ON BACALAR'S DEFENSE. COLLOQUIAL VERSION

Page 148

consideration that the way in which a tourist could interpret an experience and determine a preference depends on very complex individual valuations, if we only took into consideration how human beings individually prioritize what is important to us. It is not possible to make a simplistic statement of the emotions of tourism customers, nor to have a simplistic idea of what they are looking for, given that other aspects such as their human condition, their baggage, advertising, attraction from the tourist offer, and various factors that stimulate the decisions of the tourist would have to be incorporated. Another part of the LCA's goal was that society itself, based on tourist preferences, was going to have to build a stage with rules and abide by them. But it was built from a flimsy and uninformed place, without knowledge of the target, with a disjointed process and with a level of tokenist participation, simulated. Finally, he asserted that social empowerment was going to be limited to following the rules to meet the expectations of the tourist and learning to monitor the system to guarantee the tourist that he will have those experiences. What is understood is that the social empowerment promoted by PROTUR, would consist of letting the group of close actors to whom they were invited, convened and granted the power to decide on behalf of the whole society (to simulate that it was done "in a participatory way"), was going to establish and decide on the criteria that the rest of the population was going to have to follow and monitor obligatorily; while they (with access to administer funds or direct benefits) and the rest of the community (bound by the triad's decision) guaranteed that the Lagoon would be a place where visitors would have a satisfactory experience of a cared for natural resource, regardless of what it was. That, for the promoters of the instrument, was social empowerment and the key to the conservation of the Lagoon: Engage society, with what was decided by a group selected by themselves, with unilateral criteria, with a simulated "participatory" planning, to ensure that tourists could have a "reserved" and "protected" site that would guarantee them an experience of enjoyment of the Lagoon. Where had been the initial justification of PROTUR? to be a solution to socioenvironmental problems and for the protection of biocultural heritage. The promoters of PROTUR, as part of the triad, believed that the passive 130


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

Demystifying Stromatolites

2hr
pages 221-304

The myth of tourism and tourism in PNA, pro-poor

9min
pages 215-220

The colonialist myth of the petty or ignorant local inhabitant

16min
pages 190-198

The myth of Carrying Capacity for Tourism

24min
pages 199-211

The Acceptable Change Limit

5min
pages 212-214

Bacalar

5min
pages 186-189

The myth of the lack of regulation of the Bacalar Lagoon and its basin Hundreds of instruments to regulate and over-regulate almost everything in

3min
pages 184-185

IBANQROO and PROTUR

31min
pages 162-183

"Innovative" strategies that put the lagoon and user safety at risk

16min
pages 153-161

Unexplained zoning criteria

6min
pages 148-150

50% of the Lagoon in Conservation or only for Research

1min
page 152

Subzone 5.1 Microbialites of Buenavista

1min
page 151

The Unexplained Calculation of Load Capacity and Acceptable Change Limit

10min
pages 142-147

SWOT without feet or head

1min
page 141

Participatory construction simulation

8min
pages 137-140

The Master Plan for Sustainable Tourism of Quintana Roo 2030

10min
pages 131-136

The PNA Management Program does not solve the problems

4min
pages 127-130

Who benefits from PNAs?

7min
pages 123-126

Rule 23. The CONCCLAB in APIQROO

7min
pages 70-73

The failed PNA, in Quintana Roo

1hr
pages 81-117

The Secretary of the Navy and APIQROO

10min
pages 74-80

2011 – 2014 RAMSAR. 97,591 hectares for the triad

25min
pages 53-67

Bacalar’s PNA propposal

9min
pages 118-122

ECOSUR and IEUNAM, in APIQROO

1min
page 68
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.