PoliMi Master Thesis | SUMPS AND THE TRANSITION BEHIND PLANNING PARADIGMS

Page 137

Alcantara, M.N.P.A

6. Conclusions

Analyzing strategic documents through an in-depth methodology framework has enabled this thesis to address the dynamic urban complexities that manifest within the challenges of mobility planning processes. In addition, this research has highlighted the importance of strategic planning documents as an essential and powerful tool in the urban planning context

which gathers decision-making elements to guide but should not limit human

behaviors

fostering paradigms shift if well planned and adopted. Therefore, to answer

the research question, Vienna, Brussels, Budapest, Rome, and Lisbon, have been selected as case studies to have their mobility plans scrutinized based on the SUMP guidelines to unfold to what extent they could be considered SUMPs. Further, exploring the SUMP 12 Steps

through the 32 SUMP Activities

and its

Principles throughout the case studies has allowed the identification of strengths, weaknesses, and challenges associated with the mobility planning processes. As a result, the research findings have further supported the discussion behind the paradigm shift from TTP toward SUMPing

that although it started at the end of the 20th century, this

thesis has revealed that it is still happening nowadays toward its future consolidation. Thus, the importance of an integrated approach, by all means, has been reinstated throughout this entire work to foster sustainable urban development and unfolded the necessity to consider planning and practices into mobility paradigm transitions. As a result, all thesis research goals have been fulfilled, and the research question has been answered. Nevertheless, the author would like to uncover a final critical and very needed point as an additional brief contribution to the findings of this thesis. In general, to a certain extent, sustainable advances in planning and some practices have been implemented by EU capital cities, which for sure deserves some celebrations. However, as tackled in the literature review, the

widely fostered by the EU in the past years, which

undoubtedly has been achieving considerable progress in mobility planning and practices never accomplished before

is not enough to fully solve current and future mobility

challenges to all their extents. Whereas it does not address important topics that, in one way or another, impact and is also affected by mobility forms and patterns, such as but Sustainable Urban Mobility Plans [SUMPs] and the transition behind planning paradigms 127


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

6. Conclusions

3min
pages 137-138

Figure 78. Case Studies Comparison Results - Principles of SUMP

2min
pages 133-134

Activities

0
page 132

Figure 74

1min
page 127

Figure 73

1min
page 126

Figure 75. Lisbon MOVE Results - Principles of SUMP

1min
page 128

Figure 69

2min
pages 122-123

Figure 70

1min
page 124

Figure 68

2min
pages 120-121

Figure 65

2min
pages 116-117

Figure 64

0
page 115

Figure 63. Universal Accessibility, the unifying concept of PUMS

0
page 114

Figure 60

2min
pages 109-110

Figure 61

2min
pages 111-112

Figure 59. Budapest BMT Results - Principles of SUMP

2min
pages 107-108

Figure 58

0
page 106

Figure 57

4min
pages 103-105

Figure 56

1min
pages 101-102

Figure 50

4min
pages 92-94

Figure 55

1min
page 100

two phases

0
page 97

of intervention

2min
pages 98-99

Figure 47

4min
pages 87-89

Figure 45

1min
page 85

network

0
page 86

Figure 44

1min
page 84

during the April 2017 forum

2min
pages 78-79

originally in French, as la perception de la mobilité et de la sécurité routière

0
page 83

Figure 43

3min
pages 80-82

Figure 41

0
page 77

Figure 40. Vienna STEP UMP Results - Principles of SUMP

2min
pages 75-76

Figure 38. Overview of Vienna STEP UMP's Phase 3 analyses

3min
pages 72-73

Figure 39. Overview of Vienna STEP UMP's Phase 4 analyses

1min
page 74

Figure 33. Structure of Chapter 4

2min
pages 61-62

Figure 37

4min
pages 69-71

Table 5

0
page 68

Figure 36

4min
pages 65-67

Figure 31. Coding guide based on SUMP 12 Steps elements

2min
pages 58-59

Figure

4min
pages 56-57

transport modes

0
page 55

and stations from their bike-sharing systems and cycling infrastructure kilometers

1min
page 53

Figure 24. Lisbon Modal Split 2017

1min
page 51

Figure 23

1min
page 50

Figure 22. Lisbon location and statistics

3min
pages 48-49

Figure 21. Rome Modal Split 2016

1min
page 47

Figure 20

1min
page 46

Figure 19. Rome location and statistics

3min
pages 44-45

Figure 18. Budapest Modal Split 2017

1min
page 43

Figure 16. Budapest location and statistics

1min
page 41

Figure 15. Brussels Capital Region Modal Split 2019

0
page 40

Figure 11

1min
page 34

Figure

1min
page 35

Figure

1min
page 38

Figure 4. The 12 Steps of Sustainable Urban Mobility Planning

3min
pages 23-25

Figure 10. Vienna location and statistics

1min
page 33

Table 3. Short Table

2min
pages 26-28

Figure 1. Research Structure

1min
pages 14-15

Table

1min
page 16

17 Figure 6. eir Mobility/Transport Plans to be SUMPs

1min
page 29

Plans

2min
pages 30-31

Figure

1min
page 17

Table 1. Paradigms of academic knowledge about urban transport Table 2. Differences between traditional transport planning and Sustainable Urban

2min
pages 18-19
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.