

LT/MT

01420 556755 www.cdg.uk.com

“

Those who control their information are a step ahead of the competition, so DDM plays an important role in our company” company Mark Brouwers, Software Engineer - LAG Tailers

Powerful, Low Cost Multi-CAD PDM www.designdatamanager.com

p30_D3D_AUGSEPT21_ads.indd 1

18/08/2021 10:06

PROFILE

‘‘ When anything’s a pain in the arse for most people, it just doesn’t get used James Lucas, Joyrider

’’

in the arse,” says Lucas, and when anything’s a pain in the arse for most people, it just doesn’t get used.” Coupled with a height-adjustable table, the Cuba seats offer several configurations that outstrip traditional desk furniture, docking against the bottom of the table base when not in use. Cuba began as a clean-page design, rather than an evolution of an office chair, with the initial design quickly decided upon in little over a month. The concept won an award, with part of the prize being the chance to exhibit it at 100% Design, a trade fair for contemporary interior design in London. This left Lucas with only five months in which to make the design reality. “I had 50 in production within that time,” he reflects, “and only around two were ready on the morning of the show. It’s good having hard deadlines sometimes!” The key challenge proved to be perfecting the mechanism, ensuring that the requisite parts line up at the correct heights. “You’ve got a lot of constraints that you need to map out quickly and efficiently and we’ve now developed a process with Onshape,“ he says. “In Onshape, we all worked on the same document – we called it the Master Sketch – which drives everything and usually sits in the 3D model. We don’t necessarily extrude directly from the Master Sketch, because it can get a bit messy, but it’s there for reference and we can constrain things to it. Then it starts building out into 3D.” The mechanisms are key to the product, Lucas jokes, because if they don’t work, “it’s not a piece of responsive furniture, it’d just be a rather heavy stool! While other mechanisms exist in the furniture industry, he adds, they’re nothing like Joyride’s. “They don’t use a sliding system. They’re not made in the same way, so that has been a huge challenge, because a lot of stuff that we use in the mechanism is not used in volume products,” he explains. The style of mechanism that Joyride uses is more akin to those found in automation and manufacturing equipment, like CNC machines, to produce glides and slides. Lucas says: “You’ve got a lot of restraints with responsive furniture, so you’re more limited, but we take a lot from what already works very well in the furniture industry.

The complicated bit is making a reliable mechanism that goes up and down, and that doesn’t chop your kid’s fingers off. You’ve got to think about all these squeeze and shear points. It’s got to be a really nice experience.”

A SIT-DOWN SUCCESS When 3D CAD designs are considered advanced enough, Joyride begins to work with its suppliers to get important feedback from them, including costs, tolerances and occasionally something the design team might not have considered. “For example,” says Lucas, “we wanted to get some of the seats moulded for the Cuba product, and the more we learned about that, the more we realised the foam needed more area to flow around the mould.” These kinds of lessons are typically through more runof-the-mill productivity apps. “The more we can be doing that in a Google Docs style the better. Then we’ll reflect on what people have said, adapt the design and keep moving forwards, with different [team members] working on different part areas.” The team at Joyride is now in the early stages of sending stakeholders Onshape links to view files. “It’s definitely the way forward,” says Lucas, adding that he’s excited for other future features in Onshape that will help streamline his company’s design process even further. joyride.design

1 As the seat lowers ●

with the occupant, the backrest rises 2 Onshape ●

provides the ideal design workflow for developing the seating mechanisms

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 31

p28_31_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Joyride.indd 31

17/08/2021 16:29

FEATURE

SIT UP, TAKE NOTICE

» Tired of automotive companies playing it safe with interior design, Formation Industries took a more audacious approach when it came to its striking new McLaren Senna seat. DEVELOP3D spoke with founder Chris McGee and his team about the project

hris McGee, CEO of design and product development company Formation Industries, is baffled by the beautiful but dull interiors of many of the world’s most exclusive supercars. “Why would you have this ridiculously expensive car, and when you get in, it’s incredibly uninspiring?” he asks. “Everyone else gets to appreciate the beauty outside, but you’re just sat in there.” In response, he’s been working on his idea for a complex and multifaceted automotive interior for over five years. The end result is a perfectly smooth seat, its geometric pattern a full-frontal visual assault limited only by the colours of the material. Formation Industries has carried out many projects in the automotive interiors world, but shackled by non-disclosure agreements and hampered by manufacturers’ guidelines, the company decided to really break out with its latest project and push back the boundaries of what was possible. In collaboration with D-Class Automotive, a company specialising in crafting bespoke car interiors, McGee and his team set about creating a car seat that would showcase what they believe represents the future of luxury car interior surfaces. The idea was to create not just a concept design, but also an entire process for a quality product that can quickly be incorporated into production. “There are so many concept car interiors. You can look at them, but you can’t actually live with them – and we wanted to ask where is the future going with materials, textures and things like that,” McGee explains. “But I’m not a textile designer by any means, or a trimmer – so we butchered engineering and engineering tools into our design process to make it happen.”

TAKE A SEAT First off, a seat had to be sourced. With no manufacturer willing to release CAD data, the project team had to get creative. D-Class dug deep and bought a McLaren 600LT supercar, affording Formation a brief window of time to spend examining the car’s carbon fibre bucket seat and its sparse padding. Having drawn up several initial concept sketches, it quickly dawned on them that the concept on paper wouldn’t be enough to enable clients to fully grasp the complexity and benefits of what they had planned, because of the complex curves of the seat and the patterns involved. “That’s when we realised we would have to 3D-model the seat,” says McGee. “All we had was access to the actual seat for a 12hour window, and at that time we had no 3D scanner.” In the end, McGee and the team had to paper-pattern the unpicked seat pads and take countless photos from every angle. This process of transferring the 2D patterns into a 3D model, to then retract them for further 2D cutting and layout, proved a long one. Measurements and geometries drawn up in CorelDraw and Illustrator were imported into Fusion 360. Around 70 hours were spent modelling the seat in 3D from photographs and measurements across five revisions. “Surfacing in Fusion is still not really ideal, but I’m a bit entrenched now – nearly 24 years deep in Autodesk software,” McGee admits. “I’m not even sure what the ideal software would have

32 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p32_33_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Formation V2.indd 32

17/08/2021 14:30

‘‘

That’s what I wanted for these interiors: to bring the pomp and ceremony of a tailored suit, where the lining defines our personality

’’

been, but once we had this model, we were able to build it up in such a way that we were taking our initial flat panel concept designs and skinning them onto the seat pads, then producing the renders.” Fusion 360 impressed with its ability to take the 2D cloth-cut files and wrap them around the 3D form of the seat to produce a convincing visualisation. With the chosen Alcantara material costing nearly £100 per metre, the 3D visualisations saved the development thousands of pounds. This allowed the team to produce more than 10 interior designs in under three weeks, before then presenting them to their collaborators. Once a single final design was agreed on, the next stage was equally tasking: building a physical prototype. “We had been wondering why we had not seen many cars out there with cut Alcantara bonded to Alcantara with no stitching. As much of what it is bonded to seems to be other nonalcantara substrate materials with a wet glue process, which just isn’t suitable for the production process we envisaged for the level of detail we wanted to achieve” McGee explains. Formation had spent nearly a year researching various adhesives and bonding methods for the low surface energy material. To make matters worse, Alcantara stretches in a very tricky one-and-a-half directions and has a very low melting point. The team needed to find a way that would allow detailed laser-cut pieces of the material to be inlaid, seamlessly joining with others. Stitching was not an option, according to McGee.

“Certain areas are higher-traffic – you move into them and slide across them, so you don’t really want something where you’ve got reliefs which you could keep catching the edge of,” he says. “With headrests, people have products in their hair, so things have to be cleaned differently, so we didn’t want to leave pockets.” An additional hurdle was Alcantara’s nap. If you brush the surface in one direction, or rotate it by a 30-degree angle, it noticeably alters the shade of the colour. Says McGee: “It took three solid days of cutting and bonding to do the upper shoulder pads – it was that level of time-consuming. We had to consider every single part and its relationship to the final piece.” However, the end result is like a classically tailored suit, he says: once unbuttoned, it reveals an extravagant and colourful lining. “That’s what I wanted for these interiors: to bring the pomp and ceremony of a suit, where we could both own the same suit, but the lining – our interiors – would start to define our personalities.” The project has wowed the world of car interiors, but Formation isn’t stopping there. McGee and his team reckon that even more materials can be added, but the next stage is streamlining the workflow. An Einscan HX handheld 3D Scanner has since been purchased, reducing the 3D modelling from 70 hours down to two, and research has now moved on to how the cut slithers of material can be positioned to improve aspects of performance like grip and overall comfort.

(Above) The finished laser-cut Alcantara seats in the bespoke D-Class interior for a McLaren 600LT (Below) To get the measurements, the team had to draw out patterns from the seat pads and take multiple photos

formation.industries DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 33

p32_33_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Formation V2.indd 33

17/08/2021 14:30

A single source of truth for all your data! No more unsecure, out of date or duplicated information www.designdatamanager.com

EinScan H, HX Hybrid 3D Scanners *

• • • • • •

Fast Handheld 3D scanners Hybrid Laser, LED, IR technology Scan Accuracy from 40 microns High Resolution Mono & Full-Colour Can scan shiny and dark objects!

info@cdg.uk.com

p34_D3D_AUGSEPT21_ads.indd 1

www.cdg.uk.com

* LED & IR * Laser & LED

01420 556755

18/08/2021 10:09

FEATURE

SPARE CHANGE

» Spare parts produced by additive manufacturing open up a world of digital inventories and customer convenience. Stephen Holmes meets with Replique, a start-up steering big brands around potential AM pitfalls, to discuss its recent work with domestic appliance giant Miele

n May 2020, domestic appliance manufacturer Miele started its 3D4U project to provide customers with free designs of 3D printable accessories, a bold step for the brand renowned for its commitment to reliable products. Starting with three accessories available through its online shop – a coffee bag clip, and two specialist vacuum cleaner attachments – Miele was taking the first steps towards flexibly expanding its product portfolio. But the immediate success of the project led the company to consider enabling greater access to designs for customers with no 3D printer. “We have a beautiful maker community in Europe, but the number of people who don’t have a 3D printer is greater,” says Max Siebert, CEO of digital inventory start-up Replique, speaking from its base on BASF’s Chemovator incubator campus in Mannheim, Germany. Immediately after the launch of the 3D4U project, Siebert contacted Miele to offer Replique’s expertise in additive technologies and materials, to safely scale production globally. “We are working for various industries – transportation, agriculture, gardening. You see that all of those have the same issue at times, which is getting hold of spare parts,” says Siebert. The parts themselves might be simple components, he explains, but the volume requested is comparatively small scale, so additive manufacturing is very appealing. “It’s a new manufacturing technology that has really matured in the last years to become a very controlled industrial process, and I think this is now a good example of how people will start using this technology for certain niche applications and also to expand it,” he says.

MANUFACTURING MINEFIELD Yet for many companies, even with huge amounts of manufacturing expertise, 3D printing is still littered with unknowns. Therefore, partnering with a company that can make this process as smooth and pain-free as possible offers huge benefits. “They’re very happy to have somebody who has a very proficient knowledge in materials and can judge which material and technology route they should take, so there’s also a little consulting aspect here, because 3D printing

for end-use parts is still very young. We’re not talking about prototypes.” Siebert explains that while many services produce prototypes, where speed is the main driver, the key to enduse parts is purely quality. Take, for instance, the coffee clip – the part needs to be built with the expectancy that it will come into contact with foodstuffs. For Replique, this meant researching a full food-safe production process, beginning with materials, Siebert says. “There are really only a few food-safe certified materials – not just saying that it is ‘generally food-safe’, but that it is certified.”

POWER OF PARTNERSHIP Replique does not produce the parts itself. Instead, it works with vetted production partners that include BASF 3D Printing Solutions, making the company itself agnostic when it comes to technology, materials and processes, and giving it good global reach. One client that produces power tools found that the long guarantees that it offers on its products meant that requests for spare parts were still being received long after it had ceased making an original product. In this case, Replique was able to step in and help maintain supplies without the need for long-lost original tooling. Having proficient 3D-printed parts suppliers and a close partnership with the client means that Replique can also offer design for AM advice, helping tweak or optimise parts to make them more robust or to save material. Siebert believes that more industries are further targeting this sort of process, either to produce spares on demand, or for assessing product demand for appliance accessories. “In the past, you only produced parts where you were sure that you [would have demand for] hundreds of thousands of those,” he says, “but now you can produce way more parts, because the complexity of managing those parts is not that high.” With a quality assured system, consumers will be able to rest easy, knowing that the products – ordered online and shipped direct to them – will have the same characteristics as the original, while manufacturers won’t be faced with managing a complex warehousing and supplier network.

Spare parts created on a made-toorder basis have the potential to fundamentally change how brands manage inventory

‘‘ Clients are

happy to have somebody with proficient knowledge to judge which material and technology route they should take, Max Siebert, Replique CEO

’’

replique.io DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 35

p35_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Miele.indd 35

16/08/2021 13:40

FEATURE

36 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p36_37_D3D_AUGSEPT21_HoloLight.indd 36

16/08/2021 13:41

TRUE TO FORM True-to-scale augmented reality is having a positive effect on BMW’s development workflow, reducing the number and cost of physical test rigs needed for assembly and production

orldwide, the push for shorter development cycles when creating automotive models means further reliance on the digital design workflow and getting more value from existing CAD data. At its Vehicle Pilot Plant in Munich, BMW’s R&D base for cloud-based visualisations and smart object recognition, the German automotive giant has added augmented reality (AR) to its prototype testing for a range of concept variants and assembly processes. Using Microsoft´s HoloLens 2 headset and AR engineering software AR 3S from Munich-based Holo-Light, BMW’s engineering team can overlay digital 3D geometries over a real vehicle body. Systems and components are visualised through AR 3S, which is linked to the BMW Group’s product data management system, with CAD files dragged and dropped from the webbased database to the AR headset. Specialists from BMW’s production and assembly departments can manipulate the 3D data in true scale in a real environment by using hand movements to modify the position and angle of components.

FEWER TEST SET-UPS Michael Schneider, head of complete vehicle at the pilot plant, says: “The AR goggles and CAD data allow us to find out much more quickly whether the production worker will be able to fit the component properly later on, in series production. That way, we need far fewer test set-ups.” The integrated remote rendering technology (ISAR) in HoloLight’s software enables streaming of the entire AR application. This means that the computing power does not have to come from the headset, but instead can be provided from the cloud or, in this case, BMW’s own high-performance server. Crucial for security, all the production data is kept safe in the event of the loss or theft of a headset. Another advantage is the ability to work collaboratively with different production locations around the world, with groups able to view the same model and review designs and concepts together, identifying errors and potential problems earlier. From individual vehicle systems through to complex production stages, BMW says that by using AR, its engineers are now able to verify assembly processes at an earlier stage and adjust them ready for production, speeding up those processes by as much as 12 months. holo-light.com Workers in Microsoft HoloLens 2 headsets at BMW’s Vehicle Pilot Plant in Munich p36_37_D3D_AUGSEPT21_HoloLight.indd 37

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 37

16/08/2021 13:41

FUTURE.INDUSTRY October 19-21, 2021 Virtual Global Event Discover What’s Next in Advanced Manufacturing Join the world’s brightest minds to explore and discuss trends, technologies, and breakthrough achievements that will deliver a smarter, more connected and sustainable world. From big brand thought leaders to early-stage start-up entrepreneurs, learn how the convergence of simulation, high-performance computing, and AI is transforming how innovative companies will design, operate, and compete in the future. Save the date and register by scanning the QR code below or by visiting altair.com/future-industry

Altair. Changing tomorrow, together.

#ONLYFORWARD

AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 | DEVELOP3D.COM

Workstation special report for CAD, design viz, reality modelling and more THE LATEST

Pro

GPUs FROM A AND NVIDIAMD REVIEWED

THE BATTLE OF THE CPUs WHAT DO INTEL AND AMD’S NEW PROCESSORS REALLY MEAN FOR CAD-CENTRIC WORKFLOWS? WS01_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Cover.indd 1

DESKTOP WORKSTATIONS HOW TO BUY A WORKSTATION + OUR TOP PICKS OF THE BEST MACHINES FOR CAD & BEYOND

BEST LIGHTWEIGHT LAPTOPS ULTRA-PORTABLE MOBILE WORKSTATIONS TO TAKE CAD AND DESIGN VIZ ON THE ROAD 12/08/2021 09:27

workstation special report

Desktop workstation buyer’s g Greg Corke goes back to basics with some general advice for those looking to buy a workstation for product development workflows If you read DEVELOP3D, the chances are that you already own a workstation. But how much do you know about it and how involved were you in its purchase? If you leave everything to your general IT department, you could end up with a machine that slows you down or, worse still, is simply not able to run your more demanding applications. We all work within budget limits, so it is really important to spend your money in the right areas. We’ve heard plenty of horror stories, including that of one large engineering firm that spent loads on dual CPU workstations with lots of cores that ran at a low frequency (GHz), even though its designers only ever used CAD. In that example, buying workstations with a single high-frequency CPU with fewer cores would not only have saved money, but significantly increased the productivity of the design team. Choosing the right spec is very important – and we cover this in depth in this special report – but it is not the be all and end all of buying a workstation. In this article, we look at other important points to consider.

Warranty Virtually all workstations come with a three-year warranty, but the level of cover can vary considerably between manufacturers. This isn’t just about protecting your investment. In the event of a

HP Z2 Tower G8 running Solidworks

WS2

August / September 2021

WS02_03_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Buyers_guide.indd 2

failure, you need to get machine. Warranties can be your workstation back up extended and negotiated, so and running as quickly as also bear that in mind. possible and with minimal The chassis hassle. A next business day (NBD) Workstations are not just on site warranty is common about their constituent parts. with workstations from The chassis can be incredibly major OEMs. Some custom important. There are three manufacturers only offer main points to consider: size, ‘return to base’ as standard noise and serviceability. But or NBD on site for the first having easy access to things Having to send like USB ports or headphone year. Having to send away away your your workstation to be sockets can also make a big repaired could mean days workstation to difference. Ask yourself the without its use, which could following questions: Will the be repaired be catastrophic when on a machine fit on your desk, or could mean tight project deadline. will it have to be kept down Many minor repairs can days without it, by your feet? If you need to be done by yourself. Some which could be move it, is it heavy and does manufacturers specifically it have built-in handles? catastrophic make their workstations Are the fans so noisy that when on a tight they are distracting? Can easy to service, so customers can be guided over the project deadline you expand the system with phone or video call and GPUs, storage or memory get themselves back up (are there free memory and running the same day (or the next slots)? Is it easy to service internal day if a part needs to be sent out). Other components? manufacturers state that any repairs or Of course, if you are the type of person alterations that are carried out by the that would never dream of getting inside a customer invalidate the warranty, so computer then serviceability is a moot point. check with your supplier first. Think about the things that matter to you. When comparing prices of workstations, For some, aesthetics are very important. make sure you are looking at details of the warranty and not just the Custom manufacturer or OEM specifications of A frequently asked question is whether t h e to buy from a custom manufacturer or a major OEM like Dell, HP, Lenovo or Fujitsu? There’s no simple answer, but there are a number of things to consider. Custom manufacturers are more flexible in how machines can be configured and are generally quicker at introducing new technologies. Many such firms overclock their CPUs, which can boost performance. OEMs, on the other hand, spend much more time on R&D to make

‘‘

’’

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:05

workstation special report

s guide sure that components work well together and do extensive studies into acoustics, electromagnetic interference and thermodynamics. OEM workstations tend to be more solid and easier to service, particularly as some custom manufacturers try to cut costs by using budget PC chassis. OEM workstations also go through extensive testing and certification to make sure they work well and will be fully supported with many different CAD applications. With custom manufacturers, you are usually just getting the certification of the GPU. Of course, many large design and engineering firms will only buy from major OEMs for reasons of support, management or global availability, so the decision is already made.

Performance Nobody ever complains that their workstation is too fast, but the additional money one must spend to increase performance needs to be weighed up against the benefits experienced. Some performance increases are easy to quantify, such as the time it takes to render a scene or process a point cloud, so it is easy to envisage the potential benefits. 3D graphics performance, however, is harder to measure. More frames per second (FPS) is always better, but if you are unable to discern a difference, does it really matter? Generally speaking, anything over 25 FPS is fine for 3D design work. You can get away with lower frame rates on the desktop, but Virtual Reality is different. An underpowered GPU could make you feel sick as it can’t keep up with your head movements – or it may mean you have to spend hours manually optimising CAD models every time you bring them into VR.

