Florida Water Resources Journal - July 2022

Page 62

F W R J

Three Ion Exchange Technologies, One Tough Decision for Florida Utilities Tyler Smith, Chris Reinbold, Vinnie Hart, and Larry Elliott

O

ver the last decade, the ion exchange (IX) process has increasingly become a technology of interest for the removal of natural organic compounds in Florida source waters. Three IX options for municipal treatment plants include: S Fixed bed vessel, which is commonly used throughout Florida and the United States. S Fluidized bed, such as magnetic ion exchange (MIEX), which has seen limited use in Florida and the U.S. (about 12 installations). S Suspended ion exchange (SIX), which has four installations in Europe and is on the verge of its first U.S. installation in Tampa.

Considering Florida’s variability in source water composition and other site-specific considerations, one IX process does not fit all, and each type of IX should be evaluated, considering, among numerous other factors, a utility’s project goals, facility size, operation and maintenance (O&M) aspects, and costs. This article dives into the primary differences, similarities, and pros and cons for the three IX options so that Florida utilities can

consider the most optimal solution for their water quality challenges. Case studies from pilot- and full-scale installations across Florida, varying in size, capacity, and water quality characteristics, were considered. The MIEX is the only patented fluidized bed process (owned by IXOM Watercare Inc.) and uses a magnetized strong base anion exchange resin that is proprietary (the resin and process are both patented). The process was primarily developed to remove dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and the resin’s magnetic properties help facilitate settling (to avoid carryover to downstream processes). The MIEX resin has a mean particle size of 180 to 200 micrometers (µm). The small particle size and macroporous nature increases the available surface area, compared to traditional ion exchange resins. The MIEX process allows water and IX resin to flow through a contact tank with mixing, in which DOC and other negatively charged ions are exchanged for chloride ions. Figure 1 shows the general process flow of MIEX. Raw water flows upward from the bottom of the fluidized

Figure 1. Magnetic Ion Exchange General Process Flow Diagram (courtesy of IXOM Watercare Inc.)

62 July 2022 • Florida Water Resources Journal

Tyler Smith is senior project engineer with Carollo Engineers Inc. in Phoenix. Chris Reinbold is a project manager with Carollo Engineers Inc. in Palm Beach. Vinnie Hart is a project manager with Carollo Engineers Inc. in Denver. Larry Elliott was a vice president with Carollo Engineers Inc. in Orlando (deceased).

bed reactor/tank, where it’s contacted with resin. The resin ideally remains in suspension through the use of an agitator operating at low speeds. A series of tube settlers (or plates) at the top of the reactor vessel separate the resin from the water. Treated effluent overflows into collection launders to downstream treatment. The original treatment scheme had two stages (contact, followed by settling) with resin concentrations in the 10 to 15 milliliter (mL)/L range, while the newer “high rate” systems combine resin contact and settling in the same tank, with increased resin concentrations in the range of 200 to 250 mL/L. Virgin resin is added to the process to make up for quantities of resin that may be inadvertently carried downstream or lost to attrition. At any given time, a small portion of the resin is withdrawn from the reactor vessel, regenerated in semibatch configuration, and returned to the reactor for reuse. The MIEX has multiple full-scale and highrate installations in the U.S.; some of the larger installations include Palm Beach County Water Utilities Dept. (Water Treatment Plant 2; 16.4 mil gal per day [mgd]), Boynton Beach Utilities (20 mgd), and the C.B. Collier Water Treatment Plant in Gadsden, Ala. (24 mgd). Like the other IX technologies discussed, the resin itself has a high affinity for organics to facilitate their removal through ion exchange. In particular, the strong base anion exchange resin is effective at removing hydrophilics, humic substances, building blocks, and low-molecular-weight acids. For Palm Beach County, its full-scale MIEX process was able to reduce raw water total organic carbon (TOC) from 13 to 4 mg/L. A MIEX pilot study conducted for the City of Tampa showed reduction of TOC from 24 to 9 mg/L. Overall, the process has been proven for organics removal in Continued on page 64


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

Display Advertiser Index

4min
pages 86-88

TREEO Center Training

2min
pages 79-80

News Beat

3min
pages 81-82

What is the Operators’ Initiative and Why is it

1min
page 76

FWEA Chapter Corner: South Chapter Meeting: Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department Builds for the Future—Melody

2min
pages 70-71

C Factor—Patrick “Murf” Murphy

8min
pages 68-69

FSAWWA Speaking Out—Emilie Moore

4min
pages 72-74

Three Ion Exchange Technologies, One Tough Decision for Florida Utilities—Tyler Smith, Chris

18min
pages 62-67

Reader Profile— Felicity Appel

3min
page 61

Let’s Talk Safety: Jackhammer Safety

2min
page 60

FSAWWA 2022 Water Distribution System Awards

1min
page 58

Test Yourself—Donna Kaluzniak

3min
pages 54-55

In Memoriam: William Palan Allman

4min
page 49

Stormwater Management Planning: Does it

8min
pages 50-53

Emerging Renewal Technologies for Pressurized Pipelines—Steve Soldati

11min
pages 44-48

Students and Young Professionals Activities

2min
pages 28-29

Competitions

7min
pages 30-33

Operators Showcase

11min
pages 22-25

Women of Water Forum

7min
pages 26-27

Facility Tour

1min
page 19

Workshops and Technical Sessions

1min
page 21

CEU Challenge

4min
pages 8-9

Conference Highlights—Mish Clark

12min
pages 14-18

Exhibition

0
page 20

Addressing Per- and Poly-Fluoroalkyl Substances Through Source Water Assessments and Advanced Treatment Using Powdered Activated Carbon, Granular Activated Carbon, and Ion Exchange—

12min
pages 10-13

FWEA Focus—Sondra W. Lee

3min
pages 6-7

Fish Passage Program to Receive Federal Funding

3min
pages 4-5
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.