Know your bottlenecks Understanding how your software works and where your bottlenecks occur can help you make informed decisions on workstation purchases. Many of the major workstation OEMs offer free workstation tuning software that can monitor resources in real time and over a set period. Other good tools include GPU-Z for monitoring GPU usage, CPU-Z for CPU and Windows Performance monitor. If you are experiencing slow 3D performance, for example, check to see how much of your GPU is being used. If it’s 100%, then investing in a more powerful GPU would probably help. However, if usage is significantly less, you could be wasting your money and would be better off buying a higher frequency CPU. Once you understand where your bottlenecks occur, it can help you assign budget to the correct areas and tailor a workstation for your specific workflows. Read this DEVELOP3D article to learn more (develop3d.com/hardware/know-your-bottlenecks). www.develop3d.com

WS02_03_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Buyers_guide.indd 3

Processor (CPU) In a workstation, you should always aim for a CPU with a high frequency (GHz). This is good for general system and modelling performance as many operations are single threaded. i.e. they use only one CPU core. Multi-threaded operations can use multiple CPU cores (and sometimes virtual CPU cores). Rendering is the best example; as a rule of thumb, doubling the number of cores halves rendering time. Simulation software and point cloud processing software also tends to be multithreaded, but there can be diminishing returns as you use more cores. In saying that, it is possible to do multiple simulations on a single machine at the same time, providing you have sufficient memory and memory bandwidth, storage bandwidth and software licences. CPUs that have lots of cores typically run at lower frequencies, so it’s important to strike

Graphics (GPU) The professional 3D graphics card or graphics processing unit (GPU) is one of the key components that defines a professional 3D workstation. Unlike consumer GPU drivers, pro graphics drivers are specifically designed to work with professional 3D software (especially CAD software) and are given an official stamp of approval for each application through ‘certification’. This comes with the promise of full support from the software developer. Pro drivers can mean better performance, better stability and access to specific features, such as RealView in Solidworks, Order Independent Transparency (OIT) in PTC Creo, and AMD Radeon Viewport Boost (see page WS26). If there are any display or stability issues in your CAD software, they are more likely to be fixed in a subsequent driver release. Nvidia has the lion’s share of the add-in GPU market with its Nvidia RTX and Nvidia Quadro family, but AMD Radeon Pro also plays

Storage (SSD / HDD) M.2 NVMe Solid State Drives (SSDs) have quickly become the standard in workstations. Sequential read/write speeds are superior to 2.5-inch SATA SSDs, although this won’t always result in real world benefits. M.2s are also smaller, which has helped reduce the size of workstations. Newer workstations, including those with AMD Ryzen 5000 or 11th Gen Intel Core CPUs, support PCIe Gen 4 NVMe SSDs, which offer double the sequential read/write performance

Memory (RAM) You should always aim to have enough memory so you never run out, as performance can significantly slow down if your workstation has to page data to your SSD. Memory requirements will always change over time. Your datasets will get bigger and the

a balance. Another strategy is to optimise your workstation for modelling and send your multi-threaded calcs to a server or the cloud. Intel used to dominate the workstation CPU market, but this is changing. AMD now has extremely competitive processors for all different workflows. However, with the exception of Lenovo, AMD-based workstations are still only available from specialist manufacturers like Scan, BOXX, and Workstation Specialists. For CAD centric workflows, choose 11th Gen Intel Core or Intel Xeon W-1300 CPUs (up to 8 cores) or AMD Ryzen 5000 series (up to 16 cores). Intel still has the edge in single threaded performance, but AMD offers much better multi-threaded performance as it has double the number of cores (see page WS4). For very high-end multi-threaded workflows, it’s very hard to recommend anything other than AMD Threadripper or AMD Threadripper Pro. It’s important to note that CPUs from different families cannot be directly compared by GHz.

a very important role. Some Intel CPUs include integrated graphics. While the performance can be OK for entry-level 3D workflows, certain professional features might not be supported and the number of application certifications is much less. Still, professional GPUs are facing increased competition from their consumer counterparts — Nvidia GeForce and AMD Radeon. Some of the major workstation OEMs now offer consumer GPUs in their workstations — both desktop and mobile. High-end consumer GPUs tend to feature less memory than high-end professional GPUs but can easily compete on raw processing power. For CAD workflows we still recommend sub-£500 entry-level to mid-range pro GPUs, but when you get into the high-end, an area where you need more 3D performance for real-time visualisation, GPU rendering or virtual reality (VR), the difference in price is greater and pro graphics cards are often a harder sell for those on a budget. Nvidia even has a GeForce ‘Studio’ driver for applications including Unreal Engine, V-Ray and Enscape.

of PCIe Gen 3 models. Those working with very large datasets, such as point cloud, simulation or video editing, should benefit most. The cost of NVMe SSDs has come down a lot but Hard Disk Drives (HDDs) continue to offer the best price per GB. HDDs should absolutely not be used as a primary drive for operating system and applications, but they are good for secondary storage and do not impact load / save times of CAD models that much. However, if you need to process large point cloud or simulation datasets, especially if you don’t have enough RAM to hold the data entirely in system memory, then NVMe SSDs are always best.

memory footprint of applications will increase with new releases. With this in mind, it’s good to buy a workstation with spare RAM slots for easier upgrades. However, for best performance, memory should be installed in pairs, quads or eights, matched to the number of CPU memory channels. ECC memory can protect against crashes, which becomes important for lengthy calculations as you can lose hours of work.

August / September 2021

WS3

12/08/2021 14:05

workstation special report

WS4

August / September 2021

WS04_05_06_09_10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Intel_AMD.indd 4

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:38

workstation special report

Intel Core vs AMD Ryzen for CAD and beyond With 11th Gen Intel Core and AMD Ryzen 5000, competition in workstation CPUs has never been so strong. Greg Corke explores the best CPUs for designcentric workflows from CAD to reality modelling and rendering

ne of the questions we get asked most often at DEVELOP3D is ‘which processor is best for CAD?’ Normally, we wouldn’t hesitate in recommending Intel Core or low core count Intel Xeon processors (after all, Intel has demonstrated a clear lead in single threaded performance for the last fifteen years) but with AMD’s recent resurgence in the CPU market, things are no longer so clear cut. In October 2020 AMD launched its AMD Ryzen 5000 Series, based on its 7nm ‘Zen 3’ architecture, and finally took the performance crown from Intel. With more cores (16 vs 10), high clock speeds and superior Instructions Per Clock (IPC), AMD Ryzen 5000 outperformed 10th Gen Intel Core in both single threaded and multi-threaded workflows. It quickly became the processor of choice for users of CAD applications like, Inventor and Solidworks, as well as CPU ray trace renderers like V-Ray and KeyShot, or those built into the CAD applications themselves. Well — it did for those who could

AMD Ryzen 5000 There are four AMD Ryzen 5000 processor models, differentiated largely by the number of cores – 6, 8, 12, or 16. This is the same number of cores offered on the previous Ryzen 3000 series, but the IPC improvement is significantly higher – also 19% generation over generation. The top-end AMD Ryzen 9 5950X has 16 cores and 32 threads. It has the lowest base frequency (3.4 GHz) but the highest boost frequency (4.9 GHz), making it very well suited to both single threaded and multithreaded workflows. The other three models in the range are the Ryzen 5 5600X (6 cores, 3.7 GHz, 4.6 GHz boost), the Ryzen 7 5800X (8 cores, 3.8 GHz, 4.7 GHz boost), and the Ryzen 9 5900X (12 cores, 3.7 GHz, 4.8 GHz boost). See table below for the full specs.

11th Gen Intel Core Intel has significantly more models in its 11th Gen Intel Core family. These are differentiated mostly by power draw and base frequency, and less so by the number of cores. With 11th Gen Intel Core you only

AMD Ryzen 5 5600X

AMD Ryzen 7 5800X

AMD Ryzen 9 5900X

AMD Ryzen 9 5950X

Intel Core i5-11600

Intel Core i5-11600K

Intel Core i7-11700

Intel Core i7-11700K

Intel Core i9-11900

Intel Core i9-11900K

# of CPU Cores

# of CPU Threads

3.70 GHz

3.80 GHz

3.70 GHz

3.40 GHz

2.80 GHz

3.90 GHz

2.50 GHz

3.60 GHz

2.50 GHz

3.50 GHz

Max Boost Frequency

4.60 GHz

4.70 GHz

4.80 GHz

4.90 GHz

4.80 GHz

4.90 GHz

5.00 GHz

5.20 GHz

5.30 GHz

Cache

L2 Cache 3 MB L3 Cache 32 MB

L2 Cache 4 MB L3 Cache 32 MB

L2 Cache 6 MB L3 Cache 64 MB

L2 Cache 8 MB L3 Cache 64 MB

12 MB Intel Smart Cache

16 MB Intel Smart Cache

Default TDP / TDP

65 W

105 W

65 W

125 W

65 W

125 W

65 W

125 W

Price (Ex VAT)*

£229

£317

£424

£574

£176

£192

£262

£292

£344

£441

Base Frequency

*PRICE TAKEN FROM SCAN.CO.UK ON 5/7/21

actually get hold of one. The global chip shortage meant demand massively outweighed supply and even if AMD Ryzen 5000 CPUs were in stock, prices were sometimes hugely inflated. This bought Intel some time, and in March 2021 the chip giant hit back with its 11th Gen Intel Core desktop processor family (code-named Rocket Lake-S). Based on its ageing 14nm manufacturing process, expectations were low. However, the new chip family came with the promise of a massive 19% IPC performance improvement, generation on generation. In other words, if a single core on a 10th Gen and 11th Gen Intel Core CPU ran at the same frequency, the 11th Gen would be 19% faster. This was obviously big news for users of CAD software for whom single threaded performance really matters, and it immediately put pressure back on AMD. However, the single threaded boost came at the expense of multi-threaded performance. 11th Gen Intel Core had two fewer cores than 10th Gen Intel Core, so rendering times actually went up.

www.develop3d.com

WS04_05_06_09_10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Intel_AMD.indd 5

August / September 2021

WS5

12/08/2021 14:38

workstation special report

get a choice of 6 or 8 cores. identical to 11th Gen Intel Core processors, All Core i5 models have 6 cores and 12 but include support for Error Correcting threads, while the Core i7 and Core i9 Code (ECC) memory. models have 8 cores and 16 threads. As Finally, it’s important to note that you mentioned previously, this is a step down can’t directly compare AMD and Intel from the 10th Gen Intel Core processors CPUs in terms of their frequency. It’s not which offer up to 10 cores and 20 threads. just the GHz of the CPU that matters, but With fewer cores than the AMD Ryzen the Instructions Per Clock (IPC) that it 9 5900X and Ryzen 9 5950X, it’s very can execute. You should only compare hard for Intel’s 11th Gen Core processors frequency when trying to decide between to compete in highlytwo CPUs from the same threaded workflows like series, although you should rendering. It means the get a fairly good idea When it comes still main battleground for Intel across families. to rendering is in single threaded or more On test lightly threaded workflows, AMD Ryzen centring on CAD. In an ideal world we would 5000 wins There are three main have tested all different hands down. processors — the topmodels of Intel and AMD With the 11th end Intel Core i9-11900K CPUs, but the time it takes (3.5 GHz base, 5.3 GHz to test with real-world Gen Core Turbo), the Intel Core applications (and processor processors i7-11700K (3.6 GHz, 5.0 GHz availability) meant this was maxing out at not viable. Turbo), and the Intel Core i5-11600K (3.9 GHz, 4.9 GHz eight cores Intel Instead, we focused on Turbo), all of which can be two different workstations simply can’t overclocked (see later). — the Scan 3XS GWP-ME compete Intel also offers non “K” A132R with the top-end versions, which are locked AMD Ryzen 9 5950X (16 so can’t be overclocked, and cores) and the Workstation have a lower base frequency, a slightly Specialists WS-184 with the Intel Core lower turbo frequency and draw less i9-11900 (8 cores). Unfortunately, we power. There are also slightly cheaper were unable to get hold of an ‘unlocked’ “F” variants which have the integrated Intel Core i9-11900K which has a higher graphics disabled. With most CAD and base clock and a slightly higher boost design viz workstations featuring discrete frequency (see table on previous page). pro GPUs from AMD or Nvidia this could We’re aware that this is a bit of an save a bit of cash. ‘apples and pears’ comparison, so the Major workstation manufacturers like results should be interpreted accordingly. Dell and HP tend to offer all three variants The AMD Ryzen 9 5950X has double in their machines, as well as Intel Xeon the number of cores of the Intel Core i9W-1300 series CPUs, which are virtually 11900, so is obviously better suited to

‘‘

’’

highly-threaded workflows like rendering. It also costs around 65% more (£574 vs £344 Ex VAT). However, in terms of single threaded workflows, the two workstations should give a good indication of relative performance between the two processor families. It should also be noted that different results might be seen with different motherboards and memory configurations. For consistency, both machines featured 64 GB (2 x 32 GB) of 3,200 MHz memory and a 2 TB Samsung 980 Pro NVMe PCIe 4.0 SSD. To streamline our extensive testing, different GPUs were used for different tests, but the same GPU was always used in both machines. The full specs can be seen on page WS9.

CAD and beyond CAD tools like Solidworks and Autodesk Inventor and Building Information Modelling (BIM) software like Autodesk Revit are bread and butter tools for designers, engineers and architects. In the main they are single threaded and while some processes can use more than one CPU core, it’s only usually ray trace rendering that can take full advantage of all the processor cores, all the time. In Autodesk Revit 2021, the RFO v3 benchmark (fig. 3) showed a clear lead for the Intel workstation in model creation and export, although the AMD workstation predictably won out in rendering. We saw similar results in Solidworks with the SPECapc 2021 benchmark (fig. 1), although Intel’s lead was extended considerably in ‘model rebuild’. We also did some manual tests in Solidworks 2021 (fig. 2) and the AMD workstation closed the gap, coming in

Solidworks appears to run fastest on 11th Gen Intel Core

WS6

August / September 2021

WS04_05_06_09_10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Intel_AMD.indd 6

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:38

workstation special report

Reality modelling Reality modelling is becoming much more prevalent in the AEC sector. Agisoft Metashape is a photogrammetry tool that generates a mesh from multiple hi-res photos. It is multi-threaded and uses a combination of CPU and GPU processing. We tested using a benchmark from specialist US workstation manufacturer Puget Systems (fig. 8). In most of our tests Intel had a clear lead, but AMD did claim top spot in one test. Interestingly, Puget Systems reports that the AMD Ryzen 7 5800X, which has half as many cores as the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X but a higher base frequency (3.8 GHz), is faster in three out of the four tests. In fact, it even beat Intel. In point cloud processing software Leica Cyclone Register 360 (fig. 9), which can run on up to 6 CPU threads (as long as the workstation has sufficient memory), the AMD machine had the lead when registering both of our point cloud datasets. www.develop3d.com

WS04_05_06_09_10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Intel_AMD.indd 7

Processor frequency in relation to number of CPU threads used (using Cinebench custom run)

6.0 5.8

Processor frequency (GHz)

a touch behind the Intel workstation in model opening and IGES export. Storage does play a part in these processes, but the CPU still plays the major role by far. We also tested with the new InvMark for Inventor 2022 benchmark by Cadac Group and TFI (fig. 7). Intel had the lead in most sub tests, apart from the solid sweep modelling operation and (of course) rendering. Interestingly, while Task Manager indicated that some processes are multithreaded (for example, data translation, drawings, and FEA) multiple cores are either used sparingly or only for short bursts in combination with single threaded processes, so overall there’s no real benefit to having more than eight cores. Here, it’s worth pointing out the chart to the right where you can see how frequency drops as more cores (threads) are enabled. Between 12 and 16 threads, Intel maintains a higher frequency than AMD, so this could help give Intel a lead in workloads that use a similar number of threads. Interestingly, even though the Intel Core i9-11900 has a moderate base frequency of 2.5 GHz, the workstation’s cooling lets it maintain a 4.6 GHz boost on all eight cores. Of course, the central code in many CAD tools is quite old and new generation tools like nTopology, which focus on generative design, are built from the ground up for multi-core processors (and, more recently, GPU computation). For our nToplogy geometry optimisation test (fig. 4) we solely focused on the CPU and, with all cores in use, the AMD workstation had a clear lead.

5.6

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900)

5.4

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X)

5.2 5.0 4.8 4.6 4.4 4.2 4.0 3.8 3.6 3.4

Number of threads

Rendering There were no surprises when ray trace rendering with V-Ray, Cinema4D and KeyShot, or any renderer built-in to our CAD and BIM tools (fig 5/6). With twice as many cores as Intel, the AMD workstation was always going to come out on top, even if its cores run at a lower frequency. We also did stress tests to see if CPU frequency dropped over time. When rendering in Cinebench for over an hour, the Intel maintained 4.59 GHz and the AMD maintained 3.74 GHz, testament to the excellent cooling in both workstations.

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R » AMD Ryzen 9 5950X CPU » 64 GB (2 x 32 GB) Corsair Vengeance DDR4 3,200 MHz memory » 2 TB Samsung 980 Pro NVMe PCIe 4.0 SSD » Asus Pro WS X570-ACE motherboard » Noctua NH-D15 air cooler » Full review on page WS14

Graphics CPU frequency has some influence over graphics performance, but the extent to which it does depends on the application. In Revit, Solidworks and Inventor — applications that tend to be more CPU limited — Intel showed around a 10% Frames Per Second (FPS) performance lead over AMD when using the same GPU (fig. 10). This went to down to 5% in Solidworks when RealView, Shadows and Ambient Occlusion (AO) were enabled — graphics effects that place much bigger demands on the GPU. In Unreal Engine 4 — an application renowned for being GPU limited, rather than CPU limited — the difference between Intel and AMD was negligible with our viz test scene.

Workstation Specialists WS-184 » Intel Core i9-11900 CPU » 64 GB (2 x 32 GB) 3,200 MHz dual channel Corsair Vengance RGB Pro DDR4 memory » 2 TB Samsung 980 Pro NVMe PCIe 4.0 SSD » Asus Prime Z590-P motherboard » Be Quiet liquid cooler » Full review on page WS15

Multi-tasking These days, very few architects, engineers or product designers use single applications, and with compute intensive workflows on the rise, such as reality modelling, rendering and simulation, it’s very important to consider multi-tasking when choosing a CPU. Even with 8 cores, it’s possible to leave August / September 2021

WS7

12/08/2021 14:38

workstation special report

one or more multi-threaded tasks running in the background, and still leave resources free for bread and butter 3D modelling tasks. To explore multi-tasking potential, we pushed both machines to their limits, with a demanding AEC workflow, consisting of point cloud processing and photogrammetry (fig. 11). We registered a 24 GB point cloud dataset in Leica Cyclone Register 360 while processing a series of high-res photographs in Agisoft Metashape at the same time. If done sequentially it would have taken 1,218 secs on the AMD machine and 1,207 secs on the Intel, but running both jobs in parallel the AMD finished in 895 secs and the Intel in 954 secs. With more threads trying to run concurrently, the Intel machine starts to slow down. To push the machines even harder we added ray trace rendering into the mix, rendering an 8K scene in KeyShot 10 using 4 cores and 8 threads. Here, the AMD’s 16 cores showed a real benefit, completing all three tasks in 1,024 secs compared to 1,459 secs on Intel. The AMD machine also has the headroom to push the rendering load up to 8 cores and 16 threads which reduced the time to 863 secs. Doing the same on Intel, and dedicating all of its 8 cores to rendering really took its toll as it caused Agisoft Metashape to crash.

Solidworks 2021 SPECapc benchmark

2.63

CPU simulate 0

1,579

235.3

42.3

14,854

Multi-core test

26.6 0

100

150

200

250

24,361

300

5000

10000

15000

20000

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900)

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X)

Solidworks 2021 application testing

1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

nTopology 3.24

Geometry optimisation

10.48

Assembly open

98.99

IGES export 0

101.41

73.40

74.57 20

115.87

120

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X)

WS04_05_06_09_10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Intel_AMD.indd 8

11,064

V-Ray 5.0 CPU Benchmark

19,839

2.7 0

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900)

August / September 2021

V-Ray 5.0 / Keyshot 10

KeyShot 10 Benchmark

70.77

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900)

WS8

Ray trace rendering

Bike seat (Voronoi pattern)

100

25000

1.23 Benchmark score (bigger is better)

1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

9.44

Solidworks open

1,649

282.0

Rendering

1.86 1.64

Cinebench R23 (ray trace rendering)

Single core test

Export 2.20 2.05

CPU convert

Having read multiple reviews from respected tech websites like Anandtech, we were a little surprised that the Intel

1.23 Benchmark score (bigger is better)

89.5

2.39 1.53

The verdict

79.1

Model creation

4.35

1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

CPU rebuild

SMT/HT: Simultaneous multi-threading (SMT) on AMD and HyperThreading (HT) on Intel essentially splits each of the CPU’s physical cores into two virtual

CPU tests

1.23 Benchmark score (bigger is better)

CPU raytrace

cores. It’s enabled by default and gives Both workstations were tested straight out a proven performance benefit when of the box. However, AMD and Intel CPUs rendering, but it has been known to slow can also be tuned in different ways. down other processes. Disabling SMT / HT in the BIOS made Overclocking: Both machines were virtually no difference to performance configured with stock CPU settings, where in most applications. Puget Systems has the frequency on one or more cores gets an reported a benefit of disabling SMT on automatic boost or turbo, as long as it stays AMD workstations when using Agisoft within set thermal and power limits. Metashape, but that was not what we To push performance higher, CPUs can observed in our tests. While processing also be overclocked, a process that typically time went down in one of the datasets, for involves tweaking frequencies and voltages. the other three, it actually went up. On Intel Core processors (those with the ‘K’ suffix) overclocking permanently Availability increases the frequency of all cores. Workstation brand also has a huge Different manufacturers take different influence over your choice of CPU. Pretty approaches to overclocking and some much every vendor offers a workstation push CPUs harder than others. A few with 11th Gen Intel Core CPUs. However, manufacturers hand-select CPUs that they workstations with AMD Ryzen 5000 know will overclock best. Overclocking is CPUs are only available from specialist not supported by the major manufacturers. manufacturers like Scan and Workstation With AMD Ryzen 5000, overclocking Specialists (see page WS16 for a round-up). can be controlled through Precision Boost This could change, of course. With AMD Overdrive 2, a feature which essentially offering superior performance in some makes AMD’s standard boost technology multi-threaded workflows, we are certain more aggressive. It can’t be overclocked on that Dell, HP, Fujitsu and Lenovo are all cores in the same way that Intel can, but paying close attention. Lenovo already has some manufacturers are finding new ways a workstation with an AMD Threadripper to get more out of the processor. Pro CPU, with up to 64-cores.

Autodesk Revit 2021 RFO v3 benchmark

CPU tests

Workstation tuning

100

120

5000

10000

5.07 15000

20000

25000

30000

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900) Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X)

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:38

workstation special report

workstation performed so well. In single threaded workflows it demonstrated a clear lead over the AMD workstation. It was typically around 10% faster, but in some tests it was as little as 1% or as much as 56% (when rebuilding a model in Solidworks). For CAD and BIM software, single threaded performance is where it counts. Yes, there are some processes within these applications that are multi-threaded, but very few can use all of the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X’s 16 cores. And, even if they can, it’s often only for short bursts, mixed in with single threaded operations. There are caveats to this, such as executing a solid sweep in Inventor, where AMD has a clear lead. Also, in new generation modelling tools like nTopology, which have been built from ground up for multi-core CPUs. Some of the more advanced CAM and simulation tools can also take advantage of more than eight cores, although this is not the case for Solidworks Simulate or dynamic simulation and FEA in Inventor. Even photogrammetry software Agisoft Metascan doesn’t show any major benefit from the Ryzen 9 5950X although AMD does have a small but significant lead in point cloud processing software Leica Cyclone Register 360. All of these observations are only relevant if you’re using your workstation to do one thing at a time. The Ryzen 9

InvMark for Inventor 2022 (by Cadac Group and TFI)

5950X has significantly more potential than Intel when it comes to multi-tasking, using its 16 cores to full effect to run several CPU intensive tasks concurrently. This all leads us onto rendering where the AMD Ryzen 5000 wins hands down. With the 11th Gen Core processors maxing out at 8 cores Intel simply can’t compete. And if rendering is part of your day-to-day workflow then the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X looks to be the obvious choice. Of course, the Ryzen 5000 Series and 11th Gen Intel Core isn’t just about the top-end models. For CAD users on a tight budget the 6-core Intel Core i5-11600 looks like a great value CPU. And, as

Agisoft Metashape Professional 1.73

1,272 1,855

Assemblies

Ray Tracing

1,477

1,455

2,439 2,095

1000

5,888 5,994

2000

3000

24.90

4000

5000

27.89

Sketchy view

6000

30.90 20

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900 with Quadro RTX 4000)

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900)

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X with Quadro RTX 4000)

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X)

1,237

Leica Cyclone Register 360

1,088

Point cloud registration

1,499

1,390

1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

Multi-tasking workflow benchmarks (Cyclone Register 360, Metashape and Keyshot)

1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

1,159

Saving to disk

Dynamic Sim

3,671

22.82

1,894

Data Translation

Opening files

1,522

Graphics testing (with AMD Radeon Pro W6800)

Park Map

1,686

Autodesk Revit 2021 RFO benchmark

Standard view

391 426

School model

mentioned previously, in some workflows, the 8-core AMD Ryzen 7 5800X can actually outperform the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X in multi-threaded workflows, even though it has fewer cores. In summary, choosing a workstation processor boils down to how you intend to use your machine. 11th Gen Intel Core looks to be the CPU of choice for vanilla CAD and some lightly threaded workflows. However, AMD is not that far behind. AMD is also a strong contender for those who multi-task and if ray trace rendering is also part of your day-to-day workflow then the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X wins hands down.

1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

111 120

Rock model

School Map Drawing

Puget Systems benchmark 1.23 Time secs (smaller is better)

1.23 Benchmark score (bigger is better)

Modelling

Your choice of CPU has very little bearing on 3D performance in GPU limited applications like Unreal Engine

963

1,992

1,313

FEA

665

1,777

1,263

Large dataset (99 GB)

Cyclone and Metashape

699

Small dataset (24 GB)

1,888

1,785

Cyclone, Metashape and Keyshot on 4 cores Cyclone, Metashape and Keyshot on 8 cores

500

1000

1500

2000

895

1,439

1,024

Test did not finish 0

954

863 300

600

900

1200

1500

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900)

Workstation Specialists WS-184 (Intel Core i9-11900 with Quadro RTX 4000)

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X)

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R (AMD Ryzen 9 5950X with Quadro RTX 4000)

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000

www.develop3d.com

WS04_05_06_09_10_11_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Intel_AMD.indd 9

August / September 2021

WS9

12/08/2021 14:38

workstation special report

Multicore for CAD talking heads

Kevin Schneider, Senior director, Fusion 360 Group technology strategist / Autodesk With eight CPU cores now standard in workstations, rising in some cases to as many as 64, designers and engineers typically have a huge amount of processing power at their fingertips. So is there scope for making CAD software more multithreaded, enabling it to use more cores, more efficiently – or does the sequential nature of many operations mean the hands of CAD software developers are tied? We asked the experts to find out more Autodesk Inventor (below) nTopology (bottom)

AD applications have limits on how aggressively they can use multicore computing. For example, history-based modelling has operations that must be performed serially, and therefore cannot be parallelised across cores. Fortunately, as CAD applications mature and integrate other valuable capabilities, many of those added capabilities leverage more cores. Autodesk’s design and manufacturing applications leverage multicore compute in specific cases. These include importing solid geometries; performing mass property and sheet metal calculations; toolpath and nesting calculations; and simulations such as e-cooling, injection moulding, and meshing and model preparation. Graphics operations, like converting BREP (boundary representation) surface data to facet information for real-time rendering, are also multicore capable.

In any discussion of multicore capabilities, the importance of GPU and cloud compute cannot be overlooked. Autodesk provides multiple ray trace rendering tools, such as Autodesk VRED, which use GPU compute. In fact, rendering and ray tracing leverage as many cores as are available, and scale almost linearly with the number of cores. Autodesk also leverages ondemand cloud compute, scaling CPU/GPU resources in the cloud to deliver compute-intensive output such as simulation, rendering and generative design. Generative design can scale to using many cores and GPUs in parallel to solve its challenges and produce multiple outcomes. If you only look at history-based part modelling operations, the value of multiple CPUs is low. But CAD applications have evolved way beyond just part modelling, and customers receive significant benefits from the CAD capabilities that do use multicore computing. If you are designing assemblies, working with imported data, rendering, creating drawings and frequently calculating manufacturing toolpaths, those cores will increase your productivity. Add the ability to use cloud compute on demand and customers have even more compute available to help them push their design and manufacturing processes further and faster. ■ autodesk.com

‘‘

If you are designing assemblies, working with imported data, rendering, creating drawings and frequently calculating manufacturing toolpaths, those cores will increase your productivity

’’

WS10

August / September 2021

WS10_11_12_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Talking_Heads_CAD.indd 10

www.develop3d.com

18/08/2021 14:09

workstation special report

Danny Sicking Director of Software Engineering, NX Platform / Siemens

n developing new capabilities and expanding our products, we are always looking for ways to leverage compute power to deliver the best performance. Today’s frontier of parallel compute exists on the cloud. As microservices and horizontal scaling emerge for CAD and engineering workloads on the cloud, we can learn from recent

models in real time, based on insession dynamic content. Additionally, model and assembly load times can be reduced by spreading the load of reading data across cores. Analysing the structure from the PLM system and prepping for the load can also be parallelised. As a general guideline, compute-intensive operations with minimal UI feedback or end-user interaction are usually the best places to multithread and improve performance. UI operations must be processed on the main thread, so these cannot be executed on multiple cores. Another barrier to multithreading is when results are order-dependent, like parametric feature updates. Performance improvements can be achieved by other means, such as segmentation and reducing the

‘‘

Display-related functions such as bounding box calculations, hidden line removal, view section creation, edge extraction and rendering are easily sped up by leveraging multiple cores

’’

advancements on desktop that leverage multicore CPUs. Display-related functions such as bounding box calculations, hidden line removal, view section creation, edge extraction and rendering are easily sped up by leveraging multiple cores, mainly because the results are not orderdependent. High-end rendering also can be greatly speeded up by using GPU acceleration. Our recent advancements in AI/ML leverage multithreading to build

number of features participating in the update. At Siemens, we look to leverage advances in hardware and computing technologies in products such as NX, as well as our kernel modelling tools such as Parasolid. We do this with a focus on the value it can offer to our customers and our commitment to preserving their data and maintaining a high level of quality. ■ sw.siemens.com

www.develop3d.com

WS10_11_12_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Talking_Heads_CAD.indd 11

Chris Hall Director of software performance engineering / AMD

omputer hardware has become so much faster since I started in CAD in the early 1990s, that for many designers working on smaller parts, the single-threaded nature of CAD applications is not an obstacle to productivity in terms of designing that widget. But I think the world has moved on from simply designing an object by hand and then turning around and having it made. We’ve moved into a world now where the compute power that’s available from high core count processors allows for a more robust and rigorous design process, in a couple of ways in particular. First, with additive manufacturing, we’ve entered an era where generative design becomes important, and this is an area where having more cores is definitely a performance advantage. Second, we’re now capable of doing a lot more simulation on everything that we make. It’s no longer the realm of a

supercomputer or a cluster. With a 64-core Threadripper Pro, you can easily do simulation on your desktop. In fact, because you have so many cores available, you can set that simulation running and while it might take several hours to complete, you still have enough compute available to continue doing design work with your CAD application of choice. So, while you don’t necessarily need the additional cores for traditional design tasks, they provide a boost in those areas where CAD has evolved. Often an afterthought, the fact is that once you design a part, you still have to manufacture it. With injection moulding, you need to run a simulation of plastic flow through the part, and that simulation is multithreaded. Another element that people don’t often consider is generating CNC toolpaths – software like CAMworks, for example, is highly multithreaded. In practice, that means with Threadripper Pro, you have the opportunity to iterate more often to refine that toolpath, which can a) increase production-line throughput, and b) decrease wear on cutters and save material, both of which increase company profitability. So, it’s not the old-school way to think about CAD, but in terms of contributing to the bottom line of the company you’re working for, that’s definitely a place where high core count helps. ■ amd.com

‘‘

It’s not the old-school way to think about CAD, but in terms of contributing to the bottom line of the company you’re working for, that’s definitely a place where high core count helps

’’

August / September 2021

WS11

18/08/2021 14:09

workstation special report

Blake Courter Chief Technical Officer nTopology

Topology’s unique computational approach allows it to take full advantage of the available CPU and GPU resources of a desktop or virtual machine. We have pioneered several technologies that work together to enable this achievement. Our field-driven design and implicit modelling calculations are highly parallelisable, unlike B-rep and mesh-based

will simultaneously use all the CPU and GPU cores provided. If your hardware has any issues with cooling or the power supply, it will likely expose them. To avoid over-consuming resources, we match our worker threads to the available cores. An added benefit is that, unlike most engineering software, nTopology lets you keep working in your document while evaluation runs in the background. Our generative design tools also leverage precise B-rep, mesh, voxel and FE modelling components, solvers and algorithms. Some of these blocks inherit compute limitations from those components. Although such bottlenecks do not yet appear on the critical path for our customers, our evaluation system is stateless and purely functional, so we have the opportunity to parallelise those when possible. nTopology is still a young

‘‘

We can use double precision on the CPU for engineering computations, while simultaneously using single precision on the GPU for visualisation and real-time interaction

’’

modelling systems, which rely on sequential algorithms. The straightforward math expressions that represent our models are theoretically infinitely precise and are computed at the appropriate fidelity on the fly. For example, we can use double precision on the CPU for engineering computations, while simultaneously using single precision on the GPU for visualisation and real-time interaction. The result is that nTopology WS12

product with a natural affinity for more compute resources. Our recent 3.0 release, which demonstrated a 10-times to 100-times improvement using the GPU, exemplifies such compute flexibility. We are now experimenting with porting our implicit expressions to arbitrary platforms, from Raspberry Pi to HPC to CAD add-ins. Although we’ve been focused on individual PCs so far, distributed approaches are likely in our future as well. ■ ntopology.com

August / September 2021

WS10_11_12_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Talking_Heads_CAD.indd 12

Brett Chouinard Chief Technical Officer Altair

ecent developments in hardware technologies have indeed put multicores and threads via CPUs and GPUs at the fingertips of developers in all industries. Some of these industries were architecturally designed to benefit from multicores naturally, like the gaming industry, where applications like system AI [Artificial Intelligence], sound handling, network layers and graphic rendering could be handled through multiple cores and threads. Other industries, such as CAD or CAE, had to follow, and needed to consider the benefits of this architectural redesign of the applications over their original infrastructure, or at least identify areas within the applications’ workflows that would greatly benefit from these types of changes and updates. Altair uses multicores and threading in many aspects of its simulation suite; for example,

within the meshing and morphing capabilities of Altair HyperWorks, when reading or importing large data files and results and for graphic renderings. A good example is Altair’s graphical capabilities, which have been added to our Inspire Studio Renderer solution and now include CPU and GPU multicore support with the addition of hardware ray tracing and denoising support from the GPU. The results must be seen to be believed; they are faster than ever before and look great in real time. The more obvious areas in Altair products that show tremendous multithreading benefits are our solver solutions. One such product is Altair NanoFluidX, a solution from our CFD solver package, utilising multicores over multinodes (including cloud solutions) and Nvidia Cuda GPU hardware. Some of our test results show speed enhancements of up to 20 times, a boost that allows designers, analysts and engineers to use proper tools to turn their ideas into the best designs and products possible. Altair is a company that brings innovation to its products while utilising cutting-edge technologies, be it multithreading CPUs, compute and AI GPU power or HPC cloud-based solutions to allow people to turn their ideas and design into reality. ■ altair.com

‘‘

The more obvious areas in Altair products that show tremendous multithreading benefits are our solver solutions

’’

www.develop3d.com

18/08/2021 14:09

DISCOVER YOUR SOFTWARE’S FULL POTENTIAL Welcome to Our Greatest PRO GPU. Ever.

Welcome to Exceptional Performance. Introducing the Incredible Radeon™ PRO W6800 GPU. Delivering a Gigantic 32 GB of High-Performance Memory with ECC Support, Hardware Raytracing, Optimizations for 6 Ultra-HD HDR Displays, Accelerated Software Multi-Tasking, PCIe® 4.0 for Advanced Data Transfer Speeds, and Certifications for Many Popular Applications. ALL AS STANDARD.

Enhanced Compute Units To Decrease Latency

Ray Accelerators For Realtime Raytracing

26.8 Billion Transistors Within 520mm2

Importance to Professional Software Engineered from the ground up with superior performance and power efficiency, AMD RDNA™ 2 architecture introduces significant advancements in the form of an all new AMD Infinity Cache™ Memory, an enhanced Compute Unit, Hardware Raytracing support, combined with a new visual pipeline for added efficiencies. These advancements help enable high resolution performance and increased vivid visuals within your professional software of choice. The latest AMD Radeon PRO W6000 graphics series is compatible with modern workstations offering additional optimizations for select AMD Ryzen™ based processors, harnessing the GPU’s and system’s full performance potential.

PCIe® 4.0 x16 Support Removing Bottlenecks

AMD Infinity Cache Bandwidth Amplifier

AMD RDNA 2 graphics processor within the high performing AMD Radeon PRO W6800.

Professional Graphics for Exceptional Performance with Reliability, Stability and Software Certifications at its Core. ©2021 Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. All rights reserved. AMD, the AMD Arrow logo, AMD Infinity Cache, Radeon, AMD RDNA, Ryzen and combinations thereof are trademarks of Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. PCI Express and PCIe are registered trademarks of PCI-SIG Corporation. Other product names used in this publication are for identification purposes only and may be trademarks of their respective companies. PID#: 21822206

workstation special report

Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R 11th Gen Intel Core workstations might have have the edge in CAD and BIMcentric workflows, but this Ryzen 9 5000 beast from Scan wins hands down when it comes to rendering and extreme multi-tasking, writes Greg Corke

ike many workstation manufacturers, it’s been a frustrating six months for Bolton-based Scan. AMD Ryzen 5000 CPUs have been in huge demand, but the global chip shortage has meant limited supply. This now appears to have eased and Scan workstations with ‘Zen 3’ AMD CPUs are now rolling off the company’s production line. The delay has brought some benefits. Scan can now pair AMD’s impressive desktop CPU with a choice of three Nvidia ‘Ampere’ pro GPUs. The Nvidia RTX A4000 (16 GB), Nvidia RTX A5000 (24 GB) and Nvidia RTX A6000 (48 GB) are all available as options inside the new Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R. For our review machine, Scan has chosen the top-end AMD Ryzen 9 5950X CPU. With 16 cores, 32 threads, a base frequency of 3.4 GHz and a boost of 4.9 GHz, this processor is adept at handling all different types of workflows. You get excellent performance in single threaded CAD software, as well as multithreaded power for simulation, point cloud processing, photogrammetry, generative design, CAM and, of course rendering.

WS14

August / September 2021

WS14_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Scan.indd 14

As you’ll learn from our indemanding graphics-centric Product spec depth article on page WS4, the workflows (or a tighter budget) 11th Gen Intel Core CPU still a downgrade to the Nvidia ■ AMD Ryzen 9 5950X processor has the edge in many workflows. RTX A4000 will shave close (3.4 GHz, 4.9 GHz However, when it comes to to £1,000 off the £4,167 (Ex boost) (16 cores, 32 threads) rendering and extreme multiVAT) price tag. See our in-depth ■ Nvidia RTX A5000 tasking, the 8-core Intel Core review of both Nvidia GPUs on GPU (24 GB) i9-11900 or Intel Core i9-11900K page WS28. ■ 64 GB (2 x 32 GB) simply can’t compete with the The Asus Pro WS X570Corsair Vengeance DDR4 3,200 MHz 16-core AMD Ryzen 9 5950X. ACE motherboard is ■ 2 TB Samsung 980 To explore the machine’s workstation-grade and has Pro NVMe PCIe 4.0 SSD + 4 TB Samsung multi-tasking potential, we what Scan describes as an 870 Evo SATA SSD pushed it to its limits, with ‘over-engineered cooling and ■ 3XS workstation a demanding engineering power delivery system’. It has case with tempered glass window workflow, consisting of point four memory slots, populated ■ Microsoft Windows cloud processing in Leica in our test machine with 64 GB 10 Professional Cycone Register 360 and (2 x 32 GB) of Corsair Vengeance 64-bit photogrammetry processing DDR4 3,200 MHz memory. For ■ 3 Years warranty – 1st Year Onsite, 2nd in Agisoft Metashape. Not only memory-hungry workflows and 3rd Year RTB did it reduce processing time like point cloud processing, it’s (Parts and Labour) to 889 secs from 1,306 secs (the easy to upgrade to 128 GB, as ■ £4,167 (Ex VAT) time it took if both jobs were run we did when testing with Leica scan.co.uk/3xs sequentially), but the machine Cyclone Register 360, though was still responsive enough to you’ll first need to clip off one of model comfortably in Revit. See our in- the CPU fans to get to the slots. depth AMD vs Intel article on page WS4 to With a second PCIe Gen 4 slot, you can find out more. add a second Nvidia RTX A5000 GPU at a The 2 TB Samsung 980 Pro NVMe PCIe later date although you may need a bigger 4.0 Solid State Drive (SSD) certainly helps PSU than the 750W Corsair RMX, which here as it’s able to read and write data very is 80PLUS Gold rated. Scan technicians quickly, so storage doesn’t become too can advise here. much of a bottleneck. Everything is housed in a new custom Rather than supplementing the M.2 SSD Scan 3XS workstation case, which is with a 3.5-inch SATA Hard Disk Drive available with both solid and tempered (HDD) for secondary storage, Scan has glass side panels. It’s a nice sturdy chassis included a 4 TB Samsung 870 Evo SATA with a 3XS branded vented front that SSD instead. Costing less than 10p per GB, helps ensure cool air runs freely from SSDs are quickly becoming the future of front to back. all workstation storage, and not just for A substantial dual radiator, dual fan OS, apps and select datasets. Noctua NH-D15 air cooler helps keep the Coupled with the Nvidia RTX processor running cool. We observed A5000 GPU, the workstation a peak frequency of 4.91 GHz in single has an obvious bias towards threaded workflows, going down to 3.74 graphics intensive workflows, GHz with all 16 cores running flat out for suggested by the ‘ME’ (Media extended periods. Scan says the Noctua and Entertainment) abbreviation is generally quieter than an equivalently in the product name. rated hydrocooler, and it’s hard to The Nvidia RTX A5000 is a argue with that. The entire system was hugely powerful professional incredibly quiet, even under heavy loads. GPU for real-time viz and GPU rendering. At 4K resolution, The verdict we got in excess of 20 frames This is another excellent machine from per second in most of our test specialist workstation manufacturer applications. The exceptions Scan. With the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X were Unreal Engine 4 when real- CPU, the 3XS GWP-ME A132R is equally time ray tracing was enabled and adept at handling single threaded or in Autodesk VRED Professional multi-threaded workflows. Whether when anti-aliasing was set to that’s for rendering stills and animations, ultra-high. However, these or for demanding multi-tasking reality are extreme workloads. Most modelling workflows, it doesn’t really mainstream viz users should matter. And with an Nvidia RTX A5000 expect a smooth, reactive GPU backing it all up with substantial viewport when navigating graphics horsepower, it can handle pretty models, and superfast results much anything you throw at it. And it when GPU rendering. does all this while giving out little more For those with less than a gentle hum. www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:43

workstation special report

Workstation Specialists WS-184 The 11th Gen Intel Core processor might be a step back in some departments, but in single threaded workflows like CAD it remains king. Furthermore, coupled wth the right components — as it is in this new tower from Derby-based Workstation Specialists — it can also provide a solid foundation for more demanding workflows. By Greg Corke

hen Intel launched its ‘Rocket Lake’ processor family earlier this year it came under a lot of flak for having fewer CPU cores than the previous generation. 10th Gen Intel Core maxed out at ten, but the new 11th Gen Core CPUs were limited to eight. The reality is, this is only an issue if you use software that can take full advantage of that many cores. And for most architects, engineers and product designers, that’s typically only ray trace rendering. For those that rely solely on CAD software, it continues to be all about frequency and Instructions Per Clock (IPC). And here, Intel delivers in spades. The Intel Core i9-11900 CPU at the heart of this Workstation Specialists desktop tower might have a base clock of 2.50 GHz, but in many of our single threaded CAD tests it hit 5.15 GHz on a single core, just a touch slower than the stated maximum of 5.20 GHz. And this isn’t even Intel’s fastest 11th Intel Core CPU. If you can get hold of one, the Intel Core i9-11900K can go all the way up to 5.3 GHz. Despite ‘only’ having eight cores, the Core i9-11900 performed very well in some multi-threaded workflows like point cloud processing and reality modelling. Applications like Leica Cyclone Register 360 and Agisoft MetaShape might be multi-threaded but there appears to be little additional benefit (or none at all) to having more than eight cores. It’s only when you get into highly-threaded applications like rendering and geometry optimisation that CPUs with more cores, such as the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X, have an advantage. You can learn more about this in our AMD vs Intel article on page WS4. Our test machine came with 64 GB (2 x 32 GB) of 3,200 MHz dual channel Corsair Vengance RGB Pro DDR4 memory. This is a good amount for an allround CAD-centric workstation. Those who simply work with average sized models in Solidworks or other CAD tools should get away with 32 GB. www.develop3d.com

WS15_D3D_AUGSEPT21_WS.indd 15

Conversely, those who deal with new Nvidia RTX A4000 which Product spec huge point cloud datasets, would comes with a substantial 16 GB likely be better served with 128 of memory. As you see from our ■ Intel Core i9-11900 processor (2.5 GHz, GB — the maximum the Asus review on page WS28, this is an 5.3 GHz Turbo) PRIME Z590-P motherboard impressive all-round GPU for (8 cores, 16 threads) can take in its four memory slots. workflows that include GPU ■ 64 GB (2 x 32 GB) 3,200 MHz dual The motherboard fits snuggly rendering, real-time 3D, realchannel Corsair inside the Fractal Design Define time ray tracing and VR. Vengance RGB Pro DDR4 memory 7 Compact chassis. At 427 x For an additional £767 you ■ 2 TB Samsung 210 x 474 mm this is a shrunkcan upgrade to the Nvidia RTX 980 Pro NVMe PCIe 4.0 SSD down version of the popular A5000 (24 GB). But if you’re ■Asus Prime Z590-P workstation case used by many very much focused on CAD motherboard of the UK’s custom workstation and other less demanding 3D ■ Fractal Design manufacturers. applications, you could easily Define 7 Compact desktop chassis For easy access, there are two drop down to the Nvidia T1000 (427 x 210 x 474 mm) USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports up front, but (4 GB), or the Nvidia RTX ■ Microsoft Windows no USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 Type-C. If A2000 (6 GB), which will be 10 Professional 64-bit you have devices that need the available in October. ■ 36 Months more modern USB standard, premium RTB The verdict you’ll probably want to buy a hardware warranty with remote hub to plug into the single USB The Workstation Specialists engineer diagnostics by next business day Type C port at the rear. WS-184 is an excellent choice ■ £2,414 (Ex VAT) The machine has three fans for CAD-centric workflows. In that move air from front to applications like Solidworks ■ Upgrades back and, together with the ‘Be it delivers where it counts, 128 GB memory Quiet’ CPU air cooler, keep the but also has enough cores - add £315 machine running pretty quietly. to support more processorNvidia RTX A5000 - add £767 For a machine of this type, it intensive workflows like 8 TB Samsung 870 offers the perfect combination point cloud processing and QVO - add £696 of size and expandability. In photogrammetry. the bottom section of the case, For those with a focus on workstation specialists.com nestled alongside the 750W rendering, the fact that the ATX 80-Plus Platinum Certified Workstation Specialists WSPower Supply Unit (PSU), there are two 184 would struggle against an AMD 3.5-inch drive bays. Ryzen 9 5950X-based workstation could For most CAD-centric workstations, we’d be a moot point if your software is tuned usually expect one of these bays to be fitted for GPU. The Nvidia RTX A4000 GPU with a Hard Disk Drive (HDD) to give a cost- (or RTX A5000) is more than capable of effective mass storage partner to the on- doing the heavy lifting here. board NVMe SSD. For example, in a budget Conversely, strip out the high-end GPU, workstation, a combination of 512 GB Solid drop down to 32 GB of RAM, and pare State Drive (SSD) and 2 TB HDD is typical. back on the storage and you should have However, for this machine, Workstation a very affordable, but fast workstation for Specialists has gone for SSDs throughout. bread and butter CAD work. For the main system drive there’s the high-performance 2 TB Samsung 980 PRO M.2 PCIe 4.0 NVMe SSD, which offers up to 7,000 MBps read and 5,100MBps write. But this has been partnered with an 8 TB Samsung 870 QVO 2.5-inch SATA III SSD. With 560MBps read, and 530MBps write, the 870 QVO offers significantly lower sequential read/write performance than its PCIe 4.0 counterpart, but with a whopping 8 TB to play with, it’s a great alternative to an HDD in I/O intensive workflows like point cloud processing, where collosal datasets are frequently read from / written to disk. For graphics, there’s the August / September 2021

WS15 15

12/08/2021 14:44

workstation special report

CAD workstation round up The latest workstations for CAD-centric workflows: 11th Gen Intel Core (up to 8 cores) and AMD Ryzen 5000 (up to 16 cores) to go beyond 3D design and into the realms of rendering, reality modelling and simulation 1

BOXX Apexx S3

Dell Precision 3450 SFF

Fujitsu Celsius W5011

BOXX has built a major part of its business around overclocking and with the BOXX Apexx S3 it permanently boosts 11th Intel Core clock speeds across all eight cores. The Intel Core i7-11700K runs at 5.0 GHz, while the Intel Core i7-11900K runs at 5.3 GHz. As with all BOXX workstations, there’s also a huge focus on build quality, with the custom chassis made from ‘aircraft-grade’ aluminium, offering a strength and rigidity way beyond that of most off-the-shelf cases.

The Dell Precision 3450 SFF is a very compact desktop workstation. Measuring a mere 290 x 93 x 293mm it can even be mounted behind a display (pictured left). The ‘small form factor’ chassis does mean a more limited set of processor options, maxing out at the 65W Intel Core i9-11900 or 80W Intel Xeon W-1390. It’s also restricted to entry-level pro GPUs, but the AMD Radeon Pro WX 3200 and Nvidia Quadro P1000 are perfectly suited to 3D CAD workflows.

This 21 litre ‘micro tower’ is not as deep as comparable workstations, as the motherboard and GPU span its entire depth. It offers a choice of 11th Gen Intel Core or Intel Xeon W-1300 processors and can be configured with a massive range of GPUs, from the entry-level CAD-centric Nvidia T400 up to the Nvidia Quadro RTX 5000 (it doesn’t yet offer the new Nvidia RTX A4000 / A5000). Other features include up to 128 GB of memory, multiple drives and tool-less access.

■ boxx.com ■ boxx-tech.co.uk

■ dell.com/precision

■ fujitsu.com

Lenovo ThinkStation P350 Tiny

Boston VENOM R41-10NP

Broadberry CyberStation SFF

Tiny by name, tiny by nature — this is the smallest workstation on the planet, measuring a mere 37 x 183 x 179mm. However, it still has everything you need for mainstream CAD workflows, including an 11th Gen Intel Core i9 CPU (8 cores, 5.2 GHz), up to 64 GB of DDR4 3200 MHz memory and a choice of Nvidia P1000 or T600 GPUs. There’s no room for a HDD but with an M.2 PCIe Gen4 NVMe SSD up to 2 TB there’s still plenty of storage. Plus, built in WiFi.

Boston offers a huge variety of desktop workstations in its Venom range, from Intel Core and Intel Xeon, to AMD Threadripper, Threadripper Pro and AMD Epyc. This AMD Ryzen 5000 machine can be fitted with optional liquid cooling for ‘maximum performance and whisper quiet operation’ and matched with up to 128 GB of DDR4 3,200 MHz stock or 4,733 MHz overclocked memory. All of Boston’s workstations are available to lease.

With its 250 x 203 x 367 mm Fractal Design Core 500 chassis, the Broadberry CyberStation SFF is one of the smallest AMD Ryzen 5000 workstations. This, together with the built-in WiFi, make it well suited to home workers. Despite its size it can still take a whole host of pro GPUs, up to the Nvidia RTX A6000. Two RAM slots on the Gigabyte AMD Ryzen X570 I AORUS PRO motherboard mean it’s limited to 64 GB, but that’s still plenty for most CAD-centric workflows.

■ lenovo.com/workstations

■ boston.co.uk

■ broadberry.co.uk/amd-ryzen-workstations

Interpro IPW-R9 Dell Precision 5760

Novatech ProStation WR7-WX41

Overclockers RENDA

As the name suggests, the InterPro IPW-R9 features a choice of 3rd Gen AMD Ryzen 9 CPUs, including the 12-core Ryzen 9 5900X and 16-core Ryzen 9 5950X. To keep clock speeds running as high as possible for longer periods, the UK firm uses a range of Corsair all-inone liquid CPU coolers. Different BIOS profiles can be created for customers, matched to their workflows. For example, to allow higher clock speeds by temporarily sacrificing cores.

The Novatech ProStation WR7-WX41 is built around the AMD Ryzen 5000 Series with a choice of three CPUs — the 8-core 5800X, 12-core 5900X and 16-core 5950X. It’s fully customisable, but not just core components like memory, graphics and storage. Customers can also choose from 15 different CPU coolers (air or liquid) and nine different chassis, from full towers like the Phanteks Enthoo Pro (pictured) to 4U rack mounts like the Chenbro RM41300G.

It’s not hard to guess what this UK firm specialises in. The Overclockers RENDA workstation is all about pushing the limits of performance, while maintaining stability. Professional overclocker Ian Parry (aka 8Pack) heads up the R&D, delivering hand-built machines based on each customer’s workflow requirements. With a custom water cooling solution he says he can push the AMD Ryzen 9 5950X to 5.1 GHz on one core and 4.6 GHz on all cores.

■ ipworkstations.com

■ novatech.co.uk

■ overclockers.co.uk

WS16

August / September 2021

WS16_17_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RoundUp.indd 16

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:46

workstation special report

13 12

BIMBOX Stryker III

HP Z2 G8 SFF

BOXX Apexx Denali

Armari Magnetar

As its name suggests, BIMBOX is laser focused on the AEC (Architecture, Emgineering and Construction) sector, but can apply its extensive knowledge of Building Information Modelling and viz software to mechanical CAD workflows. The firm takes overclocking extremely seriously. For its Stryker III workstation it ‘delids’ the Intel Core i9-11900K CPU, taking off the standard heat spreader and mounting its own liquid cooler directly onto the silicon. This brings down the CPU temperature considerably so it can safely run at 5.3 GHz on all cores. BIMBOX is based in the US, but its machines will soon be built, sold and supported in the UK and other countries.

With its 338 x 308 x 100mm chassis, the HP Z2 G8 SFF is slightly bigger than the Dell Precision 3450 SFF (top left) but has the option of more powerful processors. These include the 125W Intel Core i9-11900K and the Nvidia Quadro RTX 3000, which extends the reach of the workstation beyond 3D CAD and into the realms of entry-level viz. According to HP, the Z2 G8 SFF offers ‘Unthrottled performance’ thanks to Z’s ‘industry-leading’ thermals that keep the processor and graphics card cool, so they can run at max performance for extended periods of time. ‘Unthrottled performance’ also extends to the new PCIe Gen 4 Samsung PM9A1 SSD.

With its Apexx Denali, BOXX was one of the first workstation manufacturers to offer a Ryzen 5000 Series workstation. It uses the same compact custom ‘aircraft-grade’ aluminium chassis as the Intel-based Apexx S3 and at 174 x 388 x 452mm it’s smaller than most AMD Ryzen 5000 tower workstations. But that doesn’t come at the expense of expandability. The Apexx Denali can house up to two high-end Nvidia RTX, Nvidia GeForce or AMD Radeon Pro GPUs and two 3.5-inch Hard Disk Drives (HDDs). To keep the processor running at peak frequencies it uses a liquid-cooled closed loop system with a sizeable radiator.

The Armari Magnetar V16R-RA850G2-2S is one of the smallest AMD Ryzen 5000 Series workstation out there, measuring a mere 360 x 87 x 400mm. The custom chassis features a high quality Japanese steel frame which was designed in-house by the specialist UK manufacturer. Unlike many other small form factor workstations, there is no compromise on graphics and the workstation can support one dual slot GPU like the AMD Radeon Pro W6800 or two single slot GPUs like the Nvidia RTX A4000. Custom fans and a 14cm all-in-one liquid CPU cooler help maintain peak performance, while still preserving quiet operation.

■ bimboxusa.com

■ hp.com/z

■ boxx.com ■ boxx-tech.co.uk

■ armari.com

www.develop3d.com

WS16_17_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RoundUp.indd 17

August / September 2021

WS17

12/08/2021 14:46

workstation special report

Best lightweight workstation laptops 2021 Our top picks for ultra-portable mobile workstations to take CAD and design visualisation on the road — all under 20mm and most below 2kg

HP ZBook Studio G8

The 15.6-inch HP ZBook Studio G8 is HP’s first mobile workstation to offer both pro and consumer graphics options in the same machine, up to the Nvidia RTX A5000 (16 GB) or GeForce 3080 (16 GB). Both GPUs are ideal for design viz, VR and GPU rendering but as the laptop is very slim (17.5mm) we expect the same GPU might run faster in the thicker (22.8mm) HP ZBook Fury G8 15, which should offer better cooling and increased power draw. The HP ZBook Studio G8 offers a choice of 11th Generation Intel Core H-Series processors up to the Intel Core i9-11950H but only up to 32 GB RAM, which might be a little light for some workflows. It also features an optional HP DreamColor display with a 120Hz refresh rate, a billion on-screen colours, 100% DCI-P3, and ‘end-to-end’ colour accuracy with Pantone validation. It starts at 1.79kg. ■ hp.com/z

Dell Precision 5760 The Dell Precision 5760 is somewhat unique as it remains the only thin and light 17-inch mobile workstation from a major vendor. It is a replacement for the Dell Precision 5750 but features an enhanced thermal design including dual output fans, vapour chamber and a hidden exhaust venting through the hinge. Like the 15-inch Dell Precision 5560 (see top right) it features a combination of aluminium and carbon fibre for the chassis and a 94% display to body ratio thanks to the 4-sided InfinityEdge, 16:10 aspect ratio display. The thin (8.67 mm - 13.15 mm) and light (2.15kg) design means some compromise on graphics with the Nvidia RTX A2000 (4 GB) and Nvidia RTX A3000 (6 GB) being the only options, although the latter is ‘VR Ready’. However, it offers the same broad choice of 45W 11th Gen Intel Core and Xeon CPUs and supports up to 4 TB of PCI Gen4 SSDs and 64 GB of DDR4, 3,200 MHz memory. ■ dell.com/precision

WS18

August / September 2021

WS18_19_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Laptops.indd 18

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:47

workstation special report

MSI Creator Z16 Dell Precision 5560

MSI’s new pro-focused laptop marks a change in aesthetics for the Taiwanese company. The slimline 16mm chassis is made from CNC-milled aluminium with a ‘Lunar Gray’ finish. It starts at 2.2kg. With a 16-inch 16:10 aspect ratio display you get a bit more viewing space than the traditional 16:9. ‘True Pixel technology’ means extremely accurate colours and the display is hardware calibrated in the factory to give 100% coverage of the DCI-P3 colour gamut. QHD+ (2,560 x 1,600) resolution means pixel density is lower than a typical 4K (3,840 x 2,160) laptop display. The Z16 features a choice of 11th Gen Intel Core H series processors, an Nvidia GeForce RTX 3060 laptop GPU with Nvidia Studio drivers, up to 64 GB memory and up to 4 TB of storage spread across two M.2 NVMe PCIe Gen4 SSDs.

The Dell Precision 5560 wins hands down when it comes to portability. It’s the thinnest and lightest out of all the 15.6-inch mobile workstations — a mere 7.7mm at the front, 11.64mm at the rear and starting at 1.84kg. And with ultra thin bezels, it’s also notably smaller than comparable machines. In order to achieve this sleek aesthetic, it only includes entrylevel graphics options including the Nvidia T1200 (4 GB) and Nvidia RTX A2000 (4 GB), which are best suited to 3D CAD and entry-level viz workflows. However, there’s no compromise on the CPU with options going up to the Intel Xeon W-11955M (8 Core, 2.60 GHz up to 5.00 GHz). The laptop supports up to 64 GB of DDR4 3,200 MHz memory and 4 TB of NVMe PCI 4.0 storage. The IPS 4K ‘Gorilla Glass’ display is also top notch — 500 nits, 100% AdobeRGB and 99% DCI-P3. ■ dell.com/precision

■ msi.com

Lenovo ThinkPad P1 Gen 4 The first three generations of this thin and light mobile workstation featured a 15.6-inch display and CAD-focused pro graphics. The G4 edition is a ‘clean sheet’ design with a 16-inch display and higher-powered GPUs, including the ‘professional’ Nvidia RTX A5000 (16 GB) and ‘consumer’ Nvidia GeForce 3080 (16 GB). Memory and storage capacity remains the same with up to 64 GB DDR4 3,200 MHz and up to two 2 TB M.2 NVMe PCIe Gen4 SSDs. To accommodate the higher-end GPUs, which draw significantly more power than those in previous generation ThinkPad P1s, Lenovo has developed a new thermal design. It is also using AI to dynamically manage the ‘cooling budget’. For example, if a workflow is dependent on both the CPU and the GPU, it might set the Total Graphics Power (TGP) to 80W, whereas if a workflow is totally reliant on the GPU, such as GPU rendering, it could go as high as 90W or 100W. Despite more powerful GPUs and a larger display, the ThinkPad P1 Gen 4’s carbon fibre and magnesium alloy chassis has only increased slightly in size and weight – 361.8 (w) x 245.7 (d) x 18.4mm (h) and starting at 1.81kg. ■ lenovo.com/workstations

Microsoft Surface Book 3 (15-inch) The Microsoft Surface Book 3 launched in 2020 so is the oldest machine in this round up, but it warrants inclusion because it offers something different. At the push of a button, you can remove the touchscreen display and turn it into a tablet. And with the optional pressure sensitive Surface Pen, use it for precision sketching. The 15-inch display has a resolution of 3,240 x 2,160 and an aspect ratio of 3:2, which is deeper than all the other machines. As it’s last year’s model, the Surface Book 3 features a 10th Gen Intel Core processor - the Core i7-1065G7. With a boost of 3.9 GHz, performance in CAD will be OK, but with four cores and a base clock of 1.5 GHz it will be significantly slower than others in multi-threaded workflows like rendering. For graphics, you have the option of the Nvidia Quadro RTX 3000 (6 GB), which is designed for entry-level viz, but its ‘Max-Q Design’ means it will run slower than other machines with the same GPU. The Microsoft Surface Book 3 has a thickness of between 15mm and 23mm and weighs 1.9kg with the keyboard and 0.81kg without. ■ surface.com

www.develop3d.com

WS18_19_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Laptops.indd 19

August / September 2021

WS19

12/08/2021 14:47

workstation special report

AMD Radeon Pro W6800 This beast of a card is the first pro GPU from AMD with hardware-based ray tracing built in. With a whopping 32 GB of on board memory it’s designed for the most demanding arch viz workflows, writes Greg Corke Price $2,250 amd.com/radeonpro

memory to protect against crashes. And instead of three axial fans that recirculate air inside the machine, it has a single ‘blower’, which draws in cool air from the top of the card and pushes it out the rear of the machine. This design can be particularly beneficial in multi-GPU workstations. Perhaps most importantly, however, is that the Radeon Pro W6800 has a colossal 32 GB of on-board GDRR6 memory, double that of its consumer counterparts, and more than Nvidia’s pro GPUs at the same price point.

Monster memory

t’s been a long time coming but AMD has finally delivered its first professional GPU with hardware ray tracing built in. And with 32 GB of VRAM, the AMD Radeon Pro W6800 is a beast of a graphics card. Priced at $2,249, the Radeon Pro W6800 goes head-to-head with the 16 GB Nvidia RTX A4000 ($1,000) and 24 GB Nvidia RTX A5000 ($2,250), both of which we review on page WS28. In terms of raw performance, the Radeon Pro W6800 sits somewhere between AMD’s ‘consumer’ Radeon RX 6800 and Radeon RX 6800 XT. But as a workstation-class card there are several key differences. First, it will be certified for a wide range of pro applications, including all the major CAD and Building Information Modelling (BIM) tools. This can be especially significant for enterprise customers. It can also support up to six displays, which can be important for powerwalls, and features Error Correcting Code (ECC)

32 GB is a huge amount of memory for a GPU, surpassed only by the 48 GB Nvidia RTX A6000 which costs twice as much. It means the Radeon Pro W6800 can handle some seriously demanding visualisation datasets. This could be a huge multi-disciplinary city-scale model with immense detail or one with less geometry but hyper realistic assets such as 8K textures or detailed vegetation. It’s a huge step up from its predecessor, the AMD Radeon Pro W5700, which only had 8 GB and highlights AMD’s ambitions for high-end design viz and real-time ray tracing. The new GPU features enhanced Compute Units (CU) with dedicated ‘Ray Accelerators’. As this is AMD’s first pro GPU with hardware ray tracing, there aren’t currently a huge number of applications that can take advantage of its ‘Ray Accelerators’, but this is changing. The list currently includes applications that support DirectX Raytracing (DXR), such as Unreal Engine. Also, any that

Solidworks 2021 SP3 (OpenGL) SPECapc benchmark (FSAA) - RealView, shadows & AO 1.23 Benchmark score (bigger is better)

1.72

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

N/A 0.0

0.5

AMD Radeon Pro W5700 2.08 2.29 2.52

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

2.26

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

N/A

3.0

0.0

0.5

1.0

3.02 2.90 3.35

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

Solidworks Visualize 2021 SP3 (ProRender)

Computer model (denoising disabled)

Computer model (denoising enabled)

1,000 passes, accurate quality (1,500 x 1,500 resolution)

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

Render time (secs) (smaller is better)

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

100 passes, accurate quality (1,500 x 1,500 resolution)

358 225

100

150

200

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

250

300

350

400

67 45 56 46

3.5

Render time (secs) (smaller is better)

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia RTX A5000

174 0

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

351

211

Nvidia RTX A5000

WS20_21_22_23_24_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RadeonPro.indd 20

The Radeon Pro W6800 supports a new pro driver feature called Radeon Pro Viewport Boost, which is designed to reduce latency and boost viewport navigation performance. It detects when a 3D model is moving quickly in the viewport then

SPECapc benchmark (FSAA) - shaded with edges

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

August / September 2021

Viewport boost

Solidworks 2021 SP3 (OpenGL) 1.23 Benchmark score (bigger is better)

WS20

feature Radeon ProRender 2.0, the latest version of AMD’s physicallybased rendering engine. This includes Solidworks Visualize, Acca Software, Autodesk Inventor, Rhino, Autodesk Maya, and Blender. Looking to the future, it will also extend to any application that supports Vulkan Ray tracing, including those in development at Solidworks (Project Romulan — tinyurl.com/SW-graphics), Autodesk (One Graphics System - see page WS32) and Enscape. The Radeon Pro W6800 will not accelerate ray tracing in Nvidia RTXenabled applications such as Luxion KeyShot, Chaos V-ray, Chaos Vantage, Enscape 3.0 and others. Of course, the Radeon Pro W6800 can also be used for many other applications that don’t rely on hardware ray tracing. This includes those that use the OpenGL or DirectX graphics APIs, including real-time design viz tools like Lumion or Twinmotion, Virtual Reality (VR) or photogrammetry software. The GPU is very much focused on viz and is not optimised for FP64 (Double Precision) code, so applications like engineering simulation will likely to continue to be best served by the AMD Radeon Pro VII ($1,899).

40 20

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:50

workstation special report

automatically drops the resolution in specific areas to reduce the number of pixels the GPU needs to process. Then, as soon as that movement stops, it restores the full pixel count. According to AMD, this can increase Frames Per Second (FPS) dramatically without impacting the visual experience. AMD Radeon Pro Viewport Boost currently works with Revit, 3ds Max, Twinmotion and Unreal Engine (for packaged projects only, not currently Unreal Engine Editor). Support for other applications is coming soon. We explore this in more detail on page WS26

best with PCIe 4.0 workstations. With double the bandwidth of PCIe 3.0, data can theoretically be fed into the GPU much quicker, although it won’t make a difference in all workflows. PCIe 4.0 compatible CPUs include 11th Generation Intel Core, Intel Xeon W-1300, AMD Ryzen 5000, AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3900X and Threadripper Pro 3900WX series. The AMD Radeon Pro W6800 is also designed to work better with AMD CPUs with AMD Smart Access Memory. This essentially gives the CPU better access

Unreal Engine 4.26

Specifications The AMD Radeon Pro W6800 is the first workstation GPU to be based on AMD’s 7nm RDNA 2 architecture. AMD states peak FP32 Throughput (Single Precision) as 17.83 Teraflops of Compute Performance. It is not optimised for FP64 (Double Precision). With six Mini DisplayPort outputs it can drive up to six displays at 5K resolution or up to two displays at 8K resolution. The board itself is full height, double slot, with a peak power of 250W. It requires a 6-pin and an 8-pin power connector and should fit most mid-sized tower chassis. The AMD Radeon Pro W6800 is a PCIe 4.0 graphics card. While it is fully compatible with older PCIe 3.0 workstations, it’s designed to work

to the GPU’s onboard memory. AMD says it unlocks higher performance for ‘key professional workloads’ but did not elaborate further. The Radeon Pro W6800 also includes 128 MB of AMD Infinity Cache, a ‘lastlevel’ data cache integrated on the GPU die designed to reduce latency and power consumption.

The Radeon Pro W6800 on test We put the AMD Radeon Pro W6800 through a series of real-world application

Lumion 11.5 (DirectX 12 - rendering)

Architectural house

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

9.90

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

18.40 11.60 16.53

22.30

8K (7,680 x 3,840 resolution)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

510 294 390 280

Nvidia RTX A5000

212 0

Render time (secs) (smaller is better)

1.23

100

200

300

Lumion 11.5 (DirectX 12 - real time)

Lumion 11.5 (DirectX 12 - rendering)

Colossal building (28 GB)

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

2.30

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

6.80

2.20

Nvidia RTX A4000

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Render time (secs) (smaller is better)

1,283

1,243 673

Nvidia RTX A5000 5

600

218

Nvidia RTX A4000

3.40 1

1.23

500

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 3.10

Nvidia RTX A5000

8K (7,680 x 3,840 resolution)

400

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

WS20_21_22_23_24_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RadeonPro.indd 21

Over the past few years Unreal Engine has established itself as a very prominent tool for design viz, especially in architecture and automotive. It was one of the first applications to use GPU-accelerated real-time ray tracing, which it does through Microsoft DirectX Ray tracing (DXR). It means the AMD Radeon Pro W6800 is fully compatible. For testing, we used two datasets, both freely available from Epic Games: an arch viz interior of a small apartment and the Automotive Configurator, which features an Audi A5 convertible. Both scenes were tested with ray tracing enabled (DirectX Ray tracing (DXR)) and without (DirectX 12 rasterisation). The Radeon Pro W6800 did well with DirectX 12 rasterisation, showing a vast improvement over the Radeon Pro

Lumion 11.5 (DirectX 12 - real time) 4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

www.develop3d.com

benchmarks, for GPU rendering, real-time visualisation and 3D CAD. All tests were carried out using the AMD Ryzen 5000-based Scan 3XS GWPME A132R workstation (see page WS14 for a full review). Resolution was set to 4K (3,840 x 2,160) and we used AMD’s enterprise 21.Q1 graphics driver. For comparison, we used AMD’s previous generation ‘RDNA’ workstation GPU, the AMD Radeon Pro W5700 (8 GB), plus Nvidia’s brand new ‘Ampere’ workstation GPUs, the Nvidia RTX A4000 (16 GB) and Nvidia RTX A5000 (24 GB), which we review on page WS28.

520 0

300

August / September 2021

600

900

1200

1500

WS21

12/08/2021 14:50

workstation special report

W5700, and sitting somewhere between the RTX A4000 and RTX A5000. With real-time ray tracing enabled, however, it fell notably behind both Nvidia GPUs. Without hardware ray tracing built-in, the Radeon Pro W5700 pretty much ground to a halt.

especially in real-time 3D where it was very hard to navigate the scene. With the smaller scene, however, the Nvidia RTX A5000 demonstrated a clear lead over the Radeon Pro W6800 and the RTX A4000 also stood up well, edging out the Radeon Pro W6800 when rendering.

Autodesk VRED Professional 2022

Autodesk VRED Professional is an automotive-focused 3D visualisation, virtual prototyping and VR tool. It uses OpenGL and delivers very high-quality visuals in the viewport. It offers several levels of real-time anti-aliasing (AA), which is important for automotive styling, Lumion 11.5 Enscape 3.0 as it smooths the edges of body panels. Lumion is a real-time rendering tool Enscape is a real-time viz and VR tool for However, AA calculations use a lot of GPU popular with architects. The 11.5 release architects that delivers very high-quality resources, both in terms of processing and uses DirectX 12 rasterisation. It does not graphics in the viewport. The software memory. We tested our automotive model currently support hardware-based ray has used elements of ray tracing for some with AA set to ‘off’ and ‘ultra-high’. tracing. time and version 3.0 is RTX-enabled, so As we have seen previously with AMD The software can work with 8K textures hardware ray tracing is supported on GPUs, the AMD Radeon Pro W6800 did and has a vast object library including Nvidia RTX GPUs. Later versions will OK with anti-aliasing set to off, but was trees with leaves that move still significantly behind in the wind, all of which the RTX A5000. With antican place huge demands aliasing enabled, however, The AMD Radeon Pro W6800 stands out on GPU processing and performance dropped memory. considerably, with even from the competition due to its substantial We tested the GPUs in the RTX A4000 taking a 32 GB of memory, surpassed only by the two ways: one measuring Nvidia RTX A6000 which costs twice as much substantial lead. real-time 3D performance Solidworks Visualize 2021 in terms of Frame Per The name of this GPUSecond (FPS) and two, recording the time it takes to render an use the more modern Vulkan API and accelerated physically-based renderer is a support ray tracing on both Nvidia and bit misleading as it works with many more 8K scene. applications than the CAD application of Lumion supplied us with two datasets: AMD GPUs. For our tests, we used a large scene of the same name. It can import models from a standard architectural house with surrounding vegetation, which will fit a building complex and its surrounding PTC Creo, Solid Edge, Catia and Inventor, into 8 GB of GPU memory; and a colossal area in Enscape 3.0 (non RTX). At 9.5 GB, as well as several neutral formats. The software was initially programmed building model which needs 28 GB, more the GPU memory requirements of this than the capacity of the Nvidia RTX model are relatively high, but Enscape to work with Nvidia Iray and, more recently, Nvidia RTX. However, in the A4000 (16 GB) and RTX A5000 (24 GB). models can be much larger. In terms of performance, the Radeon 2020 release, AMD Radeon ProRender It came as no surprise that the AMD Radeon Pro W6800 came out top when Pro W6800 delivered a very smooth was added, so users now have a choice testing the 28 GB model as it was the only experience at 29 FPS, more than double of two rendering engines. Both support GPU able to load the entire dataset into that of the Radeon Pro W5700. It edged denoising, a post-processing technique memory. The Nvidia RTX A4000 (16 GB) out the Nvidia RTX A4000 but was a bit that filters out noise from unfinished / noisy images and means you can get better and RTX A5000 (24 GB) really struggled, behind the Nvidia RTX A5000.

‘‘

’’

Unreal Engine 4.26 (DirectX 12 - rasterisation)

Unreal Engine 4.26 (DirectX 12 - DXR)

Audi car configurator model (ray tracing disabled)

Audi car configurator model (ray tracing enabled)

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

N/A

AMD Radeon Pro W6800 Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

1.23

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

8.38

Nvidia RTX A4000 33.00

9.40

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 24.61

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

13.44

Nvidia RTX A5000 0

19.02 10

Unreal Engine 4.26 (DirectX 12 - rasterisation)

Unreal Engine 4.26 (DirectX 12 - DXR)

Arch Viz interior model (ray tracing disabled)

Arch Viz interior model (ray tracing enabled)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

24.30

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

46.30 26.89 39.40

1.23

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

5.30

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

5.21

Nvidia RTX A4000 51.15

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700 N/A

WS20_21_22_23_24_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RadeonPro.indd 22

28.83 16.98

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

August / September 2021

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700 N/A

WS22

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

1.23

8.04

Nvidia RTX A5000 0

11.30 6

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:50

workstation special report

looking renders with significantly fewer rendering passes. We tested both AMD and Nvidia GPUs with Radeon ProRender using the PC model from the SPECapc for Solidworks 2021 benchmark. We rendered at 1,500 x 1,500 resolution with 1,000 passes (denoising disabled) and 100 passes (denoising enabled) with accurate quality. Both settings produced excellent visual results. With denoising enabled, there was little between the Radeon Pro W6800, and Nvidia’s Ampere GPUs, but the RTX A5000 had a bigger lead with denoising disabled.

With six Mini DisplayPort outputs the W6800 can drive up to six displays at 5K resolution or up to two displays at 8K

Solidworks 2021 While most CAD applications won’t benefit from any GPU more powerful that the Nvidia Quadro P2200 or AMD Radeon Pro W5500, Solidworks 2021 is an exception. By using OpenGL 4.5, a more modern version of the popular graphics API, more algorithms can be pushed onto the GPU so there is a benefit to higher performance cards. Even so, the application is still CPU limited to some extent, so the performance benefit of more powerful GPUs isn’t as big as you’d expect from a dedicated real-time viz tool. Like most CAD tools, the most popular way to view models in Solidworks is in shaded with edges mode. Using the SPECapc for SolidWorks 2021 benchmark we saw a small improvement over the Radeon Pro W5700, although the Radeon Pro W6800 was behind both Nvidia GPUs. Solidworks also features more realistic display styles for viewing models in real

With a peak power of 250W, the W6800 requires a 6-pin and an 8-pin power connector

Enscape 3.0 (OpenGL)

Autodesk VRED Professional 2022 (OpenGL)

Large building complex

Automotive model (No Anti Aliasing)

Automotive model (Anti Aliasing - Ultra-high)

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 Inconsistent results Nvidia RTX A4000

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

36 20

30.65

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

30.88

5.45

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 48.80

3.30

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

51.85

7.30

Nvidia RTX A4000 63.30

12.25

Nvidia RTX A5000

VRMark - Cyan Room DirectX 12

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

1.23

49.65

Nvidia RTX A4000

Nvidia RTX A5000

99.77 57.7

182.43

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

351.17 173.69

Nvidia RTX A4000 98.25 100

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 75.1

15.98 10

AMD Radeon Pro W5700

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

1.23

DirectX 11

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

WS20_21_22_23_24_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RadeonPro.indd 23

Frames Per Second (FPS) (bigger is better)

VRMark - Blue Room 1.23

www.develop3d.com

1.23

AMD Radeon Pro W6800

Nvidia RTX A5000 0

4K (3,840 x 2,160 resolution)

238.4

Nvidia RTX A5000 0

100

August / September 2021

150

323.43 200

250

300

350

400

WS23

12/08/2021 14:50

workstation special report

Arch viz studio Beehive pushed the W6800 to its limits in Lumion on ‘Aedas City’, a visualisation project that features six of the international architecture firm’s building designs. It uses 28 GB (yes, 28 GB) of GPU memory

time. Solidworks RealView, which is only Nvidia RTX A6000 which costs twice as competition from Nvidia. The 16 GB supported by pro GPUs, adds realistic much. But you have to take design viz very Nvidia RTX A4000, for example, materials and supports environment seriously to need such a huge amount. generally offers a little less performance reflections and floor shadows. Meanwhile, Architectural visualisation studio than the Radeon Pro W6800 but costs ambient occlusion adds more realistic Beehive certainly does. It pushed the half as much. Meanwhile, the 24 GB shadows and helps bring out details. W6800 to its limits in Lumion, while Nvidia RTX A5000 offers parity on Both viewing styles are more GPU- working on ‘Aedas City’, a visualisation price, but has a clear performance lead intensive, so performance is less limited project that features six of the international in some workflows and better software by the frequency of the CPU. In our architecture firm’s building designs. compatibility. One can’t help but wonder tests, we saw a bigger benefit to the more And because the project could be held if AMD has missed a trick by not pricing powerful GPUs when RealView, shadows entirely within GPU memory, it managed the Radeon Pro W6800 more aggressively and ambient occlusion were enabled. to massively reduce render times for a 891 to make it more competitive in workflows We were unable to test where large memory capacity the Nvidia RTX A5000 as is less important. Or perhaps Solidworks 2021 Service there’s room for a Radeon Pro There is a strong workflow argument for Pack 3 did not recognise the W6700? card. We expect this to be Nvidia also appears to have having so much memory on a GPU, by not fixed in SP4, out soon. a clear lead in DXR hardware having to worry so much about optimising ray tracing, although this geometry or textures VRMark is perhaps to be expected. We also tested with VRMark, AMD’s ray accelerators are a dedicated Virtual Reality ‘first generation’ and there is benchmark that uses both DirectX 11 and frame video – from 36 hours and 11 mins also scope for driver improvements. DirectX 12. It’s biased towards 3D games, (with the 24 GB Nvidia Quadro RTX 6000 AMD is innovating in other areas, so not perfect for our needs, but should GPU) to 9 hours and 27 mins (with the however. The Radeon Pro Viewport give a good indication of the performance Radeon Pro W6800). Boost, for example, is an exciting one might expect in ‘game engine’ viz There are big benefits for projects like feature that takes a smarter approach to tools, although all datasets are different. this but this is an extreme example. Most how precious GPU resources are The Radeon Pro W6800 came out top design-centric visualisation workflows allocated. And this is certainly one to in the ‘Cyan room’ test which measures require significantly less GPU memory, watch for the future. DirectX 12 performance. AMD itself has although with ever increasing demands We also wait with interest to see how highlighted how its ‘RDNA 2’ architecture for realism and resolution, this will the new 8 GB AMD Radeon Pro W6600 performs well in DirectX 12 applications. likely change in the future. There is also a shapes up, which launched just as we strong workflow argument for more GPU went to press. At $649 it should hit the The verdict memory, by not having to worry so much sweet spot for CAD users who also want a The Radeon Pro W6800 stands out from about optimising geometry or textures. real-time 3D, ray tracing or VR capability. the competition due to its substantial For now, in more mainstream viz We will have a full review in the next 32 GB of memory, surpassed only by the workflows, AMD faces very stiff edition of DEVELOP3D Magazine.

‘‘

’’

WS24

August / September 2021

WS20_21_22_23_24_D3D_AUGSEPT21_RadeonPro.indd 24

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:50

Now is the time to invest in VDI or Cloud based Workstations. Support your remote workers with the best performance.

Implementing a VDI (Virtual Desktop Infrastructure) solution, will enable your firm to centralise resources, reduce operating and management costs and empower and enable employees to work and collaborate more productively from anywhere, while improving the security and control that your business demands.

On Premise VDI

Private Cloud Desktops

Microsoft Azure

The most cost-eﬀective solution — All the benefits of VDI, utilising Citrix or Vmware, you buy the servers and host them, we deploy it and support you.

IMSCAD provision physical servers with your Applications and Workflows in mind, built to service your specific needs, hosted in our Cloud. Fully Managed service.

Azure Virtual Desktops, Provisioning of Desktop Disaster Recovery – If the worst happened you can fail over to Azure to run all your users in The Cloud.

Benefit from IMSCAD’s experience of deploying 100’s of successful virtual desktop solutions globally. Come and talk to the experts…

Try a VDI solution for free contact@imscadglobal.com | www.imscadglobal.com

IMSCAD Print Ad July 2021 2.indd 1

10/07/2021 11:45

workstation special report

AMD Radeon Pro Viewport Boost In recent years AMD has allocated significant resources to the development of its Radeon Pro graphics drivers. The new 21.Q2 release promises to increase 3D performance by dynamically reducing viewport resolution, and without impacting the visual experience. Radeon Pro Viewport Boost works with any AMD Radeon Pro GPU but Greg Corke tests it out with the new Radeon Pro W6800 tinyurl.com/viewport-boost

t the beginning of June AMD launched the AMD Radeon Pro W6800, a monster 32 GB professional GPU, which we review in-depth on page WS20. Such a huge amount of on-board memory certainly makes the W6800 stand out from other GPUs in its class. However, the ‘RDNA 2’ workstation card also features a new pro graphics driver feature called Radeon Pro Viewport Boost, which is designed to reduce latency and boost viewport navigation performance. The idea behind the technology is simple but smart. It detects when a 3D model is moving quickly in the viewport, then dynamically drops the resolution to reduce the number of pixels the GPU needs to process. Then, as soon as that movement stops, it restores the full pixel count. According to AMD, this can increase Frames Per Second (FPS) dramatically without impacting the visual experience. AMD Radeon Pro Viewport Boost currently works with Autodesk Revit 2021, Autodesk 3ds Max 2021, Twinmotion and Unreal Engine 4 (for packaged DirectX 11 projects only – not currently DirectX 12 or Unreal Engine Editor). Support for other applications is coming soon. It works best in GPU limited workflows. i.e. those where the GPU is being pushed to its limits and is the bottleneck in the workstation. And, with this in mind, it should deliver the biggest benefits at higher resolutions (4K and above), with larger models and when visual quality settings are maxed out.

Testing Radeon Pro Viewport Boost Radeon Pro Viewport Boost is enabled in the AMD Radeon Pro 21.Q2 driver under graphics settings. Users have control over the minimum dynamic resolution that WS26

August / September 2021

WS26_27_D3D_AUGSEPT21_ViewportBoost.indd 26

the application viewport will drop down With this in mind, the benefits of to, expressed as a percentage of its native Radeon Pro Viewport Boost in CAD or resolution. It can be set between 50% and BIM applications like Autodesk Revit are 83.3%. The lower the value, the bigger the less clear. potential performance boost. In Revit, the most popular way to view To show the extent to which it is BIM models is in ‘shaded’ mode. However, working at any given moment, one to with this display style enabled we saw no four small green dots appear in the top benefit to Radeon Pro Viewport Boost. As left corner of the viewport – one being the with many CAD and BIM tools, the GPU least, four being the most. simply isn’t stressed enough, so the CPU The smart thing about Radeon Pro becomes the bottleneck instead. Viewport Boost is that it only works when It’s only when you start ramping up the model is in fast motion, when the eye is the quality settings that more demands less sensitive to a loss of visual detail. are placed on the GPU and Radeon Pro In both of our Unreal Engine arch viz Viewport Boost can come into effect. interior scenes, for example, it only kicked And while the performance increases in when ‘running’ (shift, up arrow) and not can be large, we only found a few select when ‘walking’ (up arrow only). At 50%, scenarios where a substantial benefit the drop in resolution is clearly visible could be seen. but only really when you actively look out We tested with four relatively small for it. At 83.3% it was very hard to see any Revit models and found that if the difference. following criteria were met — realistic When modelling in Revit or 3ds max, display style, smooth lines with antilines become more pixelated. But with aliasing, transparency enabled, and the speed with which one tends to pan, viewport set to perspective mode — then rotate, or zoom-in, to quickly shift focus to there was a huge performance gain; a different part of the model, it’s really not almost double the Frames Per Second. detrimental to the overall experience. But without all of those enabled — We tested on a fairly standard 4K especially with the viewport set to (3,840 x 2,160 resolution) 60Hz IPS orthographic — the performance gains panel. There may be a bigger discernible were minimal, or there were none at all. difference on higher spec We would be interested displays. to learn how the system The performanceworks with significantly It’s good to see benefits can be huge. larger models. AMD innovating In Unreal Engine 4.26, It’s also worth pointing testing with a Paris out here that most CAD by taking a interior scene from and BIM applications smarter approach already have a built-in arch viz artist Benoit to how GPU Derau (benoitdereau.com) feature to help improve resources are we saw frame rates viewport performance more than double when working with large allocated. Why (116%) when minimum models. In Revit, for bother rendering resolution was set to example, the ‘simplify pixels that most 50%. In Unreal Engine’s display during view freely available Arch viz feature people won’t even navigation’ interior scene packaged (which is switched on notice when as a DirectX11 project it by default) suspends models are moving certain graphics effects increased by 59%. at speed? In Twinmotion the and temporarily removes boost was around 30% some objects when the with the ‘materials room’ model is in motion. demo scene when visual settings were set Radeon Pro Viewport Boost gives the to ‘ultra’. In 3ds max we saw around a 20% best performance boost when this feature improvement with AMD’s ‘snow bike’ is enabled, so you are getting a lower res model with high anti-aliasing and “High representation of a model that has already Quality” shading. been simplified. Of course, Revit like many CAD and What about CAD/BIM? BIM applications, is renowned for being For design viz applications like Unreal CPU limited so it’s hardly surprising we Engine and Twinmotion having the found reduced benefits for Radeon Pro highest quality graphics is always the Viewport Boost. This is especially true for ultimate goal. However, in 3D CAD and a high-end graphics card like the Radeon BIM modelling workflows it’s usually less Pro W6800, which is complete overkill important, with the focus instead on the for Revit. clear representation of geometry. In CAD applications that make better

‘‘

’’

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 14:53

workstation special report

use of the GPU, such as Solidworks 2021, AMD Radeon Pro Viewport Boost could have a bigger impact in a broader set of viewing styles. It’s also important to note that CAD applications are changing, with new graphics engines that use modern APIs like Vulkan to push more processing onto the GPU and reduce the CPU bottleneck. This includes future versions of Solidworks (Project Romulan tinyurl.com/SW-graphics) and Autodesk Revit (and other Autodesk applications) which will use the new One Graphics System (see page WS32).

With Radeon Pro Viewport Boost enabled and min resolution set to 50% some pixelation is noticeable on this wall painting when ‘running’ in this Unreal Engine scene. The four green dots (top left) show that Viewport Boost is in full effect

What we think It’s good to see AMD innovating by taking a smarter approach to how GPU resources are allocated. Why bother rendering pixels that most people won’t even notice when models are moving at speed? From our tests we see a clear benefit for design visualisation, where applications almost always push the GPU to its limits and visual quality is of paramount importance. We’re less convinced with the broader advantages for CAD and BIM software. In Revit, for example, it appears you have to use a fairly specific combination of visual settings in order to benefit. And, in a workflow where the clear representation of geometry is usually the priority, one would also question how many people actually view models that way. At the moment, application support is quite limited, but this will grow. We imagine AMD is working on support for Unreal Engine Editor as well as DirectX 12, which should be a big attraction for viz artists, especially those working with huge datasets that approach the substantial 32 GB memory limit of the Radeon Pro W6800. When AMD first announced Viewport Boost it was exclusive to the Radeon Pro W6800 and W6600 GPUs. AMD has now confirmed that it will be expanding support to prior generation Radeon Pro GPUs as well. So, for those that already own an AMD Radeon Pro GPU, this could be a great way to get more out of your investment. And it’s perhaps with less powerful GPUs like these, that users will get the biggest benefits. In all of our tests we experienced pretty good viewport performance (most well above 20 FPS) even with Viewport Boost disabled. But it’s when frame rates drop lower, and viewports become choppy, that any performance increase can make a huge difference to practical workflows and become far more important than numbers on charts. www.develop3d.com

WS26_27_D3D_AUGSEPT21_ViewportBoost.indd 27

As soon as you stop ‘running’ the four green dots disappear and the full resolution image is instantly restored

In 3ds Max, with Radeon Pro Viewport Boost enabled and min resolution set to 50%, there is little difference between the moving image (left) and the static image (below) although the lettering on the bike is not as sharp

August / September 2021

WS27

12/08/2021 14:53

workstation special report

Nvidia RTX A4000 / A5000 Nvidia’s new Ampere-based pro GPUs, the Nvidia RTX A4000 and RTX A5000, offer a big step up from the Turing-based Quadro RTX family. With more memory and significantly enhanced processing, they promise to make light work of demanding realtime ray tracing, GPU rendering and VR workflows, writes Greg Corke Price $1,000 (A4000) / $2,250 (A5000) nvidia.com

n February 2021 we reviewed the Nvidia RTX A6000, the first pro desktop GPU to be based on Nvidia’s ‘Ampere’ architecture. With 48 GB of memory and buckets of processing power, the dual slot 300W graphics card is designed for the most demanding visualisation workflows – think city-scale digital twins or complex product visualisations using very hi-fidelity textures, such as those captured from real-life scans. Of course, the Nvidia RTX A6000 is complete overkill for most architects or product designers who simply want a capable GPU for real-time visualisation, GPU rendering or VR. And it’s here that the new Nvidia RTX A4000 and Nvidia RTX A5000 come into play. Announced at Nvidia’s GTC event this year, the PCIe Gen 4 ‘Ampere’ Nvidia RTX A4000 and Nvidia RTX A5000 are the replacements for the PCIe Gen 3 ‘Turing’ Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 and Quadro RTX 5000, which launched in 2019. The RTX A4000 and A5000 are midrange ‘Quadro’ GPUs in everything but name. Nvidia might be retiring its longserving Quadro workstation brand, but the features remain the same. Both GPUs offer more memory than their consumer GeForce counterparts, are standard issue in workstations from Dell, HP and Lenovo, and come with pro drivers with ISV certification for a wide range of CAD/BIM applications. And with an estimated street price of $1,000 for the Nvidia RTX A4000 and $2,250 for the Nvidia RTX A5000, they have much more palatable price tags than the Nvidia RTX A6000 which costs $4,650. WS28

August / September 2021

WS28_29_30_31_AEC_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Nvidia.indd 28

Nvidia RTX A4000 (16 GB) With 16 GB of GDDR6 ECC memory, the Nvidia RTX A4000 offers a big step up from the 8 GB Quadro RTX 4000. 8 GB is fine for mainstream viz workflows but for more complex projects it can be limiting, so delivering 16 GB in a sub $1,000 pro GPU is a big step forward. Previously, 16 GB was only available on the ‘Turing’based Quadro RTX 5000. As you’d expect from Nvidia’s new ‘Ampere’ architecture, the Nvidia RTX A4000 also offers a significant improvement in processing. This can be seen in all areas of the GPU with more CUDA cores for general processing, thirdgeneration Tensor Cores for AI operations and second-generation RT Cores for hardware-based ray tracing. It leads to a substantial performance increase in many different applications (see later on). Furthermore, as the Nvidia RTX A4000 is a single slot GPU with a max power consumption of 140W delivered through a single 6-pin PCIe connector, it’s available in a wide range of desktop workstation form factors. This includes compact towers like the HP Z2 Tower G8 and Dell Precision 3650. The board features four DisplayPort 1.4a ports and can drive up to four displays at 5K resolution. It is cooled by a single ‘blower’ type fan, which draws in cool air from the top and bottom of the card, pushes it through a radiator and then directly out of the rear of the workstation chassis. This is in contrast to most consumer GeForce GPUs which use axial fans that recirculate air inside the machine. There are pros and cons to each design, but with a blower fan you can stack cards within the chassis without having to leave space between them. This means you can get a very good density of GPUs inside a mid-sized chassis. With the AMD Threadripper Pro-based Lenovo ThinkStation P620, for example, you could get four Nvidia

RTX A4000s back-to-back, which could be a very interesting proposition for GPU rendering. Even though the RTX A4000 doesn’t support NVlink (so there’s no pooling of GPU memory) 16 GB is still a good amount and two, three or four RTX A4000s could work out well in terms of price/performance compared to the more powerful RTX A5000 or A6000. Another potential use case for highdensity multi-GPU is workstation virtualisation using GPU passthrough, where each user gets a dedicated GPU. Again, this workflow looks well suited to the Lenovo ThinkStation P620, which can be configured with up to 64 CPU cores and 2 TB of memory. Other more niche pro viz features include support for 3D Stereo, Nvidia Mosaic for professional multi-display solutions, and Quadro Sync II, an addin card that can synchronise the display and image output from multiple GPUs within a single system, or across a cluster of systems.

Nvidia RTX A5000 (24 GB) With 24 GB of GDDR6 ECC memory, the Nvidia RTX A5000 offers only a 50% memory uplift compared to the Quadro RTX 5000 it replaces. Like the Nvidia RTX A4000 it offers a significant upgrade in all areas of processing — CUDA, Tensor and RT cores. It’s a double height board, with a max power consumption of 230W which it draws from the PSU via an 8-pin PCIe connector, but it’s still available in compact towers. The board also features four DisplayPort 1.4a ports and is cooled by a single ‘blower’ type fan, but only draws in cool air from one side of the card. The Nvidia RTX A5000 supports all the same features as the Nvidia RTX A4000 but differs in two main areas. One, it supports Nvidia NVLink, so GPU memory can be expanded to 48 GB by connecting two 24 GB GPUs together. Two, it supports Nvidia RTX vWS (virtual workstation software) so it can deliver multiple high-performance virtual workstation instances that enable remote users to share resources. In the AMD Threadripper Pro Lenovo ThinkStation P620, for example, which we reviewed earlier this year, you could get a very high density of CAD users who only need high-end RTX performance from time to time. www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 15:03

workstation special report

Nvidia RTX A5000 inside the AMD Ryzen 5000-based Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R workstation

Testing the new cards We put the Nvidia RTX A4000 and Nvidia RTX A5000 through a series of real-world application benchmarks, for GPU rendering, real-time visualisation and 3D CAD. All tests were carried out using the AMD Ryzen-based Scan 3XS GWP-ME A132R workstation at 4K (3,840 x 2,160) resolution using the latest 462.59 Nvidia driver (see page WS12 for a full review). For comparison, we used the last two generations of ‘4000’ class Nvidia pro GPUs – the 8 GB ‘Turing’ Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 (from 2019) and the 8 GB ‘Pascal’ Nvidia Quadro P4000 (from 2017). Three to four years is quite a typical upgrade cycle in workstations, so the intention here is to give a good idea of the performance increase one might expect from an older machine (N.B. to see all of the benchmark scores for the Nvidia Quadro P4000 visit tinyurl.com/ RTX4000). We also threw some Nvidia RTX A6000 scores in there. These were done on two different workstations with a 32-core Threadripper Pro 3970X and a quad core Intel Xeon W-2125 CPU. While both CPUs have lower frequencies and instructions per clock (IPC) the results should still give a pretty good idea of comparative performance, especially in GPU rendering software. The results of these tests can be seen in www.develop3d.com

WS28_29_30_31_AEC_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Nvidia.indd 29

the charts on page WS20 in our review of ‘real-time’. Vantage, for example, is built the AMD Radeon Pro W6800. from the ground up for real-time ray tracing so can maximise the usage of RT Hardware-based ray tracing cores within the new GPUs. It’s been just over two years since Nvidia introduced ‘Turing’ Nvidia Quadro RTX, Chaos Group V-Ray its first pro GPUs with RTX hardware ray V-Ray is one of the most popular tracing. physically based rendering tools, In a classic chicken and egg launch, there especially in architectural visualisation. were very few RTX-enabled applications We put the new cards through their paces back then, but this has now changed. For using the freely downloadable V-Ray 5 design viz, there’s Chaos V-Ray, Chaos benchmark, which has dedicated tests for Vantage, Solidworks Visualize, Autodesk Nvidia CUDA GPUs, Nvidia RTX GPUs, VRED, KeyShot Unreal Engine, Unity, as well as CPUs. Enscape, D5 render, Nvidia Omniverse, The results were impressive. In the Siemens NX Ray Traced Studio, Catia Live CUDA test, the Nvidia RTX A4000 rendering and others. was 1.62 times faster than the previous Nvidia RTX gave GPU rendering a generation Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 massive kick start and while there is and in the RTX test 1.70 times faster. The increased competition from hugely lead over the Pascal-based Quadro P4000 powerful CPUs like the 64-core AMD was nothing short of colossal – 3.53 times Threadripper [Pro], we are seeing deeper faster in the CUDA test. As the P4000 penetration of GPU rendering tools, does not have dedicated RT cores, it could especially in architect / engineer / product not run the RTX test. designer friendly workflows. Stepping up to the Nvidia RTX A5000 Nvidia RTX is being used to massively will give you an additional boost. accelerate classic viz focused ray trace Compared to the Nvidia RTX A4000 it renderers like V-Ray, KeyShot and was between 1.27 and 1.37 times faster. Solidworks Visualize, which we test later Interestingly, the RTX A5000 was not on in this article. However, some of the that far behind the RTX A6000, which more exciting developments are coming costs more than twice as much. from the Architecture, Engineering and Construction (AEC) sector in tools like Luxion Keyshot Enscape, Chaos Vantage and Unreal KeyShot, a CPU rendering stalwart, is a Engine, which really make ray tracing relative newcomer to the world of GPU August / September 2021

WS29

12/08/2021 15:03

workstation special report

rendering. But it’s one of the slickest implementations we’ve seen, allowing users to switch between CPU and GPU rendering at the click of a button. In the Keyshot 10 benchmark, part of the free KeyShot Viewer, the performance leap was even more substantial than in V-Ray. The Nvidia RTX A4000 and Nvidia RTX A5000 outperformed the Quadro RTX 4000 by a factor of 1.89 and 2.51 respectively. And the RTX A5000 was only 20% slower than the RTX A6000.

Solidworks Visualize

being able to render at such speeds is quite incredible and can have a profound impact on workflows. In comparison, it took the Quadro P4000 GPU 105 seconds, so you can see just how far things have progressed in four years.

Real time 3D While GPU rendering is a major play for the Nvidia RTX A4000 and Nvidia RTX A5000, real-time 3D using OpenGL, DirectX and (in the future) Vulkan continues to be a very important part of visualisation, with applications including Unreal Engine, Unity, TwinMotion, Lumion, Enscape, LumenRT and others. Of course, the boundaries between realtime 3D and ray tracing continue to blur. In fact, out of the list above only Lumion and Twinmotion are yet to support RTX, although it should be coming to Twinmotion soon. To test frame rates, we used a combination of monitoring software including FRAPS, Xbox Game Bar and

will still likely need the top-end Nvidia RTX A6000 especially for high-res VR workflows. In Unreal Engine we used two datasets: an arch viz interior of a small apartment and the Automotive Configurator, which features an Audi A5 convertible. Both scenes were tested with ray tracing enabled (DirectX Ray tracing (DXR)) and without (DirectX 12 rasterisation). The results were pretty much as expected with good scaling between all the GPUs with DirectX 12 rasterization. With real-time ray tracing enabled, performance naturally takes a hit in general, but the Quadro P4000 really suffers without any RT cores.

The name of this GPU-accelerated physically based renderer is a bit misleading as it works with many more applications than the CAD application of the same name. It can import models from Creo, Solid Edge, Catia and Inventor, as We also tested with VRMark, a dedicated well as several neutral formats. Virtual Reality benchmark that uses Since the 2020 release the software has DirectX 11 and DirectX 12. In the DX12 supported Nvidia RT cores and Tensor test both GPUs came in second to AMD’s cores to improve rendering performance Radeon Pro W6800 (see page WS20). with Nvidia RTX GPUs. Users can choose Computer Aided Design to render scenes with or without denoising enabled. The Nvidia RTX A4000 Denoising is a postand RTX A5000 are The performance leap from the Quadro RTX processing technique overkill for most 3D based on machine learning CAD applications and 4000 to RTX A4000 is hugely impressive, that filters out noise from are unlikely to give you and the step up from the four-year old unfinished / noisy images significantly better 3D ‘Quadro P4000 is simply phenomenal and is the foundation for performance than more many RTX-accelerated mainstream GPUs like the applications. It means Nvidia Quadro P1000 / you can get better looking renders with MSI Afterburner. We only tested at 4K P2200, or the new Nvidia T1000. significantly fewer rendering passes. (3,840 x 2,160) resolution. At FHD (1,920 x However, CAD applications are changing DS Solidworks reckons that if a scene 1,080) resolution this class of GPU simply and, in the future, should be able to make routinely needs 500 passes without the isn’t stressed enough. much better use of the plentiful power of denoiser, then you may be able to achieve higher-end GPUs like the RTX A4000 the same rendering quality with 50 passes In Autodesk VRED Professional we and A5000. with the denoiser enabled. tested our automotive model with AA set In addition, it is important to note that We tested the stock 1969 Camaro car to ‘off’ and ‘ultra-high’. both GPUs will be certified for a wide model at 4K resolution with 1,000 passes Considering that this pro viz range of pro CAD applications, which (denoising disabled) and 100 passes application used to only really run is important for some firms. This is (denoising enabled) set to accurate quality. effectively on Nvidia’s ultra-high-end especially true for enterprises that buy Both settings produced excellent visual professional GPUs, it’s quite astounding 100s or 1,000s of workstations from large results. that the Nvidia RTX A4000 – a sub OEMs like HP, Dell and Lenovo and want The RTX A4000 and RTX A5000 $1,000 card – delivered over 30 FPS at assurance that the GPUs will be stable and delivered the 100-pass render in 22 4K resolution with medium anti-aliasing. that they will be properly supported by seconds and 14 seconds respectively. In saying that, those really pushing the the software developer. This isn’t the most complex scene but boundaries of automotive visualisation Certification is a major reason why

‘‘

’’

Solidworks Visualize 2021 SP3 (Iray)

1969 Camaro car model (denoising disabled)

1969 Camaro car model (denoising enabled)

1,000 passes, accurate quality 4K (3,840 x 1,080 resolution)

1.23

Render time (secs) (smaller is better)

Nvidia Quadro P4000

100 passes, accurate quality 4K (3,840 x 1,080 resolution)

1,029

Nvidia RTX 4000

349

Nvidia RTX A4000

200

600

800

1000

1200

Nvidia Quadro P4000 1

105

14 0

100

August / September 2021

WS28_29_30_31_AEC_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Nvidia.indd 30

32.94

Nvidia RTX A4000 1

Nvidia RTX A5000 1

Nvidia RTX A6000 2

120 1

WS30

5.60

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 1

Nvidia RTX A5000 400

1.23 Relative performance to reference system (bigger is better)

Nvidia RTX A4000

140

Render time (secs) (smaller is better)

Nvidia RTX 4000

211

Nvidia RTX A5000

Nvidia Quadro P4000

1.23

Luxion KeyShot 10 benchmark (GPU)

62.34 82.60

AMD AMD Ryzen 5950X CPU (462.59 driver)

99.62 60

100

AMD Threadripper 3970X (461.09 driver)

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 15:04

workstation special report

V-Ray 5 image courtesy of Toni Bratincevic

Solidworks 2021 can make better use of powerful GPUs than most CAD applications but it is still CPU limited to some extent, so the performance benefit the new cards give you isn’t as big as you’d get from a dedicated real-time viz tool. In the SPECapc for SolidWorks 2021 benchmark we saw a small improvement, generation on generation with the shaded with edges. The Nvidia RTX A4000 was 1.10 times faster than the Quadro RTX 4000 and 1.44 times faster than the ‘Pascal’ Quadro P4000. With RealView, Shadows and Ambient Occlusion enabled we saw a bigger benefit over older GPUs. The Nvidia RTX A4000 was 1.16 times faster than the Quadro RTX 4000 and 1.57 times faster than the Quadro P4000. We were unable to test the Nvidia RTX A5000 as Solidworks 2021 SP3 did not recognise the card. We expect this to be fixed in SP4, out soon.

Conclusion With the new Nvidia RTX A4000 and A5000, Nvidia has made its ‘Ampere’ GPU architecture much more accessible to a wider audience. In particular, we see the sub $1,000 Nvidia RTX A4000 hitting the sweet spot for designers, engineers or architects that want a pro viz capability in their workflow. The performance leap from ‘Turing’ to ‘Ampere’ (Quadro RTX 4000 to RTX A4000) is hugely impressive. In realtime 3D, a 45% to 60% boost, generation on generation, seems typical, with even bigger gains from real-time ray tracing when the enhanced RT and Tensor cores come into play. The step up from the four-year old ‘Pascal’ Quadro P4000 is phenomenal, especially for rendering. Equipping the RTX A4000 with 16 GB of memory is very significant. While we often see models/scenes that surpass 8 GB (the capacity of the previous generation Quadro RTX 4000) scenes that are 16 GB and above are certainly less common, and more the preserve of viz specialists than most architects or product designers who use standard materials and assets. For viz workflows that need lots of memory, Nvidia has strong competition from the 32 GB AMD Radeon Pro W6800,

Chaos Group V-Ray 5.0 benchmark

V-Ray GPU CUDA

V-Ray GPU RTX

290

Nvidia Quadro P4000 1 634

Nvidia RTX A4000 1

Nvidia RTX A6000 2

AMD AMD Ryzen 5950X CPU (462.59 driver)

1500

AMD Threadripper 3970X (461.09 driver)

1,559

Nvidia RTX A5000 1 1,531

1000

919

2,128

Nvidia RTX A6000 2 2000 1

500

AMD AMD Ryzen 5950X CPU (462.59 driver)

1000

2,490 1500

2000

2500

AMD Threadripper 3970X (461.09 driver)

August / September 2021

WS31

www.develop3d.com

200

400

500

Nvidia RTX A4000 1 1,299

N/A

Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 1 1,025

Nvidia RTX A5000 1

For more performance data see charts on page 20 as part of the in-depth review of AMD Radeon Pro W6800 with 32 GB of on-board memory

1.23 vrays (calculations per minute) (bigger is better)

1000

Nvidia Quadro P4000 1 Nvidia Quadro RTX 4000 1

In the original edit of this article we concluded by discussing the need for Nvidia to flesh out its Ampere workstation family and bring RTX capabilities to the lower-end of the market. Then, just as DEVELOP3D was going to press, Nvidia announced the Nvidia RTX A2000 (6 GB), a $450 pro RTX GPU to replace the Pascal-based Quadro P2200. The interesting thing about the RTX A2000 is that it can be configured for both Small Form Factor (SFF) workstations and standard towers. We’re excited by what this will bring to CAD-centric workflows but wonder if it might be a little light on memory. See page 8 in the main magazine to find out more.

800

1.23 vpaths (calculations per minute) (bigger is better)

but in less demanding worflows Nvidia’s biggest competitor in pro graphics is currently itself. The new 12 GB ‘consumer’ GeForce RTX 3080 Ti, for example, might have half the memory of the Nvidia RTX A5000, but offers more performance on paper for half the price. Nvidia even has a GeForce Studio driver for applications including Enscape, Unreal Engine and V-Ray. Despite the obvious attraction of Nvidia’s consumer GPUs, Nvidia’s ‘A’ class models should continue to find favour in large firms and enterprises that buy in volume, want more memory, consistent supply, pro viz features or the assurance of certification.

600

some firms choose Nvidia’s pro-focused RTX GPUs over their ‘consumer GeForce’ counterparts so they can confidently use applications like Revit, Solidworks, PTC Creo, and Siemens NX alongside more vizfocused tools like Chaos V-Ray, Enscape, Luxion KeyShot and Solidworks Visualize.

WS28_29_30_31_AEC_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Nvidia.indd 31

12/08/2021 15:04

workstation special report

Example of ambient occlusion in Autodesk’s path traced reference application Image courtesy of Autodesk / Nvidia GTC

The Autodesk Inventor graphics boost Autodesk’s new One Graphics System (OGS) for Inventor, 3ds max and other Autodesk applications promises to improve viewport performance and visual quality through GPU ray tracing, writes Greg Corke

utodesk is working on a new graphics engine that promises to ‘radically improve’ 3D performance in its core applications, including Inventor, 3ds max, Revit and others. The ‘next-generation’ system will also improve visual quality by delivering ray tracing directly inside the viewport. The aim is to enable users to switch between a simple shaded view and a photorealistic representation very quickly – though the speed at which this can happen will depend on the graphics hardware and the complexity of the model. WS32

August / September 2021

WS32_33_34_D3D_AUGSEPT21_inventor.indd 32

The new viewport system is a complete re-architecting of the current One Graphics System (OGS), which relies solely on rasterisation, a rendering method for 3D software that takes vector data and turns it into pixels (a raster image). OGS is shared by nearly all Autodesk products, including Inventor, Revit, 3ds max, AutoCAD, Maya, Fusion, Infraworks, Navisworks and Recap. It dates back to 2007 and uses older graphics APIs including OpenGL and DirectX 9/10/11. Inventor, like many other CAD applications that use older graphics APIs, isn’t the best at harnessing the plentiful power

of modern Graphics Processing Units (GPUs). As a result, 3D performance in the software is largely bottlenecked by the frequency of the CPU. Autodesk’s ‘next generation’ viewport system should fix this, and users should get a much smoother viewport experience without having to rely on the software to temporarily simplify or discard parts of the view during model navigation by setting a minimum frame rate. By fully utilising modern graphics APIs including DirectX 12 and Vulkan, Autodesk’s applications will be able to talk straight to the GPU hardware (rather www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 10:17

workstation special report

than having to route everything through the graphics driver) and take better advantage of multi-core CPUs. The modernised OGS will also be able to use hardware-based ray tracing, which is built into modern graphics cards such as the new ‘Ampere’ Nvidia RTX A2000, A4000, A5000 or A6000 (see page WS28), or ‘RDNA 2’ AMD Radeon Pro W6600 or W6800 (see page WS20). It will utilise open standards, such as MaterialX and Pixar’s Hydra, part of USD.

Nvidia GTC showtime Autodesk’s Henrik Edstrom, senior software architect, graphics technology, and Mauricio Vives, senior principal engineer, gave a sneak peek of the ‘next-generation’ viewport system in a presentation at Nvidia’s GTC conference earlier this year. Rather than looking at performance in simple shaded views, the focus was on the eye-catching stuff — real-time ray tracing. The idea is that when working on a model in the viewport, a product designer or engineer can quickly switch to full ray traced quality at the click of a button. Inventor currently relies on CPU rendering which takes a long time and the results can be mixed. For the new engine, Vives explains that the emphasis is to provide a good real time experience, like you get with a game engine. “Photorealism is important, but we prioritise performance over quality,” he says. According to Edstrom, it will be very easy to use for non-rendering experts. “They just need a very simple solution with literally no settings,” he says. In Inventor, for example, we imagine it will be just another visual style to add to the current drop-down for wireframe, shaded, realistic, monochrome, watercolour and sketch / technical illustration.

Lights, camera, action In a demonstration of a path traced reference application, Vives showed a welding robot model that originated in Inventor. Render quality was photorealistic and looked impressive, much better than the rasterisation engine currently used in Inventor 2022. The scene was lit by a single directional light and a low frequency environment light. Vives showed off the render quality by highlighting several aspects within the scene, including contact hardening soft shadows, real ambient occlusion and glossy reflections, focusing in on the subtle reflection of a black socket on a red paint finish. www.develop3d.com

WS32_33_34_D3D_AUGSEPT21_inventor.indd 33

In order to achieve a smooth viewport experience, the frame budget was set to 30 frames per second. This resulted in some ‘noise’ when moving the camera, but the image resolved very quickly when idle by casting more rays and using denoising. The presentation then went on to show the path tracing mode of the new engine working inside in Autodesk 3ds Max, Maya and Inventor. You can watch the full presentation at tinyurl.com/ OGS-Autodesk (registration required).

But, at Autodesk University 2019, when we asked what Autodesk was doing to improve 3D performance we got a rather prickly response from CEO Andrew Anagnost. He implied this wasn’t an issue. While Autodesk would not publicly admit the current engine needed improving, we expect work on the new OGS had already started back then. Swapping out a graphics engine is a huge undertaking, especially one that covers so many diverse applications as OGS does. The emphasis is The fact is, there are Flexible architecture to provide a good many Autodesk customers To provide more flexibility that struggle with large real time for future software and performance, from experience, like model hardware developments, load times to model disyou get with a the new viewport system is play and manipulation, based on a decoupled relying on their software game engine. architecture, where the “Photorealism is to automatically simplify applications and the or turn off important, but we geometry graphic system are not as effects during view navigaprioritise intertwined as they are in tion in order to maintain the current OGS. This is performance over frame rates. being done through Hydra, Everyone wants more quality,” says part of Pixar’s USD. 3D performance, and we Mauricio Vives, expect many will be excit“That will allow us to senior principal ed by this news. Even make changes and improve OGS and add more so, if they can get this engineer, support for new features without having to upgrade Autodesk and new APIs and new GPU hardware. According hardware and so on, withto Vives, basically any out really involving the GPU, up to five years old application teams too much,” explains from any vendor, will support the modEdstrom. “It also gives us the flexibility ernised OGS. to plug in other renderers, like Arnold, The addition of real-time ray tracing in for instance, that already supports the the viewport is also a very exciting develHydra render delegate API, or some- opment. Rather than relying on slow thing like the Nvidia Omniverse RTX CPU ray tracing on typical 4, 6 or 8 core renderer which also supports this API… workstations, it will help bring visualisand there are numerous others as well.” ation more upfront in the design process The system currently uses DirectX – not just for presentations but to better Raytracing (DXR), but Autodesk is also planning to use the recently released Vulkan Ray tracing extensions.

‘‘

’’

Conclusion In DEVELOP3D’s workstation tests over the years we’ve experienced first-hand how applications like Inventor and Revit can be very CPU limited when it comes to 3D graphics and unable to take advantage of the huge processing potential of modern GPUs.

Autodesk’s new One Graphics System (OGS) will be able to take advantage of new generation GPUs like the AMD Radeon Pro W6600 which include hardware-based ray tracing

August / September 2021

WS33

12/08/2021 10:17

workstation special report

1 Example of glossy reflections in Autodesk’s path traced reference application 2 Example of soft shadows in Autodesk’s path traced reference application Images courtesy of Autodesk / Nvidia GTC

understand complex forms through more realistic shading or to explore materials and the impact of light. Those looking to take advantage of realtime ray tracing, however, will need to invest in a GPU with built in hardware ray tracing. Currently, this would be an Nvidia RTX GPU (see page WS28) or the latest AMD Radeon Pro GPUs (see page WS20) or Intel GPUs in the future. So when can we expect to see this new engine inside shipping Autodesk products? In short, it’s too early to tell. In the presentation it was described as a ‘very early work in progress’ and there were no promises as to what will or will not be supported in Autodesk’s products. But this is a standard line for a publicly traded company. The fact that Autodesk is showing this in public now perhaps shows promise for its 2023 or 2024 series of products. While it’s good to see Autodesk actively looking to improve the 3D graphics expe-

Enhanced graphics for Solidworks

Autodesk is not the only company embracing modern graphics APIs. In February, Dassault Systèmes demonstrated Project Romulan, a new Vulkan-based graphics engine for Solidworks, designed to bring enhanced visual fidelity, GPU-accelerated ray tracing, and better performance for large assemblies to the 3D CAD tool’s viewport.

rience across the board, it’s long overdue and, with rise of powerful real-time engines like Unreal Engine, designers now expect a fast and visually rich viewport in CAD tools like Inventor and Revit.

We’re excited to see how this develops, although that same enthusiasm might not be shared by firms that already have optimised visualisation workflows. ■ tinyurl.com/OGS-Autodesk

Ray tracing and denoising are used to calculate ‘accurate ambient occlusions’ with the resulting soft shadows (see below) overlaid on top of the model

■ tinyurl.com/

SW-graphics

WS34

August / September 2021

WS32_33_34_D3D_AUGSEPT21_inventor.indd 34

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 10:17

ROM F

F L HE OS HT C T KE S I D E A T I ON

A R T U O G I R F S N CO

T I O A N R O L P X &E

P R O D U CT

HOT S Y HKE T WI

O N EC L I C TT O H OV S Y E R KK

L I DF 3

CO MMU T N O N AI I C

EI MP O T R

KEY

L UA S I V

SH OT NT RI T P O3 DP

SeehowKeyShoti sus edt ovi s ual i z eyourdes i gn t hr oughoutt hepr oductdev el opmentl i f ecycl e. Ke y S h o t . c o m/E n v o y VI EWI N YOURHOME!

Workstations for Media & Entertainment Workflows 3XS GWP-ME A124C Mini

3XS GWP-ME A132R

• AMD Ryzen 9 5900X • 32GB DDR4 • 16GB NVIDIA A4000 • 1TB M.2 • Microsoft Windows 10 Pro

• AMD Ryzen 9 5950X • 64GB DDR4 • 16GB NVIDIA RTX A4000 • 2TB M.2 SSD • Microsoft Windows 10 Pro

• AMD Ryzen 9 5950X • 64GB DDR4 • 24GB NVIDIA RTX A5000 • 2TB M.2 SSD & 2TB HDD • Microsoft Windows 10 Pro

From

£2,399.99

INC VAT

£3,399.99

INC VAT

£4,299.99 INC VAT

3XS GWP-ME A132R

3XS GWP-ME A1-48T

3XS GWP-ME A264T

• AMD Ryzen 9 5950X • 64GB DDR4 • 48GB NVIDIA RTX A6000 • 2TB M.2 SSD & 2TB HDD • Microsoft Windows 10 Pro

• AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3960X • 128GB DDR4 • 48GB NVIDIA A6000 • 2TB M.2 & 4TB SSD • Microsoft Windows 10 Pro

• AMD Threadripper 3970X • 128GB DDR4 • 2x 48GB NVIDIA RTX A6000 • 2TB M.2 & 2TB HDD • Microsoft Windows 10 Pro

From

£6,799.99 INC VAT

£7,999.99 INC VAT

Discover your perfect workstation at

scan.co.uk/m&e • 01204 47 47 47

From

£13,499.99 INC VAT

workstation special report

Hybrid working what does it mean for design firms? With many firms re-evaluating office space and working from home policies, we asked Adam Jull of IMSCAD about the role that virtual workstations can play – and the differences between VDI, public and private cloud

he pandemic has shifted the way we all work. As the dust settles and we try to get back to some sort of normality, a hybrid work model seems to be the favoured approach of employers and employees alike. But what does this really mean for design firms who have historically invested a lot in their offices / studios to provide great spaces for client facing and for collaboration amongst staff? The nature of hybrid work means that staff will be in the office less and split their time between the office and home – or a remote location that is not the traditional office. As a result, less office space is required, but will this translate into firms reducing their office footprint, which could save considerable cost, or will it

Learning by example VDI and private cloud

Parkhill, a US architect and engineering firm with nine offices spread across Texas, Oklahoma and New Mexico, has deployed a successful VDI solution that gives 400+ creative professionals the freedom to work anywhere, on any device using all of their applications including the Autodesk suite. Parkhill invested in an on-premise solution, with 16 servers running 430 desktops using

www.develop3d.com

WS37_38_D3D_AUGSEPT21_IMSCAD.indd 37

‘‘

As we start to come out the other side of the pandemic, and attitudes to the traditional office continue to change, firms are looking for more robust IT solutions to support flexible working

’’

lead to firms changing the way they use their existing office space? The answer is both. Those firms that can downsize now, surely will. However, those that cannot (perhaps they have a longer lease they cannot get out of) will still likely change the way they use their existing space. In both cases, it is likely that fewer desks will be needed, staff will be hot desking, and more collaboration and meeting spaces will be required. With staff working from home for two or three days a week, firms need to ensure they invest in the right remote graphics technology solutions so everyone can work from anywhere productively.

specific applications that require a lot of resource so they can be used to their full potential. Investing in the right technology to facilitate this move to hybrid working is paramount. VDI (Virtual Desktop Infrastructure) is a proven solution for giving design users the performance they require when working remotely. VDI technology enables you to deliver desktops via virtual machines (VMs) and the desktops are managed from a central server. There are several ways for firms to deliver these virtual desktops to their users. On-premise or on-prem VDI is deployed on your own infrastructure. This could be one server in your office or a private data centre, where you are responsible for the infrastructure and everything associated with it. A real positive of this sort of solution is that the servers can be provisioned to suit your use case, your specific application-mix and the individual user workloads. Private cloud or hosted VDI is when virtual desktops are outsourced. They The tech options are deployed and hosted in a hosting In the manufacturing company’s datacentre, on bare metal space, the majority of servers, and the hosting company is designers use industry- responsible for the infrastructure. Like the

Citrix. In light of the pandemic, Parkhill will tell you it has gained an advantage over its peers from a mobility standpoint and an IT management perspective. The solution has come into its own during the pandemic, with nearly all staff working from home and now working two or three days a week away from the office. On a smaller scale is a UK-based manufacturing firm that

was looking to minimise future disruption on productivity, in terms of hours and days lost with users not being able to work to their full potential when they could not access the office during the pandemic. The firm needed a solution to enable remote work for 50+ design users and chose a private cloud solution. The solution included three servers, two of which include two GPUs,

providing desktops to 20 users each and the third, one GPU providing desktops for the further 12 users. Another example of a successful on-premise VDI solution is that of HUNT EAS, a New York-based engineering, architectural and surveying firm. Hunt had an existing Virtual desktop solution in place, but the solution had never performed, and the company was looking to upgrade from

August / September 2021

the existing four server environment providing desktops for 65 users to one providing desktops to 90+ users. The new environment consists of five servers and provides all users great performance running AutoCAD, Autodesk Revit and other applications. It has proved invaluable over the last year through the pandemic as well as when major snowfall affected New York last winter.

WS37

12/08/2021 15:00

workstation special report

on-premise solution, firms get the same benefits of provisioning infrastructure to match their use cases, applications and workflows with the extra advantage of not having to buy or manage the hardware. Hyperscale or Public Cloud Desktopse.g. Microsoft Azure, AWS, Google Cloud. This is where a firm pays for ‘instances’ of virtual desktops. While spinning up a new instance is easy, a VDI solution on the public cloud still requires extra underlying infrastructure and integration components to work. From the architecture and networking to the security, the customer is responsible for everything they build in the public cloud.

(Capital Expenditure) required as the infrastructure needs to be purchased, racked and set up before you can start provisioning the desktops. Once fully functioning, the cost are minimal - yearly licence renewals and support. With a private or hosted cloud solution, there will be an upfront fee to set up and then a monthly cost, keeping CapEx to a minimum and enabling a more manageable OpEx (Operational Expenditure) model. When looking at a Public Cloud VDI solution there are no upfront costs - you just pay for the instances. However, you will need to add additional products and components to your virtual What are the benefits? infrastructure, from domain controllers The benefits of these types of solutions are to VMs and each comes with an associated many - most importantly furnishing your cost on top of the cost of each instance. users with the performance they require when working both in the office and at One step at a time home - or anywhere else for that matter. Not all firms move to VDI in one go. Historically, users have been reluctant Some firms continue to utilise their to give up their physical workstations physical workstations and often use the as they have worried about not getting VDI solution to facilitate remote work. the same performance when using other Often they will sweat the workstation technologies. until end of life, by which time the user This was highlighted for many as they is accustomed to working on a virtual tried to work from home on hastily put desktop and the change to doing so full together remote work solutions that did not time is not so dramatic. give the performance they required when Another facet to this is those firms they suddenly had to vacate the office. that are starting small, providing a VDI Your IP is obviously very important and solution for a single team or for a specific security is another great benefit of this type project - in essence using this as a pilot. of solution. Some firms will actually invest in a single With all data being stored centrally, server either on-premise or a private no data leaves the infrastructure. With cloud, specifically as a pilot project and applications also kept centrally on the get users from all over the firm to test. Both servers, all patches, upgrades and fixes are sensible approaches. can be managed centrally as a single There are also firms employing a hybrid instance and the management of users, approach, as it is a big ask to migrate to the their access to applications and data is cloud in one single leap. You also need to also centrally controlled by IT which factor in that public cloud providers might will result in a reduction in IT not be the most cost effective for the types management costs. of applications and workloads that design With users not relying on their physical and engineering firms are using. workstations and not having to be at their desks, firms are far more resilient to any Closing thoughts interruptions. In addition to obvious When the Covid-19 pandemic first hit, pandemics, this could be due to bad many manufacturing firms had to quickly weather stopping travel or a fire at the adapt existing IT to allow designers and office. With a virtual desktop solution engineers to work effectively from home. there is a built-in business continuity Data centralisation was key, so remoting capability, meaning users can remain into office workstations quickly became a working and therefore productive no temporary fix for some. matter what happens. Now as we start to come out the other side, and attitudes to the traditional What are the real costs? office continue to change, firms are Cost is obviously a major factor in looking for more robust IT solutions to determining the solution that you will go support flexible working. And proven with, and the costs associated with each of technologies like VDI present a huge these deployment methods will vary. opportunity for those looking to fully When looking at an on-premise embrace a truly hybrid future. solution, there is a large CapEx ■ imscadglobal.com WS38

August / September 2021

WS37_38_D3D_AUGSEPT21_IMSCAD.indd 38

DEVELOP3D’s cloud workstation roundup Amazon Web Services (AWS) offers two cloud workstations; G4dn uses Intel CPUs and Nvidia GPUs while G4ad features AMD CPUs/GPUs. AWS uses the latest AMD Radeon Pro GPUs but doesn’t offer the same flexibility as Microsoft in terms of how GPU resources can be allocated. BOXX has a different take to other cloud workstation providers insofar as it takes its high-performance desktop workstations and makes them available to users of CAD and demanding viz applications over a 1:1 connection. The service is currently focused on the US, but is coming to the UK soon. Cloudalize has lots of experience of 3D CAD and BIM applications. It offers a ‘pay-per-use’ or an ‘unlimited-usage’ subscription model and a big choice of cloud workstations out of its private datacentres Google offers a big choice of GPUs for its virtual workstations including the Nvidia P4, T4, and P100 GPUs. Several come preconfigured in the Google Cloud Marketplace. Microsoft Azure NVv4 virtual workstations stand out because they offer huge flexibility in how GPU resources can be allocated. The AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 GPUs can be virtualised at a hardware level, so you only pay for the GPU resources you need, as opposed to many other cloud workstations which use a whole GPU. Nutanix Frame is a Desktop-as-a-Service (DaaS) solution designed specifically to deliver 3D applications or desktops to any device. The flexibility of the Frame service allows firms to select their preferred infrastructure (Azure, AWS, GCP or hybrid environments powered by Nutanix AHV) to allow them to reach users in more than 200 countries. The company places a big emphasis on ease of deployment. Scan, best known for its desktop workstations, teamed up with Ebb3 for its Scan 3XS Cloud Workstation. Read this DEVELOP3D article to learn more tinyurl.com/ebb3-scan Tehama offers an enterprise desktop-as-aservice with a big emphasis on security. It allows firms to create ‘secure virtual rooms and desktops’ on the cloud. Workspot aims to simplify the deployment and management of cloud workstations by delivering virtual desktops as a service. This includes Windows 10 desktops and Windows 10 cloud workstations, including the AMD-based Microsoft Azure NvV4 Virtual Machines (VMs). The company has extensive knowledge of the AEC sector and is now working with Siemens to bring NX to the cloud.

www.develop3d.com

12/08/2021 15:00

3D PRINTING & ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING INTELLIGENCE

28 29 30 SEPTEMBER 2021 NEC, Birmingham, UK

Evaluate, Adopt, Optimise… Analyse the opportunity Discover your application Learn from user success stories Understand capabilities and limitations Choose the right solution Optimise existing technology Consider enterprise adoption Ensure return on investment

With more than 80 speakers and 150 exhibitors, discover your additive strategy at TCT 3Sixty.

www.tct3sixty.com

Co-located Shows

FEATURE

SMOOTH LANDING » Much of the aerospace industry got grounded during lockdown, but some companies used the time to prepare for a future uplift in the sector’s fortunes. At Airframe Designs, a key priority was updating the company’s simulation tools, as Steffan Evans reports

ravel restrictions triggered by Covid-19 have seen the number of air passengers fall to historic lows, placing airline operators and their suppliers under significant, sustained pressure. For some, however, it’s at least been an opportunity to rethink and reskill. A good case in point is Blackpool, UK-based Airframe Designs, which has used the lull of lockdown to engage in a re-evaluation of many of its design processes and development methods. The company’s projects range from VIP galley upgrades and narrow-body aircraft seat design, to military projects such as Puma helicopter upgrades and design work for sixth-generation fighter aircraft.

Airframe Designs wanted to be able to offer clients more value from early concept through to critical design review; to upskill and invest in the engineering team as part of a AS9100 quality framework; and to become more agile in a tough, competitive market. One potential area for improvement really stood out. The company had relied on several legacy FEA [finite element analysis] programmes for the past decade. An assessment of more up-to-date approaches brought to light many new platforms and toolsets that could improve simulation work. That said, there were a number of requirements to bear in mind. The new toolset needed to support the industrystandard data format set by FEA solver MSC Nastran, used by most companies in the aerospace industry for regulatory compliance and to interact with other parties.

40 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p40_41_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Airframe.indd 40

12/08/2021 15:18

‘‘ Models developed in legacy

software can be difficult to adapt or remodel, as a design evolves. With Apex, simply modify the underlying CAD and the model updates automatically Bill Thorne, Airframe Designs

’’

On top of that, it would have to be able to integrate well with Airframe Designs’ current workflow, be quick to learn, and deliver demonstrable time savings and efficiency gains. Discussions with numerous CAE/FEA software vendors showed the Airframe team the significant advances in capability and deployment made by many different toolsets over the past decade. While many had elements that would work, they opted for MSC Apex, which they saw as a solution that is fast gathering pace in the sector. Via initial contact at an aerospace industry event, Airframe Designs engaged Evotech CAE, a dedicated MSC Apex training provider, to help with its initial assessment and get its team up to speed.

READY FOR TAKE-OFF The initial project was a typical aircraft galley structure: a Boeing 737 stowage compartment, constructed of lightweight metallic and composite sub-structures, showing detailed joint definition and the appropriate loading. In preparation, Airframe Designs’ engineers took an initial 12-hour online training course – enough for them to hit the ground running. In addition, they were also provided with a bespoke tuition programme, focusing specifically on the application of galley structure FEA. A model of the aircraft stowage compartment was built, and the team needed to be able to incorporate three typical design updates, with the resultant model to then be prepared for external analysis in MSC Nastran. The resulting model development using MSC Apex proved to be significantly more efficient than that achieved when using Airframe Designs’ legacy toolsets. Given that the work had been performed by engineers with minimal product exposure, managers at the company were impressed that the turnaround took just a little over three days, compared to eight days or more with the previous software. “Models developed in legacy software can be difficult

to adapt or remodel, as a design evolves,” says Airframe Designs lead engineer Bill Thorne. “In Apex, simply modify the underlying CAD, and the model updates 1 A Boeing ● 737 stowage automatically.” compartment was The time saved in such a project allows for effort to modelled, showing be focused on different areas of the design process, detailed joint definition and the ensuring development goals can be met earlier and appropriate loading with reduced risk. 2 Design updates The next steps for Airframe Designs’ FEA development ● were applied along process will be to add more MSC Apex-specific Python the lines of a typical training to the mix, in order that the team can incorporate customer request 3 FEA analysis could a bespoke workflow for model build, verification and ● be undertaken and downstream post-processing, ultimately leading to more files prepared for optimised structures, faster. external analysis in airframedesigns.com | evotechcae.com

MSC Nastran

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 41

p40_41_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Airframe.indd 41

12/08/2021 15:18

FEATURE

IS SKETCHING STILL RELEVANT?

» At a time when we have a huge range of 3D tools at our disposal, Chris Cheung asks what role sketching should play in today’s product development processes?

e live in a time where it’s easy to jump straight into 3D CAD when designing a product. Back when I started in the industry, it still took a lot to convince people to adopt 3D earlier in the process, and to use it to replace 2D drawings. Today, 3D is commonplace and we are midway to realising more ubiquitous applications via digital twins and reality capture, as well as discovering how virtual worlds are going to change how we make and consume. So does the dimensionally challenged 2D sketch still have a place? As a reformed industrial designer, a maker of 2D and 3D applications and a chronic doodler myself, this is a deeply familiar topic for me. To cut to the chase, my answer to the question is ‘No’, followed by an emphatic ‘Yes!’

When looking at this from a novel technology or an investment perspective, the visionary activities in the AI space and mixed reality promise to disrupt the way we’ve been doing things over the decades. It’s the stuff that will fuel entirely new interaction models and productivity. Looking for a similar seismic shift for the art of sketching is unrealistic, unless we take the human out of the equation – but then it wouldn’t be sketching anymore. What makes sketching surprisingly complex are its many facets and intangible qualities. Despite every innovation that has challenged the importance of sketching – photography, the digital imaging revolution, or the proliferation of 3D modelling and visualisation – people are still drawing. The traditional art supply

42 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p42_43_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Cheung.indd 42

17/08/2021 13:20

market is not in decline. There is no shortage of people learning how to draw, and millions upon millions of people are also sketching on their phones and computers. I believe sketching is ingrained in our DNA and is a fail-safe ‘reboot’ technology. Sure, we have other base technologies too – no one can deny the power of words. Language can stir the imagination and provide the level of instruction needed to tackle all kinds of projects. Yet, even the simplest of sketches can visually express concepts that a volume of written words cannot.

SKETCHING IS EVERYWHERE To put it simply, I believe sketching deserves legendary status. Why? For three main reasons:

THE POWER OF INTERPRETATION Light reflects off a sketch, enters our eyes, travels along the optic nerve to the visual cortex, where parts of the brain engage to make sense of it. Lines, shapes and colours process to construct the illusion of what we think we see in the sketch. This mechanism doesn’t require completeness, accuracy or even feasibility to activate the mind in seeking connections and sparking an emotional response. This is the kind of condition most desirable for fledgling projects, leveraging interpretation to inspire lateral thinking and the formation of new ideas.

RANGE Nothing comes close to the versatility of sketching. It is as effective for a business model discussion on a whiteboard as it is for envisioning an architectural structure. A sketch can illustrate very technical sequences and be used to wireframe the user interactions needed to operate it. Its capabilities even transcend use cases. Sketching can induce a state of ‘flow’, characterised by increased theta and alpha wave activity in the brain. Other studies document its therapeutic and health benefits.

BATTERIES NOT REQUIRED On any given day, I have at least two computers ablaze, three devices in tow, and about 100 browser tabs active at any given moment. But I kid you not, there is at least one piece of paper or a page from a sketchbook that saves my day, every day. If my hardware goes down or some other terrible reboot condition occurs, I may not be able to execute most of my day-to-day operations, but I know I can get shit done, traditional-style. In summary then, sketching is not an isolated activity for the design department. It is not exclusive to those born with natural talent. Sketching is a tool to spark conversation and a cost-effective means of discovering new solutions. It is invaluable for expressing emotional intent that drives story and design, and it is a constructive means of facilitating concurrent development practices for all those moments when a memo, spreadsheet, Jira ticket, or a dataset doesn’t quite get you to where you want to be. Sketching may not be top of mind for every process, but people and organisations always benefit from having diverse methods for tackling problems. For this reason alone, sketching remains vital. Chris Cheung is an advocate of creativity in business and is the founder of Mighty Dynamo, an experimental product lab and design consultancy. More recently, he became the co-owner of Sketchbook, a popular cross-platform drawing app.

APPLE IPAD IDEATION TOOLS Apple’s iPad tablet is a great device for quickly sketching up a concept. Here are four of the best apps for putting down those first lines of a killer design

SKETCHBOOK Cost: free Formerly of Autodesk, Sketchbook has struck out on its own as a standalone company headed by former Autodesk employees who know and love the product. Its smooth lines are assisted by an array of rulers and tools to help you attain accuracy, while vertical, horizontal, and radial symmetry tools can speed up the process of getting ideas down faster. Available across all Windows, Android and Apple devices, it’s a versatile platform that’s a firm favourite, due to a paired-back UI that offers an almost paper-like experience. sketchbook.com

GRAVITY SKETCH FOR IPAD Cost: free The intuitive virtual reality sketching app has a free iPad app that takes its quick sketch tools out of the VR environment and places them on Apple’s Pencil-driven hardware. It’s built as a one-stop 3D CAD ideation tool, allowing users to import engineering data as hard point markers to sketch forms over, while LandingPad allows files to be synchronised across devices, including taking a sketch directly into a VR environment. gravitysketch.com

PROCREATE FOR IPAD Cost: £9.99 Procreate comes stocked with artist tools from the off – an entire library of brushes that can be customised, downloaded or custom-made. While more focused on painterly styles than the other options featured here, the technology behind it is no slouch, taking full advantage of Apple’s Metal architecture. It’s designed to get the best performance from the iPad, offering 120fps on supported devices, while gesture controls make common functions a breeze, letting you get on with the creativity. procreate.art/ipad

PHOTOSHOP FOR IPAD Cost: £19.97 per month or as part of a Creative Cloud subscription It was only a matter of time before Adobe’s mobile apps began to infiltrate workflows. Regular updates continue to evolve Photoshop on the iPad, available as part of a Creative Cloud subscription, which offers an abundance of tools and increasingly makes for a much more useable workspace. While the sketch and paint environment lacks the natural flow and intuitive nature of some, the breadth of abilities it offers and the platform’s familiarity mean that lots of designers will be comfortable using it straight away. adobe.com/photoshop

The 12.9-inch Apple iPad Pro features a Liquid Retina XDR display and Appledesigned M1 chip

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 43

p42_43_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Cheung.indd 43

17/08/2021 13:20

LAST WORD

Having binge-watched an entire summer of sport, Stephen Holmes is thinking about how design, technology and materials now play a greater role than they ever have done before in determining sporting outcomes

ife’s not been the same since I stopped watching dancing horses while eating my breakfast. A magnificent summer of sport has just drawn to a close, and from the early morning equine body-popping of Olympic dressage, to evenings spent observing football’s failure to locate its house keys, there was something for everyone to revel in. As much as the power and skill of athletes is the main focus, I’m always acutely aware of the teams of specialists feverishly working away in the shadows to build the equipment and peripherals that can offer a competitive edge. Boosting the prospects of a nation’s athletes has switched over the last couple of decades from being the domain of state-sponsored programmes, to that of private specialists with no home allegiance – companies with the wind tunnels and materials science know-how to build elite-level equipment. While the flags and anthems of the winners still fill the arenas, there’s now a global commercial carrot dangling at the finish line. The race to design winning sporting gear is one of the most lucrative contests around.

different footwear that some brands have allowed their sponsored athletes to wear the shoes of rivals on race day until their own technologies can catch-up. Meanwhile, anyone heading out for a jog can snap up a pair of the Nike ‘4%’ running shoes, should they have the funds. Professional cycling has long been a sport of marginal gains via light-weighting and aerodynamics, and the latest technologies are now trickling down to amateurs with greater speed. It only takes a pair of Lycra-clad weekend warriors sat outside a perfectly serviceable pub to loudly inform you about the grams they’ve saved on rides. It’s a similar story for swimsuits that glide through the water with less impedance than our own skin; archery bows that feature precise weight distribution aligned through generative design; grips used in a variety of sports that are custom 3D-scanned and 3D-printed. For a growing number of Paralympians, more sports have opened up, thanks to increased access to customised prosthetics and adapted kit. This summer even saw a sport doggedly devoted to buttonup loungewear and oversized gloves finally add an element of the cutting edge, as baseball glove technology finally advanced from leather lace-ups to precision lattice polymers [see page 18]. All are available to the masses, regardless of the level they compete at, just as long as they are willing to cough up the asking price to mimic their heroes.



The race to design winning sporting gear is now one of the most lucrative contests around



HIGH-PERFORMANCE KIT Nike’s ‘super spikes’ dominated this summer’s track and field headlines, offering increased energy returns to sprinters through a carbon plate in the sole of the footwear and specially developed foams. The brand’s carbon plate technology originally appeared (albeit as heavily disguised prototypes) in long-distance races at the 2016 Games, where a reported 4% performance improvement dominated endurance events like the marathon. Such is the gulf of performance between

This leads to an uncomfortable debate over how much sports equipment should be responsible for results, and the growing disparity between the haves and have-nots. Kit costs money: ask any parent packing their potential future gold medal winner off to the new school year. Even a pair of non-performance-enhancing PE socks cost hard currency, let alone sticks, racquets, boots or balls. So will talent suffer as a result of the geographic and financial lottery, as much as elite sports have demanded elite infrastructure in which to train and compete? Perhaps some comfort is to be found in the running track at the 2020 Tokyo Olympics. Its designers, Mondo, explained that its complex make-up of rubber granules were precisely positioned to create small air pockets that give everyone running on its surface the potential for a 1% to 2% performance improvement. The regenerative energy from the track benefitted all that bounded along it, regardless of nation, resources or corporate sponsor is a timely reminder that we can create things capable of pushing everyone along, not just the few with good fortune.

Nike’s Air Zoom Victory race spikes were the footwear to be lining up in during Tokyo 2020 Credit: Nike

MARGINAL-GAINS DEBATE Back in the professional ranks, with athlete training, diet and recovery programmes reaching greater parity around the world, it will increasingly be equipment that provides the greatest marginal gains.

GET IN TOUCH: Having attended the cricket at Lords for his first post-lockdown sporting event, Stephen was quickly reminded of the financial disparity between sports, especially as he’s never had to remortgage his house to buy a pint at Derwent Park. On Twitter, he’s @swearstoomuch

44 AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 DEVELOP3D.COM

p44_D3D_AUGSEPT21_LastWord.indd 44

18/08/2021 11:08

DEVELOP3DSERVICES TO ADVERTISE YOUR SERVICES HERE CONTACT STEVE KING STEVE@X3DMEDIA.COM | +44 (0) 20 3355 7314 | +44 (0)7850 507362

Save the date

ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING

replik8@cdg.uk.com 01420 556755

6 April 2022

2022

Sheffield UK | develop3dlive.com

Save the date

Digital fabrication, construction 3D printing, architecture, real time viz, VR, plus lots more

3D SCANNING

Bureau Service | Product Sales • High Accuracy & Resolution • Reverse Engineering • Scan-to-CAD • Inspection Reports • Geomagic Software • Wrap, DX, CX, Freeform

London 9 November 2021

nxtbld.com

DEVELOP3D.COM AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2021 45

p45_D3D_AUGSEPT21_Services.indd 45

16/08/2021 08:36

Design and Simulation Systems Award-winning CAD & CAE workstations from Scan 3XS

Scan recommends Microsoft Windows 10

Discover your perfect workstation at

scan.co.uk/pro-graphics • 01204 47 47 47